David Macias v. Hunt & Henriques, LLP et al
Filing
48
STIPULATED AND PROTECTIVE ORDER by Magistrate Judge Douglas F. McCormick re Stipulation for Protective Order 41 . (see document for details.) (et)
<![CDATA[
->DBB45 0<<>D3 (#
# %0A:24=C4A A (D8C4
(0=C0 =0
)
H70<<>D3C742A438C0CC>A=4H2><
--)+(!0, ")+ & $(-$""
/$ $ ,
N2EN
N$N"
%;08=C855
E
XXXXXXXX
454=30=CB
%*'%$(( # ! " )) $#(
8B2>E4AH 8= C78B 02C8>= 8B ;8:4;H C> 8=E>;E4 ?A>3D2C8>= >5 2>=5834=C80; ?A>?A84C0AH
>A ?A8E0C4 8=5>A<0C8>= 5>A F7827 B?4280; ?A>C42C8>= 5A>< ?D1;82 38B2;>BDA4 0=3 5A><
DB4 5>A 0=H ?DA?>B4 >C74A C70= ?DABD8=6 C78B ;8C860C8>= <0H 14 F0AA0=C43
22>A38=6;H C74 ?0AC84B 74A41H BC8?D;0C4 C> 0=3 ?4C8C8>= C74 >DAC C> 4=C4A C74
5>;;>F8=6 (C8?D;0C43 %A>C42C8E4 $A34A )74 ?0AC84B 02:=>F;4364 C70C C78B $A34A
3>4B =>C 2>=54A 1;0=:4C ?A>C42C8>=B >= 0;; 38B2;>BDA4B >A A4B?>=B4B C> 38B2>E4AH 0=3
C70C C74 ?A>C42C8>= 8C 055>A3B 5A>< ?D1;82 38B2;>BDA4 0=3 DB4 4GC4=3B >=;H C> C74
;8<8C43 8=5>A<0C8>= >A 8C4<B C70C 0A4 4=C8C;43 C> 2>=5834=C80; CA40C<4=C D=34A C74
0??;8201;4 ;460; ?A8=28?;4B )74 ?0AC84B 5DAC74A 02:=>F;4364 0B B4C 5>AC7 8= (42C8>=
14;>F C70C C78B (C8?D;0C43 %A>C42C8E4 $A34A 3>4B =>C 4=C8C;4 C74< C> 58;4
2>=5834=C80; 8=5>A<0C8>= D=34A B40; 8E8; !>20; 'D;4 B4CB 5>AC7 C74
?A>243DA4B C70C <DBC 14 5>;;>F43 0=3 C74 BC0=30A3B C70C F8;; 14 0??;843 F74= 0
?0ACH B44:B ?4A<8BB8>= 5A>< C74 2>DAC C> 58;4 <0C4A80; D=34A B40;
$$ *( ())"#)
)78B 02C8>= 8B ;8:4;H C> 8=E>;E4 CA034 B42A4CB 2DBC><4A 0=3 ?A828=6 ;8BCB 0=3 >C74A
E0;D01;4 A4B40A27 34E4;>?<4=C 2><<4A280; 58=0=280; C427=820; 0=3>A
?A>?A84C0AH 8=5>A<0C8>= 5>A F7827 B?4280; ?A>C42C8>= 5A>< ?D1;82 38B2;>BDA4 0=3
5A>< DB4 5>A 0=H ?DA?>B4 >C74A C70= ?A>B42DC8>= >5 C78B 02C8>= 8B F0AA0=C43 (D27
2>=5834=C80; 0=3 ?A>?A84C0AH <0C4A80;B 0=3 8=5>A<0C8>= 2>=B8BC >5 0<>=6 >C74A
C78=6B 2>=5834=C80; 1DB8=4BB >A 58=0=280; 8=5>A<0C8>= 8=5>A<0C8>= A460A38=6
2>=5834=C80; 1DB8=4BB ?A02C824B >A >C74A 2>=5834=C80; A4B40A27 34E4;>?<4=C >A
2><<4A280; 8=5>A<0C8>= 8=2;D38=6 8=5>A<0C8>= 8<?;820C8=6 ?A8E02H A867CB >5 C78A3
?0AC84B 8=5>A<0C8>= >C74AF8B4 64=4A0;;H D=0E08;01;4 C> C74 ?D1;82 >A F7827 <0H
14 ?A8E8;4643 >A >C74AF8B4 ?A>C42C43 5A>< 38B2;>BDA4 D=34A BC0C4 >A 5434A0; BC0CDC4B
2>DAC AD;4B 20B4 3428B8>=B >A 2><<>= ;0F 22>A38=6;H C> 4G?438C4 C74 5;>F >5
8=5>A<0C8>= C> 5028;8C0C4 C74 ?A><?C A4B>;DC8>= >5 38B?DC4B >E4A 2>=5834=C80;8CH >5
38B2>E4AH <0C4A80;B C> 034@D0C4;H ?A>C42C 8=5>A<0C8>= C74 ?0AC84B 0A4 4=C8C;43 C>
:44? 2>=5834=C80; C> 4=BDA4 C70C C74 ?0AC84B 0A4 ?4A<8CC43 A40B>=01;4 =424BB0AH DB4B
