Elan Microelectronics Corporation v. Apple, Inc.

Filing 325

Letter from Jane Bu regarding July 5, 2011 Hearing on Apple's Motion to Compel and Supplemental Exhibits in Support of Elan's Opposition to Motion to Compel. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B, # 3 Exhibit C, # 4 Exhibit D)(Bu, Jane) (Filed on 7/6/2011)

Download PDF
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` )., ?QLLSMNQMSL BVIL `C[QZM (,' ` ?MUSV AIXR$ 64 0+'),%+''/ ` -,'&/*/&)''( 9I^ ` -,'&/*/&)''' DMS ` -,'&/*/&)(), 7QXMKZ HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH 4ZSIUZI < 6PIXSVZZM < 7ISSIY ` >VY 4UOMSMY ` @M] GVXR ` BMYMIXKP DXQIUOSM < CQSQKVU EISSM_ ` FIYPQUOZVU$ 76 ####################################################### 256 0BJ<MD9J )*' =BK<DGKMJ>. 7G >FKMJ> <GEHDB9F<> OBLA J>IMBJ>E>FLK BEHGK>= ;Q LA> 256 9F= GLA>J L9PBF@ 9MLAGJBLB>K$ O> BF?GJE QGM LA9L 9FQ L9P 9=NB<> <GFL9BF>= BF LABK <GEEMFB<9LBGF !BF<DM=BF@ 9FQ 9LL9<AE>FLK" BK FGL BFL>F=>= GJ OJBLL>F LG ;> MK>=$ 9F= <9FFGL ;> MK>=$ ?GJ LA> HMJHGK> G? !B" 9NGB=BF@ H>F9DLB>K LA9L E9Q ;> BEHGK>= GF 9FQ L9PH9Q>J GJ !BB" HJGEGLBF@$ E9JC>LBF@ GJ J><GEE>F=BF@ LG 9FGLA>J H9JLQ 9FQ LJ9FK9<LBGF GJ E9LL>J 9==J>KK>= A>J>BF& 888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888 347201. 7ABK >%E9BD E>KK9@> 9F= 9DD 9LL9<AE>FLK LJ9FKEBLL>= OBLA BL E9Q <GFL9BF D>@9DDQ HJBNBD>@>= 9F= <GF?B=>FLB9D BF?GJE9LBGF BFL>F=>= KGD>DQ ?GJ LA> MK> G? LA> 9==J>KK>>& 2? LA> J>9=>J G? LABK E>KK9@> BK FGL LA> BFL>F=>= J><BHB>FL$ QGM 9J> A>J>;Q FGLB?B>= LA9L 9FQ J>9=BF@$ =BKK>EBF9LBGF$ =BKLJB;MLBGF$ <GHQBF@$ GJ GLA>J MK> G? LABK E>KK9@> GJ BLK 9LL9<AE>FLK BK KLJB<LDQ HJGAB;BL>=& 2? QGM A9N> J><>BN>= LABK E>KK9@> BF >JJGJ$ HD>9K> FGLB?Q LA> K>F=>J BEE>=B9L>DQ ;Q L>D>HAGF> !+'+% --(%,'''" GJ ;Q >D><LJGFB< E9BD !HGKLE9KL>J/9DKLGF&<GE"$ 9F= =>D>L> LABK E>KK9@> 9F= 9DD <GHB>K 9F= ;9<CMHK LA>J>G?& 7A9FC QGM& DPM QUNVXTIZQVU KVUZIQUML QU ZPQY MTIQS TMYYIOM QY QUZMULML VUS_ NVX [YM VN ZPM QULQ\QL[IS VX MUZQZ_ UITML IJV\M& <N ZPM XMILMX VN ZPQY TMYYIOM QY UVZ ZPM QUZMULML XMKQWQMUZ$ VX ZPM MTWSV_MM VX IOMUZ XMYWVUYQJSM ZV LMSQ\MX QZ ZV ZPM QUZMULML XMKQWQMUZ$ _V[ IXM PMXMJ_ UVZQNQML ZPIZ IU_ LQYYMTQUIZQVU$ LQYZXQJ[ZQVU VX KVW_QUO VN ZPQY KVTT[UQKIZQVU QY YZXQKZS_ WXVPQJQZML& <N _V[ PI\M XMKMQ\ML ZPQY KVTT[UQKIZQVU QU MXXVX$ WSMIYM QTTMLQIZMS_ UVZQN_ [Y J_ MTIQS !WVYZTIYZMX3]MQS&KVT"$ IUL LMYZXV_ ZPM VXQOQUIS TMYYIOM& DPIUR _V[& &

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?