Elan Microelectronics Corporation v. Apple, Inc.

Filing 408

Declaration of Jane H. Bu in Support of 406 Objection filed byElan Microelectronics Corporation. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B, # 3 Exhibit C, # 4 Exhibit D, # 5 Exhibit E, # 6 Exhibit F, # 7 Exhibit G, # 8 Exhibit H)(Related document(s) 406 ) (Bu, Jane) (Filed on 8/22/2011)

Download PDF
EXHIBIT D Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25 ELAN MICROELECTRONICS CORPORATION'S PRIVILEGE LOG - OCTOBER 25, 2010 DATE PRIVILEGE ASSERTED PORTION WITHHELD Document prepared by or at direction of Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis 2/11/2004 WP Entire document Draco Wu Document prepared by or at direction of Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis 2/11/2004 WP Entire document 3 Akin Gump (outside counsel) Document prepared by Elan's outside counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation 12/11/2006 WP Entire document 4 Chao-Hui Hsu Document prepared by or at direction of Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent information 3/9/2005 WP Entire document 5 Elan Legal Department Document prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice. 9/17/2007 WP Entire document 6 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Document prepared by Elan for third parties having a common legal interest with Elan, containing communications with counsel regarding patent analysis in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice. 8/4/2008 WP/Common Interest Portion withheld 7 Yitai Hu (Akin Gump) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis 6/30/2008 AC/WP Entire document 8 JD Tsai Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Godwin Chiu, Charles Pai, Hank Chen, Eliot Lin Document reflecting communications with Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation 3/26/2008 AC/WP Entire document 9 Elan Legal Department Document prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent information 8/9/2007 WP Entire document 10 Godwin Chiu Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), I.H. Yeh, W.F. Lu Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re settlement negotiation 7/31/2007 AC Entire document 11 Godwin Chiu Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), I.H. Yeh, W.F. Lu, Ian Chung Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent information 12/10/2007 AC Entire document NO. AUTHOR 1 Draco Wu 2 RECIPIENT Certain Electronic Devices with Multi-Touch Enabled Touchpads and Touchscreens ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-714 COPY RECIPIENT DESCRIPTION Ian Chung 1 Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc. Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PVT) Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25 NO. AUTHOR RECIPIENT 12 Godwin Chiu Jeff Cheng (Elan Legal) Annie Jeong, DJ Seo, Michael Na 13 Godwin Chiu DATE PRIVILEGE ASSERTED PORTION WITHHELD Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Ian Chung, Wayne Chang (Elan in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Legal) seeking/providing legal advice re contract negotiation 1/28/2008 AC Entire document Email communications reflecting communication with Elan legal department and containing attachment prepared by Elan's outside Peggy Lin, Charles Pai, Ian Chung counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation 2/20/2008 AC/WP Entire document Email communications reflecting communications with Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation 3/14/2008 AC Entire document COPY RECIPIENT DESCRIPTION 14 Godwin Chiu Charles Pai, Ian Chung 15 Godwin Chiu Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Ian Chung, hank Chen, William Lee, Charles Pai, JD Tsai, Peggy Lin, Eliot Lin I.H. Yeh Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation 3/20/2008 AC Entire document 16 Godwin Chiu I.H. Yeh, Ian Chung, Kuo-Lung Yen, Chun-An Tan, Charles Pai, Ming-Shu Wang, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Chi-Tien Yeh Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent application 3/23/2008 AC Entire document Email communications with Elan legal department and containing W.F. Lu, Ian Chung, Roven Lee, attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis and patent litigation 4/16/2008 AC/WP Entire document Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis and patent litigation 4/17/2008 AC/WP Entire document 17 Godwin Chiu I.H. Yeh, Bill Tsai (Elan Legal) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Bill Tsai (Elan Legal) 18 Godwin Chiu I.H. Yeh, Ian Chung, W.F. Lu, Godwin Chiu 19 Godwin Chiu I.H. Yeh, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Roven Lee, Charlie Huang Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Eliot Lin, Ian Chung, Eric Huang, in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Maco Tang, Charles Pai seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis 4/27/2008 AC Entire document 20 Godwin Chiu Chi-Tien Yeh, WenJun Chen, Charles Pai, Roven Lee, Ian Chung Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), I.H. in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Yeh seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis 6/3/2008 AC Entire document 8/4/2008 AC/WP Entire document 8/11/2008 AC Entire document 21 Godwin Chiu Ian Chung 22 Godwin Chiu Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Ian Chung, Charles Chen Email communications reflecting communications with Bill Tsai (Elan Legal) and containing attachments prepared by Elan's outside counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis. Certain Electronic Devices with Multi-Touch Enabled Touchpads and Touchscreens ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-714 Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel I.H. Yeh, Jeff Cheng (Elan Legal) in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis 2 Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc. Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PVT) Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25 NO. AUTHOR RECIPIENT COPY RECIPIENT DESCRIPTION DATE PRIVILEGE ASSERTED PORTION WITHHELD 23 I.H. Yeh Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Godwin Chiu, W.F. Lu Ian Chung Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re settlement negotiation 7/31/2007 AC Entire document 24 I.H. Yeh Ian Chung, Godwin Chiu, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis 11/10/2007 AC Entire document 25 I.H. Yeh 12/1/2007 AC Entire document 26 I.H. Yeh 12/8/2007 AC Entire document 27 I.H. Yeh 12/8/2007 AC Entire document 28 I.H. Yeh 12/25/2007 AC Entire document 29 I.H. Yeh 12/28/2007 AC Entire document 30 I.H. Yeh Ian Chung Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Dai-Min Liu, Wayne Chang (Elan in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Legal), Godwin Chiu, Charles Pai seeking/providing legal advice re patent information 12/31/2007 AC Entire document 31 I.H. Yeh I.H. Yeh, Ian Chung, Kuo-Lung Yen, Chun-An Tang, Godwin Chiu, Charles Pai, Ming-Shu Wang, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent application 3/22/2008 AC Entire document I.H. Yeh Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Kuo-Lung Yen, Ian Chung, Godwin Chiu, W.F. Lu Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation and settlement 7/31/2008 AC/WP Entire document Catherine Pai Email communications reflecting communications with Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis and patent litigation. 