Boggs v. Victoria's Secret et al

Filing 7

STATUS (PRETRIAL SCHEDULING) ORDER signed by District Judge Kimberly J. Mueller on 2/4/16: Designation of Expert Witnesses due by 7/1/2016. Discovery due by 2/12/2016. Dispositive Motions shall be heard no later than 12/16/2016. Final Pretrial C onference set for 3/10/2017 at 10:00 AM in Courtroom 3 (KJM) before District Judge Kimberly J. Mueller. Bench Trial set for 4/17/2017 at 09:00 AM in Courtroom 3 (KJM) before District Judge Kimberly J. Mueller. Settlement Conference set for 2/17/2016 at 09:00 AM in Courtroom 25 (KJN) before Magistrate Judge Kendall J. Newman. (Kaminski, H)

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

9

FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

10
11

BARBARA BOGGS,

12

No. 2:15-CV-1920 KJM KJN

Plaintiff,

13

v.

STATUS (PRETRIAL SCHEDULING)

14

VICTORIA’S SECRET, et al.,

15

Defendants.

ORDER

16
17
An initial scheduling conference was held in this case on January 21, 2016.

18
19

Michael Kronlund appeared for plaintiff; Richard Sutherland appeared for defendants.
Having reviewed the parties’ Joint Status Report filed on January 14, 2016, and

20
21

discussed a schedule for the case with counsel at the hearing, the court makes the following

22

orders:

23

I.

SERVICE OF PROCESS
All named defendants have been served and no further service is permitted without

24
25

leave of court, good cause having been shown.

26

/////

27

/////

28

/////
1

1

II.

ADDITIONAL PARTIES/AMENDMENTS/PLEADINGS

2
3

Plaintiff may seek to join additional defendants. If the defense will not stipulate to
joinder, any motion to join shall be filed within thirty (30) days of the scheduling conference.

4

No further joinder of parties or amendments to pleadings is permitted without

5

leave of court, good cause having been shown. See Fed. R. Civ. P. 16(b); Johnson v. Mammoth

6

Recreations, Inc., 975 F.2d 604 (9th Cir. 1992).

7

III.

JURISDICTION/VENUE

8
9
10

Jurisdiction is predicated upon 28 U.S.C. §§ 1331, 1343(a)(3) and 1983.
Jurisdiction and venue are not disputed.
IV.

DISCOVERY

11

Initial disclosures as required by Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(a) shall be

12

completed by February 12, 2016. All discovery shall be completed by September 2, 2016. In

13

this context, “completed” means that all discovery shall have been conducted so that all

14

depositions have been taken and any disputes relative to discovery shall have been resolved by

15

appropriate order if necessary and, where discovery has been ordered, the order has been obeyed.

16

All motions to compel discovery must be noticed on the magistrate judge’s calendar in

17

accordance with the local rules of this court. While the assigned magistrate judge reviews

18

proposed discovery phase protective orders, requests to seal or redact are decided by Judge

19

Mueller as discussed in more detail below. In addition, while the assigned magistrate judge

20

handles discovery motions, the magistrate judge cannot change the schedule set in this order,

21

even in connection with a discovery matter.

22

The following methods will be used to avoid unnecessary proof and cumulative

23

evidence, and anticipated limitations or restrictions on the use of testimony under Federal Rule of

24

Evidence 702:

25

a. There is video of the incident, and the Parties will stipulate to the video's

26

authenticity and genuineness, thereby reducing (if not eliminating) cumulative

27

evidence regarding the circumstances of the incident;

28

/////
2

1

b. It is anticipated that the Parties will likely be able to stipulate to much of the

2

medical injuries and damages sustained by Plaintiff. It is further anticipated

3

that there may be stipulations as to the authenticity, genuineness and

4

admissibility of Plaintiffs medical records and medical bills.

5

c. As the case develops, the Parties will further confer on what methods may be

6

best to reduce judicial burdens, including but not limited to potential

7

stipulations as to exhibits (documentary or otherwise) to avoid testimony

8

intended solely to lay foundations for admission of such evidence.

9
10

V.

DISCLOSURE OF EXPERT WITNESSES
All counsel are to designate in writing, file with the court, and serve upon all other

11

parties the name, address, and area of expertise of each expert that they propose to tender at trial

12

not later than July 1, 2016. The designation shall be accompanied by a written report prepared

13

and signed by the witness. The report shall comply with Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(a)(2)(B). By July 22,

14

2016, any party who previously disclosed expert witnesses may submit a supplemental list of

15

expert witnesses who will express an opinion on a subject covered by an expert designated by an

16

adverse party, if the party supplementing an expert witness designation has not previously

17

retained an expert to testify on that subject. The supplemental designation shall be accompanied

18

by a written report, which shall also comply with the conditions stated above.

