Coupons, Inc. v. Stottlemire
Filing
21
Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Opposition to Defendant Stottlemire's Motion to Dismuiss or in the Alternative Motion for Summary Judgment; Opposition to Request for Judicial Notice, Objections to Evidence and Motion to Strike; Coupon's Opposition to Defendant's Motion for Sanction re ( 12 ), ( #15 ), ( #28 ) filed by Coupons, Inc. (Cusack, Dennis) (Filed on 11/13/2007) Text modified and linkage added on 11/15/2007 (bw, COURT STAFF).
<![CDATA[
oupons, Inc. v. Stottlemire
Doc. 21
! -
+2 + *+ ,
# 8# 9#
) + "' !$ ) + ! ''$ ) + !!! !$
&
: 3%
! "! 4 #! $ !%!!"" 4 #! $ !%!!'" 49 ;<= + ;<= + < << () +
9
8;<= +
'
*/ *)
/ )(,3- , ,3 -( ,.( , */.,
" !
)*.,63.) ) ,.( , * -( * 1* 3 -(5( (*)
( *.)(
/ *) >
&
() +
< <
-
) + 4" % 5%" !
6.
+ 1*6) ,*,, 3 -(.3 9 -*3 + %"
, 1
4 4 94
4
= ! "" "4"" + + 6 = 6 ? 9 .+ 9
C
'
<9
" !
&
'
(
# !$ !%!!"" ! "!
)*,(*) *. /
*,+ ,* -( ( *. .0 1/-2 3), ) + 4" % 5%" ! 6.
)*
+ ,*
7
"+
&
Dockets.Justia.com
!
+
&
.3 ( () .0 , ,3 3),+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ + + + (),.*-/ ,(*) ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ,/ .* 3-/. ,63 + + *,(*) ,* -( 32 @2.*/)- +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ * ,/.3 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ( ( A(,6*/, 3.(, +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
'
( (+
, )- .-+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ " ++++++++
" !
3 */ *) 6 323, ,6 , ( .*53- A*/ +, ( 6 ,6 , ,*,, 3 (.3 6 5(* ,3- /+ + + B + + , << 8 9 ( , C 9 5 9 (5 *< B
" # $# $ ++++++++++
" #=$# $ +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
,*,, 3 (.3 (2)*.3 3 -3, )+ ( /)-3. , )- ,63 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ' +
&
: : : C,
9 9
: 8< 3<< > D
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ' ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ' (. ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
+ ( ((+
'
,63 *,(*) *. / .0 1/-2 3), ( .3 *) ,63 + 3 ( *) 3 ,(*) */, ,63 + + 32 ,63
,/.3 )3++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
, )- .-+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ *,(*) 6*/ - 3 -3)(3.3 ,/.3 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
" !
,63 3 3 3), ,* / *., ( *. .3 (3 /)-3. ,63 6 53 3(,63. 33) 3, () */ *) C 5*. *. ()5* 53 23)/()3 -( /,3 * + ,3.( ,++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ *? + !+ + ,63 3<< / *,(*) 9 ( > D9 8 :<5 9 = , > 9< : +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ! ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ! ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ > ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ " #=$# $ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ &
&
+ 3+
,* --.3
3 ,(*)
,*,, 3 (.3 6 ,* / *., 6( *,(*) *.
)*, / (,,3- - ( ( 3 35(-3) 3 *,(*) ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ & / , 3 -3)(3-++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ '
'
(5+ 5+ (
,63 *)
) ,(*)
/ (*) +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ '
# ! $ !%!!""
! "!
( *,(*) *. /
*,+ ,* -( ( *. .0 1/-2 3), ) + 4" % 5%" ! 6.
)*
+ ,*
% %
&
7
"+
!
&
+ !
