Surgical Instrument Service Company, Inc. v. Intuitive Surgical, Inc.

Filing 205

OMNIBUS SEALING ORDER. Signed by Judge Araceli Martinez-Olguin on April 1, 2024. (amolc3, COURT STAFF) (Filed on 4/1/2024)

1
2
3
4

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

5

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

6
7

SURGICAL INSTRUMENT SERVICE
COMPANY, INC., et al.,

8

Plaintiffs,

9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11

Case No. 21-cv-03496-AMO
OMNIBUS ORDER RE: SEALING

v.
INTUITIVE SURGICAL, INC.,
Defendant.

12
13

Before the Court are the Parties’ and Third-Parties’ Administrative Motions to Seal,

14

Motions to Consider Sealing Third-Party Materials, Statements in Support of Sealing,

15

Declarations in Support of Sealing, and associated exhibits, at ECF 122, 123, 124, 125, 130, 133,

16

136, 138, 149, 150, 151, 152, 153, 154, 155, 161, 171, 173, 178. The Court, having carefully

17

considered the submissions, the record, the applicable law, and any arguments related thereto,

18

hereby orders that the Administrative Motions are GRANTED in part and DENIED in part.
LEGAL STANDARD

19
20

Pursuant to Civil Local Rule 79-5, the party seeking to file a document or portions of it

21

under seal must explain “(i) the legitimate private or public interests that warrant sealing; (ii) the

22

injury that will result if sealing is denied; and (iii) why a less restrictive alternative to sealing is

23

not sufficient.” Civil L.R. 79-5(c)(1). The request must be “narrowly tailored to seal only the

24

sealable material.” Id. at 79-5(c)(3).

25

A party seeking to seal records must provide “compelling reasons” to overcome the

26

“strong presumption in favor of access.” Kamakana v. City & Cty. Of Honolulu, 447 F.3d 1172,

27

1178 (9th Cir. 2006); see Ctr. for Auto Safety v. Chrysler Grp., LLC, 809 F.3d 1092, 1096 (9th

28

Cir. 2016). The standard derives from the “common law right ‘to inspect and copy public records

1

and documents, including judicial records and documents.’” Pintos v. Pac. Creditors Ass’n, 605

2

F.3d 665, 678 (9th Cir. 2010) (quoting Kamakana, 447 F.3d at 1178). To overcome this strong

3

presumption, the party seeking to seal judicial records must “articulate compelling reasons

4

supported by specific factual findings . . . that outweigh the general history of access and the

5

public policies favoring disclosure, such as the public interest in understanding the judicial

6

process.” Kamakana, 447 F.3d at 1178-79 (citations omitted). The party must make a

7

“particularized showing” that “specific prejudice or harm will result” if the information is

8

disclosed. Phillips ex rel. Estates of Byrd v. Gen. Motors Corp., 307 F.3d 1206, 1210-11 (9th Cir.

9

2002).

United States District Court
Northern District of California

10

It is in the “sound discretion of the trial court” to determine what constitutes a “compelling

11

reason” for sealing a court document. Ctr. for Auto Safety, 809 F.3d at 1097 (quoting Nixon v.

12

Warner Commc’ns, Inc., 435 U.S. 589, 599 (1978)). Compelling reasons justifying sealing court

13

records generally exist when such “court files might . . . become a vehicle for improper purposes”

14

such as “releas[ing] trade secrets,” Kamakana, 447 F.3d at 1179, or “as sources of business

15

information that might harm a litigant’s competitive standing,” Ctr. for Auto Safety, 809 F.3d at

16

1097; see In re Elec. Arts, Inc., 298 F. App’x 568, 569 (9th Cir. 2008) (sealing trade secret

17

information about “the pricing terms, royalty rates, and guaranteed minimum payment terms” in

18

the parties’ licensing agreement). Records attached to nondispositive motions must meet the

19

lower “good cause” standard of Rule 26(c) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, as such

20

records “are often unrelated, or only tangentially related, to the underlying cause of action.”

21

Kamakana, 447 F.3d at 1179-80 (quotations omitted).

22

DISCUSSION

23

The Court finds that compelling reasons exist to support the filing under seal of the

24

documents or portions thereof listed as “granted” in the following chart and grants the requests to

25

seal these documents or portions thereof where they appear on the public docket. The Court

26

denies the request to seal any documents or portions thereof (1) listed as “denied” in the following

27

chart or (2) provisionally filed under seal pursuant to Local Rule 79-5(f) because a Party or Third-

28

Party had designated them as confidential or highly confidential under the protective order but that
2

1

were not included in the below chart because no Party or Third-Party filed a statement or

2

declaration seeking to maintain them under seal pursuant to Local Rule 79-5(f).

3

The Court appreciates the efforts of counsel to prepare the chart below, including citations

4

to the relevant docket entries. The Court notes that, while it grants sealing many of the documents

5

presented at this stage, it will be disinclined to permit sealing of materials presented in a public

6

trial.

7
Documents or Portions Thereof that Intuitive Seeks to Maintain Under Seal

8

Document or Portion of
Document Sought to be
Sealed1
ECF No. 125-2
Exhibit A - Cahoy
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Kurt
Humphrey, Exhibit 4
(Expert Report of Paul D.
Martin, Ph.D.)
•
Page 19, redacted
portions of ¶ 53

9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16

ECF No. 125-2
Exhibit A - Cahoy
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Kurt
Humphrey, Exhibit 4
(Expert Report of Paul D.
Martin, Ph.D.)
•
Page 25, redacted
portions of ¶ 67

17
18
19
20
21

Evidence offered in
Support of Sealing
ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 4

Objections

Ruling
GRANTED.
Cybersecurity
development
content.

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-4
ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 4

GRANTED.
Cybersecurity
development
content.

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-4

22
23
24
25
26
27
28

1

The docket numbers listed refer to the under seal version of the document at issue that was
submitted in unredacted form for the Court’s review.
3

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25

Documents or Portions Thereof that Intuitive Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Document Sought to be
Sealed1
ECF No. 125-3
Exhibit B - Cahoy
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Kurt
Humphrey, Exhibit 9
(Expert Report of Kurt
Humphrey)
•
Page 11, figure
appearing between ¶ 29 and
¶ 30
ECF No. 125-3
Exhibit B - Cahoy
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Kurt
Humphrey, Exhibit 9
(Expert Report of Kurt
Humphrey)
•
Att. 3, page 20,
redacted portions of ¶ 66

Evidence offered in
Support of Sealing
ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 4

Objections

Ruling
GRANTED.
Cybersecurity
development
content.

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-4
ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 4

GRANTED.
Cybersecurity
development
content.

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-4

ECF No. 125-3
Exhibit B - Cahoy
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Kurt
Humphrey, Exhibit 9
(Expert Report of Kurt
Humphrey)
•
Att. 3, page 27,
redacted portions of ¶ 93

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 4

ECF No. 125-3
Exhibit B - Cahoy
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Kurt
Humphrey, Exhibit 9
(Expert Report of Kurt
Humphrey)
•
Att. 3, page 27,
redacted portions of ¶ 95

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 4

GRANTED.
Cybersecurity
development
content.

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-4

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-4

26
27
28
4

GRANTED.
Cybersecurity
development
content.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19

Documents or Portions Thereof that Intuitive Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Document Sought to be
Sealed1
ECF No. 125-3
Exhibit B - Cahoy
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Kurt
Humphrey, Exhibit 9
(Expert Report of Kurt
Humphrey)
•
Att. 3, page 27,
redacted portions of ¶ 96

Evidence offered in
Support of Sealing
ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 4

Objections

Ruling
GRANTED.
Cybersecurity
development
content.

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-4

ECF No. 125-3
Exhibit B - Cahoy
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Kurt
Humphrey, Exhibit 9
(Expert Report of Kurt
Humphrey)
•
Att. 3, page 28,
redacted portions of ¶ 96

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 4

ECF No. 125-3
Exhibit B - Cahoy
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Kurt
Humphrey, Exhibit 9
(Expert Report of Kurt
Humphrey)
•
Att. 3, page 28,
redacted portions of ¶ 97

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 4

ECF No. 125-3
Exhibit B - Cahoy
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Kurt
Humphrey, Exhibit 9
(Expert Report of Kurt
Humphrey)
•
Att. 3, page 28,
redacted portions of ¶ 98

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 4

GRANTED.
Cybersecurity
development
content.

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-4
GRANTED.
Cybersecurity
development
content.

