Bank of New York Mellon v. City of Richmond, California et al

Filing 64

NOTICE OF APPEAL to the 9th CCA Bank of New York Mellon, Bank of New York Mellon Trust Company, N.A.. Appeal of Judgment 54 (Appeal fee FEE NOT PAID.) Joint Notice of Appeal (Pollock, Bronwyn) (Filed on 12/9/2013)

I
2

b

MAYER BROWN LLP
DONALD M. FALK (SBN 1s02s6)
[e-mail]
Two Palo Alto Square, Suite 300
3000 El Camino Real
Palo Alto, CA 94306-2112
Tel: [phone]
Fax: [phone]

J

4
5

6

l
8

BRONWYN F. POLLOCK (SBN 210912)
bp

o

ll o c k@may erbr ow n. c o m

MTCHAEL D. SHAPTRO (SBN 27t912)
erbr own. c om
350 S. Grand Ave,, 25th Floor
Los Angeles, CA 90071-1503
Tel: [phone]
Fax:[phone]
ms hap ir o @m ay

9
10

l1
12

Attorneys for Plaintiffs
THE BANK OF NEV/ YORK MELLON
(flkla The Bank of New York) and
THE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON TRUST
COMPANY, N.A. (flk/a The Bank ofNew York Trust
Company, N.A.) as Trustees for the Trusts listed on
Attachment A

13

I4

fAdditional counsel listed on signature pages.]

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

15

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

t6
t7

THE BANK OF NEV/ YORK MELLON (flkla
The Bank of New York) et al.,

18

Plaintiffs,

t9

Case No. 3: I 3-cv-3664-CRB

JOINT NOTICE OF APPEAL
Honorable Charles R. Breyer

V

20
21

22
23

CITY OF RICHMOND, CALIFORNIA, A
municipality; RICHMOND CITY COUNCIL;
MORTGAGE RES OLUTION PARTNERS
L.L.C., a Delaware limited liability company;
and GORDIAN SV/ORD LLC, a Delaware
limited liability company,

24

Defendants
25

26
27
28
JOINT NOTICE OF APPEAL; CASE NO. l3-cv-3664-CRB

I

Notice is hereby given that Plaintiffs The Bank of New York Mellon (f/k/a The Bank of

2

New York); The Bank of New York Mellon Trust Company, N.A. (f/k/a The Bank of New York

ô

J

Trust Company, N.A.); U.S. Bank National Association; V/ilmington Trust Company; and

4

V/ilmington Trust, National Association, each in their respective capacity as Trustees for the

5

Trusts listed on Attachments A, B, and C, hereby appeal to the United States Court of Appeals

6

for the Ninth Circuit from the final judgment entered in this action on the eighth day of

7

November 2013.

8

Dated: December 9,2013

Respectfully submitted,

9

MAYER BROWN LLP
DONALD M. FALK
BRONV/YN F. POLLOCK
MICHAEL D. SHAPIRO

10

1l

t2
By: /s/ Bronwvn F. Pollock
Bronwyn F. Pollock
Attomeys for Plaintifß
THE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON
(f/k/a The Bank of New York) and
THE BANK OF NEW YORK MELLON TRUST
COMPANY, N.A.(f/k/a The Bank of New York
Trust Company, N.A.), as Trustees for the Trusts
listed on Attachment A

13

l4
15
T6

t7
18
19

20

2l
22
23

24
25

26
27

Dated: December 9,2013

JONES DAY
BRrAN D. HERSHMAN (SBN 168175)
bhers hman@j ones day. com
555 South Flower Street, 50th Floor
Los Angeles, CA 90071-2300
Tel: [phone]
Fax: [phone]
JONES DAY
MATTHEW A. MARTEL

(pro hac vice)
[e-mail]
JOSEPH B. SCONYERS
(pro hac vice)

j s c o ny ers @j on es day. c o m

100 High Street, 21st Floor
Boston, MA 02110
Telephone: 6ll -960-3939
Facsimile: 617 -449-6999

28
JOINT NOTICE OF APPEAL; CASE NO. l3-cv-3664-CRB

By: /s/ Brian D. Hershman
Brian D. Hershman
Attomeys for Plaintiff
U.S. BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION,
as Trustee for the Trusts listed on Attachment B

1

2
J

4

Dated: December 9,2013
5

ALSTON & BIRD LLP
KURT OSENBAUGH (SBN 106132)
kur

6

t. o s enb

qugh@als

to n.

c

om

wHrrNEY CHELGREN (SBN 28s362)
c om
333 South Hope Street, Sixteenth Floor
Los Angeles, Californi a 9007 I
Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: 213-576-1100

w hitn ey. chel gr en@als to n.

