U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission v. Farmers Insurance Exchange
Filing
66
CONSENT DECREE signed by District Judge Anthony W. Ishii on 10/26/2016. CASE CLOSED. (Lundstrom, T)
1
2
3
4
5
6
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
7
EASTERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
U.S. EQUAL EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY ) Case No: 1:13-CV-01574 AWI SKO
)
COMMISSION,
)
Plaintiff,
) CONSENT DECREE
)
)
vs.
)
FARMERS INSURANCE EXCHANGE , AND )
)
DOES 1-10, INCLUSIVE,
)
)
)
Defendant
)
)
16
17
Plaintiff U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (the “EEOC” or
18
“Commission”) and Defendant Farmers Insurance Exchange (“Farmers” or “Defendant”) hereby
19
stipulate and agree to entry of this Consent Decree (“Decree”) to resolve the Commission’s
20
complaint against Defendant in U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission v. Farmers
21
Insurance Exchange, et al., Case No. 1:13-CV-1574 AWI SKO (the “Action”). On September
22
30, 2013, Plaintiff filed this Action in the United States District Court, Eastern District of
23
California, for violations of the Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, as amended, 42 U.S.C.
24
§ 2000e et seq. (“Title VII”). The Action alleges Defendant violated Title VII by unlawfully
25
discriminating against a class of Asian employees and further retaliated against a non Asian
26
employee for his participation in a protected activity. The Defendant denies any liability in this
27
Action. This Decree and compliance with the terms herein shall not be construed as an
28
admission that Defendant is liable for any alleged violation of Title VII.
-1-
1
I.
2
PURPOSES AND SCOPE OF THE DECREE
In the interest of resolving this matter, and as a result of having engaged in
3
comprehensive settlement negotiations, the EEOC and Defendant (the “Parties”) have agreed
4
that this Action against the Defendant should be finally resolved by entry of this Decree. This
5
Decree shall be binding on and enforceable against Defendant and its agents, successor and
6
assigns. The EEOC and Defendant, as parties to this Decree, agree that this Decree resolves any
7
and all claims arising out of the Action.
8
II.
9
A.
RELEASE OF CLAIMS
The Parties agree that this Decree resolves all claims alleged by the EEOC in its
10
Complaint of the Action that were made, or could have been made, by the EEOC in this Action
11
against Defendant based on the administrative charges that were filed and that formed the basis
12
of the EEOC’s Complaint in the Action, or that could be filed against Defendant in the Action
13
itself.
14
B.
Nothing in this Decree shall be construed to preclude any party from bringing suit
15
to enforce this Decree in the event that any party hereto fails to perform the promises and
16
representations contained herein.
17
18
19
C.
Nothing in this Decree shall be construed to limit or reduce Defendant’s
obligation to comply fully with Title VII or any other federal employment statute.
D.
This Decree in no way affects the EEOC’s right to bring, process, investigate, or
20
litigate other charges that may be in existence or may later arise against Defendant in accordance
21
with standard EEOC procedures. This Decree shall in no way hinder or affect an individual’s
22
right to file a charge with the EEOC or applicable state agency, participate in a federal or state
23
investigation, or the EEOC’s investigation and determinations into such charges.
24
25
26
27
28
III.
A.
JURISDICTION
The Court has jurisdiction over the Parties and the subject matter of this Action.
The Court is authorized to grant the equitable relief set forth in this Decree.
B.
This Decree conforms with the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and Title VII and
is not in derogation of the rights or privileges of any person.
-2-
1
C.
The Court shall retain jurisdiction of this action during the duration of the Decree
2
for the purposes of entering any order, judgment, or decree that may be necessary to implement
3
the relief provided herein.
4
5
6
7
8
IV.
A.
The provisions and agreements contained herein are effective immediately upon
the date in which this Decree is entered by the Court (“the Effective Date”).
B.
Except as otherwise provided herein, this Decree shall remain in effect for two
years (2 years) after the Effective Date.
9
10
EFFECTIVE DATE AND DURATION OF DECREE
V.
A.
MODIFICATION AND SEVERABILITY
This Decree constitutes the complete understanding of the Parties with respect to
11
the matters contained herein. No waiver, modification, or amendment of any provision of this
12
Decree will be effective unless made in writing and signed by an authorized representative of
13
each of the Parties.
14
B.
If one or more of the provisions of the Decree are rendered unlawful or
15
unenforceable, the parties shall make good faith efforts to agree upon appropriate amendments to
16
this Decree in order to effectuate the purposes of the Decree. In any event, the remaining
17
provisions will remain in full force and effect unless the purposes of the Decree cannot, despite
18
the Parties’ best efforts, be achieved.
