McHale v. Silicon Valley Law Group

Filing 122

ORDER GRANTING re 119 Trial Stipulation No. 2 filed by Gerard A McHale, Jr. Signed by Judge Joseph C. Spero on 1/16/13. (klh, COURT STAFF) (Filed on 1/16/2013)

~:n ~'r~.~~i~~~, ~al~forn~a. X41

5

1~
~l
1
1~

~.~IJELT~ . 'VIT
A~,~,'~'Ql'~ A~.BE~.~`
±~,ar~L,I~C~+~I. ~IEI''~;~.1~T ~C~1~. BEI~.,L
4~ ~ ~dis~n Av~nu
mew 'Y'+~r , l'~~~?v ~'"~►rl~ 1~!Q
T~l~~~►~:~: 1~~9~!~'-~'~~Q
F'~~~s rile X12-~~4- 3~0~
Er~.~:l: rrid~~v~~~n ~l~~.b~~~:.~~.
.ail: 'v~~t c~l~n~~~~,~c~~n
~rna~l: ~.~.l~~r~ o~~~nbc~c~..~o

1~

P~~I~C~E L~l~

,~.ttcar.~~~ f~~r ~~~ P~ai~t~~f~
,
~a-~rark. ~. ~I~Ha1~, Jr , P~ R.~.., L.iqui~:at~o~. ~'rust~~e

~1(~'~'HF!1. I~►I~TI~"~" ~I►~'
_

~'1~.'~'

l
~-

~.ttc~rn~y~ fir T~~f~nd~:nt ~ l cc~n V~.~~e~ ~,a ~'rr~~p

~-E~:A
~~:~fi►~ ~.~:L,~ Jar:; P~~►.:, as
~,~~u~~at~~n T~~.st~~ fir the 1~3l T~ebto~
~~gr~~c~~~t~~~ Tr~~t,

~~

F`l~.int~f,

~.~~~"~l►~~.1~A ~ A ~"~►1'~I~ I~►~~?`~~T
_
.~►.~~ `fib. ~'~~`~.Q

~'IPUI.aA.TI~1 '~'~'I' F~~.'~' 'T"
~~~1 ~ M IL .

v.
2~
~2

~IL~~+C~~ VAL,LE'~ I~~~V x~.~~TP, a
~al~or~a L~.w ~c~r~Qr~:ti~n,

~~

L?~fer~~.a~t.

~4

~~

~~~.~,~ , ~l~e ~'la~nt~ff ~ a~ not~~ed t~:e ~.~~os~t~~►n ~►f .~b~rt

cEIrQ~ fob Au,~~st ~"~,
f

l

~~ ~ 1, ~n F~:~~hn~Qn~., V~~ ~n~~., and hay ~erve~. a su~p~ena Qr~ l~Ir. ~~~lr~y ~~th r~sp►~ t t~i~retQ
~

•

•.

R

R

~7`IPULATIC}I~fi
972197.1

'~V~E~;~A, t~.~ u~.d~lrir~~d ~ar~x~s ~.r~e that ~l~e ~~~~ ar~~. ~p~~~.~~~ ~ ~~~~t~~~n vvit.

1

~u~~. ~: ~.~p~s tio~ can b~ av~i~.~~: ~ y ~~.ter~~. n~Q ~h ~ st~~~lat~~r~ with. re ~ae~t t~ ~~rtain ~.~cu~~a:~nt
3

TI-~~~F~T~..E, TIDE TEA .`~I~
l.

4

TI~'UL.~:~'E ~► ~ .~ rRE~ ,~.~ ~'~~,L~'

l~Ir, ~I~Elr~y .~ ~:~~ in 1~T~►°~~~ra..~~r ~Q~.~ ~.~ ~. pa~tr~e~ in t~~ law ~~rr~.

~ ~I~~xuire'~'oQds,I ~hmor~.~., '~'~r ~~:i~.. In N~v~m.1~~r Q(}~, ~'~ .~t~~ Hea~~~ way a.~s~ ~. ~.r~n~~ ~.t
1VV~~ r~~r~V~oo~~.~ ~.~~. a~~~~~: the firm: ~r~ ~(~~. Mr. He~.phy w~.~ an a~~~~t~.n~t ~...~n~ted ~tat~s .~.tt+~r~a..~

7

~~for~ j:~i~.ng Mcur~'~V'~a~d.~, ar~.d in ~~1~ l~e~t l~~~ruir~~~~.~ t~ b►~~~rra~ ~h LT:~~~+d ~~.t

a.

