Oracle America, Inc. v. Google Inc.

Filing 976

Minute Entry: Jury Trial held on 4/24/2012 before Judge William Alsup (Date Filed: 4/24/2012). Witness called. Plaintiff REST - Phase One. Further Jury Trial set for 4/25/2012 7:30 AM. (Court Reporter Kathy Sullivan; Debra Pas.) (dt, COURT STAFF) (Date Filed: 4/24/2012)

Download PDF
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA CIVIL TRIAL MINUTES The Honorable WILLIAM H. ALSUP Date: April 24, 2012 Case No.: C10-03561 WHA Case Name: ORACLE AMERICA, INC. v. GOOGLE INC. Plaintiff's Counsel: Michael Jacobs; Dan Muino; Fred Norton; David Boies; Steven Holtzman; Ken Kuwayti Dorian Daley; Safra Catz (Corporate Representative) Defendant's Counsel: Robert Van Nest; Christa Anderson; Dan Purcell; Michael Kwun; Bruce Baber Renny Hwang; Catherine Lacavera (Corporate Representative) Clerk: Dawn K. Toland Court Reporter: Kathy Sullivan; Debra Pas Trial Began: April 16, 2012 Further Trial: April 25, 2012 at 7:30 am Trial Motions Heard: 1. 2. 3. Other: Time in Trial: 5 hours 50 minutes Disposition UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA Case No: C10-03561 WHA Case Name: ORACLE AMERICA, INC. v. GOOGLE INC. EXHIBIT and WITNESS LIST JUDGE: WILLIAM H. ALSUP PLAINTIFF ATTORNEY: Michael Jacobs; Dan Muino Fred Norton; David Boies; Dorian Daley Steven Holtzman; Ken Kuwayti DEFENSE ATTORNEY: Robert Van Nest; Christa Anderson Dan Purcell; Michael Kwun Bruce Baber TRIAL DATE: April 24, 2012 REPORTER(S): Kathy Sullivan; Debra Pas CLERK: Dawn Toland PLF NO. DEF NO DATE OFFERED ID REC DESCRIPTION 7:30 am Outside the presence of the jury. Plaintiff provided the Court and agreed upon list of witnesses and attorneys to give the jury. Plaintiff submitted deposition excerpts and demonstrative exhibits: 1066, 1067 and 1073. David Boies advised the Court parties have stipulated to admit the following exhibits: 34, 278, 298, 387, 538 and 1048. Parties argued an issue regarding a blog - exhibit 2352. Court ruled it can be used. Defendant raised issue regarding exhibit 431 as 403. Court overruled the objection. 8:02 am Reconvene...jury present Court addressed the jury re approaching witnesses 8:04 am Direct of Andy Rubin continued 207 x x Email from Eric Schmidt to Andy Rubin re java phone 214 x x Email from Eric Schmidt to Andy Rubin re sun deal 215 x x Email from Chris Desalvo to Andy Rubin re Java class libraries 216 x x Email from Eric Schmidt to AndyRubin 217 x x Email from Dave Burke to Andy Rubin re Future of Mobile conference 221 x x Email from Andy Rubin to Louis Perrochon re On the good stuff 223 x x Email from Larry Page to AndyRubin 230 x x Email from Andy Rubin to Bob Lee 273 x x Email form Andy Rubin to Dan Bornstein 382 x x Email from Andy Rubin to Eric Chu re Google folks 389 x x Email from Richard Miner to Andy Rubin re JVM BY 431 x x Email from Cathay Bi to Alan Eagle re BOD question 433 x x Android GPS - Meeting notes 438 x x Email from Andy Rubin to AlanEustace re Noser agreement 618 x x Email from Andy Rubin to Vineet Gupta re Confidential 619 x x Email from Andy Rubin to Vineet Gupta re Revised agreement 1002 x x Email from Tim Lindholm to Andy Rubin re Android and JavaOne 1044 x x 1050 x x 1051 x x 1060 x x 3443 x x Email: dated