Valdivia, et al v. Schwarzenegger, et al

Filing 1852

STIPULATION and ORDER signed by Judge Lawrence K. Karlton on 8/1/13: IT IS CONFIRMED that $1,243,077.20 plus interest accruing at the rate provided by 28 U.S.C. § 1961 is due and collectable as of forty-five days from the date of entry of this Order. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit)(Kaminski, H)

Valdivia v. Brown
SUMMARY OF SETTLED FEES AND COSTS
$
$
$
$

Claimed
496,862.62
95,712.50
283,156.69
536,855.92

$
$
$
$

Settlement
437,239.11
84,227.00
249,177.89
472,433.21

TOTAL: $

1,412,587.73

$

1,243,077.20

2D QUARTER 2013:
JULY 1 - JULY 23, 2013:
DEFERRED DISTRICT COURT:
APPEAL NOS. 09-15836, 12-15457, 12-15492:

Valdivia v. Brown
2nd Quarterly Statement of 2013
April 1, 2013 through June 30. 2013

SUMMARY OF SETTLED FEES AND COSTS
FEES

MONITORING:

$

482,226.00

FEES ON FEES:

$

4,845.00

TOTALS:

$

487,071.00

TOTAL FEES AND COSTS:

$

496,862.62

SETTLEMENT AMOUNT

$

437,239.11

COSTS

$ 9,666.26
$

125.36

$ 9,791.62

Valdivia v. Brown
Summary of Fees
2nd Quarter - April 1, 2013 through June 30, 2013
Matter: Monitoring/Merits (720-1)
Actual

Claimed

2013

Actual

Claimed

Hours

Attorney/Law Firm

Hours

Rates

Fees

Fees

BINGHAM, MCCUTCHEN
Geoff Holtz (GH)
Frank Busch (FB)
Cameron Saul (CS)

29.70
23.90
46.00

99.60

96.60

70.60
71.30
122.90
69.90
99.70
62.10
110.80
33.60
119.70
23.90
41.60
23.40
39.70
34.00
50.50

70.10
71.30
120.10
68.20
97.20
62.10
110.70
33.50
117.50
16.90
39.10
23.00
37.00
27.00
47.40

973.70

941.10

0.5
39.60

0.50
39.60

40.10

TOTAL BMc:

29.70
22.80
44.10

$735
$570
$405

40.10

$
$
$

21,829.50
13,623.00
18,630.00

$
$
$

21,829.50
12,996.00
17,860.50

$

54,082.50

$

52,686.00

$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$

55,068.00
44,919.00
58,992.00
32,503.50
44,366.50
27,324.00
48,752.00
13,608.00
44,887.50
6,692.00
10,816.00
5,148.00
8,734.00
7,480.00
11,110.00

$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$
$

54,678.00
44,919.00
57,648.00
31,713.00
43,254.00
27,324.00
48,708.00
13,567.50
44,062.50
4,732.00
10,166.00
5,060.00
8,140.00
5,940.00
10,428.00

ROSEN BIEN GALVAN & GRUNFELD
Michael W. Bien (MWB)
Ernest Galvan (EG)
Kenneth M. Walczak (KMW)
Lori Rifkin (LR)
Katie Mantoan (KGM)
Aaron J. Fischer (AJF)
Sidney S. Hollar (SSH)
Michael Freedman (MLF)
Sumana Cooppan Wolf (SCW)
Kevin Jones (KEJ)
Karen E. Stilber (KES)
Abigail Hamilton (AMH)
Diana Ruslani (DAR)
Haruka Roudebush (HR)
Lucy Taylor (LRT)
TOTAL RBGG:

$780
$630
$480
$465
$445
$440
$440
$405
$375
$280
$260
$220
$220
$220
$220

$ 420,400.50

$ 410,340.00

$
$

390.00
18,810.00

$
$

390.00
18,810.00

$

19,200.00

$

19,200.00

PRISON LAW OFFICE
Donald Specter (DS)
Megan Hagler (MH)

Total Monitoring - All Offices

$780
$475

1113.40 1077.80

$ 493,683.00 $ 482,226.00

Valdivia v. Brown
Summary of Fees
2nd Quarter - April 1, 2013 through June 30, 2013
Matter: Fees Work (720-2)
Actual
Hours

Claimed
Hours

2013
Rates

Actual
Fees

Claimed
Fees

BINGHAM, MCCUTCHEN
Geoff Holtz (GH)

0.80

0.80

0.80

0.80

0.50
1.50
3.80
14.70

TOTAL BINGHAM:

0.00
0.00
2.40
12.60

20.50

15.00

$

588.00

$

588.00

$

$735

588.00 $

588.00

ROSEN BIEN GALVAN & GRUNFELD
Gay C. Grunfeld (GCG)
Ernest Galvan (EG)
Kenneth M. Walczak (KMW)
Haruka Roudebush (HR)

TOTAL RBGG:

$660
$630
$480
$220

$
$
$
$

330.00
945.00
1,824.00
3,234.00

$
$
$
$

1,152.00
2,772.00

$

6,333.00 $

3,924.00

PRISON LAW OFFICE
Edie DeGraff (ED)

Total Fees - All Offices

1.80

1.80

$

333.00

$

333.00

1.80

1.80

$185

$

333.00

$

333.00

21.30

15.80

$

7,254.00 $

4,845.00

Valdivia v. Brown
2nd Quarterly Statement of 2013
April 1, 2013 through June 30. 2013
Costs

Matter: Merits/Monitoring (720-1)

Claimed
Costs

Bingham McCutchen
Travel - Mileage, Tolls, Food
Printing and Photocopying
Electronic Research
Postage

$
$
$
$

495.00
175.20
1,037.20
21.96

Total BMc Costs: $

1,729.36

$
$
$
$
$
$
$

2,147.31
2,870.00
906.17
10.30
864.40
103.80
541.12

Total RBGG Costs: $

7,443.10

$
$

447.87
45.93

Total PLO Costs: $

493.80

TOTAL MONITORING COSTS: $

9,666.26

Rosen Bien Galvan & Grunfeld
Travel - Mileage, Tolls, Food
Printing and Photocopying (in-house)
Printing and Photocopying (outside)
Telephone
Lexis Research
Pacer Online Research
Postage and Delivery

Prison Law Office
Travel - Mileage, Tolls, Food
Printing

Valdivia v. Brown
2nd Quarterly Statement of 2013
April 1, 2013 through June 30. 2013

Matter: Fees on Fees (720-2)

Claimed
Costs

Rosen Bien Galvan & Grunfeld
Photocopying (In-House)
Photocopying (Outside Service)
Pacer Online Research
Postage & Delivery

$
$
$
$

78.19
47.17

Total RBGG Costs: $

125.36

TOTAL FEES COSTS: $

125.36

Valdivia v. Brown
Summary of Fees & Costs
July 1, 2013 through July 23, 2013

SUMMARY OF SETTLED FEES AND COSTS
FEES

COSTS

MONITORING:

$

74,007.50

$

228.00

FEES ON FEES:

$ 21,477.00

$

-

TOTALS:

$ 95,484.50

$

228.00

TOTAL FEES AND COSTS:

$ 95,712.50

SETTLEMENT AMOUNT:

$ 84,227.00

Valdivia v. Brown
Summary of Fees & Costs
July 1, 2013 through July 23, 2013

ROSEN BIEN GALVAN & GRUNFELD, MERITS
Timekeeper
Bien, Michael W.
Galvan, Ernest
Fischer, Aaron J.
Thompson, Blake
Walczak, Kenneth M.
Mantoan, Kathryn G.
Rifkin, Lori
Bien‐Kahn, Benjamin
Nolan, Thomas
Roudebush, Haruka
Stilber, Karen E.
Hamilton, Abigail M.
Ruslani, Diana A.
Tseng, Doris
Taylor, Lucy R.
Jones, Kevin E.
Total

Hours Incurred
18.2
29.2
17.7
0.8
18.7
20.4
5
0.1
0.7
3
5.4
4.3
3.4
4.3
8.6
0.5
140.3

Hours Claimed
18.2
29.2
17.7
0
18
19.9
4.8
0
0.7
3
5
4.3
2.7
1.4
8.6
0.5
134

Rate
$780
$630
$440
$435
$480
$445
$465
$375
$550
$220
$260
$220
$220
$220
$220
$280

Amount Incurred Amount Claimed 
$14,196.00
$14,196.00
$18,396.00
$18,396.00
$7,788.00
$7,788.00
$348.00
$0.00
$8,976.00
$8,640.00
$9,078.00
$8,855.50
$2,325.00
$2,232.00
$37.50
$0.00
$385.00
$385.00
$660.00
$660.00
$1,404.00
$1,300.00
$946.00
$946.00
$748.00
$594.00
$946.00
$308.00
$1,892.00
$1,892.00
$140.00
$140.00
$68,125.50
$66,192.50

Hours Claimed
19.5
0
35.1
54.6

Rate
$630
$480
$220

Amount Incurred Amount Claimed 
$12,285.00
$12,285.00
$288.00
$0.00
$7,942.00
$7,722.00
$20,515.00
$20,007.00

Hours Claimed
1.1
2.7
13.5
17.3

Rate
$735
$570
$405

Amount Incurred Amount Claimed 
$808.50
$808.50
$1,539.00
$1,539.00
$5,467.50
$5,467.50
$7,815.00
$7,815.00

Hours Claimed
2
2

Rate
$735

Amount Incurred Amount Claimed 
$1,470.00
$1,470.00

ROSEN BIEN GALVAN & GRUNFELD, FEES
Timekeeper
Galvan, Ernest
Walczak, Kenneth M.
Roudebush, Haruka
Total