19
20
C.
the interests of justice and fairness in order to effectuate the provisions of the Decree.
21
22
By mutual agreement of the Parties, this Decree may be amended or modified in
VI.
A.
COMPLIANCE AND RESOLUTION
The Parties agree that if the EEOC has reason to believe that Defendant has failed
23
to comply with any provision of this Decree, the EEOC may bring an action before this Court to
24
enforce the Decree. Prior to initiating such action, the EEOC will notify Defendant and its legal
25
counsel of record, in writing, of the nature of the dispute. This notice shall specify the particular
26
provision(s) that the EEOC believes Defendant has breached. Defendant shall have thirty (30)
27
days to attempt to resolve or cure the breach. However, the parties may agree to extend this
28
period upon mutual consent.
-3-
1
B.
After sixty (60) days, inclusive of the thirty (30) days to resolve or cure the breach
2
referenced in Section VI.A, have passed with no resolution or agreement to extend the time
3
further, the EEOC may petition this Court for resolution of the dispute. The EEOC may seek all
4
available relief, including an extension of the term of the Decree for such period of time that the
5
Court finds the Decree was not complied with and/or any other relief that the Court may deem
6
appropriate.
7
8
9
10
11
12
VII.
A.
MONETARY RELIEF
In settlement of this lawsuit, Defendant shall pay a gross, maximum settlement
amount of $225,000.00 (the “monetary relief”).
B.
Allocation of the monetary relief to the Claimants (Chia Xiong, John Yang, and
Jason Lowry) shall be at the sole discretion of the EEOC.
C.
On the Effective Date, the EEOC shall inform Defendant the amount of monetary
13
relief allocated by the EEOC, together with all other information necessary to issue payments to
14
the three Claimants, including relevant tax forms and updated address information. Within ten
15
(10) business days after being informed of the allocation and obtaining the necessary
16
information, Defendant shall, via certified mail, issue payment representing the amount payable
17
as wages, minus applicable withholdings, to the three Claimants as well as a separate check
18
representing the amount payable as emotional distress damages. Defendant has met its
19
obligations with respect to monetary relief under this Decree by honoring the checks upon timely
20
presentment by Claimants.
21
D.
For tax purposes, the monetary relief will be characterized as 50% for alleged lost
22
wages to be reported on a W-2, and 50% for alleged emotional distress damages to be reported
23
on a Form 1099. Defendant shall prepare and distribute Form W-2, Form 1099, or equivalent tax
24
reporting forms to Claimants in accordance with the instructions of the EEOC and shall make
25
the appropriate reports to the Internal Revenue Service and other tax authorities. Defendant is
26
not giving any tax advice in connection with the monetary relief or any payments to be made
27
pursuant to this Consent Decree. Each Claimant agrees to hold harmless Defendant from any
28
liability for taxes, fees, costs, or assessments resulting from his failure to timely pay his share of
-4-
1
taxes, interest, fees, or penalties owed. Within three (3) business days of the issuance of the
2
settlement checks, Defendant shall submit a copy of the checks and related correspondence to
3
Anna Y. Park, Regional Attorney, U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, 255 East
4
Temple Street, 4th Floor, Los Angeles, California, 90012.
5
VIII. GENERAL INJUNCTIVE RELIEF
6
Defendant, on behalf of its officers and agents, hereby acknowledges its obligations to
7
comply with Title VII, including the law’s anti-discrimination and anti-retaliation provisions.
8
Specifically, Defendant acknowledges that it is an unlawful employment practice for an
9
employer to discriminate against any individual with respect to his compensation, terms,
10
conditions, or privileges of employment, because of such individual’s race and that it is an
11
unlawful employment practice to discriminate against any individual because he has opposed any
12
practice made an unlawful employment practice by Title VII, or because he has made a charge,
13
testified, assisted, or participated in any manner in an investigation, proceeding, or hearing under
14
Title VII, including this Action or this Decree.
15
16
17
IX.
A.
SPECIFIC INJUNCTIVE RELIEF
Internal Equal Employment Opportunity Monitor
1.
Within sixty (30) days after the Effective Date, Defendant shall designate
18
an internal Equal Employment Opportunity Monitor (“Monitor”). The Monitor shall have
19
demonstrated experience in areas of employment discrimination and retaliation, and shall be
20
independent from the Fresno Branch Claims Office (“BCO”) in the reporting structure to ensure
21
independent oversight by the Monitor. The Monitor shall monitor Defendant’s compliance with
22
Title VII at the Fresno BCO as specified by the provisions of this Decree.
23
2.