>5 BD27 <0C4A80; 8= ?A4?0A0C8>= 5>A 0=3 8= C74 2>=3D2C >5 CA80; C> 033A4BB C748A
70=3;8=6 0C C74 4=3 >5 C74 ;8C860C8>= 0=3 B4AE4 C74 4=3B >5 9DBC824 0 ?A>C42C8E4 >A34A
5>A BD27 8=5>A<0C8>= 8B 9DBC85843 8= C78B <0CC4A C 8B C74 8=C4=C >5 C74 ?0AC84B C70C
8=5>A<0C8>= F8;; =>C 14 34B86=0C43 0B 2>=5834=C80; 5>A C02C820; A40B>=B 0=3 C70C
=>C78=6 14 B> 34B86=0C43 F8C7>DC 0 6>>3 508C7 14;845 C70C 8C 70B 144= <08=C08=43 8=
0 2>=5834=C80; =>=?D1;82 <0==4A 0=3 C74A4 8B 6>>3 20DB4 F7H 8C B7>D;3 =>C 14
?0AC >5 C74 ?D1;82 A42>A3 >5 C78B 20B4
# ) $#(
2C8>= /$ $ , / .(- ( !(+$*.!, ( $-$ (%
8E8; 2C8>= #>
2E
$"
70;;4=68=6 %0ACH 0 %0ACH >A #>=%0ACH C70C 270;;4=64B C74
34B86=0C8>= >5 8=5>A<0C8>= >A 8C4<B D=34A C78B $A34A
J$# #) !K =5>A<0C8>= >A C4<B 8=5>A<0C8>= A460A3;4BB >5
7>F 8C 8B 64=4A0C43 BC>A43 >A <08=C08=43 >A C0=681;4 C78=6B C70C @D0;85H 5>A
?A>C42C8>= D=34A 434A0; 'D;4 >5 8E8; %A>243DA4 2 0=3 0B B?4285843 01>E4 8=
C74 >>3 0DB4 (C0C4<4=C
>D=B4; $DCB834 >D=B4; >5 '42>A3 0=3 >DB4 >D=B4; 0B F4;; 0B
C748A BD??>AC BC055
4B86=0C8=6 %0ACH 0 %0ACH >A #>=%0ACH C70C 34B86=0C4B 8=5>A<0C8>=
>A 8C4<B C70C 8C ?A>3D24B 8= 38B2;>BDA4B >A 8= A4B?>=B4B C> 38B2>E4AH 0B
J$# #) !K
8B2;>BDA4 >A 8B2>E4AH "0C4A80; 0;; 8C4<B >A 8=5>A<0C8>= A460A3;4BB
>5 C74 <438D< >A <0==4A 8= F7827 8C 8B 64=4A0C43 BC>A43 >A <08=C08=43 8=2;D38=6
0<>=6 >C74A C78=6B C4BC8<>=H CA0=B2A8?CB 0=3 C0=681;4 C78=6B C70C 0A4 ?A>3D243
>A 64=4A0C43 8= 38B2;>BDA4B >A A4B?>=B4B C> 38B2>E4AH
G?4AC 0 ?4AB>= F8C7 B?4280;8I43 :=>F;4364 >A 4G?4A84=24 8= 0 <0CC4A
?4AC8=4=C C> C74 ;8C860C8>= F7> 70B 144= A4C08=43 1H 0 %0ACH >A 8CB 2>D=B4; C> B4AE4
0B 0= 4G?4AC F8C=4BB >A 0B 0 2>=BD;C0=C 8= C78B 2C8>=
>DB4 >D=B4; 0CC>A=4HB F7> 0A4 4<?;>H44B >5 0 ?0ACH C> C78B
2C8>= >DB4 >D=B4; 3>4B =>C 8=2;D34 $DCB834 >D=B4; >5 '42>A3 >A 0=H >C74A
>DCB834
2>D=B4;
#>=%0ACH 0=H =0CDA0; ?4AB>= ?0AC=4AB78? 2>A?>A0C8>= 0BB>280C8>=
>A >C74A ;460; 4=C8CH =>C =0<43 0B 0 %0ACH C> C78B 02C8>=
$DCB834 >D=B4; >5 '42>A3 0CC>A=4HB F7> 0A4 =>C 4<?;>H44B >5 0
?0ACH C> C78B 2C8>= 1DC 0A4 A4C08=43 C> A4?A4B4=C 0 ?0ACH C> C78B 2C8>= 0=3 70E4
0??40A43 8= C78B 2C8>= >= 1470;5 >5 C70C ?0ACH >A 0A4 0558;80C43 F8C7 0 ;0F 58A< C70C
70B
0??40A43
>=
1470;5
>5
C70C
?0ACH
0=3
8=2;D34B
BD??>AC
BC055
%0ACH 0=H ?0ACH C> C78B 2C8>= 8=2;D38=6 0;; >5 8CB >55824AB 38A42C>AB
4<?;>H44B 2>=BD;C0=CB A4C08=43 4G?4ACB 0=3 $DCB834 >D=B4; >5 '42>A3 0=3 C748A
BD??>AC BC055B
%A>3D28=6 %0ACH 0 %0ACH >A #>=%0ACH C70C ?A>3D24B 8B2;>BDA4 >A
8B2>E4AH "0C4A80; 8= C78B 2C8>=
%A>54BB8>=0; +4=3>AB ?4AB>=B >A 4=C8C84B C70C ?A>E834 ;8C860C8>=
