Hovsepian v. Apple, Inc.

Filing 150

Hovsepian v. Apple, Inc.

Doc. 150 Att. 2

EXHIBIT C

Dockets.Justia.com

HENNIGAN, BENNETT & DORMAN LLP
LAWYERS
601 SOUTH F"IGUEROA STREET

SUITE 3300

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90017
TELEPHONE [phone] F"ACSIMILE [phone]

DIRECT PHONE [phone] DORMANRO HBDLAWYERS.COM

January 13,2006

VI ELECTONIC MAL
TO ALL COUNSEL OF RECORD:
See Attached Disfnöution List

Re: In re Acacia Media Technologies Corporation Patent Litigation

Dear Counel:

Attached is a proposed stipulated sum judgment of non-iningement and
invalidity for indefiteness of U.S. Patent No. 6,144,702. Please review the docuent
and communcate to Alan Block by Monday, Janua 23, 200 whether the content and form is acceptable to your respecve clents.

RGD:ls

Enclosure

524457\vl

DISTRIUTION LIST
Juanita R. Brooks Todd G. Miller Fish & Richardson 12390 El Camno Real San Diego, California 92130-2081
Counsel for:

Jonathan E. Singer Wiliam R. Woodford Fish & Richardson
60 South Sixth Street, Suite 3300 Minneapolis, Minnesota 55402

Counsel for:

ACMP LLC;Ademia Multmedia ac; Adult
Entertinment Broadcast Network;

ACMP LLC;Ademia Muledia LLC; Adult
Entertainment Broadcast Network;

Adult Revenue Services; Audio Communicatns; Cl Inc.; Club lenna Inc.; Cyber Trend Inc.; Cybernet Ventures Inc.; Game Unk Inc.; Global A VS Inc.; Innovatve
Ideas Internnal; Ughtspeedcash; Natnal

Adult Revenue Services; Audio . Communicatns; Cl Inc.; Club lennalnc.; Cyber Trend Inc.; Cybemet Ventures Inc.;
Game Link Inc.; Global A VS Inc.; Innovatvf?
Ideas Internna; Lightspeedcash; Natnal A-I Adverting Inc.; New Destiny

A-I Adverting Inc.; New Destiny Internet
Group LLC; VS Media Inc.
Victor De Gyaras

Internet Group LLC; VS MedUlInc.
Gar A. Hecker
James Michael Slominski

Willam J. Robinson Foley & Ladner 2029 Century Park E, 35th Floor Los Angeles, Californa 90067
Counsel for:

Hecker Law nroup

1925 Centu Park East, Suite 2300
Los Angeles, California 90067
Counsel for:

Internatna Web Innovatns, Inc.

Offendae Commercil Umited BV
Alfredo A. Bismonte Daniel II Fingerman Bobby T. Shih Mount & Stoelker, P.C.
River Park Tower, 17th Floor

Mark D. Schneider Gifford, Krass, Groh, Sprinkle, Anderson and Citkowski 280 N. Old Woodward Avenue, Suite 400 Birmngham, Michigan 48009-5394
Counsel for:

Askcs.com Inc.

333 W. San Carlos St. San Jose, CA 95110
Counsel for:

Askcs.com Inc.

Ada Robert Alper David Allen York
Latham & Watkins

135 Commonwealth Drive Menlo Park, California 94025
Counsel for:

Rachel Krevans Jason A. Crotty Paul A. Friedman Mornson & Foerster LLP
425 Market Strt

AP Net Marketing Inc.; ICS Inc.

San Francisco, California 94105-2482
Counsel for:

SateUite ac; Echostar Technologis Corporatn; Echostar Communicatns Corporaton
David C. Doyle Morrson & Foerster LLP 3811 Valley Centr Dr., Suite 500 San Diego, California 92130
Counsel for:

Echo3tar Technologis Corporaton

Annemare A. Daley Stephen P. Safranski

Robins Kaplan Miller & Ciresi LLP 2800 LaSalle Plaza
800 LaSalle A venue

Richard R. Patch J. Timothy Nardell Coblentz, Patch, Duffy & Bass LLP One Ferry Building, Suite 200 San Francisco, California 94111-4213
Counsel for:

Minneapolis, Minnesota 55402
Counsel for:

Coxcom, Inc.; Hospitli Network, Inc.