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-4

20
21
22
23
24
25

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-4

26
27
28
5

GRANTED.
Cybersecurity
development
content.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19

Documents or Portions Thereof that Intuitive Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Document Sought to be
Sealed1
ECF No. 125-2
Exhibit A - Cahoy
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Kurt
Humphrey, Exhibit 4
(Expert Report of Paul D.
Martin, Ph.D.)
•
Page 9, redacted
portions of ¶ 24

Evidence offered in
Support of Sealing
ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 5

Objections

Ruling
GRANTED.
Proprietary
product
development
content.

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 4-5

ECF No. 125-2
Exhibit A - Cahoy
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Kurt
Humphrey, Exhibit 4
(Expert Report of Paul D.
Martin, Ph.D.)
•
Page 11, redacted
portions of ¶ 31

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 5

ECF No. 125-2
Exhibit A - Cahoy
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Kurt
Humphrey, Exhibit 4
(Expert Report of Paul D.
Martin, Ph.D.)
•
Redacted portions
of pages 26–29

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 5

ECF No. 125-2
Exhibit A - Cahoy
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Kurt
Humphrey, Exhibit 4
(Expert Report of Paul D.
Martin, Ph.D.)
•
Page 31, redacted
portions of ¶ 79

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 5

GRANTED.
Proprietary
product
development
content.

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 4-5
GRANTED.
Proprietary
product
development
content.

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 4-5

20
21
22
23
24
25

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 4-5

26
27
28
6

GRANTED.
Proprietary
product
development
content.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19

Documents or Portions Thereof that Intuitive Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Document Sought to be
Sealed1
ECF No. 125-4
Exhibit C - Cahoy
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Kurt
Humphrey, Exhibit 12
(Expert Rebuttal Report of
Kurt Humphrey)
•
Page 3, redacted
portions of ¶ 14

Evidence offered in
Support of Sealing
ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 5

Objections

Ruling
GRANTED.
Proprietary
product
development
content.

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 4-5

ECF No. 125-3
Exhibit B - Cahoy
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Kurt
Humphrey, Exhibit 9
(Expert Report of Kurt
Humphrey)
•
Page 5, redacted
portions of ¶ 16

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 5

ECF No. 125-3
Exhibit B - Cahoy
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Kurt
Humphrey, Exhibit 9
(Expert Report of Kurt
Humphrey)
•
Page 23-24,
redacted portions of ¶ 56

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 5

ECF No. 125-3
Exhibit B - Cahoy
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Kurt
Humphrey, Exhibit 9
(Expert Report of Kurt
Humphrey)
•
Page 24, redacted
portions of ¶ 57

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 5

GRANTED.
Proprietary
product
development
content.

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 4-5
GRANTED.
Proprietary
product
development
content.

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 4-5

20
21
22
23
24
25

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 4-5

26
27
28
7

GRANTED.
Proprietary
product
development
content.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

Documents or Portions Thereof that Intuitive Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Document Sought to be
Sealed1
ECF No. 125-3
Exhibit B - Cahoy
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Kurt
Humphrey, Exhibit 9
(Expert Report of Kurt
Humphrey)
•
Page 25, chart
appearing prior to ¶ 58

Evidence offered in
Support of Sealing
ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 5

Objections

Ruling
GRANTED.
Proprietary
product
development
content.

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 4-5

ECF No. 125-3
Exhibit B - Cahoy
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Kurt
Humphrey, Exhibit 9
(Expert Report of Kurt
Humphrey)
•
Redacted portions
of pages 25–27, including
charts appearing on Page 25
after ¶ 58 and the chart
appearing on page 26
before ¶ 59
ECF No. 125-3
Exhibit B - Cahoy
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Kurt
Humphrey, Exhibit 9
(Expert Report of Kurt
Humphrey)
•
Page 26, redacted
portions of ¶ 59

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 5

ECF No. 125-5
Exhibit D - Cahoy
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Kurt
Humphrey, Exhibit 10
(Deposition Tr. of Kurt
Humphrey)
•
Pages 31-32,
redacted portions of
116:23-117:22

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 5

GRANTED.
Proprietary
product
development
content.

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 4-5

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 5

GRANTED.
Proprietary
product
development
content.

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 4-5

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 4-5

8

GRANTED.
Proprietary
product
development
content.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7

Documents or Portions Thereof that Intuitive Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Document Sought to be
Sealed1
ECF No. 125-6
Exhibit E - Chaput
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Dr.
T. Kim Parnell, Ex. 8
(Howe 1/18/23 Larkin Rpt)
•
Page 28, Figure 6

8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13

16
17
18

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 6

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 6

ECF No. 125-6
Exhibit E - Chaput
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Dr.
T. Kim Parnell, Ex. 8
(Howe 1/18/23 Larkin Rpt)
•
Page 37, Figure 10

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 6

ECF No. 125-6
Exhibit E - Chaput
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Dr.
T. Kim Parnell, Ex. 8
(Howe 1/18/23 Larkin Rpt)
•
Page 84, Figure 20

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 6

19

Objections

Ruling
GRANTED.
Proprietary
product
development
content.

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 5

ECF No. 125-6
Exhibit E - Chaput
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Dr.
T. Kim Parnell, Ex. 8
(Howe 1/18/23 Larkin Rpt)
•
Page 36, Figure 9

14
15

Evidence offered in
Support of Sealing

GRANTED.
Proprietary
product
development
content.

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 5
DENIED.
Descriptions of
surgical
maneuvers are not
proprietary.

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 5

20
21
22
23
24
25

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 5

26
27
28
9

DENIED.
Descriptions of
surgical
maneuvers are not
proprietary.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7

Documents or Portions Thereof that Intuitive Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Document Sought to be
Sealed1
ECF No. 125-6
Exhibit E - Chaput
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Dr.
T. Kim Parnell, Ex. 8
(Howe 1/18/23 Larkin Rpt)
•
Page 88, Figure 21

8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13

16
17
18

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 6

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 6

ECF No. 125-7
Exhibit F - Chaput
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Dr.
T. Kim Parnell, Ex. 9
(Howe 1/18/23 SIS Rpt)
•
Page 29, Figure 6

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 6

ECF No. 125-7
Exhibit F - Chaput
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Dr.
T. Kim Parnell, Ex. 9
(Howe 1/18/23 SIS Rpt)
•
Page 37, Figure 9

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 6

19

Objections

Ruling
GRANTED.
Proprietary
product
development
content.

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 5

ECF No. 125-6
Exhibit E - Chaput
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Dr.
T. Kim Parnell, Ex. 8
(Howe 1/18/23 Larkin Rpt)
•
Page 89, redacted
portions of ¶ 174

14
15

Evidence offered in
Support of Sealing

GRANTED.
Proprietary
product
development
content.

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 5
GRANTED.
Proprietary
product
development
content.

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 5

20
21
22
23
24
25

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 5

26
27
28
10

DENIED.
Descriptions of
surgical
maneuvers are not
proprietary.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7

Documents or Portions Thereof that Intuitive Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Document Sought to be
Sealed1
ECF No. 125-7
Exhibit F - Chaput
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Dr.
T. Kim Parnell, Ex. 9
(Howe 1/18/23 SIS Rpt)
•
Page 38, Figure 10

8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14

Evidence offered in
Support of Sealing
ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 6

ECF No. 125-12
Exhibit K - Lannin
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Dr.
Robert Mahal, Ex. 9 (Howe
1/18/23 SIS Rpt)
•
Page 28, Figure 6
•
Page 37, Figure 9
•
Page 38, Figure 10

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 6

ECF No. 125-8
Exhibit G - Lazerow
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude Jean
Sargent, Ex. 9 (Intuitive00626597–6616)
•
Page Intuitive00626611, top row
•
Page Intuitive00626611, bottom row
•
Page Intuitive00626612, top row
•
Page Intuitive00626612, bottom row
•
Page Intuitive00626613, top row
•
Page Intuitive00626613, bottom row

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 7

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 5

16

18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27

Ruling
DENIED.
Descriptions of
surgical
maneuvers are not
proprietary.