19

Failure of a party to comply with the disclosure schedule as set forth above in all

20

likelihood will preclude that party from calling the expert witness at the time of trial. An expert

21

witness not appearing on the designation will not be permitted to testify unless the party offering

22

the witness demonstrates: (a) that the necessity for the witness could not have been reasonably

23

anticipated at the time the list was proffered; (b) that the court and opposing counsel were

24

promptly notified upon discovery of the witness; and (c) that the witness was promptly made

25

available for deposition.

26

For purposes of this scheduling order, an “expert” is any person who may be used

27

at trial to present evidence under Rules 702, 703 and 705 of the Federal Rules of Evidence, which

28

include both “percipient experts” (persons who, because of their expertise, have rendered expert
3

1

opinions in the normal course of their work duties or observations pertinent to the issues in the

2

case) and “retained experts” (persons specifically designated by a party to be a testifying expert

3

for the purposes of litigation). A party shall identify whether a disclosed expert is percipient,

4

retained, or both. It will be assumed that a party designating a retained expert has acquired the

5

express permission of the witness to be so listed. Parties designating percipient experts must state

6

in the designation who is responsible for arranging the deposition of such persons.

7

All experts designated are to be fully prepared at the time of designation to render

8

an informed opinion, and give the bases for their opinion, so that they will be able to give full and

9

complete testimony at any deposition taken by the opposing party. Experts will not be permitted

10

to testify at trial as to any information gathered or evaluated, or opinion formed, after deposition

11

taken subsequent to designation. All expert discovery shall be completed by September 30,

12

2016.

13

VI.

MOTION HEARING SCHEDULE

14

All dispositive motions, except motions for continuances, temporary restraining

15

orders or other emergency applications, shall be heard no later than December 16, 2016.1 The

16

parties may obtain available hearing dates by checking Judge Mueller’s page on the court’s

17

website.

18
19

All purely legal issues are to be resolved by timely pretrial motions. Local Rule
230 governs the calendaring and procedures of civil motions; the following provisions also apply:

20

(a)

The opposition and reply must be filed by 4:00 p.m. on the day due; and

21

(b)

When the last day for filing an opposition brief falls on a legal holiday, the

22

opposition brief shall be filed on the last court day immediately preceding the legal holiday.

23

Failure to comply with Local Rule 230(c), as modified by this order, may be deemed consent to

24

the motion and the court may dispose of the motion summarily. Brydges v. Lewis, 18 F.3d 651,

25

652-53 (9th Cir. 1994).

26

/////

27
28

1

Note that this date may not correspond to a law and motion calendar date.
4

1

The court places a page limit of twenty (20) pages on all moving papers, twenty

2

(20) pages on oppositions, and ten (10) pages for replies. All requests for page limit increases

3

must be made in writing at least fourteen (14) days prior to the filing of the motion.

4

Prior to filing a motion in a case in which the parties are represented by counsel,

5

counsel shall engage in a pre-filing meet and confer to discuss thoroughly the substance of the

6

contemplated motion and any potential resolution. Plaintiff’s counsel should carefully evaluate

7

the defendant’s contentions as to deficiencies in the complaint and in many instances the party

8

considering a motion should agree to any amendment that would cure a curable defect. Counsel

9

should discuss the issues sufficiently so that if a motion of any kind is filed, including for

10

summary judgment, the briefing is directed only to those substantive issues requiring resolution

11

by the court. Counsel should resolve minor procedural or other non-substantive matters during

12

the meet and confer. A notice of motion shall contain a certification by counsel filing the

13

motion that meet and confer efforts have been exhausted, with a brief summary of meet and

14

confer efforts.

15

The parties are cautioned that failure to raise a dispositive legal issue that could

16

have been tendered to the court by proper pretrial motion prior to the dispositive motion cut-off

17

date may constitute waiver of such issue.

18

VII.

19

SEALING
No document will be sealed, nor shall a redacted document be filed, without the

20

prior approval of the court. If a document for which sealing or redaction is sought relates to the

21

record on a motion to be decided by Judge Mueller, the request to seal or redact should be

22

directed to her and not the assigned Magistrate Judge. All requests to seal or redact shall be

23

governed by Local Rules 141 (sealing) and 140 (redaction); protective orders covering the

24

discovery phase of litigation shall not govern the filing of sealed or redacted documents on the

25

public docket. The court will only consider requests to seal or redact filed by the proponent of

26

sealing or redaction. If a party plans to make a filing that includes material an opposing party has

27

identified as confidential and potentially subject to sealing, the filing party shall provide the

28

/////
5

1

opposing party with sufficient notice in advance of filing to allow for the seeking of an order of

2

sealing or redaction from the court.