8/4/2008 AC/WP Entire document 32 33 I.H. Yeh Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Ian in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Chung, Godwin Chiu, Charles Pai seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel W.F. lu, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Godwin Chiu Ian Chung in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel W.F. Lu, Godwin Chiu, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Phoenix Lin, Ian Chung in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Charles Pai, Ian Chung, in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Andy Wu, Godwin Chiu, W.F. Lu seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation and settlement negotiation Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel W.F. Lu, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Charles Pai, in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of W.F. Lu ian Chung, Andy Wu, Godwin Chiu seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation and settlement negotiation David Lin Certain Electronic Devices with Multi-Touch Enabled Touchpads and Touchscreens ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-714 Chi-Tien Yeh Godwin Chiu, Ian Chung 3 Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc. Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PVT) Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25 NO. 34 35 DESCRIPTION DATE PRIVILEGE ASSERTED PORTION WITHHELD Ian Chung, Godwin Chiu, Dai-Min Liu, W.F. Lu, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation 11/19/2008 AC/WP Entire document Charles Pai, Godwin Chiu, Ian Chung, Ming-Shu Wang, Maco Tang Email communications reflecting communications with Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Bill Tsai (Elan Legal), JH Liu (Elan Legal) and Nick Lin (Elan Legal) and containing attachments prepared by 11/28/2008 Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent application and patent analysis. AC/WP Entire document Email communications reflecting communications with Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Bill Tsai (Elan Legal), JH Liu (Elan Legal) and Nick Lin (Elan Legal) and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent application and patent analysis. 12/1/2008 AC/WP Entire document AUTHOR RECIPIENT I.H. Yeh Wen Kai Lee COPY RECIPIENT 36 Wen Kai Lee Maco Tang, Charles Pai, Ming-Shu Wang, Ian Chung, Godwin Chiu 37 Roven Lee Godwin Chiu, I.H. Yeh, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Charlie Huang Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Eliot Lin, Ian Chung, Eric Huang, in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Maco Tang, Charles Pai seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis 4/28/2008 AC Entire document William Lee, David Lin, Charlie Huang, Ian Chung Email communications reflecting communications with Wayne Maco Tang, Roven Lee, Godwin Chang (Elan Legal) and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation Chiu and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis and patent litigation. 9/10/2007 AC Entire document 11/11/2007 AC Entire document 38 Chi-Tien Yeh 39 David Lin Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Godwin Chiu, Ian Chung, I.H. Yeh, in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Peggy Lin seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis and patent litigation 40 Charlie Huang Godwin Chiu, I.H. Yeh, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Roven Lee Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Eliot Lin, Ian Chung, Eric Huang, in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Maco Tang, Charles Pai seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis 4/28/2008 AC Entire document Eliot Lin Godwin Chiu, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Ian Chung, Hank Chen, William Lee, Charles Pai, JD Tsai, Peggy Lin Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis and patent litigation 3/24/2008 AC Entire document I.H. Yeh, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis and patent litigation 12/17/2007 AC Entire document 41 42 Charles Pai Certain Electronic Devices with Multi-Touch Enabled Touchpads and Touchscreens ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-714 Ian Chung, Godwin Chiu 4 Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc. Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PVT) Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25 NO. 43 44 45 46 AUTHOR Charles Pai Charles Pai Charles Pai RECIPIENT Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), I.H. Yeh Ian Chung Daniel Chen Charles Pai Ian Chung, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Hank Chen wangyong@longcheertel.com; yangrongsheng@longcheertel.com 48 Hank Chen Godwin Chiu, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Ian Chung, William Lee, Charles Pai, JD Tsai, Peggy Lin, Eliot Lin 49 Hank Chen 50 JD Tsai 51 Pei Wang William Lee, Chi-Tien Yeh DESCRIPTION DATE PRIVILEGE ASSERTED PORTION WITHHELD Ian Chung, Godwin Chiu Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis and patent litigation 12/17/2007 AC Entire document Email communications reflecting communications with Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Bill Tsai (Elan Legal) and Jeff Cheng (Elan Legal) and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re NDA agreement, patent analysis and patent litigation. 2/27/2008 AC/WP Entire document 2/27/2008 WP/Common Interest Entire document 3/21/2008 AC/WP Entire document 1/31/2008 WP/Common Interest Entire document Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis and patent litigation 3/21/2008 AC/WP Entire document Email communications containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation 6/24/2008 WP Entire document 3/25/2008 AC Entire document 9/11/2007 AC Entire document Godwin Chiu Document prepared by Elan for third parties having a common Ming-Shu Wang, Eva Chen, legal interest with Elan, containing communications with counsel James Chen, Wayne Chang (Elan regarding patent analysis in anticipation of litigation and/or for Legal) purposes of seeking/providing legal advice. Godwin Chiu, Ming-Shu Wang, Jeff Cheng (Elan Legal) Godwin Chiu, Ian Chung, JD Tsai Godwin Chiu, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Ian Chung, Hank Chen, William Lee, Charles Pai, Peggy Lin, Eliot Lin COPY RECIPIENT 47 Certain Electronic Devices with Multi-Touch Enabled Touchpads and Touchscreens ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-714 Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re NDA agreement; patent analysis and patent litigation Document prepared by Elan for third parties having a common Ian Chung, Godwin Chiu, Wayne legal interest with Elan, containing communications with counsel Chang (Elan Legal) regarding patent analysis in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice. I.H. Yeh Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis and patent litigation Email communications reflecting communications with Wayne David Lin, Charlie Huang, Ian Chang (Elan Legal) and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation Chung, Maco Tang, Roven Lee, and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent Godwin Chiu litigation 5 Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc. Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PVT) Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25 NO. AUTHOR RECIPIENT DATE PRIVILEGE ASSERTED PORTION WITHHELD Email communications reflecting communications with Wayne Chi-Tien Yeh, David Lin, Charlie Chang (Elan Legal) and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation Huang, Ian Chung, Maco Tang, and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent Roven Lee, Godwin Chiu litigation. 