Elan Microelectronics Corporation v. Apple, Inc.

Filing 342

Declaration of Jane H. Bu in Support of 341 MOTION to Compel Discovery Related to Apple iOS Applications for the Accused Products filed byElan Microelectronics Corporation. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B, # 3 Exhibit C, # 4 Exhibit D, # 5 Exhibit E, # 6 Exhibit F, # 7 Exhibit G, # 8 Exhibit H, # 9 Exhibit I)(Related document(s) 341 ) (Bu, Jane) (Filed on 7/15/2011)

EXHIBIT F

#216*+2! &,33+.
%21/"
&+04"
'1"
$)"
&5(-+)4"

/Q# 6?KC
>CBKCOB?T# 6QIT %)# '%&& *+(( 97
>?IPCN# 1CNCH
.MMIC 2I?K >47 <CNRGAC, 2I?K .MMIC =C?J
3>+ 7CCP ?KB 0LKDCN ;C 2I?K 1CMLOGPGLK 8LPGACO

6LYLR2
FOHUR `V\ MVY NL[[PUN IHJR [V \Z YLNHYKPUN [OLZL ^P[ULZZLZ' GL HYL H]HPSHISL HU` [PTL 8YPKH` MVY HU MVSSV^ \W TLL[ HUK
JVUMLY [V KPZJ\ZZ [OL V]LYHSS KLWVZP[PVU ZJOLK\SL' ;V^L]LY% HZ < OH]L PUKPJH[LK K\YPUN V\Y =\UL */ TLL[ HUK JVUMLY% ^L
ULLK [V RUV^ ^OL[OLY 3WWSL ^PSS WYVK\JL VUL VY TVYL ^P[ULZZLZ MVY [OL YLTHPUKLY VM 7SHU"Z KLWVZP[PVU [VWPJZ%
WHY[PJ\SHYS` [OL [VWPJZ YLSH[PUN [V [OL PBE 3WWZ' CSLHZL JVUMPYT I` [OL JSVZL VM I\ZPULZZ VU [OPZ 8YPKH`% ^OL[OLY 3WWSL
PU[LUKZ [V WYV]PKL ^P[ULZZ#LZ$ MVY [OL YLZ[ VM [OL [VWPJZ'
8\Y[OLY% 3WWSL MPYZ[ ZLY]LK P[Z YLZWVUZL [V 7SHU"Z +YK ZL[ VM KVJ\TLU[Z YLX\LZ[Z VU @H` )*% *()) HUK 3WWSL OHZ PUKPJH[LK
[OH[ P[ ^PSS JVUZPKLY [OL YLSL]HUJL [OLVY` VM [OL PBE 3WWZ KPZJV]LY`' ;V^L]LY% [V KH[L ^L OH]L UV[ OLHYK HU` HMMPYTH[P]L
YLZWVUZL MYVT 3WWSL YLNHYKPUN [OPZ PZZ\L' FOLYLMVYL% WSLHZL HSZV JVUMPYT I` [OL JSVZL VM I\ZPULZZ VU [OPZ 8YPKH`% ^OL[OLY
3WWSL PU[LUKZ [V WYVK\JL KPZJV]LY` YLSH[PUN [V [OL PBE 3WWZ MVY [OL HJJ\ZLK WYVK\J[Z' B[OLY^PZL% ^P[O 3WWSL"Z YLM\ZHS [V
L]LU JVTTP[ [V HU HMMPYTH[P]L WVZP[PVU MVY [OL PBE 3WW KPZJV]LY`% ^L ^PSS OH]L UV JOVPJL I\[ [V ZLLR JV\Y[ PU[LY]LU[PVU
VU [OPZ PZZ\L'

4LZ[%
=HUL

#-,*! @DLSGQ" 4GQGK AMDJLSO.4GQGK#@DLSGQ0VGJL#EOMB
$(+.! 6QJFDW" 8TLW $%" &$%% (.%' <9
%,! 2T" 8DNG
"'! 1PPLG 5LDN @79 >GQUJEG/ 5LDN 1PPLG ?GDM
$/&)('.! =5. 9GGS DNF 3ONHGQ =G 5LDN 4GPORJSJON ;OSJEGR

=HUL2
8VSSV^PUN \W VU V\Y TLL[ HUK JVUMLY% ^L JHU UV^ PKLU[PM` [OL MVSSV^PUN ^P[ULZZLZ MVY [OL MVSSV^PUN [VWPJZ PU 7SHU"Z
+(#I$#.$ UV[PJL% Z\IQLJ[ [V V\Y VIQLJ[PVUZ2
FVWPJZ -&))2 @HYR 4\JRSL`
FVWPJZ *0&*12 >YPZ[P 4H\LYS`
GL"SS IL PU [V\JO YLNHYKPUN ZJOLK\SPUN HUK ZOV\SK WYVIHIS` ZL[ \W H [PTL [V KPZJ\ZZ HU V]LYHSS ZJOLK\SL MVY HSS VM [OL
\WJVTPUN KLWVZP[PVUZ VU IV[O ZPKLZ'
FOHURZ%
6LYLR

%

#-,*! 2T" 8DNG AMDJLSO.8DNG#2T0DLRSON#EOMB
$(+.! 6QJFDW" 8TNG &(" &$%% &.%' <9
%,! @DLSGQ" 4GQGK
"'! 1PPLG 5LDN @79 >GQUJEG/ 5LDN 1PPLG ?GDM
$/&)('.! =5. 9GGS DNF 3ONHGQ =G 5LDN 4GPORJSJON ;OSJEGR