'
::+ 9 "' #)+-+
+ ""!$ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ "
/+ + ! # '&$ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ + " ' + + 9 !& # $ & ( ! " ! ' +9 % ) , * + %"&% & ! "" A + +) + + !" E #3+-+ $ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ' # 9+ /+ + # '&$ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ + + " # + ""!$+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ' ! + 9&# + "" $+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ " ! # "" $ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ # + '$+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ' ( )% *+ % &&
" !
#
&
'
+ 9 ' "
& #9 # #! . "# #9 #& +
* " !$++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ % ' $+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ # !/ '&$+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
' +9 +' +9 ( #" ' , % "! + 9 +9 1 /+ +
!
0
'&$++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ! + ""!$+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ' "
! +' "
&
! , &
2 "& ! # '&$ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
'
, "
/ /+ + & ! # & $ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ + 1! ::+ 9 #)+-+ + "" $ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ & &
(
# ! $ !%!!"" ! "!
) * + ,* *,+ ,* -( ( *. *,(*) "*. / .0 1/-2 3), ) + 4" % 5%" ! 6.
% %
&
7
"+
! ,
+ ::+ 9 + 9! / #9
&! ! # +-+)+0+ """$+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
!'
"! !&
+ "" $ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
&
'
+ + + B " +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ! / /+ + + B "&+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ /+ + + B /+ + + B " +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ " # $# $ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ " # $# $# $ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ! & "
" !
/+ + + B /+ + + B /+ + + B /+ + + B /+ + + B
" # $# $# $+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ ! " # $# $# $+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ " # $# $ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ " #=$ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ " #=$# $++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ " #=$# $# $ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ & " #=$# $# $ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ " #=$# $# $ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ & " #=$# $# $ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ & & &
&
'
+ + +B / + + +B / /+ + + B /+ + + B 9 + + +B
" !
+ .+ 9
>+ + &#=$#&$+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ &# $ +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ &# $ +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ #<$ FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFF++ ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ & +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
+ .+ 3> 9+ " '" ! " 9 "
&
*
'
8
(
?
9
<
B +' # 3
"" $ ++++++++++++++++++++++ !
(
# ! $ !%!!"" ! "!
,*,(*) *. /
*,+ ,* -( ( *. .0 1/-2 3), ) + 4" % 5%" ! 6.
)*
+ ,*
% %
&
7
"+
!
C
&
:: : 8 9H >9
9: +I
:
G C > 9 < 9
> 99 9 : << > + ?> = << : 9 + 9 = 9+ ( >9 < ?9 + 9 : + : C : C
# H I$ ? << : : 9# /+ + + B : 9
? < < :
?< : <
'
" <?
G+ H9 J : + 9 < 19 > ? 9< 9 = -
I$+ ( 9 9 : C:
" !
9 9 99
9 9 ,9
&
9
C = < 9
<
C = K9 +
9> 9 < 9 9
9
'
: 9 <> : >9 : ? =: : : ? < 9? : $+ : C : : 9 9 > D9 9 << > : 9 9 < = 9 < = % : << 9 9 C : := 9 <9 ? : : #< = : : +A : +A < : < < 9 9 9 > ? < :> = < < 9> +, : C: +
" !
&
9
=
9=
: <?
'
G : (
# ! $ !%!!"" ! "!
99 K9 9
< C
((( 3 9 ?
) =9 +
% %
C .G
<
19
) 9(
?
) * + ,* *,+ ,* -( ( *. *,(*) *. / C .0 1/-2 3), ) + 4" % 5%" ! 6.
&
7
"+
!
:
9
=
< C
:
+ >
: %
C
: >
?8 :>
=K < -
: +
:
&
< 9
<9 : 9 -
:
1 : = C
"" !
9 "" + = 9 = ! : "" +
)
"" + <9 C ? : <
'
? >9 ? 99 > : + G +
<
: <
-
" !
C
< :
9+ .+ = 9<
>+ + <
#=$#&$ +I
99=
H !