Coxcom, Inc.; Hospitalit Network, Inc.
Jeffrey H. Dean Kevin D. Hogg Bradford P. Lyerla
Carl E. Myers

Wiliam R. Overend Morgan D. Tovey Reed Smith Crosby Heafey
Two Embarcadero Center, Suite 200
San Francisco, Californa 9411 1 Counsel for:

Marhall Gerstein & BOfUn LL 6300 Sears Tower 233 South Wacker Drive
Chicago, DIinois 60606
Counsel for:

Charter Communicatns, Inc.

Armstrong Group; Arvig Communicatn

Systems; Chaer Communicatns, Inc.; East
Clevela TV

and Communicatns ac;

MassüIon Cable T~ Inc.; Wid Open West LLC
Daralyn J. Dure Joshua H. Lerner David J. Silbert Keker & VanNest LL 710 Sansome Street San Francisco, Californa 94111 Counselfor:
Comcast Cable Communicatns, ac; Insight

Victor G. Savikas Kevin G. McBride Mara K. Nelson Marha E. Mullin Jones Day 555 South Flower Street, 50th Floor Los Angeles, Calfornia 90071
Counsel for:

Communicatns, Inc.
Stephen E. Taylor Jan J. Klohonatz Taylor & Co. Law Offices, Inc. One Ferr Building, Suite 355 San Francisco, California 94111
Counsel for:

DiecTV Group, Inc.
Mitchell D. Lukin
Baker Botts L.L.P.

One Shell Plaza 910 Louisiana Houston, Texas 77022
Counsel for:

Mediacom Communicatns Corporatn

Mediaom Communicatns Corporatn; Bresnan Communicatns
Rebecca Anne Bortolotti
John Christopher Reich

Jeffrey D. Sullvan Michael J. McNamara Baker Botts L.L.P. 30 Rockefeller Plaza New York, New York 10112
Counsel for:

Albert L. Underhill Merchant & Gould
80 S. 8th Street, Suite 3200

Mediacom Communicatns Corporaton;

Minneapolis, Minnesota 55402
Counsel for:

Bresnan Communicatons

Arvig Communicatns Systems; Cannon
Valley Communicatns, Inc.; Loretel Cablevision; Mid-Continent Media, Inc.;

Savage Communicatns, Inc.; Sjoberg's
Cable

vision, Inc.; US Cable Holdings LP

Sean David Garson
Robert Francis Copple

C. Mark Kittedge
Perkins Coie Brown & Bain P A

Lewis & Roca LL
40 N. Central A venue

P.O. Box 400 Phoenix, Arzona 85001-04
Counsel for:

Phoenix, Arzona 85004-429
Counsel for:

Cable One Inc.
Gregory T. Spalj Fabyanske Westra & Har PA
800 LaSalle Avenue, Suite 190

Cable America Corp.
Troy Blinn Forderman George Chun Chen Bryan Cave LLP 2 N. Central A venue, Suite 2200 Phoenix, Arzona 8500-406
Counsel for:

Minneapolis, Minnesota 55402
Counsel for:

Cable System Service, Inc.
Fritz Byers 824 Spitzer Bulding
520 Madison A venue

Cable System Service Inc.
Patrick J. Whalen Spencer Fan Britt & Brown LL

100 Walnut Stret, Suite 1400
Kansas City, Missouri 64106
Counsel for:

Toledo, Ohio 43604
Counsel for:

NPG Cable Inc.
Clay K. Keller

Block Communicatns, Inc.
Melissa G. Ferraro
Bar S. Goldsmith Gar H. Nunes

Buckingham, Doolittle & Burroughs
50 South Main Strt Akon, Ohio 44308
Counsel for:

Womble Carlyle Sandrdge & Rice

8065 Leesburg Pike, Four Floor
Tysons Corner, VA 22182
Counsel for:

Nelsonvüle TV Cable, Inc.

