Armstrong, et al v. Davis, et al

Filing 1942

ORDER Granting 1941 Proposed Order for Payment of Attorney's Fees for 2010 and the First Quarter of 2011, Pursuant to the Court's August 8, 2011 Order, with Exhibits A-D. Signed by Judge Claudia Wilken on 10/3/20112. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibits)(ndr, COURT STAFF) (Filed on 10/3/2011)

EXHIBIT A

Armstrong v. Brown
Summary of Fees Owed Pursuant to August 8, 2011 Order (Dkt. No. 1919)
Q1 2010 through Q1 2011 (January 1, 2010 through March 31, 2011)
CDCR/AOAP Monitoring Work

Undisputed

2008

2010

Between 2008

Hours

Rates

Rates

and 2010 Rates

Michael W. Bien (MWB)
Gay C. Grunfeld (GCG)
Ernest Galvan (EG)
Tom Nolan (TN)
Holly M. Baldwin (HMB)
Amy Whelan (AEW)
Lisa Ells (LAE)
Aaron Fischer (AJF)
Mark Feeser (MRF)
Blake Thompson (BT)

55.22
223.90
5.03
721.69
11.39
187.61
408.05
3.95
173.40
551.29

$640
$475
$450
$440
$425
$370
$295
$340
$270
$270

$700
$575
$560
$510
$490
$430
$360
$345
$325
$325

$60
$100
$110
$70
$65
$60
$65
$5
$55
$55

$3,313.47
$22,389.70
$553.74
$50,518.62
$740.35
$11,256.42
$26,522.96
$19.74
$9,537.17
$30,320.84

Michael Freedman (MLF)
Anita Nabha (AN)
Sofia Milham (SAM)
Josephine Weinberg (JBW)
Karen Stilber (KES)
Ritika Aggarwal (RA)
Matt Harrison (MRH)
Haruka Roudebush (HR)
Misha Goodwin (NMG)
Claire Hoffmann (CAH)
Hugo Cabrera (HDC
Paralegal Rate
Hugo Cabrera (HDC)
Litigation Assistant Rate

377.43
24.10
120.37
315.71
16.30
1.80
278.11
702.69
6.55
214.89

$295
$250
$180
$200
$210
$170
$170
$170
$125
$160

$305
$285
$225
$220
$240
$200
$200
$200
$200
$200

$10
$35
$45
$20
$30
$30
$30
$30
$75
$40

$3,774.26
$843.50
$5,416.56
$6,314.28
$488.88
$54.00
$8,343.42
$21,080.75
$491.10
$8,595.66

63.40

$170

$200

$30

$1,902.00

682.24

$160

$185

$25

$17,055.93

99.60

$170

$200

$30

$2,988.00

444.04
1.50

$160
$160

$185
$185

$25
$25

$11,100.93
$37.60

581-3
Attorney/Law Firm

Principal
Due

ROSEN BIEN & GALVAN

Marc Shinn-Krantz (MSK)
Paralegal Rate
Marc Shinn-Krantz (MSK)
Litigation Assistant Rate
Elizabeth Hennessey (ESH)
TOTAL RBG

5690.26

$243,659.85

CDCR/AOAP Monitoring Work (Continued)
Undisputed

2008

2010

Between 2008

Hours

Rates

Rates

and 2010 Rates

Donald Specter (DS)
Judith Rosenberg (JR)
Steve Fama (SF)
Susan Christian (SDC)
Sara Norman (SN)
Alison Hardy (AH)
Millard Murphy (MM)
Rebekah Evenson (RE)
Megan Hagler (MH)
Penny Godbold (PG)
Kelly Knapp (KK)
Rana Anabtawi (RA)
Vincent Quan (VC)
Anna Darby (AD)
Miriam Rubenson (MR)
Julia Lum (JL)
Emma Rosenberg (ER)
Riley Evans (RDE)
Nila Natavahan (NN)

23.62
53.60
0.19
124.33
169.23
0.49
30.89
385.59
910.25
327.09
1.13
327.14
358.62
163.05
0.30
0.28
354.31
7.85
18.33

$615
$570
$550
$475
$430
$455
$460
$380
$340
$340
$270
$250
$170
$170
$170
$170
$170
$170
$170

$700
$650
$650
$550
$530
$510
$510
$470
$390
$390
$315
$275
$180
$180
$180
$180
$180
$180
$180

