Williams-Sonoma, Inc. v. Friendfinder, Inc. et al

Filing 77

MOTION for Bill of Costs Declaration of Timothy R. Cahn in Support of Plaintiff Williams-Sonoma, Inc.'s Submission for an Award of Attorney's Fee and Costs Pursuant to Court Order Dated March 4, 2008 filed by Williams-Sonoma, Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit Exhibit B)(Chung, Megan) (Filed on 3/24/2008)

EXHIBIT A 

A I P LA
REPORT

OF THE

ECONOMIC SURVEY

2007
PREPARED UNDER DIRECTION OF THE
AMERICAN INTEllECTUAL PROPERTY LAW ASSOCIATION
LAW PRACTICE MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE

KEVIN ALAN WOLFF, CHAIR
ASHOK K. MANNAVA, VICE CHAIR

July 2007

ARI
As Re, Inc.

4 RESEARCH PLACE, SUITE 220
ROCKVILLE, MARYLAND 20850

TEL: [phone]
ARI(§ASSOCIA TIONRESEARCH.COM

(£2007 AMERICAN INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY lAW ASSOCIATION
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. No PART OF THIS BOOK MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN
ANY FORM OR BY ANY MEANS, ELECTRONIC OR MECHANICAL, INCLUDING PHOTOCOPYING,
RECORDING, OR BY AN INFORMATION STORAGE AND RETRIEVAL SYSTEM, WITHOUT PERMISSION
IN WRITING FROM THE PUBLISHER.

COPIES OF THIS REPORT ARE AVAILABLE FROM AIPlA AT A COST OF $35 PER COPY FOR

MEMBERS AND $300 PER COPY FOR NON-MEMBERS.

AMERICAN INTEllECTUAL PROPERTY LAW ASSOCIATION
24118TH STREET, SOUTH, SUITE 700

ARLINGTON VA 22202-3694
[phone]
WW.AIPLA.ORG

$184

$80

$150

$250

Mean (Average)

First Quartle 25%

Median (Midpoint)

Third Quartle 75%

$350

$175

$63

$228

12

CMSA

$325

$100

$23

$159

13

CMSA

NYC

7

$175

$125

$10

$110

Phila
CMSA

$163

$100

$50

$169

22

Wash, DC
CMSA

$200

$150

$100

$168

12

Other East

$450

Median (Midpoint)

Third Quartle 75%

$675

$175

$150

$388

13

CMSA

$450

$250

$84

$267

14

CMSA

NYC

7

$400

$250

$30

$222

Phila
CMSA

$375

$225

$138

$255

21

Wash, DC
CMSA

$437

$200

$350

$600

First Quartle 25%

Median (Midpoint)

Third Quartle 75%

190

Mean (Average)

Number of Respondents

Total

$750

$300

$150

$548

11

CMSA

Boston

9

$700

$363

$178

$414

12

Phila
CMSA

$550

$400

$213

$408

9

Other East

$423

$575

$400

$300

$1,000

$325

$263

$493

10

east
7

east

South-

, 1~94

9

$600

$500

$225

$431

$1,063

$600

$475

$745

10

CMSA

Chicago

Location

$600

$350

$120

Other
SouthMetro

$500

$350

$210

11

$434

CMSA

Chicago

$385

$300

$150

$288

AlPLA Report of the Economic Survey 2007

$788

$450

$150

$530

20

Wash, DC
CMSA

7

east

$374

east

South-

Location

$300

$200

$100

$214

Other
South-

Metro

$306

$213

$163

$229

11

CMSA

Chicago

Location

11

east

east
8

Other
South-

South-

Metro

Minne,-

5

5

4

NA

$475

NA

$538

PMSA

SI. Paul

Minne"

$488

$400

$288

$390

Minne,SI. Paul
PMSA

$263

$200

$188

$220

PMSA

SI. Paul

Oter
L.A,

L.A.

$450

$250

$150

$324

43

$588

$325

$250

$431

12

$500

$350

$175

$439

9

$350

$200

$125

$286

10

CMSA

L.A,

$225

$113

$46

$146

10

CMSA

CMSA

Texas

$500

$375

$200

$398

18

Texas

$288

$175

$131

$226

20

Texas

Other

$400

$250

$125

$292

49

Other
Central

$200

$150

$75

$156

48

Central

Centrl

Total Costs: Litigation- Trademark Infringement by Location

$550

$250

$125

$312

CMSA

NYC

$325

$250

$125

$268

13

Other East

Litigation-Trademark Infrngement $1-$25M at risk-End of Discovery (OOOs) (Q37c)

$150

$255

First Quartle 25%

$327

216

Mean (Average)

Number of Respondents

Total

Boston

Litigation-Trademark Infrngement Less than $1M at risk--Inclusive, all costs (OOOs) (Q37b)

218

Number of Respondents

Total

Boston

Litigation-Trademark Infringement Less than $1M at risko-End of Discovery (OOOs) (Q37a)

Total Costs: Litigation- Trademark Infringement by Location

S.F,

$613

$450

$225

$418

12

CMSA

S,F,

$563

$400

$263

$504

12

CMSA

S,F.