NelsonviU TV Cable, Inc.
Christopher B. Fagan Fay Share Fagan Minnch & McKee 1100 Superior Avenue, Seventh Floor Cleveland, Ohio 44114-2518
Counsel for:
Annstrong Group; East Cleveland TV

Communicatns LL; MassiUon Cable ~
Inc.; Wide Open West, LLC
Benjamn Hershkowitz

and

Stephen S. Korniczky James V. Fazio Paul Hastings Janofsky & Walker LL 3579 Valley Centr Drive San Diego, CA 92130
Counsel for:

Cebrige Connectins
David S. Benyacar Daniel Reisner Kaye Scholar LLP
425 Park A venue

Goodwin Proctor LL
599 Lexington Avenue New York, NY 10022

Counselfor:
CSC Holdings, Inc.

New York, NY. 10022
Counsel for:

Time Warner Cable, Inc.

1 COUNSEL LISTED ON SIGNATUR PAGES
2
3

4
5

6
7
8

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
SAN JOSE DIVISION

9

10
11

In re:
12
0. '" '"

) Case No. C 05-01114

0

m

13

ACACIA MEDIA TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATION PATENT LITIGATION

) MDL No. 1665 )

Q

e H 0

.;
.¡
.¡
Q)

14
15

) (PROPOSED) STIPULATED SUMMARY ) JUDGMENT OF NONINFRINGEMENT ) AND INVALIDITY FOR
) INDEFINITENESS OF US PATENT NO.
) 6,144,702

i: Q) ai
om

0

)

16 17
18

) (F.R.C.P. 54(B); N.D. CAL. LOCAL RULE
7-12)

.o.i .

0 0

:i

Q)

19

20
21

22
23

24
25

26
27
28
Case No. 05-CY-OI 1 14 JW MDL No. 1665

Non-Infringement and Invalidity of

(Proposed) Stipulated Summary Judgment of the '702 Patent

1 On December 7,2005, the Honorable James Ware issued the "Further Claim Construction

2 Order; Order Finding Claims Terms Indefinite And Claims Invalid" ("Order"). In the Order, the
3 Court found, among other things, the following:
4
5
1.

that the claim term "sequence encoder," which appears in independent claims i and
17 and in dependent claims 18 and 32, of

U.S. Patent No. 6,144,702 ("the '702

6
7
8

patent"), is indefinite;
2.

that the claim term "identification encoder," which appears in independent claims 1,
17, and 27 and in dependent claims 5, 6, 19, and 31 of

the '702 patent, is indefinite;

9
10
11

and
3.

that the claim phrase "transmission system at a first location," which appears in

independent claims I, 17, and 27 ofthe '702 patent, means "a transmission system at
one paricular location separate from the location of

12
.0. .. .
i:
'" E

the reception system."

13 Although this MDL proceeding involves claims for patent infrngement by Acacia regarding
14 five related U.S. Patents, Nos. 5,132,992; 5,253,275; 5,550,863; 6,002,720; and the '720 patent, the

"
i:
'"

o

.j .j
'" '" OI

i: i:

15 claim terms "sequence encoder," "identification encoder," and "transmission system at a first

i: '" m -cl i: i: '" II

16 location," do not appear in any ofthe claims ofthese four patents. These claim terms appear only in
17 the claims of

the '702 patent.

18 The paries agree that the effect of

the Court's finding that the term "sequence encoder" in

19 claims 1, 17, 18, and 32 is indefinite and finding that the term "identification encoder" in claims 1,
20 17, and 27 is indefinite, ifupheld on appeal, would be to render all ofthe claims of

the '702 patent

21 (claims 1-42) indefinite, and therefore invalid, under 35 D.S.C. § 112, ~ 2.
22 The paries also agree that the effect of the Court's construction of

the phrase "transmission

23 system ata first location" in claims 1, 17, and 27 of

the '702 patent as meaning "a transmission

24 system at one paricular location separate from the location of the reception system," if upheld on
25 appeal, would be to render all ofthe claims of

the '702 patent (claims 1-42) not infrnged by the

26 transmission systems made, used, or sold by the defendants in this case which are located at more
27 than one location.

