O'Bannon, Jr. v. National Collegiate Athletic Association et al

Filing 271

Exhibit List Joint Final Trial Exhibit List by Edward C. O'Bannon, Jr... (Bojedla, Swathi) (Filed on 7/1/2014)

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
For the Northern District of California
Case No._________09-CV-3329-CW_________

Date______June 9, 2014______________________

O’Bannon, et al. v. National Collegiate Athletic Association, et al.
JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
EX.
NO.
62
73
75
112

160
181
248
269
270
275
280
281
283

293

DESCRIPTION

SPONSOR WITNESS

DATE
ADMITTED

NBA Uniform Player Contract between
Sam Jacobson and the Lakers
Release Agreement between Harry
Flournoy and Panini America, Inc.
Harry Flournoy trading card listing from
eBay
Facsimile attaching Release Agreement
between David Lattin and Panini
America, Inc.
Thought Equity Talent Clearance
Release
Arena Football One, LLC Standard
Player Contract
07/19/06 Minutes of the Student-Athlete
Likeness Meeting
08/29/08 Email from David Berst to
Myles Brand
09/04/2008 Email from Myles Brand to
David Berst
11/20/07 Email from Greg Shaheen to
David Knopp
10/13/08 Email chain between David
Berst and Beth Debauche
10/14/09 Meeting notes - David Berst
09/03/10 Email from David Berst to Jim
Isch and Lorry Weaver [responding to
email from Isch to Berst, Greg Shaheen,
Scott Bearby, Wally Renfro, Joni
Comstock, Bernard Franklin, Keith
Martin, Mike Racy, Dan Dutcher, Bob
Williams and Kevin Lennon]
02/06/03 Email from Greg Weitekamp
to Kellie Carroll

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

Stipulation, ECF 259

6/30/2014

Emmert, Mark

6/20/2014

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

Order, ECF 264
Stipulation, ECF 259
Stipulation, ECF 239

6/30/2014
[not for truth]
6/30/2014
6/23/2014

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

1

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
EX.
NO.

SPONSOR WITNESS

DESCRIPTION

DATE
ADMITTED

298

05/09/09 Email from Greg Shaheen to
David Knopp

Emmert, Mark

6/20/2014

300

06/01/10 Email from Greg Weitekamp
to Ronnie Ramos and Brad Alderson

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

303

03/01/07 Email from Peter Davis to
Jordan Edelstein, Erika Austin, Jim
Haynes, Tyler Vaught, Jeramy
Michiaels
07/14/03 Email from Heidi Clarke to
Peter Davis

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

Stipulation, ECF 259

6/30/2014

308

10/11/04 Email from Greg Weitekamp
to Peter Davis

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

332

04/22/08 Email from David Knopp to
Greg Weitekamp, Dave Schnase, Peter
Davis, and Jim Haynes
03/04/09 Email from Peter Davis to
Joan Scott

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

NCAA Corporate Champion and
Corporate Partner (CC/P) Marketing
Guidelines
06/04/10 Multi-Media Agreement
between Turner Broadcasting System,
Inc., CBS Broadcasting Inc., and the
National Collegiate Athletic Association
[FILED UNDER SEAL, redacted public
version at 400R]
10/17/10 Email from Wally Renfro to
Mark Emmert, forwarded to Diane
Young by Mark Emmert
12/11/02 Facsimile attaching Executed
Player Contracts

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

Stipulation, ECF 223

6/17/2014

Stipulation, ECF 211

6/13/2014

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

552

10/27/05 Email from Michael Drucker
(CLC) to Lizzle Singian

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

556

02/21/07 Email from Peter Davis to
Cory Moss, other CLC and NCAA
employees
Photo of Bill Russell Wheaties Box

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

305

336
339

400

424

498

650

2

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
EX.
NO.
682
700
702

DESCRIPTION

SPONSOR WITNESS

DATE
ADMITTED

Supplement No. 1 - Summary of Invited
Guest Comments
NCAA Names Presentation, organizer
Todd Sitrin, attendee Tom Goedde
11/07/07 Email from David Kirkpatrick
to Jeremy Strauser

Plonsky, Chris

6/17/2014

Stipulation, ECF 239
Stipulation, ECF 239

pp. 31-34
6/23/2014
6/23/2014

719

11/04/05 Email from David Knopp to
Greg Shaheen

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

730

Promotional Activities, NCAA Bylaw
12.5, Pre and Post-Enrollment

Emmert, Mark

6/20/2014

735

05/0406 Interpretation re: Student
Athlete image use, response from Bo
Kerin
08/25/05 Email from Kevin Lennon to
Bo Kerin, Steve Mallonee, Ellen Ferris,
and Wendy Walters
07/14/06 Email from Myles Brand to
Kevin Lennon, David Berst, Bernard
Franklin, and Greg Shaheen
07/13/07 Email from Todd Sitrin to
Jordan Edelstein and Joel Linzner

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/22//2014

Emmert, Mark

6/20/2014

Stipulation, ECF 259

6/30/2014

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

Delany, Jim

6/20/2014

Garnham, Chase

6/16/2013

Stipulation, ECF 260

pp. 1, 6, 8
6/30/14

826

835

938
1005
1022
1028

Big Ten Conference Student Athlete
Name and Likeness Release
08/01 Email from Candice Storey to
Chase Garnham
Screenshots of Vanderbilt Player
Number 36 in EA Sports Video Game