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 5

15

17

Objections

ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 5-6

28
11

Page 28, Figure 6
GRANTED.
Proprietary
business
information.
Page 37, Figure 9
Page 38, Figure 10
DENIED.
Descriptions of
surgical
maneuvers are not
proprietary.
GRANTED.
Non-public
financial
information.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27

ECF No. 125-9
Exhibit H - Bass
Declaration in Support of
the Motion to Exclude
Richard Bero, Ex. 1 (Bero
12/2/22 Report)
•
Schedule 6.0, page 1
of 2: Data A for columns
2014-2022 and for column
“2020-2021 decline”; Data
D for columns 2023-2025;
Data F for columns 20142022.
•
Schedule 8.0, page 1
of 1: Data A for all
columns; Data B for all
columns.
•
Schedule 8.1, page 1
of 6: Data A for Units and
all columns.
•
Schedule 8.1, page 2
of 6: Data A for Units,
Total units, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 8.1, page 5
of 6: Data C for Net Sales
dollars and all columns.
•
Schedule 8.1, page 6
of 6: Data C for Net Sales
dollars, Total net sales
dollars, and all columns.
•
Schedule 8.2, page 1
of 6: Data A for Units and
all columns.
•
Schedule 8.2, page 2
of 6: Data A for Units,
Total units, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 8.2, page 5
of 6: Data B for Net Sales
dollars and all columns.
•
Schedule 8.2, page 6
of 6: Data B for Net Sales
dollars, Total net sales
dollars, and all columns.
•
Schedule 9.0, page 1
of 2: Data A for all

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 7
ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 5-6

28
12

GRANTED.
Non-public
financial
information.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

columns; Data D for all
columns.
•
Schedule 9.1, page 1
of 1: Data A labels and for
all columns; Data B labels
and for all columns.
•
Schedule 11.0, page
1 of 1: Data A, B, and C for
all columns in the tables
labeled “Units” and
“Costs.”
•
Schedule 11.1, page
1 of 5: Data A for Units and
all columns.
•
Schedule 11.1, page
2 of 5: Data A for Units,
Total units, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 11.1, page
3 of 5: Data C for Costs and
all columns.
•
Schedule 11.1, page
4 of 5: Data C for Costs,
Total costs, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 11.2, page
1 of 5: Data A for Units and
all columns.
•
Schedule 11.2, page
2 of 5: Data A for Units,
Total units, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 11.2, page
3 of 5: Data C for Costs and
all columns.
•
Schedule 11.2, page
4 of 5: Data C for Costs,
Total costs, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 13.0, page
1 of 1: Data A, B, and C for
all columns in the tables
labeled “Units” and “Net
sales dollars.”
•
Schedule 13.1, page
1 of 4: Data A for Units and
all columns; Data B (Total
units) for all columns.
13

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

Documents or Portions Thereof that Intuitive Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Document Sought to be
Sealed1
•
Schedule 13.1, page
2 of 4: Data A for Net sales
dollars and all columns;
Data B (Total net sales
dollars) for all columns.
•
Schedule 13.1, page
3 of 4: Data B for ASP and
all columns, but not Data B
for Total ASP.
•
Schedule 13.2, page
1 of 4: Data A for Units and
all columns; Data B (Total
units) for all columns.
•
Schedule 13.2, page
2 of 4: Data A for Net sales
dollars and all columns;
Data B (Total net sales
dollars) for all columns.
•
Schedule 13.2, page
3 of 4: Data B for ASP and
all columns, but not Data B
for Total ASP.
•
Schedule 16.0, page
1 of 1: Data B for columns
2020-2022; Data C for
columns 2020-2022.
ECF No. 125-10
Exhibit I - Bass Declaration
in Support of the Motion to
Exclude Richard Bero, Ex.
4 (Bero 2/25/23
Report/Updated Schedules)
•
Schedule 6.0, page 1
of 2: Data A for columns
2014-2022 and for column
“2020-2021 decline”; Data
D for columns 2023-2025;
Data F for columns 20142022.
•
Schedule 8.0, page 1
of 1: Data A for all
columns; Data B for all
columns.

Evidence offered in
Support of Sealing

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 7
ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 5-6

14

Objections

Ruling

GRANTED.
Non-public
financial
information.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27

Documents or Portions Thereof that Intuitive Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Evidence offered in
Document Sought to be
Support of Sealing
Sealed1
•
Schedule 8.1, page 1
of 6: Data A for Units and
all columns.
•
Schedule 8.1, page 2
of 6: Data A for Units,
Total units, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 8.1, page 5
of 6: Data C for Net Sales
dollars and all columns.
•
Schedule 8.1, page 6
of 6: Data C for Net Sales
dollars, Total net sales
dollars, and all columns.
•
Schedule 8.2, page 1
of 6: Data A for Units and
all columns.
•
Schedule 8.2, page 2
of 6: Data A for Units,
Total units, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 8.2, page 5
of 6: Data B for Net Sales
dollars and all columns.
•
Schedule 8.2, page 6
of 6: Data B for Net Sales
dollars, Total net sales
dollars, and all columns.
•
Schedule 9.0, page 1
of 2: Data A for all
columns; Data D for all
columns.
•
Schedule 9.1, page 1
of 1: Data A labels and for
all columns; Data B labels
and for all columns.
•
Schedule 11.0, page
1 of 1: Data A, B, and C for
all columns in the tables
labeled “Units” and
“Costs.”

28
15

Objections

Ruling

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27

Documents or Portions Thereof that Intuitive Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Evidence offered in
Document Sought to be
Support of Sealing
Sealed1
•
Schedule 11.1, page
1 of 5: Data A for Units and
all columns.
•
Schedule 11.1, page
2 of 5: Data A for Units,
Total units, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 11.1, page
3 of 5: Data C for Costs and
all columns.
•
Schedule 11.1, page
4 of 5: Data C for Costs,
Total costs, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 11.2, page
1 of 5: Data A for Units and
all columns.
•
Schedule 11.2, page
2 of 5: Data A for Units,
Total units, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 11.2, page
3 of 5: Data C for Costs and
all columns.
•
Schedule 11.2, page
4 of 5: Data C for Costs,
Total costs, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 13.0, page
1 of 1: Data A, B, and C for
all columns in the tables
labeled “Units” and “Net
sales dollars.”
•
Schedule 13.1, page
1 of 4: Data A for Units and
all columns; Data B (Total
units) for all columns.
•
Schedule 13.1, page
2 of 4: Data A for Net sales
dollars and all columns;
Data B (Total net sales
dollars) for all columns.

28
16

Objections

Ruling

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27

Documents or Portions Thereof that Intuitive Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Document Sought to be
Sealed1
•
Schedule 13.1, page
3 of 4: Data B for ASP and
all columns, but not Data B
for Total ASP.
•
Schedule 13.2, page
1 of 4: Data A for Units and
all columns; Data B (Total
units) for all columns.
•
Schedule 13.2, page
2 of 4: Data A for Net sales
dollars and all columns;
Data B (Total net sales
dollars) for all columns.
•
Schedule 13.2, page
3 of 4: Data B for ASP and
all columns, but not Data B
for Total ASP.
•
Schedule 16.0, page
1 of 1: Data B for columns
2020-2022; Data C for
columns 2020-2022.
ECF No. 125-11
Exhibit J - Bass Declaration
in Support of the Motion to
Exclude Richard Bero, Ex.
5 (Bero 3/1/23 Report)
•
Schedule 6.0, page 1
of 2: Data A for columns
2014-2022 and for column
“2020-2021 decline”; Data
D for columns 2023-2025;
Data F for columns 20142022.
•
Schedule 8.0, page 1
of 1: Data A for all
columns; Data B for all
columns.
•
Schedule 8.1, page 1
of 6: Data A for Units and
all columns.
•
Schedule 8.1, page 2
of 6: Data A for Units,

Evidence offered in
Support of Sealing

ECF No. 125-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Motion to
Seal, ¶ 7
ECF No. 125
Administrative
Motion to File Under
Seal, pg. 2-3, 5-6

28
17

Objections

Ruling

GRANTED.
Non-public
financial
information.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

Documents or Portions Thereof that Intuitive Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Evidence offered in
Document Sought to be
Support of Sealing
Sealed1
Total units, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 8.1, page 5
of 6: Data C for Net Sales
dollars and all columns.
•
Schedule 8.1, page 6
of 6: Data C for Net Sales
dollars, Total net sales
dollars, and all columns.
•
Schedule 8.2, page 1
of 6: Data A for Units and
all columns.
•
Schedule 8.2, page 2
of 6: Data A for Units,
Total units, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 8.2, page 5
of 6: Data B for Net Sales
dollars and all columns.
•
Schedule 8.2, page 6
of 6: Data B for Net Sales
dollars, Total net sales
dollars, and all columns.
•
Schedule 9.0, page 1
of 2: Data A for all
columns; Data D for all
columns.
•
Schedule 9.1, page 1
of 1: Data A labels and for
all columns; Data B labels
and for all columns.
•
Schedule 11.0, page
1 of 1: Data A, B, and C for
all columns in the tables
labeled “Units” and
“Costs.”
•
Schedule 11.1, page
1 of 5: Data A for Units and
all columns.
•
Schedule 11.1, page
2 of 5: Data A for Units,
Total units, and all
columns.
18

