Elan Microelectronics Corporation v. Apple, Inc.

Filing 325

Letter from Jane Bu regarding July 5, 2011 Hearing on Apple's Motion to Compel and Supplemental Exhibits in Support of Elan's Opposition to Motion to Compel. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B, # 3 Exhibit C, # 4 Exhibit D)(Bu, Jane) (Filed on 7/6/2011)

EXHIBIT B

Elan's Privilege Log 2010-09-01 (2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

ELAN MICROELECTRONICS CORPORATION'S PRIVILEGE LOG - SEPTEMBER 1, 2010 (SECOND REVISION)

NO.

New
No.

AUTHOR

1

175

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

2

176

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

3

177

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

4

178

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

5

179

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

6

180

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

7

181

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

8

182

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

9

Wayne Chang
183
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

10

184

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

RECIPIENT

COPY RECIPIENT

DESCRIPTION
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
in anticipation of the Elan v. Apple litigation.
1

DATE

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

PORTION
WITHHELD
Entire pages and
paragraphs in
ELN350108ELN350163
Entire pages and
paragraphs in
ELN350164ELN350340
Entire page and
paragraphs in
ELN350341ELN350517
Entire page and
paragraphs in
ELN350518ELN350608
Entire page and
paragraphs in
ELN350609ELN350691
Entire page and
paragraphs in
ELN350692ELN350774
Entire page and
paragraphs in
ELN350775ELN350856

11/20/2009

AC/WP

11/20/2009

AC/WP

11/20/2009

AC/WP

11/20/2009

AC/WP

11/20/2009

AC/WP

11/20/2009

AC/WP

11/20/2009

AC/WP

11/20/2009

AC/WP

Entire page in
ELN350857ELN350976

11/13/2009

AC/WP

Entire pages and
paragraphs in
ELN350977ELN351055

6/20/2008

AC/WP

Entire pages in
ELN351201ELN351203

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Elan's Privilege Log 2010-09-01 (2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

New
No.

AUTHOR

11

185

12

RECIPIENT

COPY RECIPIENT

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

186

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

13

187

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

14

Wayne Chang
188
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

15

189

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

16

190

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

17

191

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

18

192

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

19

193

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

20

194

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

21

195

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

DESCRIPTION
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
in anticipation of the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elantech v Synaptics litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, reflecting
communication with U.S. counsel and U.S. counsel work product for
purposes of providing advice re U.S. patent analysis.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, reflecting
communication with U.S. counsel and U.S. counsel work product for
purposes of providing advice re U.S. patent analysis.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, reflecting
communication with U.S. counsel and U.S. counsel work product for
purposes of providing advice re U.S. patent analysis.

2

DATE

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

PORTION
WITHHELD

8/24/2009

AC/WP

Entire page in
ELN351204ELN351205

11/21/2009

AC/WP

Entire paragraphs
in ELN351274ELN351450

11/9/2009

AC/WP

Entire paragraphs
in ELN351451ELN351534

10/30/2009

AC/WP

Entire page and
paragraphs in
ELN351535ELN351617

9/21/2009

AC/WP

Entire paragraphs
in ELN351618ELN351699

11/10/2009

AC/WP

Entire pages and
paragraph in
ELN412409ELN412487

11/11/2009

AC/WP

Entire paragraphs
in ELN412488ELN412358

8/5/2008

AC/WP

Entire pages in
ELN437263ELN437292

6/16/2008

AC/WP

Entire pages in
ELN442713ELN442811

8/4/2008

AC/WP

8/4/2008

AC/WP

Entire page in
ELN442841ELN442870
Entire pages in
ELN442929ELN442958

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Elan's Privilege Log 2010-09-01 (2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

New
No.

AUTHOR

22

196

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

23

Wayne Chang
197
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

24

198

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

25

199

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

26

Wayne Chang
200
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

27

201

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

28

202

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

N/A

N/A

29

Wayne Chang
203
(Elan Legal)

I.H. Yeh

Ian Chang

30

204

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

I.H. Yeh

N/A

31

205

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

I.H. Yeh

N/A

RECIPIENT

COPY RECIPIENT

N/A

N/A

DESCRIPTION
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.

