MP Nexlevel of CA, Inc. v. CVIN, LLC, et al.

Filing 269

STIPULATION and ORDER regarding the discovery disagreements between plaintiff MP Nexlevel of California, Inc., and defendant CVIN, LLC. The stipulation of the parties is hereby approved, and the items listed in paragraphs 1-5 of the stipulation shall be the Order of the Court. Order signed by Magistrate Judge Erica P. Grosjean on 3/2/2016. (Rooney, M)

Ben Patrick (SBN 244092)
1 GORDON & REES LLP
275 Battery Street
2 Suite 2000
San Francisco, CA 94111
3 Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: [phone]
4 e-mail: [e-mail]
5
Holly J. Newman (MN Bar No. 026457X) (Pro Hac Vice)
6 James D. Kremer (MN Bar No. 211461) (Pro Hac Vice)
DEWITT MACKALL CROUNSE & MOORE, S.C.
7 901 Marquette Avenue, Suite 1400
Minneapolis, MN 55402
8 Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile:
[phone]
9 e-mail: [e-mail]
[e-mail]
10
David W. Larson (MN Bar No. 60495) (Pro Hac Vice)
11 MARTIN & SQUIRES, P.A.
332 Minnesota Street, Suite W2750
12 St. Paul, Minnesota 55101
Telephone:
[phone]
13 Facsimile: [phone]
e-mail: [e-mail]
14
Attorneys for Plaintiff
15 MP NEXLEVEL OF CALIFORNIA, INC.
And Third-Party Defendant
16 WESTERN SURETY COMPANY
17
18

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

19

EASTERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

20

FRESNO DIVISION

21 MP NEXLEVEL of California, Inc.,
22
23

MP Nexlevel,
v.

24 CVIN, LLC dba VAST NETWORKS,

CALAVERAS COMMUNICATIONS

Case No. 1:14-cv-00288-LJO-GSA
STIPULATION RE DISCOVERY
DISAGREEMENTS BETWEEN
PLAINTIFF MP NEXLEVEL OF
CALIFORNIA, INC. AND DEFENDANT
CVIN, LLC

25 COMPANY, SEBASTIAN

[Discovery Motion – L.R. 251]

ENTERPRISES, INC., VOLCANO
26 COMMUNICATIONS COMPANY,
STAGELINE COMMUNICATIONS,
27 INC., THE PONDEROSA TELEPHONE
COMPANY, SIERRA TEL

Complaint Filed February 28, 2014
Trial Date: July 25, 2017

28

STIPULATION AND ORDER RE DISCOVERY DISAGREEMENTS BETWEEN PLAINTIFF MP
NEXLEVEL OF CALIFORNIA, INC. AND DEFENDANT CVIN, LLC

[1]
1238098v.1

COMMUNICATIONS GROUP,

1 VARNET, INC., CAL-ORE

TELEPHONE CO., DUCOR

2 TELEPHONE COMPANY,

CONSOLIDATED COMMUNICATIONS

3 HOLDINGS, INC., MOHAVE

INVESTMENT, LLC, SIERRA TEL

4 BROADBAND, SUREWEST FIBER

VENTURES, LLC, VARCOMM, INC,

5 VOLCANO TELECOM, INC. and DOES
6

1 to 100,
Defendants.

7
8

CVIN, LLC,
Counter and Cross-Claimant,

9

v.

10

MP NEXLEVEL OF CALIFORNIA, INC,

11 WESTERN SURETY COMPANY, ROES
12

1 through 50, inclusive,
Cross-Defendants,

13

MP NEXLEVEL OF CALIFORNIA,

14 INC.,
15
16

Third-Party Plaintiff,
v.

17 APEX DIRECTIONAL DRILLING, LLC;

AND JK COMMUNICATIONS &

18 CONSTRUCTION, INC. dba KLEVEN

CONSTRUCTION, GEORGE

19 VALENTINEZ, dba ALLIED PLUS LOW
20

VOLTAGE
Third-Party Defendants.