Objections

Ruling

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

Documents or Portions Thereof that Intuitive Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Evidence offered in
Document Sought to be
Support of Sealing
Sealed1
•
Schedule 11.1, page
3 of 5: Data C for Costs and
all columns.
•
Schedule 11.1, page
4 of 5: Data C for Costs,
Total costs, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 11.2, page
1 of 5: Data A for Units and
all columns.
•
Schedule 11.2, page
2 of 5: Data A for Units,
Total units, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 11.2, page
3 of 5: Data C for Costs and
all columns.
•
Schedule 11.2, page
4 of 5: Data C for Costs,
Total costs, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 13.0, page
1 of 1: Data A, B, and C for
all columns in the tables
labeled “Units” and “Net
sales dollars.”
•
Schedule 13.1, page
1 of 4: Data A for Units and
all columns; Data B (Total
units) for all columns.
•
Schedule 13.1, page
2 of 4: Data A for Net sales
dollars and all columns;
Data B (Total net sales
dollars) for all columns.
•
Schedule 13.1, page
3 of 4: Data B for ASP and
all columns, but not Data B
for Total ASP.
•
Schedule 13.2, page
1 of 4: Data A for Units and
all columns; Data B (Total
units) for all columns.
19

Objections

Ruling

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14

Documents or Portions Thereof that Intuitive Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Document Sought to be
Sealed1
•
Schedule 13.2, page
2 of 4: Data A for Net sales
dollars and all columns;
Data B (Total net sales
dollars) for all columns.
•
Schedule 13.2, page
3 of 4: Data B for ASP and
all columns, but not Data B
for Total ASP.
•
Schedule 16.0, page
1 of 1: Data B for columns
2020-2022; Data C for
columns 2020-2022.
ECF No. 133-2
SIS’s Motion to consider
Whether Another Party’s
Material Should Be Sealed,
Exhibit 12 (Intuitive02066979 –
Intuitive-02067059)

15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27

Pages containing redacted
information:
•
Intuitive-02066986
– Intuitive-02066988
•
Intuitive-02066991
– Intuitive-02066996
•
Intuitive-02066999
•
Intuitive-02067001
– Intuitive-02067003
•
Intuitive-02067005
– Intuitive-02067007
•
Intuitive-02067012
– Intuitive-02067013
•
Intuitive-02067018
– Intuitive-02067023
•
Intuitive-02067030
– Intuitive-02067031
•
Intuitive-02067035
– Intuitive-02067036
•
Intuitive-02067051
– Intuitive-02067053

Evidence offered in
Support of Sealing

ECF No. 133-1
Declaration of Dr.
Jaime Wong in
Support of Defendant
Intuitive Surgical’s
Statement in Support
of Plaintiffs’
Administrative
Motions to Consider
Whether Another
Party’s Materials
Should be Sealed
(“Wong Declaration
in Support of
Statement to Consider
Sealing”), ¶ 5
ECF 133
Intuitive Surgical’s
Statement in Support
of Plaintiff’s
Administrative
Motion to Consider
Whether Another
Party’s Materials
Should be Sealed, pg.
1-3

28
20

Objections

Ruling

GRANTED.
Proprietary
business
information.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

Documents or Portions Thereof that Intuitive Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Document Sought to be
Sealed1
•
Intuitive-02067056
– Intuitive-02067059
ECF No. 133-3
SIS’s Motion to Consider,
Exhibit 16 (Intuitive00671209 – Intuitive00671220)
•
Page Intuitive00671210, redacted
portions.
•
Page Intuitive00671220, redacted
portions.

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25

ECF No. 136-2
Declaration of Kathryn E.
Cahoy in Support of
Intuitive’s Opposition to
Plaintiff’s Motion for
Summary Judgment and
Cross-Motion for Summary
Judgment (“Cahoy Dec.”)
Ex. 75 (Howe 1/18/23 SIS
Rpt)
•
Page 29, Figure 6
•
Page 37, Figure 9
•
Page 38, Figure 10

Evidence offered in
Support of Sealing

ECF No. 133-1
Wong Declaration in
Support of Statement
to Consider Sealing, ¶
4, 5

Objections

Ruling

GRANTED.
Proprietary
business
information.

ECF 133
Intuitive Surgical’s
Statement in Support
of Plaintiff’s
Administrative
Motion to Consider
Whether Another
Party’s Materials
Should be Sealed, pg.
1-3
ECF No. 136-1
Declaration of Dr.
Jaime Wong in
Support of Intuitive
Surgical’s
Administrative
Motions to Seal
Materials From Its
Summary Judgment
Briefs (“Wong Dec.”)
¶6
ECF No. 136
Intuitive’s
Administrative
Motion to Seal
Materials from its
Summary Judgment
Briefs, pg. 1-2, 4

26
27
28
21

Page 29, Figure 6
GRANTED.
Proprietary
business
information.
Page 37, Figure 9
Page 38, Figure 10
DENIED.
Descriptions of
surgical
maneuvers are not
proprietary.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

ECF No. 136-3
Cahoy Dec. Ex. 81 (Bero
Report, Dec. 2, 2022)
•
Schedule 6.0, page 1
of 2: Data A for columns
2014-2022 and for column
“2020-2021 decline”; Data
D for columns 2023-2025;
Data F for columns 20142022.
•
Schedule 8.0, page 1
of 1: Data A for all
columns; Data B for all
columns.
•
Schedule 8.1, page 1
of 7: Data A for Units and
all columns.
•
Schedule 8.1, page 2
of 7: Data A for Units,
Total units, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 8.1, page 5
of 7: Data C for Net Sales
dollars and all columns.
•
Schedule 8.1, page 6
of 7: Data C for Net Sales
dollars, Total net sales
dollars, and all columns.
•
Schedule 8.2, page 1
of 7: Data A for Units and
all columns.
•
Schedule 8.2, page 2
of 7: Data A for Units,
Total units, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 8.2, page 5
of 7: Data B for Net Sales
dollars and all columns.
•
Schedule 8.2, page 6
of 7: Data B for Net Sales
dollars, Total net sales
dollars, and all columns.
•
Schedule 9.0, page 1
of 2: Data A for all
columns; Data D for all
columns.
•
Schedule 9.1, page 1
of 1: Data A labels and for

ECF No. 136-1
Wong Dec. ¶ 7
ECF No. 136
Intuitive’s
Administrative
Motion to Seal
Materials from its
Summary Judgment
Briefs, pg. 1-2, 4-5

22

GRANTED.
Non-public
financial
information.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

all columns; Data B labels
and for all columns.
•
Schedule 11.0, page
1 of 1: Data A, B, and C for
all columns in the tables
labeled “Units” and
“Costs.”
•
Schedule 11.1, page
1 of 5: Data A for Units and
all columns.
•
Schedule 11.1, page
2 of 5: Data A for Units,
Total units, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 11.1, page
3 of 5: Data C for Costs and
all columns.
•
Schedule 11.1, page
4 of 5: Data C for Costs,
Total costs, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 11.2, page
1 of 5: Data A for Units and
all columns.
•
Schedule 11.2, page
2 of 5: Data A for Units,
Total units, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 11.2, page
3 of 5: Data C for Costs and
all columns.
•
Schedule 11.2, page
4 of 5: Data C for Costs,
Total costs, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 13.0, page
1 of 1: Data A, B, and C for
all columns in the tables
labeled “Units” and “Net
sales dollars.”
•
Schedule 13.1, page
1 of 4: Data A for Units and
all columns; Data B (Total
units) for all columns.
•
Schedule 13.1, page
2 of 4: Data A for Net sales
dollars and all columns;
23

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26

Documents or Portions Thereof that Intuitive Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Document Sought to be
Sealed1
Data B (Total net sales
dollars) for all columns.
•
Schedule 13.1, page
3 of 4: Data B for ASP and
all columns, but not Data B
for Total ASP.
•
Schedule 13.2, page
1 of 4: Data A for Units and
all columns; Data B (Total
units) for all columns.
•
Schedule 13.2, page
2 of 4: Data A for Net sales
dollars and all columns;
Data B (Total net sales
dollars) for all columns.
•
Schedule 13.2, page
3 of 4: Data B for ASP and
all columns, but not Data B
for Total ASP.
•
Schedule 16.0, page
1 of 1: Data B for columns
2020-2022; Data C for
columns 2020-2022.
ECF No. 136-4
Cahoy Dec. Ex. 85 (Expert
Report of Paul D. Martin,
Ph.D.)
•
Page 9, redacted
portions of ¶ 24
•
Page 11, redacted
portions of ¶ 31
•
Page 19, redacted
portions of ¶ 53
•
Page 25, redacted
portions of ¶ 67
•
Redacted portions
of pages 26–29
•
Page 31, redacted
portions of ¶ 79

Evidence offered in
Support of Sealing

ECF No. 136-1
Wong Dec. ¶¶ 4, 5
ECF No. 136
Intuitive’s
Administrative
Motion to Seal
Materials from its
Summary Judgment
Briefs, pg. 1-3

27
28
24

Objections

Ruling

GRANTED.
Proprietary
product design
information.

