Oracle America, Inc. v. Google Inc.

Filing 944

Minute Entry: Jury Trial held on 4/19/2012 before William Alsup (Date Filed: 4/19/2012). Witnessess called. Further Jury Trial set for 4/20/2012 7:30 AM. (Court Reporter Kathy Sullivan; Debra Pas.) (dtS, COURT STAFF) (Date Filed: 4/19/2012)

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
CIVIL TRIAL MINUTES
The Honorable WILLIAM H. ALSUP
Date: April 19, 2012

Case No.: C10-03561 WHA
Case Name: ORACLE AMERICA, INC. v. GOOGLE INC.
Plaintiff's Counsel: Michael Jacobs; Dan Muino; Fred Norton; Andrew Temkin; David Boies; Dorian Daley
Steven Holtzman; Safra Catz (Corporate Representative)
Defendant's Counsel: Robert Van Nest; Christa Anderson; Dan Purcell; Michael Kwun; Bruce Baber
Catherine Lacavera (Corporate Representative)
Clerk: Dawn K. Toland

Court Reporter: Kathy Sullivan; Debra Pas

Trial Began: April 16, 2012

Further Trial: April 20, 2012 at 7:30 am

Trial Motions Heard:
1.
2.
3.

Other:

Time in Trial: 6 hours 5 minutes

Disposition

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
Case No: C10-03561 WHA
Case Name: ORACLE AMERICA, INC. v. GOOGLE INC.
EXHIBIT and WITNESS LIST
JUDGE:
WILLIAM H. ALSUP

PLAINTIFF ATTORNEY:
Michael Jacobs; Dan Muino
Fred Norton; Andrew Temkin
David Boies; Dorian Daley
Steven Holtzman

DEFENSE ATTORNEY:
Robert Van Nest; Christa Anderson
Dan Purcell; Michael Kwun
Bruce Baber

TRIAL DATE:
April 19, 2012

REPORTER(S):
Kathy Sullivan; Debra Pas

CLERK:
Dawn Toland

PLF
NO.

DEF
NO

DATE
OFFERE
D

ID

RE
C

DESCRIPTION

7:30 am

Outside the presence of the jury. Court and counsel addressed 4
juror notes. Parties are attempting to agree on list to give the
jury. Michael Jacobs advised the Court parties have stipulated to
admit the following exhibits: 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43, 44,
45, 46, 47, 51, 53, 54, 65, 70, 74 and 30. Plaintiff may need to
call an associate (without notice) to admit other exhibits and
request the time be charged against the defendant. Plaintiff can
use exhibits 1062 and 1063. Court confirmed exhibit 6 was
admitted yesterday.

7:55 am

Reconvene...jury present

8:01 am

Direct of Mark Reinhold continued

610.2

x

x

Java 2 Platform Standard Edition 5.0 API Specification

984

x

x

The Java Language Specification Third Edition

1062

x

x

Classes and Interfaces Mentioned

1063

x

x

Classes and Interfaces

623

x

x

Source Code for Java 2 Standard Edition Version 5.0

980

x

x

The Java Application Programming Interface, Volume 1

981

x

x

The Java Application Programming Interface, Volume 2

622

x

x

Source Code for Java 2 Standard Edition Version 1.4

965

x

x

Source code for Java Standard Edition 6

623.
1623.1
0

x

x

\j2se\src\share\classes\java\util\Arrays.java

BY

8:37 am
984

Cross Examination by Dan Purcell
x

x

The Java Language Specification Third Edition

8:57 am

Recess

9:18 am

Reconvene...jury present
Cross Examination continued

984

x

x

The Java Language Specification Third Edition

1062

x

x

Classes and Interfaces Mentioned

9:31 am

Redirect Examination

9:35 am

Witness Excused, Subject to Recall
Plaintiff’s witness Joshua Bloch sworn-in. Direct by Michael
Jacobs

624

x

x

Javapolis Presentation: How to Design a Good API and Why it
Matters

794

x

x

Demonstrative re rangeCheck functions from Timsort.java and
Arrays.java

10:08 am
984

Cross Examination by Bruce Babers
x

x

The Java Language Specification Third Edition
Demonstration done by witness

11:20 am

Recess

11:33 am

Reconvene...jury present
Cross Examination continued

11:58 am
794

Redirect Examination
x

x

12:05 pm

Demonstrative re rangeCheck functions from Timsort.java and
Arrays.java
Recross

3452

x

4027

x

Demonstrative Chart drawn by Dr. Bloch
x

The Java Language Specification First Edition

12:09 pm

Re Redirect Examination

12:10 pm

Witness Excused, Subject to Recall
David Boies advised the Court parties have stipulated to admit
the following exhibits: 3, 9, 10, 11, 12, 17, 125, 212, 213, 222,
317, 318, 321, 325 and 330.

12:13 pm
25

Plaintiff’s witness Tim Lindholm sworn-in. Direct by David
Boies
x

x

The Java Virtual Machine Specification First Edition

987

x

x

The Java Virtual Machine Specification Second Edition

9

x

x

Email from Tim Lindholm to Andy Rubin and Rich Miner re
One last thought on Sun

2

x

x

Email from Andy Rubin to [e-mail]

3

x

x

Email from Andy Rubin to Tim Lindholm re Review

326

x

x

Email from Bob Lee to Tim Lindhollm re Open Source Java

10

x

x

Email from Tim Lindholm to Andy Rubin et al. Re Context for
discussion

12:35 pm

Cross Examination by Cristy Anderson

17

x

x

Email from Bill Coughran to Tim Lindholm re Travel for
Android requested

318

x

x

Email from Tim Lindholm re Android notes

321

x

x

Email from Andy Rubin to Tim Lindholm re Project advisors

326

x

x

Email from Bob Lee to Tim Lindhollm re Open Source Java

330

x

x

Email from Tim Lindholm to Matt Frantz re Fwd: Java is free:-)

10

x

x

Email from Tim Lindholm to Andy Rubin et al. Re Context for
discussion

12:59
12

Redirect Examination
x

1:01 pm

x

Email from Tim Lindholm to Andy Rubin re JCP Click-Through
Licenses?
Witness Excused
Recess
Outside the presence of the jury. Court and counsel discussed
several issues.

1:35 pm

Recess until 4/20/12 at 7:30 am