21
22
23
24
25
26

WHEREAS, a dispute exists between Plaintiff MP Nexlevel of California, Inc. (“MPN”)
and Defendant CVIN, LLC (“CVIN”) regarding the sufficiency of the efforts undertaken by CVIN
to date to search for and produce responsive, relevant emails and CVIN’s compliance with the
Stipulation for Preserving and Producing Electronic Evidence (the “ESI Protocol”);

27
28

STIPULATION AND ORDER RE DISCOVERY DISAGREEMENTS BETWEEN PLAINTIFF MP
NEXLEVEL OF CALIFORNIA, INC. AND DEFENDANT CVIN, LLC

[2]
1238098v.1

1

WHEREAS, CVIN conducted electronic searches of its records to identify and produce

2 responsive, non-privileged emails in response to MPN’s discovery requests, employing certain
3 search terms (the “Prior CVIN Productions”);
4

WHEREAS, MPN has challenged the sufficiency of CVIN’s search terms and search

5
efforts underlying and relating to the Prior CVIN Productions, and requested that CVIN conduct
6
supplemental searches of its emails utilizing additional search terms identified by MPN and make
7
a supplemental production in accordance with the ESI Protocol;
8
9

WHEREAS, counsel for MPN and CVIN participated in informal discovery conferences

10 with the Court on December 18, 2015 and January 13, 2016, and have separately engaged in meet
11 and confer communications, in an effort to resolve the disputes between them relating to the Prior
12 CVIN Productions without resort to formal motion practice;
13
WHEREAS, during the January 13, 2016 informal discovery conference CVIN disclosed
14

to MPN and the Court that pst (email) files (the “Missing PST Files”) that should have been

15
included in the materials provided by CVIN to its counsel for review and production were
16
unintentionally omitted from the corpus of documents heretofore reviewed for responsiveness and
17
production to MPN, necessitating a supplemental search and production of responsive emails from
18
the Missing PST Files;
19
20

WHEREAS, following the January 13, 2016 informal discovery conference and with the

21 benefit of the Court’s guidance provided therein, counsel for CVIN and MPN have met and
22 conferred regarding the scope and timing of supplemental searches and a supplemental production
23 by CVIN in accordance with the ESI Protocol, including the collection and production by CVIN
24 of custodian and “other custodian” information; and
25
WHEREAS, MPN and CVIN have agreed to resolve their present discovery disagreements
26
in accordance with the terms set forth herein,
27
28

STIPULATION AND ORDER RE DISCOVERY DISAGREEMENTS BETWEEN PLAINTIFF MP
NEXLEVEL OF CALIFORNIA, INC. AND DEFENDANT CVIN, LLC

[3]
1238098v.1

1

NOW THEREFORE, MPN and CVIN stipulate and agree as follows:

2
1. CVIN shall review and produce the responsive emails contained within the Missing
3

PST Files (hereinafter “Supplemental Email Production”). The Missing PST Files, and

4
the corresponding responsive emails, will be de-duplicated against the emails
5
previously produced by CVIN.

CVIN represents that the Missing PST Files are

6
comprised of email searches conducted using the CVIN search terms attached hereto as
7
Exhibit A and performed at the CVIN server level; that this prior search did not capture
8

“Custodian” and “Other Custodian” information; and that “Custodian” and “Other

9

Custodian” information cannot be extracted from the Missing PST Files.

10
Consequently, the production of responsive communications from the Missing PST
11

Files will indicate that the “Custodian” is the CVIN Email Server. The emails subject

12
to the Supplemental Email Production shall generally include those responsive, non13
privileged emails generated from and after January 1, 2010 including, without
14
limitation, (1) emails generated between February 21, 2014 and June 19, 2014, but only
15
to the extent those emails relate to the completion of Segment 19 of the Project
16

following MPN’s termination, (2) emails generated between February 21, 2014 and

17
May 30, 2015, but only to the extent those emails relate to the completion of Segment
18

27 of the Project following MPN’s termination, (3) any alleged defects in the work