BD??>AC B4AE824B 46 ?7>C>2>?H8=6 E834>C0?8=6 CA0=B;0C8=6 ?A4?0A8=6 4G7818CB >A
34<>=BCA0C8>=B 0=3 >A60=8I8=6 BC>A8=6 >A A4CA84E8=6 30C0 8= 0=H 5>A< >A <438D<
0=3 C748A 4<?;>H44B 0=3 BD12>=CA02C>AB
%A>C42C43 "0C4A80; 0=H 8B2;>BDA4 >A 8B2>E4AH "0C4A80; C70C 8B
34B86=0C43 0B J$# #) !K
'4248E8=6 %0ACH 0 %0ACH C70C A4248E4B 8B2;>BDA4 >A 8B2>E4AH
"0C4A80; 5A>< 0 %A>3D28=6 %0ACH
($%
)74 ?A>C42C8>=B 2>=54AA43 1H C78B (C8?D;0C8>= 0=3 $A34A 2>E4A =>C >=;H
%A>C42C43 "0C4A80; 0B 3458=43 01>E4 1DC 0;B> 0=H 8=5>A<0C8>= 2>?843 >A
4GCA02C43 5A>< %A>C42C43 "0C4A80; 0;; 2>?84B 4G24A?CB BD<<0A84B >A
2><?8;0C8>=B >5 %A>C42C43 "0C4A80; 0=3 0=H C4BC8<>=H 2>=E4AB0C8>=B >A
?A4B4=C0C8>=B 1H %0AC84B >A C748A >D=B4; C70C <867C A4E40; %A>C42C43 "0C4A80;
=H DB4 >5 %A>C42C43 "0C4A80; 0C CA80; B70;; 14 6>E4A=43 1H C74 >A34AB >5 C74
CA80; 9D364 0=3 >C74A 0??;8201;4 0DC7>A8C84B )78B $A34A 3>4B =>C 6>E4A= C74 DB4 >5
%A>C42C43 "0C4A80; 0C CA80;
*') $#
E4= 05C4A 58=0; 38B?>B8C8>= >5 C78B ;8C860C8>= C74 2>=5834=C80;8CH >1;860C8>=B
8<?>B43 1H C78B $A34A B70;; A4<08= 8= 45542C D=C8; 0 4B86=0C8=6 %0ACH 06A44B
>C74AF8B4 8= FA8C8=6 >A 0 2>DAC >A34A >C74AF8B4 38A42CB 8=0; 38B?>B8C8>= B70;; 14
344<43 C> 14 C74 ;0C4A >5 38B<8BB0; >5 0;; 2;08<B 0=3 3454=B4B 8= C78B 2C8>=
F8C7 >A F8C7>DC ?A49D3824 0=3 58=0; 9D36<4=C 74A48= 05C4A C74 2><?;4C8>=
0=3 4G70DBC8>= >5 0;; 0??40;B A4740A8=6B A4<0=3B CA80;B >A A4E84FB >5 C78B
2C8>= 8=2;D38=6 C74 C8<4 ;8<8CB 5>A 58;8=6 0=H <>C8>=B >A 0??;820C8>=B 5>A
4GC4=B8>= >5 C8<4 ?DABD0=C C> 0??;8201;4 ;0F
( #) # %'$)) ")' !
G4A28B4 >5 '4BCA08=C 0=3 0A4 8= 4B86=0C8=6 "0C4A80; 5>A
%A>C42C8>= 027 %0ACH >A #>=%0ACH C70C 34B86=0C4B 8=5>A<0C8>= >A 8C4<B 5>A
?A>C42C8>= D=34A C78B $A34A <DBC C0:4 20A4 C> ;8<8C 0=H BD27 34B86=0C8>= C> B?428582
<0C4A80; C70C @D0;8584B D=34A C74 0??A>?A80C4 BC0=30A3B )74 4B86=0C8=6 %0ACH <DBC
34B86=0C4 5>A ?A>C42C8>= >=;H C7>B4 ?0ACB >5 <0C4A80; 3>2D<4=CB 8C4<B >A >A0; >A
FA8CC4= 2><<D=820C8>=B C70C @D0;85H B> C70C >C74A ?>AC8>=B >5 C74 <0C4A80;
3>2D<4=CB 8C4<B >A 2><<D=820C8>=B 5>A F7827 ?A>C42C8>= 8B =>C F0AA0=C43 0A4 =>C
BF4?C D=9DBC85801;H F8C78= C74 0<18C >5 C78B $A34A
"0BB 8=38B2A8<8=0C4 >A A>DC8=8I43 34B86=0C8>=B 0A4 ?A>7818C43 4B86=0C8>=B
C70C 0A4 B7>F= C> 14 2;40A;H D=9DBC85843 >A C70C 70E4 144= <034 5>A 0= 8<?A>?4A
?DA?>B4 46 C> D==424BB0A8;H 4=2D<14A C74 20B4 34E4;>?<4=C ?A>24BB >A C>
8<?>B4 D==424BB0AH 4G?4=B4B 0=3 1DA34=B >= >C74A ?0AC84B <0H 4G?>B4 C74
4B86=0C8=6 %0ACH C> B0=2C8>=B
5 8C 2><4B C> 0 4B86=0C8=6 %0ACHLB 0CC4=C8>= C70C 8=5>A<0C8>= >A 8C4<B C70C
