TransPerfect Global, Inc. et al v. MotionPoint Corporation

Filing 412

ORDER by Judge Claudia Wilken Granting 410 Amended Stipulation re Admitted Exhibits (Attachments: # 1 Affidavit A (Admitted Exhibits)) (ndr, COURT STAFF) (Filed on 7/10/2013)

APPENDIX A

Exhibit
No.

Date
Offered

DPX-001

6/27/2013

Admission
During Trial
(no. of pages in exhibit)
Admitted. (patent-in-suit)

Parties’ Stipulated
Exhibit Admission

Any Change from
Admission at Trial?

DPX-003

6/27/2013

Admitted. (patent-in-suit)

Admitted.

DPX-004

6/27/2013

Admitted. (patent-in-suit)

Admitted.

DX-0019

7/8/2013

Select pages admitted:
0002

Selected pages admitted:
0001, 0002

DX-0023

7/8/2013

Select pages admitted:
0002

Selected pages admitted:
0001, 0002

DX-0079

6/27/2013

Admitted. (11 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002.

DX-00101

7/8/2013

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0008, 0010.

Selected pages admitted:
0001, 0002, 0008, 0010.

DX-0156

6/27/2013

Admitted. (3 pages)

Admitted. (3 pages)

DX-0186

7/9/2013

Admitted. (5 pages)

Admitted. (5 pages)

DX-0582

6/27/2013

Admitted. (19 pages)

Admitted. (19 pages)

Admitted complete –
MotionPoint Provisional
Patent Application

DX-0701

7/1/2013

Admitted. (28 pages)

Admitted. (28 pages)

Admitted complete – prior art
patent

DX-0703

7/1/2013

Admitted. (42 pages)

Admitted. (42 pages)

Admitted complete – prior art

Admitted.

1

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

Exhibit
No.

Date
Offered

Admission
During Trial
(no. of pages in exhibit)

Parties’ Stipulated
Exhibit Admission

Any Change from
Admission at Trial?
patent

DX-0707

7/2/2013

Admitted. (15 pages)

Admitted. (15 pages)

DX-0718

7/3/2013

Admitted. (2 pages)

Admitted. (2 pages)

DX-0747

7/8/2013

Admitted. (7 pages)

Admitted. (7 pages)

DX-0785

7/8/2013

Admitted. (2 pages)

Admitted. (2 pages)

DX-0794

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0002, 0118

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002, 0117

Yes (corrected requested pages)

DX-0797

7/3/2013

Select pages admitted:
0078.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002, 0078.

Yes (additional published pages
added)

DX-0816

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0019.

Select pages admitted:
0019.

DX-0818

7/3/2013

Select pages admitted:
0006, 0009, 0010

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002, 0006, 0009,
0010.

Yes (additional published pages
added)

7/8/2013

Admitted complete – prior art
patent

DX-0819

7/3/2013

Select pages admitted:
0004.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002, 0003, 0004.

Yes (additional published pages
added)

DX-0822

7/3/2013

Select pages admitted:
0002.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002, 0003, 0012.

Yes (additional published pages
added)

DX-0829

6/25/2013

Select pages admitted:
0003, 0004, 0007, 0010.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002, 0003, 0004,
0007, 0010.

Yes (additional published pages
added)

DX-0835

6/25/2013

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0004, 0005, 0007.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002, 0003, 0004,

Yes (additional published pages
added)

7/8/2013

2

Exhibit
No.

Date
Offered

Admission
During Trial
(no. of pages in exhibit)

Parties’ Stipulated
Exhibit Admission

Any Change from
Admission at Trial?

0005, 0007.
DX-0837

7/3/2013

Select pages admitted:
0002.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002.

DX-0840

6/25/2013

Admitted (13 pages)

Admitted (13 pages)

Yes (additional published pages
added)
Admitted complete

7/8/2013
DX-0845

07/9/2013

Admitted. (7 pages)

Admitted. (7 pages)

DX-0854

7/3/2013

Select pages admitted:
0004.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0004.

Yes (additional published pages
added)

DX-0856

7/3/2013

Select pages admitted:
0005.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0005.

Yes (additional published pages
added)

DX-0870

7/8/2013

Admitted. (3 pages)

Admitted. (3 pages)

DX-0875

7/8/2013

Admitted. (7 pages)

Admitted. (7 pages)

DX-0884

7/8/2013

Admitted. (4 pages)

Admitted. (4 pages)

DX-0895

7/8/2013

Admitted. (2 pages)

Admitted. (3 pages)

DX-0987

7/8/2013

Admitted. (5 pages)

Admitted. (5 pages)

DX-0991

7/3/2013

Select pages admitted:
0002, 0003.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002, 0003.

DX-1031

7/8/2013

Admitted. (3 pages)

Admitted. (3 pages)

DX-1063

7/3/2013

Select pages admitted:
0003.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002, 0003.

DX-1107

7/8/2013

Admitted. (2 pages)

Admitted. (2 pages)
3

Yes (additional published pages
added)
Yes (additional published pages
added)

Exhibit
No.