19
performed by MPN and/or any MPN subcontractors, and (4) any alleged damages
20
claimed by CVIN against MPN.
21
22

2. CVIN will conduct a supplemental search of all emails in its possession, custody or

23

control (the “Supplemental Email Search”). The emails subject to the Supplemental

24

Email Search shall generally include those emails generated from and after January 1,

25

2010 including, without limitation, (1) emails generated between February 21, 2014

26

and June 19, 2014, but only to the extent those emails relate to the completion of

27

Segment 19 of the Project following MPN’s termination, (2) emails generated between

28

STIPULATION AND ORDER RE DISCOVERY DISAGREEMENTS BETWEEN PLAINTIFF MP
NEXLEVEL OF CALIFORNIA, INC. AND DEFENDANT CVIN, LLC

[4]
1238098v.1

1

February 21, 2014 and May 30, 2015, but only to the extent those emails relate to the

2

completion of Segment 27 of the Project following MPN’s termination, (3) any

3

alleged defects in the work performed by MPN and/or any MPN subcontractors, and

4

(4) any alleged damages claimed by CVIN against MPN. CVIN represents that the

5

Supplemental Email Search will be run against the entirety of CVIN’s email database

6

retrieved at the custodian level. Before conducting the Supplemental Email Search,

7

CVIN will run a de-duplication process to identify email communications previously

8

produced by CVIN, capture and produce to MPN “Custodian” and “Other Custodian”

9

data for all such previously produced email communications, and exclude the

10

previously produced email communications from the Supplemental Email Search. All

11

remaining email communications will then be searched utilizing the MPN search

12

terms attached hereto as Exhibit B. CVIN shall conduct the Supplemental Email

13

Search and produce responsive email communications in full compliance with the ESI

14

Protocol, including collecting and producing “Custodian,” “Other Custodian” and other

15

information and metadata required by the ESI Protocol (the “MPN Email Search

16

Production”). CVIN and MPN shall cooperatively work together to establish an agreed

17

upon search protocol for the Supplemental Email Search; provided, however, that any

18

such effort shall not relieve CVIN of the obligation to complete the searches required

19

and produce documents in accordance with the ESI Protocol by the deadlines specified

20

herein.

21
3. CVIN shall produce the Supplemental Email Production and MPN Email Search
22
Production on a rolling basis. CVIN shall complete the Supplemental Email
23
Production by no later than March 25, 2016 , and the MPN Email Search Production by
24
no later than April 29, 2016.
25
26

4. MPN and CVIN preserve all rights with respect to privilege objections and
confidentiality issues under the terms of the case Protective Order.

27
28

STIPULATION AND ORDER RE DISCOVERY DISAGREEMENTS BETWEEN PLAINTIFF MP
NEXLEVEL OF CALIFORNIA, INC. AND DEFENDANT CVIN, LLC

[5]
1238098v.1

1

5. MPN preserves its right to later challenge the sufficiency of CVIN’s production of

2

emails pursuant to this Stipulation, by initiating the required meet and confer, and

3

following any Court Orders or other directions on the procedures for raising and

4

resolving discovery issues with the Court. However, said challenge will not be based

5

on the adequacy of the search terms – either those used by CVIN (Exhibit A) or

6

submitted by MPN (Exhibit B) – or CVIN’s searches and productions, to the extent

7

said searches and production comply with the ESI Protocol and this Stipulation.

8

Further, nothing herein shall limit MPN’s right to challenge the scope of CVIN’s

9

production of documents and the sufficiency of CVIN’s discovery responses in this
matter.

10
11

SO STIPULATED:
12
13
14

Dated: February 29, 2016

15
16
17
18

GORDON & REES LLP
Ben Patrick, Esq. (SBN: 244092)
275 Battery Street
Suite 2000
San Francisco, CA 94111
Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: [phone]
e-mail: [e-mail]
DEWITT MACKALL CROUNSE & MOORE
S.C.