$85
$80
$100
$75
$100
$55
$50
$90
$50
$50
$45
$25
$10
$10
$10
$10
$10
$10
$10

$2,007.70
$4,288.00
$18.80
$9,324.60
$16,923.30
$26.84
$1,544.58
$34,703.19
$45,512.50
$16,354.55
$50.76
$8,178.40
$3,586.23
$1,630.48
$3.00
$2.81
$3,543.12
$78.54
$183.30

Galen Currens (GC)

82.14

$170

$180

$10

$821.43

Eddie DeGraff (ED)

0.47
3,338.90

$150

$170

$20

$9.36
$148,791.48

$565

$40

$265.52

581-3

Attorney/Law Firm

Principal
Due

PRISON LAW OFFICE

TOTAL PLO

DISABILITY RIGHTS EDUCATION AND DEFENSE FUND
Linda Kilb (LDK)

6.64
TOTAL DREDF

Total Monitoring - All Offices

10.84

9,040.00

$525

$265.52

$392,716.85

Armstrong v. Brown
Summary of Fees Owed Pursuant to August 8, 2011 Order (Dkt. No. 1919)
Q1 2010 through Q1 2011 (January 1, 2010 through March 31, 2011)
CDCR/AOAP Fees Work
581-2
Attorney/Law Firm
ROSEN BIEN & GALVAN
Sanford Jay Rosen (SJR)
Michael W. Bien (MWB)
Ernest Galvan (EG)
Holly M. Baldwin (HMB)
Maria V. Morris (MVM)
Kenneth Walczak (KMW)
Blake Thompson (BT)
Sumana Cooppan (SC)
Anita Nabha (AN)
Karen Stilber (KES)
Sofia Milham (SAM)

Between 2008

Undisputed
Hours

2008
Rates

2010
Rates

and 2010 Rates

36.92
34.28
58.41
139.87
205.51
3.20
7.51
8.37
2.20
3.80
38.61

$740
$640
$450
$425
$370
$340
$270
$250
$250
$210
$180

$800
$700
$560
$490
$430
$390
$325
$285
$285
$240
$225

$60
$60
$110
$65
$60
$50
$55
$35
$35
$30
$45

$2,215.20
$2,056.56
$6,425.54
$9,091.58
$12,330.60
$160.00
$413.16
$293.02
$77.00
$114.00
$1,737.54

Misha Goodwin (NMG)

12.54

$125

$200

$75

$940.80

Paralegal Rate

$150

$200

$50

TOTAL RBG

39.76
562.61

$1,988.10
$38,882.30

$615
$430
$340
$150

$700
$530
$390
$170

$85
$100
$50
$20

TOTAL PLO

0.18
2.32
0.35
15.15
17.99

$14.96
$231.80
$17.60
$302.92
$567.28

$585

$655

$70

TOTAL BMc

8.66
8.66

$606.20
$606.20

$565

$40

$168.32
$168.32

PRISON LAW OFFICE
Donald Spector (DS)
Sara Norman (SN)
Megan Hagler (MH)
Edie DeGraff (ED)

BINGHAM MCCUTCHEN
Geoffrey T. Holtz (GH)

Principal
Due

DISABILITY RIGHTS EDUCATION AND DEFENSE FUND
Linda Kilb (LDK)
TOTAL DREDF

Total Fees - All Offices

4.21
4.21

593.47

$525

$40,224.10

EXHIBIT B

Armstrong v. Brown
Summary of Fees Owed Pursuant to August 8, 2011 Order (Dkt. No. 1919)
Q1 2010 through Q1 2011 (January 1, 2010 through March 31, 2011)
BPH Monitoring Work
581-4
Attorney/Law Firm

Between 2008

Undisputed
Hours

2008
Rates

2010
Rates

and 2010 Rates

Principal
Due

36.81
114.96
6.55
129.08
148.37
86.42
1.80
151.86
26.16

$640
$475
$450
$440
$425
$370
$370
$360
$340

$700
$575
$560
$510
$490
$430
$430
$415
$390

$60
$100
$110
$70
$65
$60
$60
$55
$50

$2,208.72
$11,495.95
$720.94
$9,035.50
$9,644.08
$5,185.05
$108.00
$8,352.52
$1,307.85

52.30
3.64
117.40
285.01
4.90
89.29
11.37
8.37
100.75
22.49
32.56
39.39
19.34
46.38

$290
$295
$340
$270
$295
$295
$250
$225
$210
$170
$170
$170
$170
$125

$390
$360
$345
$325
$305
$305
$285
$275
$240
$200
$200
$215
$200
$200

$100
$65
$5
$55
$10
$10
$35
$50
$30
$30
$30
$45
$30
$75

$5,230.00
$236.47
$586.99
$15,675.66
$49.00
$892.88
$398.09
$418.30
$3,022.46
$674.57
$976.68
$1,772.37
$580.23
$3,478.35

