TransPerfect Global, Inc. et al v. MotionPoint Corporation

Filing 418

ORDER by Judge Claudia Wilken Granting 417 Second Amended Stipulation re Admitted Exhibits. (ndr, COURT STAFF) (Filed on 7/11/2013)

Case4:10-cv-02590-CW Document417 Filed07/11/13 Page1 of 4

1

[Counsel listed on signature page]

2
3
4
5
6
7
8

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

9

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

10

OAKLAND DIVISION

11
12
13
14
15
16
17

TRANSPERFECT GLOBAL, INC.,
TRANSPERFECT TRANSLATIONS
INTERNATIONAL, INC., AND
TRANSLATIONS.COM, INC.,
Plaintiffs/Counterclaim-Defendants,
v.
MOTIONPOINT CORPORATION,
Defendant/Counterclaim-Plaintiff.

Case No. CV 10-02590 CW (JCS)
SECOND AMENDED JOINT
STIPULATION TO ADMIT EXHIBITS
INTO EVIDENCE
Trial Date: June 24, 2013
Time: 8:30 a.m.
Crtm: 2, 4th Floor
Judge: Hon. Claudia Wilken

18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

SECOND AMENDED JOINT STIPULATION
TO ADMIT EXHIBITS

CASE NO. CV 10-02590 CW (JCS)

Case4:10-cv-02590-CW Document417 Filed07/11/13 Page2 of 4

1

Pursuant to the Court’s instructions and the parties’ conversation with the Court’s Clerk

2

and Courtroom Deputy, Nikki Riley, on the afternoon of July 10, 2013, TransPerfect Global,

3

Inc., TransPerfect Translations International, Inc., and Translations.com, Inc. (“TransPerfect”)

4

and MotionPoint Corporation (“MotionPoint”) jointly attach, as Exhibit A, a second amended list

5

of exhibits that the parties agree have been admitted into evidence thus far, limited to selected

6

pages where applicable.

7

The parties have noted the pages of exhibits that were specifically admitted into evidence

8

during trial in a column labeled “Admitted During Trial.” Where the parties have agreed to entry

9

of different or additional pages for the exhibit, the parties note those differences in a column

10

labeled “Parties’ Stipulated Exhibit Admission.” For all exhibits that have been admitted in

11

complete form, the parties have inserted “Admitted” in the “Admission During Trial” column,

12

and have denoted the number of pages included in the exhibit for the Court’s review.

13

The parties have included in Appendix A all exhibits entered into evidence as part of the

14

Court’s July 9, 2013 grant of the parties’ Joint Stipulation to Admit Exhibits into Evidence, and

15

the Court’s July 10, 2013 grant of the parties’ Amended Joint Stipulation to Admit Exhibits into

16

Evidence, which was filed July 10, 2013. (Dkt. 405, granting Dkt. 392; Dkt. 414, granting Dkt.

17

413). The parties will continue to correspond with the Court’s Clerk and Courtroom Deputy,

18

Nikki Riley, to ensure that the Court has all exhibits and pages listed in Appendix A.

19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
SECOND AMENDED JOINT STIPULATION
TO ADMIT EXHIBITS

-1-

CASE NO. CV 10-02590 CW (JCS)

Case4:10-cv-02590-CW Document417 Filed07/11/13 Page3 of 4

1
2
3
4

Dated: July 11, 2013
LATHAM & WATKINS LLP
KASOWITZ BENSON TORRES &
FRIEDMAN LLP

QUINN EMANUEL URQUHART & SULLIVAN
LLP

5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14

/s/ Robert P. Watkins III
DOUGLAS E. LUMISH
JEFFREY G. HOMRIG
GABRIEL S. GROSS
MICHAEL B. EISENBERG (pro hac
vice)
JOSEPH H. LEE
L. OKEY ONYEJEKWE JR.
JOSEPH B. SHEAR
STEFAN R. STOYANOV (pro hac vice)
STEVEN D. CHIN (pro hac vice)
ROBERT P. WATKINS III (pro hac vice)

/s/ Gregory C. Wyckoff
CHARLES K. VERHOEVEN
AMY H. CANDIDO
EMMA E. MANN-MEGINNISS
ROBERT W. STONE
RICHARD W. ERWINE (pro hac vice)
MATTHEW ROBSON (pro hac vice)
GREGORY C. WYCKOFF (pro hac vice)
Attorneys for Defendant/Counterclaim-Plaintiff
MotionPoint Corporation

Attorneys for Plaintiffs/CounterclaimDefendants TransPerfect Global, Inc.,
TransPerfect Translations International,
Inc., and Translations.com, Inc.