< + , 9< 9 + +
! # "" $+ *>
&
"9 "A G 9
G !" : C << :9 9: = ? 9: < H = E #3+-+ << : +$+ 8 < H 9
9+
9% %
9 E
9 99
'
=+, 9 :
% = = 9 : << = ?<
K
9
9< 9 ? :
9 +++ : +I L& +"" : M 9N ? 9 99 L& : 9 < = 9 < = : + ? = << ? (? 9 << ? >
< L& : : 9 < 9 : ? =9 9 < +I
%
" !
9 <= / < <9 <<
:: 9 : : C <<C
:
H M? N + < 9
= I= 9 >
&
'
: < < + ( O 9 <9) < << = < = ?< < < <A ? = 9 29 99 9 = . = ?< 9 ! ""
# ! $ !%!!""
! "!
) * + ,* *,+ ,* -( ( *. *,(*) *. / D .0 1/-2 3), ) + 4" % 5%" ! 6.
% %
&
7
"+
! : > >
&
! C : 9 " :> <
9
:: 9 < +! : <
+
: C 9
<
/+ + + B % << 8
" # $# $
9 *
" #=$# $+ ! 2)32 3
"#""$%&'(% ()**'+,%- . %+/.#$#01 . '#$)"'#.
'
" # $# $ : > 9 : ): 9 >9 > : ? :
4 < << < 9 9 >9 ? 8: 9 ?9 + 9 : &! + ::+ 9 ! 8 > = D9 & # +-+)+0+ + 9! 9 < ? ? ? = /+ + + B < 9= 9 + 9 = S MTN # = 9? 8 9 : : < G : :< "+ :? 9< 8< = 9 < ?+ $U > : : 9? 8 ? U << > :: < ? < << 9 P :9 Q < 9 :: Q 9< << :: > < 9 : << :9 := >
" !
#$ : >? 8: #$ < < ? ># $ >:
"
&
8 ? ? 8:
9= : 9 H: = 9 9
: R8 >
'
F ? 9>
# $# $ :9 9>
9<
8+I ,
" !
# """$ # 9 / ! = 9 ? 9 9Q < 9 < "" $+ ( & !
9$ <<C9 : 9 : C
!,
<
&
K
'
9 9+ :C = " # $# C$ : > 9 4 H 9 ? 9 = < > 9=: >9 > ? : ? Q 9 MTN # $ 8C < 9 <? : ? 8+I (
) * + ,* *,+ ,* -( ( *. *,(*) *. / .0 1/-2 3), ) + 4" % 5%" ! 6.
<
# ! $ !%!!""
! "!
% %
&
7
"+
! 9
: 9 9<
8
9 :
< :
+
+
"+, -5-
9
9
= 9
9 : <
< : :
+, ?9
? =:
: 9 : -5< :
9< : : =: 9> : 9
: ? 99 < 9 > : 9 ? 8# + G 9 :9 9> 9
&
, 9< 9 : :
-5?= 9 ?9 + +, ? #+ << >
+ > 99 9
+ 9
9
'
> 9 ? " # $# $# $ =
" # $# $# $ =
4 $# < +$Q $
" !
$Q $ 9 I=
9? 8 <
9 :
<
H? :
? 89 ? ? <9 > 9 9! : 9 /: : , C 9 <? > : Q 9 H>9 I$Q (9 C 4 : 9Q 9 < TT # 9 : 99 << 9<
<: 9? 9 9 < 9 9 <
% '$Q ? +, : 9 9
9 !$ 9
9< 9 ? <> < :: < : +
99 + << , +
&
<
:: 9 K
#+
'
!&$ 6 +
9
+
+ "" $+ << < = :: -
" !
?8 T : %Q
=K Q :
:
: =% D9
9
,
<
= (
<
: :
<
&
( < :
"" I 9: TQ
9 9< <9 < : 9 C
9 << 9 > : # 9
< H ( > : ? : + <
?
'
, * # 9< (
9 " "" :V H 9$ ?= : ? : 9 T "Q
%
: C = <
9 :
< ? < 9 < ?= QI
# ! $ !%!!""
! "!