5.30

$170

$200

$30

$159.00

25.06

$160

$185

$25

$626.40

41.40

$170

$200

$30

$1,242.00

102.23

$160

$185

$25

$2,555.63

ROSEN BIEN & GALVAN
Michael W. Bien (MWB)
Gay C. Grunfeld (GCG)
Ernest Galvan (EG)
Tom Nolan (TN)
Holly M. Baldwin (HMB)
Maria Morris (MVM)
Amy Whelan (AW)
Shirley Huey (SH)
Kenneth Walczak (KMW)
Kenneth Walczak (KMW)
Q1 2010
Lisa Ells (LAE)
Aaron Fischer (AJF)
Blake Thompson (BT)
Bahareh Mostajelean (BMM)
Michael Freedman (MLF)
Sumana Cooppan (SC)
Kevin Jones (KEJ)
Karen Stilber (KES)
Ritika Aggarwal (RSA)
Matthew Harrison (MRH)
Leslie Thornton (LAT)
Haruka Roudebush (HR)
Misha Goodwin (NMG)
Elizabeth Hennessey (ESH)
Paralegal Rate
Elizabeth Hennessey (ESH)
Litigation Assistant Rate
Hugo Cabrera (HDC)
Paralegal
Hugo Cabrera (HDC)
Litigation Assistant Rate
TOTAL RBG

1709.17

$86,633.67

Bingham, McCutchen
Geoffrey T. Holtz (GH)
Tracey D. Berger (TB)
Frank Busch (FB)

$585
$345
$285

$655
$480
$400

$70
$135
$115

TOTAL BMc

0.84
177.92
11.65
190.41

494.68
494.68

$475

$550

$75

TOTAL PLO

$59.08
$24,018.53
$1,340.27
$25,417.87

Prison Law Office
Susan Christian (SDC)

Total Monitoring - All Offices

2,394.26

$37,101.34

$37,101.34

$149,152.88

Armstrong v. Brown
Summary of Fees Owed Pursuant to August 8, 2011 Order (Dkt. No. 1919)
Q1 2010 through Q1 2011 (January 1, 2010 through March 31, 2011)
BPH Fees Work
581-4A
Attorney/Law Firm

Between 2008

Undisputed
Hours

2008
Rate

2010
Rate

and 2010 Rates

0.28
0.94
19.18
2.54
11.28
3.42

$475
$450
$425
$270
$180
$125

$575
$560
$490
$325
$225
$200

$100
$110
$65
$55
$45
$75

Principal
Due

ROSEN BIEN & GALVAN
Gay C. Grunfeld (GCG)
Ernest Galvan (EG)
Holly M. Baldwin (HMB)
Blake Thompson (BT)
Sofia Milham (SAM)
Misha Goodwin (NMG)

TOTAL RBG

37.64

$28.20
$103.40
$1,246.73
$139.59
$507.47
$256.50

$2,281.89

PRISON LAW OFFICE
Edie DeGraff (ED)

4.04

TOTAL PLO

$150

$170

$20

4.04

$80.78

$80.78

Bingham, McCutchen
Geoffrey T. Holtz (GH)

0.50

TOTAL BMc
Total Fees - All Offices

$585

$655

$70

$35.00

0.50

$35.00

42.18

$2,397.67

EXHIBIT C

Armstrong v. Brown
Summary of Fees Owed Pursuant to August 8, 2011 Order (Dkt. No. 1919)
Q1 2010 through Q1 2011 (January 1, 2010 through March 31, 2011)
DAPO Monitoring Work

581-9

Between
2008

Undisputed

2008

2010

Hours

Rates

Rates

and 2010 Rates

Michael W. Bien (MWB)
Gay C. Grunfeld (GCG)
Ernest Galvan (EG)
Holly M. Baldwin (HMB)
Kenneth M. Walczak (KMW)
Mark Feeser (MRF)
Blake Thompson (BT)
Bahareh Mostajelean (BMM)
Michael Freedman (MLF)
Sumana Cooppan (SC)
Sofia Milham (SAM)
Karen Stilber (KES)
Misha Goodwin (NMG)
Claire Hoffmann (CAH)
Matt Harrison (MRH)
Marc Shinn-Krantz (MSK)
Haruka Roudebush (HR)
Elizabeth Hennessey (ESH)
Hugo Cabrera (HDC)
TOTAL RBG

5.26
47.68
6.50
61.95
148.59
1.50
4.90
1.10
1.50
300.39
1.80
132.26
147.49
22.81
116.82
1.10
7.02
13.63
1.00
1023.28