9/12/2007 AC Entire document COPY RECIPIENT DESCRIPTION 52 Pei Wang William Lee 53 Jeff Cheng (Elan Legal) David Lin Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Godwin Chiu, Ian Chung, Wayne in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Chang (Elan Legal) seeking/providing legal advice re NDA agreement 12/21/2007 AC/WP Entire document 54 Jeff Cheng (Elan Legal) Godwin Chiu Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Ian Chung, Wayne Chang (Elan in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Legal) seeking/providing legal advice re NDA agreement 1/28/2008 AC Entire document Godwin Chiu, I.H. Yeh, W.F. Lu Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re NDA agreement and patent litigation 7/6/2007 AC Entire document Godwin Chiu, I.H. Yeh, W.F. Lu Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re NDA agreement and patent litigation 7/6/2007 AC Entire document Godwin Chiu, I.H. Yeh Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis and patent litigation 7/9/2007 AC Entire document 7/10/2007 AC/WP Entire document 55 56 57 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Ian Chung Ian Chung Ian Chung 58 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Ian Chung Godwin Chiu, I.H. Yeh Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent information 59 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) I.H. Yeh, Godwin Chiu, W.F. Lu Ian Chung Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation and settlement 7/31/2007 AC Entire document 60 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Godwin Chiu, I.H. Yeh, W.F. Lu Ian Chung Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation and settlement 8/2/2007 AC Entire document Godwin Chiu Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent information 8/22/2007 AC/WP Entire document 61 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Ian Chung Certain Electronic Devices with Multi-Touch Enabled Touchpads and Touchscreens ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-714 6 Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc. Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PVT) Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25 NO. 62 63 AUTHOR Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) RECIPIENT Terial Lu Godwin Chiu, Ian Chung DATE PRIVILEGE ASSERTED PORTION WITHHELD Ian Chung Document prepared by Elan for third parties having a common legal interest with Elan, containing communications with counsel regarding patent analysis in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice. 10/4/2007 WP/Common Interest Entire document I.H. Yeh Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re indemnification agreement 11/6/2007 AC/WP Entire document 11/6/2007 AC/WP Entire document COPY RECIPIENT DESCRIPTION 64 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Ian Chung Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re indemnification agreement 65 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) I.H. Yeh, W.F. Lu, Godwin Chiu, Ian Chung Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis 12/9/2007 AC Entire document 66 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Charles Pai, I.H. Yeh Ian Chung, Godwin Chiu Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis 12/17/2007 AC Entire document 67 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Charles Pai, I.H. Yeh Ian Chung, Godwin Chiu Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis 12/17/2007 AC Entire document 68 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) I.H. Yeh, Charles Pai, Ian Chung, Andy Wu, Godwin Chiu, W.F. Lu Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis and patent litigation 12/25/2007 AC Entire document 69 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) I.H. Yeh, Ian Chung, Godwin Chiu, Dai-Min Liu, W.F. Lu Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation 11/19/2008 AC Entire document 70 Jason Oung Ian Chung Email communications containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation. 8/5/2008 WP Portion withheld Email communications containing attachment prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis and patent litigation 6/16/2008 WP Portion withheld Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis 6/13/2007 AC Entire document 71 Ivy Chen Ian Chung 72 Daisuke Shudo Godwin Chiu, Ocean Chen, I.H. Yeh, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Godwin Chiu Certain Electronic Devices with Multi-Touch Enabled Touchpads and Touchscreens ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-714 Ian Chung, Rich Tan, Fumiaki Karasawa, Denny Huang, W.F. Lu, Draco Wu 7 Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc. Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PVT) Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25 NO. AUTHOR DATE PRIVILEGE ASSERTED PORTION WITHHELD Ian Chung, Rich Tan, Fumiaki Karasawa, Denny Huang, W.F. Lu, Godwin Chiu, Ocean Chen, I.H. Yeh, Wayne Chang (Elan Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Legal), Jacky Wu, Eric Yang, Alan in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Tsai, Saturn Tu, Alex Lee, Darren seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis Chen, Miller Wang, Peter He, Ago Lin, Jim Huang, Jane Chen, Jimmy Liu, Leo Chen RECIPIENT 6/27/2007 AC Entire document COPY RECIPIENT DESCRIPTION 73 Draco Wu Daisuke Shudo 74 W.F. Lu Godwin Chiu, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), I.H. Yeh Phoenix Lin, Ian Chung Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis 12/8/2007 AC Entire document 75 W.F. Lu I.H. Yeh, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Charles Pai, Ian Chung, Andy Wu, Godwin Chiu W.F. Lu Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation and settlement 12/28/2007 AC Entire document Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Godwin Chiu, Ian Chung, Rich Tan seeking/providing legal advice re patent application and patent analysis 5/29/2008 AC Entire document 76 Ji-Han Liu (Elan Legal) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), I.H. Yeh, W.F. Lu 77 I.H. Yeh Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Kuo-Lung Yen, Ian Chung, Steven Tsai, Godwin Chiu, Charles Pai, Venny Lin Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation and settlement 8/14/2008 AC Entire document 78 I.H. Yeh W.F. Lu, Venny Lin, Charles Pai, Godwin Chiu, Steven tsai, Ian Chung, Kuo-Lung Yen, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation and settlement 8/27/2008 AC Entire document 79 I.H. Yeh Nick Lin (Elan Legal), Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Bill Tsai (Elan Legal), Ian Chung, Godwin Chiu, KuoLung Yen, Charles Pai Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent information 2/3/2009 AC Entire document Ian Chung Email communications reflecting communications with Bill Tsai (Elan Legal) and Eve Chang (Elan Legal) and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent application information 11/18/2008 AC/WP Entire document Ian Chung Email communications with Elan legal department and containing Godwin Chiu, Kuo-Lung Yen, I.H. attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in Yeh, Bill Tsai (Elan Legal), Nick anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing Lin (Elan Legal) legal advice re patent analysis 2/4/2009 AC/WP Entire document 80 81 Vivian Yang Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Certain Electronic Devices with Multi-Touch Enabled Touchpads and Touchscreens ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-714 8 Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc. Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PVT) Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25 DESCRIPTION DATE PRIVILEGE ASSERTED PORTION WITHHELD I.H. Yeh, Ian Chung, Godwin Chiu Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re NDA agreement 11/10/2008 AC Entire document Godwin Chiu Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), I.H. Yeh, Ian Chung Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re NDA agreement 11/10/2008 AC Entire document 84 I.H. Yeh Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Godwin Chiu Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Charles Pai, Ian Chung, Kuo-Lung in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Yen seeking/providing legal advice re NDA agreement 12/5/2008 AC Entire document 85 Godwin Chiu I.H. Yeh, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Charles Pai, Ian Chung, Kuo-Lung in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Yen seeking/providing legal advice re NDA agreement 12/5/2008 AC Entire document 86 I.H. Yeh Godwin Chiu, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Charles Pai, Ian Chung, Kuo-Lung in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Yen seeking/providing legal advice re NDA agreement 12/5/2008 AC Entire document 87 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) I.H. Yeh, Godwin Chiu Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Charles Pai, Ian Chung, Kuo-Lung in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Yen seeking/providing legal advice re NDA agreement 12/5/2008 AC Entire document 88 Ian Chung Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation 7/9/2007 AC Entire document 89 Ian Chung Terial Lu Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Huang Lee, Odin Chang, Godwin in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Chiu, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) seeking/providing legal advice re patent information 7/27/2007 AC Entire document 11/7/2007 AC Entire document 12/31/2007 AC Entire document NO. AUTHOR RECIPIENT 82 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 83 COPY RECIPIENT Godwin Chiu, I.H. Yeh, W.F. Lu 90 Ian Chung Odin Chang Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Godwin Chiu, Wayne Chang (Elan in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Legal), Peggy Wen, Jennifer Hung seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation and indemnity agreement 91 Ian Chung I.H. Yeh Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Dai-Min Liu, Wayne Chang (Elan in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Legal), Godwin Chiu, Charles Pai seeking/providing legal advice re patent information 92 Ian Chung Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 93 Ian Chung Eva Chen Certain Electronic Devices with Multi-Touch Enabled Touchpads and Touchscreens ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-714 Godwin Chiu, Charles Pai, I.H. Yeh, Bill Tsai (Elan Legal) Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent information 1/4/2008 AC Entire document Godwin Chiu, Charles Pai Email communications reflecting communications with Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) and Jeff Cheng (Elan Legal) and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re NDA agreement and patent information 3/21/2008 AC/WP Entire document 9 Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc. Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PVT) Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25 NO. AUTHOR 94 Nick Lin (Elan Legal) 95 Akin Gump (outside counsel) 96 Akin Gump (outside counsel) 97 Charles Pai RECIPIENT COPY RECIPIENT Document prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent information Document prepared by Elan's outside counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis Document prepared by Elan's outside counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation PRIVILEGE ASSERTED PORTION WITHHELD 2/24/2009 WP Entire document 4/20/2006 AC/WP Entire document 12/11/2006 AC/WP Entire document Kuo-Lung Yen, W.F. Lu, Bill Tsai Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel (Elan Legal), Godwin Chiu, Ji-Han in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Liu (Elan Legal) seeking/providing legal advice re patent information 2/13/2009 AC/WP Entire document Email communications reflecting communications with Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Bill Tsai (Elan Legal), JH Liu (Elan Legal) and Nick Lin (Elan Legal) and containing attachment prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent information 3/2/2009 AC/WP Entire document Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation 9/19/2008 AC Entire document 10/14/2008 AC/WP Entire document 3/26/2009 AC/WP Entire document 4/1/2009 AC/WP Entire document 4/6/2009 AC/WP Entire document Charles Pai Ming-Shu Wang , Roven Lee, WenJun Chen, Maco Tang, Chi-Tien Yeh 99 Richard Chae (Akin Gump) Roven Lee, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 100 Bill Tsai (Elan Legal) Jimmy Wang, Ming-Shu Wang, Roven Lee, Tokui Tsai 101 Nick Lin (Elan Legal) Jimmy Wang, Roven Lee, Jesse Lin, Vincent Tao, Chun-Chung Huang, Rong-Shou Huang, Chi-Tien Yeh, Bill Tsai (Elan Legal) 102 Bill Tsai (Elan Legal) Roven Lee Nick Lin (Elan Legal) DATE Nick Lin (Elan Legal), Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), I.H. Yeh 98 103 DESCRIPTION Elantech Team <elantech.team@alston.com> Email communications with Elan legal department and containing Charles Pai, Godwin Chiu, Rongattachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in Shou Huang, Chi-Tien Yeh, Nick anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing Lin (Elan Legal), Eve Chang legal advice re patent information Email communications with Elan legal department and containing Kuo-Lung Yen, Godwin Chiu, attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent information Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent information Email communications with Elan legal department and containing Ming-Shu Wang, Chi-Tien Yeh, WJ Hsu, Venny Lin, Kuo-Lung Yen, Wayne Chang attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in Chun-Chung Huang, James Chen, Roven Lee, TH (Elan Legal), Bill Tsai (Elan Legal) anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing Liu, Vincent Tao legal advice re patent and patent analysis Certain Electronic Devices with Multi-Touch Enabled Touchpads and Touchscreens ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-714 10 Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc. Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PVT) Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25 NO. 104 105 AUTHOR Jimmy Wang Roven Lee DATE PRIVILEGE ASSERTED PORTION WITHHELD Rong-Shou Huang, Roven Lee, Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Chi-Tien Yeh, Vincent Tao, Kuoin anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Lung Yen, Wayne Chang (Elan seeking/providing legal advice re patent and patent analysis Legal), Chun-Chung Huang 4/6/2009 AC Entire document Ian Chung Email communications reflecting communications with Eve Chang (Elan Legal) and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent application 5/20/2005 AC/WP Entire document Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent information 4/1/2009 AC/WP Entire document Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent and patent analysis 3/29/2006 AC Entire document RECIPIENT Bill Tsai (Elan Legal), Nick Lin (Elan Legal) COPY RECIPIENT DESCRIPTION 106 Roven Lee Bill Tsai (Elan Legal) 107 Roven Lee Clark Jablon (Outside Counsel ) 108 Chipworks, Inc. Elan Legal Department Document prepared at direction of Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis 7/11/2008 AC/WP Entire document 109 Akin Gump (outside counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Document prepared by Elan's outside counsel in preparation of litigation and/or for purposes of providing legal advice re patent analysis 4/20/2006 AC/WP Entire document 110 Chipworks, Inc. Elan Legal Department Document prepared at direction of Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis 4/1/2009 AC/WP Entire document 111 Chipworks, Inc. Elan Legal Department Document prepared at direction of Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis 4/1/2009 AC/WP Entire document 112 Chipworks, Inc. Elan Legal Department Document prepared at direction of Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis 8/20/2008 AC/WP Entire document 113 Elan Legal Department Document prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation. 