1042

University of Arizona Student
Handbook

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

1047

University of Minnesota Student
Handbook

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

1111

NBA Broadcast or Telecast Rights
[excerpted]
EA-CLC License Agreement NCAA
Football [redacted]

Stipulation, ECF 260

6/30/2014

Linzner, Joel

p. 7
6/18/2014

Stipuation, ECF 259

pp. 1-7, 10-16, 23,
28-32, 34
6/30/2014

1125

3

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
EX.
NO.
1126

DESCRIPTION

SPONSOR WITNESS

1133
2000

2006
2007
2011

2012

2013

2016

Linzner, Joel

08/13/07 Email correspondence among
CLC executives [David Kirkpatrick,
Derek Eiler, Cory Moss, Pat Battle;
earlier emails include: Wendy Harmon
and Cathy Aldridge]
06/09/04 Agent and Amateurism
Subcommittee Meeting presentation
03/29/04 Email from Bill Saum to
Dennis Cryder, Wallace Renfro, David
Knopp, and others, attaching Discussion
of Legislative Issue regarding NCAA
Bylaw 12.5.2
03/16/05 Email from Myles Brand to
Greg Shaheen
04/15/05 EA Sports NCAA Overview
presentation slides
01/04/06 Email from Greg Shaheen to
Scott Bearby, David Knopp, Peter
Davis, and Greg Weitekamp, attaching
State of the Association Speech
01/04/06 Email forwarding from Bob
Williams to Wally Renfro, Dennis
Cryder, and Erik Christianson a
12/22/05 email from Gail Dent to Bob
Williams
01/09/06 Emails between Kit Walsh and
Scott Bouyack [original email from
Jennifer Jernstedt to Christine Plonsky]
05/15/06 Email from Jim Isch to Myles
Brand, Abe Frank, Todd Petr, and
Wally Renfro, and Abe Frank Letter to
Congress

4

p. 6
6/18/2014

Stipulation, ECF 259

1127

EA-CLC License Agreement NCAA
Basketball [redacted]

DATE
ADMITTED

Stipulation, ECF 259

pp. 1-7, 10-16, 22,
28-34, 36
6/30/2014
6/30/2014

Stipulation, ECF 238

6/23/2014

Rubinfeld, Daniel

pp. 1, 2
6/27/2014

Emmert, Mark

6/20/2014

Linzner, Joel
Emmert, Mark

6/18/2014
[not for truth]
6/20/2014

Emmert, Mark

6/20/2014

Plonsky, Chris

p. 2
6/17/2014

Petr, Todd

6/23/2014

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
EX.
NO.
2017

2018

2020

2021
2023

2026

2027
2029
2033
2037

2038
2045

2046

DESCRIPTION

SPONSOR WITNESS

10/06 Report issued by the Presidential
Task Force on the Future of Division I
Intercollegiate Athletics entitled The
Second-Century Imperatives,
Presidential Leadership – Institutional
Accountability
[excerpted]

Plonsky, Chris

10/05/06 Timeline of Agent and
Amateurism Subcommittee's
Promotional Activities Discussions
(February 2004-June 2006)
01/11/07 NCAA Study Group on Use of
SA NIL, Summary of Invited Guest
Comments
03/02/07 Email from Joel Linzner to
Greg Shaheen and Pat Battle
08/19/07 Email chain among Greg
Shaheen, Myles Brand and Tom
Jernstedt
11/21/07 Email from David Knopp to
Kevin Lennon, Greg Shaheen, Wendy
Walters, Leeland Zeller, Scott Bearby,
David Berst and Jim Haynes
01/02/08 Email from Kevin Lennon to
Leeland Zeller and David Knopp
01/05/08 Email chain among David
Berst, Myles Brand, and Greg Shaheen
02/21/08 Email from Vicki McEachran
to David Berst, with CAIA attachments
07/28/08 Email Chain among Greg
Shaheen, Myles Brand, David Berst,
Wally Renfro, Beth Debauche, Bob
Williams, Scott Bearby, David Knopp,
Greg Weitekamp, Bernard Franklin,
Kevin Lennon
08/26/08 Memorandum from Myles
Brand to university presidents
10/17/08 Email from David Berst,
attaching Report of the October 6, 2008
NCAA Division I Task Force Meeting
12/08/08 Email from Betsy Altmaier to
Task Force on Commercial Activity
[forwarded from Graham Spanier to
David Berst]
5

DATE
ADMITTED
pp. 8, 9, 25, 59, 62
6/16/2014

Plonsky, Chris

pp. 2-3, 11-16, 1824, 26, 29-30, 3541, 43, 53-56, 5961
6/30/2014
6/17/2014

Stipulation, ECF 259

6/30/2014

Subject of Pending
Motion, ECF 256
Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

Emmert, Mark

6/20/2014

Plonsky, Chris

6/17/2014

Plonsky, Chris

6/17/2014

Plonsky, Chris
Emmert, Mark

pp. 27-30
6/17/2014
6/19/2014

Stipulation, ECF 259

6/30/2014

Plonsky, Chris

6/17/2014

Order, ECF 264

6/30/2014
[not for truth]