6LYLR2 @VUKH` *WT ^VYRZ' GL ^PSS NP]L `V\ H JHSS H[ `V\Y VMMPJL'
4LZ[%
=HUL
#-,*! @DLSGQ" 4GQGK AMDJLSO.4GQGK#@DLSGQ0VGJL#EOMB
$(+.! 6QJFDW" 8TNG &(" &$%% %.(% <9
%,! 2T" 8DNG
"'! 1PPLG 5LDN @79 >GQUJEG/ 5LDN 1PPLG ?GDM
$/&)('.! =5. 9GGS DNF 3ONHGQ =G 5LDN 4GPORJSJON ;OSJEGR

=HUL2
GP[O YLZWLJ[ [V 7SHU"Z +(#I$#.$ KLWVZP[PVU UV[PJL% 3WWSL ^PSS IL ZLY]PUN P[Z ^YP[[LU VIQLJ[PVUZ SH[LY [VKH`' 9P]LU [OH[
3WWSL PZ ZLY]PUN [OLZL VIQLJ[PVUZ VU H [PTL ZJHSL JVTWHYHISL [V [OL [PTL ZJHSL [OH[ 7SHU [VVR [V YLZWVUK [V 3WWSL"Z
+(#I$#.$ UV[PJL VM KLWVZP[PVU HUK [OH[ 7SHU"Z UV[PJLZ VM KLWVZP[PVUZ VM PUKP]PK\HS ^P[ULZZLZ ^LYL ZLY]LK VUS` SHZ[ ^LLR%
HU` Z\NNLZ[PVU [OH[ 3WWSL OHZ !PNUVYLK! `V\Y 7SHU"Z YLX\LZ[Z VU KLWVZP[PVU ZJOLK\SPUN PZ UV[ ^LSS [HRLU'
DLNHYKSLZZ% ZPUJL YLJLP]PUN `V\Y KLWVZP[PVU UV[PJLZ% 3WWSL OHZ ILLU ^VYRPUN KPSPNLU[S` [V PKLU[PM` KH[LZ MVY ^P[ULZZLZ%
THU` VM ^OVT HYL UV[ L]LU 3WWSL LTWSV`LLZ HU`TVYL' 3[ [OPZ WVPU[% ^L JHU VMMLY [OL MVSSV^PUN KH[LZ2
9YLN @HYYPV[[ & =\S` *.
E[L]L 4VSSPUNLY & =\S` *1
GL HYL Z[PSS ^VYRPUN VU KH[LZ MVY @Y' 4HY&AHO\T HUK @Z' 5PULYLZRP'
8PUHSS`% ^P[O YLNHYK [V TLL[ HUK JVUMLY VU +(#I$#.$ [VWPJZ HUK KLZPNULLZ HUK KLWVZP[PVU ZJOLK\SPUN% ^L HYL UV[ H]HPSHISL
VU @VUKH` H[ [OL [PTL `V\ Z\NNLZ[% I\[ ^L JHU [HSR VU @VUKH` H[ *2(( C@'
FOHURZ%
6LYLR

#-,*! 2T" 8DNG AMDJLSO.8DNG#2T0DLRSON#EOMB
$(+.! 6QJFDW" 8TNG &(" &$%% %$.&- 19
%,! @DLSGQ" 4GQGK
"'! 1PPLG 5LDN @79 >GQUJEG/ 5LDN 1PPLG ?GDM
$/&)('.! 9GGS DNF 3ONHGQ =G 5LDN 4GPORJSJON ;OSJEGR

7KWKP2 8QGS OXXZKJ OYX +("H#".# JKUTXOYOTS STYOIK YT 4UUQK TS >ZSK /YN& EK GQXT STYOIKJ @W& @GWWOTYY$ @W&
5GW%AGNZR$ @W& 5TQQOSMKW$ GSJ @X& 6OSKWKXPO LTW JKUTXOYOTSX LTW SK]Y \KKP& DT JGYK$ JKXUOYK TZW WKUKGYKJ
WKVZKXY LTW RKKY GSJ ITSLKW YT \TWP TZY G WKGXTSGHQK XINKJZQK$ 4UUQK NGX ITSXOXYKSYQ^ OMSTWKJ TZW
WKVZKXYX& =S QOMNY TL YNK QGWMK [TQZRK TL JKUTXOYOTSX ITROSM ZU LWTR HTYN XOJKX$ \K WKVZKXY G RKKY GSJ
ITSLKW TS @TSJG^ WKMGWJOSM 4UUQK!X UTXOYOTS TS 8QGS!X +("H#".# JKUTXOYOTS YTUOIX$ YNK UWTUTXKJ +("H#".#
&

4UUQK JKXOMSKKX GSJ YNK OSJO[OJZGQ \OYSKXX JKUTXOYOTSX! XINKJZQK& BQKGXK ITSLOWR H^ IQTXK TL HZXOSKXX
YTJG^ ^TZW G[GOQGHOQOY^ YT RKKY GSJ ITSLKW GY )(2(( GR @TSJG^& =L YNGY YORK OX STY GIIKUYGHQK$ UQKGXK
UWTUTXK GSTYNKW YORK @TSJG^&
5KXY$
>GSK

#-,*! @DLSGQ" 4GQGK AMDJLSO.4GQGK#@DLSGQ0VGJL#EOMB
$(+.! ?ITQRFDW" 8TNG &'" &$%% ,.$- <9
%,! 2T" 8DNG/ 5LDN 1PPLG ?GDM
"'! 1PPLG 5LDN @79 >GQUJEG
$/&)('.! =5. 9GGS DNF EONHGQ QG FGPORJSJONR OH 5LDN VJSNGRR

