Elan Microelectronics Corporation v. Apple, Inc.

Filing 269

Declaration of Sean P. DeBruine in Support of 268 MOTION for Extension of Time to File Response/Reply / Motion to Continue Deadline for Filing of Elan's Reply Brief in Support of Elan's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment filed byElan Microelectronics Corporation. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B)(Related document(s) 268 ) (DeBruine, Sean) (Filed on 6/8/2011)

"&#$!$% !

$76<./7! )188/3
&764#
)/59#
*6#
%-#
);,2/-9#

8J6UXNRJ& CJFR
EJIRJVIF\& >XRJ )0& +)** ,2.- A@
@JMWF& CSRFP3 5TTPJ 9PFR E<@ CJUYNHJ
9PFR 5TTPJ DJFQ
B92 9PFR"V @SWNSR KSU CXQQFU\ >XILQJRW

BUTGR%
BOTIK ]K XKIKO\KJ 2VVRK"Y ?VVUYOZOUT GTJ 5X' 3GRGQXOYNTGT"Y TKGX -( VGMK JKIRGXGZOUT% ]K NG\K HKKT IUTYOJKXOTM
]NKZNKX ]K IGT GJKW[GZKR_ GJJXKYY ZNK SGT_ OYY[KY XGOYKJ ]OZNU[Z ZNK ZOSK GTJ K^VKTYK UL G JKVUYOZOUT' 2Y 9
SKTZOUTKJ% ]K NG\K IUSK ZU ZNK IUTIR[YOUT ZNGZ G JKVUYOZOUT OY TKIKYYGX_ GTJ ]ORR HKYZ LXGSK ZNK OYY[KY LUX ZNK 4U[XZ'
ENORK ZNK YZOV[RGZOUT JOJ OTIR[JK G ;[TK 0 JGZK LUX 6RGT"Y AKVR_% OZ ]GY VXKSOYKJ UT G ;[TK *( NKGXOTM JGZK' CNKXK OY
YOSVR_ TU IUSVKRROTM XKGYUT LUX ZNK XKVR_ ZU HK LORKJ SUXK ZNGT G SUTZN HKLUXK ZNK NKGXOTM' EK GXK ZNKXKLUXK GYQOTM LUX
ZNK YGSK IU[XZKY_ ]K K^ZKTJKJ ZU 2VVRK && ZNGZ U[X HXOKL HK LORKJ GVVXU^OSGZKR_ G ]KKQ GLZKX ZNK JKVUYOZOUT OY ZGQKT'
@RKGYK RKZ SK QTU] ZNOY GLZKXTUUT OL 2VVRK ]ORR GMXKK% UX ]K ]ORR TKKJ ZU XGOYK ZNOY ]OZN ZNK 4U[XZ'
CNGTQY'
BKGT

#-,*! 4@CL=" 7HG=E ;F=DELH+7HG=E#4@CL=-O@DE#>HF<
$(+.! 9@?G@K?=P" 3MG@ $*" &$%% &+)( 54
%,! 0@/JMDG@" 7@=G, .IIE@ 1E=G 924 7@JND>@
"'! 1E=G .IIE@ 8@=F
$/&)('.! 61+ 1E=G!K 4HLDHG AHJ 7MFF=JP 3M?BF@GL