10/31/2007 AC/WP Entire document 114 Godwin Chiu; Ting-Hao Yeh; Yung-Lieh Chien; Shih-Chi Lin Document prepared at direction of Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent application 2/12/2003 AC/WP Entire document Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Godwin Chiu Elan Legal Department Certain Electronic Devices with Multi-Touch Enabled Touchpads and Touchscreens ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-714 11 Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc. Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PVT) Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25 AUTHOR RECIPIENT 115 Phoenix Lin Ji-Han Liu (Elan Legal) 117 Phoenix Lin Herod Gong PRIVILEGE ASSERTED PORTION WITHHELD 3/25/2009 WP Entire document Alfie Tsai, Eric Yang, W.F. Lu Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent and patent analysis 1/18/2008 AC Entire document Matt You Email communications containing information prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis 6/17/2008 AC/WP Portion withheld Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis 9/4/2008 AC/WP Entire document Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation 10/3/2008 AC Entire document Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis 12/1/2008 AC Entire document Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis 2/4/2009 AC Entire document 9/5/2008 AC/WP Entire document Elan Legal Department 116 DATE Document prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent information NO. 118 Phoenix Lin Ji-Han Liu (Elan Legal) 119 Phoenix Lin Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 120 Phoenix Lin Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 121 Phoenix Lin Ji-Han Liu (Elan Legal) COPY RECIPIENT W.F. Lu Eric Yang, W.F. Lu, Violet Yeh, Liyu Chan DESCRIPTION 122 W.F. Lu Phoenix Lin, Ji-Han Liu (Elan Legal) Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis 123 Ji-Han Liu (Elan Legal) Ji-Han Liu (Elan Legal), Phoenix Lin Daisuke Shudo, Rich Tan, Ocean Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Chen, Eric Yang, W.F. Lu, Jenny in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Chang seeking/providing legal advice re patent information 7/10/2007 AC Entire document Ocean Chen, W.F. Lu, Phoenix Lin, Lina Kao, Eddie Wei, Jack Chang, Jan Chen, Stober Chen, Rich Tan, Daisuke Shudo Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re OEM agreement 10/16/2007 AC/WP Entire document Eve Chang (Elan Legal), Wayne Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Chang (Elan Legal), Rich Tan, in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of W.F. Lu seeking/providing legal advice re Trademark application 1/12/2009 AC Entire document 124 Ji-Han Liu (Elan Legal) KL Chen 125 Ji-Han Liu (Elan Legal) Eric Yang, Alfie Tsai, Phoenix Lin Certain Electronic Devices with Multi-Touch Enabled Touchpads and Touchscreens ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-714 12 Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc. Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PVT) Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25 NO. 126 127 128 129 130 131 132 AUTHOR RECIPIENT DATE PRIVILEGE ASSERTED PORTION WITHHELD Email communications containing information prepared at the Chia-Miao Wu, Eric Yang, Phoenix direction of Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of Lin, Ocean Chen litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation and settlement negotiation 8/30/2007 AC Entire document COPY RECIPIENT DESCRIPTION W.F. Lu I.H. Yeh W.F. Lu Ji-Han Liu (Elan Legal), Eric Yang, Alfie Tsai, Jacky Wu, Phoenix Lin Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis and patent information 4/16/2008 AC Entire document Ji-Han Liu (Elan Legal), Phoenix Lin, Alfie Tsai Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation and cease and desist letter 4/18/2008 AC Entire document Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) I.H. Yeh, Phoenix Lin Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation and cease and desist letter 6/6/2008 AC Entire document I.H. Yeh, Phoenix Lin Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation and cease and desist letter 6/6/2008 AC Entire document I.H. Yeh, Phoenix Lin Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation and cease and desist letter 6/6/2008 AC Entire document I.H. Yeh, Phoenix Lin Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation and cease and desist letter 6/6/2008 AC Entire document 6/6/2008 AC Entire document W.F. Lu W.F. Lu Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) W.F. Lu W.F. Lu W.F. Lu Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 133 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) W.F. Lu I.H. Yeh, Phoenix Lin Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation and cease and desist letter 134 W.F. Lu Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Ji-Han Liu (Elan Legal) I.H. Yeh, Alfie Tsai, Phoenix Lin Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent information 7/15/2008 AC Entire document Ji-Han Liu (Elan Legal) Liyu Chan, Ocean Chen, W.F. Lu, KL Chen, Phoenix Lin, Lina Kao, Eddie Wei, Jack Chang, Jan Chen, Stober Chen Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re OEM agreement 9/5/2007 AC Entire document 135 Rich Tan Certain Electronic Devices with Multi-Touch Enabled Touchpads and Touchscreens ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-714 13 Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc. Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PVT) Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25 NO. 136 137 138 139 140 AUTHOR RECIPIENT Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) DESCRIPTION DATE PRIVILEGE ASSERTED PORTION WITHHELD Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent and patent litigation 9/18/2008 AC/WP Entire document Email communications with Elan legal department and containing I.H. Yeh, Wayne Chang (Elan attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in Legal), W.F. Lu, Ji-Han Liu (Elan anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing Legal), Nick Lin (Elan Legal) legal advice re patent information 11/29/2008 AC/WP Entire document Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis and patent litigation 12/20/2007 AC/WP Entire document Email communications reflecting communications with Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Eve Chang (Elan Legal) and JH Liu (Elan Legal) and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation 5/30/2008 AC/WP Entire document Email communication with Elan legal department and containing document prepared at direction of Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis 4/22/2008 AC/WP Entire document 5/23/2008 AC/WP Portion withheld Alfie Tsai, Phoenix Lin, W.F. Lu, I.H. Yeh, Jeff Cheng (Elan Legal) Bill Tsai (Elan Legal) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Violet Yeh Alfie Tsai Wen Kai Lee, Samuel Hsu, Alfie Tsai, Jan Chen Phoenix Lin Alfie Tsai COPY RECIPIENT W.F. Lu W.F. Lu, Phoenix Lin Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Phoenix Lin 141 Alfie Tsai Phoenix Lin Email communications containing attachment prepared by or at direction of Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis 142 Liyu Chan Elsa Tsai (Elan Legal), Phoenix Lin Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent and indemnity agreement 10/8/2008 AC Entire document 143 Elsa Tsai (Elan Legal) Phoenix Lin, Liyu Chang Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent and indemnity agreement 10/15/2008 AC Entire document 144 Sophia Wang Eric Yang Email communications reflecting communications with Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation. 