1
2
3
4
5
6

Documents or Portions Thereof that Intuitive Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Document Sought to be
Sealed1
ECF No. 136-5
Cahoy Dec. Ex. 89 (Expert
Rebuttal Report of Kurt
Humphrey)
•
Page 3, redacted
portions of ¶ 14

7
8

Evidence offered in
Support of Sealing
ECF No. 136-1
Wong Dec. ¶ 5
ECF No. 136
Intuitive’s
Administrative
Motion to Seal
Materials from its
Summary Judgment
Briefs, pg. 1-3

Objections

Ruling
GRANTED.
Proprietary
product design
information.

9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

ECF No. 136-6
Cahoy Dec. Ex. 90
(Intuitive-00506505
excerpts)
•
Pages Intuitive00506539–42, redacted
portions
•
Pages Intuitive00506593–94, redacted
portions
ECF No. 151-2
SIS Opposition to Intuitive
Motion to Exclude Kurt
Humphrey’s Expert
Testimony (Dkt. 145 &
Dkt. 149 Attachment 2)
•
Page 6, redacted
portions on lines 22–23.

ECF No. 136-1
Wong Dec. ¶ 4
ECF No. 136
Intuitive’s
Administrative
Motion to Seal
Materials from its
Summary Judgment
Briefs, pg. 1-3
ECF No. 151-1
Declaration of Dr.
Jaime Wong in
Support of Intuitive
Surgical, Inc.’s
Statement in Support
of Plaintiffs’ April 20,
2023 Administrative
Motions to Consider
Whether Another
Party’s Materials
Should Be Sealed, ¶ 4
ECF No. 151
Intuitive’s Statement
in Support of
Plaintiff’s April 20,
2023 Administrative
Motion to Consider
Whether Another
Party’s Materials
Should be Sealed, pg.
2-4
25

GRANTED.
Proprietary
product design
information.

GRANTED.
Proprietary
product design
information.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7

Documents or Portions Thereof that Intuitive Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Document Sought to be
Sealed1
ECF No. 171-2
Van Hoven Decl., Exhibit
10
(Intuitive-00027299 –
Intuitive00027303)
•
Intuitive-00027303,
redacted portions

8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13

Evidence offered in
Support of Sealing
ECF No. 171-1
Declaration of Dr.
Jaime Wong in
Support of Intuitive
Surgical, Inc.’s
Statement in Support
of
Plaintiffs’ May 4,
2023
Administrative
Motions to
Consider Whether
Another Party’s
Materials Should
Be Sealed (“Wong
Dec.”), ¶ 6.

Objections

Ruling
GRANTED.
Proprietary
product design
information.

ECF No. 171
Intuitive’s Statement
in Support of
Plaintiff’s May 4,
2023 Administrative
Motion to Consider
Whether Another
Party’s Materials
Should be Sealed, pg.
1-2, 4

14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26

ECF No. 171-3
Van Hoven Decl., Exhibit
27
Excerpts of Deposition of
Sharathchandra Somayaji
(November 4, 2022)
•
Pages 132–38,
redacted portions.

ECF No. 171-1
Wong Dec. ¶ 5
ECF No. 171
Intuitive’s Statement
in Support of
Plaintiff’s May 4,
2023 Administrative
Motion to Consider
Whether Another
Party’s Materials
Should be Sealed, pg.
1-4

27
28
26

GRANTED.
Proprietary
product design
information.

1
2
3
4

Documents or Portions Thereof that Intuitive Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Document Sought to be
Sealed1
ECF No. 171-4
Van Hoven Decl., Exhibit
34

5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11

Exhibit 267 of the 30(b)(6)
Deposition of Grant Duque,
bates-labeled as Intuitive02068695 –Intuitive0206897
•
Page Intuitive02068695, redacted
portions

ECF No. 133-2, 161-39

12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

Evidence offered in
Support of Sealing
ECF No. 171-1
Wong Dec. ¶ 4
ECF No. 171
Intuitive’s Statement
in Support of
Plaintiff’s May 4,
2023 Administrative
Motion to Consider
Whether Another
Party’s Materials
Should be Sealed, pg.
1-3
ECF No. 171-1
Wong Dec. ¶ 6

Van Hoven Decl., Exhibit
36,
Intuitive-02066979 –
Intuitive02067059

ECF No. 171
Intuitive’s Statement
in Support of
Plaintiff’s May 4,
2023 Administrative
Pages containing redacted
Motion to Consider
information:
Whether Another
•
Intuitive-02066986 - Party’s Materials
Should be Sealed, pg.
Intuitive-02066988
•
Intuitive-02066991 - 1-2, 4
Intuitive-02066996
•
Intuitive-02066999
•
Intuitive-02067001 Intuitive-02067003
•
Intuitive-02067005 Intuitive-02067007
•
Intuitive-02067012 Intuitive-02067013
•
Intuitive-02067018 Intuitive-02067023
•
Intuitive-02067030 Intuitive-02067031
•
Intuitive-02067035 Intuitive-02067036
•
Intuitive-02067051 Intuitive-02067053
27

Objections

Ruling
GRANTED.
Proprietary
product design
information.

GRANTED.
Proprietary
business strategy
information.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

Documents or Portions Thereof that Intuitive Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Evidence offered in
Document Sought to be
Support of Sealing
Sealed1
•
Intuitive-02067056 Intuitive-02067059
(See Dkt. 133-1 (March 30,
2023 Wong Dec.) at 4).
ECF No. 133-3, 161-45
Van Hoven Decl., Exhibit
42, Intuitive-00671209 –
Intuitive00671220
•
Page Intuitive00671210, redacted
portions.

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12

(See Dkt. No. 133-1 (March
30, 2022 Wong Dec.) at 2).

13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21

ECF No. 171-5
Van Hoven Decl., Exhibit
54,
Sales, License, and Service
Agreement dated December
7,
2018, Intuitive-01807644 –
Intuitive-01807658
•
Page Intuitive01807654, redacted
portions
•
Page Intuitive01807657, redacted
portions

ECF No. 171-1
Wong Dec. ¶ 5
ECF No. 171
Intuitive’s Statement
in Support of
Plaintiff’s May 4,
2023 Administrative
Motion to Consider
Whether Another
Party’s Materials
Should be Sealed, pg.
1-4
ECF No. 171-1
Wong Dec. ¶ 7
ECF No. 171
Intuitive’s Statement
in Support of
Plaintiff’s May 4,
2023 Administrative
Motion to Consider
Whether Another
Party’s Materials
Should be Sealed, pg.
1-2, 4-5

22
23
24
25
26
27
28
28

Objections

Ruling

GRANTED.
Proprietary
business strategy
information.