15
16
17
18

I hereby attest pursuant to Civil Local Rule 5-1(i) that concurrence in the electronic filing
of this document has been obtained from the other signatories.

19

/s/ Robert P. Watkins III

20
21
22
23

,
PURSUANT TO STIPULATION, IT IS SO ORDERED. except that exhibit DX-

1381 consists of pages 2 and 9.
11
Dated: July, __, 2013

_________________________________
Hon. Claudia Wilken

24

United States District Judge

25
26
27
28
SECOND AMENDED JOINT STIPULATION
TO ADMIT EXHIBITS

-2-

CASE NO. CV 10-02590 CW (JCS)

Case4:10-cv-02590-CW Document417 Filed07/11/13 Page4 of 4

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27

DOUGLAS E. LUMISH (Bar No. 183863)
[e-mail]
JEFFREY G. HOMRIG (Bar No. 215890)
[e-mail]
GABRIEL S. GROSS (Bar No. 254672)
[e-mail]
LATHAM & WATKINS LLP
140 Scott Drive
Menlo Park, California 94025
Tel: [phone]; Fax: [phone]
MICHAEL B. EISENBERG (pro hac vice)
[e-mail]
LATHAM & WATKINS LLP
885 Third Avenue
New York, New York 10022
Tel: [phone]; Fax: [phone]
JOSEPH. H. LEE (Bar No. 248046)
[e-mail]
LATHAM & WATKINS LLP
650 Town Center Drive, 20th Floor
Costa Mesa, CA 92626
Tel: [phone]; Fax: [phone]
L. OKEY ONYEJEKWE JR. (Bar No.
250354)
[e-mail]
JOSEPH B. SHEAR (Bar No. 262222)
[e-mail]
KASOWITZ, BENSON, TORRES &
FRIEDMAN LLP
333 Twin Dolphin Drive, Suite 200
Redwood Shores, California 94065
Tel: [phone]; Fax: [phone]

CHARLES K. VERHOEVEN (Bar No.
170151)
[e-mail]
AMY H. CANDIDO (Bar No. 237829)
[e-mail]
EMMA E. MANN-MEGINNISS (Bar No.
286656)
[e-mail]
QUINN EMANUEL URQUHART &
SULLIVAN, LLP
50 California Street, 22nd Floor
San Francisco, California 94111-4624
Tel: [phone]; Fax: [phone]
ROBERT W. STONE (Bar No. 163513)
[e-mail]
QUINN EMANUEL URQUHART &
SULLIVAN, LLP
555 Twin Dolphin Drive, 5th Floor
Redwood Shores, California 94065
Tel: [phone]; Fax: [phone]
RICHARD W. ERWINE (pro hac vice)
[e-mail]
MATTHEW D. ROBSON (pro hac vice)
[e-mail]
GREGORY C. WYCKOFF (pro hac vice)
[e-mail]
QUINN EMANUEL URQUHART &
SULLIVAN, LLP
51 Madison Avenue, 22nd Floor
New York, New York 10010
Tel: [phone]
Attorneys for Defendant/CounterclaimPlaintiff MotionPoint Corporation

STEFAN R. STOYANOV (pro hac vice)
[e-mail]
STEVEN D. CHIN (pro hac vice)
[e-mail]
ROBERT P. WATKINS III (pro hac vice)
[e-mail]
KASOWITZ, BENSON, TORRES &
FRIEDMAN LLP
1633 Broadway
New York, New York 10019
Tel: [phone];
Fax: [phone]
Attorneys for Plaintiffs/CounterclaimDefendants Transperfect Global, Inc.,
Transperfect Translations International,
Inc., and Translations.com, Inc.