=HUL2
FOHUR `V\ MVY `V\Y LTHPS ILSV^ WYV]PKPUN M\Y[OLY KL[HPS VU 7SHU"Z KLZPNUH[PVU VM ^P[ULZZLZ [V HSSV^ \Z [V TLL[ HUK
JVUMLY VU [OL ZJVWL VM [OL D\SL +(#I$#.$ KLWVZP[PVU HUK [V JVUZPKLY `V\Y YLX\LZ[ [OH[ [OL KLWVZP[PVUZ IL JVUK\J[LK PU
FHP^HU'
8PYZ[% ^P[O YLZWLJ[ [V [OL ZJVWL VM [OL D\SL +(#I$#.$ [LZ[PTVU`% ^L YLZWVUK ILSV^ VU [OL VWLU P[LTZ2
"

FVWPJZ )+% )-2 3S[OV\NO 3WWSL PZ LU[P[SLK [V [LZ[PTVU` VU [OLZL [VWPJZ UV[^P[OZ[HUKPUN 7SHU"Z PU[LYYVNH[VY`
YLZWVUZLZ% ^L JHU HNYLL% PU [OL ZWPYP[ VM LMMPJPLUJ`% [V `V\Y WYVWVZHS [OH[ [OL WHY[PLZ KPZJ\ZZ [OL ULLK MVY
[LZ[PTVU` VU [OLZL [VWPJZ HM[LY 3WWSL YL]PL^Z 7SHU"Z Z\WWSLTLU[HS PU[LYYVNH[VY` YLZWVUZLZ VU [OL JVUKP[PVU [OH[
^L YLJLP]L [OVZL Z\WWSLTLU[HS YLZWVUZLZ YPNO[ H^H` Z\JO [OH[ V\Y YLX\LZ[ MVY D\SL +(#I$#.$ [LZ[PTVU` PZ UV[
Z\IQLJ[ [V M\Y[OLY KLSH`' CSLHZL JVUMPYT [OH[ ^L ^PSS YLJLP]L 7SHU"Z Z\WWSLTLU[HS YLZWVUZLZ I` =\UL *0[O'

"

FVWPJZ ,%-%0%12 3WWSL KVLZ UV[ HNYLL [V ^P[OKYH^ [OLZL [VWPJZ' GOPSL 3WWSL KPK VI[HPU JLY[HPU [LZ[PTVU`
YLSH[PUN [V 7SHU"Z HJX\PZP[PVU HUK SPJLUZPUN VM [OL "+-* WH[LU[ PU [OL <F5 PU]LZ[PNH[PVU% [OH[ [LZ[PTVU` ^HZ PU [OL
JVU[L_[ VM 7SHU"Z KVTLZ[PJ PUK\Z[Y` HSSLNH[PVUZ HUK UV[ PU [OL JVU[L_[ VM WH[LU[ KHTHNLZ% ^OPJO HYL H[ PZZ\L PU
[OL KPZ[YPJ[ JV\Y[ JHZL MVY [OL MPYZ[ [PTL' @VYLV]LY% 3WWSL"Z [VWPJZ HSZV YLSH[L [V [OL "+-+ WH[LU[% ^OPJO ^HZ UV[
H[ PZZ\L PU [OL <F5' CSLHZL JVUMPYT [OH[ @Y' 5OHUN ^PSS [LZ[PM` VU [OLZL [VWPJZ PU HKKP[PVU [V FVWPJZ /% ))% )*% ),
HUK ). HUK *)% VY SL[ \Z RUV^ PM 7SHU ^PSS IL KLZPNUH[PUN HUV[OLY ^P[ULZZ VU [OLZL [VWPJZ'

"

FVWPJ .2 GL [HRL `V\Y Z[H[LTLU[ HZ H YLWYLZLU[H[PVU [OH[ 7SHU KVLZ UV[ OH]L HU` RUV^SLKNL VY PUMVYTH[PVU VU
[OL JVUJLW[PVU HUK YLK\J[PVU [V WYHJ[PJL VM [OL a+-* WH[LU[ IL`VUK [OL ZV\YJLZ ZWLJPMPJHSS` PKLU[PMPLK PU 7SHU"Z
^YP[[LU YLZWVUZL [V [OPZ KLWVZP[PVU [VWPJ% P'L'% !@Y' E[L]LU 4PZZL[ HUK @Y' CH\S ;H\NOL`aZ KLWVZP[PVUZ [HRLU VU
ELW[LTILY */% *()( HUK BJ[VILY )*% *()( HUK [V 3WWSLaZ @HYJO *.% *()( E\IWVLUH PZZ\LK [V ?VNP[LJO HUK HU`
KVJ\TLU[Z WYVK\JLK I` ?VNP[LJO PU YLZWVUZL [V [OH[ Z\IWVLUH'! <U YLSPHUJL VU [OH[ YLWYLZLU[H[PVU HUK ^P[O
[OL \UKLYZ[HUKPUN [OH[ ^L ^PSS VWWVZL HU` H[[LTW[ I` 7SHU [V YLS` VU HU` HKKP[PVUHS PUMVYTH[PVU YLSH[LK [V
JVUJLW[PVU HUK YLK\J[PVU [V WYHJ[PJL VM [OL "+-* WH[LU[ IL`VUK [OH[ ZWLJPMPJHSS` PKLU[PMPLK% 3WWSL ^PSS ^P[OKYH^
FVWPJ .' <M [OPZ \UKLYZ[HUKPUN PZ PUJVYYLJ[% [OLU 7SHU T\Z[ KLZPNUH[L H ^P[ULZZ [V [LZ[PM` VU P[Z ILOHSM'