BKGT%
EK GXK Y[XVXOYKJ ZU YKK _U[X KSGOR HKRU] OT ]NOIN _U[ TU] Y[MMKYZ ZNGZ 6RGT"Y XKVR_ HXOKL OT Y[VVUXZ UL OZY Y[SSGX_
P[JMSKTZ SUZOUT OY J[K UT ;[TK +( GTJ XKW[KYZ LUX ZNK LOXYZ ZOSK G JKVUYOZOUT UL 5X' 3GRGQXOYNTGT'
EOZN XKYVKIZ ZU ZNK NKGXOTM JGZK% 6RGT"Y VUYOZOUT OY LRGZR_ OTIUTYOYZKTZ ]OZN ZNK VGXZOKY" VXOUX JOYI[YYOUTY% ZNK YZOV[RGZOUT
_U[ YOMTKJ% ZNK UXJKX YOMTKJ H_ ;[JMK BKKHUXM KTZKXOTM ZNGZ YZOV[RGZOUT% GTJ U[X IUT\KXYGZOUT _KYZKXJG_ K\KTOTM' 9T
LGIZ% ]NKT _U[ IGRRKJ SK _KYZKXJG_ K\KTOTM ZU XKW[KYZ G UTK&]KKQ K^ZKTYOUT LUX _U[X XKVR_ HXOKL% 9 YVKIOLOIGRR_ IUTLOXSKJ
]OZN _U[% GTJ _U[ K^VXKYYR_ GIQTU]RKJMKJ% ZNGZ 6RGT"Y XKVR_ HXOKL OY J[K ZUSUXXU]% ;[TK 0% GTJ ZNGZ 6RGT"Y XKW[KYZ ]GY
LUX G UTK&]KKQ K^ZKTYOUT UL ZNGZ JGZK ZU TK^Z CN[XYJG_% ;[TK ).' FU[ GRYU GMXKKJ ZNGZ% ]OZN ZNGZ K^ZKTYOUT% 6RGT ]U[RJ
TUZ ZGQK 5X' 3GRGQXOYNTGT"Y JKVUYOZOUT' FU[X KSGOR HKRU] OY G IUSVRKZK GHU[Z&LGIK LXUS _U[X YZGZKSKTZY UT U[X IGRR RGYZ
TOMNZ' =UXK OSVUXZGTZR_% OZ OY G IUSVRKZK GHU[Z&LGIK LXUS ZNK YZOV[RGZOUT _U[ YOMTKJ GTJ ]NOIN ;[JMK BKKHUXM KTZKXKJ'
BVKIOLOIGRR_% UT =G_ )0% ZNK VGXZOKY" VXKYKTZKJ ZU ZNK 4U[XZ G YZOV[RGZKJ HXOKLOTM YINKJ[RK [TJKX ]NOIN 6RGT"Y XKVR_ HXOKL
OY J[K ;[TK 0 GTJ TUZ ZOKJ ZU ZNK NKGXOTM JGZK1 !>?E% C86A67?A6% 9C 9B 86A63F BC9@D<2C65 H_ GTJ HKZ]KKT ZNK
VGXZOKY% ZNXU[MN ZNKOX XKYVKIZO\K IU[TYKR% ZNGZ ZNK NKGXOTM JGZK LUX 6RGT"Y SUZOUT LUX VGXZOGR Y[SSGX_ P[JMSKTZ HK
XKYINKJ[RKJ ZU ;[TK *(% *()) #Y[HPKIZ ZU ZNK 4U[XZ"Y G\GORGHOROZ_$% ]OZN 2VVRK"Y UVVUYOZOUT ZU 6RGT"Y SUZOUT J[K UT ;[TK *%
*()) GTJ 6RGT"Y XKVR_ HXOKL J[K UT ;[TK 0% *())'! #%% 59 *(-' FU[ YOMTKJ ZNGZ YZOV[RGZOUT UT HKNGRL UL 6RGT' "$! ?T =G_
*-% *())% ZNK 4U[XZ"Y KTZKXKJ GT UXJKX MXGTZOTM ZNK YZOV[RGZKJ XKROKL ]OZN G INGTMK ZU UTR_ ZNK NKGXOTM JGZK GTJ TUZ ZU
ZNK JGZK LUX KOZNKX VGXZOKY" HXOKL' #%% 59 *)/' 2Z ZNGZ VUOTZ% 6RGT ]GY UT TUZOIK ZNGZ ZNK NKGXOTM ]U[RJ TUZ HK [TZOR ;[R_
),% H[Z JOJ TUZ XGOYK UX XKW[KYZ GT_ INGTMK ZU ZNK ;[TK * GTJ ;[TK 0 HXOKLOTM JKGJROTKY GMXKKJ [VUT H_ ZNK VGXZOKY GTJ
KTZKXKJ H_ ZNK 4U[XZ' CU ZNK IUTZXGX_% 6RGT YGZ YORKTZR_ GTJ GRRU]KJ 2VVRK ZU LORK OZY UVVUYOZOUT UT ;[TK * OT IUSVROGTIK
]OZN ZNK YZOV[RGZOUT GTJ ;[JMK BKKHUXM"Y ?XJKX' FU[X Y[MMKYZOUT ZNGZ 6RGT OY TU] LXKK ZU JOYXKMGXJ ZNGZ YZOV[RGZOUT GTJ
%