7
8

9

l0

ll
12
13

By: /s/ Kurt Osenbaush
Kurt Osenbaugh
Attorneys for Plaintiff
V/ILMINGTON TRUST COMPANY and
WILMINGTON TRUST, NATIONAL
ASSOCIATION, as Trustees for the Trusts listed
on Attachment C

14
15

16

1l
18
T9

20

2t
22
23

24
25

26
27
28
2
JOINT NOTICE OF APPEAL; CASE NO. I3-cv-3664-CRB

1

2
J

SIGNATURE ATTESTATION
I, Bronwlm F. Pollock, attest that the concurrence in the filing of this Joint Notice of
Appeal has been obtained from Brian D. Hershman and Kurt Osenbaugh.

4
5

6
7
8

9

By: /s/ Bronwvn F. Pollock
Bronwyn F. Pollock
Attorneys for Plaintiffs
THE BANK OF NEV/ YORK MELLON
(flk/a The Bank of New York) and THE BANK
OF NEV/ YORK MELLON TRUST
COMPANY, N.A. (flWa The Bank ofNew York
Trust Company, N.A.), as Trustees for the Trusts
listed on Attachment A

l0
l1
12
13

I4
15

16
17
18
19

20

2l
22
23

24
25
26
27
28
J
JOINT NOTICE OF APPEAL; CASE NO. l3-cv-3664-CRB

REPRE SBNTATION STATEMENT

1

2

Pursuant

to

Fed. R. App. P. 12(b) and Circuit Rule 3-2, this representation statement

J

identifies all parties to the action along with the names, addresses, and telephone numbers of

4

their respective counsel.

5

6
7
8

9

MAYER BRO\ryN LLP
DONALD M. FALK

The Bank of New York Mellon (f/k/a The
Bank of New York), as Trustee for the Trusts
listed on Attachment A

10

The Bank of New York Mellon Trust

ll

Company, N.A. (f/k/a The Bank of New York
Trust Company, N.A.), as Trustee for the

12

[e-mail]
Two Palo Alto Square, Suite 300
3000 El Camino Real
Palo Alto, CA 94306-2112
Tel: [phone]
Fax: [phone]

Trusts listed on Attachment A

MAYER BROWN LLP
BRONV/YN F. POLLOCK

13

bp o I lo

c

k@may erbr own. c om

MICHAEL D. SHAPIRO

14

com

Floor

3s0
Los
Tel:
Fax: [phone]

15

16

1

503

17

l8

JONES DAY
BRIAN D. HERSHMAN

U.S. Bank National Association, as Trustee
for the Trusts listed on Attachment B

bh

er s hm an @j o n e s d ay.

co

m

555 South Flower Street, 50th Floor
Los Angeles, CA 90071-2300
Tel: [phone]
Fax:[phone]

19

20

2t

JONES DAY

MATTHEV/ A. MARTEL

22

[e-mail]
JOSEPH B. SCONYERS

23

j s c o ny ers @j o n es d ay. c o m
100 High Street, 2lst Floor
Boston, MA 02110

24

Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile : 617 - 449 -6999

25
26
27
28
4

JOINT NOTICE OF APPEAL; CASE NO. l3-cv-3664-CRB

1

2
J

\üilmington Trust Company, as Trustee for ALSTON & BIRD LLP
MICHAEL E. JOHNSON
the Trusts listed on Attachment C
mi ch ael j o hns o n@al s to n. c om
Wilmington Trust, National Association, as 90 Park Avenue 10016
New York, NY
Trustee for the Trusts listed on Attachment C

Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: 212-210-9444

4

ALSTON & BIRD LLP
KURT OSENBAUGH

5

kurt.

6

os

enb augh@øls ton.

co

m

WHITNEY CHELGREN
whi tney. c helgr en@als ton. c om

1

333 South Hope Street, Sixteenth Floor
Los Angeles, California 9007 I
Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: 213-576-1100

8

9
10
11

I2

ALTSHULER BERZON LLP
STEPHEN P. BERZON
SCOTT A. KRONLAND
STACEY M. LEYTON
ERIC P. BROWN

City of Richmond, California
Richmond City Council

13

I4

[e-mail]
177 Post Street, Suite 300
San Francisco, CA 94108
Telephone: [phone]l
Facsimile: 415-362-8064

15

I6
I7

RICHMOND CITY ATTORNEY'S OFFICE
BRUCE R. GOODMILLER
CARLOS A. PRIVAT

18

t9

bru

ce

3o o dmill er @ci. ri c hm on d. c a. us

City of Richmond
450 Civic Center Plaza
Richmond, CA 94804

20

2t

Telephone:

5I

0-620-6509

Facsimile: 510-620-65

22

1

8

23

24
25

26
27
28
5
JOINT NOTICE OF APPEAL; CASE NO. l3-cv-3664-CRB

1

2

ALTSHULER BERZON LLP
STEPHEN P. BERZON
SCOTT A. KRONLAND
STACEY M. LEYTON
ERIC P. BROWN

Mortgage Resolution Partners L.L.C.
Gordian Sword LLC

J

6

[e-mail]
177 Post Street, Suite 300
San Francisco, CA 94108
Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: 415-362-8064

l

WILLIAM A. FALIK

4
5

[e-mail]
100 Tunnel Rd.
Berkeley, CA94705
Telephone: 5 I 0-540-5960
Facsimile: 5 10-704-8803

8

9

l0
l1

t2
13

14
15
16

t7
18

l9
20

2l
22
23

24
25

26
27
28
6
JOINT NOTICE OF APPEAL; CASE NO. I3-cv-3664-CRB

Ãttachment A

Trusts For Which The Bank of New York Mellon . flkla The Bank of New York. is Trustee:
CHASE 2006-52

29

CV/ALT 2006-0A2I

57

cwl-

2

CV/ALT 2OO4-14T2
J CV/ALT 2OO4-2OTI
4 CWALT 2OO5-I1CB

30

CWL 2OO4-ECCl

31

cwALT 2006-OC10
cwALT 2006-OC8
CV/ALT 2OO]-IITI

58

a

59

cv/L
cv/L

5

cwALT 200s-16

33

6I

6

CV/ALT 2OO5-2OCB

34

7

cwALT

35

8

CV/ALT 2OO5-3CB

36

9

cwALT 2005-43
cwALT 2005-51
cwALT 200s-56
cwALT 2005-58
cv/ALT 2005-62
cv/ALT 2005-63
cwALT 2005-71
cv/ALT 2005-76

37

CWALT 2OO7-I6CB
CWALT 2OO7.17CB
CWALT 2OO7-4CB
CWALT 2OO7-8CB
CWALT 2OO7-HY4

38

cv/ALT

2007 -OH2

66

39

CV/ALT 2OO7-OH3

67

40

68

CWALT 2OO6-33C8
CV/ALT 2006-39C8

45

46

cwHL 2004-7
cwHL 2005-31
cwHL 2005-9
cwHL 2006-16
cwHL 2006-19
cwHL 2006-20
cwHL 2006-9

47
48

1

1

0

11

I2
1

J

14
1

5

1

6

Il
I8

32

200s-27

4I
42
43
44

I 9 cv/ALT 2006-42
20 CWALT 2OO6-43C8
2 I CWALT 2OO6-6CB
22 CWALT 2OO6-HY1O
23 CV/ALT 2OO6-HY13
24 CV/ALT 2006-0AI
25 CV/ALT 2006-0A1O
26 CV/ALT 2006-01-12
27 CWALT 2006-0A17
28 CV/ALT 2006-0A2

Trusts For which the
New Y
I
2

49
50
51

52
53

54
55
56

60
62
63

64
65

2004-BC4
2005-17
2005-3

cwl. 2005-4
cwl- 2005-AB4
cwl- 2005-ABs
cv/L 2006-13
cwl- 2006-14
cv/L 2006-16

cwl, 2006-18
cwl- 2006-19

73

cv/L 2006-20
cv/L 2006-22
cwl- 2006-24
cwl- 2006-26
cwl- 2006-3

74

CV/L 2OO6-BC4

CWHL 2OO6-HYBl

75

cwHL 2007-11
cv/HL 2007-12
cv/HL 2007-15
cwHL 2001-2
cwHL 2007-1

76

cv/L 2007-13
cwl- 2001-3
cwl- 2007-s
cwl- 2007-7
cwl- 2007-8
cwl- 2007 -BC3

CV/HL 2OO7-HY6
CWHL 2OO7-HYBl

81

cwlcwl-

83

2003-5

69
70
71

12

77
78

l9
80
82

FHAMS 2OO5-FA9
FHAMS 2006-AA4
FHAMS 2OO6-FA4

2004-14

of New York Mellon Trust Company. N.4.. f/k/a The Bank of
v. N.4.. is Trustee:
CHASE 2OO1-41
CHASE 2OO1-54