A,.ttorn.~y for t~~

~~~~r~. ~~str~t a►f V~rgir~i~. ~.~.d ~t~ll s~rv~~ ~n t~.~:t .~ap~i~~,

G4

4.

3

Thy m~n~.o~ra~:du atta~~.~~. ~~re~o ~.~ ~~hib~t and n~.~.r~~d. a.~ ]~~~a►s~t~ca .

E .l~~l~i~ 6~Q (~~~.phy ,~) ~.n~. marl~~~l with a~~~ 1`~Q. 1VI
~u~~:ua~:t t~ F'e~. I~., Vivid. ~~3 ~5) and (6}.

' th r~~~aect ~~► t ~ ~t~.t~ en~~ +~f 11~I~. i x~~n~ r~~~~r~~~.

ix~ ~~~.~bit ~ (~► t~:~~~ art accur~.te sta~~r ~nt~ of

2~

Q02-~~ ~ ~:c~r i~~ ~b~~ a~ a l~u.s ~~~ ~~+~~r

r. in~:~r~n ' ~ staxe .ent~ tQ 1'~Ir.

~~~ro~ c

~To►ve .bar ~1, ~~~~, an d ~~ ~► all parties re~er~v~ their ri ht~ as t~ tl~~ adm ~~ ~►n. ire ~vid~n~~ of 1VIr.

2.8
2
~'I'IPI.ILATIQN
~~'2197.1

r ~.:'s statem.ent in ~~~:~b t ~ a~ non-~e~.r~~.~ Qr ~.r~ ~~.~~ptic~~. to the ~~:x~~,~ r~.l~ ~.~.d. a~ to ~~.e

~.

r~~~~ar~c~ ~f the ev~~:~n~e, w~~c~ art ~~~~r~~ . f~~ ~~:~~r ~~ter~a.inati~► . ~~ the ~~~.rt.

~1
T'1~.~ d~~un~a.~~.t ~.~t~~i~~. ~r~t~ ~.s ~h~~t ~ ~.~~ m~r~~d w~t~i ~.~~s ~, l
~~►~~ ~~ ~~.

~~ ~l~ a~ a l~u~ ~~~~ r~~o~r~i ~~.rs~.~,~t ~G~ Fed. .. ~~~~1. Q (~~ ~.~c~ ( ~. ,~ t~ x+~~p~ t t

t~i~ ~~aterr~en.~~ ~►f l~r
7
E~~

~~l~phc~~.~

i~nr n r~~car~.ec~ ire o

bit 4 (~ ~~e~~ axe ~.~~~:x~.t~ tran~~ri~'~~~r~~ ~►f the
~

~s~a., ~ l~~ l~~ Mr ~i r~~.g +an ~Tover~a.b~r ~, 2 Q~, ~.n.d iii) x.11 p~.r~~~~ r~~~~~~ t~.~ r

ri hits a~ ~~ the a~.~n.~ssi~n ire e~ ~.en~~ ~f 1"~Ir. S mr n 's ~t~.t~r~~nt~ ix~ ~ ~.~~~t ~ a~ non-~~ar~~.Y ar ~n
~~~~~at~c~r~ ta► t~.~ ~~~.r~ay r~~~, ar~~ t~ t~:~ ~~~~va~.c~ cif the ~v~d.+e~.~~, ~v~i~~. ar+~ r~~~rv~~. fir la~~r
de~~rr~.~n~.t+~n ~~ ~h~ ~QU.rt,

l~
l
1

+~.

Thy doc~.n~:ent ~.ttache~. her~t~ ~.~ ~~~:~~~~ S ~.nd r~a~ :~c~ a~ I~►~p~~iti~►n ~ ~. b t

~~l (~~a~h~ 6) aid rr~.~.r~+~~: with ~at~~ I~T~.11/~W lQ~~- ~ ~~ ~.drr~: ~~ibl~ ~.~ ~. ~a~~~n~~~ r~~~r

~,

ursu:an~ to Fed..I. E~i~l 8~~ ~~ ~n~. ~~ to ~~:ov~ v~hat l~Ir.11~I~~lr~ r~~~~~~~d f~r+~
~
~

~

Tav~b r ~ ~ ~~~~. ~T~thin., ~n th~~ ~t~~u:l~.t~~r~ ~~ ~~.t~~.d~~. t~. ~~~v~ any ~~l~~ a. ~ ~b~ ~~t~~► : ~.~ ~~
,

-,

'.

R

~i~ ~~r~~ ~ ~►n

~~

the ~.~~is~~b~lity of E~l~ib~t ~ and the parties ~ti~u~~.t~ t~~.t those ~►bj~~t~on~ ar~~ r~s~rv~~ for ~at~~

~

+d~t~r .ina~t~~n b~' the ou.~t.

l'9

I

2Q
1

.,

~',

Thy +~o~uxne~.t ~.tt~ ~l~~~. ~.ereta .s ~~h~b~~ G ~.r~d r~~.rl~ed a:~ ~►~pa~~t~a~~. ~~~~~~t

f ~ ~I~~a~~:~' 7 and. a,rk~c~ ~i~~i Bate I~To. l~✓IV~ Q:~~~~-~~~~ i ~.~. issibl~ a~ ~. ~u ~~.~~~ ~~ c~r~.

~~

~~11~~4~~~+ ~~r,/ 1 4/'\. e
~'

~~

U~~~n~ber

~

J:J Y ~~rrk•