GRANTED.
Proprietary
business strategy
information.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

ECF No. 125-11, 161-60
Van Hoven Decl., Exhibit
57
Expert Report of Richard F.
Bero
(March 1, 2023)

ECF No. 171-1
Wong Dec. ¶ 7

ECF No. 171
Intuitive’s Statement
in Support of
Plaintiff’s May 4,
Pages containing redacted
2023 Administrative
information:
Motion to Consider
•
Schedule 6.0, page 1 Whether Another
Party’s Materials
of 2: Data A for columns
Should be Sealed, pg.
2014-2022 and for column
“2020-2021 decline”; Data 1-2, 4-5
D for columns 2023- 2025;
Data F for columns 20142022.
•
Schedule 8.0, page 1
of 1: Data A for all
columns; Data B for all
columns.
•
Schedule 8.1, page 1
of 6: Data A for Units and
all columns
•
Schedule 8.1, page 2
of 6: Data A for Units,
Total units, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 8.1, page 5
of 6: Data C for Net Sales
dollars and all columns.
•
Schedule 8.1, page 6
of 6: Data C for Net Sales
dollars, Total net sales
dollars, and all columns.
•
Schedule 8.2, page 1
of 6: Data A for Units and
all columns.
•
Schedule 8.2, page 2
of 6: Data A for Units,
Total units, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 8.2, page 5
of 6: Data B for Net Sales
dollars and all columns.
•
Schedule 8.2, page 6
of 6: Data B for Net Sales
dollars, Total net sales
dollars, and all columns.
29

GRANTED.
Non-public
financial
information.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

•
Schedule 9.0, page 1
of 2: Data A for all
columns; Data D for all
columns.
•
Schedule 9.1, page 1
of 1: Data A labels and for
all columns; Data B labels
and for all columns.
•
Schedule 11.0, page
1 of Data A, B, and C for
all columns in the tables
labeled “Units” and “Costs”
•
Schedule 11.1, page
1 of 5: Data A for Units and
all columns.
•
Schedule 11.1, page
2 of 5: Data A for Units,
Total units, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 11.1, page
3 of 5: Data C for Costs and
all columns.
•
Schedule 11.1, page
4 of 5: Data C for Costs,
Total costs, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 11.2, page
1 of 5: Data A for Units and
all columns.
•
Schedule 11.2, page
2 of 5: Data A for Units,
Total units, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 11.2, page
3 of 5: Data C for Costs and
all columns.
•
Schedule 11.2, page
4 of 5: Data C for Costs,
Total costs, and all
columns.
•
Schedule 13.0, page
1 of 1: Data A, B, and C for
all columns in the tables
labeled “Units” and “Net
sales dollars.”
•
Schedule 13.1, page
1 of 4: Data A for Units and
30

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21

Documents or Portions Thereof that Intuitive Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Evidence offered in
Document Sought to be
Support of Sealing
Sealed1
all columns; Data B (Total
units) for all columns.
•
Schedule 13.1, page
2 of 4: Data A for Net sales
dollars and all columns;
Data B (Total net sales
dollars) for all columns.
•
Schedule 13.1, page
3 of 4: Data B for ASP and
all columns, but not Data B
for Total ASP.
•
Schedule 13.2, page
1 of 4: Data A for Units and
all columns; Data B (Total
units) for all columns.
•
Schedule 13.2, page
2 of 4: Data A for Net sales
dollars and all columns;
Data B (Total net sales
dollars) for all columns.
•
Schedule 13.2, page
3 of 4: Data B for ASP and
all columns, but not Data B
for Total ASP.
•
Schedule 16.0, page
1 of 1: Data B for columns
2020-2022; Data C for
columns 2020-2022.
(See Dkt. 125.1 (March 23,
2022 Wong Dec.) at 8–9).

22
23
24
25
26
27
28
31

Objections

Ruling

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27

Documents or Portions Thereof that Intuitive Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Document Sought to be
Sealed1
ECF No. 125-3, 161-61
Van Hoven Decl., Exhibit
58
Expert Report of Kurt
Humphrey
(July 26, 2021)
•
Page 11, figure
appearing between ¶ 29 and
¶ 30
•
Att. 3, page 20,
redacted portions of ¶ 66
•
Att. 3, page 27,
redacted portions of ¶ 93
•
Att. 3, page 27,
redacted portions of ¶ 95
•
Att. 3, page 27,
redacted portions of ¶ 96
•
Att. 3, page 28,
redacted portions of ¶ 96
•
Att. 3, page 28,
redacted portions of ¶ 97
•
Att. 3, page 28,
redacted portions of ¶ 98
(See Dkt. 125.1 (March 23,
2022 Wong Decl.) at 2).
ECF No. 125-3, 161-61
Van Hoven Decl., Exhibit
58
Expert Report of Kurt
Humphrey
(July 26, 2021)
Pages containing redacted
information:
•
Page 5, redacted
portions of ¶ 16
•
Page 23-24,
redacted portions of ¶ 56
•
Page 24, redacted
portions of ¶ 57

Evidence offered in
Support of Sealing
ECF No. 171-1
Wong Dec. ¶ 4
ECF No. 171
Intuitive’s Statement
in Support of
Plaintiff’s May 4,
2023 Administrative
Motion to Consider
Whether Another
Party’s Materials
Should be Sealed, pg.
1-3

ECF No. 171-1
Wong Dec. ¶ 5
ECF No. 171
Intuitive’s Statement
in Support of
Plaintiff’s May 4,
2023 Administrative
Motion to Consider
Whether Another
Party’s Materials
Should be Sealed, pg.
1-4

28
32

Objections

Ruling
GRANTED.
Proprietary
product design
information.

GRANTED.
Proprietary
product design
information.

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16

Documents or Portions Thereof that Intuitive Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Evidence offered in
Document Sought to be
Support of Sealing
Sealed1
•
Page 25, chart
appearing prior to ¶ 58
•
Redacted portions
of pages 25–27, including
charts appearing on Page 25
after ¶ 58 and the chart
appearing on page 26
before ¶ 59
•
Page 26, redacted
portions of ¶ 59
(See Dkt. 125.1 (March 23,
2022 Wong Decl.) at 3)
ECF No. 171-6
Plaintiff’s Opposition to
Intuitive’s Motion for
Summary
Judgment and Reply in
Support
of Partial Summary
Judgment (Dkt. 156, 161.2)
•
Page 13, highlighted
portion (lines 8-10).

17
18

Objections

ECF No. 171-1
Wong Dec. ¶ 5

Ruling

GRANTED.
Proprietary
product design
information.

ECF No. 171
Intuitive’s Statement
in Support of
Plaintiff’s May 4,
2023 Administrative
Motion to Consider
Whether Another
Party’s Materials
Should be Sealed, pg.
1-4

19

Documents or Portions Thereof that Alliance Seeks to Maintain Under Seal

20

Document or Portion of
Document Sought to be
Sealed
ECF No. 130-48

21
22
23

AHP000527

24

Exhibit 13, Motion to
Exclude Testimony of
Phillips
AHP000527

25
26

Evidence offered in
Support of Sealing
ECF No. 135

Objections

Ruling
GRANTED.
Proprietary
business
information.

27
28
33

1
2
3

Documents or Portions Thereof that Alliance Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Document Sought to be
Sealed
ECF No. 138-27

Evidence offered in
Support of Sealing

Objections

ECF No. 139

GRANTED.
Proprietary
business
information.

4
AHP000527
5

7

Cross-Motion for Summary
Judgement Cahoy Dec. Ex.
41

8

Documents or Portions Thereof that Rebotix Seeks to Maintain Under Seal

9

Document or Portion of
Document Sought to be
Sealed
ECF No. 130-18
Ex. 11 to Cahoy
Declaration in Support of
Motion to Exclude
Testimony of Kurt
Humphrey

6

10
11

United States District Court
Northern District of California

Ruling

12
13
14
15

17
18

Section of page 10

19
20

ECF No. 130-14
Expert Report of Richard F.
Bero (12/02/2022)

GRANTED.
Proprietary
business
information.

ECF No. 132

GRANTED.
Proprietary
business
information.

ECF No. 132

GRANTED.
Proprietary
business
information.

ECF No. 132

GRANTED.
Proprietary
business
information.

Section of page 30

24

ECF No. 130-6
Expert Report of Richard F.
Bero (03/01/2023)

25

Section of page 5

23

Ruling

ECF No. 132

21
22

Objections

Pages 7-12
ECF No. 130-14
Expert Report of Richard F.
Bero (12/02/2022)

16

Evidence offered in
Support of Sealing

26
27
28
34

1
2
3
4

Documents or Portions Thereof that Rebotix Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or Portion of
Document Sought to be
Sealed
ECF No. 130-35
Expert Report of Robert
Howe (01/18/2023)

Evidence offered in
Support of Sealing

GRANTED.
Proprietary
business
information.

ECF No. 132

GRANTED.
Proprietary
business
information.

ECF No. 132

GRANTED.
Proprietary
business
information.

ECF No. 130-35
Expert Report of Robert
Howe (01/18/2023)
Page 25, ¶ 51

ECF No. 132

GRANTED.
Proprietary
business
information.

ECF No. 138-2
Opposition of
Defendant/Counterclaimant
Intuitive Surgical, Inc. To
Plaintiff’s Motion for
Summary Judgment and
Cross-Motion for Summary
Judgment (SIS)

ECF No. 141

GRANTED.
Proprietary
business
information.

ECF No. 141

GRANTED.
Proprietary
business
information.