The Monitor shall be subject to the EEOC’s approval, which shall not be
24
unreasonably withheld. Defendant shall provide the name and a summary of qualification for the
25
proposed Monitor to the EEOC two weeks prior to the designation of the Monitor. If the EEOC
26
does not approve Defendant’s proposed Monitor, Defendant shall provide a list of at least three
27
alternative candidates and from which EEOC shall select the Monitor. Defendant shall bear all
28
costs associated with the selection and retention of the Monitor and the performance of his/her
-5-
1
duties. Should the Monitor be unable or unwilling to continue as Monitor for the duration of the
2
Decree, the procedures set forth in this Section IX.A.2 shall also apply to the selection of a new
3
Monitor.
4
3.
The Monitor’s responsibilities shall include:
5
a.
Ensuring Defendant’s compliance with the terms of the Decree;
6
b.
Ensuring Defendant maintains policies and procedures that effectively
7
carry out its obligations under Title VII at the Fresno BCO as specified by
8
this Decree;
9
c.
Ensuring that all employees at the Fresno BCO required under the law or
10
this Decree are trained on their rights and responsibilities under Title VII
11
and this Decree;
12
d.
Ensuring that all employees at the Fresno BCO are provided an
13
opportunity to provide information regarding racial discrimination or
14
retaliation;
15
e.
Ensuring that the investigations regarding racial discrimination,
16
harassment or retaliation at the Fresno BCO are effective, that Defendant
17
properly communicates with complainants from the Fresno BCO
18
regarding the status and results of their complaints, and that Defendant
19
ensures no retaliatory actions are taken against the complainant at the
20
Fresno BCO;
21
f.
Ensuring the provision of training and guidance to human resources
22
personnel dedicated to serving the Fresno BCO on how to conduct
23
investigations and review and assess human resources’ response and
24
advice as to EEO matters under Title VII at the Fresno BCO;
25
g.
Ensuring that Defendant creates or maintains a centralized system of
26
tracking discrimination, harassment and retaliation complaints with
27
respect to the Fresno BCO, as required by this Decree;
28
-6-
1
h.
2
Preparing an annual report to the EEOC on Defendant’s progress and its
compliance under this Decree, as described in Section IX G below; and
3
i.
4
Ensuring that all reports required by this Decree are accurately compiled
and timely submitted.
5
B.
Policies and Procedures
6
1.
Within ninety (90) days of the Effective Date, Defendant will confirm that they
7
have published, or will publish in a form that is accessible to its employees, anti-harassment and
8
anti-discrimination policies that prohibit violation of Title VII (the “Policy”), which include the
9
following provisions in substantive part (although, the policies need not be verbatim of the
10
11
language in this Decree):
a. A clear explanation of prohibited conduct under the Policy, including an
12
explanation that harassment and discrimination on the basis of race, color,
13
national origin, sex, age, disability, creed/religion, or any other protected class,
14
and retaliation is prohibited with a particular emphasis that the company will not
15
tolerate any incidents of race discrimination or retaliation;
16
b. An assurance that employees who make complaints of harassment/discrimination
17
or provide information related to such complaints will be protected against
18
retaliation;
19
c. A clearly described complaint process that provides accessible and confidential
20
avenues for complaints, including information regarding an internal and external
21
person whom employees may report incidents of discrimination and retaliation;
22
d. An assurance that Defendant will protect the confidentiality of complainants to
23
the extent possible from being disclosed to those persons who do not need to
24
know;
25
26
e. Assurances that the complaint process will include a prompt, thorough, and
impartial investigation;
27
f. A procedure for communicating with the complainant regarding the status of the
28
complaint/investigation, results of the investigation, and any remedial action
-7-
1
taken;
2
g. An instruction that supervisors and managers shall report to human resource
3
personnel incidents of harassment or discrimination that they witness or are aware
4
of; and
5
h. Assurances that Defendant will take immediate and appropriate corrective action
6
if it determines that harassment/discrimination and/or retaliation has occurred.
7
2.