~~~

~~~ ~~4F ~~~ ~V

47.1.141. YY

~V~~~

~s ~~/-~-..I~1~

~1rlV\✓~~~!~ ~~4~J,+L~- ~~~~~ J ~'1M~~rf~ ~~

i

~~

QQ~6. Ncat~~~: i~ th s,~t p~l~.t ~n i~ nter~d~~. ~t~ ~va~v~e any ~~l~van~~ a~'~~~~c~n ~.~ t
J

..
t~:~ ~.dr~.~~~~la~l~ty of ~ ~:~b~t ~ ~~d. t :~ pa~rti~s ~t~pulat~ t~:at th~s~ ~l~j~ct~~ ~ art r~~~~v~~. ~~r l~.t~r
~.~t~rn~:i~~,tio~. y ~h:e ~ur~.

2

~TIPUL.,~TIQI~t
~~21.9'7.1

l

T~.~ d~cu.~►:~nt atta~h+~d h~ret~ ~s ~~~~t ~ l ~d rn~r~~~. ~.~ I~~p~c~~ti~►~.

~~.ibit ~~~ ~.~~. r:~~~r~~. v~it~i 8~.~~~ 1`~~..l'~' ~~~ ~v~.~ r~~~~v~d ~ay

~, ~I~~~r~~ ~►~. ~'~Tc~v~b r ~

ar ~1 ~QQ~.
4
1~,
,-

T~.~ ~lo~um~.t a~~~a~~ie~. h~r~tc~ as E~hil~t 1 ~.r~~ rn~.rl~~~. a.s ~~pQ~ti~~.

~hibit ~ ~ ~ ~a~ ~e~t 1~ 1V.~r. l~I~~l~c~~ to l~Ir. +~~ur~ ~n 1'~Qv~rr~~a~r 1~ ~Q~+~ ~ ~.~~ ~s a~. ~.~~ur~.t~e
~_q~

/~f
qm~s
yy~q
~/~~+
r~yTM
~~.r~~~i►.i ~.1 ~~~~~✓#..l.l~/~~~ J.-~-1~~V ~~ 1~M.LJ.. ~~~~1V~ ~~:1~

9

y.

q~~r

.i . ~1►ll,l\.~11~ ~.~.1 1~1 Q~1►/~~l.~.t ~ 1 9 ~~~~ ~il

a~.n~is~~la~e ~:s ~. ~au~~n~~s rec~►x~. p~u~~ua~t t~ ~'~~.. R, Ev~d:: ~Q (~j ~.nd ~~~.

lU
~1

.;

I~AT~~: ~a~u~.ry 14, 2Q ~ 3

LE~.~H ~'U~ER: ~,~,F

12
l
~4
1S

By:
~~

. ~_.

.~

~_

!

_

I,a~ gaup

_ ..

17

//
//

~9

T~~.TEI~ Janu~.ry 1~4, ~Ql

~C1I~~~T~Q►~. EIEI~'.~A~T .~.~J.
~EI~L_ ~'~~II~ ►~ CI F

~~

~y:

~~

R NIA

Spero
seph C.

NO

Dated: 1/16/13

ERED

Judge Jo

RT

A

H

ER

FO

2

O ORD
IT IS S

N

F
D IS T IC T O
R

C

STI~UL~TIQll`~11
-~~219'7.1

/~f l~I~h~~~ D~~r~~.i

1VI~l~~.~l ~. ~ev~a~rk~, ~sq, ~prc~ ~,a~ ~i~~~
J~.~~~.~~ine Vii. Veit, ~~~. ~p~'~ hac vise)
A.11~~c~r~ ~, .~:lb~rt~ ~~c~. ~ar~ a~ vi~~~
~.tt~.eys f4~ ~~~intf~ r+~r~.~d A. I~IeH~I~ Jr.,
PRA►. ~ ~. ~ ~.u%~:~.t o~: ~'xus~~~ for the 1~~ ~
I~~b~tor ~qu~~.a.~o~: T'r~~t

LI

~~

ISTRIC
ES D
TC
AT
T

RT
U
O

S

~~
UNIT
ED

i

/~l ~~br~: ~t~:rr
J~ro.e 1~T. I~~r~i, Eq.
~~1~~~. t~el ttakr~r~.~~r, Eq.

C