$250

$225

$100

$196

12

CMSA

$550

$325

$159

$424

22

West

Oter

$400

$250

$200

$293

27

West

Oter

$250

$150

$75

$168

27

West

Oter

$350

$650

$1,000

Median (Midpoint)

Third Quartle 75%

$1 ,400

$525

$263

$865

12

$775

$500

$196

$480

10

CMSA

NYC

$1 ,400

$650

$350

$825

12

Phila
CMSA

$1,500.

$775

$500

$1,066

20

Wash, DC
CMSA

$825

$600

$425

$644

9

Other East

$250

$600

$1,100

First Quartle 25%

Median (Midpoint)

Third Quartle 75%

$1,438

$350

$188

$828

10

CMSA

7

$1,000

$325

$250

$470

CMSA

NYC

$1 ,400

$988

$250

$846

10

Phila
CMSA

$2,000

$1,000

$280

$1,200

18

Wash, DC
CMSA

$1,000

$1,000

$350

$793

7

Other East

$1,586

$600

$1 ,250

$2,000

First Quartle 25%

Median (Midpoint)

Third Quartle 75%

155

Mean (Average)

Number of Respondents

Total

$2,250

$750

$250

$1,288

10

CMSA

Boston

9

$2,000

$1,000

$268

$1,951

CMSA

NYC

$1,900

$1 ,450

$475

$1,195

10

Phila
CMSA

$1,500

$1,400

$700

$1,368

7

Other East

$614

7

$2,000

$1 ,400

$550

$1,500

$1,350

$800

$1,226

$2,313

$1,000

$450

$1,258

east

$3,750

$2,600

$1,000

$2,764

1-95

7

CMSA

east

South-

6

8

$1,400

Chicago

Location

$1,500

$400

$50

$718

7

CMSA

Other
South-

Metro

$1,200

$700

$500

$786

east

east

Chicago

$1,738

$1,100

$775

$1,230

10

CMSA

Chicago

Location

$1,625

$550

South-

7

$821

$303

Other
South-

Metro

$800

$650

$375

10

east

east
7

Other
South-

Metro

South-

Location

AIPLA Report of the Economic Survey 2007

$3,000

$2,000

$1,150

$2,527

18

CMSA

Wash,. DC

Litigation-Trademark Infringement Greater than $25M at risk--Inclusive, all costs (ODDs) (Q37f)

$868

155

Mean (Average)

Number of Respondents

Total

Boston

Litigation- Trademark Infringement Greater than $25M at risk..End of Discovery (ODDs) (Q37 e)

$790

First Quartle 25%

191

Mean (Average)

Number of Respondents

Total

Boston
CMSA

Litigation-Trademark Infringement $1-$25M at risk--Inclusive, all costs (ODDs) (Q37d)

4

3

3

NA

$1,250

NA

$2,150

PMSA

SI. Paul

Minne,-

NA

$750

NA

$1,500

PMSA

SI. Paul

Minne"

NA

$775

NA

$788

Minne,SI. Paul
PMSA

LA

Oter

$750

$500

$200

$525

35

Central

Oter

$850

$600

$300

$636

43

$1,500

$750

$500

$1,007

35

$2,000

$1,000

$600

$1,627

11

Texas

$1,000

$500

$250

$932

11

Texas

$1,000

$725

$375

$738

12

8

4

4

NA

$1,250

NA

$1,625

CMSA

L.A.

NA

$800

NA

$850

CMSA

L.A.

$1,375

$625

$165

$829

CMSA

Texas

Oter
Centrl

Central

Total Costs: Litigation- Trademark Infringement by Location

1.94

AlPLA Report of the Economic Survey 2007

S,F,

$3,000

$1,500

$1,000

$1,964

11

CMSA

SF

$1,200

$750

$250

$1,175

11

S,F,
CMSA

$1,425

$1,000

$738

$1,092

12

CMSA

17

17

$2,000

$1,200

$850

$1 ,485

West

Oter

$1,500

$600

$350

$953

Wes

Oter

$925

$500

$345

$670

22

West

Oter

$80

$150

$250

First Quartle 25%

Median (Midpoint)

Third Quartle 75%

$200

$100

$43

$131

$250

$188

$100

$210

$300

$200

$113

$223

$200

$125

$79

$158

22

32

102

57

All

Corprate

76 or more
Attorneys

6-75
Attorneys

1-5

Attorneys

$150

$255

$450

Median (Midpoint)

Third Quartle 75%

1-5

$338

$225

$100

$239

57

Attorneys

$500

$300

$200

$340

98

6.75
Attorneys

$600

$450

$400

$250

$150

$347

$43
$250

23

33

All

Corprate

76 or more
Attorneys

$437

$200

$350

$600

First Quartle 25%

Median (Midpoint)

Third Quartle 75%

190

Mean (Average)

Number of Respondents

Total

$350

$200

$100

$240

41

1.5
Attomeys

$650

$400

$250

$489

$750

$500

$300

$545

1-96
__ ___.I 1-__ ~:___ --.,__

AlPLA Report of the Economic Survey 2007

$600

$400

$150

$430

23

37

87

All

Corporate

76 or more
Attorneys

6-75
Attomeys

Litigation-Trademark Infrngement $1-$25M at risk-End of Discovery (OOOs) (Q37c)

$327

First Quartle 25%

216

Mean (Average)

Number of Respondents

Total

Litigation-Trademark Infrngement Less than $1M at risk-Inclusive, all costs (OOOs) (Q37b)

$184

218

Mean (Average)

Number of Respondents

Total

Litigation-Trademark Infrngement Less than $1M at risk-End of Discovery (OOOs) (Q37a)

Total Costs: Litigation- Trademark Infringement by Firm Type

Q)

~
i;
ê

it
::
.c

..
s:

..

