Be In, Inc. v. Google Inc. et al

Filing 72

TRANSCRIPT ORDER by GOOGLE UK LTD., Google Inc., YouTube, LLC for Court Reporter Lee-Anne Shortridge. (Bal, Colleen) (Filed on 8/19/2013)

" 6F=A=B4@
4
" 6=J=@

" 4DD84@
" BCB%4DD84@

/& 6CIFH F8DCFH8F B4A8 " 9CF 9HF$ @84J8 5@4B? 4B7 6<86? 5CL#" " 9HF

Lee-Anne Shortridge

"V[VaVNY`#

>I7;8

HMD8
"R&T& 6A6#

DCFH=CB
=S _R^bR`aV[T YR`` aUN[ SbYY URN_V[T$
`]RPVSf ]\_aV\[ "R&T& dVa[R`` \_ aVZR#

<84F=B;"G# "CF DCFH=CBG C9 <84F=B;G#

O&
H8LH'4G6==
"RZNVY#

m
!

!
!
!
!
!

D79
"RZNVY#

m
!

!
!
!
!
!

!

D4D8F

LHK

CMC

),%7Nf

"/%QNf#

8LD87=H87

!

!

!

!

!

7=GHF=5IH=CB2

/s/ Colleen Bal
" 6CIFH 6CDM

" HF4BG6F=DH=CB 6CDM

<CIF@M
"* U_`#

" CF78F 6CDM

74=@M
"BRea QNf#

08/19/2013

!

!

!

!

!

" CF78F F868=DH

"+(%QNf#

CF7=B4FM

))& G=;B4HIF8

!

!

!

!

!

!

869 4668GG
"dRO#

P&

CF78F ! 68FH=9=64H=CB "))& ! )*&# 5f `VT[V[T ORY\d$ = PR_aVSf aUNa = dVYY ]Nf NYY PUN_TR` "QR]\`Va ]Yb` NQQVaV\[NY#&

)(& 477=H=CB4@ 6CAA8BHG$ =BGHFI6H=CBG$ EI8GH=CBG$ 8H62

8/14/13

!

6CB78BG87
"RZNVY#

G8@86H 9CFA4H"G# "/02+' +), 3446BB ;B ;>4<D565
F;C9 @DA493B6 ?7 1*," C6GC" @3@6A ?A 4?>56>B65$!

78@=J8FM HMD8 " 6U\\`R \[R ]R_ YV[R#

" 6>42 7\ [\a b`R aUV` S\_Z3 b`R 9\_Z 6>4*,

)*& 74H8

N&

5:12-cv-03373

.& 64G8 BIA58F

F84@H=A8

" =[ S\_ZN ]Nb]R_V` "BCH82 6\b_a \_QR_ S\_ a_N[`P_V]a` Zb`a OR NaaNPURQ#

[e-mail]

+#& 4HHCFB8M 8A4=@ 477F8GG

1& HF4BG6F=DH"G# F8EI8GH87 "G]RPVSf ]\_aV\["`# N[Q QNaR"`# \S ]_\PRRQV[T"`# S\_ dUVPU a_N[`P_V]a V` _R^bR`aRQ#$ S\_ZNa"`# ! ^bN[aVaf N[Q QRYVcR_f af]R2

0& H<=G HF4BG6F=DH CF78F =G 9CF2

6CIFH IG8 CB@M

[e-mail]

+"& 6CBH46H 8A4=@ 477F8GG

Be In, Inc. v. Google Inc., et al.

-& 64G8 B4A8

[phone]

*O& 4HHCFB8M D<CB8 BIA58F

[phone]

*N& 6CBH46H D<CB8 BIA58F

1<63B6 A635 ;>BCAD4C;?>B ?> >6GC @386$

$

Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati
650 Page Mill Road
Palo Alto, CA 94304