) * + ,* *,+ ,* -( ( *. *,(*) *. / : .0 1/-2 3), ) + 4" % 5%" ! 6.
!%
&7
"+
! H
: V :> T+ Q
9
"" 9 < ? I$ <? I << 9 9 << 9 : TT !% + H 9
"
9 ?= H? > 9 < :
9 << 9 <? : : > =
:= # : 9= V <? 9
Q
&
< < => Q
> <:
D9
'
, < 9 > > G <+ G 9 ? 9 : :
<
<
I 9 #( 9=
9 $ < : 9 > : C
: 9 9 <
=
:: <?
9 : < +
9 +,
" !
+
!+ %+"'#. ! 2632 3
"#""$%&'(% 4 #.-5+" '#$)"%" #=$# $ : > 9
&
4 < : < P :: 9 :: ? 9 < << : 9 <Q >9 : > : : 9= : : C8 << 9 9 = < : <Q ?9 ? " # $# $ > 9 > < < 9 9 9 : < 9 9 " #=$# $ < < ?8 ! +, 4 HM N = 9 < ?8 < << 9 9 = < : << :9 := >
: ): 9 >9 > : < ?< #$ : > : >: 8 : #$ < ?< #
?
'
9 : 9 9< << 9 9 = < : ?
" !
8 8 ? :
? < ?< 8 =
&
$ >: > : :
<+ =? << 8 <
, " < = # $# $ =
: : >
9 << =
'
" #=$# $ #< ?8
= (
# ! $ !%!!"" ! "!
) * + ,* *,+ ,* -( ( *. *,(*) *. / * .0 1/-2 3), ) + 4" % 5%" ! 6.
% %
&
7
"+
!
: < 9 :9 : <:
9!
!! # 9 9 :> =
"" $+ < + 9 :
: #
C ? $+ * :9 : < < < > 9
: : > : =
&
9 +
9
<? >9
: : +
C
9
'
( 9 9 , 9 <9 9> < :9 9= : =: + + + 9 >% 9? '+ , 99 + % !+ 1 #=$# $# :$+ , : 9 9< + 1 ,< 9 J H :? + 9< : ::+ 9 << ( >< : : :> + < < 9 : 9 !" J: : : + 9 :: > < << ::+ 9 9 9 U < 9 > :9 : =: /+ + + B 9 9> > > + % 9 : > << 9 9 = > 9 > !" 9H 9 : C +( : : : : ! : >9 9 : 9< <Q $ << 9 9 = < : ? 9 : 4$ : < << 8 9 Q : 9 9$ > 9 9 9 9 = <? : 8. 9 9 9 9 9 : : = :> 9? ? 1 ! + " + 9 ::+ 9 = ?9 : 8 ? #)+-+ 9 + "" $ 1 9 A !
+( 1 > 9= 9
" !
=
8
&
( "
'
" !
&
4U > 9 +C H ?
" #=$# $# $+I 1 U I< J <
'
H
: >9 9 ?
&% %
9 <
&7
:
"+
# ! $ !%!!""
! "!
) * + ,* *,+ ,* -( ( *. *,(*) *. / .0 1/-2 3), + ) + 4" % 5%" ! 6.
!
J : > <
9
+C :9 ? 8: < 1 ,! 8 :
/+ + + B :
" #=$# $# $+I , 9? 8 9: :
< :: 9
: > +
? >?89
9 =
? 8: = D 94 = > 9 =:
? 8: =
/+ + + B "&+
&
,
'
" !
1 ! 6" : <> 9 9 +
" #=$ : = << 8 >9 > ? ? :> : J < :9 ?8 ?: 9 > >? 8 9 = : < ? 8: < 8: = =9 9 9: ?8 := + " !" )) + # " + # )!# + ::+ 9 : < 9 9 9% 9 9 + 9 < : ? # ?8 <? + > : J = 9 < :9 9< : 9 !# : 99 9$+ << 8 9 9? 9 9 <? : < % : ? ? : Q = 9+ <? 9 ? C > + : << 8 9 ? : C
&
:
'
" !