28 Accordingly, the parties to the cases listed below agree and request entry of summary

1 judgment of: (1) invalidity for indefiniteness of claims 1 -42 of the '702 patent on the basis that the
2 Court

has found that the terms "sequence encoder" and "identification encoder" of claims 1 -42 of

3 the '702 patent are indefinite; and (2) for non-infrngement of claims 1 -42 the '702 patent on the

4 basis that the Court has construed the phrase "transmission system at a first location" to mean "a

5 transmission system at one particular location separate from the location of the reception system,"

6 which would thereby cause claims 1 -42 ofthe '702 to not be infrnged by transmission systems 7 made, used, or sold by defendants which are located at more than one location. This Summary
8 Judgment is without prejudice as to all rights of Acacia on appeal and without prejudice to Acacia
9 asserting that claims 1 -42 ofthe '702 patent are valid and infrnged by defendants should Acacia

10 prevail in its appeaL.

11 THEREFORE, IT is ADJUICATED, as a matter ofIaw, that Plaintiff Acacia shall take
12 nothing as to all defendants listed below on its claim for infrngement of

its '702 patent, and that, as

13 to all defendants listed below, the Cour shall enter Sumar Judgment of: (1) invalidity of claims.
14 1 -42 for indefiniteness on the basis that the Cour has found that the terms "sequence

encoder" and

15 "identification encoder" of

claims 1-42 of

the '702 patent are indefinite; and (2) non-infrngement of

16 claims 1 -42 on the basis that the Cour has construed the phrase "transmission system at a first

17 location" to mean "a transmission system at one paricular location separate from the location ofthe
18 reception system," which would thereby cause claims 1 -42 ofthe '702 to not be infrnged by

19 transmission systems made, used, or sold by defendants which are located at more than one location.
20 The entry of

this Sumar Judgment is without prejudice to Acacia's rights as outlined above.

21 There is no just cause for delay, and thus the Court directs entry of

this judgment pursuant to

22 Fed. R. Civ. P. Rule 54(b) in the cases listed below:
23
Separate N.D. CaL. Case

Defendant( s)

24
25

Number
05-CY-01561 JW
Game Link, Inc.
Club Jerma, Inc. and CJ, Inc.

26
27 28

05-CY-01562 JW
05-CY-01563 JW

1. Cybemet Yentures, Inc.
2

Case No. 05-CV-OIII4 JW MDL No. 1665

(Proposed) Stipulated Summary Judgment of
Non-Infringement and Invalidity of

the '702 Patent

1

Separate N.D. CaL. Case

Defendant(s)
2. ACMP, LLC

2
3

Number

4
5

3. Global Media Resources SA

05-CY-01564 JW
05-CY-OI565 JW

Global A YS, Inc., dba DrewNet

6

1. ICS, Inc.
2. AP Net Marketing, Inc.

7 8

9

05-CY-01566 JW 05-CY-01568 JW 05-CY-01569 JW 05-CY-01570 JW
.

National A- i Advertising, Inc.

10
11

New Destiny Internet Group
Audio Communications
VS Media, Inc.

12
13

05-CY-01571 JW
14
15

Ademia Multimedia, LLC

05-CY-01572 JW

1. International Web Inovations, Inc.
2. Offendale Commercial Ltd. BY

16 17 18 19

05-CY-01573 JW
05-CV-OI574 JW 05-CY-OI575 JW

Adult Entertainment Broadcast Network
Cybertrend, Inc.

Lightspeedcash
1. Adult Revenue Service
2. Inovative Ideas International

20
21

05-CY-01576 JW

22
23

3. Global Intermedia, Inc.
4. Askcs.com, Inc.
04-CY -02308 JW

24
25

I. Comcast Cable Communications, LLC
2. Charter Communications, Inc.

26
27

3. The DIRCTV Group, Inc.
28
3

Case No. 05-CV-OI I 14 JW MDL No. 1665

(Proposed) Stipulated Summary Judgment of
Non-Infrngement and Invalidity of

the '702 Patent

1

2
3

Separate N.D. Cat. Case Number

Defendant( s)

4. Echostar Technologies Corp.

4
5

5. Echostar Satellite LLC
6. Hospitality Network, Inc.
7. Coxcom, Inc.

6
7
8

04-CY-03789 JW 05-CV-01399 JW

Mediacom Communications Corporation
1. Mid-Continent Media, Inc.