Ãttachment B

Trusts For Which U.S. Bank National Association is Trustee:
41

csMc

42
43

FFMLT
FFMLT

4

ABSC 2004-HE5
ABSC 2OO4-HEIO
ABSC 2006-HE5 OOMC
ACE OI-HEl

44

GPMF 2OO6-AR6

84

5

AHMIT 2005-4

45

85

6

Ameriquest 2001-2
BAFC 2006-2

46

GPMF 2OO6-AR7
GPMF 2OO7-ARI

87

BAFC 2006-A
BAFC 2OO6-D
BAFC 2OO6-G
BAFC 2OO6-J
BAFC 2OO7-C

48

89

50

GSAA 2006-3
GSAA 2006-12
GSAA 2OO7-I
GSAA 2OO1-3

MASTR ABS Trust 2004-ÌVMC1
MASTR ABS 2OO5-HEI
MASTR ABS 2OO5-HE2
MASTR 2OO6-NC2
MLMI2OO5-49
MLMI2OO6-SLI
RALr 2006-QO2
RALr 2006-Q52
RAMP 2OO5-EFC5

90

RASC 2OO6.KS5

5l

GSR 2OO5-9F

9l

52

GSR 2OO5-AR1

92

RASC 2OO5-KSI I
RFMSI2OO5-S5

GSR 2OO5-AR7

93

RFMSI2006-5A1

54

GSR 2OO6-2F

94

BNC 2007-1
BNC 2007-2
BSABS 2OO4-FRI
BSABS 2OO4-HEI
BSABS 2OO4-HE5
BSABS 2OO6-IMI

55

GSR 2OO7-IF
GSR 2OO7-4F
GSR 2OO7-5F

95

RFMSI2OOT-S8
SACO 12005-V/Ml
SAIL 2005.7

98

Chew Chase 2005-C
Chew Chase 2006-2
CMALT 2OO7-A].
CMALT 2OO7.A3
CMALT 2007-A6

6l

CMLTI2OO5-8
CMLTI2OO6-ARI
CMLTI2OO6-HE3
CMLTI2OO6-ÌVF1
CMLTI2OO6-WF2

66

HarborView 2005-l
FlarborView 2005-2
HarborView 2005-16
HarborView 2006-1
HarborView 2006-4
JPMAC 2OO5-OPTI
JPMAC 2OO5-OPT2
JPMAC 2OO6-CH2
Luminent 2005-1

CMLTì

I
2
3

7

I
9

l0
l1
12

l3
74

l5
16
17
18

2t
22
24
25
26
.,,1

28

29
30

3t
32

BART 2OO5-5
BAYVIEW 2OO6-C

2OO7-IO

CMLTI2OOT-AR8

47
49

56
57
58
59
60
62

2007-4

82

2OO6-FF14

83

99
100
101

t02
103

r04

SAIL 20O6-3
SAIL 2OO6-BNC3
SARM 2OO5-9
SARM 2OO5-I9XS
SARM 2005-22
SARM 2005-23
SARM 2OO7-8

sASCO 2006-V/I'3

108
110

1l

LXS 2OO6-4N
LXS 2006-l6N

72

LXS

2OO6-GP3

n2

SASCO 2OO7-BC3
SASCO 2OO'7-BC4
SASCO 2OO7-BNCI
sASCO 2007-WF2
TMST 2006-4

IJ

LXS 2007-l5N
LXS 2007-l6N

113

l

u8

68
69

70

36

CSFB MBS 2OO3-4R28

76

37

CS}'B MBS 2OO4-AR7
CSFB MBS 2OO5-2
CSFBMSC HEAT 2OO7-2
CSMC 2006.I

77
78

LXS 2OO7-7N

't9

MARM 200't-l

80

MARM

39

97

t07

LXS 2007-l8N
LXS 2OO7-2N
LXS 2OO7-4N

40

96

LXS 2OO5.5N
LXS 2OO5-7N
LXS 2OO5-9N

67

74

38

88

106

35

34

86

SASCO 2OO6-BC2
SASCO 2()O6-NCI
SASCO 20O6-V/F2

65

CSFB 2OO5-4
CSFB HEAT 2OO5-8
CSFB MBS 2002-26

JJ

8l

2OO6-FF2

75

2OO7-3

105

109

ll1
114
15

116

tIl

TMST 2OO6-5
Terwin Mortgage Tl'trst 2004-l6SL
Terwìn Mortgage Trust 2004-l8SL
WFMBS 2006-2
WFMBS 2OO6-AR1
V/FMBS 2OO6.AR2

Attachment C

Trusts For'Which'Wilminston Trust Companv is Trustee:
I

SASCO 2OO5-4XS

2

Morgan Stanley Mortgage Loan Trust 2007-154R

I
2
J

4
5

6
7

SASCO 200s-10
Lehman XS 2005-08
Lehman XS 2006-17

SAMI II 2OO7-AR5
BSALTA 2006.7
BSARM 2OO7-2
BSARM 2007.4