57#.4 $$%0%- #71('0/" (#"%+"'#. : J : : : :G +& : < ? 8 #+ + +, : < 1 << A 9 >9 D #HA D C C > ?8 G : < /+ + +I$ T + : *<< < < : 9 9 :: : $ 9 : C + : : =K =K
&
'
& . (
# ! $ !%!!"" ! "!
! :
)* + ,*
<
>9 '
< +9
% %
: !%
C> 9 #&
+ (! + + ""!$+
& 7 "+
? *,(*) *. /
*,+ ,* -( ( *. .0 1/-2 3), ) + 4" % 5%" ! 6.
!
? + < , +( < & #9 ? 99 < G << > : = : ::
9 <J 99 : < 9 <
9
< 9 9? 8
<
:
C <<
: <
9 :
: C 9
> &!
? + 9 : < : ::+ 9
&
: : +
+
% J
<? 8
$+ ,
'
9
#57#.4 $$%0%- )+, #* 5"/#('8)"'#.
" !
-: ? < ? 9T ? T 9 ? + : = & :
C D 9+ : < + D9 TT " + : H> 9 < :9 : : : 8 9
:
: D 9 9: < 9 H= 9 :9 : 9I #= H> 9 < > 8 ?9 9 C > D9 : I< : : 9+I : : : D9 = < +A D = : C < 9 = 9 <
C = <? : ? +
&
: >9 +
'
( < < ?$ ? D 9+ :: : C 9 <
" !
<
9 + T '+
&
'
+ + " # + 9 < 9 : >9 9 : 9 : C 9 : 9: ? : 9= << > < ++ ' % '!+ , : << D9 : < : #+ ' $Q ? > : << 9 9 ? < 9+ + +, 99 < J9 9 D 9 9 ? 9 = 9 << :> 9< 9 C ? = 9= > < C : : : 9 9: < : 9 9: ? D + < < C <? = 99 9 9 : : + <' +, 9 9 < ? :9 =9 : 9 <? < ? 9: 9 =9 : ++ '+ ( +9 > ' # 9+ 9 ? + ""!$ : "!
) * + ,* *,+ ,* -( ( *. *,(*) *. / C .0 1/-2 3), ) + 4" % 5%" ! 6. '% % &7
"+
'
<
"! 9+ (
# ! $ !%!!""
! "!
! :
>
<
D = H?
9 < :
" # $# $+ , ? I
" #=$# $+
&
9 9 C 9+ ( ? : < >
#57#.4 4 %+/.#$#01 **%+"':%$1 (#"%+"4 "4 '0/"4 8 << : D ?< J > < : : : < < : 99 ?8 ? J: 9 9 9 C 8 H << <. #=$#&$ << > +, &! G < + + &! < < 9 < 9< 9 " # $# $# $ = U +, << > :: ? < < ? 8+CI <9 C ? H? 8 : J: ? 8C < : + % '+ I? : >9 :: ? 99 H 9< H 9 ? = H << ::+ 9 " > < + ! %' " I + < : C I : 9? 8 = J = 9 : C = ? + : + : = < <
'
: ?
" !
:
: = < 99 >
:
: 9 :
+
:
&
+'
,
# +-+)+0+ """$Q
'
::+ 9 "'
):-+ +
+ ""!$ # 9? 8?
:
" !
G <
$+ & !
?+I < : < '
+
G :
&
'
) G : 9 (
# ! $ !%!!"" ! "!
:
9 <
: >> : 8 ? ?
C <9 +
% %
< > A D <
K9 9 +T + :<
) * + ,* *,+ ,* -( ( *. *,(*) *. > / .0 1/-2 3), ) + 4" % 5%" ! 6.
&
7
"+
!
