Orange County Coastkeeper v. Alloy Die Casting Co.,

Filing 24

CONSENT DECREE by Judge Fred W. Slaughter. NOW THEREFORE IT IS HEREBY STIPULATED BETWEEN THE SETTLING PARTIES AND ORDERED AND DECREED BY THE COURT AS FOLLOWS: The Court has jurisdiction over the subject matter of this Action pursuant to Section 505( a)(1)(A) of the Clean Water Act, 33 USC 1365(a)(1)(A). The Court shall retain jurisdiction over this matter for purposes of enforcing the terms of this Consent Decree for the life of the Consent Decree, or as long thereafter as is necessary for the Court to resolve any motion to enforce this Consent Decree. Related to: Stipulation for Judgment 23 . (MD JS-6. Case Terminated.) See document for further information. (jp)

Download PDF
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

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?