8C 34B86=0C43 5>A ?A>C42C8>= 3> =>C @D0;85H 5>A ?A>C42C8>= C70C 4B86=0C8=6 %0ACH
<DBC ?A><?C;H =>C85H 0;; >C74A %0AC84B C70C 8C 8B F8C73A0F8=6 C74 8=0??;8201;4
34B86=0C8>=
"0==4A 0=3 )8<8=6 >5 4B86=0C8>=B G24?C 0B >C74AF8B4 ?A>E8343 8=
C78B $A34A >A 0B >C74AF8B4 BC8?D;0C43 >A >A34A43 8B2;>BDA4 >5 8B2>E4AH "0C4A80;
C70C @D0;8584B 5>A ?A>C42C8>= D=34A C78B $A34A <DBC 14 2;40A;H B> 34B86=0C43 145>A4
C74 <0C4A80; 8B 38B2;>B43 >A ?A>3D243
4B86=0C8>= 8= 2>=5>A<8CH F8C7 C78B $A34A A4@D8A4B
0
5>A 8=5>A<0C8>= 8= 3>2D<4=C0AH 5>A< 46 ?0?4A >A 4;42CA>=82
3>2D<4=CB 1DC 4G2;D38=6 CA0=B2A8?CB >5 34?>B8C8>=B >A >C74A ?A4CA80;
>A CA80; ?A>24438=6B C70C C74 %A>3D28=6 %0ACH 0558G 0C 0 <8=8<D< C74
;464=3 J$# #) !K 74A48=05C4A J$# #) ! ;464=3K
C> 4027 ?064 C70C 2>=C08=B ?A>C42C43 <0C4A80; 5 >=;H 0 ?>AC8>= >5 C74
<0C4A80; >= 0 ?064 @D0;8584B 5>A ?A>C42C8>= C74 %A>3D28=6 %0ACH 0;B>
<DBC 2;40A;H 834=C85H C74 ?A>C42C43 ?>AC8>=B 46 1H <0:8=6
0??A>?A80C4 <0A:8=6B 8= C74 <0A68=B
%0ACH >A #>=%0ACH C70C <0:4B >A868=0; 3>2D<4=CB 0E08;01;4
5>A 8=B?42C8>= =443 =>C 34B86=0C4 C74< 5>A ?A>C42C8>= D=C8; 05C4A C74
8=B?42C8=6 %0ACH 70B 8=3820C43 F7827 3>2D<4=CB 8C F>D;3 ;8:4 2>?843
0=3 ?A>3D243
DA8=6 C74 8=B?42C8>= 0=3 145>A4 C74 34B86=0C8>= 0;; >5 C74
<0C4A80;
<034
0E08;01;4
5>A
8=B?42C8>=
B70;;
14
344<43
J$# #) !K 5C4A C74 8=B?42C8=6 %0ACH 70B 834=C85843 C74
3>2D<4=CB 8C F0=CB 2>?843 0=3 ?A>3D243 C74 %A>3D28=6 %0ACH <DBC
34C4A<8=4 F7827 3>2D<4=CB >A ?>AC8>=B C74A4>5 @D0;85H 5>A ?A>C42C8>=
D=34A C78B $A34A )74= 145>A4 ?A>3D28=6 C74 B?4285843 3>2D<4=CB C74
%A>3D28=6 %0ACH <DBC 0558G C74 J$# #) ! ;464=3K C> 4027
?064 C70C 2>=C08=B %A>C42C43 "0C4A80; 5 >=;H 0 ?>AC8>= >5 C74 <0C4A80;
>= 0 ?064 @D0;8584B 5>A ?A>C42C8>= C74 %A>3D28=6 %0ACH 0;B> <DBC
2;40A;H 834=C85H C74 ?A>C42C43 ?>AC8>=B 46 1H <0:8=6 0??A>?A80C4
<0A:8=6B 8= C74 <0A68=B
1
5>A C4BC8<>=H 68E4= 8= 34?>B8C8>=B C70C C74 4B86=0C8=6 %0ACH 834=C8584B
C74 8B2;>BDA4 >A 8B2>E4AH "0C4A80; >= C74 A42>A3 145>A4 C74 2;>B4
>5 C74 34?>B8C8>= 0;; ?A>C42C43 C4BC8<>=H
2
5>A 8=5>A<0C8>= ?A>3D243 8= B><4 5>A< >C74A C70= 3>2D<4=C0AH 0=3
5>A 0=H >C74A C0=681;4 8C4<B C70C C74 %A>3D28=6 %0ACH 0558G 8= 0
?A><8=4=C ?;024 >= C74 4GC4A8>A >5 C74 2>=C08=4A >A 2>=C08=4AB 8= F7827
C74 8=5>A<0C8>= 8B BC>A43 C74 ;464=3 J$# #) !K 5 >=;H 0
?>AC8>= >A ?>AC8>=B >5 C74 8=5>A<0C8>= F0AA0=CB ?A>C42C8>= C74
%A>3D28=6 %0ACH C> C74 4GC4=C ?A02C8201;4 B70;; 834=C85H C74 ?A>C42C43
?>AC8>=B
C> 34B86=0C4 @D0;85843 8=5>A<0C8>= >A 8C4<B 3>4B =>C BC0=38=6 0;>=4 F08E4 C74