19

By: /s/ James D. Kremer, Esq.
Holly J. Newman, Esq., Pro Hac Vice
James D. Kremer, Esq., Pro Hac Vice
901 Marquette Avenue, Suite 1400
Minneapolis, MN 55402
Telephone: [phone]
Fax: [phone]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]

20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

STIPULATION AND ORDER RE DISCOVERY DISAGREEMENTS BETWEEN PLAINTIFF MP
NEXLEVEL OF CALIFORNIA, INC. AND DEFENDANT CVIN, LLC

[6]
1238098v.1

MARTIN & SQUIRES, P.A.
David W. Larson, Esq., Pro Hac Vice
332 Minnesota Street, Suite W2750
St. Paul, Minnesota 55101
Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: [phone]
[e-mail]

1
2
3
4

Attorneys for Plaintiff MP Nexlevel of California,
Inc. and Third-Party Defendant Western Surety
Company

5
6
7
8

Dated: February 25, 2016

9
10
11
12

DOWLING AARON INCORPORATED
Steven D. McGee (State Bar No. 71886)
[e-mail]
Matthew R. Dildine (SBN 258685)
[e-mail]
8080 North Palm Avenue, Third Floor
Fresno, CA 93729-8902
Telephone:
559-432-4500
Facsimile:
559-432-4590
RUTAN & TUCKER, LLP

13

By: /s/ Kaveh Badiei, Esq.
William T. Eliopoulos (State Bar No. 100633)
[e-mail]
Kaveh Badiei (State Bar No. 215179)
[e-mail]
Five Palo Alto Square
3000 El Camino Real, Suite 200
Palo Alto, CA 94306-9814
Telephone:
650-320-1500
Facsimile:
650-320-9905

14
15
16
17
18
19

Attorneys for
CVIN, LLC

20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

STIPULATION AND ORDER RE DISCOVERY DISAGREEMENTS BETWEEN PLAINTIFF MP
NEXLEVEL OF CALIFORNIA, INC. AND DEFENDANT CVIN, LLC

[7]
1238098v.1

ORDER

1
2

The foregoing Stipulation of the parties is hereby approved, and the items listed in

3 Paragraphs 1-5 of the Stipulation above shall be the Order of the Court.
4
5 IT IS SO ORDERED.
6
7

Dated:

March 2, 2016

/s/
UNITED STATES MAGISTRATE JUDGE

8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

STIPULATION AND ORDER RE DISCOVERY DISAGREEMENTS BETWEEN PLAINTIFF MP
NEXLEVEL OF CALIFORNIA, INC. AND DEFENDANT CVIN, LLC

[8]
1238098v.1

EXHIBIT A

1

CVIN SEARCH TERMS

2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

STIPULATION AND ORDER RE DISCOVERY DISAGREEMENTS BETWEEN PLAINTIFF MP
NEXLEVEL OF CALIFORNIA, INC. AND DEFENDANT CVIN, LLC

[9]
1238098v.1

EXHIBIT B

1
2 Term
3 MPN/MPN
Personnel:
4 MPN
5 Coby Hanson,
Coby, chanson
6 Travis Wilde,
twilde, Travis,
7 Wilde
Louis George
8 Menard
Rob Pribyl
9
10 Linda Sturtz
11 Curtis Rykhus
12 Mike Aydt
13 Richard (Dick)
Sanfilippo
14
15

Engineering/Con
16 sulting
Companies:
17 AECOM
18 Carlton
Engineering
19
CCI Systems
20
Compliance One
21
22 Compliance
Solutions
23 Engineering
Associates
24
25 Gateway
Engineering,
26 gatewayeng
27
28

MPN REQUESTED SEARCH TERMS
Terms and
Methodology
Strings1,2
MPN
"Coby Hanson",
Coby, chanson
"Travis Wilde",
twilde, Travis,
Wilde
"Louis George
Menard", lmenard
"Rob Pribyl",
rpribyl, pribyl
"Linda Sturtz",
Linda, lsturtz
"Curtis Rykhus",
crykhus, rykhus
"Mike Aydt",
mikea
"Richard
Sanfilippo", "Dick
Sanfilippo",
rsanfilippo,
sanfilippo