3

DATE

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

PORTION
WITHHELD

10/12/2009

AC/WP

Entire paragraphs
in ELN457618ELN457722
Entire page and
paragraphs in
ELN457723ELN457793
Entire page and
paragraphs in
ELN457794ELN457864

10/12/2009

AC/WP

10/12/2009

AC/WP

10/12/2009

AC/WP

Entire paragraphs
in ELN457865ELN457936

10/12/2009

AC/WP

Entire page and
paragraph in
ELN457937ELN458007

10/12/2009

AC/WP

Entire paragraphs
in ELN458008ELN458078

9/10/2009

AC/WP

Entire page in
ELN458305ELN458306

9/10/2009

AC/WP

Entire pages and
paragraphs in
ELN466486ELN466564

11/5/2009

AC/WP

Entire paragraphs
in ELN470321ELN470375

2/28/2010

AC/WP

Entire page in
ELN470381ELN470511

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Elan's Privilege Log 2010-09-01 (2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

New
No.

AUTHOR

32

206

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

I.H. Yeh

33

207

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

I.H. Yeh

34

208

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

I.H. Yeh

35

209

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

Ian Chung, Jesse Huang,
Godwin Chiu

210

Ivy Chen

RECIPIENT

36
37

Ian chung

38
39

40

211

I.H. Yeh

41

212

I.H. Yeh

W.F. Lu, Venny Lin,
Charles Pai, Godwin Chiu,
Steven Tsai, Ian Chung, KuoLung Yen, Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)
Wayne Chang (Elan Legal),
Kuo-Lung Yen, Ian Chung,
Steven Tsai, Godwin Chiu,
Charles Pai, Venny Lin

42
43

44

45

DATE

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

PORTION
WITHHELD

2/1/2010

AC/WP

Entire paragraphs
in ELN471143ELN471310

3/19/2010

AC/WP

Entire paragraphs
ELN473952ELN474117

5/14/2008

AC/WP

Entire pages
ELN478306ELN478366

12/9/2008

AC/WP/CO
MMON
INTEREST

Entire pages
ELN531113ELN531164

12/9/2008

AC/WP

Entire pages
ELN531329ELN531380

Elan internal communication reflecting U.S. counsel communication
and for purposes of seeking legal advice re the Elantech v. Synaptics
litigation.

8/27/2008

AC

Entire document

Elan internal communication reflecting U.S. counsel communication
and for purposes of seeking legal advice re the Elantech v. Synaptics
litigation.

8/14/2008

AC

Entire document

COPY RECIPIENT

DESCRIPTION

Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
N/A
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
N/A
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re the patent analysis
Communication between Elan and Sinbon, Elan agent, having a
I.H. Yeh, Chile Wang,
common legal interest with Elan, with work product prepared by U.S.
Joseph Wang, Mite Liang,
counsel for purposes of providing legal advice in anticipation of the
Brad Rendall
Elan v. Apple litigation.
Duplicate to other entries on the logs.
Document prepared by Elan, for third party customers, subject to
common legal interest, reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
Godwin Chiu, I.H. Yeh
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing legal advice
re patent analysis.
Elan will produce.
Irrelevant and none-responsive.
N/A

Irrelevant and none-responsive
Yitai Hu
213 (Outside
Counsel)
Yitai Hu
214 (Outside
Counsel)
215

Godwin Chiu

Wayne Jong

Communications with U.S. counsel for purposes of providing legal
advice in anticipation of the Elan v. Apple litigation.

6/30/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

Wayne Jong

Communications with U.S. counsel for purposes of providing legal
advice in anticipation of the Elan v. Apple litigation.

6/30/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal),
I.H. Yeh, W.F. Lu, Ian
Chung

Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking legal advice re
licensing negotiation with Apple and in anticipation of the Elan v.
Apple litigation.

12/9/2007

AC

Entire document

4

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Elan's Privilege Log 2010-09-01 (2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

New
No.

AUTHOR

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

PORTION
WITHHELD

46

216

Godwin Chiu

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

AC/WP

Entire document

48

217

Godwin Chiu

Ian Chung

AC/WP

Entire document

49

218

Ian Chung

AC/WP

Entire document

50

219

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

W.F. Lu

I.H. Yeh, Godwin Chiu

3/2/2007

AC

Entire document

51

220

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

Chi-Tien Yeh, Godwin
Chiu, Roven Lee

I.H. Yeh

5/15/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

55

221

Bill Tsai (Elan
Legal)

Godwin Chiu

Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking legal advice in
anticipation of the Elan v. Apple litigation.

4/1/2009

AC

Entire document

56

222

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

Godwin Chiu

Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking legal advice in
anticipation of the Elan v. Apple litigation.