#
H <<
> )
I #
: + + 9 ? 9
9? 8 < '+ , :: > = >
< 9= 4
)"" M-N < 9 < C = ? > 9: 9+ ( ? 99 : C <
" !
< 9: 9?
&
'
< < 9 9< 9 ? ? <: ? : ? : 9 ++ : = ' 8 +9 : 9 9> 99 : 9< 9 : K < < : :> : < 9 : : 99
9 9= +, < (! + + ""!$ < 9 < 9 < < + : < 89 9 : 9 9 9 < K < : : : 9 9= = 9 ? 9 9 + ? < +, : C + = > + < :
!
#&
<J : : 9< 9< 9 99 < : = > 8 99 -
9 : 9 : < 9 <+ 9 9 +, :
8+ ( 9 <? :
(! + <
&
:
'
= <? :
> + +, 9> 9 > " ? : 9> ? !+ = : 99 > < : = : : ? : ? ? 9 ? : : < 9 :
<
" !
+ :
9< + +, : + + !&+ . < J:
9
: 9=
9 :<
9
9
<
G:
&
9 + + =
?
:
> <
9+
+
'
(: =
"
: 9
: -
9 ?
: +
, : ( =+
9: > + !!+
# ! $ !%!!""
! "!
) * + ,* *,+ ,* -( ( *. *,(*) *. < / .0 1/-2 3), ) + 4" % 5%" ! 6.
"% %
&7
"+
!
?
!+ 9 > + !'+ ( H < <9 : : = : 9 8 : # < = 9 + + 8 : 9 < : = : 9: : : !+ 9 J:
9 ?8 ? < U C< J ?8 >
? 9 :?
< 9 99
:: 9 -5<
=
&
9C 8 (
J
:+
? 8+I = J: : 9 : ? < < < J + -5+ 99
+( :
? : : : : (! + 9 9 ? 8= 9 ? : : H 9 9 9
'
!+
J:
" !
:+ 9>
+ 9
9
: 9 ? 8+I> .
9
:> 8
&
: :
/
(! + ? : 9 # 8 : T
?
: 9
:
'
+ $ :
TT > -
%
!%
+, 9 9
< > +
?8 %:
" !
(
9 <' < :
&
K9 ? #9 ? ? K9 # '&$Q + '&$+
H <
C
:
= = 9+I 0 #" = < < 9 9
>9: , H ? > ( /+ + ! %
9
= "! + 9 9: < !9 /+ +
K9 99
<9 :<9 >
'
< ?+I
9+ .+
>+ + &# $Q !
! # '&$+
(
# ! $ !%!!"" ! "!
) * + ,* *,+ ,* -( ( *. *,(*) *. / .0 1/-2 3), ( ) + 4" % 5%" ! 6.
% %
&
7
"+
!
> : # , +
> " /<
= 1
99 ? 2 & /+ + & ! & < "&
=
< ! H= 9 > : " /+ + < 9 # = < ! ' # '&$
# & $$+ , ?
&
9 '= 9= + 9 !& > * + ? : = * & : : > + 9 :: > < =9 :9 : ?9 : : :: # < <9 > ' +9 99 9+ ? 9= " # $# $# $ ( #$ : J " "& # A : 9 < 9 9 D > 9 + : > : > C 9 9 9+ : :: :: I +I$ # + 9 +, 9 : < > # <> < + :: >9 : '$+
::
+I
'
<< :: *3 "
H
9< 9 I +9
<> 9
<
" !
!# 9
+
!$+
H< :> <
9
= > C <
: G
< =
+I 6 ? > 9 > ?8 <
&
> : :
C
:: := + < A D K9 > 9: ) < . '&$$+ 9 J: :9 > 9 9< 9 # $+
% %
: 9 :
9
J ?
9 -
'
+ TT !% + : 9< % K9 &#<$ : #! . : # 9 '' +9 : = !/ H< ' 9+ .+ >+ + &#<$
" !