AECOM,
aecom.com
"Carlton /2
Engineering",
Carlton
"CCI /2 Systems",
CCI
"Compliance /2
One",
"gocomp1.com"
"Compliance /3
Solutions"
"Engineering /2
Associates",
engineeringassoci
ates.com, EA
"Gateway
Engineering",
"Gateway /2
Eng!",
gatewayeng,
gateway

No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String

1

Terms without quotation
marks or Boolean qualifiers
should be run as standalone
terms, no stemming,
character strings

2

Each term or string,
separated by a comma in
the Terms and Strings
column, should be run as a
separate term

No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String

STIPULATION AND ORDER RE DISCOVERY DISAGREEMENTS BETWEEN PLAINTIFF MP
NEXLEVEL OF CALIFORNIA, INC. AND DEFENDANT CVIN, LLC

[10]
1238098v.1

4 LightRiver

GrassRoots,
grassrotsenv.com
"K&B
Engineering",
K&B
"Lane /2
Engineering"
LightRiver

5 Yamabe

Yamabe

6 Almendariz

Almendariz,
almendarizconsult
ing.com
"Bennett /2
Trenchless",
bennettrenchless.c
om, bennett

1
2

GrassRoots
K&B Engineering

3 Lane Engineering

7
Bennett
8 Trenchless
9
10 Subcontractors/
Vendors:
11 Accu Bore

"Accu /2 Bore"

12 Alvarion

Alvarion

13 Apex

Apex

14 Baileys
Trenchless
15
McKuin
16 (William/Bill
McKuin, McKuin
17 Pipeline)

"Baileys /2
Trenchless",
Baileys
McKuin, "McKuin
/3 Pipeline",
"William
McKuin", "Bill
McKuin"
"Bridge Masters",
bridgemasters
"Capitol
Barricade",
capitalbarricade,
capitolbarricade
Cenvalley,
"Central Valley
Engineering &
Asphalt"
Doumit

18 Bridge Masters,
bridgemasters
19 Capitol Barricade
20
21 Cenvalley,
Central Valley
22 Engineering &
Asphalt
23 Doumit

No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String

No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String

No Stemming, Character
String
Fuzzy 1, No Stemming,
Character String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String

"Downing
24 Downing
Diversified
Diversified",
Downing
25
EDX Wireless
EDX
No Stemming, Character
String
26
J. Fletcher
"Fletcher /2
No Stemming, Character
27 Creamer, JFC,
Creamer",
String
JCF
jfcson.com, JFC,
28
STIPULATION AND ORDER RE DISCOVERY DISAGREEMENTS BETWEEN PLAINTIFF MP
NEXLEVEL OF CALIFORNIA, INC. AND DEFENDANT CVIN, LLC

[11]
1238098v.1

1 Henkels &
McCoy
2
3 Horizon
Underground
4 JB Excavating

JCF
"Henkels /3
McCoy",
henkels.com,
henkels
"Horizon
Underground"
"JB Excavating"

5 JK
Communications,
6 Kleven, klevcon
KRC Safety,
7 krcsafey
8 Nuvision, nuvision
9 Patriot
Environmental
10
Ventura
11 Directional,
venturadrilling
12
Youngdahl
13
A-D
14 Technologies,
Arnco
15 SCWW

"JK /3
Communications",
Kleven, klevcon
"KRC Safety",
krcsafey
Nuvision, nuvision
"Patriot
Environmental",
patriot
"Ventura
Directional",
venturadrilling,
ventura
Youngdahl

16 Sierratrafficmarki
ngs
17 Usan

Sierratrafficmarki
ngs
Usan

18 Uscsupply

Uscsupply

19 Inspectors/Inspe
ction Companies:
20 ITC Service
Group, ITC,
21 callitc
Addakid
22
Iseger
23
Hanley,
24 drhanley19@aol.c
om
25 Lovelady,
Fiberoptikid
26
Bill Brown,
27 ohiobill
28