9

10
11

2. US Cable Holdings LP
3. Savage Communications Inc.

12
13

4. Loretel Cablevision

5. Arig Communication System
14
15

6. Canon Yalley Communications, Inc.
7. Sjoberg's Cablevision, Inc.

16 17
18

05-CY-01543 JW

1. Arstrong Group
2. Block Communications, Inc, dba Buckeye Cable
3. Wide Open West LLC
4. Massillon Cable TY, Inc.

19

20
21

22
23

05-CY-01598 JW

1. Cable America Corporation
2. Cable One, Inc.

24
3. NPG Cable, Inc.

25

26
27
28

05-CY-OI703 JW

Cebridge Communications

SO ORDERED.
4

Case No. 05-CY-OI I 14 JW MDL No. 1665

(Proposed) Stipulated Summary Judgment of
Non-Infringement and Invalidity of

the '702 Patent

1

2
3

Date:

United States District Judge
4
5

Stipulated to and agreed upon:

Dated: January _,2006

6
7
8

RODERICK G. DORMAN (CA SBN 96908) ALAN P. BLOCK (CA SBN 143783) KEVIN 1. SHENKAN (CA SBN 223315)

HENNIGAN, BENNTT & DORM LLP
601 South Figueroa Street, Suite 3300

Los Angeles, California 90017

9

10
11

BY:

12
13

ATTORNYS FOR PLAINTIFF ACACIA MEDIA TECHNOLOGIES CORPORA nON

14
15

Dated: Januar _,2006

16 17 18

VICTOR G. SA VIKS (CA SBN 145658) KEVIN G. McBRIE (CA SBN 195866) MASHA E. MULLIN (CA SBN 93709) MAR K. NELSON (CA SBN 155608) JONES DAY 555 West Fifth Street, Suite 4600 Los Angeles, California 90013-1025

19

By:

20
21

Victor G. Savikas

Attorneys for Defendant

THE DIRCTV GROUP, INe.

22
23

24
25

26 27
28
5

Case No. 05-CY-OI 1 14 JW MDL No.1 665

Non-Infringement and Invalidity of

(Proposed) Stipulated Summary Judgment of the '702 Patent

1

Dated: January _, 2006

HAROLD J. McELHIN (CA SBN 66781)
RACHEL KRV ANS (CA SBN 116421) PAUL A. FRIEDMAN. (CA SBN 208920) JASON A. CROTTY (CA SBN 196036) MORRSON & FOERSTER LLP 425 Market Street San Francisco, California 94105-2482
DA VID C. DOYLE (CA SBN 70690) MORRSON & FOERSTER LLP 3811 Valley Centre Dr., Suite. 500 San Diego, California 92130

2
3

4
5

6
7
8

9
10
11

By:

Harold J. McElhinny
Attorneys for Defendants ECHOSTAR SATELLITE LLC and ECHOSTAR TECHNOLOGIES CORPORATION

12

I3

Dated: J anuar ~, 2006
14
15

DARLYN J. DUR (CA SBN 169825)
DAVID J. SILBERT (CA SBN 173128) KEKER & V AN NEST LLP 710 Sansome Street San Francisco, California 94111-1704

16

17
18

By:

19

David Silbert

20
21

Attorneys for Defendant

COMCAST CABLE COMMUICATIONS, LLC

22
23

24
25

26 27
28
6

Case No. 05-CY-OI I 14 JW MOL No. i 665

Non-Infrngement and Invalidity of

(Proposed) Stipulated Summary Judgment of the '702 Patent

1

Dated: January _,2006

2
3

ANAMARIE A. DALEY (pro hac vice) TAR D. SUTTON (pro hac vice) STEPHEN P. SAFRASKl (pro hac vice) ROBINS, KALAN, MILLER & CIRSI LLP 2800 LaSalle Plaza, 800 LaSalle Avenue Minneapolis, Minnesota 55402 RICHAR R. PATCH (CA SBN 88049) J. TIMOTHY NARELL (CA SBN 184444) COBLENTZ, PATCH, DUFFY & BASS, LLP One Ferry Building, Suite 200 San Francisco, California 94111-4213