?XJKX GTJ [TORGZKXGRR_ K^ZKTJ ZNK JGZK LUX OZY XKVR_ HXOKL H_ ZNXKK ]KKQY GLZKX 2VVRK NGY GRXKGJ_ YKX\KJ OZY UVVUYOZOUT OY
OT IRKGX \OURGZOUT UL ZNK 4U[XZ"Y ?XJKX GTJ% LXGTQR_% YSGIQY UL MGSKYSGTYNOV' 9TJKKJ% Y[IN GT K^ZKTYOUT ]U[RJ IXKGZK
YOMTOLOIGTZ VXKP[JOIK ZU 2VVRK' 2Z ZNOY VUOTZ% GHYKTZ GT UXJKX LXUS ;[JMK BKKHUXM K^ZKTJOTM ZNK JGZK% 6RGT OY UHROMGZKJ ZU
LORK OZY XKVR_ HXOKL ZUSUXXU]' @RKGYK ZGQK ZNOY KSGOR GY TUZOIK ZNGZ% GHYKTZ GT Y[IN GT UXJKX% 2VVRK ]ORR SU\K ZU YZXOQK GT_
XKVR_ HXOKL ZNGZ OY LORKJ U[Z UL ZOSK'
<OQK]OYK% ]K ]KXK Y[XVXOYKJ ZU XKIKO\K _U[X XKW[KYZ ZU JKVUYK 5X' 3GRGQXOYNTGT' 2Z TU VUOTZ J[XOTM ZNK VGXZOKY"
K^ZKTJKJ SKKZ GTJ IUTLKX UT ZNK VXUIKYY UX YINKJ[RK LUX Y[SSGX_ P[JMSKTZ VXUIKKJOTMY JOJ 6RGT K\KT XGOYK ZNK
VUYYOHOROZ_ ZNGZ OZ ]U[RJ YKKQ G JKVUYOZOUT UL 5X' 3GRGQXOYNTGT OL NK Y[HSOZZKJ G JKIRGXGZOUT Y[IN ZNGZ ]K IU[RJ ]UXQ
ZUMKZNKX ZU H[ORJ ZNGZ OTZU ZNK YINKJ[RK' 9T LGIZ% _U[ ZURJ SK _KYZKXJG_ K\KTOTM ZNGZ 6RGT ]U[RJ TUZ JKVUYK 5X'
3GRGQXOYNTGT OL 2VVRK ]U[RJ GMXKK ZU G UTK&]KKQ K^ZKTYOUT LUX 6RGT"Y XKVR_ HXOKL' 9T GT_ K\KTZ% 5X' 3GRGQXOYNTGT"Y
JKIRGXGZOUT ]GY LORKJ RGYZ CN[XYJG_ GTJ 6RGT ]GOZKJ YO^ JG_Y% [TZOR ZNK JG_ HKLUXK OZY XKVR_ HXOKL OY J[K% ZU XKW[KYZ G
JKVUYOZOUT' 9Z OY NGXJ ZU YKK ZNOY XKW[KYZ GY GT_ZNOTM SUXK ZNGT GT GZZKSVZ H_ 6RGT ZU Y[HYZGTZOGRR_ JKRG_ LOROTM OZY XKVR_
HXOKL OT G ]G_ ZNGZ ]U[RJ VXKP[JOIK 2VVRK' CNGZ YGOJ% ]K GXK ]ORROTM ZU IUTYOJKX _U[X XKW[KYZ LUX G JKVUYOZOUT UL 5X'
3GRGQXOYNTGT OL 6RGT IGT VXU\OJK GT K^VRGTGZOUT LUX OZY LGOR[XK ZU JOROMKTZR_ V[XY[K ZNGZ JKVUYOZOUT'
AKMGXJY%

)65+3 (" '/09+
EJNP& <SWVMFP ! @FRLJV ??A
+)* BJIZSSI CMSUJV AFUOZF\
BJIZSSI CMSUJV& 75 1-)/.'**,VSRFP(QJMWF4ZJNP(HSQ
%* /.) 0)+ ,**0 8NUJHW
%* /.) 0)+ ,*)) ;F[

#-,*! 0@/JMDG@" 7@=G ;F=DELH+7@=G#0@/JMDG@-=EKLHG#>HF<
$(+.! 9@?G@K?=P" 3MG@ $*" &$%% %&+&$ 54
%,! 4@CL=" 7HG=E, .IIE@ 1E=G 924 7@JND>@
"'! 1E=G .IIE@ 8@=F
$/&)('.! 1E=G!K 4HLDHG AHJ 7MFF=JP 3M?BF@GL
BUTGR%
?T L[XZNKX IUTYOJKXGZOUT GLZKX U[X IUT\KXYGZOUT _KYZKXJG_% ]K ]ORR TKKJ ZU ZGQK 5X' 3GRGQXOYNTGT"Y JKVUYOZOUT IUTIKXTOTM NOY
JKIRGXGZOUT OT UVVUYOZOUT ZU ZNK Y[SSGX_ P[JMSKTZ SUZOUT' @RKGYK RKZ SK QTU] ]NKT 5X' 3GRGQXOYNGT ]ORR HK G\GORGHRK' ?[X YZXUTM
VXKLKXKTIK ]U[RJ HK ZU IUTJ[IZ ZNK JKVUYOZOUT TK^Z ]KKQ' 3KIG[YK [TJKX ZNK <UIGR A[RKY U[X XKVR_ OY J[K Z]U ]KKQY HKLUXK ZNK
NKGXOTM% UT ;[TK +(% ]K TKKJ ZU YINKJ[RK ZNK JKVUYOZOUT LUX TU RGZKX ZNGT ;[TK *,' 9 RUUQ LUX]GXJ ZU NKGXOTM LXUS _U['
3KYZ XKMGXJY%
6;7@ 1;/BE=@;
.?CDA@ ! /=B9 224
&+) 3=99?;<=;?9 5A79 F 6E=D; %)$ F 3;@?A 47B>" 0. -($&)
*)$#,',#&%&% 1=B;8D
C]KR\K 4UTYKI[ZO\K FKGXY UT 7UXZ[TKc SGMG`OTKaY !CNK )(( 3KYZ 4USVGTOKY ZU EUXQ 7UX!"