8
9

Page 24, ¶ 49

10
11

United States District Court
Northern District of California

Page 23, ¶ 49
ECF No. 130-35
Expert Report of Robert
Howe (01/18/2023)

7

ECF No. 130-35
Expert Report of Robert
Howe (01/18/2023)

12
13
14
15

Ruling

ECF No. 132

5
6

Objections

Page 24-25, ¶ 50

16
17
18
19
20
21
22

Page 6

23

ECF No. 138-7
Cahoy Dec. Ex. 14
(REBOTIX100995 REBOTIX101019)

24
25
26

Entire Document

27
28
35

1

5

Document or Portion of
Document Sought to be
Sealed
ECF No. 138-8
Cahoy Dec. Ex. 15
(REBOTIX162404 REBOTIX162424)

6

Entire Document

2
3
4

7
8
9
10
11

United States District Court
Northern District of California

Documents or Portions Thereof that Rebotix Seeks to Maintain Under Seal

12
13
14

ECF No. 173-4
Reply in Support of Motion
of Intuitive to Exclude
Testimony of K. Humphrey

Evidence offered in
Support of Sealing

17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27

Ruling

ECF No. 141

GRANTED.
Proprietary
business
information.

ECF No. 175

GRANTED.
Proprietary
business
information.

ECF No. 175

GRANTED.
Proprietary
business
information.
(Applies to
content above
Header IV.)

Page 6-7
ECF No. 173-4
Reply in Support of Motion
of Intuitive to Exclude
Testimony of K. Humphrey
Page 7 n.4

15
16

Objections

Documents or Portions Thereof that Restore Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or
Evidence Offered in Objections
Ruling
Portion of Document Support of Sealing
Sought to be Sealed
Dkt. No. 130-2
Dkt. No. 134
GRANTED.
Bero 12/02/2022
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
Proprietary business
Opening Report at 13 (3:14-3:21)
information.
Dkt. No. 130-2
Bero 12/02/2022
Opening Report at 21

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(4:1-4:7)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-2
Dkt. No. 134
Bero 12/02/2022
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
Opening Report at 31- (4:9-4:10)
32

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Redact between
“repair procedure”
and “Clifton Parker”

28
36

1
2
3
4
5
6

Documents or Portions Thereof that Restore Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or
Evidence Offered in Objections
Ruling
Portion of Document Support of Sealing
Sought to be Sealed
Dkt. No. 130-2
Dkt. No. 134
GRANTED.
Bero 12/02/2022
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
Proprietary business
Opening Report at 32 (4:11-5:8)
information.
Dkt. No. 130-2
Bero 12/02/2022
Opening Report at 44

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(5:9-5:14)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-2
Bero 12/02/2022
Opening Report at 46

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(5:16-5:19)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-2
Bero 12/02/2022
Opening Report at 57

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(5:20-5:21)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-42
Foreman 01/18/2023
Report (SIS) at 44 ¶
133

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(5:22-5:24)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-42
Foreman 01/18/2023
Report (SIS) at 44 ¶
134

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(5:25-5:27)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-42
Foreman 01/18/2023
Report (SIS) at 44 ¶
135
text only (not
footnote)

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(6:1-6:3)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-42
Foreman 01/18/2023
Report (SIS) at 44 ¶
136

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(6:4-6:5)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

7
8
9
10

Redact second
sentence

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
37

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

Documents or Portions Thereof that Restore Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or
Evidence Offered in Objections
Ruling
Portion of Document Support of Sealing
Sought to be Sealed
Dkt. No. 130-42
Dkt. No. 134
GRANTED.
Foreman 01/18/2023
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
Proprietary
Report (SIS) at 44 ¶
(6:6)
production methods.
174
Dkt. No. 130-42
Foreman 01/18/2023
Report (SIS) at 44 ¶
223

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(6:7-6.8)

GRANTED.
Proprietary
production methods.

Dkt. No. 130-42
Foreman 01/18/2023
Report (SIS) at 44 ¶
224

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(6:9-6:10)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-35
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (SIS) at 8 ¶ 19

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(6:11)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-35
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (SIS) at 23-24
¶ 46

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(6:12-6:16)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-35
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (SIS) at 24 ¶
47

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(6:17-6:18)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-35
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (SIS) at 43 ¶
75

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(6:20-6:22)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-35
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (SIS) at 66 ¶
125

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(6:23-6:24)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-35
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (SIS) at 66 ¶
127

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(6:25)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
38

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

Documents or Portions Thereof that Restore Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or
Evidence Offered in Objections
Ruling
Portion of Document Support of Sealing
Sought to be Sealed
Dkt. No. 130-35
Dkt. No. 134
GRANTED.
Howe 01/18/2023
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
Proprietary business
Report (SIS) at 73 ¶
(6:26)
information.
143
Dkt. No. 130-35
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (SIS) at 73 ¶
144

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(6:27)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-35
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (SIS) at 73-74
¶ 145

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(7:1-7:8)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-35
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (SIS) at 74-75
¶ 147

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(7:9)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-35
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (SIS) at 76 ¶
148

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(7:10)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-35
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (SIS) at 76-77
¶ 149

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(7:11)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-35
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (SIS) at 77 ¶
150

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(7:12-7:13)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-35
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (SIS) at 78 ¶
152

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(7:14-7:16)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
39

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

Documents or Portions Thereof that Restore Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or
Evidence Offered in Objections
Ruling
Portion of Document Support of Sealing
Sought to be Sealed
Dkt. No. 130-35
Dkt. No. 134
GRANTED.
Howe 01/18/2023
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
Proprietary business
Report (SIS) at 78-79 (7:17-7:19)
information.
¶ 153
Dkt. No. 130-35
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (SIS) at 79-80
¶ 154

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(7:20-7:23)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-35
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (SIS) at 80 ¶
155

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(7:25-7:26)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-35
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (SIS) at 81 ¶
158

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(8:1-8:3)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-34
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (Larkin) at 5 ¶
12

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(8:4-8:5)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(8:6-8:9)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-34
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (Larkin) at 23
¶ 49

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(8:10-8:11)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-34
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (Larkin) at 42
¶ 78

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(8:12-8:15)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20

Redact first sentence
in footnote
Dkt. No. 130-34
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (Larkin) at 2223 ¶ 48

21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
40

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17

Documents or Portions Thereof that Restore Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or
Evidence Offered in Objections
Ruling
Portion of Document Support of Sealing
Sought to be Sealed
Dkt. No. 130-34
Dkt. No. 134
GRANTED.
Howe 01/18/2023
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
Proprietary business
Report (Larkin) at 42 (8:16-8:17)
information.
¶ 79
Dkt. No. 130-34
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (Larkin) at 66
¶ 128

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(8:18)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-34
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (Larkin) at 71
¶ 142
redact parenthetical in
footnote

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(8:20-8:21)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-34
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (Larkin) at 72
¶ 145

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(8:22)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-34
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (Larkin) at 72
¶ 146

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(8:23)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-34
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (Larkin) at 7273 ¶ 147

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(8:24-9:6)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-34
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (Larkin) at 7374 ¶ 149

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(9:7)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-34
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (Larkin) at 75
¶ 150

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(9:8)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 135
Berhold Dec. ¶¶ 3-7

18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
41

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

Documents or Portions Thereof that Restore Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or
Evidence Offered in Objections
Ruling
Portion of Document Support of Sealing
Sought to be Sealed
Dkt. No. 130-34
Dkt. No. 134
GRANTED.
Howe 01/18/2023
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
Proprietary business
Report (Larkin) at 75 (9:10)
information.
¶ 151
Dkt. No. 130-34
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (Larkin) at 76
¶ 152

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(9:11-9:12)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-34
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (Larkin) at 77
¶ 155

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(9:13-9:14)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-34
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (Larkin) at 77
¶ 156
Dkt. No. 130-34
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (Larkin) at 78
¶ 157

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(9:15-9:18)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(9:19-9:21)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-34
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (Larkin) at 95
¶ 183
redact text only

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(9:23-9:27)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-34
Howe 01/18/2023
Report (Larkin) at 95
¶ 184

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(10:1-10:2)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(10:5)

GRANTED.
Proprietary
production method.

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27

Redact first sentence
in footnote only
Dkt. No. 130-16
Att. 3, Humphrey
12/2/2022 Opening
Report at 13 ¶ 33

28
42

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

Documents or Portions Thereof that Restore Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or
Evidence Offered in Objections
Ruling
Portion of Document Support of Sealing
Sought to be Sealed
Dkt. No. 130-16
Dkt. No. 134
GRANTED.
Att. 3, Humphrey
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
Proprietary business
12/2/2022 Opening
(10:6-10:9)
information.
Report at 13 ¶ 34
Dkt. No. 130-16
Att. 3, Humphrey
12/2/2022 Opening
Report at 13-14 ¶ 35

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(10:10-10:11)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-29
Parnell 03/01/2023
Rebuttal Report
(Larkin) at 131 ¶ 292

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(10:12-10:15)

GRANTED.
Proprietary
production method.