4B86=0C8=6 %0ACHLB A867C C> B42DA4 ?A>C42C8>= D=34A C78B $A34A 5>A BD27 <0C4A80;
*?>= C8<4;H 2>AA42C8>= >5 0 34B86=0C8>= C74 '4248E8=6 %0ACH <DBC <0:4 A40B>=01;4
455>ACB C> 0BBDA4 C70C C74 <0C4A80; 8B CA40C43 8= 022>A30=24 F8C7 C74 ?A>E8B8>=B >5 C78B
$A34A
=03E4AC4=C 08;DA4B C> 4B86=0C4 5 C8<4;H 2>AA42C43 0= 8=03E4AC4=C 508;DA4
!!# # $# #) ! )- ( #) $#(
)8<8=6 >5 70;;4=64B =H %0ACH >A #>=%0ACH <0H 270;;4=64 0 34B86=0C8>=
>5 2>=5834=C80;8CH 0C 0=H C8<4 C70C 8B 2>=B8BC4=C F8C7 C74 >DACLB (2743D;8=6 $A34A
"44C 0=3 >=54A )74 70;;4=68=6 %0ACH B70;; 8=8C80C4 C74 38B?DC4
A4B>;DC8>= ?A>24BB D=34A !>20; 'D;4 4C B4@
)74 1DA34= >5 ?4ABD0B8>= 8= 0=H BD27 270;;4=64 ?A>24438=6 B70;; 14
>= C74 4B86=0C8=6 %0ACH A8E>;>DB 270;;4=64B 0=3 C7>B4 <034 5>A 0= 8<?A>?4A
?DA?>B4 46 C> 70A0BB >A 8<?>B4 D==424BB0AH 4G?4=B4B 0=3 1DA34=B >= >C74A
?0AC84B <0H 4G?>B4 C74 70;;4=68=6 %0ACH C> B0=2C8>=B *=;4BB C74 4B86=0C8=6
%0ACH 70B F08E43 >A F8C73A0F= C74 2>=5834=C80;8CH 34B86=0C8>= 0;; ?0AC84B B70;;
2>=C8=D4 C> 055>A3 C74 <0C4A80; 8= @D4BC8>= C74 ;4E4; >5 ?A>C42C8>= C> F7827 8C 8B
4=C8C;43 D=34A C74 %A>3D28=6 %0ACHLB 34B86=0C8>= D=C8; C74 >DAC AD;4B >= C74
270;;4=64
(( )$ # *( $ %'$)) ")' !
0B82 %A8=28?;4B '4248E8=6 %0ACH <0H DB4 %A>C42C43 "0C4A80; C70C
8B 38B2;>B43 >A ?A>3D243 1H 0=>C74A %0ACH >A 1H 0 #>=%0ACH 8= 2>==42C8>= F8C7 C78B
2C8>= >=;H 5>A ?A>B42DC8=6 3454=38=6 >A 0CC4<?C8=6 C> B4CC;4 C78B 2C8>= (D27
%A>C42C43 "0C4A80; <0H 14 38B2;>B43 >=;H C> C74 20C46>A84B >5 ?4AB>=B 0=3 D=34A
C74 2>=38C8>=B 34B2A8143 8= C78B $A34A ,74= C74 2C8>= 70B 144= C4A<8=0C43 0
'4248E8=6 %0ACH <DBC 2><?;H F8C7 C74 ?A>E8B8>=B >5 B42C8>= 14;>F #!
(%$( ) $#
%A>C42C43 "0C4A80; <DBC 14 BC>A43 0=3 <08=C08=43 1H 0 '4248E8=6 %0ACH 0C 0
;>20C8>= 0=3 8= 0 B42DA4 <0==4A C70C 4=BDA4B C70C 0224BB 8B ;8<8C43 C> C74 ?4AB>=B
0DC7>A8I43 D=34A C78B $A34A
8B2;>BDA4 >5 J$# #) !K =5>A<0C8>= >A C4<B *=;4BB
>C74AF8B4 >A34A43 1H C74 2>DAC >A ?4A<8CC43 8= FA8C8=6 1H C74 4B86=0C8=6 %0ACH 0
'4248E8=6
%0ACH
<0H
38B2;>B4
0=H
8=5>A<0C8>=
J$# #) !K >=;H C>
>A
8C4<
34B86=0C43
0
C74 '4248E8=6 %0ACHLB $DCB834 >D=B4; >5 '42>A3 8= C78B 2C8>= 0B F4;;
0B 4<?;>H44B >5 B083 $DCB834 >D=B4; >5 '42>A3 C> F7>< 8C 8B
A40B>=01;H =424BB0AH C> 38B2;>B4 C74 8=5>A<0C8>= 5>A C78B 2C8>=
1
C74 >55824AB 38A42C>AB 0=3 4<?;>H44B 8=2;D38=6 >DB4 >D=B4; >5 C74
'4248E8=6 %0ACH C> F7>< 38B2;>BDA4 8B A40B>=01;H =424BB0AH 5>A C78B
2C8>=
2
G?4ACB 0B 3458=43 8= C78B $A34A >5 C74 '4248E8=6 %0ACH C> F7><
38B2;>BDA4 8B A40B>=01;H =424BB0AH 5>A C78B 2C8>= 0=3 F7> 70E4 B86=43
C74 J2:=>F;436<4=C 0=3 6A44<4=C C> 4 >D=3K G7818C