Date
Offered

DX-1119

7/8/2013

Admission
During Trial
(no. of pages in exhibit)
Admitted. (3 pages)

Parties’ Stipulated
Exhibit Admission

Any Change from
Admission at Trial?

DX-1131

6/25/2013

Admitted. (5 pages)

Admitted. (5 pages)

DX-1138

07/09/2013

Admitted. (9 pages)

Admitted. (9 pages)

DX-1145

6/25/2013

Admitted. (7 pages)

Admitted. (7 pages)

DX-1146

6/25/2013

Select pages admitted:
0007, 0033, 0098, 0111,
0112, 0114.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002, 0004, 0007,
0033, 0069, 0098, 0111,
0112, 0114.

DX-1154

7/8/2013

Admitted. (3 pages)

Admitted. (3 pages)

DX-1381

6/27/2013

Admitted. (32 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002, 0009.

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

DX-1391

6/27/2013

Admitted. (34 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0009, 0013, 0034.

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

DX-1393

6/25/2013

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0003.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002, 0003.

DX-1406

07/09/2013

Admitted (38 pages)

Admitted. (38 pages)

DX-1407

07/09/2013

Select pages admitted:
0001.

Select pages admitted:
0001.

Admitted. (3 pages)

4

Yes (additional published pages
added)

Admit all – MotionPoint published
patent application.

Exhibit
No.

Date
Offered

Admission
During Trial
(no. of pages in exhibit)
Select pages admitted:
0001.

Parties’ Stipulated
Exhibit Admission

Any Change from
Admission at Trial?

Select pages admitted:
0001.

DX-1408

07/09/2013

DX-1409

6/25/2013

Admitted. (3 pages)

Admitted. (3 pages)

DX-1414

6/25/2013

Admitted. (Video)

Admitted. (Video)

PTX-5003

6/25/2013

Admitted. (13 pages –
patent-in-suit)

Admitted. (13 pages –
patent-in-suit)

Admitted complete – TransPerfect
Patent-in-Suit

PTX-5007

6/26/2013

Select pages admitted:
0160, 0180.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0020, 0065, 0067,
0072, 0079, 0149, 150,
0160, 0180, 0188.

Yes (additional published pages
added)

PTX-5008

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0010, 0011.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0010, 0011.

PTX-5009

7/1/2013

Select pages admitted:
0011.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0011.

Yes (additional published pages
added)

PTX-5012

7/3/2013
7/8/2013

Select pages admitted:
087, 0232, 0278, 0282,
0294.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 087, 0232, 0278,
0282, 0294.

Yes (additional published pages
added)

PTX-5018

6/27/2013

Admitted. (36 pages)

0001,0002, 0007, 0008,
0010, 0017, 0035.

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

PTX-5037

6/26/2013

Admitted. (408 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0252, 0265.

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

5

Exhibit
No.

Date
Offered

Admission
During Trial
(no. of pages in exhibit)
Select pages admitted:
0001, 0015.

Parties’ Stipulated
Exhibit Admission

Any Change from
Admission at Trial?

PTX-5039

7/9/2013

PTX-5041

6/26/2013

Admitted. (43 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0032.

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

PTX-5042

6/26/2013

Admitted. (125 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0011, 0069.

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

PTX-5043

7/1/2013

Admitted. (4 pages)

Admitted.

PTX-5065

6/25/2013

Select pages admitted:
0001.

Select pages admitted:
0001.

PTX-5069

7/1/2013

Select pages admitted:
0003.

Select pages admitted:
0003 (redacted).

PTX-5084

7/9/2013

Admitted. (3 pages)

Admitted. (3 pages)

PTX-5090

7/1/2013

Admitted. (22 pages)

Admitted. (22 pages

Dispute – TransPerfect wants to
Admit Complete

PTX-5091

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0011

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0003, 0011, 0013,
0038, 0040, 0049, 0050
0059, 0063.

Yes (additional published pages
added)

PTX-5094

7/3/2013

Admitted. (7 pages)

Admitted. (7 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0015.

6

Exhibit
No.
PTX-5095

Date
Offered
6/27/2013
7/9/2013

Admission
During Trial
(no. of pages in exhibit)
Select pages admitted:
0001, 0064, 0183, 0184,
0194, 0217, 0229, 0243,
0260, 0273, 0297.

Parties’ Stipulated
Exhibit Admission

Any Change from
Admission at Trial?

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0183, 0184, 0194,
0217, 0229, 0243, 0260,
0273, 0297.

PTX-5096

7/3/2013

Admitted. (2 pages)

Admitted.

PTX-5097

7/8/2013

Select pages admitted:
0052, 0059, 0060, 0061,
0063. (263 pages)

0001, 0002, 0052-65.

PTX-5098

7/8/2013

Admitted. (13 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0003, 0004, 0006,
0009.

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

PTX-5104

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0032

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0027, 0032, 0034.

Yes (additional published pages
added)

PTX-5137

7/1/2013

Select pages admitted:
0006.

Select pages admitted:
0006 (redacted).