,& A4=@=B; 477F8GG "=B6@I78 @4K 9=FA B4A8$ =9 4DD@=645@8#

Colleen Bal

)O& 4HHCFB8M B4A8 "VS QVSSR_R[a#

Kathie Ramos

)N& 6CBH46H D8FGCB 9CF H<=G CF78F

"64B7 FRc& 7'*()+#

64B7 ,+-

IB=H87 GH4H8G 7=GHF=6H 6CIFH
BCFH<8FB 7=GHF=6H C9 64@=9CFB=4

Clear Form

=aRZ ))&
=aRZ )*&

=aRZ 1P&

aRZ 1O&

=aRZ 1N&

=aRZ 0&

=aRZ` -%.&
=aRZ /&

=aRZ` )%+

# +( PNYR[QN_ QNf`&
# ), PNYR[QN_ QNf`&
# / PNYR[QN_ QNf`&
# 9\YY\dV[T NQW\b_[ZR[a N[Q ]_V\_ a\ aUR [\_ZNY \]R[V[T U\b_ \S aUR P\b_a \[ aUR S\YY\dV[T Z\_[V[T dURaUR_ \_ [\a Va NPabNYYf V` N P\b_a QNf&
# dVaUV[ ad\ "*# U\b_`&
# 4 Q_NSa b[RQVaRQ$ b[PR_aVSVRQ a_N[`P_V]a ]_\QbPRQ Of N PR_aVSVRQ _RNYaVZR _R]\_aR_ N` N Of]_\QbPa \S _RNYaVZR a\ OR QRYVcR_RQ RYRPa_\[VPNYYf Qb_V[T
]_\PRRQV[T` \_ VZZRQVNaRYf S\YY\dV[T NQW\b_[ZR[a&
GVT[ V[ aUV` `]NPR a\ PR_aVSf aUNa f\b dVYY ]Nf NYY PUN_TR` "aUR QR]\`Va ]Yb` N[f NQQVaV\[NY PUN_TR`&# 4[ RYRPa_\[VP \_ P\[S\_ZRQ "'`'# `VT[Nab_R V` NPPR]aNOYR&
8[aR_ aUR QNaR \S `VT[V[T aUR \_QR_ N[Q PR_aVSVPNaV\[&

=[ SVRYQ` )N$ *N ! +N$ ]YRN`R ]_\cVQR aUR P\[aNPa [NZR N[Q V[S\_ZNaV\[ S\_ aUR ]R_`\[ _R`]\[`VOYR S\_ \_QR_V[T aUR a_N[`P_V]a& =[ N YNd \SSVPR$ aUV` V` b`bNYYf N
]N_NYRTNY \_ NQZV[V`a_NaVcR N``V`aN[a$ [\a aUR Naa\_[Rf& =[ SVRYQ` )O$ *O ! +O$ ]_\cVQR aUR Naa\_[Rf [NZR N[Q P\[aNPa V[S\$ VS aUR Naa\_[Rf V` [\a aUR P\[aNPa ]R_`\[&
C[Yf \[R PN`R [bZOR_ ZNf OR YV`aRQ ]R_ \_QR_&
JV`Va PN[Q&b`P\b_a`&T\c'a_N[`P_V]a` S\_ V[`a_bPaV\[` S\_ QRaR_ZV[V[T aUR [NZR \S aUR P\b_a _R]\_aR_ dU\ _R]\_aRQ aUR ]_\PRRQV[T \_ VS aUR ]_\PRRQV[T dN`
NbQV\_RP\_QRQ& =S ZV[baR` UNcR [\a ORR[ SVYRQ$ P\[aNPa WbQTRh` P\b_a_\\Z QR]baf&
6URPX N]]RNY CF [\[%N]]RNY 4B7 P_VZV[NY CF PVcVY&
2 N P\b_a \_QR_ `]RPVSVPNYYf NbaU\_VgV[T a_N[`P_V]a` V` _R^bV_RQ ORS\_R a_N[`P_V]a` ZNf OR
\_QR_RQ ;> 7?A=3 @3D@6A;B&
@V`a `]RPVSVP QNaR"`# \S aUR ]_\PRRQV[T` S\_ dUVPU a_N[`P_V]a V` _R^bR`aRQ& 4 a_N[`P_V]a \S \[Yf N ]\_aV\[ \S N ]_\PRRQV[T ZNf OR \_QR_RQ$ VS aUR QR`P_V]aV\[ V` PYRN_Yf
d_VaaR[ a\ SNPVYVaNaR ]_\PR``V[T& I[QR_ iaf]R$j V[QVPNaR O_VRSYf dUNa af]R \S ]_\PRRQV[T Va dN`$ `bPU N` iZ\aV\[$j i`R[aR[PV[T$j \_ i6A6&j
GRYRPa QR`V_RQ
S\_ a_N[`P_V]a& HUR_R V` N[ NQQVaV\[NY PUN_TR S\_ RNPU S\_ZNa \_QR_RQ& JV`Va PN[Q&b`P\b_a`&T\c'a_N[`P_V]a_NaR` S\_ QRaNVY`& I[Y\PX 869'dRO
NPPR`` V` V[PYbQRQ Na [\ Rea_N PUN_TR dVaU RNPU \S aUR \aUR_ S\_ZNa`&
HUR_R N_R .
a\ PU\\`R S_\Z "aVZR` N_R P\Z]baRQ S_\Z QNaR \S _RPRV]a \S aUR QR]\`Va SRR \_ 76B [bZOR_#&
2 9bYY ]_VPR ZNf OR PUN_TRQ \[Yf VS
aUR a_N[`P_V]a V` QRYVcR_RQ dVaUV[ aUR _R^bV_RQ aVZR S_NZR& 9\_ ReNZ]YR$ VS N[ \_QR_ S\_ Re]RQVaRQ a_N[`P_V]a V` [\a P\Z]YRaRQ N[Q QRYVcR_RQ dVaUV[ / PNYR[QN_ QNf`$
aUR ),%QNf 56<;E6AH _NaR d\bYQ OR PUN_TRQ&