ELJVUK% ^P[O YLZWLJ[ [V SVJH[PVU% ^L OH]L NVUL IHJR HUK JVUZPKLYLK HNHPU `V\Y YLX\LZ[ [OH[ [OL KLWVZP[PVUZ IL [HRLU PU
FHP^HU% I\[ MVY [OL YLHZVUZ ^L OH]L WYL]PV\ZS` KPZJ\ZZLK% JHUUV[ HNYLL [V HIYVNH[L [OL WHY[PLZ" HNYLLTLU[ [OH[ WHY[`
^P[ULZZLZ ^PSS IL THKL H]HPSHISL MVY KLWVZP[PVU PU [OL AVY[OLYU 6PZ[YPJ[ VM 5HSPMVYUPH' <UKLLK% ^L KV UV[ [OPUR `V\Y
HYN\TLU[Z MVY ^O` [OL KLWVZP[PVUZ ZOV\SK [HRL WSHJL PU FHP^HU HYL ^LSS&[HRLU% L]LU PM 7SHU OHK YHPZLK [OVZL WVPU[Z
ILMVYL [OL WHY[PLZ Z[PW\SH[LK #[^PJL$ [OH[ [OL KLWVZP[PVUZ ^PSS NV MVY^HYK OLYL' GL ^PSS IL MPSPUN UL_[ ^LLR H TV[PVU [V
'

JVTWLS 7SHU [V WYLZLU[ [OL ^P[ULZZLZ SVJHSS` W\YZ\HU[ [V [OH[ HNYLLTLU[ HUK ^PSS IL YLX\LZ[PUN H ZOVY[LULK IYPLMPUN
ZJOLK\SL HUK OLHYPUN KH[L'
GL HYL H]HPSHISL [V KPZJ\ZZ [OLZL PZZ\LZ I` [LSLWOVUL HNHPU PM `V\ ^V\SK SPRL'
FOHURZ%
6LYLR

#-,*! 2T" 8DNG AMDJLSO.8DNG#2T0DLRSON#EOMB
$(+.! @GFNGRFDW" 8TNG &&" &$%% ,.%+ <9
%,! @DLSGQ" 4GQGK
"'! 5LDN 1PPLG ?GDM/ 1PPLG 5LDN @79 >GQUJEG
$/&)('.! =G. 9GGS DNF EONHGQ QG FGPORJSJONR OH 5LDN VJSNGRR

7KWKP2
DT LTQQT\ ZU R^ >ZSK )- KRGOQ$ \K XYOQQ NG[K STY NKGWJ GS^YNOSM LWTR 4UUQK WKMGWJOSM 4UUQK!X OSJO[OJZGQ
GSJ +("H#".# \OYSKXXKX JKUTXOYOTS XINKJZQK& BQKGXK UWT[OJK ZX YNK QOXY TL YNK JKXOMSGYKJ +("H#".#
\OYSKXXKX GSJ YNK UWTUTXKJ XINKJZQK GX XTTS GX UTXXOHQK&
9ZWYNKW$ GX UWTROXKJ$ NKWK OX YNK QOXY TL YNK ITSLOWRKJ 8QGS JKXOMSGYKJ \OYSKXXKX LTW 4UUQK!X +("H#".#
YTUOIX2
DTUOIX )$ )12 8WOI FGSM "FGSM$ EKO%EKS3 }~y#
DTUOIX *$ +$ )/$ )02 =GS 6NZSM "6NZSM$ CNZGS%?ZSM3 ƒ ‚ #
DTUOIX /$ ))$ )*$ ),$ ).$ *)2 EG^SK 6NGSM "6NGSM$ EKO%6ZT3 |•{#
DTUOI )(2 =GS 6NZSM$ ;WGIK ?GO "?O%QOSM ?GO € „ z#& BQKGXK STYK YNGY @X& ?GO OX JKXOMSGYKJ LTW YNK QOROYKJ
UZWUTXK TL GZYNKSYOIGYOSM GSJ K]UQGOSOSM YNK LOKQJX TL 8QGS!X XGQK XUWKGJXNKKYX&
DTUOI )+$ )-2 DT XYWKGRQOSK YNK IGXK$ 8QGS OX OS YNK UWTIKXX TL XZUUQKRKSYOSM OYX OSYKWWTMGYTW^ WKXUTSXKX
ITWWKXUTSJOSM YT YNKXK YTUOIX& EK HKQOK[K OSLTWRGYOTS UWT[OJKJ OS YNK XZUUQKRKSYKJ WKXUTSXKX \OQQ
RGPK YNK JKUTXOYOTSX ZSSKIKXXGW^& EK!J HK NGUU^ YT JOXIZXX JKXOMSGYKJ \OYSKXXKX GSJ JKUTXOYOTS
QTMOXYOIX OL ZUTS WK[OK\OSM YNK WKXUTSXK 4UUQK JKIOJKX YNGY LZWYNKW YKXYORTS^ OX SKIKXXGW^ YT K]UQTWK
YNKXK YTUOIX&
DTUOIX *(2 KGIN OSJO[OJZGQ \OYSKXX JKXOMSGYKJ LTW YNK YTUOI
DTUOIX ,$-$0$12 8QGS \OQQ STY UWTJZIK G \OYSKXX LTW YNKXK YTUOIX XOSIK @W& 6NGSM NGX MO[KS K]YKSXO[K
YKXYORTSOKX LTW YNK XGRK YTUOIX OS YNK =D6 4IYOTS& BQKGXK ITSLOWR YNGY 4UUQK \OQQ JWTU YNKXK YTUOIX&
DTUOI .2 8QGS JTKX STY NG[K GS^ GJJOYOTSGQ WKXUTSXO[K OSLTWRGYOTS& BQKGXK ITSLOWR YNGY 4UUQK \OQQ JWTU
YNOX YTUOI&