Q)

CI
CI

E
Q)
0)

N

;:

~
::
(J

,s:

.s
.s

()

ã)
..

8
..

't
C

¡e ""

i
~
II

5ß

~

.ß ic
~

::

U

~
II

'" co
"' co

LL Q)

fß zq

ER

cooioo
C' 0 r- 0
~~~o_
;;

"; ~
"" :t

-

c:

..
c

~ ~
E

"C
cu

::
II
N
.

CI

E
CI

cc
c

.5

'9

~ 0

~

c;

Jj ..

~

o

I

E
CI

't
I!
le
o

~
cu

:¡
::
C)

W

-

'C

nn

::
II

N
C

o 0 co
10 co co

C' C" 10
ER ER ER

o 0 0 0
CJ 10 10 0
Sf zz ~ 0_

;;

'C

t:
cu

o

;;

-

cu
.c
..

S
cu
e
(!

c
CI

E
CI

C)

c

~ (/ T"

0"' C"
E ~

oß

o o 0
o 0_ 0
.. ER o v_
.. co ;; ~
ER
co
co

¡e ""

0
~ ~ C" 0 0 10
co

100

~ zz Sf ;;
"!

LL Q)

.. E
r. 0

~

t:
cu
E

c:

E' ,.
Q; L( 'õ ~
'" N a. Q)
Q)
ir ~ :ê '0 ;e
..
o
~ §
:; :: g¡ '"
.0 c: o c: o
'*

8en

E

::
z

'"

Q)

::

i! 'i
Q)

ü:::

'E

~

CI
't
I!
li

:¡
:¡
::
C

o

cu

C)

::
U
c

i
..

o
~ g co

~

~ ~

o 0 10
10 10 C'

C' C" co
ER ER ER

~

co 0 0 o
coioo ..
co C' co o
ER ER ER
~ ..
;;
10
10

Q)

c:

:g r:
'8. ~
i: ~ :ê '0 ;e
~ g¡
o '" 'E
1¡ l ~ c: o
c:
'"
E
'"

Q)

::

z

cu

N

-

cu
.c
..

S
nn
e
C)
c
CI

E
GI

C)
C
"C

.5

t:
cu

.I
c:
'0

o
a.

-

::
II
C

.5
.I
c:

~
"¡¡
II
";:

:E
Q)
"C

u

'*

CD L(
C) N

Q)

::

ü:::
i! ij

~

Õ

1:

.s ~
~

:ë ~
o

E

CI
't
I!
le
o

:¡
:¡
::
cu

C)

CJ

o

a.

10 10 o
0 o
C'
10

i:

ER

:5
0.

~ ~ "!
;; ;;

Ñ

0 o 0
* ~ t; CJ10 0_ 0
CJ
o
E E
~ t; ii

ëã
.¡¡
o
u

:ë ~

II

~
o

aa

:i

o 0 o
o o 0 o
C'_ ii o

~ tJ T"

"'
C'

oß

ER

0"' C"
E ~
¡e c:

Z; ~

ER
Ñ

CI

;;

ER ER ER

o
o
..

co 10 C"
0
~ t: C' co "! o
10
CC ~
"; ~
Z; Z; ER
""
CD

L( Q)

Ñ

11

J!
In

ER

C'00V
co .. 0
co v

"" :t

~g
~ Ë

C"
C'
CJ
ER

v 10 10
0
CJ C'

a

Sf C'_

;;

~

10 co 0 0 o
10 co 0 10
o
S .. 10. ~ "! o

~ z;

~

ER
Ñ

.:

~ ~
o

~
o
U

Jg ~
~

Ü

:N

íi

000
10100
~ ~ "!

Õ

CO

,~

Q) v
~ N ;;
r-

Õ

.¡ e.
o
o
s:

,0

o
o

e.
~

Õ

e
C"

Ñ

=c
..

-

o
o
e.

íi

Ü

~

w,
aa
.r

íi

Ü

~
ii

e

e
C"

en

"E

Q)

'0

c:

8'"
Q)

i:

'*

Q; L(
'" N

~ Q)

::

z

Z' ?f
c: L(
ë5 Q)
la.

~ ~ ~ ~
::

1¡ :: ::
c: 0
E
Õ

E

o

c
0..
() Ø)

E'
CO

¡¡

~
(t

'E

:: ü:
ii i!

c:
'"

o

ij 'E
:: ~

-