Stipulation, ECF 259

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
EX.
NO.
2047

2049
2054

2057

2059

2062

2065

2074

2078

DESCRIPTION

SPONSOR WITNESS

DATE
ADMITTED

01/12/09 Email from David Berst
attaching Final Report of the NCAA
Task Force on Commercial Activity in
Division I Intercollegiate Athletics
02/22/09 Email from Wally Renfro to
Myles Brand and David Berst
03/07/09 Email from Joe Dunn
responding to Peter Davis’ original
message which included: CBS, CLC,
IMG, and Host Communications
06/04/09 Email from Greg Shaheen to
Jamie Zaninovich attaching The NCAA,
Bundled Rights, Basketball & More
presentation slides
07/19/09 Email from Greg Shaheen to
Brenda Butz, attaching Thought Equity
Summit Powerpoint and Agenda
12/14/09 Email from Joe Dunn to Erika
Austin and Peter Davis [original email
from Moya Nickodem to Dave
Kirkpatrick, David Bertram and Boyd
Kendall; Kirkpatrick forwarded to Erika
Austin, Cory Moss, C. Aldridge and
David Bertram; Austin forwarded to
Peter Davis and Joe Dunn]
05/14/10 Email from Wally Renfro to
Lydia Sanchez and Diane Young,
attaching Presidential Briefing
Documents
10/11/10 Email from Lorry Weaver (on
behalf of Jim Isch) to self, attaching
NCAA Strategic Communication Plan
October 1, 2010
2010 GOALS study presentation, pulled
from the NCAA's website at
http://www.ncaa.org/sites/default/files/
DI_GOALS_FARA_final_1.pdf.

Stipulation, ECF 211

6/13/2014

Emmert, Mark

6/20/2014

Emmert, Mark

6/20/2014

Stipulation, ECF 239

p. 1
6/23/2014

Stipulation, ECF 239

pp. 1, 2
6/23/2014

Emmert, Mark

6/20/2014

Emmert, Mark

6/20/2014

Emmert, Mark

6/19/2014

Staurowsky, Ellen

pp. 17, 19, 21
6/16/2014

Stipulation, ECF 259

2080

08/09/11 NCAA Presidential Retreat
Division I Financial Sustainability
August 9-10, 2011

Emmert, Mark

6

pp. 1, 2, 3, 10, 18,
22, 23, 25, 28-30,
32, 33
6/30/14
6/20/2014

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
EX.
NO.
2081
2083

2084

2095

2096

DESCRIPTION

SPONSOR WITNESS

DATE
ADMITTED

08/24/11 Agenda: Collegiate Model,
Rules Subcommittee
09/30/11 Email from Dave Schnase to
Wally Renfro, Judy Baker and Lynn
Dickey re Competitive Equity, attaching
Competitive Equity Within
Intercollegiate Athletics
10/11/11 Meeting acceptance for Lynn
Dickey, David Berst, Jackie Campbell,
Lynn Holzman, Brad Hostetter, LuAnn
Humphrey, Jim Isch, Kevin Lennon,
Steve Mallonee, Donald Remy, Wally
Renfro, Dave Schnase and Emily
Wollet, attaching agenda
12/02/13 Email from Jean Frankel to
David Berst attaching “Presentation to
NCAA Division 1 Board of Directors
Subcommittee on Restructuring the
NCAA by President Bernie Machen,
University of Florida and Chancellor
Harvey Perlman, University of
Nebraska-Lincoln”
1/3/14 Agenda of Division I Board of
Directors Steering Committee on
Governance, with supplemental
documents (12/30/13 "Division I NCAA
Governance 'NYC Group' Report of
12.9.13 Meeting and Working
Documentation" and 01/01/14 "Division
I Board of Directors Steering
Committee on Governance - Draft
Proposed Model")

Sankey, Greg

6/24/2014

Emmert, Mark

6/20/2014

Emmert, Mark

pp. 34, 35
6/20/2014

2102

05/31/94 Agreement between SEC and
ESPN

2104

12/06/94 “National Collegiate
Basketball Championship Agreement”

2110

06/04/99 Agreement between SEC and
ESPN

2116

11/18/99 CBS and NCAA broadcast
contract
7

pp. 20, 21
Subject of Pending
Stipulation, ECF 269
Order, ECF 264

6/30/14
[not for truth]

Sankey, Greg

pp. 1, 10-22
6/24/2014

Subject of Pending
Motion, ECF 255 and
258
Desser, Edwin

6/12/2014

Subject of Pending
Motion, ECF 255 and
258
Desser, Edwin

6/12/2014

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
EX.
NO.
2117

2119

2133
2141

2147

2151
2162
2179

2195

2225

2230
2266

2273
2281
2283

2287

DESCRIPTION

SPONSOR WITNESS

03/11/00 Agreement between Big
Twelve, ABC Sports, ESPN, Inc., and
ESPN Regional Television
06/23/00 Agreement between ACC,
Raycom Sports, Inc., and Jefferson-Pilot
Sports, Inc.
01/06/05 Broadcast Agreement C-USA
and CSTV [redacted]
05/05/05 Agreement between
University of Georgia Athletic
Association and Cable Sports, Southeast
LLC
12/31/05 Agreement between Atlantic
10 Conference and CSTV Networks,
Inc.
05/20/06 Big 12 and ESPN Telecast
Agreement
2007 Contract between FBS Bowls and
the FBS conferences for 2007-2010

