Oracle America, Inc. v. Google Inc.

Filing 155

Minute Entry: Discovery Hearing HELD on 5/31/2011 before Magistrate Judge Donna M. Ryu. Plaintiff's Administrative Motion to file Under Seal Exhibits A, b, & D to Declaration of Dorian Daley GRANTED. Plaintiff's request to grant the following Designated House Counsel access to attorneys' eyes only ("AEO") information pursuant to the Protective Order: A. Dorian Daley - DENIED; B. Deborah Kay Miller - GRANTED ACCESS TO AEO INFORMATION, BUT NO ACCESS TO CONTRACTS WITH CARRIERS OR HARDWARE MANUFACTURERS; C. Matthew Sarboraria - GRANTED ACCESS TO AEO INFORMATION, BUT NO ACCESS TO CONTRACTS WITH CARRIERS OR HARDWARE MANUFACTURERS; D. Andrew Temkin - FURTHER INFORMATION REQUIRED. Please see minutes for more particulars. (Date Filed: 5/31/2011). ***Motions terminated: #150 Administrative Motion to File Under Seal Exhibits A, B and D to Declaration of Dorian Daley filed by Oracle America, Inc. (Court Reporter Raynee Mercado.) (ig, COURT STAFF) (Date Filed: 5/31/2011) Modified on 6/1/2011 (ig, COURT STAFF).

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
CIVIL LAW & MOTION MINUTE ORDER
CASE NO. C-10-03561-WHA (DMR)
CASE NAME: Oracle America Inc. v. Google Inc.
MAGISTRATE JUDGE DONNA M. RYU

COURTROOM DEPUTY: Ivy Garcia

DATE: 5/31/2011

COURT REPORTER: Raynee Mercado

TIME: 11:31 a.m. -1:15 p.m.

COUNSEL FOR PLAINTIFF:
Daniel Muino
Jessica Tipton
Steven Holtzman
Marc Peters

PROCEEDINGS:

COUNSEL FOR DEFENDANT:
Bruce Baber
Renny Hwang
Steven Snyder
Scott Weingaertner
Christa Anderson

Discovery Hearing HELD

RULING:

1. Plaintiff's Administrative Motion to file Under Seal
Exhibits A, B, & D to Declaration of Dorian Daley

GRANTED

2. Plaintiff's request to grant the following Designated
House Counsel access to attorneys' eyes only ("AEO")
information pursuant to the Protective Order:
A. Dorian Daley

DENIED

B. Deborah Kay Miller

GRANTED ACCESS TO AEO
INFORMATION, BUT NO ACCESS TO
CONTRACTS WITH CARRIERS OR
HARDWARE MANUFACTURERS

C. Matthew Sarboraria

GRANTED ACCESS TO AEO
INFORMATION, BUT NO ACCESS TO
CONTRACTS WITH CARRIERS OR
HARDWARE MANUFACTURERS

D. Andrew Temkin

FURTHER INFORMATION REQUIRED

_________________________________________________________________________
By no later than 5:00 p.m. on 6/1/11, Plaintiff shall file a detailed supplemental
declaration setting forth the job duties of Andrew Temkin so that the Court may determine
whether he is involved in competitive decision-making. Among other things, the declaration
shall elucidate the earlier ambiguous statements regarding Temkin's duties that were
discussed during oral argument. The declaration shall also set forth the facts supporting
Temkin's need to view AEO information.

By no later than 5:00 p.m. on 6/3/11, Defendant shall file a letter brief explaining why
Andrew Temkin should not be given access to AEO information. Defendant's letter brief may
not exceed 2 ½ pages. The matter will be deemed submitted on the papers.
Defendant shall promptly provide Plaintiff with a list of AEO contracts with carriers or
hardware manufacturers that Defendant contends should not be shown to Miller or Sarboraria.
Parties shall meet and confer regarding the appropriate means for maintaining security
of AEO information without unduly burdening or inconveniencing either party.

cc:

Chambers

* (T) = Telephonic Appearance

2