(

4X = NG[K OSJOIGYKJ HKQT\$ \K \TZQJ HK GHQK YT RGPK YNKXK \OYSKXXKX$ OSIQZJOSM YNK OSJO[OJZGQQ^
JKXOMSGYKJ \OYSKXXKX G[GOQGHQK LTW JKUTXOYOTS OS DGO\GS GY YNK KSJ TL >ZSK GSJ LOWXY \KKP TL >ZQ^& 4 \KKP
NGX UGXXKJ GSJ \K NG[K STY NKGWJ GS^YNOSM LWTR 4UUQK WKMGWJOSM OYX LOSGQ UTXOYOTS$ GX XZIN \K IGS!Y TLLKW
YT UWTJZIK YNKXK \OYSKXXKX SK]Y \KKP OS DGO\GS& <T\K[KW$ \K WKRGOS \OQQOSM YT RGPK YNKR G[GOQGHQK
UWTRUYQ^& 9ZWYNKW$ OS QOMNY TL YNK WKIKSY UWTJZIYOTS TL @W& AOIP ?OS!X UGYKSY XZRRGWOKX$ \K GQXT HKQOK[K
NOX JKUTXOYOTS \OQQ ST QTSMKW HK SKIKXXGW^& BQKGXK QKY ZX PST\ \NKYNKW 4UUQK \OQQ ITSXOJKW JWTUUOSM @W&
?OS!X JKUTXOYOTS&
9OSGQQ^$ YNK UGWYOKX NG[K STY JOXIZXXKJ YNK )'* [KWXZX *'+ YORK GMGOSXY YNK YTYGQ *)%NTZW +("H#".# YORK
QOROY JZK YT YNK YWGSXQGYOTS SKKJX& 8QGS RGOSYGOSX OYX UTXOYOTS TL *'+ YORK GMGOSXY YNK QOROY$ HZY \K GWK
\OQQOSM YT LZWYNKW JOXIZXX YNOX OXXZK&
5KXY$
>GSK
CCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC
#-,*! 2T" 8DNG
$(+.! @GFNGRFDW" 8TNG %)" &$%% %$.&+ <9
%,! !@DLSGQ" 4GQGK!
"'! 5LDN 1PPLG ?GDM/ 1PPLG 5LDN @79 >GQUJEG
$/&)('.! 9GGS DNF EONHGQ QG FGPORJSJONR OH 5LDN VJSNGRR

5N[NT%
; JV `[R]RWP ]X LXWOR[V X^[ LXW_N[\J]RXW NJ[URN[ ]XMJb [NPJ[MRWP ]QN MNYX\R]RXW\ XO 6UJW `R]WN\\ JWM
]X NVYQJ\RcN \XVN \JURNW] YXRW]\'
2\ `N MR\L^\\NM% ]QN \]J]NVNW] ]QJ] 6UJW `X^UM K[RWP !6UJW NVYUXbNN\! JWM RW_NW]X[\ ]X ]QN ?542
`J\ VJMN `R]Q ]QN RW]NW]RXW XO LX_N[RWP `R]WN\\N\ OX[ 6UJW"\ LUJRV\' FN QJ_N WX] [N_R\R]NM ]QJ]
UJWP^JPN \RWLN 2YYUN XWUb [NLNW]Ub WX]RLNM JWb \^LQ MNYX\R]RXW\ RW ]QR\ LJ\N' ; JU\X WX]N% JWM J\ `N
QJ_N MR\L^\\NM RW X^[ @YYX\R]RXW ]X 2YYUN >X]RXW ]X 4XVYNU% J] ]QN ]RVN 6UJW VJMN ]QN X[RPRWJU
4>4 \]J]NVNW]% ]Q[NN XO ]QN +-+ RW_NW]X[\ QJM JU[NJMb UNO] ]QN LXVYJWb JWM \^LQ RWOX[VJ]RXW `J\
LUNJ[Ub [NY[N\NW]NM ]X 2YYUN RW 6UJW"\ ;WR]RJU B^UN *. 5R\LUX\^[N MJ]NM CNY]NVKN[ *((1' DQN OX^[]Q
JWM UJ\] RW_NW]X[ UNO] 6UJW"\ NVYUXb \QX[]Ub ]QN[NJO]N[% \X 6UJW R\ WX UXWPN[ RW J YX\R]RXW ]X Y[X_RMN
JWb XO ]QN RW_NW]X[\ RW ]QN EWR]NM C]J]N\'
2\ bX^ J[N WX MX^K] J`J[N% ]QN Y[N\^VY]RXW R\ ]QJ] LX[YX[J]N NVYUXbNN\ `RUU KN MNYX\NM `QN[N ]QNb
`X[T' 2YYUN QJ\ WX] PR_NW ^\ JWb [NJ\XW ]X LQJWPN ]QR\ Y[N\^VY]RXW' DQJ] R\ N\YNLRJUUb ]QN LJ\N
QN[N `QN[N 2YYUN QJ\ WX]RLNM J UJ[PN W^VKN[ XO MNYX\R]RXW\% MNVJWMNM ]QJ] ]QNb XLL^[ RW J \QX[]
YN[RXM XO ]RVN JWM `QN[N VJWb XO ]QN MNYX\R]RXW\ R] R\ MNVJWMRWP J[N [NM^WMJW] XO ]N\]RVXWb
JU[NJMb ]JTNW O[XV `R]WN\\ Y[N_RX^\Ub VJMN J_JRUJKUN RW ]QN EWR]NM C]J]N\' 6_NW ^WMN[ 2YYUN"\
[NJMRWP XO ]QN 4>4 \]J]NVNW]% ]QJ] Y[X_R\RXW MXN\ WX] PR_N 2YYUN ]QN ^WON]]N[NM [RPQ] ]X WX]RLN NW]R[N
MNYJ[]VNW]\ J] 6UJW% WX[ ]X \NNT Y^[NUb [NM^WMJW] MNYX\R]RXW\' GN] ]QJ] R\ Y[NLR\NUb `QJ] 2YYUN QJ\
MXWN' 2YYUN QJ\ WX]RLNM ]QN RWMR_RM^JU MNYX\R]RXW\ XO >[' 6[RL GJWP% 5[JLX F^% JWM =NX 4QNW% JUU XO
`QXV J[N NWPRWNN[\ RW ]QN \JVN MNYJ[]VNW]'
;W JMMR]RXW% RW X^[ LXW_N[\J]RXW bX^ NaY[N\\Ub MNVJWMNM ]QJ] 6UJW Y[X_RMN `R]WN\\N\ RW ]QN EWR]NM
C]J]N\ ]X ]N\]ROb XW ]XYRL\ WNJ[Ub RMNW]RLJU ]X ]QN ]XYRL\ XW `QRLQ 6UJW NVYUXbNN\ QJ_N JU[NJMb KNNW
)