28
SECOND AMENDED JOINT STIPULATION
TO ADMIT EXHIBITS

CASE NO. CV 10-02590 CW (JCS)

Case4:10-cv-02590-CW Document417-1 Filed07/11/13 Page1 of 12

APPENDIX A

Case4:10-cv-02590-CW Document417-1 Filed07/11/13 Page2 of 12

Exhibit
No.

Date
Offered

DPX-001

6/27/2013

Admission
During Trial
(no. of pages in exhibit)
Admitted. (patent-in-suit)

Parties’ Stipulated
Exhibit Admission

Any Change from
Admission at Trial?

DPX-003

6/27/2013

Admitted. (patent-in-suit)

Admitted.

DPX-004

6/27/2013

Admitted. (patent-in-suit)

Admitted.

DX-0019

7/8/2013

Select pages admitted:
0002

Selected pages admitted:
0002

DX-0023

7/8/2013

Select pages admitted:
0002

Selected pages admitted:
0002

DX-0079

6/27/2013

Admitted. (10 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0002.

DX-00101

7/8/2013

Select pages admitted:
0002, 0008, 0010.

Selected pages admitted:
0002, 0008, 0010.

DX-0156

6/27/2013

Admitted. (2 pages)

Admitted. (2 pages)

DX-0186

7/9/2013

Admitted. (4 pages)

Admitted. (4 pages)

DX-0582

6/27/2013

Admitted. (18 pages)

Admitted. (18 pages)

Admitted complete –
MotionPoint Provisional
Patent Application

DX-0701

7/1/2013

Admitted. (27 pages)

Admitted. (27 pages)

Admitted complete – prior art
patent

DX-0703

7/1/2013

Admitted. (41 pages)

Admitted. (41 pages)

Admitted complete – prior art

Admitted.

1

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

Case4:10-cv-02590-CW Document417-1 Filed07/11/13 Page3 of 12

Exhibit
No.

Date
Offered

Admission
During Trial
(no. of pages in exhibit)

Parties’ Stipulated
Exhibit Admission

Any Change from
Admission at Trial?
patent

DX-0707

7/2/2013

Admitted. (14 pages)

Admitted. (14 pages)

DX-0718

7/3/2013

Admitted. (1 page)

Admitted. (1 page)

DX-0747

7/8/2013

Admitted. (6 pages)

Admitted. (6 pages)

DX-0785

7/8/2013

Admitted. (1 page)

Admitted. (1 page)

DX-0794

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0002, 0118

Select pages admitted:
0002, 0117

Yes (corrected requested pages)

DX-0797

7/3/2013

Select pages admitted:
0078.

Select pages admitted:
0002, 0078.

Yes (additional published pages
added)

DX-0816

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0019.

Select pages admitted:
0019.

DX-0818

7/3/2013

Select pages admitted:
0006, 0009, 0010

Select pages admitted:
0002, 0006, 0009, 0010.

Yes (additional published pages
added)

7/8/2013

Admitted complete – prior art
patent

DX-0819

7/3/2013

Select pages admitted:
0004.

Select pages admitted:
0002, 0003, 0004.

Yes (additional published pages
added)

DX-0822

7/3/2013

Select pages admitted:
0002.

Select pages admitted:
0002, 0003, 0012.

Yes (additional published pages
added)

DX-0829

6/25/2013

Select pages admitted:
0003, 0004, 0007, 0010.

Yes (additional published pages
added)

DX-0835

6/25/2013

Select pages admitted:
0002, 0004, 0005, 0007.

Select pages admitted:
0002, 0003, 0004, 0007,
0010.
Select pages admitted:
0002, 0003, 0004, 0005,
0007.

7/8/2013

2

Yes (additional published pages
added)

Case4:10-cv-02590-CW Document417-1 Filed07/11/13 Page4 of 12

Exhibit
No.

Date
Offered

Admission
During Trial
(no. of pages in exhibit)
Select pages admitted:
0002.

Parties’ Stipulated
Exhibit Admission

DX-0837

7/3/2013

DX-0839

7/10/2013

None

Select pages admitted:
0002.

DX-0840

6/25/2013

Admitted (12 pages)

Any Change from
Admission at Trial?

Select pages admitted:
0002.

Admitted (12 pages)

Yes (additional published pages
added)

7/8/2013
DX-0845

07/9/2013

Admitted. (6 pages)

Admitted. (6 pages)

DX-0854

7/3/2013

Select pages admitted:
0004.

