Netflix, Inc. v. Blockbuster, Inc.

Filing 179

Attachment 3
NOTICE by Blockbuster, Inc. Final Invalidity Contentions for U.S. Patent No. 7,024,381 (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A# 2 Exhibit B# 3 Exhibit C# 4 Exhibit D# 5 Exhibit E# 6 Exhibit F# 7 Exhibit G# 8 Exhibit H# 9 Exhibit I# 10 Exhibit J# 11 Exhibit K)(Chen, Tony) (Filed on 4/11/2007)

Download PDF
N etflix, Inc. v. Blockbuster, Inc. BLOCKBUSTER'S FINAL INVALIDITY CONTENTIONS APRIL 11, 2007 U.S. PATENT NO. 7,024,381 B1 EXHIBIT C IDENTIFICATION OF PRIOR ART Prior Art Public Use, Public Knowledge, Sales and Offers for Sale1 Public Use 1. Subscription-based video rental service with monthly fees that allowed a member to rent as many video cassettes as the member wanted (1 at a time) at no extra cost and keep them for as long as the member wanted without incurring late fees. Video rental service with membership programs that allowed a member to rent 1 or 2 video tapes at a time at no extra cost and keep them for as long as the member wanted, and, upon returning the tapes, the member could receive another 1 or 2 tapes in exchange. Person/Entity Multi-Video, Will Espin Charlotte, North Carolina Date of Use No later than July 1982 Short Name Multi-Video services2 2. Pop*Card, Linda Verin Oklahoma City, OK No later than January 1985 Pop*Card services3 1 Hereafter collectively "Public Use" or "Use." "Multi-Video Article" and "Multi-Video services" are hereinafter referred to collectively as "Multi-Video." 3 "Pop*Card publications" and "Pop*Card services" are hereinafter referred to collectively as "Pop*Card." 2 Dockets.Justia.com Doc. 179 Att. 3 925437_2.DOC BLOCKBUSTER'S FINAL INVALIDITY CONTENTIONS (U.S. PATENT NO. 7,024,381 B1) Public Use 3. Subscription-based video rental service with monthly fees that allowed a member to rent as many video cassettes as the member wanted (1 at a time) at no additional charge. Subscription-based video rental service with monthly fees that allowed a member to rent 3 to 7 videos at a time at no extra charge and keep them as long as the member wanted without incurring late fees. Subscription-based audio and video tape rental service that allowed a member to rent 2 tapes at a time at no extra charge and keep them as long as the member wanted without incurring late fees. Subscription-based financial training courses on computer readable disks, CR-ROMs and video tapes Person/Entity Video Hit Parade Red Bank, NJ Date of Use No later than October 1985 Short Name Video Hit services4 4. Cine Club Video, Jacques-Henri Djian, Guy Desombre Manhattan, New York AudioQueue, Duane Ramm, Mark Ramm Covesville, Virginia Bankers Training & Consulting Co., Dean Pichee, Jean Dunaway Talking Book World, Richard Simtob Southfield, Michigan Multipost Retail Systems, Harry Magerman No later than October 1985 Cine Club services5 5. No later than 1989 AudioQueue services6 6. In the 1980s BTCC 7. Subscription-based audio book rental service with quarterly fees that allowed a member to rent 1 to 2 tapes at a time and keep them as long as the member wanted with no late fees. Computer software for video rental services that had reservation features No later than 1994 Talking Book World services7 8. No later than 1995 Video Vendor services8 4 5 "Video Hit Article" and "Video Hit services" are hereinafter referred to collectively as "Video Hit." "Cine Club publication" and "Cine Club services" are hereinafter referred to collectively as "Cine Club." 6 "AudioQueue publication" and "AudioQueue services" are hereinafter referred to collectively as "AudioQueue." 7 "Talking Book World Article" and "Talking Book World services" are hereinafter referred to collectively as "TBW." 8 "Video Vendor User Manual" and "Video Vendor services" are hereinafter referred to collectively as "Video Vendor." EXHIBIT C: IDENTIFICATION OF PRIOR ART (Prior Art Public Use) Page 2 of 3 925437_2.DOC BLOCKBUSTER'S FINAL INVALIDITY CONTENTIONS (U.S. PATENT NO. 7,024,381 B1) Public Use 9. 10. Online vehicle rental service with features allowing users to select vehicles and make reservations online Video rental store that offered subscription plan (3 out at a time with flat monthly fee) Book rental services that features an ordered list for customers to indicate the order of receiving their desired books Business training library service that allows members to subscribe to pay a period fee and obtain up to 5 programs at a time and keep them as long as they want and return them for exchange of new programs Bankers training program service that allows subscribers to obtain a limited number of programs at a time and keep them as long as they want and return them for exchange of new programs TV broadcast program storage, distribution and retrieval functions Online DVD rental services provided by Netflix Person/Entity Avis Rent A Car Campus Video, Charles Annable Oberlin, Ohio Books on Tape, Duvall Hecht, Ron Pravell Business Training Library St. Louis, Missouri Date of Use No later than May 1996 No later than 1996 Short Name Avis services9 Campus Video services10 Books on Tape services11 Business Training Library services12 11. No late than February 1997 No later than April 1998 12. 13. BVS Performance Systems Cedar Rapids, Iowa No later than April 1998 BVS services13 14. 15. TiVo Netflix Inc. No later than March TiVo services14 1999 No later than April 27, 1999 Netflix service15 9 "Avis publication" and "Avis services" are hereinafter referred to collectively as "Avis." "Campus Video Article" and "Campus Video services" are hereinafter referred to collectively as "Campus Video." 11 "Books On Tape publications" and "Books on Tape services" are hereinafter referred to collectively as "BOT." 12 "Business Training Library Web Pages" and "Business Training Library services" are hereinafter referred to collectively as "BTL." 13 "BVS Publications" and "BVS services" are hereinafter referred to collectively as "BVS." 14 "TiVo publications" and "TiVo services" are hereinafter referred to collectively as "TiVo." 15 "Netflix publications" and "Netflix services" are hereinafter referred to collectively as "Netflix." EXHIBIT C: IDENTIFICATION OF PRIOR ART (Prior Art Public Use) Page 3 of 3 10 925437_2.DOC

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.

Why Is My Information Online?