Subject of Pending
Motion, ECF 255 and
258
Subject of Pending
Motion, ECF 255 and
258
Stipulation, ECF 239

06/13/08 Agreement between
University of Notre Dame and NBC
Sports
07/01/09 XOS and SEC Digital Rights
Agreement [redacted]

Subject of Pending
Motion, ECF 255 and
258
Sankey, Greg

TEXAS000017-TEXAS000067 12/24/10 Texas-ESPN "Longhorn
Network" Agreement
Telecast Rights Agreement between
FOX and Big 12 [redacted]
08/01/13 Form 13-3a: Student-Athlete
Statement signed by Chase Garnham for
Vanderbilt for Academic Year 20132014
SEC student athlete release form
1999-2000 era “Division I Amateurism
Deregulation Proposals”
01/2006 Knight Commission on
Intercollegiate Athletics – Public
Opinion Poll, Executive Summary
2010 Knight Commission Report:
Restoring the Balance, Dollars, Values,
and the Future of College Sports
8

DATE
ADMITTED

6/23/2014

Subject of Pending
Motion, ECF 255 and
258
Subject of Pending
Motion, ECF 255 and
258
Stipulation, ECF 239

6/22//2014

Desser, Edwin

6/12/2014

Plonsky, Chris

pp. 1-17, 21, 2324, 30, 37, 52
6/24/2014
6/17/2014

Desser, Edwin

6/12/2014

Garnham, Chase

6/16/2014

Sankey, Greg

6/24/2014

Rubinfeld, Daniel

pp. 1, 6
6/27/2014
6/27/2014
[not for truth]

Rubinfeld, Daniel

Order, ECF 264

pp. 1, 17
6/30/14
[not for truth]

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
EX.
NO.

2289

2290
2292

2293

2296
2297
2299
2339

2340

2448
2450
2451
2459

SPONSOR WITNESS

DATE
ADMITTED

01/12/03 NCAA State of the
Association address by Myles Brand
01/08/05 NCAA State of the
Association by Myles Brand: “The
Myths of College Sports: Debunking the
Four Great Commonly Held
Misperceptions About Intercollegiate
Athletics”
01/07/06 2006 State of the Association
by Myles Brand, excerpted
10/27/08 certified transcript of Wally
Renfro speech to Knight Commission "Commercialism in Sports and
Athletics' Rights in the 21st Century"
01/15/09 State of the Association by
Myles Brand: “State of the Association
2009: The Challenges of Commercial
Activity”
01/15/10 2010 State of the Association
by Jim Isch
01/13/12 2012 State of Association by
Mark Emmert
2013 State of the Association by Mark
Emmert
SEC Form 990 (2011-2012)

Emmert, Mark

6/19/2014

Emmert, Mark

6/19/2014

Stipulation, ECF 259

6/30/2014

Stipulation, ECF 239

pp. 1, 5-19, 84
6/23/2014

Emmert, Mark

6/19/2014

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

Staurowsky, Ellen

6/16/2014

Emmert, Mark

6/20/2014

Sankey, Greg

pp. 9, 11, 27
6/24/2014

Stipulation, ECF 260

2288

DESCRIPTION

pp. 1, 10, 13, 22,
25, 29
6/30/2014

Staurowsky, Ellen

pp. 15, 18, 359,
360
6/16/2014

2013-2014 NCAA 2014 Division I
Manual

Summary exhibit: Clotfelter chart and
tables
01/07/2013 BCS National
Championship Program
2014 DI Men's Basketball - Final Four
Program
Video: iTalkSEC - The Mark of
Number 4 [excerpted]
9

Additional Pages
Subject of Pending
Stipulation, ECF 269
Staurowsky, Ellen
Stipulation, ECF 239
Emmert, Mark
Stipulation, ECF 239

6/16/2014
p. 147
6/23/2014
p. 203
6/19/2014
6/22/2014

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
EX.
NO.
2480
2481
2482
2484
2487

2488
2492
2493
2509
2520

2521

2527
2529
2530

2531
2532

2533

DESCRIPTION

SPONSOR WITNESS

Photographs of NCAA Division I
stadiums and facilities
Photographs of NCAA Division I
basketball and football games
Pre- & Post-Game Interviews

Stipulation, ECF 239
Emmert, Mark
Stipulation, ECF 239

03/23/07 Email from David Knopp to
Chris Plonsky and Kevin Lennon
The State of NCAA Division I Football:
A Survey of Division I-A & I-AA
Presidents & Chancellors (2002)

07/29/09 Email between Harvey
Perlman and Dan Beebe
Chase Garnham Press Conference

Plonsky, Chris
Order, ECF 264

Plonsky, Chris
Stipulation, ECF 239

DATE
ADMITTED
pp. 9, 13
6/23/2014
pp. 37, 51
6/19/2014
p. 3
6/23/2014
pp. 20, 21
6/17/2014
6/30/2014
[statements of
administrators
within not for
truth]
6/17/2014