MNYX\NM% RW ]QN EWR]NM C]J]N\' 7X[ NaJVYUN% 2YYUN"\ 7R[\] ?X]RLN XO 5NYX\R]RXW XO 6UJW R\\^NM RW ]QN
;D4 JL]RXW% DXYRL\ )&1% J[N N\\NW]RJUUb RMNW]RLJU ]X 2YYUN"\ L^[[NW] +(#K$#.$ DXYRL\ ,%-%0% JWM 1' #FN
JU\X WX]N ]QJ] 6UJW QJ\ JOOR[VJ]R_NUb [N\YXWMNM RW R]\ [N\YXW\N ]X 2YYUN ;W]N[[XPJ]X[b ?X' /% ]QJ] 6UJW
QJ\ WX] URLNW\NM X[ J]]NVY]NM ]X URLNW\N ]QN +-+ AJ]NW]$' DQN[NOX[N% ]QN\N ]XYRL\ J[N LXVYUN]NUb
[NM^WMJW]' 2YYUN QJ\ Y[X_RMNM WX PXXM [NJ\XW `Qb 6UJW \QX^UM KN Y^] ]X ]QN K^[MNW XO Y[X_RMRWP
`R]WN\\ OX[ ]QN\N ]XYRL\ J] JUU% V^LQ UN\\ RWL^[ ]QN K^[MNW JWM NaYNW\N XO K[RWPRWP ]QX\N `R]WN\\N\ ]X
]QN EWR]NM C]J]N\' ;WMNNM% RW ]QN <JW^J[b *(% *()) SXRW] 4>4 \]J]NVNW]% `N QJ_N JP[NNM ]QJ] !HNIJLQ
YJ[]b QJ\ VJMN _XU^VRWX^\ Y[XM^L]RXW XO MXL^VNW]\% JWM MNYX\R]RXW\ XO YJ[]b `R]WN\\N\% RW_NW]X[\
JWM WXW&YJ[]RN\ QJ_N ]JTNW YUJLN' >^LQ XO ]QR\ MR\LX_N[b QJ\ KNNW ^WMN[]JTNW RW LXWWNL]RXW `R]Q ]QN
;D4 RW_N\]RPJ]RXW' BNVJRWRWP ]XYRL\ XO MR\LX_N[b RWLU^MN LXVYUN]RXW XO MXL^VNW] Y[XM^L]RXW\%
MNYX\R]RXW\ XO LN[]JRW RWMR_RM^JU\ WJVNM J\ RW_NW]X[\ JWM YJ[]b `R]WN\\N\ [NUJ]RWP ]X ]QN JLL^\NM
O^WL]RXWJUR]RN\% J\ `NUU J\ MJVJPN\&[NUJ]NM MR\LX_N[b RWLU^MRWP \JUN\ JWM Y[XOR]\ MN[R_NM O[XV ]QN
JLL^\NM Y[XM^L]\'! FR]Q ]QJ] \JRM% RO 2YYUN LJW WJ[[X` ]QN\N ]XYRL\ ]X ]QN \^KSNL]\ WX] LX_N[NM RW ]QN
Y[N_RX^\ MNYX\R]RXW\% `N `RUU LXW\RMN[ Y[X_RMRWP `R]WN\\N\ OX[ URVR]NM MNYX\R]RXW\ RW DJR`JW'
DQR\ ^WMN[\LX[N\ X^[ YX\R]RXW ]QJ] NLXWXVb% NOORLRNWLb JWM OUNaRKRUR]b OJ_X[ ]QN MNYX\R]RXW\ PXRWP
OX[`J[M RW DJR`JW' ;WMNNM% RWLU^MRWP ]QN OR_N RWMR_RM^JU NVYUXbNN\ 2YYUN QJ\ WX]RLNM% `N J[N
UXXTRWP J] JKX^] 1&)( `R]WN\\ MNYX\R]RXW\' FQRUN 6UJW R\ RWZ^R[RWP RW]X `R]WN\\N\" _R\J \]J]^\% \^LQ
Y[XLNM^[N `RUU WX] KN ][R_RJU% WNR]QN[ R\ ]QN MR\[^Y]RXW ]X WX[VJU `X[T OUX` JWM LX\] 6UJW `RUU RWL^[ ]X
K[RWP ]QN\N `R]WN\\N\ ]X ]QN ?542'
7^[]QN[% J\ bX^ J[N JU[NJMb J`J[N O[XV >[' 4Q^WP"\ MNYX\R]RXW% 6UJW"\ ]X^LQYJM JWM ]X^LQ\L[NNW