' $ #HA K <
+
&
9 >
(
: < :: < 9 > <
>9 > > < 9 G 9# 9W
= 9 ? < >
& 7 "+
9
'
<8 ?
" #=$# $# $
# ! $ !%!!""
! "!
, *,(*) *. /
*,+ ,* -( ( *. .0 1/-2 3), ) + 4" % 5%" ! 6.
)*
+ ,*
!
$ &" !#?
$ % &&
: ' : 8
J: ( .
9
< )% &#<$ > 8
= * +& = :
9+
# +9
+ "" $ #HM,N : < <
J: <
9 <
<
&
9 < :
8 9 <9 = 9I$+
'
H
:
" !
<< ? 8 # $ << 9#$ 9: <
> >
<B
" # $# $ 9=
: >4#$ ? ?
:<> =
9
: # $ #< >
>
? : 9 :9 <
#!$ ? 9= 9: : <
D = > > +F : #$ # + Q << < ' Q# $ #$ := < <:9 9 8 9
< 9< 9
&$
#$9 9
=9:
&
< = :>
> #$ 9< 9 # 9+ +I
< #$ "! 9: > +
< #&$# $ # $ + "
=9 +9 '
'
"8
+ ""!$+ ;.%(4/'7 #* ) )$'- #71('0/"
" !
: 9J: 9 + #3 < ? ?
?:
H =:
?8 >9 9> 9* : Q
< :9 : 8 ( =K 9 :
:I ? = ? : 9 9 <J 9 : +T + , + < : 9
<J 9
=< 9 ?8 <
<
9<
/+ + + B " Q : > 9 : : : < : C 9 : + : A ::
B +'
"" C + $
: ? = Q : 9
9 D9 < > 8 :
&
< : ? + 9 (<
9
<? 9
? < =K
'
J: > :
D
-
?8
% %
# ! $ !%!!""
! "!
) * + ,* *,+ ,* -( ( *. *,(*) *. / 9 .0 1/-2 3), ) + 4" % 5%" ! 6.
&
7
"+
! <: <
&
C 9 > 99 "+ (< 9 9 >> > H9 :9 9 << : +
: I C 9 > 9 < ?
<J 9= C ? : : 9
J 9
9 9
:
<
J 9+ :
:: 9 J
=
9 ? 8+ . :
'
**%+"':% #."(#$ 61 ) %+/.#$#0'+)$ :
" !
%)45(% > <: I
:> 9 ? 8+ & ! > < 9 9? 8 < 9
< < H? : + ::+ 9 : ? 9 : :> 9 < 39 # G 9$ : #H > :< 9< <: : 9 < + A D 9 < 9 9 << ? 89
<<
9<
9? <
% '+ H(< << > 99 9 9>9 < < : 9 +I$ TT !% + J: 99 < =: + T !+ 9< +A 9 +A < 9? : D 9 D > +I + ? :: '+ 9 << < :
?
&
: C
9 9+ < +: 99
+6
9G > : ? C <9 +
<
'
" !
> T +, : :: : 9 J 9
<
9
>
9
:
.)5"/#('8%- '(+5&:%."'#. 9= H > ? < : : 9 9 <?
!% %
&
> /
9<
I < : 9 = H= D9
9
=: : = D 9=
&7
:
? < -
+
'
+ + + B : " # $# $+ 6 9 ( : 9=
9+ A :
+ T '+ <?
"+
# ! $ !%!!""
! "!
) * + ,* *,+ ,* -( ( *. *,(*) *. / .0 1/-2 3), : ) + 4" % 5%" ! 6.
!
>9 9= : < +I
: D
+
9? + T !+ (
9 ? < : 9
?
< C +, : <
<? 9 9 < : : 9
: <? C + ?9 :
9
= 9: ?