4/2/2009

AC

Entire document

57

223

Bill Tsai (Elan
Legal)

Godwin Chiu

Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking legal advice in
anticipation of the Elan v. Apple litigation.

4/1/2009

AC

Entire document

Roven Lee

Bill Tsai (Elan Legal), Maco
Tang, Kelvin Chiang,
Chao-Hui Hsu, Wen Kai Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking legal advice in
Wayne Chang (Elan Legal),
Lee
anticipation of the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.
Godwin Chiu, Draco Wu,
Jacky Wu, Ian Chung

1/11/2005

AC

Entire document

Roven Lee

Roven Lee, Bill Tsai (Elan
Legal), Maco Tang, Kelvin
Chao-Hui Hsu, Wen Kai Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking legal advice in
Chiang, Wayne Chang (Elan
Lee
anticipation of the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.
Legal), Godwin Chiu, Draco
Wu, Jacky Wu, Ian Chung

1/11/2005

AC

Entire document

RECIPIENT

47

Ian Chung, Vivian Yang,
Johnny Shyy

52
53
54

58

59

60
61
62
63
64

224

225

COPY RECIPIENT

DESCRIPTION

DATE

Elan internal communication with work product prepared by U.S.
counsel for purposes of providing legal advice in anticipation of the
8/7/2008
Elan v. Apple litigation.
Irrelevant and none-responsive.
Elan internal communication with work product prepared by U.S.
counsel for purposes of providing legal advice in anticipation of the
8/3/2008
Elan v. Apple litigation.
Elan internal communication with attachment reflecting
Ocean Chen, Godwin
communication with U.S. counsel and U.S. counsel work product for
Chiu, Wayne Chang (Elan
10/26/2006
purposes of providing legal advice re the Elantech v. Synaptics
Legal)
litigation.
Bill Tsai (Elan Legal)

Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking legal advice in
anticipation of the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Elan internal communication with attachment(s) prepared under the
instruction of U.S. counsel and to provide to U.S. counsel in
anticipation of the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.

Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.
5

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Elan's Privilege Log 2010-09-01 (2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

New
No.

AUTHOR

65

226

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

RECIPIENT

I.H. Yeh, Godwin Chiu,
W.F. Lu, Kuo-Lung Yen

DESCRIPTION

DATE

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

PORTION
WITHHELD

Elan internal communication with attachment(s) reflecting
communication with U.S. counsel and U.S. counsel work product for
purposes of providing legal advice on Synaptics' U.S. patents re the
Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

10/4/2007

AC/WP

Entire document

2/18/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

12/14/2006

AC/WP

Entire document

COPY RECIPIENT

66

Already produced

67
68
69

Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.

70

Wayne Chang
227
(Elan Legal)

71
72

Charles Pai, Min-Shu
Elan internal communication with attachment(s) prepared under the
Cruise Teng, Bill Tsai (Elan Wang, Kuo-Lung Yen,
instruction of U.S. counsel for purposes of seeking legal advice re
Legal)
Chun-An Tong, I.H. Yeh,
U.S. patent prosecution.
Godwin Chiu
Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.

73

Elan will produce.

74
75
76
77
78

79

228

229

Ocean Chen

Ocean Chen

Draco Wu, Ian Chung

Vivian Yang, Ariel Yang,
Ian Chung, Stanley Hsiao

80
81

82

Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.
Duplicate to other entries on the logs.
Wayne Chang (Elan
Elan internal communication with attachment(s) prepared under the
Legal), I.H. Yeh, Godwin instruction of U.S. counsel and to provide to U.S. counsel re the
Chiu
Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

Withholding
Communication between Elan and Wintron, a third party having a
portions of an
common legal interest with Elan, with attachment reflecting
AC/WP/CO attachment; email
Godwin Chiu, Liyu Chan,
communication with U.S. counsel and U.S. counsel work product for 11/15/2006
MMON
communication
Jason Liu
purposes of providing legal advice on Synaptics' U.S. patent, re the
INTEREST and other public
Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.
attachments will
be produced
Elan will produce.
Already produced

230

Bill Tsai (Elan
Legal)

Godwin Chiu

Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking legal advice on
Synaptics' U.S. patents in anticipation of the Elantech v. Synaptics
litigation.

83

AC

Entire document

Already produced

84
85

9/16/2004

Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.

6

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Elan's Privilege Log 2010-09-01 (2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

New
No.