7/9/2006 AC Entire Document Certain Electronic Devices with Multi-Touch Enabled Touchpads and Touchscreens ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-714 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 14 Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc. Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PVT) Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25 NO. 145 146 AUTHOR Daisuke Shudo JH Liu (Elan Legal) RECIPIENT Duke Shudo; Ocean Chen; Rich Tan COPY RECIPIENT DESCRIPTION Wayne Chang (Elan Legal); Godwin Chiu; IH Yeh; Allen Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Chang; Denny Huang; Draco Wu; in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Eddie Wei; Eric Yang; Ian Chung; seeking/providing legal advice re patent strategy. Jack Chang; Jason Liu; Karasawa, Fumiaki; Lina Kao; Stober Chen DATE PRIVILEGE ASSERTED PORTION WITHHELD 10/29/2006 AC Entire Document Rich Tan, Daisuke Shudo Jason Liu, Eric Yang, Liyu Chan, Jan Chen, Debby Yu, Stober Chen, Lina Kao, Ocean Chen, Chung-Nan Chang Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachment prepared by Elan legal department in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re draft agreement. 6/14/2007 AC/WP Entire Document Ian Chung, Rich Tan, Karasawa Fumiaki, Denny Huang, WF Lu, Godwin Chiu, Ocean Chen,,IH Yeh, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Jacky Wu, Eric Yang, Alan Tsai, Saturn Tu, Alex Lee, Darren Chen, Miller Wang, Peter He Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachment prepared at direction of Elan legal department in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis. 6/27/2007 AC/WP Entire Document Daisuke Shudo, Rich Tan, Ocean Chen, Eric Yang, WF Lu, JH Liu (Elan Legal) Daisuke Shudo, Rich Tan, Ocean Chen, Eric Yang, WF Lu, Jenny Chang Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent search and analysis. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent search and analysis. 7/9/2007 AC Entire Document 7/9/2007 AC Entire Document Email communications reflecting communication with Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis. 7/30/2007 AC Entire Document 10/15/2007 AC/WP Entire Document 11/26/2007 AC Entire Document 4/16/2008 AC/WP Entire Document 147 Draco Wu Daisuke Shudo 148 JH Liu (Elan Legal) Phoenix Lin 149 JH Liu (Elan Legal) JH Liu (Elan Legal), Phoenix Lin 150 Rich Tan Stober Chen, Eric Yang Ocean Chen Rich Tan, Ocean Chen, WF Lu, Phoenix Lin 151 JH Liu (Elan Legal) Eric Yang 152 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) WF Lu, Phoenix Lin, JH Liu (Elan Legal), Eric Yang, IH Yeh, Bill Tsai (Elan Legal) 153 WF Lu JH Liu (Elan Legal), Eric Yang, Alfie Tsai, Jacky Wu, Phoenix Lin Certain Electronic Devices with Multi-Touch Enabled Touchpads and Touchscreens ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-714 15 Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis. Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis. Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc. Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PVT) Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25 NO. AUTHOR RECIPIENT 154 WF Lu JH Liu (Elan Legal), Eric Yang 155 Draco Wu Godwin Chiu 156 JH Liu (Elan Legal) WF Lu 157 JH Liu (Elan Legal) Eric Yang 158 JH Liu (Elan Legal) Phoenix Lin, WF Lu, Eric Yang, Alfie Tsai, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Bill Tsai (Elan Legal), IH Yeh, Rich Tan, Draco Wu 159 Jenny Chang Eric Yang 160 JH Liu (Elan Legal) Eric Yang 161 Godwin Chiu Daisuke Shudo 162 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Daisuke Shudo 163 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Daisuke Shudo 164 Roven Lee Kelvin Chien, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Kelvin Chien, Jacky Wu, Hsiu-Yun Chen, Bill Tsai (Elan legal), Rich Tan, Daisuke Shudo, Eric Yang, Jacky DATE PRIVILEGE ASSERTED PORTION WITHHELD 7/25/2008 AC Entire Document Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared at the direction of Elan legal department in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis. 1/15/2004 AC/WP Entire Document 1/15/2008 AC/WP Entire Document 5/8/2008 AC Entire Document 5/13/2008 AC/WP Entire Document 6/8/2008 AC Entire Document 6/9/2008 AC/WP Entire Document 4/20/2005 AC Entire Document 3/6/2006 AC/WP Entire Document 6/20/2005 AC/WP Entire Document 2/23/2006 AC/WP Entire Document Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department in anticipation of Eric Yang, Draco Wu litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis. Email communications reflecting communication with JH Liu (Elan Legal) in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent search. Email communications with Elan legal department and containing Draco Wu, WF Lu, Wayne Chang attachments prepared by Elan's outside counsel in anticipation of (Elan Legal), Bill Tsai (Elan Legal)' litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel IH Yeh, Rich Tan, Ian Chung, in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) seeking/providing legal advice re settlement negotiation. Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachment prepared by Elan's outside counsel in anticipation of Draco Wu, Godwin Chiu, IH Yeh litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation. Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachment prepared by Elan legal department in anticipation of IH Yeh, Godwin Chiu litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re settlement negotiation. Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared at the direction of Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis. Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Certain Electronic Devices with Multi-Touch Enabled Touchpads and Touchscreens ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-714 DESCRIPTION Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis. COPY RECIPIENT 16 Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc. Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PVT) Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25 NO. 165 AUTHOR Kelvin Chien 166 Kelvin Chien 167 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 168 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 169 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 170 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 171 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 172 IH Yeh 173 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 174 Godwin Chiu 175 Godwin Chiu RECIPIENT Ian Chung COPY RECIPIENT DESCRIPTION DATE PRIVILEGE ASSERTED PORTION WITHHELD Godwin Chiu Email communications reflecting communication with Eve Chang (Elan Legal) and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent applications. 4/21/2005 AC/WP Entire Document 6/1/2005 WP Entire Document 11/6/2006 AC Entire Document 8/16/2006 AC Entire Document 11/17/2006 AC Entire Document 1/10/2007 AC Entire Document 1/10/2007 AC Entire Document 11/18/2006 AC Entire Document 8/25/2006 AC/WP Entire Document 6/21/2006 AC Entire Document 7/25/2006 AC Entire Document Email communications containing attachment prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or Draco Wu for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent application. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Daisuke Shudo, Ian Chung Godwin Chiu, IH Yeh, Rich Tan in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel IH Yeh, Draco Wu, Ian Chung, Godwin Chiu in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Roven Lee seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel IH Yeh, Godwin Chiu, Daisuke Shudo, Ocean Chen in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Ian Chung, Draco Wu Alex Lee, Jacky Wu, Ocean Chen in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Ian Chung, Draco Wu Alex Lee, Jacky Wu, Ocean Chen in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Godwin Chiu, Daisuke in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Shudo, Godwin Chiu, Ocean Chen seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation. Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department in anticipation of Rich Tan, Daisuke Shudo Godwin Chiu, Ian Chung, IH Yeh litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation. Email communications containing communications with Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation Ian Chung and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis and patent litigation. Email communications containing communications with Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation Stober Chen, Rich Tan, Ocean Chen, Daisuke Shudo and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation. Certain Electronic Devices with Multi-Touch Enabled Touchpads and Touchscreens ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-714 17 Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc. Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PVT) Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25 NO. 176 AUTHOR Godwin Chiu RECIPIENT Godwin Chiu Ian Chung 178 Godwin Chiu Ian Chung 179 Godwin Chiu IH Yeh, Li-Ling Lai 180 Godwin Chiu Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 181 Godwin Chiu Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 182 Godwin Chiu Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Duke Shudo, Godwin Chiu 183 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Godwin Chiu 185 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Daisuke Shudo 186 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Daisuke Shudo Certain Electronic Devices with Multi-Touch Enabled Touchpads and Touchscreens ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-714 PORTION WITHHELD 4/11/2006 AC/WP Entire Document 4/3/2006 WP Entire Document 5/7/2006 AC/WP Entire Document 1/1/2007 AC Entire Document 8/17/2006 AC Entire Document 4/13/2006 AC Entire Document 5/22/2006 AC Entire Document 12/11/2006 AC/WP Entire Document Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis and litigation. 5/6/2006 AC Entire Document 4/27/2006 AC Entire Document 4/19/2006 AC Entire Document Email communications containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re trademark applications. Email communications containing communications with Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re common interest agreement. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Stober Chen, Wayne Chang (Elan in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Legal) seeking/providing legal advice re litigation. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel IH Yeh, Draco Wu, Ian Chung, in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Roven Lee seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel IH Yeh, Daisuke Shudo, Elsa Tsai in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of (Elan Legal), Ian Chung seeking/providing legal advice re settlement negotiation. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel IH Yeh in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent development strategy. Draco Wu 184 PRIVILEGE ASSERTED DESCRIPTION Email communications containing communications with Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) and containing attachments prepared by Elan's outside counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis. Ian Chung 177 DATE Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachment prepared by Elan's outside counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis and litigation. COPY RECIPIENT IH Yeh, Daisuke Shudo Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Ian Chung, Godwin Chiu, IH Yeh, in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Rich Tan seeking/providing legal advice re patent license. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Ian Chung, Godwin Chiu, IH Yeh, in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Rich Tan seeking/providing legal advice re patent license. 18 Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc. Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PVT) Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25 NO. AUTHOR 187 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 188 Roven Lee 189 Violet Yeh 190 JH Liu (Elan Legal) 191 WF Lu 192 WF Lu 193 Charlie Huang 194 JH Liu (Elan Legal) RECIPIENT COPY RECIPIENT DESCRIPTION Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent strategy and license. Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachment prepared at the direction of Elan legal department in Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Ian Chung, Godwin Chiu anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent information. Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Godwin Chiu anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice regarding litigation Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), IH Yeh, WF Lu Godwin Chiu, Ian Chung, Rich Tan in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice, regarding patent application. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel WF Lu, Godwin Chiu, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) IH Yeh in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice, regarding patent analysis. Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in Goodwin Chiu, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) IH Yeh anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice, regarding patent analysis. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Godwin Chiu, IH Yeh, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Eliot Lin, Ian Chung, Eric Chung, in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Roven Lee Maco Tang, Charles Pai seeking/providing legal advice, regarding patent analysis. Duke Shudo, Godwin Chiu IH Yeh DATE PRIVILEGE ASSERTED PORTION WITHHELD 5/21/2006 AC Entire Document 4/14/2006 AC/WP Entire Document 5/29/2008 AC/WP Entire Document 5/28/2008 AC Entire Document 5/13/2008 AC Entire Document 5/13/2008 AC/WP Entire Document 4/27/2008 AC Entire Document Bill Tsai (Elan Legal) IH Yeh, WF Lu, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Godwin Chiu, Eve Chang (Elan Legal) Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice, regarding information on touch pad information. 4/11/2008 AC/WP Entire Document Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent information. 4/2/2009 AC/WP Entire Document Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent information. 1/7/2009 AC/WP Entire Document Email communication containing attachment prepared by Elan IH Yeh, Chile Wang, Joseph legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or Wang, Mite Liang, Brad Rendell for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis. 12/9/2008 WP Portion Withheld 195 Nick Lin (Elan Legal) IH Yeh, Wayne Chang Kuo-Lung Yen, WF Lu, Godwin Chiu, Charles Pai, Jimmy Wang, Rove Lee, Jesse Lin, Vincent Tao, CC Huang, Rong-Shou Huang 196 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) IH Yeh Nick Lin (Elan Legal), Bill Tsai (Elan Legal), Jason Oun, KuoLung Yen, Godwin Chiu 197 Ian Chung Ian Chung, Jesse Huang, Godwin Chiu Certain Electronic Devices with Multi-Touch Enabled Touchpads and Touchscreens ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-714 19 Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc. Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PVT) Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25 DATE PRIVILEGE ASSERTED PORTION WITHHELD 8/27/2008 AC Entire Document 8/4/2008 WP/Common Interest Portion Withheld 7/31/2008 AC Entire Document 7/30/2008 AC Entire Document 7/20/2008 AC Entire Document 7/3/2008 AC Entire Document Annie Jeong Email communications containing information prepared by Elan Peggy Lin, Roven Lee, Dongjuns; legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or Michael Na, Smith Han, Annie for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice, regarding litigation Jeong against Synaptics. 