2013-2014 College Sport Research
Institute 2013-2014 Adjusted
Graduation Gap Report: NCAA D-I
Basketball
2013-2014 College Sport Research
Institute 2013-2014 Adjusted
Graduation Gap Report: NCAA
Division I Football
05/14/14 Letter from Pac-12 Presidents

Staurowsky, Ellen

p. 1
6/23/2014
pp. 2, 4
6/30/2014
6/13/2014
[not for truth]
6/16/2014

Staurowsky, Ellen

6/16/2014

Order, ECF 264

Noll Demonstrative 5 - Offers and
Acceptance by Division 2007-2011
Noll Demonstrative 6 - Competition for
Student Athletes - Basketball - All
Recruits 2007-2011
Noll Demonstrative 12 - Expert Report
Exhibit 9: Football Violations, FBS
Noll Demonstrative 20 - Inefficient
Substitution: Coaches (BCS
Conferences)
Noll Demonstrative 21 - Inefficient
Substitutions: Facilities

Stipulation, ECF 211

6/30/2014
[not for truth]
6/13/2014

Stipulation, ECF 211

6/13/2014

Stipulation, ECF 211

6/13/2014

Stipulation, ECF 211

6/13/2014

Stipulation, ECF 211

6/13/2014

EA NCAA Football ‘05 screenshot –
Tyrone Prothro
October 2011 Override Summary

Stipulation, ECF 260
Rascher, Daniel

10

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
EX.
NO.
2534

2535
2536

2537

2538

2539

2540

2541

2542

2543

2544
2545

2546

SPONSOR WITNESS

DATE
ADMITTED

Exhibit 14: Definitions of Amateurism
by Various International and National
Sports Organizations
Curriculum Vitae of Roger Noll, Ph.D.

Stipulation, ECF 211

6/13/2014

Stipulation, ECF 211

6/13/2014

Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 2A Federally-Filed Revenue and Expense
Numbers for Major Conference
Schools, 2012-2013
Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 2B Federally-Filed Revenue and Expense
Numbers for Major Conference
Schools, 2012-2013
Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 3A Division I Basketball and FBS Football
Revenues, 2000-01 to 2012-13
Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 3B Football and Basketball Revenues,
FBS Major Conferences
Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 3C Football and Basketball Revenue,
FBS Other Conferences
Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 3D Basketball Revenue, Non-FBS
Conferences
Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 3E Division I Men's Basketball Revenue,
2000-01 to 2012-13
Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 3F Division I Men's Football Revenue,
2000-01 to 2012-13
Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 4 Estimated Broadcast Revenue
Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 5 Current Television Contracts for the
Major College Conferences
Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 6A From Expert Report of Daniel L.
Rubinfeld Regarding Merits
September 25, 2013) - Exhibit 3A-3B,
pg.78-79 - Exhibit 3A: Basketball
Attendance by League (2009-10
Season)

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014
[provisional]

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014
[provisional]

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014
[provisional]

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014
[provisional]

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014
[provisional]

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014
[provisional]

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014
[provisional]

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014

DESCRIPTION

11

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
EX.
NO.
2547

2548

2549

2550

2551

2552

2553

2554

2555

2556
2557

2558

2559

DESCRIPTION

SPONSOR WITNESS

DATE
ADMITTED

Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 6B From Expert Report of Daniel L.
Rubinfeld Regarding Merits (September
25, 2013) Exhibit 3A-3B, pg.78-79,
40.000.000 - Exhibit 3B" Football
Attendance by League (2012 Season)
Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 7 Federally-Filed Revenue and Expense
Numbers for Major Conference
Schools, 2012-2013 w/ NHL
Comparison
Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 19 Average Player Salary ~Total MLB
Revenue
Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 25A Coaching Pay is Increasing Faster in
FBS/D 1 than in the NFL/NBA
Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 25B Coaching Pay is Much Larger Relative
to Revenue in FBS/D 1 than in the
NFL/NBA
Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 26A 2011 Head Coach Salary vs. Football
Revenue
Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 26B Total Count of Stars vs. Division IA
Football Revenue 2007-2011
Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 27 Basketball & Football Commits, 20072011
Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 29A Spearman's Rank Correlation
Coefficient (SRCC)
Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 29B Margin of Victory
Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 30 Spearman's Rank Correlation
Coefficient (SRCC)
Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 31 College and Professional Expected
Football Spreads Based on Betting
Markets, 2013-14
Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 34 Total Football Revenue Rank vs.
Sagarin Rank, 2011-12

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014

12

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
EX.
NO.
2560

2561

2562
2563
2564
2565

2567
2568
2569

2570

2576
2579
2580
2582
2584
2587
2588

2589

DESCRIPTION

SPONSOR WITNESS

DATE
ADMITTED

Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 36 Total Football Expenditures Rank vs.
Sagarin Rank, 2011-12
Rascher Demonstrative Exhibit 38 - FB
Athletes with Multiple Offers and
Forgone Cost Greater than or equal to
$10,000
Curriculum Vitae of Daniel Rascher,
Ph.D.
Historical Nielsen TV Ratings, 19602009
Rascher Exhibit 10: Examples of
Possible Related Party Transactions