4
5

6 7
8

9

By:
Anararie A. Daley

10
11

Attorneys for Defendants COXCOM, INe. and HOSPITALITY NETWORK,

INe.
12
13

14
15

16 17
18

19

20
21

22
23

24
25

26 27
28
7

Case No. 05-CY-Oll 14 JW MDL No. 1665

(Proposed) Stipulated Summary Judgment of
Non-Infringement and Invalidity of

the '702 Patent

1

Dated: January _, 2006

2
3

4
5

BRAFORD LYERLA (pro hac vice app. pending) KEVIN HOGG (pro hac vice app. pending) JEFFREY DEAN (pro hac vice app. pending) MARSHALL, GERSTEIN & BORUN LLP 6300 Sears Tower 233 South Wacker Drive Chicago, Ilinois 60606-6357
MORGAN W. TOVEY (CA SBN 136242)

WILLIA R. OVEREND (CA SBN 180209)
6 7
8

REED SMITH LLP Two Embarcadero Center, Suite 2000 San Francisco, CA 94111

9

By:
10
11

Jeffrey Dean

12
13

Attorneys for Defendant CHARTER COMMUICATIONS, INe., WIDE OPEN WEST, ARSTRONG UTILITIES, MASSILON CABLE TV, INC., EAST CLEVELAND CABLE TV, MID-CONTINNT

14
15

MEDIA, INC., CANON VALLEY COMMICATIONS, US CABLE HOLDINGS,
LP, ARVIG ENTERPRISES, SJOBERG CABLE, LORETEL SYSTEMS, INC., NPG CABLE, INC.

16

DATED: January_,2006
17
18

REBECCA ANN BORTOLOTTI JOHN CHRITOPHER REICH ALBERT L. UNERHILL MERCHANT & GOULD
80 S. 8th Street, Suite 3200

19

Minneapolis, Minnesota 55402

20
21

By

22
23

Rebecca Ane Bortolotti
Attorneys for Defendants MID-CONTINENT MEDIA, INC., SA V AGE COMMUICATIONS, INC., CANNON V ALLEY

24
25

COMMUICATIONS, US CABLE HOLDINGS, LP, ARVIG ENTERPRISES, SJOBERG'S CABLE, LORETEL SYSTEMS, INC.,

26

27
28
8

Case No. 05-CY-01114 JW MDL No. 1665

Non-Infrngement and Invalidity of

(Proposed) Stipulated Summary Judgment of the '702 Patent

1

DATED: January _,2006

2
3

JUANITA R. BROOKS TODD G. MILLER FISH & RICHARSON P.e. 12390 El Camino Real San Diego, California 92130-2081

4
5

By
Todd R. Miller
Attorneys for Defendants

6

7
8

NEW DESTIN INTERNT GROUP, L.L.C., AUDIO COMMUICATIONS, INC., VS MEDIA,
INC., ADEMIA MULTIMEDIA, LLC, CYBERHEAT, INC., AEBN, INC., LIGHTSPEED MEDIA CORPORATION, INOV A TIVE IDEAS INTERNATIONAL, LTD., GAME LIN, INC., AN CYBERTREND, INC.
DATED: January _,2006

9

10
11

12 13

JONATHA E. SINGER WILLIA R. WOODFORD FISH & RICHARSON P.e.
60 South Sixth Street, Suite 3300 Minneapolis, Minnesota 55402

14
15

By
16

Jonathan E. Singer
Attorneys for Defendants

17
18

NEW DESTIN INTERNT GROUP, L.L.C., AUDIO COMMUICATIONS, INC., VS MEDIA,
INC., ADEMIA MULTIMEDIA, LLC, CYBERHEAT, INe., AEBN, INC., LIGHTSPEED MEDIA CORPORATION, INOVATIVE IDEAS INTERNATIONAL, LTD., GAME LIN, INC.,

19

20
21

AN CYBERTREND, INe.
DATED: January_,2006
22
23

WILLIA J. ROBINSON VICTOR DE GY AR AS

FOLEY & LARNER
2029 Century Park East, 35th Floor

Los Angeles, California 90067
24
By
25

Victor de Gyarfas Attorneys for Defendants International Web Innovations, Inc. and OFFENDALE COMMERICAL LIMITED BV