Select pages admitted:
0002, 0004.

DX-0856

7/3/2013

Select pages admitted:
0005.

Select pages admitted:
0005.

DX-0870

7/8/2013

Admitted. (2 pages)

Admitted. (2 pages)

DX-0875

7/8/2013

Admitted. (6 pages)

Admitted. (6 pages)

DX-0884

7/8/2013

Admitted. (3 pages)

Admitted. (3 pages)

DX-0895

7/8/2013

Admitted. (2 pages)

Admitted. (2 pages)

DX-0987

7/8/2013

Admitted. (4 pages)

Admitted. (4 pages)

DX-0991

7/3/2013

Select pages admitted:
0002, 0003.

Select pages admitted:
0002, 0003.

DX-1031

7/8/2013

Admitted. (2 pages)

Admitted. (2 pages)

DX-1063

7/3/2013

Select pages admitted:
0003.

Select pages admitted:
0002, 0003.

DX-1107

7/8/2013

Admitted. (1 page)

Admitted. (1 page)
3

Yes (additional published pages
added)

Case4:10-cv-02590-CW Document417-1 Filed07/11/13 Page5 of 12

Exhibit
No.

Date
Offered

DX-1119

7/8/2013

Admission
During Trial
(no. of pages in exhibit)
Admitted. (2 pages)

DX-1131

6/25/2013

Admitted. (4 pages)

Admitted. (4 pages)

DX-1138

07/09/2013

Admitted. (8 pages)

Admitted. (8 pages)

DX-1145

6/25/2013

Admitted. (6 pages)

Admitted. (6 pages)

DX-1146

6/25/2013

Select pages admitted:
0007, 0033, 0098, 0111,
0112, 0114.

Yes (additional published pages
added)

DX-1154

7/8/2013

Admitted. (2 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0002, 0004, 0007, 0033,
0069, 0098, 0111, 0112,
0114.
Admitted. (2 pages)

DX-1381

6/27/2013

Admitted. (31 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002, 0009.

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

DX-1391

6/27/2013

Admitted. (33 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0009, 0010, 0011, 0012,
0013, 0034.

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

7/10/2013

Parties’ Stipulated
Exhibit Admission

Any Change from
Admission at Trial?

Admitted. (2 pages)

DX-1393

6/25/2013

Select pages admitted:
0002, 0003.

Select pages admitted:
0002, 0003.

DX-1406

07/09/2013

Admitted (37 pages)

Admitted. (37 pages)

DX-1407

07/09/2013

Select pages admitted:
0002.

Select pages admitted:
0002.
4

Admit all – MotionPoint published
patent application.

Case4:10-cv-02590-CW Document417-1 Filed07/11/13 Page6 of 12

Exhibit
No.

Date
Offered

Admission
During Trial
(no. of pages in exhibit)
Select pages admitted:
0002.

Parties’ Stipulated
Exhibit Admission

Any Change from
Admission at Trial?

Select pages admitted:
0002.

DX-1408

07/09/2013

DX-1409

6/25/2013

Admitted. (2 pages)

Admitted. (2 pages)

DX-1414

6/25/2013

Admitted. (Video)

Admitted. (Video)

PTX-5003

6/25/2013

Admitted. (12 pages –
patent-in-suit)

Admitted. (12 pages –
patent-in-suit)

Admitted complete – TransPerfect
Patent-in-Suit

PTX-5007

6/26/2013

Select pages admitted:
0160, 0180.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0020, 0065, 0067,
0072, 0079, 0149, 150,
0160, 0180, 0188.

Yes (additional published pages
added)

PTX-5008

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0010, 0011.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0010, 0011.

PTX-5009

7/1/2013

Select pages admitted:
0011.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0011.

Yes (additional published pages
added)

PTX-5012

7/3/2013

Select pages admitted:
0087, 0232, 0278, 0282,
0294.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0087, 0232, 0278,
0282, 0294, 0307.

Yes (additional published pages
added)

7/8/2013
7/10/2013
PTX-5018

6/27/2013

Admitted. (35 pages)

0001,0002, 0007, 0008,
0010, 0017, 0035.

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

PTX-5037

6/26/2013

Admitted. (407 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0252, 0265.