8
Defendant further agrees that the Policy shall describe the process by which Defendant’s
9
Procedure for Handling Complaints
employees will handle complaints of discrimination. The Policy shall at minimum provide the
10
following general information (although verbatim language is not required): (1) upon a
11
complaint by an employee or any other form of notice, the employee receiving the complaint
12
shall inform one or more persons identified in the Defendant’s policies outlining the method for
13
raising complaints regarding possible discrimination in the workplace (including, but not limited
14
to Human Resources); (2) Human Resources and/or an authorized designee shall conduct a
15
prompt and thorough investigation of all complaints, including but not limited to interviewing
16
the complaining party/victim, the alleged perpetrator, available or identifiable witnesses; (3)
17
Human Resources and/or an authorized designee shall update the complaining party/victim of the
18
status of the investigation; (4) Human Resources and/or an authorized designee and Defendant’s
19
employees shall limit information revealed to those individuals that have a business need to
20
know and to the extent a prompt and thorough investigation will allow; (5) at the conclusion of
21
the investigation, Defendant shall take all appropriate steps to remedy and prevent future
22
incidents of discrimination, harassment, and retaliation with respect to the complaining party;
23
and (6) Defendant will provide any complaining employee with information regarding how to
24
report issues relating to perceived retaliation. Defendant further agrees to implement a
25
centralized system for tracking, gathering, and retaining discrimination, harassment, and
26
retaliation complaints.
27
///
28
///
-8-
1
3.
Distribution of Policy
2
For any revised or additional documents describing the Policy, within forty-five (45) days
3
of the Effective Date of this Decree, Defendant shall provide to the EEOC a copy of the revised
4
or additional documents describing the Policy. Within sixty (60) days of the Effective Date and
5
annually thereafter, Defendant shall ensure that it has distributed, either physically or
6
electronically, any revised or additional documents describing the Policy to all employees in the
7
Fresno BCO. Within ninety (90) days of the Effective Date, Defendant shall submit to the
8
EEOC a statement confirming the distribution of any revised or additional documents describing
9
the Policy.
10
Within thirty (30) days of the hire date of any person hired in the Fresno BCO after the
11
initial distribution but within the term of the Decree, Defendant shall ensure that it has
12
distributed the Policy to that person. On an annual basis for the duration of the Decree,
13
Defendant shall submit to the EEOC a statement confirming the distribution of the Policy to any
14
person hired after the initial distribution but within the term of the Decree.
15
Within sixty (60) days of the Effective Date, Defendant shall ensure that it has posted the
16
Policy, physically or electronically, in an area accessible to all employees in the Fresno BCO.
17
Within ninety (90) days of the Effective Date, Defendant shall submit to the EEOC a statement
18
confirming the posting of the Policy.
19
C.
20
21
Accountability for Implementing Anti-Discrimination and Anti-Retaliation
Policies and Procedures
Defendant remains committed to its policies and procedures that prohibit conduct made
22
unlawful by Title VII and will continue to hold its human resources personnel accountable for
23
abiding by all applicable federal and state laws relating to the prevention of and prohibition
24
against discrimination and retaliation, including through performance feedback in performance
25
evaluations of human resources personnel.
26
D.
Posting of Notice of Consent Decree and Settlement
27
Within thirty (30) days of the Effective Date and for the duration of the Decree,
28
Defendant shall ensure that it has posted the Notice of Consent Decree and Settlement (attached
-9-
1
to this Decree as Attachment A), physically or electronically, in a conspicuous place accessible
2
in Defendant’s Fresno BCO facility. Within thirty (30) days of the Effective Date and annually
3
thereafter during the duration of this Consent Decree, Defendant shall submit to the EEOC a
4
statement confirming the posting of the Notice of Consent Decree and Settlement.
5
E.
Training
6
Within one-hundred and twenty (120) days of the Effective Date and annually thereafter
7
during the duration of this Consent Decree, Defendant shall provide in-person “live” training,
8
lasting at least one hour in duration to all of Defendant’s Human Resources personnel and Field
9
Claims Managers dedicated to serving or overseeing the Fresno BCO. The trainings shall cover
10
the Policy, Defendant’s complaint process, and federal laws regarding employment
11
discrimination with a particular emphasis on race discrimination and retaliation. The training
12
shall have interactive components. Where an employee is unable to attend the scheduled
13
training, Defendant shall provide an alternative interactive web-based training session within
14
sixty (60) days of the training. All persons required to attend such training shall verify their
15
attendance in writing. Within sixty (60) days of the hire date of any Human Resources employee
16
or Field Claims Managers dedicated to serving the Fresno BCO hired after the annual training
17
but within the term of the Decree, Defendant shall provide an interactive web-based training of at
18
least one hour duration covering the Policy, Defendant’s complaint process, and federal laws
19
regarding employment discrimination with a particular emphasis on race discrimination and
20
retaliation. All persons required to attend such training shall verify their attendance in writing.
21
Within one-hundred and twenty (120) days of the Effective Date and annually thereafter,
22
Defendant shall produce to the EEOC documents verifying the occurrence of all training sessions
23
conducted as required under this Decree, including a description of the training provided, a list of
24
individuals who conducted the training, and the names and job titles of those who attended the
25
training session.
26
F.