86

231

Draco Wu

87

232

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

AUTHOR

RECIPIENT

COPY RECIPIENT

DESCRIPTION

DATE

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

PORTION
WITHHELD

Kelvin Chiang

Godwin Chiu, Daisuke
Shudo

Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking legal advice on
Synaptics' patents in anticipation of the Elantech v. Synaptics
litigation.

6/15/2004

AC

Entire document

Ian Chung, Eve Chang (Elan
Legal)

Godwin Chiu, I.H. Yeh,
Daisuke Shudo, Roven
Lee, Ji-Han Liu (Elan
Legal)

Elan internal communication, reflecting U.S. counsel communication
and for purposes of seeking legal advice re the Elantech v. Synaptics
litigation.

6/7/2006

AC

Entire document

11/24/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

7/3/2007

AC

Entire document

1/12/2007

AC

Entire document

11/29/2006

AC

Entire document

12/15/2006

AC/WP

Entire document

3/28/2006

AC/WP

Entire document

88
89
90

233

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

Godwin Chiu

91

234

I.H. Yeh

Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.
Elan internal communication with attachment prepared by Elan
reflecting communication with U.S. counsel and U.S. counsel work
product for purposes of providing legal advice re U.S. patents.
Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking advice re U.S.
patent analysis in anticipation of the Elan v. Apple litigation.
Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.

Godwin Chiu

92
93
94
95

Daisuke Shudo

Elan will produce.

96

Elan will produce.

97
98

Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.

99

235

Daisuke Shudo

Daisuke Shudo, I.H. Yeh,
Olivia Yu, Ian Chung, Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking legal advice in
Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Ocean Chen, Godwin Chiu anticipation of the Elan v. Apple litigation.

100

Elan will produce.

101

Elan will produce.

102
103

236

Daisuke Shudo

Daisuke Shudo, Godwin
Chiu, I.H. Yeh, Rich Tan

Fumiaki Karasawa

Already produced
Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking legal advice on
Synaptics' U.S. patents re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

104

Elan will produce.

105

Elan will produce.

106
107

Elan will produce.
237

Draco Wu

238

Roven Lee

108
109

Godwin Chiu, Ian Chung, Elan internal communication with attachment(s) prepared under the
Wayne Chang (Elan Legal),
I.H. Yeh, Steven Lin,
instruction of U.S. counsel and to provide to counsel re the Elantech
Ocean Chen, Alex Lee
Miller Wang
v. Synaptics litigation.
Elan will produce.
Clark A. Jablon (Outside
Wayne Chang (Elan
Communications with U.S. counsel for purposes of seeking legal
Counsel)
Legal), Godwin Chiu
advice re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

7

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Elan's Privilege Log 2010-09-01 (2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

New
No.

AUTHOR

110

239

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

I.H. Yeh, Godwin Chiu,
Daisuke Shudo

111

240

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

Roven Lee

112

241

Daisuke Shudo, Wayne
Daisuke Shudo Chang (Elan Legal), Godwin
Chiu, I.H. Yeh

RECIPIENT

COPY RECIPIENT

Godwin Chiu

Elan internal communication with attachment(s) prepared under the
instruction of U.S. counsel and to provide to counsel re the Elantech
v. Synaptics litigation.
Elan internal communication reflecting communication with U.S.
counsel for purposes of providing legal advice re the Elantech v.
Synaptics litigation.
Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking legal advice re
the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

113
114

DESCRIPTION

DATE

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

PORTION
WITHHELD

3/7/2006

AC/WP

Entire document

2/8/2007

AC

Entire document

5/11/2006

AC

Entire document

5/28/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

5/28/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

8/2/2006

AC/WP

Entire document

2/26/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

5/10/2006

AC

Entire document

2/10/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

8/31/2006

AC/WP

Entire document

4/6/2006

AC/WP

Entire document

Elan will produce.
242

Ji-Han Liu (Elan Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Godwin Chiu, Ian Chung, Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking legal advice re
Legal)
I.H. Yeh, W.F. Lu
Rich Tan
U.S. patent prosecution.

115

Elan will produce.

116

Duplicate to other entries on the logs.

117

243

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

I.H. Yeh, W.F. Lu

Elan internal communication with attachment(s) prepared U.S.
Godwin Chiu, Ian Chung counsel for purposes of providing legal advice on Synaptics' U.S.
patent re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

118

Elan will produce.

119

Duplicate to other entries on the logs.