$640
$475
$450
$425
$340
$270
$270
$295
$295
$250
$180
$210
$125
$160
$170
$170
$170
$160
$160

$700
$575
$560
$490
$390
$325
$325
$305
$305
$285
$225
$240
$200
$200
$200
$200
$200
$185
$185

$60
$100
$110
$65
$50
$55
$55
$10
$10
$35
$45
$30
$75
$40
$30
$30
$30
$25
$25

Total Monitoring - All Offices

1,023.28

Attorney/Law Firm

Principal
Due

ROSEN BIEN & GALVAN
$315.39
$4,767.70
$715.50
$4,026.56
$7,429.60
$82.28
$269.28
$11.00
$14.96
$10,513.79
$81.00
$3,967.65
$11,061.75
$912.32
$3,504.69
$33.00
$210.54
$340.75
$25.00
$48,282.75

$48,282.75

Armstrong v. Brown
Summary of Fees Owed Pursuant to August 8, 2011 Order (Dkt. No. 1919)
Q1 2010 through Q1 2011 (January 1, 2010 through March 31, 2011)
DAPO Fees Work
581-10

Between
2008

Undisputed

2008

2010

Attorney/Law Firm

Hours

Rates

Rates

and 2010 Rates

Ernest Galvan (EG)
Holly M. Baldwin (HMB)
Sofia Milham (SAM)
Misha Goodwin (NMG)

0.75
2.91
6.29
2.26
12.20

$450
$425
$180
$125

$560
$490
$225
$200

$110.00
$65.00
$45.00
$75.00

TOTAL RBG

Total Monitoring - All Offices

12.2015

Principal
Due
$82.72
$189.02
$282.85
$169.20
$723.79

$723.79

EXHIBIT D

EXHIBIT D FEES OWED TO PLAINTIFFS PURSUANT TO THE COURT'S 8/8/11 ORDER

Description

Amount Owed

Interest
Rate

Daily
Interest

Next
Compounding
Date

Amount Owed
Including Interest
through 9/29/11

CDCR/AOAP - 1st Qtr 2010
(581-2/581-3)

$72,932.25

0.28%

$0.56

6/14/2012

$73,196.57

BPH - 1st Qtr 2010
(581-4/581-4a)

$31,783.50

0.28%

$0.24

6/14/2012

$31,896.78

$5,216.50

0.28%

$0.04

6/14/2012

$5,235.38

$102,248.79

0.22%

$0.62

9/18/2011

$102,481.91

$24,960.76

0.22%

$0.15

9/18/2011

$25,193.88

$9,397.22

0.22%

$0.06

9/18/2011

$9,630.34

CDCR/AOAP - 3rd Qtr 2010
(581-2/581-3)

$92,066.16

0.30%

$0.76

11/18/2011

$92,305.56

BPH - 3rd Qtr 2010
(581-4/581-4a)

$29,807.87

0.30%

$0.24

11/18/2011

$30,047.27

DAPO - 3rd Qtr 2010
(581-9/581-10)

$10,787.44

0.30%

$0.09

11/18/2011

$11,026.84

CDCR/AOAP - 4th Qtr 2010
(581-2/581-3)

$86,066.74

0.26%

$0.61

2/28/2012

$86,196.67

BPH - 4th Qtr 2010
(581-4/581-4a)

$35,924.92

0.26%

$0.26

2/28/2012

$36,054.85

$9,252.42

0.26%

$0.07

2/28/2012

$9,382.35

CDCR/AOAP - 1st Qtr 2011
(581-2/581-3)

$79,627.00

0.18%

$0.39

5/23/2012

$79,700.53

BPH - 1st Qtr 2011
(581-4/581-4a)

$29,073.50

0.18%

$0.14

5/23/2012

$29,147.03

DAPO - 1st Qtr 2011
(581-9/581-10)

$14,352.96

0.18%

$0.07

5/23/2012

$14,426.49

DAPO - 1st Qtr 2010
(581-9/581-10)
CDCR/AOAP - 2nd Qtr 2010
(581-2/581-3)
BPH - 2nd Qtr 2010
(581-4/581-4a)
DAPO - 2nd Qtr 2010
(581-9/581-10)

DAPO - 4th Qtr 2010
(581-9/581-10)

TOTAL CDCR/AOAP

$432,940.94

$433,881.24

TOTAL BPH

$151,550.55

$152,339.81

$49,006.54

$49,701.40

$633,498.03

$635,922.45

TOTAL DAPO

GRAND TOTAL

Page 1