MNYJ[]VNW]\ J[N UXLJ]NM RW \NYJ[J]N UXLJ]RXW\' DQ^\ JWb PR_NW 6UJW NVYUXbNN R\ V^LQ VX[N OJVRURJ[
`R]Q NR]QN[ 6UJW"\ ]X^LQYJM X[ ]X^LQ\L[NNW Y[XM^L] URWN\% WX] KX]Q' DQN JKRUR]b XO J `R]WN\\ ]X XK]JRW
JMMR]RXWJU RWOX[VJ]RXW \QX^UM ]QNb WX] [NLJUU J YJ[]RL^UJ[ \^KSNL] VJ]]N[ RW J +(#K$#.$ ]XYRL `RUU KN
P[NJ]Ub NWQJWLNM Kb QJ_RWP LX[YX[J]N [N\X^[LN\ [NJMRUb J_JRUJKUN' ;O 6UJW R\ OX[LNM ]X K[RWP R]\
`R]WN\\N\ ]X ?542% 6UJW `RUU LN[]JRWUb MN\RPWJ]N ]QN VX\] TWX`UNMPNJKUN `R]WN\\N\ JWM Y[NYJ[N
]QNV XW ]QN Y[XM^L]\ ]QNb MXW"] TWX` O[XV MJRUb NaYN[RNWLN' 8R_NW ]QN \QNN[ W^VKN[ XO MNYX\R]RXW\
2YYUN R\ MNVJWMRWP% 6UJW \RVYUb `RUU WX] KN JKUN ]X Y[X_RMN VX[N ]QJW ) `R]WN\\ OX[ JUU 6UJW Y[XM^L]
[NUJ]NM ]XYRL\' 9X`N_N[% RO ]QN MNYX\R]RXW\ `N[N ]X ]JTNW YUJLN RW DJR`JW% 6UJW `RUU QJ_N ]QN JMMNM
KNWNOR] ]X QJ_N RVVNMRJ]N JLLN\\ ]X X]QN[ NVYUXbNN\' 2\ \^LQ% RO WNLN\\J[b JWM `R]QRW [NJ\XW% 6UJW R\
`RUURWP ]X Y[XM^LN ]`X `R]WN\\N\ OX[ NJLQ ]XYRL [NUJ]RWP ]X 6UJW Y[XM^L]\ ]X KN\] LXVY[NQNW\R_NUb
LX_N[ 2YYUN"\ MNYX\R]RXW ]XYRL\' 2\ ; JU\X MR\L^\\NM% OX[ \QX[]N[ MNYX\R]RXW\% YN[QJY\ 2YYUN \QX^UM
LXW\RMN[ _RMNX LXWON[NWLRWP J\ JW JU]N[WJ]R_N JYY[XJLQ'
5^[RWP ]QN VNN] JWM LXWON[% ; QJ_N Y[X_RMNM bX^ ]QN RMNW]RORN\ XO 6UJW"\ MN\RPWJ]NM +(#K$#.$
`R]WN\\N\' FN `RUU [N&LXWOR[V ]QN `R]WN\\ MN\RPWJ]RXW\ `R]Q 6UJW JWM `RUU Y[X_RMN bX^ ]QN ORWJU UR\]
XO ]QN MN\RPWJ]NM `R]WN\\N\ JWM ]QNR[ 4QRWN\N WJVN\ \QX[]Ub'
7RWJUUb% `N QJ_N WX] QNJ[M JWb [N\YXW\N O[XV 2YYUN [NUJ]RWP 6UJW"\ +(#K$#.$ MNYX\R]RXW\ X[ 6UJW"\
<^WN )(% *()) UN]]N[ MR\L^\\RWP ]QN \N[RX^\ MXL^VNW] Y[XM^L]RXW MNORLRNWLRN\ O[XV 2YYUN' @]QN[ ]QJW
J ON` URLNW\N\% `N QJ_N WX] [NLNR_NM JWb MJVJPN\ MXL^VNW]\ O[XV 2YYUN% OX[ NaJVYUN \JUN\ _XU^VN%
[N_NW^N JWM LX\] MJ]J' ;W URPQ] XO ]QN JYY[XJLQRWP MR\LX_N[b L^]&XOO% YUNJ\N LXWOR[V ]QJ] 2YYUN R\
J_JRUJKUN XW 7[RMJb OX[ J VNN] JWM LXWON[ ]X MR\L^\\ ]QN\N X^]\]JWMRWP MR\LX_N[b R\\^N\'
3N\]%