3
C74 2>DAC 0=3 8CB ?4AB>==4;
4
2>DAC A4?>AC4AB 0=3 C748A BC055
5
?A>54BB8>=0; 9DAH >A CA80; 2>=BD;C0=CB <>2: 9DA>AB 0=3 %A>54BB8>=0;
+4=3>AB C> F7>< 38B2;>BDA4 8B A40B>=01;H =424BB0AH 5>A C78B 2C8>= 0=3
F7> 70E4 B86=43 C74 J2:=>F;436<4=C 0=3 6A44<4=C C> 4 >D=3K
G7818C
6
C74 0DC7>A >A A428?84=C >5 0 3>2D<4=C 2>=C08=8=6 C74 8=5>A<0C8>= >A 0
2DBC>380= >A >C74A ?4AB>= F7> >C74AF8B4 ?>BB4BB43 >A :=4F C74
8=5>A<0C8>=
7
3DA8=6 C748A 34?>B8C8>=B F8C=4BB4B 0=3 0CC>A=4HB 5>A F8C=4BB4B 8= C74
2C8>= C> F7>< 38B2;>BDA4 8B A40B>=01;H =424BB0AH ?A>E8343 C74
34?>B8=6 ?0ACH A4@D4BCB C70C C74 F8C=4BB B86= C74 5>A< 0CC02743 0B
G7818C 74A4C> 0=3 C74H F8;; =>C 14 ?4A<8CC43 C> :44? 0=H
2>=5834=C80; 8=5>A<0C8>= D=;4BB C74H B86= C74 J2:=>F;436<4=C 0=3
6A44<4=C C> 4 >D=3K G7818C D=;4BB >C74AF8B4 06A443 1H C74
4B86=0C8=6 %0ACH >A >A34A43 1H C74 2>DAC %064B >5 CA0=B2A8143
34?>B8C8>= C4BC8<>=H >A 4G7818CB C> 34?>B8C8>=B C70C A4E40; %A>C42C43
"0C4A80; <0H 14 B4?0A0C4;H 1>D=3 1H C74 2>DAC A4?>AC4A 0=3 <0H =>C 14
38B2;>B43 C> 0=H>=4 4G24?C 0B ?4A<8CC43 D=34A C78B (C8?D;0C43 %A>C42C8E4
$A34A 0=3
8
0=H <4380C>AB >A B4CC;4<4=C >55824AB 0=3 C748A BD??>AC8=6 ?4AB>==4;
<DCD0;;H 06A443 D?>= 1H 0=H >5 C74 ?0AC84B 4=60643 8= B4CC;4<4=C
38B2DBB8>=B
%'$)) ")' ! (*%$# $' $''
%'$* # $) ' ! ) ) $#
5 0 %0ACH 8B B4AE43 F8C7 0 BD1?>4=0 >A 0 2>DAC >A34A 8BBD43 8= >C74A ;8C860C8>= C70C
2><?4;B 38B2;>BDA4 >5 0=H 8=5>A<0C8>= >A 8C4<B 34B86=0C43 8= C78B 2C8>= 0B
J$# #) !K C70C %0ACH <DBC
0
=>C85820C8>= B70;; 8=2;D34 0 2>?H >5 C74 BD1?>4=0 >A 2>DAC >A34A
?A><?C;H =>C85H 8= FA8C8=6 C74 4B86=0C8=6 %0ACH (D27
1
?A><?C;H =>C85H 8= FA8C8=6 C74 ?0ACH F7> 20DB43 C74 BD1?>4=0
>A >A34A C> 8BBD4 8= C74 >C74A ;8C860C8>= C70C B><4 >A 0;; >5 C74
<0C4A80; 2>E4A43 1H C74 BD1?>4=0 >A >A34A 8B BD1942C C> C78B
%A>C42C8E4 $A34A (D27 =>C85820C8>= B70;; 8=2;D34 0 2>?H >5 C78B
(C8?D;0C43 %A>C42C8E4 $A34A 0=3
2
2>>?4A0C4 F8C7 A4B?42C C> 0;; A40B>=01;4 ?A>243DA4B B>D67C C> 14
?DABD43 1H C74 4B86=0C8=6 %0ACH F7>B4 %A>C42C43 "0C4A80;
<0H 14 05542C43 5 C74 4B86=0C8=6 %0ACH C8<4;H B44:B 0
?A>C42C8E4 >A34A C74 %0ACH B4AE43 F8C7 C74 BD1?>4=0 >A 2>DAC
>A34A B70;; =>C ?A>3D24 0=H 8=5>A<0C8>= 34B86=0C43 8= C78B
02C8>= 0B J$# #) !K 145>A4 0 34C4A<8=0C8>= 1H C74
2>DAC 5A>< F7827 C74 BD1?>4=0 >A >A34A 8BBD43 D=;4BB C74 %0ACH
70B >1C08=43 C74 4B86=0C8=6 %0ACHLB ?4A<8BB8>= )74
4B86=0C8=6 %0ACH B70;; 140A C74 1DA34= 0=3 4G?4=B4 >5 B44:8=6
?A>C42C8>= 8= C70C 2>DAC >5 8CB 2>=5834=C80; <0C4A80; 0=3 =>C78=6
8= C74B4 ?A>E8B8>=B B7>D;3 14 2>=BCAD43 0B 0DC7>A8I8=6 >A