120

244

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

Godwin Chiu, Roven Lee,
Ian Chung, Jason Liu

121

245

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

Charles Pai

122

246

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

Godwin Chiu, I.H. Yeh,
Daisuke Shudo

123

247

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

Roven Lee, Roven Lee,
Ming Tao Yang

Elan internal communication with work product prepared by U.S.
I.H. Yeh, Daisuke Shudo,
counsel for purposes of providing legal advice re the Elantech v.
Rich Tan
Synaptics litigation.
I.H. Yeh, Godwin Chiu, Elan internal communication with work product prepared by U.S.
Bill Tsai (Elan Legal), Jeff counsel for purposes of providing legal advice on Synaptics' U.S.
Cheng (Elan Legal)
patent re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.
Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking legal advice re
the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.
Elan internal communication with attachment(s) prepared under the
Charles Pai, Godwin Chiu,
instruction of U.S. counsel for purposes of seeking legal advice re
I.H. Yeh
U.S. patent prosecution.

124

Elan will produce.

125

248

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

Roven Lee, Draco Wu

Godwin Chiu

126

249

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

Daisuke Shudo

I.H. Yeh, Godwin Chiu

Elan internal communication with work product prepared by U.S.
counsel for purposes of providing legal advice on Elantech's U.S.
patent re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.
Elan internal communication with work product prepared by U.S.
counsel for purposes of providing legal advice re the Elantech v.
Synaptics litigation.

8

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Elan's Privilege Log 2010-09-01 (2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

New
No.

AUTHOR

127

250

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

Hank Chen

128

251

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

W.F. Lu, I.H. Yeh

129

252

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

Daisuke Shudo

130

253

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

Roven Lee

RECIPIENT

131

DESCRIPTION

Elan internal communication with work product prepared by U.S.
counsel for purposes of providing legal advice on Synaptics' U.S.
patent re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.
Roven Lee, Godwin Chiu, Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking legal advice on
Dennis Liu
Synaptics' U.S. patent re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.
Elan internal communication with work product prepared by U.S.
Draco Wu, Godwin Chiu counsel for purposes of providing legal advice of Elan's U.S. patent
re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.
Elan internal communication reflecting communication with U.S.
Godwin Chiu
counsel for purposes of providing legal advice re the Elantech v.
Synaptics litigation.
Godwin Chiu

DATE

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

PORTION
WITHHELD

1/31/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

4/18/2008

AC

Entire document

3/6/2006

AC/WP

Entire document

2/8/2007

AC

Entire document

8/3/2006

AC/WP

Entire document

AC

Entire document

AC/WP

Entire document

AC/WP

Entire document

AC/WP

Entire document

AC/WP

Entire document

AC

Entire document

AC/WP

Entire document

Duplicate to other entries on the logs.

132

254

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

133

255

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

134

256

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

135

257

Violet Yeh

136

258

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

137

259

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

138

260

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

139

140

COPY RECIPIENT

Ming Tao Yang (Outside
Counsel), Godwin Chiu,
Roven Lee, Ian Chung,
Jason Liu, Draco Wu,
Stober Chen

Communications with U.S. counsel for purposes of seeking legal
advice re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

Daisuke Shudo, Godwin Elan internal communication reflecting communication with U.S.
Chiu, I.H. Yeh, Ocean counsel for purposes of providing legal advice re the Elantech v.
4/18/2007
Chen, Rich Tan, W.F. Lu Synaptics litigation.
Elan internal communication with attachment(s) reflecting
communication with U.S. counsel and U.S. counsel work product for
Ocean Chen
Godwin Chiu
10/23/2006
purposes of providing legal advice on Synaptics' U.S. patents re the
Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.
Elan internal communication with work product prepared by U.S.
Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)
Godwin Chiu
counsel for purposes of providing legal advice re the Elantech v.
5/29/2008
Synaptics litigation.
Elan internal communication with work product prepared by U.S.
Godwin Chiu, I.H. Yeh,
Roven Lee
counsel for purposes of providing legal advice on Synaptics' U.S.
4/10/2006
Daisuke Shudo
patents re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.
Elan internal communication with work product prepared by U.S.
Godwin Chiu
counsel for purposes of providing legal advice re the Elantech v.
8/22/2006
Synaptics litigation.
Elan internal communication reflecting communication with U.S.
Roven Lee, Draco Wu, I.H. Yeh, W.F. Lu, Godwin
counsel for purposes of providing legal advice re the Elantech v.
7/2/2008
Jason Liu
Chiu
Synaptics litigation.
Daisuke Shudo

Duplicate to other entries on the logs.