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014

Rascher, Daniel

6/13/2014

Stipulation, ECF 238

6/23/2014

Stipulation, ECF 238

6/23/2014

Order, ECF 264

6/30/2014

NCAA March Madness Contracts:
1995-2024
[FILED UNDER SEAL]
SEC Multi-Media Agreements with
ESPN and CBS
Curriculum Vitae of Ellen Staurowsky,
Ph.D.
Graph 1. Percent Change in NCAA
Division IA Recruiting Expenditures
Between 2004 and 2012
Table 8. Recruiting Expenses (in
Dollars), 2003-2004 & 2011-2012 for
ACC, Big Ten, PAC-12, SEC, ACC
Head Coach Agreement, University of
Texas-Mack Brown
University of Texas, South Goal Post
photograph
University of Texas at Austin GSR and
FGR reports
04/28/08 Email from David Knopp to
Peter Davis, Erika Austin
01/19/11 NCAA Press Release,
Emmert: Substantial Change Need
2001 NCAA Membership Report

Stipulation, ECF 238

6/23/2014

Pastides, Harris

6/18/2014

Staurowsky, Ellen

6/16/2014

Staurowsky, Ellen

6/16/2014

Staurowsky, Ellen

6/16/2014

Plonsky, Chris

6/17/2014

Plonsky, Chris

6/17/2014

Plonsky, Chris

6/17/2014

Emmert, Mark

6/20/2014

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

Emmert, Mark

6/19/2014

07/31/10 XOS Digital Royalty
Statement for University of South
Carolina
Official Outfitter Agreement, University
of South Carolina-Under Armour

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/22/2014

Pastides, Harris

pp. 1-4, 18, 23
6/18/2014

13

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
EX.
NO.

DESCRIPTION

SPONSOR WITNESS

DATE
ADMITTED

2590

University of South Carolina, Columbia
GSR and FGR Reports

Pastides, Harris

6/18/2014

2592

2011-12 Guide for the College-Bound
Student-Athlete

Stipulation, ECF 239

2593

12/03/07 Email from David Berst to
Kevin Lennon, Greg Shaheen, Myles
Brand, Wallace Renfro, Bob Williams,
Erik Christianson
12/96 National Center for Education
Statistics, Statistics in Brief
06/19/14 Georgia Tech Marketing tweet

Stipulation, ECF 239

pp. 1, 3-6, 8-9, 11,
16, 19
6/23/2014
6/23/2014

Stipulation, ECF 259

pp. 1-2
6/18/2014
6/30/2014

Jameis Winston 2012 UD USA Football
#26 Rookie Card, website printout
Nike Oregon Ducks #8 Game Football
Jersey, website printout
Estimated NCAA Distributions, 201112
Screenshots from Todd Petr, Nicole
Bracken presentation of NCAA
Division I finances
Transcript of Todd Petr, Nicole Bracken
presentation of NCAA Division I
finances
Big Ten GSR and FGR reports
compilation
Total NCAA Distributions to
Conferences
NCAA and Subsidiaries Consolidated
Financial Statements as of and for the
Years Ended August 31, 2013 and 2012,
Supplementary Information as of and
for the Year Ended August 31, 2013,
and Independent Auditors' Report
Summary Exhibit: Distribution of InSeason and Rebroadcasted Football and
Basketball Games
Curriculum Vitae of Hal Poret
University of Florida, University of
Arkansas, and Louisiana State
University GSR and FGR reports
University of Illinois student-athlete
release form

Stipulation, ECF 259

6/30/2014

Stipulation, ECF 259

6/30/2014

Petr, Todd

6/23/2014

Petr, Todd

pp. 1-2
6/23/2014

Petr, Todd

6/23/2014

Stipulation, ECF 259

6/30/2014

Petr, Todd

6/23/2014

Petr, Todd

6/23/2014

2595
2598
2603
2604
2605
2614

2615

2616
2619
2621

2623

2624
2627

2628

14

Heckman, James

Subject of Pending
Motion, ECF 256
Poret, Hal
Stipulation, ECF 259

Subject of Pending
Motion, ECF 256

6/25/2014
6/30/2014

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
EX.
NO.

DESCRIPTION

SPONSOR WITNESS

DATE
ADMITTED

2629

Illicit Payments -191 Survey Responses

Dennis, Michael

6/24/2014

2630

Salary/Stipend - 83 Survey Responses

Dennis, Michael

6/24/2014

2631

NIL Payments - 14 Survey Responses

Dennis, Michael

6/24/2014

2645

National Association of Intercollegiate
Athletics’ IRS Form 990 (2011-2012)
NBA Uniform Player Contract
[excerpted]
09/25/13 Excerpt from Dr. Rubinfeld’s
Merits Expert Report
Compilation of Conference USA GSR
and FGR reports
1995-96 - 2000-01 ESPN/Creative
Sports-Big 12 Agreement
Telecast Agreement between The Big
Twelve Conference, Inc., ABC Sports,
Inc and ESPN Regional Television, Inc.
09/00 Policies Related to the NCAACBS Contract 2003-2013
NCAA Licensee Guidelines

Subject of Pending
Motion, ECF 256
Stipulation, ECF 260

6/30/2014

Subject of Pending
Motion, ECF 256
Subject of Pending
Motion, ECF 256
Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