4=2>DA068=6 0 '4248E8=6 %0ACH 8= C78B 2C8>= C> 38B>14H 0
;0F5D; 38A42C8E4 5A>< 0=>C74A 2>DAC
#$#%')-L( %'$)) ")' ! ($* ) )$
%'$* # ) ( ! ) ) $#
0
)74 C4A<B >5 C78B $A34A 0A4 0??;8201;4 C> 8=5>A<0C8>= ?A>3D243 1H 0
#>=%0ACH 8= C78B 2C8>= 0=3 34B86=0C43 0B J$# #) !K (D27
8=5>A<0C8>= ?A>3D243 1H #>=%0AC84B 8= 2>==42C8>= F8C7 C78B ;8C860C8>=
8B ?A>C42C43 1H C74 A4<4384B 0=3 A4;845 ?A>E8343 1H C78B $A34A #>C78=6
8= C74B4 ?A>E8B8>=B B7>D;3 14 2>=BCAD43 0B ?A>7818C8=6 0 #>=%0ACH
5A>< B44:8=6 0338C8>=0; ?A>C42C8>=B
1
= C74 4E4=C C70C 0 %0ACH 8B A4@D8A43 1H 0 E0;83 38B2>E4AH A4@D4BC C>
?A>3D24 0 #>=%0ACHLB 2>=5834=C80; 8=5>A<0C8>= 8= 8CB ?>BB4BB8>= 0=3
C74 %0ACH 8B BD1942C C> 0= 06A44<4=C F8C7 C74 #>=%0ACH =>C C> ?A>3D24
C74 #>=%0ACHLB 2>=5834=C80; 8=5>A<0C8>= C74= C74 %0ACH B70;;
?A><?C;H =>C85H 8= FA8C8=6 C74 '4@D4BC8=6 %0ACH 0=3 C74
#>=%0ACH C70C B><4 >A 0;; >5 C74 8=5>A<0C8>= A4@D4BC43
8B BD1942C C> 0 2>=5834=C80;8CH 06A44<4=C F8C7 0 #>=
%0ACH
?A><?C;H ?A>E834 C74 #>=%0ACH F8C7 0 2>?H >5 C74
(C8?D;0C43 %A>C42C8E4 $A34A 8= C78B 2C8>= C74 A4;4E0=C
38B2>E4AH
A4@D4BCB
0=3
0
A40B>=01;H
34B2A8?C8>= >5 C74 8=5>A<0C8>= A4@D4BC43 0=3
B?428582
<0:4 C74 8=5>A<0C8>= A4@D4BC43 0E08;01;4 5>A 8=B?42C8>=
1H C74 #>=%0ACH 85 A4@D4BC43
2
5 C74 #>=%0ACH 508;B C> B44: 0 ?A>C42C8E4 >A34A 5A>< C78B 2>DAC F8C78=
30HB >5 A4248E8=6 C74 =>C824 0=3 022><?0=H8=6 8=5>A<0C8>= C74
'4248E8=6 %0ACH <0H ?A>3D24 C74 #>=%0ACHLB 2>=5834=C80;
8=5>A<0C8>= A4B?>=B8E4 C> C74 38B2>E4AH A4@D4BC 5 C74 #>=%0ACH
C8<4;H B44:B 0 ?A>C42C8E4 >A34A C74 '4248E8=6 %0ACH B70;; =>C ?A>3D24
0=H 8=5>A<0C8>= 8= 8CB ?>BB4BB8>= >A 2>=CA>; C70C 8B BD1942C C> C74
2>=5834=C80;8CH 06A44<4=C F8C7 C74 #>=%0ACH 145>A4 0 34C4A<8=0C8>=
1H C74 2>DAC 1B4=C 0 2>DAC >A34A C> C74 2>=CA0AH C74 #>=%0ACH B70;;
140A C74 1DA34= 0=3 4G?4=B4 >5 B44:8=6 ?A>C42C8>= 8= C78B 2>DAC >5 8CB
%A>C42C43 "0C4A80;
*#*) $' . (!$(*' $ %'$)) ")' !
5 0 '4248E8=6 %0ACH ;40A=B C70C 1H 8=03E4AC4=24 >A >C74AF8B4 8C 70B
38B2;>B43 %A>C42C43 "0C4A80; C> 0=H ?4AB>= >A 8= 0=H 28A2D<BC0=24 =>C 0DC7>A8I43
D=34A C78B (C8?D;0C43 %A>C42C8E4 $A34A C74 '4248E8=6 %0ACH <DBC 8<<4380C4;H 0
=>C85H 8= FA8C8=6 C74 4B86=0C8=6 %0ACH >5 C74 D=0DC7>A8I43 38B2;>BDA4B 1 DB4 8CB
14BC 455>ACB C> A4CA84E4 0;; D=0DC7>A8I43 2>?84B >5 C74 %A>C42C43 "0C4A80; 2 8=5>A<
C74 ?4AB>= >A ?4AB>=B C> F7>< D=0DC7>A8I43 38B2;>BDA4B F4A4 <034 >5 0;; C74 C4A<B
>5 C78B $A34A 0=3 3 A4@D4BC BD27 ?4AB>= >A ?4AB>=B C> 4G42DC4 C74
J2:=>F;436<4=C 0= 6A44<4=C C> 4 >D=3K 0CC02743 74A4C> 0B G7818C
#+')#) %'$*) $# $ %' + ! $'
$) ', ( %'$)) ")' !