3

VIII.

4
5

METHODS TO AVOID UNNECESSARY PROOF
The court approves the following methods to be used from the outset to avoid

unnecessary proof and cumulative evidence:

6

1.

There is video of the incident, and the parties will stipulate to the video's

7

authenticity and genuineness, thereby reducing if not eliminating cumulative evidence regarding

8

the circumstances of the incident.

9

2.

The parties will endeavor to stipulate to much of the medical injuries and

10

damages sustained by plaintiff, and to the authenticity, genuineness and admissibility of plaintiffs

11

medical records and medical bills.

12

3.

As the case develops, the parties will further confer on what methods will

13

reduce judicial burdens, including but not limited to potential stipulations as to exhibits

14

(documentary or otherwise) to avoid testimony intended solely to lay foundations for admission

15

of such evidence.

16

IX.

17

FINAL PRETRIAL CONFERENCE
The Final Pretrial Conference is set for March 10, 2017, at 10:00 a.m. At least

18

one of the attorneys who will conduct the trial for each of the parties shall attend the Final Pretrial

19

Conference. If by reason of illness or other unavoidable circumstance a trial attorney is unable to

20

attend, the attorney who attends in place of the trial attorney shall have equal familiarity with the

21

case and equal authorization to make commitments on behalf of the client.

22

Counsel for all parties are to be fully prepared for trial at the time of the Final

23

Pretrial Conference, with no matters remaining to be accomplished except production of

24

witnesses for oral testimony. The parties shall confer and file a joint pretrial conference

25

statement by February 17, 2017. The provisions of Local Rule 281 shall apply with respect to

26

the matters to be included in the joint pretrial statement. In addition to those subjects listed in

27

Local Rule 281(b), the parties are to provide the court with the following:

28

/////
6

1
2
3

- A plain, concise statement that identifies every non-discovery motion previously
tendered to the court and its resolution.
- A concise, joint list of undisputed core facts that are relevant to each claim.

4

Disputed core facts should then be identified in the same manner. The parties are reminded not to

5

identify every fact in dispute but only those disputed facts that are essential to the formulation of

6

each claim. Each disputed fact and undisputed fact should be separately numbered or lettered.

7

Where the parties are unable to agree on the core disputed facts, they should nevertheless list core

8

disputed facts in the above manner.

9

- Concise lists of disputed evidentiary issues that will be the subject of a party’s

10

motion in limine, and whether the parties believe resolution of any of these motions will be

11

necessary before the first day of trial.

12

- Each party’s points of law, which concisely describe the legal basis or theory

13

underlying their claims and defenses. Points of law should reflect issues derived from the core

14

undisputed and disputed facts. Parties shall not include argument with any point of law; the

15

parties may include concise arguments in their trial briefs.

16
17
18

Discovery documents to be listed in the pretrial statement shall not include
documents to be used only for impeachment and in rebuttal.
The parties are reminded that pursuant to Local Rule 281 they are required to

19

attach to the Final Pretrial Conference Statement an exhibit listing witnesses and exhibits they

20

propose to offer at trial. After the name of each witness, each party shall provide a brief

21

statement of the nature of the testimony to be proffered. The parties may file a joint list or each

22

party may file separate lists. These list(s) shall not be contained in the body of the Final Pretrial

23

Conference Statement itself, but shall be attached as separate documents to be used as addenda to

24

the Final Pretrial Order.

25

Plaintiff’s exhibits shall be listed numerically. Defendant’s exhibits shall be listed

26

alphabetically. The parties shall use the standard exhibit stickers provided by the court: pink for

27

plaintiff and blue for defendant. In the event that the alphabet is exhausted, the exhibits shall be

28

marked “AA-ZZ”. However, if the amount of defendant exhibits exceeds “ZZ” exhibits shall be
7

1

then listed as AAA, BBB, CCC etc. All multi-page exhibits shall be stapled or otherwise fastened

2

together and each page within the exhibit shall be numbered. The list of exhibits shall not include

3

excerpts of depositions to be used only for impeachment. In the event that plaintiff(s) and

4

defendant(s) offer the same exhibit during trial, that exhibit shall be referred to by the designation

5

the exhibit is first identified. The court cautions the parties to pay attention to this detail so that

6

all concerned, will not be confused by one exhibit being identified with both a number and a

7

letter. The parties are encouraged to consult concerning exhibits and, to the extent possible,

8

provide joint exhibits, which shall be designated as JX and listed numerically, e.g., JX-1, JX-2.