April 29, 2006 from Eric Schmidt to Andy Rubin 1061 x x Email with Attached Presentation 1 x x Android GPS Key Strategic Decisions Around Open Source 12 x x Email from Tim Lindholm to Andy Rubin re JCP Click 7 x x Email from Tracey Cole to Andy Rubin, including email from Andy Rubin to Larry Page 125 x x Email from Tim Lindholm to Andy Rubin re Anything useful in yesterday’s Sun meeting 9 x x Email from Tim Lindholm to Andy Rubin and Rich Miner re One last thought on Sun 21 x x Email from Andy Rubin to Dan Bornstein re What are we doing? 180 x x Email from Erin Fors to Michael Kirkland, Barry Schnitt and Andy Rubin re New question on Android Java 8:36 am Defendant reserved cross of Mr. Rubin until case in chief 8:40 am Recess 8:58 am Reconvene...jury present Plaintiff’s witness Eric Schmidt sworn-in. Direct by David Boies 6 x x Email from Andy Rubin to emg@google.coom including Android GPS presentation 158 x x Email from Andyt@google.com to tangjanfeng@chinamobile.com re Materials on Google 251 x x Email from Dan Morrill to Dan Bornstein re Android JRE Coverage 151 x x Email from Steve Horowitz to Andy Rubin re GPS Notes 10 x x Email from Tim Lindholm to Andy Rubin 17 x x Email from Bill Coughran to Tim Lindholm re Travel for Android 1 x x Android GPS Key Strategic Decisions Around Open Source 405 x x Email from Eric Schmidt to Bob Lee 9:22 am Plaintiff REST Rule 50 Motion deemed made 9:22 am Defendant’s witness Eric Schmidt by Robert Van Nest 1 x x Android GPS Key Strategic Decisions Around Open Source 205 x x Email from Scott McNealy to Eric Schmidt re Potential Sun Google 435 x x Email from Jonathan Schwartz to Eric Schmidt 2372 x x Email; Dated: May 8, 2006 from Vineet Gupta 3441 x x Email; Dated: November 9, 2007 from Eric Schmidt 2352 x 3466 x 3521 x Blog Entry; Dated: November 5, 2007 x Email; Dated March 31, 2008 from Eric Schmidt to Jonathan Schwartz Email; Dated May 6, 2008 from Andy Rubin to Eric Schmidt 10:38 am Side Bar 10:44 am Direct continued 10:46 am Recess 11:02 am Reconvene...jury present Cross Examination by David Boies 154 x x Email from Jason Harinstein to Andy Rubin 1048 x x Publication Sun concerned Google’s Android will fracture Java 30 x x Noser Engineering AG statement of Work 3 x x Emil from Andy Rubin to Tim Lindholm 7 x x Email from Tracey Cole to Andy Rubin, including email from Andy Rubin to Larry Page 406 x x Email from Eric Schmidt to Brett Slatkin 11:38 am 406 Redirect Examination x 11:51 am x Email from Eric Schmidt to Brett Slatkin Cross Examination 3452 x Demonstrative Drawn by Dr. Bloch 11:58 am Redirect Continued 12:00 pm 1028 x x Java Class Libraries 18 x x Email from Greg Stein to Andy Rubin 12:03 pm Side Bar 12:05 pm Witness Excused Defendant’s witness Andy Rubin by Robert Van Nest 617 x x Email from Leo Cizek to Matthew Marquis re Time-sensitive 11 x x Email from Rich Miner to Steve Horowitz re Sun doc 18 x x Email from Greg Stein to Andy Rubin re the open J2ME project 331 x Email from Andy Rubin to Tim Lindholm Sun Deal Review 2881 x Android Platform Diagram 1:00 pm Recess Outside the presence of the jury. Court gave counsel the amount of time used. 1:20 pm Recess until 4/25/12 at 7:30 am

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?