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

5

Case4:10-cv-02590-CW Document417-1 Filed07/11/13 Page7 of 12

Exhibit
No.

Date
Offered

Admission
During Trial
(no. of pages in exhibit)
Select pages admitted:
0001, 0015.

Parties’ Stipulated
Exhibit Admission

Any Change from
Admission at Trial?

PTX-5039

7/9/2013

PTX-5041

6/26/2013

Admitted. (42 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0032.

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

PTX-5042

6/26/2013

Admitted. (122 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0011, 0069.

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

PTX-5043

7/1/2013

Admitted. (3 pages)

Select Pages Admitted:
0001, 0002

PTX-5065

6/25/2013

Select pages admitted:
0001.

Select pages admitted:
0001.

PTX-5069

7/1/2013

Select pages admitted:
0003.

Select pages admitted:
0003 (redacted).

PTX-5084

7/9/2013

Admitted. (2 pages)

Admitted. (2 pages)

PTX-5090

7/1/2013

Admitted. (22 pages)

Admitted. (22 pages)

PTX-5091

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0011

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0003, 0011, 0013,
0038, 0040, 0049, 0050
0059, 0063.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0015.

6

TransPerfect wants to Admit
Complete
Yes (additional published pages
added)

Case4:10-cv-02590-CW Document417-1 Filed07/11/13 Page8 of 12

Exhibit
No.

Date
Offered

Admission
During Trial
(no. of pages in exhibit)
Admitted. (6 pages)

PTX-5094

7/3/2013

PTX-5095

6/27/2013

Parties’ Stipulated
Exhibit Admission
Admitted. (6 pages)

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0064, 0183, 0184,
0194, 0217, 0229, 0243,
0260, 0273, 0297.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0064, 0183, 0184,
0194, 0217, 0229, 0243,
0260, 0273, 0297.

PTX-5096

7/3/2013

Admitted. (1 page)

Admitted. (1 page)

PTX-5097

7/8/2013

Select pages admitted:
0052, 0059, 0060, 0061,
0063. (263 pages)

0001, 0002, 0052-65.

PTX-5098

7/8/2013

Admitted. (12 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0003, 0004, 0006,
0009.

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

PTX-5104

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0032

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0027, 0032, 0034.

Yes (additional published pages
added)

PTX-5137

7/1/2013

Select pages admitted:
0006.

Select pages admitted:
0006 (redacted).

PTX-5138

7/9/2013

Admitted. (3 pages)

Admitted. (3 pages)

PTX-5158

6/27/2013

Admitted. (5 pages)

Admitted. (5 pages)

PTX-5159

7/1/2013

Admitted. (3 pages)

Admitted. (3 pages)

PTX-5165

6/27/2013

Admitted. (3 pages)

Admitted. (3 pages)

PTX-5168

6/27/2013

Admitted. (2 pages)

Admitted. (2 pages)

7

Any Change from
Admission at Trial?

Yes (added pages to provide
context)

Case4:10-cv-02590-CW Document417-1 Filed07/11/13 Page9 of 12

Exhibit
No.

Date
Offered

Admission
During Trial
(no. of pages in exhibit)
Admitted. (2 pages)

Admitted. (2 pages)

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0064, 0332, 0355.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0064, 0332, 0355.

PTX-5196

6/27/2013

Admitted. (44 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002.

PTX-5259

6/26/2013

Admitted. (10 pages)

Admitted. (10 pages)

PTX-5295

6/27/2013

Admitted. (1 pages)

Admitted. (1 pages)

PTX-5389

6/27/2013

Admitted. (2 pages)

Admitted. (2 pages)

PTX-5404

6/26/2013

None

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002

PTX-5193

6/27/2013

PTX-5195

6/27/2013

7/10/2013

Parties’ Stipulated
Exhibit Admission

PTX-5407

6/26/2013

Admitted. (2 pages)

7/8/2013

Admitted. (2 pages)

Admitted. (2 pages)

PTX-5433

7/8/2013

Admitted. (9 pages)

Admitted. (9 pages)

PTX-5434

7/8/2013

Select pages admitted:
0013, 0097, 0098, 0161

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0009, 0013, 0094,
0097, 0098, 0112, 0161

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0048, 0049, 0050.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0048, 0049, 0050.