PTX-5138

7/9/2013

Admitted. (4 pages)

Admitted. (4 pages)

PTX-5158

6/27/2013

Admitted. (6 pages)

Admitted. (6 pages)

PTX-5159

7/1/2013

Admitted. (4 pages)

Admitted. (4 pages)

PTX-5165

6/27/2013

Admitted. (4 pages)

Admitted. (4 pages)

PTX-5168

6/27/2013

Admitted. (3 pages)

Admitted. (3 pages)

PTX-5193

6/27/2013

Admitted. (3 pages)

Admitted. (3 pages)

7

Yes (added pages to provide
context)

Exhibit
No.

7/9/2013

Admission
During Trial
(no. of pages in exhibit)
Select pages admitted:
0001, 0064, 0332, 0355.

PTX-5196

6/27/2013

Admitted. (46 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002.

PTX-5259

6/26/2013

Admitted. (10 pages)

Admitted. (10 pages)

PTX-5295

6/27/2013

Admitted. (2 pages)

Admitted. (2 pages)

PTX-5389

6/27/2013

Admitted. (3 pages)

Admitted. (3 pages)

PTX-5407

6/26/2013

Admitted. (3 pages)

Admitted. (3 pages)

PTX-5431

7/8/2013

Admitted. (3 pages)

Admitted. (3 pages)

PTX-5433

7/8/2013

Admitted. (10 pages)

Admitted. 10 pages)

PTX-5434

7/8/2013

Select pages admitted:
0013, 0097 0098, 0161

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0009, 0013, 0094,
0098, 0112, 0161

PTX-5195

Date
Offered
6/27/2013

7/9/2013

Parties’ Stipulated
Exhibit Admission

Any Change from
Admission at Trial?

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0332, 0355.

PTX-5445

6/25/2013

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0048, 0049, 0050.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0048, 0049, 0050.

PTX-5446

7/8/2013

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002.

PTX-5451

7/8/2013

Admitted. (6 pages)

Admitted. (6 pages)

8

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

Yes (additional published pages
added)

Exhibit
No.
PTX-5506

Date
Offered
6/26/2013
7/9/2013

Admission
During Trial
(no. of pages in exhibit)
Select pages admitted:
0001, 0003, 0005, 0012,
0017, 0037, 0038, 0045.

Parties’ Stipulated
Exhibit Admission

Any Change from
Admission at Trial?

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0003, 0005, 0012,
0017, 0037, 0038, 0045.

PTX-5520

7/3/2013

Select pages admitted:
0003.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0003.

PTX-5521

6/27/2013

Admitted. (3 pages)

Admitted. (3 pages)

PTX-5542

6/26/2013

Admitted. (25 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0008, 0009.

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

PTX-5597

6/26/2013

Admitted. (23 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0021.

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

PTX-5607

6/27/2013

Admitted. (9 pages)

Admitted. (9 pages)

PTX-5634

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0065.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0018, 0034, 0050,
0065, 0073.

PTX-5639

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0013.

Select pages admitted:
0013.

PTX-5662

6/25/2013

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0004.

Select pages admitted:
0001; 0004.

PTX-5686

6/27/2013

Admitted. (14 pages)

Admitted. (14 pages)
9

Yes (additional published pages
added)

Yes (additional published pages
added)

Admitted Complete – all pages

Exhibit
No.

Date
Offered

Admission
During Trial
(no. of pages in exhibit)

Parties’ Stipulated
Exhibit Admission

Any Change from
Admission at Trial?
needed for context (Best Buy web
site)

PTX-5673

7/2/2013

Select pages admitted:
0189, 0191

Selected pages admitted:
0001, 0189, 0191

PTX-5687

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002, 0034, 0035.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002, 0034, 0035

PTX-5720

6/26/2013

Admitted. (35 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0034.

PTX-5734

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0002.

Select pages admitted:
0002.

PTX-5766

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0041, 0049.

Select pages admitted:
0041, 0042, 0049, 0051.

PTX-5782

7/3/2013

Admitted. (4 pages)

Admitted. (4 pages)

PTX-5790

6/27/2013

Admitted. (14 pages)

Admitted. (14 pages)

PTX-5801

6/26/2013

Admitted. (33 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0007, 0010, 0011,
0016, 0025, 0026.

PTX-5829

6/27/2013

Admitted. (2 pages)

Admitted. (2 pages)

PTX-5840

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0012, 0013.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0012, 0013.

PTX-5834

6/27/2013

Admitted. (16 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0001.

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

PTX-5984

6/26/2013

Admitted. (105 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0014.

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

10

Yes (additional published pages
added)

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

Exhibit
No.

Date
Offered

Admission
During Trial
(no. of pages in exhibit)
Select pages admitted:
0004.

PTX-6002

7/9/2013

PTX-6025

Parties’ Stipulated
Exhibit Admission
Select pages admitted:
0004.

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0014, 0021, 0022.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0014, 0021, 0022.

PTX-6026

6/25/2013

Select pages admitted:
0001.

Select pages admitted:
0001.

PTX-6029

7/3/2013

Admitted. (8 pages)

Admitted. (8 pages)

7/9/2013

11

Any Change from
Admission at Trial?