261

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

Kuo-Lung Yen, Daisuke
Shudo, Ocean Chen,
Elan internal communication, reflecting U.S. counsel communication
Wayne Chang (Elan Legal),
Godwin Chiu, W.F. Lu, and for purposes of seeking legal advice re the Elantech v. Synaptics
I.H. Yeh
Elsa Tsai (Elan Legal), Ian litigation.
Chung
9

3/27/2007

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Elan's Privilege Log 2010-09-01 (2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

New
No.

AUTHOR

RECIPIENT

COPY RECIPIENT

141
262

Bill Tsai (Elan
Legal)

143

263

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

Godwin Chiu, Charles Pai,
Brian Sung
W.F. Lu, I.H. Ye, Dennis
Liu, Godwin Chiu, Alfie
Tsai, Eve Chang (Elan
Legal), Ji-Han Liu (Elan
Legal)

I.H. Yeh, Wayne Chang Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking legal advice on
(Elan Legal)
Synaptics' U.S. patent re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.
Elan internal communication with work product prepared by U.S.
counsel for purposes of providing legal advice re the Elantech v.
Synaptics litigation.

144

146

W.F. Lu, Rich Tan

I.H. Yeh, Godwin Chiu

Roven Lee

Godwin Chiu

PORTION
WITHHELD

8/18/2008

AC

Entire document

5/28/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

Elan internal communication reflecting the instruction of U.S.
counsel re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.
Elan internal communication reflecting legal communication with
U.S. counsel re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

5/28/2008

AC

Entire document

4/22/2007

AC

Entire document

5/27/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

AC

Entire document

6/4/2003

AC/WP

Entire document

3/23/2003

AC/WP

Entire document

5/26/2003

AC

Entire document

Elan will produce.

266

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

W.F. Lu, I.H. Yeh, Dennis
Liu, Godwin Chiu, Alfie
Tsai, Eve Chang (Elan
Legal)

149

Elan internal communication with work product prepared by U.S.
counsel for purposes of providing legal advice re the Elantech v.
Synaptics litigation.
Elan will produce.

150
151

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

Duplicate to other entries on the logs.
Wayne Chang
264
(Elan Legal)
Wayne Chang
265
(Elan Legal)

147

148

DATE

Elan will produce.

142

145

DESCRIPTION

Elan will produce.
267

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

I.H. Yeh, Charles Pai, Ian
Chung, Andy Wu, Godwin
Chiu, W.F. Lu

Elan internal communication, reflecting U.S. counsel communication
and for purposes of seeking legal advice re the Elantech v. Synaptics 12/25/2007
litigation.

152

Elan will produce.

153

Duplicate to other entries on the logs.

154

Elan will produce.

155
156
157

268

Kelvin Chiang

160

269

Bill Tsai (Elan
Legal)

161

270

Draco Wu

158
159

Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.
Elan internal communication with attachment(s) prepared under the
Godwin Chiu
instruction of U.S. counsel for purposes of seeking legal advice re
U.S. patent prosecution.
Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.
Elan internal communication with attachment(s) prepared under the
Godwin Chiu
I.H. Yeh
instruction of outside counsel for purposes of seeking legal advice re
patent prosecution.
Godwin Chiu, Wayne Chang Chun-Tzu Chen (Outside Communication with outside counsel for purposes of seeking legal
(Elan Legal)
Counsel)
advice re contract negotiation.
10

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Elan's Privilege Log 2010-09-01 (2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

New
No.

AUTHOR

RECIPIENT

162
163

271

Kelvin Chien

Godwin Chiu

164

272

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

Grace Hsu (Outside
Counsel)

165

COPY RECIPIENT

DESCRIPTION

Elan will produce.
Elan internal communication with attachment(s) prepared under the
instruction of U.S. counsel for purposes of seeking legal advice re
U.S. patent prosecution.
Godwin Chiu, Elsa Tsai Communication with outside counsel for purposes of seeking legal
(Elan Legal)
advice re contract negotiation.
Elan will produce.

166

Entire document

5/2/2003

AC

Entire document

2/6/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

4/25/2009

AC/WP

Entire document

3/16/2008

AC

Entire document

Irrelevant and privileged.

171

AC/WP

Irrelevant and privileged.

170

11/9/2003

Irrelevant and privileged.