*

<JWN
"(,-*) ! #'+& $$%
%*( 1;77=89;8=7 3?57 D 4B;A8 $(# D 18>=? 25@<! .- ,'#%(
)(#"+&+"%#$, /;@86A
)(#"+&+"%##$ 05C
####################################################### 256 0BJ<MD9J )*' =BK<DGKMJ>. 7G >FKMJ>
<GEHDB9F<> OBLA J>IMBJ>E>FLK BEHGK>= ;Q LA> 256 9F= GLA>J L9PBF@ 9MLAGJBLB>K$ O> BF?GJE QGM LA9L 9FQ L9P
9=NB<> <GFL9BF>= BF LABK <GEEMFB<9LBGF !BF<DM=BF@ 9FQ 9LL9<AE>FLK" BK FGL BFL>F=>= GJ OJBLL>F LG ;> MK>=$ 9F=
<9FFGL ;> MK>=$ ?GJ LA> HMJHGK> G? !B" 9NGB=BF@ H>F9DLB>K LA9L E9Q ;> BEHGK>= GF 9FQ L9PH9Q>J GJ !BB" HJGEGLBF@$
E9JC>LBF@ GJ J><GEE>F=BF@ LG 9FGLA>J H9JLQ 9FQ LJ9FK9<LBGF GJ E9LL>J 9==J>KK>= A>J>BF&
888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888888 347201. 7ABK >%E9BD E>KK9@> 9F= 9DD
9LL9<AE>FLK LJ9FKEBLL>= OBLA BL E9Q <GFL9BF D>@9DDQ HJBNBD>@>= 9F= <GF?B=>FLB9D BF?GJE9LBGF BFL>F=>= KGD>DQ ?GJ
LA> MK> G? LA> 9==J>KK>>& 2? LA> J>9=>J G? LABK E>KK9@> BK FGL LA> BFL>F=>= J><BHB>FL$ QGM 9J> A>J>;Q FGLB?B>= LA9L
9FQ J>9=BF@$ =BKK>EBF9LBGF$ =BKLJB;MLBGF$ <GHQBF@$ GJ GLA>J MK> G? LABK E>KK9@> GJ BLK 9LL9<AE>FLK BK KLJB<LDQ
HJGAB;BL>=& 2? QGM A9N> J><>BN>= LABK E>KK9@> BF >JJGJ$ HD>9K> FGLB?Q LA> K>F=>J BEE>=B9L>DQ ;Q L>D>HAGF> !+'+%
--(%,'''" GJ ;Q >D><LJGFB< E9BD !HGKLE9KL>J/9DKLGF&<GE"$ 9F= =>D>L> LABK E>KK9@> 9F= 9DD <GHB>K 9F= ;9<CMHK
LA>J>G?& 7A9FC QGM&

=FC GKDLNJ?PGLK ALKP?GKCB GK PFGO CJ?GI JCOO?EC GO GKPCKBCB LKIT DLN QOC LD PFC GKBGRGBQ?I LN CKPGPT K?JCB ?@LRC$ 5D PFC
NC?BCN LD PFGO JCOO?EC GO KLP PFC GKPCKBCB NCAGMGCKP# LN PFC CJMILTCC LN ?ECKP NCOMLKOG@IC PL BCIGRCN GP PL PFC GKPCKBCB
NCAGMGCKP# TLQ ?NC FCNC@T KLPGDGCB PF?P ?KT BGOOCJGK?PGLK# BGOPNG@QPGLK LN ALMTGKE LD PFGO ALJJQKGA?PGLK GO OPNGAPIT
MNLFG@GPCB$ 5D TLQ F?RC NCACGRCB PFGO ALJJQKGA?PGLK GK CNNLN# MIC?OC GJJCBG?PCIT KLPGDT QO @T CJ?GI
!MLOPJ?OPCN-SCGI$ALJ"# ?KB BCOPNLT PFC LNGEGK?I JCOO?EC$ =F?KH TLQ$

=FC GKDLNJ?PGLK ALKP?GKCB GK PFGO CJ?GI JCOO?EC GO GKPCKBCB LKIT DLN QOC LD PFC GKBGRGBQ?I LN CKPGPT K?JCB ?@LRC$ 5D PFC
NC?BCN LD PFGO JCOO?EC GO KLP PFC GKPCKBCB NCAGMGCKP# LN PFC CJMILTCC LN ?ECKP NCOMLKOG@IC PL BCIGRCN GP PL PFC GKPCKBCB
NCAGMGCKP# TLQ ?NC FCNC@T KLPGDGCB PF?P ?KT BGOOCJGK?PGLK# BGOPNG@QPGLK LN ALMTGKE LD PFGO ALJJQKGA?PGLK GO OPNGAPIT
MNLFG@GPCB$ 5D TLQ F?RC NCACGRCB PFGO ALJJQKGA?PGLK GK CNNLN# MIC?OC GJJCBG?PCIT KLPGDT QO @T CJ?GI
!MLOPJ?OPCN-SCGI$ALJ"# ?KB BCOPNLT PFC LNGEGK?I JCOO?EC$ =F?KH TLQ$

=FC GKDLNJ?PGLK ALKP?GKCB GK PFGO CJ?GI JCOO?EC GO GKPCKBCB LKIT DLN QOC LD PFC GKBGRGBQ?I LN CKPGPT K?JCB ?@LRC$ 5D PFC
NC?BCN LD PFGO JCOO?EC GO KLP PFC GKPCKBCB NCAGMGCKP# LN PFC CJMILTCC LN ?ECKP NCOMLKOG@IC PL BCIGRCN GP PL PFC GKPCKBCB
NCAGMGCKP# TLQ ?NC FCNC@T KLPGDGCB PF?P ?KT BGOOCJGK?PGLK# BGOPNG@QPGLK LN ALMTGKE LD PFGO ALJJQKGA?PGLK GO OPNGAPIT
MNLFG@GPCB$ 5D TLQ F?RC NCACGRCB PFGO ALJJQKGA?PGLK GK CNNLN# MIC?OC GJJCBG?PCIT KLPGDT QO @T CJ?GI
!MLOPJ?OPCN-SCGI$ALJ"# ?KB BCOPNLT PFC LNGEGK?I JCOO?EC$ =F?KH TLQ$

+