,74= 0 %A>3D28=6 %0ACH 68E4B =>C824 C> '4248E8=6 %0AC84B C70C 24AC08= 8=03E4AC4=C;H
?A>3D243 <0C4A80; 8B BD1942C C> 0 2;08< >5 ?A8E8;464 >A >C74A ?A>C42C8>= C74
>1;860C8>=B >5 C74 '4248E8=6 %0AC84B 0A4 C7>B4 B4C 5>AC7 8= 434A0; 'D;4 >5 8E8;
%A>243DA4
1 )78B ?A>E8B8>= 8B =>C 8=C4=343 C> <>385H F70C4E4A
?A>243DA4 <0H 14 4BC01;8B743 8= 0= 438B2>E4AH >A34A C70C ?A>E834B 5>A ?A>3D2C8>=
F8C7>DC ?A8>A ?A8E8;464 A4E84F %DABD0=C C> 434A0; 'D;4 >5 E834=24
4 8=B>50A 0B C74 ?0AC84B A4027 0= 06A44<4=C >= C74 45542C >5 38B2;>BDA4 >5 0
2><<D=820C8>= >A 8=5>A<0C8>= 2>E4A43 1H C74 0CC>A=4H2;84=C ?A8E8;464 >A F>A:
3 0=3
?A>3D2C ?A>C42C8>= C74 ?0AC84B <0H 8=2>A?>A0C4 C748A 06A44<4=C 8= C74 BC8?D;0C43
?A>C42C8E4 >A34A BD1<8CC43 C> C74 2>DAC
" (!!#$*(
'867C C> DAC74A '4;845 #>C78=6 8= C78B $A34A 01A8364B C74 A867C >5 0=H
?4AB>= C> B44: 8CB <>385820C8>= 1H C74 >DAC 8= C74 5DCDA4
'867C C> BB4AC $C74A $1942C8>=B H BC8?D;0C8=6 C> C74 4=CAH >5 C78B
%A>C42C8E4 $A34A => %0ACH F08E4B 0=H A867C 8C >C74AF8B4 F>D;3 70E4 C> >1942C C>
38B2;>B8=6 >A ?A>3D28=6 0=H 8=5>A<0C8>= >A 8C4< >= 0=H 6A>D=3 =>C 033A4BB43 8=
C78B (C8?D;0C43 %A>C42C8E4 $A34A (8<8;0A;H => %0ACH F08E4B 0=H A867C C> >1942C >=
0=H 6A>D=3 C> DB4 8= 4E834=24 >5 0=H >5 C74 <0C4A80; 2>E4A43 1H C78B %A>C42C8E4
$A34A
8;8=6 %A>C42C43 "0C4A80; %0ACH C70C B44:B C> 58;4 D=34A B40; 0=H
%A>C42C43 "0C4A80; <DBC 2><?;H F8C7 !>20; 8E8; 'D;4 %A>C42C43 "0C4A80;
<0H >=;H 14 58;43 D=34A B40; ?DABD0=C C> 0 2>DAC >A34A 0DC7>A8I8=6 C74 B40;8=6 >5 C74
B?428582 %A>C42C43 "0C4A80; 5 0 %0ACHLB A4@D4BC C> 58;4 %A>C42C43 "0C4A80; D=34A B40;
8B 34=843 1H C74 2>DAC C74= C74 '4248E8=6 %0ACH <0H 58;4 C74 8=5>A<0C8>= 8= C74
?D1;82 A42>A3 D=;4BB >C74AF8B4 8=BCAD2C43 1H C74 2>DAC
#! (%$( ) $#
5C4A C74 58=0; 38B?>B8C8>= >5 C78B 2C8>= 0B 3458=43 8= ?0A06A0?7 F8C78=
30HB >5 0 FA8CC4= A4@D4BC 1H C74 4B86=0C8=6 %0ACH 4027 '4248E8=6 %0ACH <DBC
A4CDA= 0;; %A>C42C43 "0C4A80; C> C74 %A>3D28=6 %0ACH >A 34BCA>H BD27 <0C4A80; B
) ( ($ () %*!) ) '$* $*#(! $ '$'
) 41AD0AH
) ' ) ))$'#- #
H , ).,,!" '').
->DBB45 0<<>D3
).(,!& ")+ & $(-$""
/$ $ ,
) 41AD0AH
*#) #' &*( !!%
H , .,-$,, ) ,
DAC8BB 02>1B !!"
).(,!& ")+ !"!( (.(- !(+$*.!,
)74 D=34AB86=43 70B A403 0=3 D=34ABC0=3B C74 C4A<B >5 C74 6A443
%A>C42C8E4>=5834=C80;8CH $A34A 45542C8E4 8= C78B 20B4 /$ $ , / .(- (
!(+$*.!, ( $-$ (% $/$& -$)( )
F7827 8B 2DAA4=C;H ?4=38=6 8= C74 *=8C43 (C0C4B 8BCA82C >DAC 5>A C74 4=CA0;
/
8BCA82C >5 0;85>A=80 (>DC74A= 8E8B8>= )74 D=34AB86=43 06A44B 8 C> 01834 1H
C74 C4A<B >5 C74 6A443 %A>C42C8E4>=5834=C80;8CH $A34A 88 =>C C> DB4 >A 38ED;64
D=34A ?4=0;CH >5 ;0F 0=H 3>2D<4=CB <0C4A80;B >A >C74A 8=5>A<0C8>= 2>E4A43 1H C74
6A443 %A>C42C8E4>=5834=C80;8CH $A34A 8=2;D38=6 >=5834=C80; =5>A<0C8>=
4G24?C 0B ?4A<8CC43 1H C74 C4A<B >5 C74 6A443 %A>C42C8E4>=5834=C80;8CH $A34A
0=3 888 C> BD1<8C C> C74 9DA8B382C8>= >5 C74 *=8C43 (C0C4B 8BCA82C >DAC 5>A 4=CA0;
8BCA82C >5 0;85>A=80 (>DC74A= 8E8B8>= 5>A A4B>;DC8>= >5 0=H 8BBD4B 0A8B8=6 D=34A
C74 6A443 %A>C42C8E4>=5834=C80;8CH $A34A
0C43 ////////////////////
(86=43 ////////////////////////
%A8=C43 ////////////////////////
]]>
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?