####################################################### 256 0BJ<MD9J )*' =BK<DGKMJ>. 7G >FKMJ>
<GEHDB9F<> OBLA J>IMBJ>E>FLK BEHGK>= ;Q LA> 256 9F= GLA>J L9PBF@ 9MLAGJBLB>K$ O> BF?GJE QGM LA9L 9FQ L9P
&

9=NB<> <GFL9BF>= BF LABK <GEEMFB<9LBGF !BF<DM=BF@ 9FQ 9LL9<AE>FLK" BK FGL BFL>F=>= GJ OJBLL>F LG ;> MK>=$ 9F=
<9FFGL ;> MK>=$ ?GJ LA> HMJHGK> G? !B" 9NGB=BF@ H>F9DLB>K LA9L E9Q ;> BEHGK>= GF 9FQ L9PH9Q>J GJ !BB" HJGEGLBF@$
E9JC>LBF@ GJ J><GEE>F=BF@ LG 9FGLA>J H9JLQ 9FQ LJ9FK9<LBGF GJ E9LL>J 9==J>KK>= A>J>BF&
888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888 347201. 7ABK >%E9BD E>KK9@> 9F= 9DD
9LL9<AE>FLK LJ9FKEBLL>= OBLA BL E9Q <GFL9BF D>@9DDQ HJBNBD>@>= 9F= <GF?B=>FLB9D BF?GJE9LBGF BFL>F=>= KGD>DQ ?GJ
LA> MK> G? LA> 9==J>KK>>& 2? LA> J>9=>J G? LABK E>KK9@> BK FGL LA> BFL>F=>= J><BHB>FL$ QGM 9J> A>J>;Q FGLB?B>= LA9L
9FQ J>9=BF@$ =BKK>EBF9LBGF$ =BKLJB;MLBGF$ <GHQBF@$ GJ GLA>J MK> G? LABK E>KK9@> GJ BLK 9LL9<AE>FLK BK KLJB<LDQ
HJGAB;BL>=& 2? QGM A9N> J><>BN>= LABK E>KK9@> BF >JJGJ$ HD>9K> FGLB?Q LA> K>F=>J BEE>=B9L>DQ ;Q L>D>HAGF> !+'+%
--(%,'''" GJ ;Q >D><LJGFB< E9BD !HGKLE9KL>J/9DKLGF&<GE"$ 9F= =>D>L> LABK E>KK9@> 9F= 9DD <GHB>K 9F= ;9<CMHK
LA>J>G?& 7A9FC QGM&
DMJ NRKSUQFWNSR HSRWFNRJI NR WMNV JQFNP QJVVFLJ NV NRWJRIJI SRP\ KSU XVJ SK WMJ NRINYNIXFP SU JRWNW\ RFQJI FGSYJ( =K WMJ
UJFIJU SK WMNV QJVVFLJ NV RSW WMJ NRWJRIJI UJHNTNJRW& SU WMJ JQTPS\JJ SU FLJRW UJVTSRVNGPJ WS IJPNYJU NW WS WMJ NRWJRIJI
UJHNTNJRW& \SX FUJ MJUJG\ RSWNKNJI WMFW FR\ INVVJQNRFWNSR& INVWUNGXWNSR SU HST\NRL SK WMNV HSQQXRNHFWNSR NV VWUNHWP\
TUSMNGNWJI( =K \SX MFYJ UJHJNYJI WMNV HSQQXRNHFWNSR NR JUUSU& TPJFVJ NQQJINFWJP\ RSWNK\ XV G\ JQFNP
#TSVWQFVWJU4ZJNP(HSQ$& FRI IJVWUS\ WMJ SUNLNRFP QJVVFLJ( DMFRO \SX(

'