"A-D
Technologies",
Arnco
SCWW

No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String

ITC, callitc

No Stemming, Character
String

Addakid

No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String

Iseger, "Bryon
Iseger"
drhanley19,
"Dennis Hanley",
hanley
Lovelady,
Fiberoptikid, "Jeff
Lovelady"
ohiobill, ohiobil

No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String

STIPULATION AND ORDER RE DISCOVERY DISAGREEMENTS BETWEEN PLAINTIFF MP
NEXLEVEL OF CALIFORNIA, INC. AND DEFENDANT CVIN, LLC

[12]
1238098v.1

1
2
3
4
5

Paul Newman
Midgley
Veresh
Mosher
Buckley

rchamberlain,
"Ron
Chamberlain",
7
chamberlain
Runge
Runge, "Mike
8
Runge"
Jerry Berg, Gerald "Jerry Berg",
9
Berg
"Gerald Berg"
10 Jesse Day, jessday "Jesse /2 Day",
jessday,
jessday@foothill.n
11
et
Vali Cooper,
"Vali Cooper",
12
valicooper
valicooper, "vail
cooper"
13
Rickard, jprikard
jprikard, "Jason
Rickard", rickard
14
Hitchko
Hitchko, "Kevin
Hitchko"
15
Shayne Pope,
"Shayne /2 Pope",
shaynepope
Shayne,
16
shaynepope
Matranga
Matranga, "Steve
17
Matranga"
Kidd,
stacy.kidd, "Stacie
18
stacy.kidd@gmail Kidd", "Stacy
Kidd"
19 .com
Sauer
Sauer, csauer
20
Eric Cate,
eric.ca8, "Eric
21 eric.ca8@gmail.c Cate"
om
klguillory, "Kevin
22 Kevin Guillory,
[e-mail] Guillory"
23 m
Terri King,
tkinggirl, "Terri
24 tkinggirl@gmail.c King"
om
25 Terrial King,
tkingguy, "Terrial
tkingguy@gmail.c King"
26 om
Allen LeHew,
allen.tlehew,
27 allen.tlehew@gm "Allen /3 LeHew"
6

28

Chamberlain

"Paul Newman",
newmanpaul33
Midgley, "Harry
Midgley"
Veresh, "Jeff
Veresh"
Mosher, "John
Mosher"
Buckley

No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String

STIPULATION AND ORDER RE DISCOVERY DISAGREEMENTS BETWEEN PLAINTIFF MP
NEXLEVEL OF CALIFORNIA, INC. AND DEFENDANT CVIN, LLC

[13]
1238098v.1

ail.com
1 Sam Lewis,
slewis.jr14@gmai
2 l.com
Mike Rostad,
3 mrostad@charter.
net
4 CVIN Member
Entities/Related
5 Entities:
Cal Ore, calore
6 (domain name)
Calaveras
7
8 CENIC
9 Consolidated
Communications
10 Mohave
Investment
11 Peak to peak

slewis.jr14, "Sam
Lewis"

No Stemming, Character
String

mrostad, "Mike
Rostad"

No Stemming, Character
String

"Cal Ore", calore

No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String
No Stemming, Character
String

Calaveras
CENIC

12 Ponderosa

"Consolidated
Communications"
"Mohave
Investment"
"Peak to Peak",
peaktopeaktelcom
Ponderosa

13 Sebastian

Sebastian

14 Sierra Tel

"Sierra Tel"

15 Stageline

Stageline

16 Surewest
17 Varcomm

Surewest,
"Surewest Fiber"
Varcomm

18 Varnet

Varnet

19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

STIPULATION AND ORDER RE DISCOVERY DISAGREEMENTS BETWEEN PLAINTIFF MP
NEXLEVEL OF CALIFORNIA, INC. AND DEFENDANT CVIN, LLC

[14]
1238098v.1