<
9 : <
=
&
%4'0.%- #( :
)(,%"%- *#( '(+5&:%."'#. :: < J: :: 9 #9 : FI + 9 H( +I > 9? 9 9 9 + T !Q 9 8 :: 9 : $ ? J< < 9 ? = < <? ? TT !% <>9 9 : 9 << > > >
'
9 9 4 9: <<
: >9 9 >9 9 : 9 < C 9 <? <?
9 9=
+( <
" !
: :
H( 9= : 9
: <? =
: >9 9= < : << J << J < 3J = + : +
# $
&
9= C
<? > ?
< 9 <<
+, G
'
= 9 =C <
C
:: .G ((( 3
9 < 19
= ) <
9 <?
9 < C
9 K9
)+ 9+
" !
9= 9
! 2 32 3 < " #=$# $+ , K9 9 " #=$# $# $ H : : : > 1 ! : " 9< <Q $ << 9 9 = < + : ::+ 9 ? 9 #)+-+ + : 4 : $ 9 > 99 : C << << 8 9 Q 9 9
: ? +
&
: < 9 > :: < << +, 9>
: 9 9<
: >
'
$:
"" $+ (
# ! $ !%!!"" ! "!
: *,(*) *. /
*,+ ,* -( ( *. .0 1/-2 3), ) + 4" % 5%" ! 6.
)*
+ ,*
% %
&
7
"+
!
I : : : + 9= : 9= : 9? 8# 9 << : C < + C # 3J = 2$ : 8: : 9 ?? = < ) ? .G :: : < 9< 9
<< :
9 C <? <
9
9 9
<?
? ? : =: ?
9? 9
H= = <
+ TT % + 6 : : < > $+ 9 9:
?9 : 1 ! "
&
<
:9 ::+ 9 % 9
99 !+ , 9 9 <?
= J
:
+ : :
'
9 <
" !
< < H K K9
19
) 9
J= 9+ .+ 3> 9+ " + 1 9 = 9: #$ #$ := = < =G 99 < 9: 9: = =: 9 ? 9 ::
<?
=K 9 ? C : J= =K +A <
9 9+I
9 9+ .+
&
3 .> 9+ " + )
'
= +( >9
G
<
19 3
94 ?= 9 9+ .+ 3> 9+ " + < < 9+ .+ 9 +( 9+ "" + = 9+ .+ <
J >= =
" !
-%
,
< 9 3J = 3 =:
96 9 9
9 > C 9+ .+ 3> 9+ !" +
J= % 9: 9 : > > : C9 :: <? + ? = 3 < 9 9 =: > 9+< " + , 3J = > C 3 9 =: 9+ .+ 3> 9+ !" +
&
9=6 J : <9 = < 3 .+ 3> 9+ '" +
< 9
C 9
? 9 9 => <
<
? ?= J= 9 =: 9: 3. 9 >+
'
(
# ! $ !%!!"" ! "!
,J = 2 :9 3: : < > 9+ !" +
: ? K9 ::
: =
<9 >=
9 : 9 9< =
) * + ,* *,+ ,* -( ( *. *,(*) *. / 6 .0 1/-2 3), ) + 4" % 5%" ! 6.
&% %
&7
"+
!
. G &# $+ < 19 = 9 C ) J 99
= :: < 9 .G C < 19 ) < K9
< + 9
3J = 9+ .+ >+ +
&
9= 9
9+
'
? : <:
< 9= J :
= ?
9 9 = > *:: < < <9 : : 8 >9 < C
: ::
C +, 9 K <9 9+
" !
K9 9 : :: + 9 K 9
+ *:: 9
9 9<
9
9= 9 =A
&
C 9
=>
:
:
<
G K9 ?+
9 9 ? +
>< C G G < K9 9
'
9
:
C
<
" !
94 ) >
=
""
4.3
. /)
.,3
-WW + * < : / *) () +
&
8
'
(
# ! $ !%!!"" ! "!
) * + ,* *,+ ,* -( ( *. *,(*) *. / .0 1/-9 3), 2 ) + 4" % 5%" ! 6.
% %
&
7
"+
]]>
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?