Dkt. No. 130-29
Parnell 03/01/2023
Rebuttal Report
(Larkin) at 131 ¶ 293

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(10:18-10:19)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-30
Parnell 03/01/2023
Rebuttal Report (SIS)
at 111-12 ¶ 264

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(10:20-10:23)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-4
Dkt. No. 134
Smith 01/18/2023
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
Rebuttal Report at 12- (11:1)
13 ¶ 23

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-4
Dkt. No. 134
Smith 01/18/2023
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
Rebuttal Report at 14- (11:2-11:3)
15 ¶ 25

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-41
01/18/2023 Reply
Report (Foreman) at
39 ¶ 118-119

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(11:4-11:7)
Dkt. No. 135
Berhold Dec. ¶¶ 3-7

27
28
43

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9

Documents or Portions Thereof that Restore Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or
Evidence Offered in Objections
Ruling
Portion of Document Support of Sealing
Sought to be Sealed
Dkt. No. 130-41
Dkt. No. 134
GRANTED.
01/18/2023 Reply
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
Proprietary business
Report (Foreman) at
(11:8-11:11)
information.
40 ¶ 121-122
Dkt. No. 135
Berhold Dec. ¶¶ 3-7
Dkt. No. 130-41
01/18/2023 Reply
Report (Foreman) at
40 ¶ 122-124

United States District Court
Northern District of California

12
13

Dkt. No. 130-41
01/18/2023 Reply
Report (Foreman) at
40-41 ¶ 125

16
17

Dkt. No. 130-41
01/18/2023 Reply
Report (Foreman) at
41 ¶ 125-127

20
21

Dkt. No. 130-41
01/18/2023 Reply
Report (Foreman) at
42 ¶ 128-129

24
25
26

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(11:20-11:23)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(11:24-11:25)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 135
Berhold Dec. ¶¶ 3-7

22
23

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 135
Berhold Dec. ¶¶ 3-7

18
19

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(11:16-11:19)
Dkt. No. 135
Berhold Dec. ¶¶ 3-7

14
15

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 135
Berhold Dec. ¶¶ 3-7

10
11

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(11:12-11:15)

Dkt. No. 130-41
01/18/2023 Reply
Report (Foreman) at
42-43 ¶ 131

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(12:1-12:3)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 135
Berhold Dec. ¶¶ 3-7

27
28
44

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

Documents or Portions Thereof that Restore Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or
Evidence Offered in Objections
Ruling
Portion of Document Support of Sealing
Sought to be Sealed
Dkt. No. 130-41
Dkt. No. 134
GRANTED.
01/18/2023 Reply
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
Proprietary business
Report (Foreman) at
(12:4-12:7)
information.
43 ¶ 131-132
Dkt. No. 130-41
01/18/2023 Reply
Report (Foreman) at
43 ¶ 133-134

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(12:8-12:11)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-41
01/18/2023 Reply
Report (Foreman) at
46 ¶ 139, 141

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(12:12-12:13)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-41
01/18/2023 Reply
Report (Foreman) at
47 ¶ 142

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(12:14-12:15)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14

Dkt. No. 135
Berhold Dec. ¶¶ 3-7

15
16
17

Dkt. No. 130-41
01/18/2023 Reply
Report (Foreman) at
56-57 ¶ 174

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(12:16-12:17)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-41
Trautman 01/18/2023
Reply Report
(Foreman) at 64 ¶ 205

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(12:18-12:19)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-41
01/18/2023 Reply
Report (Foreman) at
69 ¶ 223-224

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(12:20-12:21)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 130-41
01/18/2023 Reply
Report (Foreman) at
69-70 ¶ 224

Dkt. No. 134
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
(12:22-12:23)

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
45

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12

Documents or Portions Thereof that Restore Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or
Evidence Offered in Objections
Ruling
Portion of Document Support of Sealing
Sought to be Sealed
Dkt. No. 130-41
Dkt. No. 134
GRANTED.
01/18/2023 Reply
Parker Dec. ¶¶ 3-5
Proprietary business
Report (Foreman) at
(12:24-12:25)
information.
73-74 ¶ 233
Dkt. No. 138-25
Cahoy Dec. Ex. 39,
Deposition of Clifton
Parker (May 4, 2021)

Dkt. No. 138-25
Cahoy Dec. Ex. 39,
Deposition of Clifton
Parker (May 4, 2021)
Pages 213-216

14

Dkt. No. 138-43

15

17

Cahoy Dec. Ex. 95
Deposition of Clifton
Parker (October 25,
2022)

18

Pages 31-32

19

Dkt. No. 138-44
Cahoy Dec. Ex. 96
Deposition of Kevin
May (November 3,
2022)

20
21

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 140

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 140

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 140

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 140

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Pages 204-205

13

16

Dkt. No. 140

22
23
24

Page 60
Dkt. No. 138-24
Cahoy Dec. Ex. 38

25
26
27

Restore-00001248 Restore-00001256
Attached as Ex.1.

28
46

6

Documents or Portions Thereof that Restore Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or
Evidence Offered in Objections
Ruling
Portion of Document Support of Sealing
Sought to be Sealed
Dkt. No. 138-28
Dkt. No. 140
GRANTED.
Cahoy Dec. Ex. 42
Proprietary business
information.
Restore-00086093 Restore-00086120
Attached as Ex. 2.

7

Dkt. No. 130-29

8

Parnell 03/01/2023
Rebuttal Report

1
2
3
4
5

9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13
14
15
16

Dkt. No. 158

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 158

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 158

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 170

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Page 120 ¶ 268
Restore-00089490, at
-9493
Dkt. No. 130-29
Parnell 03/01/2023
Rebuttal Report
Page 120 ¶ 269
Restore-00089490, at
-9493

17
Dkt. No. 130-29
18
19
20

Parnell 03/01/2023
Rebuttal Report

22

Page 120 ¶ 270
Restore-00089490, at
-9493-95, -9495,
9496-9467

23

Dkt. No. 161-61

21

24
25

Expert Report of Kurt
Humphrey

26

Pages 13-14

27
28
47

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12
13

Documents or Portions Thereof that Restore Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or
Evidence Offered in Objections
Ruling
Portion of Document Support of Sealing
Sought to be Sealed
Dkt. No. 161-24
Dkt. No. 170
GRANTED.
Proprietary business
Expert Report of Dr.
information.
T. Kim Parnell
(March 1,
2023)
Pages 110-111
Restore-00086093 –
Restore-00086120
Testing Protocols
Production Methods
510(k) Submission
Regulatory Strategy
* See ECF No. 140 at
6 and
ECF No. 140-2.
Dkt. No. 161-24

Dkt. No. 170

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 170

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 170

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

14
15
16
17

Expert Report of Dr.
T. Kim Parnell
(March 1,
2023)
Page 112

18
19

Dkt. No. 161-63

21

Deposition of Clifton
Parker (October 25,
2022)

22

Pages 141-142

23

Dkt. No. 161-22

20

24
25

Deposition of Kevin
May (November 3,
2022)

26
27

Page 60

28
48

1
2
3
4
5

Documents or Portions Thereof that Restore Seeks to Maintain Under Seal
Document or
Evidence Offered in Objections
Ruling
Portion of Document Support of Sealing
Sought to be Sealed
Dkt. No. 161-22
Dkt. No. 170
GRANTED.
Proprietary business
Deposition of Kevin
information and nonMay (November 3,
public financial
2022)
information.

6
Pages 75-76
7
8

10

Deposition of Kevin
May (November 3,
2022)

11

Pages 89-90

9

United States District Court
Northern District of California

Dkt. No. 161-22

12
13
14
15
16

Dkt. No. 161-22

Dkt. No. 170

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Dkt. No. 176

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Pages 89-90
Dkt. No. 173-6

18

Defendant’s Reply
Brief in Support of
Motion of
Intuitive to Exclude
Testimony of R. Bero

20

GRANTED.
Proprietary business
information.

Deposition of Kevin
May (November 3,
2022)

17

19

Dkt. No. 170

21
Page 6
22
23
24

IT IS SO ORDERED.
Dated: April 1, 2024

25
26
27

ARACELI MARTÍNEZ-OLGUÍN
United States District Judge

28
49