I`R aUV` S\_Z a\ \_QR_ aUR a_N[`P_V]aV\[ \S ]_\PRRQV[T`&
5RS\_R P\Z]YRaV[T aUV` S\_Z$ ]YRN`R cV`Va PN[Q&b`P\b_a`&T\c'a_N[`P_V]a` S\_ P\Z]YRaR
a_N[`P_V]a \_QR_V[T V[S\_ZNaV\[&
)&
6\Z]YRaR N `R]N_NaR \_QR_ S\_Z S\_ RNPU PN`R [bZOR_ S\_ dUVPU a_N[`P_V]a` N_R \_QR_RQ&
*&
6\Z]YRaR N `R]N_NaR \_QR_ S\_Z S\_ RNPU P\b_a _R]\_aR_ dU\ _R]\_aRQ ]_\PRRQV[T` V[ aUR PN`R&
+&
6\Z]YRaR =aRZ` )%)*& ?RR] N P\]f \S f\b_ P\Z]YRaRQ \_QR_ S\_Z S\_ f\b_ _RP\_Q`&
,&
8%SVYR aUV` S\_Z V[ aUR I&G& 7V`a_VPa 6\b_a 6A'869 `f`aRZ&
2 "N# `RNYRQ PN`R`']_\PRRQV[T`3 "O# [\[%]N_aVR`3 "P# ]_\ `R ]N_aVR` dU\ N_R [\a R%SVYR_`&
=[ `bPU PN`R`$ ZNVY \_ UN[Q%QRYVcR_ N UN_Q P\]f NQQ_R``RQ a\ aUR P\b_a _R]\_aR_ P'\ aUR 6YR_Xh` CSSVPR Na aUR 6\b_a QVcV`V\[ dUR_R aUR ]_\PRRQV[T dN` URYQ&
-&
8ZNVY aUR P\b_a _R]\_aR_ "RZNVY YV`a NcNVYNOYR Na PN[Q&b`P\b_a`&T\c'P\b_a_R]\_aR_P\[aNPa# ]_\Z]aYf NSaR_ aUV` H_N[`P_V]a C_QR_ 9\_Z V` R%SVYRQ a\ \OaNV[ aUR NZ\b[a \S
aUR _R^bV_RQ QR]\`Va 7RYVcR_ ]NfZR[a a\ aUR P\b_a _R]\_aR_ ]_\Z]aYf& I]\[ _RPRV]a \S aUR QR]\`Va$ aUR P\b_a _R]\_aR_ dVYY ORTV[ d\_X \[ aUR a_N[`P_V]a&
"N# \_QR_` S\_ 9HF a_N[`P_V]a` N[Q "O# QNVYf a_VNY a_N[`P_V]a \_QR_`&
.&
I[YR`` ]_R]NfZR[a V` dNVcRQ$ QRYVcR_f aVZR V` P\Z]baRQ S_\Z aUR QNaR aUR P\b_a _R]\_aR_ _RPRVcR` aUR QR]\`Va$ NbaU\_VgRQ 6>4 *, 9\_Z$ NbaU\_VgNaV\[ S_\Z 9RQR_NY
DbOYVP 7RSR[QR_h` CSSVPR \_$ S\_ a_N[`P_V]a` \_QR_RQ Of aUR I&G& T\cR_[ZR[a$ S_\Z aUR QNaR \S _RPRV]a \S aUR 76B [bZOR_&
/&
HUR QR]\`Va SRR V` N[ R`aVZNaR& 4[f \cR_NTR dVYY OR _RSb[QRQ3 N[f `U\_aNTR dVYY OR QbR S_\Z f\b&

64B7 ,+"FRc& (.')+#