Stipulation, ECF 259

Stipulation, ECF 259

pp. 1, 41-43
6/30/2014
1, 9, 10
6/30/2014
6/30/2014

Stipulation, ECF 239
Stipulation, ECF 259

6/23/2014
6/30/2014

Stipulation, ECF 259

6/30/2014

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

Delany, Jim

6/20/2014

Stipulation, ECF 259

6/30/2014

Order, ECF 264

6/30/2014
[not for truth]

2651
2661
2662
3004
3008

3009
3017
3020
3029
3042
3062
3069

3078

3080
3081

NCAA/Wray Ward Laseter Advertising
Footage License Agreement
ESPN, Inc. Rights Agreement
Email from Greg Weitekamp to Ben
Brinkman and Erika Austin
Thought Equity/Entertainment Highway
Footage License Agreement
Pay-Per-View Telecast Rights University of Texas v. Sam Houston
State - September 30, 2006
Telecast Rights Agreement between
The Big Ten Conference, Inc. and The
Big Ten Network, LLC dated
02/13/2007
Emails re: Game Simulations on
ESPN.com
Discussion of the Application of the
Recommendations of the NCAA Study
Group on the Use of Student-Athletes’
Names and Likenesses

15

Stipulation, ECF 259

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
EX.
NO.
3083

3086

3089

3095

3117

3130
3134

3165

3168
3176
3191

3193

3208

DESCRIPTION

SPONSOR WITNESS

DATE
ADMITTED

NCAA Study Group on the Use of
Student Athletes Names and Likenesses
Proposed Legislative Language,
Supplement No. 12 DI AEC 6/07
04/01/06 Agreement between ACC, Big
East, Big Ten, Big Twelve, Conference
USA, MAC, Mountain West, Pac-10,
SEC, Sun Belt, and Western Athletic
conferences, University of Notre Dame,
and Fox Sports Productions, Inc.
Pay-Per-View Telecast Rights University of Texas v. Arkansas September 1, 2007
Memo from Myles Brand to Selected
NCAA Conference Commissioners re:
NCAA Proposal Nos 2007-25 2007-26
and 2007-28 of the NCAA Study Group
on the Use of Student Athletes Names
and Likenesses
05/01/08 Email from Peter Davis to
[e-mail], Zak Raffel, Erika
Austin, Keith Holden, and Kati Reeves
NCAA footage license to Tap TV for
trivia
Pay-Per-View Telecast Rights University of Texas v. Florida Atlantic
University - August 30, 2008
Thought Equity Motion/Youreeeka
Collegiate Sports Footage License
Agreement
08/06/09 Agenda, NCAA Division 1
Board of Directors
12/17/09 Email from Peter Davis to
Ashley Hicks
TEM/Athletics Nation Big Ten football
and basketball footage licensing
agreement
10/13/10 Memo from Jim Delany to
Division 1 Conference Commissioners
re NCAA Proposal 2010-26 - Use of
Student-Athlete's Name or Likeness
Name of Reporting Institution
University of Texas at Austin
Information for the Reporting Year
2010

Plonsky, Chris

6/17/2014

16

Subject of Pending
Motion, ECF 255 and
258

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

Plonsky, Chris

6/17/2014

Stipulation, ECF 259

6/30/2014

Stipulation, ECF 259

6/30/2014

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/22/2014

Stipulation, ECF 259

6/30/2014

Emmert, Mark
Stipulation, ECF 259

pp. 27-28
6/20/2014
6/30/2014

Stipulation, ECF 259

6/30/2014

Emmert, Mark

6/20/2014

Plonsky, Chris

6/17/2014

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
EX.
NO.

DATE
ADMITTED

3230

3290
3308
3314

3317

3332
3369

3372

3389
3392

SPONSOR WITNESS

01/13/11 NCAA Convention, 2011 San
Antonio - Examining the StudentAthlete Experience Through the NCAA
GOALS and SCORE Studies

Petr, Todd

pp. 1, 6-8, 24, 26,
31, 32
6/23/2014

Stipulation, ECF 259

3210

DESCRIPTION

Plonsky, Chris

pp. 12, 14, 15
6/30/14
6/12/2014

Sankey, Greg

6/24/2014

Stipulation, ECF 239
Sankey, Greg

pp. 1-21, 23
6/23/2014
6/24/2014

Petr, Todd

6/23/2014

Muir, Bernard

p. 41
6/18/2014
6/16/2014

NFL Standard Player Contract from
2011 NFL Collective Bargaining
Agreement [excerpted]
Michigan State University Gymnastics
schedule
2013-14 Division 1 Revenue
Distribution Plan
SECU, The Academic Initiative of the
SEC - SECU Academic Initiative
Programs and Activities
Revenues & Expenses, 2004-2012,
NCAA Division I Intercollegiate
Athletics Programs Report
Stanford Student Handbook
10/13 Trends in Graduation-Success
Rates and Federal Graduation Rates at
NCAA Division I Institutions
[also admitted as 3373 on 6/23/2014,
renamed pursuant to stipulation at ECF
239]
University of South Carolina, Report on
Financial Statements, Year ending
06/30/2013
Curriculum Vitae of J. Michael Dennis,
Ph.D.
Main Survey Online Survey Screen
Captures (Dennis Survey)

Staurowsky, Ellen

Pastides, Harris

pp. 1, 10
6/18/2014

Dennis, Michael

6/24/2014

Dennis, Michael

6/25/2014

3393

Topline Report (Dennis Survey)

Dennis, Michael

6/25/2014

3399

Pastides, Harris

6/18/2014

3411

University of South Carolina Columbia Department of Athletics,
Independent Accountant's Report on
Appling Agreed-Upon Procedures, YE
06/30/2013
The Final Four

Stipulation, ECF 259

3413

Bowl All Star Game Records

Stipulation, ECF 259

pp. 1-2
6/30/2014
pp. 1, 15, 72-73
6/30/2014

17

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
EX.
NO.