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

Admitted. (2 pages)

PTX-5431

Any Change from
Admission at Trial?

7/9/2013
PTX-5445

6/25/2013

8

Yes (additional published pages
added)

Case4:10-cv-02590-CW Document417-1 Filed07/11/13 Page10 of 12

Exhibit
No.

Date
Offered

Admission
During Trial
(no. of pages in exhibit)
Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002.

PTX-5446

7/8/2013

PTX-5451
PTX-5506

Parties’ Stipulated
Exhibit Admission
Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002.

7/8/2013

Admitted. (5 pages)

Admitted. (5 pages)

6/26/2013
7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0003, 0005, 0012,
0017, 0037, 0038, 0045.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0003, 0005, 0012,
0017, 0037, 0038, 0045.

PTX-5520

7/3/2013

Select pages admitted:
0003.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0003.

PTX-5521

6/27/2013

Admitted. (2 pages)

Admitted. (2 pages)

PTX-5542

6/26/2013

Admitted. (26 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0008, 0009.

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

PTX-5597

6/26/2013

Admitted. (23 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0021.

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

PTX-5607

6/27/2013

Admitted. (8 pages)

Admitted. (8 pages)

PTX-5634

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0065.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0018, 0034, 0050,
0065, 0073.

9

Any Change from
Admission at Trial?

Yes (additional published pages
added)

Yes (additional published pages
added)

Case4:10-cv-02590-CW Document417-1 Filed07/11/13 Page11 of 12

Exhibit
No.

Date
Offered

Admission
During Trial
(no. of pages in exhibit)
Select pages admitted:
0013.

PTX-5639

7/9/2013

PTX-5662

Parties’ Stipulated
Exhibit Admission
Select pages admitted:
0013.

6/25/2013

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0004.

Select pages admitted:
0001; 0004.

PTX-5673

7/2/2013

Select pages admitted:
0189, 0191

Selected pages admitted:
0001, 0189, 0191

PTX-5686

6/27/2013

Admitted. (13 pages)

Admitted. (13 pages)

PTX-5687

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002, 0034, 0035.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002, 0034, 0035

PTX-5707

7/10/2013

None

Admitted. (5 pages)

PTX-5719

7/10/2013

None

Admitted. (3 pages)

PTX-5720

6/26/2013

Admitted. (34 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0034.

PTX-5734

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0002.

Select pages admitted:
0002.

PTX-5766

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0041, 0049.

Select pages admitted:
0041, 0042, 0049, 0051.

PTX-5771

7/10/2013

Select pages admitted:
0079

Select pages admitted:
0079

PTX-5782

7/3/2013

Admitted. (3 pages)

Admitted. (3 pages)
10

Any Change from
Admission at Trial?

Yes (additional published pages
added)
Admitted Complete – all pages
needed for context (Best Buy web
site)

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

Case4:10-cv-02590-CW Document417-1 Filed07/11/13 Page12 of 12

Exhibit
No.

Date
Offered

PTX-5790

6/27/2013

Admission
During Trial
(no. of pages in exhibit)
Admitted. (13 pages)

Parties’ Stipulated
Exhibit Admission

Any Change from
Admission at Trial?

PTX-5801

6/26/2013

Admitted. (32 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0007, 0010, 0011,
0016, 0025, 0026.

PTX-5829

6/27/2013

Admitted. (1 page)

Admitted. (1 page)

PTX-5840

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0012, 0013.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0012, 0013.

PTX-5834

6/27/2013

Admitted. (15 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0001.

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

PTX-5984

6/26/2013

Admitted. (104 pages)

Select pages admitted:
0014.

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)

PTX-6002

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0004.

Select pages admitted:
0004.

PTX-6024

7/10/2013

None

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0002.

PTX-6025

7/9/2013

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0014, 0021, 0022.

Select pages admitted:
0001, 0014, 0021, 0022.

PTX-6026

6/25/2013

Select pages admitted:
0001.

Select pages admitted:
0001.

PTX-6029

7/3/2013

Admitted. (7 pages)

Admitted. (7 pages)

Admitted. (13 pages)

7/9/2013

11

Yes (selected pages to decrease
volume)