169

PORTION
WITHHELD

Irrelevant and privileged.

168

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

Irrelevant and privileged.

167

DATE

Elan will produce.

172

273

Roven Lee

173
174
175

Elan internal communication with attachment(s) prepared under the
Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Charles Pai, Godwin Chiu instruction of U.S. counsel for purposes of seeking legal advice re
U.S. patent prosecution.
Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.

176

Already produced

177
178
179
180
181
182

Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.

183

Elan will produce.

184

274

Godwin Chiu

Michael Kim (Outside
Counsel), Yitai Hu (Outside
Counsel)

185
186

Helen Su (Outside
Communication with U.S. counsel for purposes of seeking legal
Counsel), Wayne Chang
advice re the Elan v. Apple litigation.
(Elan Legal)
Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.

187
188

Elan will produce.
275

Godwin Chiu

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

I.H. Yeh, Ian Chung

Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking legal advice on
Synaptics' U.S. patent re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.
11

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Elan's Privilege Log 2010-09-01 (2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

New
No.

AUTHOR

RECIPIENT

COPY RECIPIENT

DESCRIPTION

189

AC

Entire document

11/27/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

7/21/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

10/4/2005

AC/WP

Entire document

5/15/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

Irrelevant and none-responsive.

196

3/29/2007

Irrelevant and none-responsive.
Irrelevant and none-responsive.
Irrelevant and none-responsive.
Irrelevant and none-responsive.

195

PORTION
WITHHELD

Elan will produce.

191
192
193
194

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

Irrelevant and none-responsive.

190

DATE

Duplicate to other entries on the logs.

201
202

Elan internal communication with attachment(s) prepared under the
instruction of U.S. counsel for purposes of seeking legal advice re
U.S. patent prosecution.
Elan will produce.
Elan internal communication with attachment(s) prepared under the
instruction of U.S. counsel for purposes of seeking legal advice re
U.S. patent prosecution.
Elan internal communication with work product prepared by U.S.
counsel for purposes of providing legal advice in anticipation of the
Elan v. Apple litigation.
Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.

203

Elan will produce.

204
205
206

Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.
Irrelevant and none-responsive.

207

Elan will produce.

208

Elan will produce.

209

211
212

Elan will produce.
Elan internal communication with attachment(s) prepared under the
instruction of U.S. counsel for purposes of seeking legal advice re
U.S. patent prosecution.
Irrelevant and none-responsive.
Irrelevant and none-responsive.

213

Irrelevant and none-responsive.

276

Gracie Lo (Elan
Legal)

Godwin Chiu, Ian Chung,
Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

199

277

Wen Kai Lee

Charles Pai, Godwin Chiu,
Ian Chung, Min-Shu Wang,
Maco Tang

200

278

Bill Tsai (Elan
Legal)

Godwin Chiu

197

I.H. Yeh

198

210

279

Ian Chung

Godwin Chiu

214
215
216

Eve Chang
280
(Elan Legal)

Rex Hsi

Godwin Chiu

Elan will produce.
Elan internal communication with attachment(s) prepared by outside
counsel for purposes of seeking legal advice re patent prosecution.
Irrelevant and none-responsive.
12

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Elan's Privilege Log 2010-09-01 (2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

New
No.

AUTHOR

RECIPIENT

COPY RECIPIENT

DESCRIPTION

217

AC

Entire document

2/11/2007

AC

Entire document

2/26/2008

AC/WP/CO
MMON
INTEREST

Entire document

4/11/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

1/29/2004

AC/WP

Entire document

Irrelevant and none-responsive.

223

11/18/2006

Elan will produce.
Already produced
Elan will produce.

222

PORTION
WITHHELD

Duplicate to other entries on the logs.

219
220
221

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

Elan will produce.

218

DATE

Irrelevant and none-responsive.

224

226

Elan will produce.
Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking legal advice re
licensing negotiation with Apple and in anticipation of the Elan v.
Apple litigation.
Irrelevant and none-responsive.

227

Duplicate to other entries on the logs.

228

Already produced

229

Irrelevant and none-responsive.

230

Duplicate to other entries on the logs.

231

Duplicate to other entries on the logs.