DESCRIPTION

3414

Football Bowl Subdivision Records

3419

SPONSOR WITNESS

NCAA Eligibility Center - 2013-14
Guide for the College Bound Student
Athlete
Stanford Student Handbook

3426
3492
3596
3607
3673
3731
3741

Stipulation, ECF 259

Staurowsky, Ellen

Texas Longhorns Athletics the
University of Texas Mission Statement
Graphic Showing Conference USA
Member Schools
Video: One Shining Moment 2014 HD #oneshiningmoment
01/27/10 Email from Jim Haynes to
Peter Davis
Overall Division I Freshman Cohort
Graduation Rates
The Big O: My Life, My Times, My
Game by Oscar Robertson [excerpted]
Slam Dunk to Glory by David Lattin
[excerpted]

3886

Interpretation - Composition of
Financial Aid Appeals Committee
Investing Where it Matters
08/01/08 Multi-media Agreement
between ESPN and the SEC
2014 Annual Report, University of
Texas
2014 Membership Guide, Longhorn
Foundation
Big-Time Sports in American
Universities
Curriculum Vitae of James Heckman,
Ph.D.
Nielsen Television at a Glance (Summer
2008)
Complete Super Bowl TV Rating, 19972009
If College Athletes Were Paid, Would
You Lose Interest?

3907
3908
3919
3922
3941
3942
3961

18

pp. 1, 96-99, 108113
6/30/2014
6/16/2014

Stipulation, ECF 259

3742

3900
3906

DATE
ADMITTED

6/30/14

Plonsky, Chris

6/17/2014

Banowsky, Britton

6/23/2014

Stipulation, ECF 260

6/30/2014

Stipulation, ECF 259

6/30/2014

Stipulation, ECF 259

6/30/2014

Subject of Pending
Motion, ECF 255 and
258
Subject of Pending
Motion, ECF 255 and
258
Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

Stipulation, ECF 239
Sankey, Greg
Plonsky, Chris

6/23/2014
pp. 1, 52, 59
6/24/2014
6/17/2014

Plonsky, Chris

6/17/2014

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

Heckman, James

6/17/2014

Stipulation, ECF 238

6/23/2014

Stipulation, ECF 238

6/23/2014

Poret, Hal

6/24/2014
[proffered, not
admitted]

JOINT TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST
EX.
NO.

DESCRIPTION

SPONSOR WITNESS

DATE
ADMITTED

University of South Carolina, Columbia
Freshman-Cohort Graduation Rates,
2007-08 Rates
NCAA March Madness: 2014 NCAA
March Madness Tune In Marketing
Recap
Louisiana State University 2013
Football Schedule Poster
Mobile, AL Little League Photo

Stipulation, ECF 239

6/23/2014

Lewis, Mark

6/27/2014

Sankey, Greg

p. 3
6/24/2014
6/24/2014

Stipulation, ECF 259

4005

Curriculum Vitae of Lauren Stiroh,
Ph.D.
Division I Median Coaches'
Compensation As Proportion of Total
Expenses
Number of Division I Schools
Reporting Positive Net Revenue in
Athletics Departments
Disadvantage College Athletes and
Completion
College Attendance

4006

3962

3966

3968
3971
3987

Sankey, Greg

Petr, Todd

pp. 2-9
6/30/2014
6/23/2014

Petr, Todd

6/23/2014

Heckman, James

6/18/2014

Heckman, James

6/18/2014

College Attendance

Heckman, James

6/18/2014

4007

College Attendance

Heckman, James

6/18/2014

4008

Graduation Rates

Heckman, James

6/18/2014

4009

Graduation Rates

Heckman, James

6/18/2014

4010

Post-College Wages

Heckman, James

6/18/2014

4011

Post-College Wages

Heckman, James

6/18/2014

4012

White-Collar Jobs

Heckman, James

6/18/2014

4013

White-Collar Jobs

Heckman, James

6/18/2014

4035

Stanford's 36 Sports

Muir, Bernard

6/18/2014

4038

Nielsen Television Ratings for World
Series
Nielsen Television Ratings for
Olympics
Colleges in the SEC

Stipulation, ECF 238

6/23/2014

Stipulation, ECF 238

6/23/2014

Sankey, Greg

Public Opinion About Paying StudentAthletes - Findings from a Scientific
Survey Conducted by J. Michael
Dennis, Ph.D. dated June 24, 2014

Dennis, Michael

p. 1
6/24/2014
6/25/2014

4001

4003

4004

4039
4044
4045

19