27
Defendant shall maintain a record-keeping procedure that provides for the centralized
28
Record Keeping
tracking of discrimination complaints as well as the monitoring of such complaints, including the
-10-
1
identities of the parties involved. The records to be maintained shall include all documents
2
generated through the duration of the Decree in connection with Defendant’s compliance with
3
the Decree, any complaints of discrimination, any investigation into the complaint, and any
4
resolution of the complaint. Defendant shall maintain records to enable identification of repeat
5
offenders of complaints of race discrimination/harassment or retaliation.
6
G.
7
Defendant, through the internal Monitor, shall provide the following annual reports to the
8
9
10
Reporting
EEOC:
1.
Confirmation of the training sessions required under this Decree that
occurred since the previous report, including the names and job titles of attendees;
11
2.
Confirmation of receipt of the Policy by all employees hired in the Fresno
12
BCO since the previous report;
13
3.
A general description of the process for reporting and responding to
14
complaints of race discrimination/harassment and retaliation made during the time period
15
covered by the report.
16
4.
A general description of the race discrimination/harassment and retaliation
17
complaints made during the time period covered by the report in the Fresno BCO. The
18
description shall include, subject to the Attorney-Client and/or Attorney Work Product
19
Privileges: the date of the complaint; the nature of the complaint; identification of the alleged
20
perpetrators by use of anonymized individual identifiers; identification of the complainant by
21
use of anonymized individual identifiers; whether the alleged perpetrator(s) have been the
22
subject of more than one complaint of race discrimination/harassment or retaliation during the
23
term of the Consent Decree; whether witnesses were interviewed; a statement about whether a
24
finding was made; and, a brief summary of how the complaint was resolved, including whether
25
action was taken.
26
27
The EEOC may require Defendant, within fourteen (14) days after a demand by EEOC,
to provide names of alleged perpetrators where more than one race discrimination/harassment or
28
-11-
1
retaliation complaint has been filed against the same perpetrator alleging the same or similar
2
conduct during the term of the Consent Decree.
3
5.
Verification that the Notice of Consent Decree and Settlement and Policy
4
continue to be posted, physically or electronically, in a conspicuous place accessible to all
5
employees in the Fresno BCO;
6
6.
7
A summary of the procedures and methods for the record keeping
described in Section IX.F
8
7.
The status of Defendant’s compliance with the terms of the Decree; and
9
8.
Whether any of Defendant’s policies and procedures regarding
10
discrimination and harassment have been revised, including a copy of the revised policies or
11
procedures.
12
13
X. MISCELLANEOUS PROVISIONS
A.
During the term of this Decree, Defendant shall assure that each of its officers,
14
managers, and supervisors with responsibilities over the Fresno BCO is aware of any term(s) of
15
this Decree which may be related to his/her job duties.
16
B.
Unless otherwise stated, all notices, reports and correspondence required under
17
this Decree shall be delivered to the attention of Anna Y. Park, Regional Attorney, U.S. Equal
18
Employment Opportunity Commission, 255 East Temple Street, 4th Floor, Los Angeles,
19
California, 90012; facsimile number (213) 894-1301.
20
21
22
23
24
25
C.
This Decree may be signed in counterparts. A facsimile signature shall have the
same force and effect of an original signature or copy thereof.
D.
During the term of this Decree, Defendant shall provide any potential successor in
interest with a copy of the Decree.
XI.
COSTS AND ATTORNEYS’ FEES
Defendant shall bear all costs associated with its administration and implementation of its
26
obligations under this Decree, including but not limited to the distribution of the settlement
27
money. Each party shall bear its own costs of suit and attorneys’ fees.
28
All parties, through the undersigned, respectfully apply for and consent to the entry of
-12-
1
this Consent Decree Order.
2
Respectfully Submitted,
3
U.S. EQUAL EMPLOYMENT
OPPORTUNITY COMMISSION
Anna Y. Park
4
5
Date: _____10/6/16___________
6
7
By: _______/s/ signature in original__________
Anna Y. Park
Attorneys for Plaintiff EEOC
8
FARMERS INSURANCE EXCHANGE
9
10
Date: ______10/5/16__________
By: ________/s/ signature in original_________
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
-13-
1
ORDER
2
3
GOOD CAUSE APPEARING:
4
The Court hereby finds that compliance with all provisions of the foregoing Decree is fair
5
6
and adequate. The Court hereby retains jurisdiction for the term of the foregoing Consent
Decree, and the provisions thereof are hereby approved.
7
8
9
10
IT IS SO ORDERED.
Dated:
October 26, 2016
SENIOR DISTRICT JUDGE
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
-14-
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?