225

232

233

281

282

283

I.H. Yeh

I.H. Yeh

Charles Pai

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal),
Godwin Chiu, Daisuke
Shudo, Ocean Chen

Godwin Chiu, Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

Daniel Chen

234
235

284

Ji-Han Liu (Elan
Legal)

285

Kelvin Chiang

Bill Tsai (Elan Legal)

236
237
238

Bill Tsai (Elan Legal),
Roven Lee, Maco Tang,
Chao-Hui Hsu

Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking legal advice re
licensing negotiation with Apple and in anticipation of the Elan v.
Apple litigation.
Communication between Elan and Innolux, a third party having a
Min-Shu Wang, Eva Chen, common legal interest with Elan, with attachment reflecting
James Chen, Wayne Chang communication with U.S. counsel and U.S. counsel work product for
(Elan Legal)
purposes of providing legal advice on Synaptics' U.S. patent, re the
Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.
Elan will produce.
I.H. Yeh, W.F. Lu, Wayne
Elan internal communication with attachment(s) prepared under the
Chang (Elan Legal),
instruction of U.S. counsel for purposes of seeking legal advice re
Godwin Chiu, Eve Chang
U.S. patent prosecution.
(Elan Legal)
Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.
Elan internal communication with attachment(s) prepared for
Wayne Chang (Elan
purposes of seeking legal advice on Elantech's U.S. patents in
Legal), Godwin Chiu
anticipation of the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

13

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Elan's Privilege Log 2010-09-01 (2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

New
No.

AUTHOR

239

286

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

RECIPIENT

I.H. Yeh, Godwin Chiu

COPY RECIPIENT

DESCRIPTION

Elsa Tsai (Elan Legal), Communication with outside counsel with attachment(s) prepared by
Wellington Liu (Outside Elan to provide to outside counsel for purposes of seeking legal
Counsel)
advice re patent analysis.

240

PORTION
WITHHELD

6/17/2003

AC/WP

Entire document

9/7/2004

AC/WP

Entire document

1/1/2004

AC

Entire document

3/19/2007

AC/WP

Entire document

Elan will produce.

242
243

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

Elan will produce.

241

DATE

Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.

244
245
246
247
248

Irrelevant and none-responsive.
Elan will produce.
Irrelevant and none-responsive.
287

Daisuke Shudo

Aaron Wininger (Outside
Counsel)

288

Wayne Chang
(Elan Legal)

Godwin Chiu

249
250
251

252

Draco Wu, Godwin Chiu,
Communication with U.S. counsel for purposes of seeking legal
Wayne Chang (Elan
advice re patent prosecution.
Legal), Rich Tan
Elan will produce.
Irrelevant and none-responsive.
Irrelevant and none-responsive.

Bill Tsai (Elan Legal)

Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking legal advice on
Synaptics' U.S. patents in anticipation of the Elantech v. Synaptics
litigation.

253

Elan will produce.

254

Elan will produce.
Elan internal communication with attachment(s) prepared under the
instruction of U.S. counsel and to provide to U.S. counsel re the
Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

255

289

Ian Chung

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal),
Elsa Tsai (Elan Legal)

Ocean Chen, Godwin
Chiu, I.H. Yeh

256

Already produced

257

Already produced
14

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Elan's Privilege Log 2010-09-01 (2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

New
No.

AUTHOR

RECIPIENT

DATE

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

PORTION
WITHHELD

Elan internal communication with work product prepared by U.S.
counsel for purposes of providing legal advice in anticipation of the
Elan v. Apple litigation.

8/7/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

Elan internal communication with work product prepared by U.S.
counsel for purposes of providing legal advice in anticipation of the
Elan v. Apple litigation.

8/3/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

8/11/2008

AC

Entire document

COPY RECIPIENT

DESCRIPTION

258

Elan will produce.

259

Duplicate to other entries on the logs.

260

290

Godwin Chiu

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

261

291

Godwin Chiu

Ian Chung

262

Godwin Chiu

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), I.H. Yeh, Jeff Cheng (Elan
Irrelevant and none-responsive.
Ian Chung, Charles Chen
Legal)

263

264

Bill Tsai (Elan Legal)

Elan will produce.

292

Ian Chung

Ian Chung, Johnny Shy,
Vivian Yang

Communication between Elan and Acer, a third party having a
Ocean Chen, Godwin
AC/WP/CO
common legal interest with Elan, with work product prepared by U.S.
Chiu, Wayne Chang (Elan
10/26/2006
MMON
counsel for purposes of providing legal advice on Synaptics' U.S.
Legal)
INTEREST
patents, re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

265
266
267
268
269
270

Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.
Irrelevant and none-responsive.
Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.
Elan will produce.

271

Entire document

Already produced

15

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)