Parrish et al v. National Football League Players Incorporated

Filing 657

RESPONSE to Objections and Class Counsels' Objection to Participation By Non-Class Members in Any Phase of the Settlement Proceedings by Herbert Anthony Adderley. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1)(Katz, Ronald) (Filed on 11/5/2009)

Exhibit 1 to the Class Counsels' Response to Objections and Class Counsels' Objection to Participation by Non-Class Members in Any Phase of the Settlement Proceedings

Name

Class Member

Don Herrmann

Yes

Michael T. Bass

Yes

J. Bruce Jarvis

Yes

Paul R. Flatley

Yes

Gale Gillingham

Yes

Bobby Franklin

No

Dave Pear

Yes

W illiam R. Mack

No

Albert Guntuden

No

Summary of Objection Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two.

Name

Class Member

Preston Carpenter

Yes

Roy Jefferson

Yes

Bill Truax

Yes

LeRoy Kelly

Yes

David B. Olerich

No

Jon Arnett

No

Bob Lurtsema

Yes

Johnny E. Roland

Yes

Norm Bulaich

Yes

Summary of Objection Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two.

Name

Class Member

Pat Matson

No

Clyde L. Werner

No

Ted Kwalick

No

Richard J. Camarillo

Yes

Charles L. Johnson

No

Ronald D. Pritchard

Yes

Frank H. Nunley

Yes

Gerald Philbin

Yes

Robert J. Scholtz

Yes

Summary of Objection Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two.

Name

Class Member

Anthony R. Franklin

No

Dick Bielski

No

Larry Kaminski

Yes

Marvin Fleming

No

Marvin Cobb

No

George Visger

No

Douglas Wilkerson

No

Carl Brettschneider John Bramlett Bernard Parrish

Yes No No

Summary of Objection Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Includes synopsis of medical history and past litigation related to medical injury while playing for the 49ers. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. [form letter is not signed] Dues paying member who was not included in the current litigation. Believes that numerous other retired members were not included on the class member list. Requests copy of August 4, 2009 amendment.

Name

Michael Sandusky Billy Ray Barnes

Kevin House

R. Gern Nagler

Searlier y of Objection Class Member Believes Electronic Arts was released in ummarversions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Includes synopsis of medical/work history. Yes Member of Bert Bell pension plan and NFLPA but was excluded from the group of players receiving a portion of the financial settlement. No Submitted a signed GLA but was excluded from list of retired players receiving a portion of the financial settlement. Disagrees with the reported number of retired players (2,062) and the amount of damages awarded. No Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Yes Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. Supports settlement, noting it represents 93.4% of jury verdict. Supports settlement, noting the money he receives will be useful States the settlement documents are bewildering and that he is upset with the settlement. Contains numerous unattributed comments about settlement. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two. Believes Electronic Arts was released in earlier versions of the Settlement Agreement. Does not agree with damages calculation based on information provided by NFLPA. Requests recalculation of damages based on expert witnesses Rowley and Rascher's financial reports. The settlement should be one payment, instead of two.

Doug Cosbie Jeff Nixon Troy Auzenne Bernard Parrish No name given

Yes Yes Yes No Unknown

Jason Suttle

Yes

Raymond Berry

No

Kevin House

No

Thomas S. "Tim" Van Galder

No

Name

Class Member

Edward M. Khayat Robert C. Khayat

No No

Summary of Objection Dues paying member who was not included in the current litigation. Believes that numerous other retired members were not included on the class member list, and that some class members should not be included. Dues paying member who was not included in the current litigation. Believes that numerous other retired members were not included on the class member list.