26
27 28

9

Case No. 05-CY-OI I 14 JW MDL No. 1665

(Proposed) Stipulated Summary Judgment of
Non-Infringement and Invalidity of

the '702 Patent

1

DATED: January _,2006

DOUGLAS W. SPRIE MARD. SCHNEIDER
GIFFORD, KRSS, GROH, SPRILE, ANERSON & CITKOWSKI, P.C. 280 N. Old Woodward Avenue, Suite 400 Birmingham, Michigan 48009-5394
ALFREDO A. BISMONTE

2
3

4
5

BOBBY T. SHil
MOUNT & STOELKER, P.C.
333 W. San Carlos S1., 17th Floor

6

San Jose, California 95110-2740
7
8

By
Bobby T. Shih
Attorneys for Defendant ASKCS.COM, INC.
DATED: January _,2006

9
10
11

12
13

14
15

By _
DATED: Januar _,2006

GARY A. HECKER JAMES M. SLOMINSKI THE HECKER LAW GROUP 1925 Century Park East, Suite 2300 Los Angeles, California 90067

James M. Slominski

16 17
18

Attorneys for Defendant OFFENDALE COMMERCIAL BV, LTD.

DAVID A. YORK

LATHAM & WATKIS
19

20
21

135 Commonwealth Drive Menlo Park, California 94025

By
David A. York
Attorneys for Defendants
ICS, Inc. and AP Net Marketing, Inc.

22
23

24
25

26
27 28
10

Case No. 05-CY-OI I 14 JW MDL No. 1665

(Proposed) Stipulated Summary Judgment of Non-Infringement and Invalidity of the '702 Patent

MITCHELL D. LUKIN

BAKR BOTTS LLP
One Shell Plaza 910 Louisiana
Houston, Texas 77022

JEFFREY D. SULLIVAN

MICHAEL J. MCNAMAR BAKR BOTTS LLP
30 Rockefeller Plaza New York, New York 10112
STEPHEN E. TAYLOR TAYLOR & CO. LAW OFFICES, INC. One Ferr Building, Suite 355
San Francisco, California 941 1 i

By
Mitchell D. Lukin

Attorneys for Defendant

MEDIACOM COMMUICA nONS
CORPORATION

SEAN DAVID GARSON ROBERT FRACIS COPPLE LEWIS & ROCA LLP 40 N. Central Avenue Phoenix, Arzona 85004-4429

By I

Sean David Garrson

Attorneys for Defendant CABLE AMERlCA CORP.

C. MA KITTREDGE
PERKS COlE BROWN & BAIN P A P.O. Box 400 Phoenix, Arzona 85001-0400

By

C. Mark Kittredge

Attorneys for Defendants CABLE ONE INe.
II

(Proposed) Stipulated Summary Judgment of
Non-Infrngement and Invalidity of

the '702 Patent

1

DATED: Januar _,2006

2
3

PATRICK J. WHALEN SPENCER FAN BRITT & BROWN LLP 1000 Walnut Street, Suite 1400 Kansas City, Missouri 64106

4
5

By
Patrick J. Whalen
Attorneys for Defendants NPG CABLE INe.
DATED: January _,2006

6
7
8

9 10
11

FRITZ BYERS 520 Madison Avenue Toledo, Ohio 43604

By
12
13

Fritz Byers

Attorneys for Defendants

14
15

BLOCK COMMICATIONS, INC.
DATED: Januar _,2006

CHRISTOPHER B. FAGAN

FAY SHAE FAGAN MINICH & MCKEE
16 17
18

1100 Superior A venue, Seventh Floor

Cleveland, Ohio 44114-2518

19

By

Chrstopher B. Fagan
Attorneys for Defendants ARSTRONG GROUP; EAST CLEVELAND TV

20
21

AN COMMUICATIONS LLC; MASSILLON
22
23

CABLE TV, INe.; WIDE OPEN WEST, LLC

24
25

26 27 28
516629\vl
12

Case No. 05-CV-01114 JW MDL No. 1665

Non-Infringement and Invalidity of

(Proposed) Stipulated Summary Judgment of the '702 Patent