Hours Incurred
19.5
0.6
36.1
56.2

BINGHAM MCCUTCHEN, MERITS
Timekeeper
Geoffrey T. Holtz
Frank Busch
Cameron Saul
Total

Hours Incurred
1.1
2.7
13.5
17.3

BINGHAM MCCUTCHEN, FEES
Timekeeper
Geoffrey T. Holtz
Total
TOTAL FEES
TOTAL COSTS
TOTAL

Hours Incurred
2
2

$97,925.50

$95,484.50
$228.00
$95,712.50

Valdivia v. Brown
Summary of Fees & Costs
Deferred District Court, Jan. 1, 2011 through Dec. 31, 2011
(Proceedings Related to Jan. 24, 2012 Order)

SUMMARY OF SETTLED FEES AND COSTS
FEES

COSTS

MONITORING:

$

FEES ON FEES:

$

TOTALS:

$

266,425.50

TOTAL FEES AND COSTS: $

283,156.69

$

249,177.89

SETTLEMENT AMOUNT

266,425.50

-

$
$
$

16,731.19
16,731.19

Valdivia v. Brown
Summary of Fees & Costs
Deferred District Court, Jan. 1, 2011 through Dec. 31, 2011
(Proceedings Related to Jan. 24, 2012 Order)
Rosen Bien Galvan & Grunfeld
Timekeeper
Bien, Michael W.
Galvan, Ernest
Fischer, Aaron J.
Huey, Shirley
Morris, Maria V.
Stilber, Karen E.
Total

Hours Claimed
27.6
31.6
20.7
52.1
109.2
14.9
256.1

Rate
$780
$630
$440
$490
$490
$260

Amount 
Incurred
Amount Claimed 
$22,620.00
$21,528.00
$20,538.00
$19,908.00
$10,032.00
$9,108.00
$29,792.00
$25,529.00
$54,292.00
$53,508.00
$3,952.00
$3,874.00
$141,226.00
$133,455.00

Hours Incurred
30.5
123.7
57.6
211.8

Hours Claimed
30
118.7
51
199.7

Rate
$570
$735
$530

Amount 
Incurred
Amount Claimed 
$17,385.00
$17,100.00
$90,919.50
$87,244.50
$30,528.00
$27,030.00
$131,374.50

Hours Incurred
2.8

Hours Claimed
2.8

Rate
$570

Hours Incurred
29
32.6
22.8
60.8
110.8
15.2
271.2

Bingham McCutchen
Timekeeper
Frank Busch
Geoffrey T. Holtz
Tracey D. Berger*
Grand Total

Prison Law Office
Timekeeper
Sue Christian
TOTAL FEES
TOTAL COSTS
TOTAL

Amount 
Incurred
Amount Claimed 
$1,596.00
$1,596.00
$266,425.50
$16,731.19
$283,156.69

Valdivia v. Brown
Summary of Fees & Costs
Appeal Nos. 09-15836, 12-15457, 12-15492
SUMMARY OF SETTLED FEES AND COSTS
FEES

COSTS

$ 525,752.00

$ 11,103.92

TOTAL FEES AND COSTS:

$ 536,855.92

SETTLEMENT AMOUNT

$ 472,433.21

Valdivia v. Brown
Summary of Fees & Costs
Appeal Nos. 09-15836, 12-15457, 12-15492
Rosen Bien Galvan & Grunfeld
Timekeeper
Bien, Michael W.
Galvan, Ernest
Huey, Shirley
Stilber, Karen E.
TOTAL

Hours Incurred
72.4
114.6
166.7
87.6
441.3

Hours Claimed
69.2
111.5
166.4
81.6
428.7

Rate
$780
$630
$490
$260

Amount Incurred Amount Claimed 
$56,472.00
$53,976.00
$72,198.00
$70,245.00
$81,683.00
$81,536.00
$22,776.00
$21,216.00
$233,129.00
$226,973.00

RBGG COSTS
RBGG TOTAL

$4,835.44
$231,808.44

Bingham McCutchen
Timekeeper
Geoffrey T. Holtz
Frank Busch
Tracey D. Berger
Alexis Martin
TOTAL

Hours Incurred
313.4
27.4
60.3
64.3
465.4

Hours Claimed
311.4
23.9
55.9
53.3
444.5

Rate
$735
$570
$530
$500

Amount Incurred Amount Claimed 
$230,349.00
$228,879.00
$15,618.00
$13,623.00
$31,959.00
$29,627.00
$32,150.00
$26,650.00
$310,076.00
$298,779.00

BINGHAM MCCUTCHEN COSTS
BINGHAM MCCUTCHEN TOTAL
TOTAL FEES
TOTAL COSTS 
TOTAL

$6,268.48
$305,047.48
$543,205.00

Billing Judgment Summary
Difference between Amount Incurred and Claimed for These Timekeepers
Omitting timekeepers with fewer than 20 hours.
TOTAL

$525,752.00
$11,103.92
$536,855.92

$17,453.00
$33,732.00
$51,185.00