9

The Final Pretrial Order will contain a stringent standard for the offering at trial of

10

witnesses and exhibits not listed in the Final Pretrial Order, and the parties are cautioned that the

11

standard will be strictly applied. On the other hand, the listing of exhibits or witnesses that a

12

party does not intend to offer will be viewed as an abuse of the court’s processes.

13
14

Counsel shall produce all trial exhibits to Casey Schultz, the Courtroom Deputy,
no later than 3:00 p.m. on the Friday before trial.

15
16

Failure to comply with Local Rule 281, as modified by this order, may be grounds
for sanctions.

17

The parties also are reminded that pursuant to Rule 16 of the Federal Rules of

18

Civil Procedure it will be their duty at the Final Pretrial Conference to aid the court in: (a) the

19

formulation and simplification of issues and the elimination of frivolous claims or defenses; (b)

20

the settling of facts that should properly be admitted; and (c) the avoidance of unnecessary proof

21

and cumulative evidence. Counsel must cooperatively prepare the joint Final Pretrial Conference

22

Statement and participate in good faith at the Final Pretrial Conference with these aims in mind.2

23

A failure to do so may result in the imposition of sanctions which may include monetary

24

sanctions, orders precluding proof, elimination of claims or defenses, or such other sanctions as

25

the court deems appropriate.

26

2

27
28

“If the pretrial conference discloses that no material facts are in dispute and that the undisputed
facts entitle one of the parties to judgment as a matter of law,” the court may summarily dispose
of the case or claims. Portsmouth Square v. Shareholders Protective Comm., 770 F.2d 866, 86869 (9th Cir. 1985).
8

1

Concurrently with the filing of the Joint Final Pretrial Conference Statement,

2

counsel shall submit to chambers the word processable version of the Statement, in its entirety

3

(including the witness and exhibit lists) to: [e-mail].

4

X.

MOTIONS IN LIMINE

5

All motions in limine must be filed in conjunction with the joint pretrial statement.

6

In most cases, motions in limine are addressed and resolved on the morning of the first day of

7

trial. As noted above, the parties may alert the court at the final pretrial conference and in their

8

final pretrial statement that a particular motion or motions should be resolved earlier. At the final

9

pretrial conference, the court will then set a briefing and hearing schedule on these motions in

10

limine as necessary.

11

The parties are reminded that a motion in limine is a pretrial procedural device

12

designed to address the admissibility of evidence. The court looks with disfavor upon

13

dispositional motions presented at the Final Pretrial Conference or at trial in the guise of motions

14

in limine.

15

XI.

16

TRIAL SETTING
The court trial is set for April 17, 2017 at 9:00 a.m. The parties estimate a trial

17

length of approximately three (3) to five (5) days. Trial briefs are due by April 3, 2017.

18

XII.

19

SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE
The parties have expressed interest in appearing for settlement conference and

20

waive conflict to the assigned magistrate judge acting as settlement judge. A settlement

21

conference is scheduled before Magistrate Judge Kendall J. Newman for February 17, 2016 at

22

9:00 a.m. in Courtroom No. 25, 8th Floor.

23

The parties are directed to exchange non-confidential settlement conference

24

statements seven (7) days prior to this settlement conference. These statements shall

25

simultaneously be delivered to the Court using the following email address:

26

[e-mail]. If a party desires to share additional confidential information with

27

the Court, they may do so pursuant to the provisions of Local Rule 270(d) and (e). Waivers will

28

be required if not previously filed.
9

1
2

XIII.

MODIFICATION OF STATUS (PRETRIAL SCHEDULING) ORDER
The parties are reminded that pursuant to Rule 16(b) of the Federal Rules of Civil

3

Procedure, the Status (Pretrial Scheduling) Order shall not be modified except by leave of court

4

upon a showing of good cause. Agreement by the parties pursuant to stipulation alone does not

5

constitute good cause. Except in extraordinary circumstances, unavailability of witnesses or

6

counsel does not constitute good cause.

7

XIV. OBJECTIONS TO STATUS (PRETRIAL SCHEDULING) ORDER

8
9
10
11

This Status Order will become final without further order of the court unless
objections are filed within fourteen (14) calendar days of service of this Order.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
DATED: February 4, 2016.

12
13
14

UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE

15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
10