Oracle America, Inc. v. Google Inc.

Filing 975

Minute Entry: Jury Trial held on 4/23/2012 before Judge William Alsup (Date Filed: 4/23/2012). Witnesses called. Further Jury Trial 4/24/2012 7:30 AM. (Court Reporter Kathy Sullivan; Debra Pas.) (dt, COURT STAFF) (Date Filed: 4/23/2012)

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
CIVIL TRIAL MINUTES
The Honorable WILLIAM H. ALSUP
Date: April 23, 2012

Case No.: C10-03561 WHA
Case Name: ORACLE AMERICA, INC. v. GOOGLE INC.
Plaintiff's Counsel: Michael Jacobs; Dan Muino; Fred Norton; Andrew Temkin; David Boies; Dorian Daley
Steven Holtzman; Safra Catz (Corporate Representative)
Defendant's Counsel: Robert Van Nest; Christa Anderson; Dan Purcell; Michael Kwun; Bruce Baber
Renny Hwang; Catherine Lacavera (Corporate Representative)
Clerk: Dawn K. Toland

Court Reporter: Kathy Sullivan; Debra Pas

Trial Began: April 16, 2012

Further Trial: April 24, 2012 at 7:30 am

Trial Motions Heard:
1.
2.
3.

Other:

Time in Trial: 6 hours 25 minutes

Disposition

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
Case No: C10-03561 WHA
Case Name: ORACLE AMERICA, INC. v. GOOGLE INC.
EXHIBIT and WITNESS LIST
JUDGE:
WILLIAM H. ALSUP

PLAINTIFF ATTORNEY:
Michael Jacobs; Dan Muino
Fred Norton; Andrew Temkin
David Boies; Dorian Daley
Steven Holtzman

DEFENSE ATTORNEY:
Robert Van Nest; Christa Anderson
Dan Purcell; Michael Kwun
Bruce Baber

TRIAL DATE:
April 23, 2012

REPORTER(S):
Kathy Sullivan; Debra Pas

CLERK:
Dawn Toland

PLF
NO.

DEF
NO

DATE
OFFERED

ID

REC

DESCRIPTION

7:30 am

Outside the presence of the jury. Court advised the parties to be
mindful of what’s in the trial record. Counsel addressed the
issue of what goes to the jury or the Court. Michael Jacobs
advised the Court parties have stipulated to admit the following
exhibits: 26, 104, 157, 233, 234, 251, 21, 172, 1029, 238, 34,
165, 383, 384, 416, 897, 729, 896.1, 896.2, 896.3, 896.4, 896.5,
896.6, 896.7, 896.7, 612, 617, and 2223. Plaintiff will submit a
brief re findings of fact and conclusion of law. Plaintiff argued
for the admission of exhibit 1026 - admitted. Court read note
from a member of the jury.

8:09 am

Reconvene...jury present

8:11 am

Direct of Bob Lee continued. By Michael Jacobs

610.
2

x

x

Java 2 Platform Standard Edition 5.0 API Specification

767

x

x

Android API Documentation

8:24 am

Cross Examination by Bruce Babers

405

x

x

Email from Eric Schmidt to Bob Lee re It was great chatting
with you yesterday

281

x

x

Email from Bob Lee to Hioshi Lockheimer re Nosers in 2009

8:58 am

Redirect Examination

1047

x

x

FAQ Letter to Sun Microsystem

1045

x

x

Apache Software Foundation Blog

9:07 am
1045

Recross
x

9:07 am

x

Apache Software Foundation Blog
Witness Excused

BY

Plaintiff’s witness Professor John Mitchell sworn-in. Direct
by Michael Jacobs
687

x

3452

x

1028

x

x

CV of Professor Mitchell
Demonstrative Chart drawn by Dr. Bloch

x

Java Class Libraries Poster

9:30 am

Recess

9:53 am

Reconvene...jury present
Direct of Professor Mitchell continued

10:47 am

Cross Examination by Robert Van Nest

686

x

Opening Expert Report of John C Mitchell Regarding Copyright

2564

x

x

Gosling, J., The Java Language Specification

980

x

x

The Java Application Programming Interface, Volume 1

984

x

x

The Java Language Specification Third Edition

1062

x

x

Classes and Interfaces

11:15 am

Recess
Outside the presence of the jury - one juror stayed behind to
address an issue regarding her employer

11:18 am

Side Bar

11:23 am

Recess

11:40 am

Reconvene...jury present
Cross Examination continued

3452

x

Demonstrative Chart drawn by Dr. Bloch

727

x

Opening Expert Report of Marc Visnick Regarding Copyright

686

x

Opening Expert Report of John C Mitchell Regarding Copyright

12;25 pm
1072

Redirect
x

x

12:34 pm

Accused API Packages and Files in Android
Witness Excused
Court read a party stipulation
Plaintiff’s witness Andy Rubin sworn-in. Direct by David
Boies

14

x

x

Email from Andy Rubin to Sergey Brin

15

x

x

Email from Andy Rubin to Rich Miner

18

x

x

Email from Greg Stein to Andy Rubin

22

x

x

Email from Karen Tsay to [e-mail]

29

x

x

Email from Andy Rubin to Dick Wall

131

x

x

Email from Tim Lindholm to Andy Rubin re Another thought
on Sun motivation

140

x

x

Email from Bill Coughran to Tim Lindholm and Andy Rubin

147

x

x

Email from Urs Hoelzle to Andy Rubin re Skelmir

151

x

x

Email from Steve Horowitz to Andy Rubin re GPS Notes

154

x

x

Email from Jason Harinstein to Andy Rubin

158

x

x

Email from [e-mail] to
[e-mail]

161

x

x

Email rom Jason Harington to Andy Rubin re Project Guava

165

x

x

Email from Richard Miner to Anthony House

180

x

x

Email from Erin Fors to Michael Kirkland, Barry Schnitt and
Andy Rubin

183

x

x

Emailfrom Eric Schmidt to Andy Rubin re Do you have time for
a call?

203

x

x

Email from Andy Rubin to [e-mail] re Fwd: Sun
slides

207

x

3

x

x

Email from Andy Rubin to Tim Lindholm re Review

7

x

x

Email from Tracey Cole to Andy Rubin

12

x

x

Email from Tim Lindholm to Andy Rubin

1

x

x

Android GPS Key Strategic Decisions Around Open Source

17

x

x

Email from Bill Coughran to Tim Lindholm re Travel

18

x

x

Email from Greg Stein to Andy Rubin re the open J2ME project

1:00 pm

Email from Eric Schmidt to Andy Rubin re java phone

Recess
Outside the presence of the jury. Defense raised a concern over
the admission of a exhibits. Court provided the number of
minutes used. Could the issue of wilfulness be advanced to
phase one. Court asked counsel to respond to question re
derivative work. Parties discussed other legal issues.

1:55 pm

Recess until 4/24/12 at 7:30 am