ADT Security Services, Inc. v. Security One International, Inc. et al
Filing
341
PRETRIAL ORDER NO.7 RE: DISPUTED DISCOVERY EXCERPTS-PARTIAL. Signed by Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers on 9/13/2013. (fs, COURT STAFF) (Filed on 9/13/2013)
1
2
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
3
4
NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA – OAKLAND DIVISION
5
6
7
8
9
CIVIL ACTION No. C 11-05149 YGR
ADT SECURITY SERVICES, INC.,
10
Plaintiff,
11
PRETRIAL ORDER NO. 7 RE: DISPUTED
DISCOVERY EXCERPTS - PARTIAL
vs.
12
13
SECURITY ONE INTERNATIONAL, INC.,
et al.,
14
Trial Date: September 16, 2013
Time: 8:00 a.m.
Defendants.
JURY TRIAL DEMAND
15
16
Pending before this Court are Plaintiff ADT Security Services, Inc. (“ADT”) and
17
18
Defendants Security One International, Inc. and Claudio Hand (“Defendants”) Joint List of
19
Discovery Excerpts and the Disputed Designations. The Court having considered the legal
20
objections made, HEREBY ORDERS as follows:
21
22
No.
Form of
Excerpt
Designation in Dispute
Court’s Ruling
23
24
25
26
27
PLAINTIFF’S DESIGNATIONS
Answer to
Defendant Security One
1.
Request to
International, Inc.’s
Admit
Answer to Plaintiff’s
(Plaintiff’s
First Set of Requests for
Designation)
Admission, Request No.
15
Reserves
28
ORDER RE DISCOVERY EXCERPTS
Case No. C-11-05149-YGR
0
1
2
No.
2.
3
4
5
6
6.
7
8
9
7.
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
Form of
Excerpt
Answer to
Request to
Admit
(Plaintiff’s
Designation)
Designation in Dispute
Defendant Security One
International, Inc.’s
Answer to Plaintiff’s
First Set of Requests for
Admission, Request No.
16
Deposition of 10:23-25;
Sharlene Dore 11:5-22
(Defendants’
CounterDesignation)
Deposition of 13:18-25;
Jamie
14:8-24;
Tandberg
15:6-7;
(Plaintiff’s
15:14-16;
Designation)
15:18;
15:20-23;
16:1-2;
16:4;
17:14-16;
17:18;
19:17-19;
30:24-31:1;
31:3;
31:8-32:6;
33:4-14;
34:2-4
19
20
Court’s Ruling
Reserves
10:23-25 - Sustained
11:5-22 - Overruled
Objections sustained to designations:
13:18-25;
14:8-24;
15:6-7;
15:14-16;
15:18;
15:20-23;
16:1-2;
16:4;
17:14-16;
17:18;
31:19-32:1
Objections overruled to
19:17-19
30:24-31:1
31:3
31:8-18
Court reserves on the remaining
designations for a proffer on the purpose
for which they are offered
21
22
23
8.
24
25
26
9.
27
28
Deposition of
Jamie
Tandberg
(Defendants’
CounterDesignation)
Deposition of
Pamela
McCollom
(Plaintiff’s
17:24-18:3;
40:17-25;
42:4-44:22
17:24-18:3 designation is moot
40:17-25: objections overruled.
40:23 is stricken
42:4-44:22: overruled
16:1-16:7;
16:11-14;
22:4-11
Designations are withdrawn
ORDER RE DISCOVERY EXCERPTS
Case No. C-11-05149-YGR
1
1
No.
2
3
10.
4
5
Form of
Excerpt
Designation)
Deposition of
Pamela
McCollom
(Defendants’
CounterDesignation)
Designation in Dispute
34:3-10;
36:23-37:2
Court’s Ruling
34:3-10 overruled. 34:6-7 is stricken
36:23-37:2
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
DEFENDANTS’ DESIGNATIONS
11. Arta Motadel 8:14-21;
Deposition
11:24-12:1;
Transcript
12:24;
(Defendants’
14:10;
Designation)
21:22-22:13;
12. Richard
9:25-10:5
Weiner
Deposition
Transcript
(Defendants’
Designation)
18. Carlos Mejia
11:17-20;
Deposition
11:21-12:5;
Transcript
17:20-23;
(Defendants’
18:1-5;
Designation)
18:14-20;
18:23-19:2 ;
19:9-10;
19:12;
49:4-5;
49:7;
59:14-19;
59:21-25;
35:9-39:22;
40:25-41
19.
24
25
26
27
28
20.
Carlos Mejia
Deposition
Transcript
(Plaintiff’s
CounterDesignation)
Percy Green
Deposition
Transcript
8:14-21 overruled
11:24-12:1 overruled
12:24 sustained
14:10 sustained
21:22-22:13 overruled
9:25-10:5 sustained
Reserves
27:16-28:19;
29:6-9;
29: 25-30:5;
27:16-28:19 overruled
29:6-9 overruled
29: 25-30:5 overruled
12:4-6;
12:11-14;
12:16-22;
12:4-6 overruled
12:11-14 overruled
12:16-18 overruled
ORDER RE DISCOVERY EXCERPTS
Case No. C-11-05149-YGR
2
1
No.
2
Form of
Excerpt
(Defendants’
Designation)
Designation in Dispute
Court’s Ruling
Interrogatory
Response
(Defendants’
Designation)
ADT’s
supplemental Designations are withdrawn
response to Defendants’
Interrogatory No. 4
12:19-22 sustained
3
4
5
21.
6
7
IT IS SO ORDERED.
8
9
Dated: September 13, 2013
10
_______________________________________
YVONNE GONZALEZ ROGERS
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT JUDGE
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
ORDER RE DISCOVERY EXCERPTS
Case No. C-11-05149-YGR
3
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?