6/12/2008 WP Entire Document Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Godwin Chiu, Dai-Min Liu, WF Lu seeking/providing legal advice, regarding litigation against Synaptics. 5/30/2008 AC Entire Document 5/28/2008 AC Entire Document 5/28/2008 AC/WP Entire Document NO. AUTHOR RECIPIENT 198 IH Yeh WF Lu, Venny Lin, Charles Pai, Godwin Chiu, Steven Tsai, Ian Chung, Kuo-Lung Yen, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 199 Ian Chung 200 IH Yeh 201 IH Yeh 202 IH Yeh 203 IH Yeh 204 Godwin Chiu 205 IH Yeh 206 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 207 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) COPY RECIPIENT DESCRIPTION Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re settlement negotiation. Email communication containing attachment prepared by Elan legal department for third parties having a common legal interest Charles Pai, Godwin Chiu, Eliot Tom Tsai, Yuka Yeh with Elan, containing communications with counsel regarding Lin, CL Fu, Ian Chung patent analysis in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel IH Yeh, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Kuo-Lung Yen, in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Ian Chung, Godwin Chiu, WF Lu seeking/providing legal advice, regarding litigation involving Synaptics. Email communications with Elan legal department in anticipation Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Kuo-Lung Yen, Ian of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice, Chung, Godwin Chiu, WF Lu regarding litigation strategy. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Kuo-Lung Yen, Ian Chung, WF Lu, in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Godwin Chiu, Charles Pai seeking/providing legal advice; regarding litigation/potential litigation against Apple. Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Dai-Min Liu Email communications with Elan legal department in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice regarding patented technology. WF Lu, Godwin Chiu Email communications Elan legal department and/or counsel in IH Yeh, WF Lu, Bill Tsai (Elan Legal), JH Liu (Elan Godwin Chiu, Ian Chung, Rich Tan anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing Legal) legal advice; email communications containing patent analysis. Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice, regarding certain court or administrative order. WF Lu, IH Yeh, Dennis Liu, Godwin Chiu, Alfie Tsai, Eve Chang (Elan Legal), JH Liu (Elan Legal) Certain Electronic Devices with Multi-Touch Enabled Touchpads and Touchscreens ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-714 20 Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc. Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PVT) Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25 NO. AUTHOR RECIPIENT COPY RECIPIENT 208 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) IH Yeh, WF Lu, JH Liu (Elan Legal) Godwin Chiu, Ian Chung 209 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) IH Yeh, WF Lu Godwin Chiu, Ian Chung Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) WF Lu, IH Yeh, Dennis Liu, Godwin Chiu, Alfie Tsai, Eve Chang (Elan Legal), JH Liu (Elan Legal) 210 211 IH Yeh Godwin Chiu, WF Lu, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 212 Roven Lee Godwin Chiu, IH Yeh, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Charlie Huang 213 Godwin Chiu IH Yeh, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Roven Lee, Charlie Huang 214 Godwin Chiu IH Yeh, Ian Chuang, WF Lu, Godwin Chiu 215 Godwin Chiu IH Yeh, Bill Tsai (Elan Legal) 216 Godwin Chiu Smith Han 217 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) IH Yeh 218 JH Liu (Elan Legal) Eric Yang Certain Electronic Devices with Multi-Touch Enabled Touchpads and Touchscreens ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-714 DESCRIPTION Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice, regarding patent application. Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan's outside counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis. Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice, regarding certain court/administrative order. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice, regarding litigation against Synaptics. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Eliot Lin, Ian Chung, Eric Jhuang, in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Maco Tang, Charles Pai seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Eliot Lin, Ian Chung, Eric Jhuang, in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Maco Tang, Charles Pai seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis. Email communications with Elan legal department and containing Wayne Chang (Elan Legal); Bill attachment prepared by Elan legal department in anticipation of Tsai (Elan Legal) litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice; containing patent analysis. WF Lu, Ian Chung, Roven Lee, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice, regarding Elan patent analysis. Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachment prepared by Elan legal department in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice, regarding UI patent. Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachments prepared by Elan legal department and/or counsel in Godwin Chiu, Dai-Min Liu, WF Lu anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice, regarding patent litigation. Wayne Chang (Elan Legal); Bill Tsai (Elan Legal), Annie Jeong, Michael Na Email communications with Elan legal department and containing Draco Wu, WF Lu, Wayne Chang attachment prepared by Elan's outside counsel in anticipation of (Elan Legal), Bill Tsai (Elan Legal) litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis and patent litigation. 21 DATE PRIVILEGE ASSERTED PORTION WITHHELD 5/28/2008 AC Entire Document 5/28/2008 AC/WP Entire Document 5/27/2008 AC/WP Entire Document 5/23/2008 AC Entire Document 4/27/2008 AC Entire Document 4/27/2008 AC Entire Document 4/17/2008 AC/WP Entire Document 4/16/2008 AC/WP Entire Document 4/15/2008 AC/WP Entire Document 6/2/2008 AC/WP Entire Document 6/9/2008 AC/WP Entire Document Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc. Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PVT) Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25 NO. AUTHOR RECIPIENT 219 JH Liu (Elan Legal) Phoenix Lin, WF Lu, Eric Yang, Alfie Tsai, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Bill Tsai (Elan Legal), IH Yeh, Rich Tan 220 JH Liu (Elan Legal) Draco Wu 221 JH Liu (Elan Legal) WF Lu 222 Alfie Tsai Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Phoenix Lin 223 IH Yeh Chin-Chih Wu 224 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) IH Yeh, WF Lu 225 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) IH Yeh, WF Lu 226 Phoenix Lin Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 227 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) IH Yeh, WF Lu 228 WF Lu Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), JH Liu (Elan Legal) 229 Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Jason Liu 230 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) COPY RECIPIENT Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachment prepared by Elan legal department in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis. Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachment prepared by Elan's outside counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis. Email communications with Elan legal department and containing IH Yeh, Alfie Tsai, Phoenix Lin, attachment prepared by Elan legal department in anticipation of Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Rich litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re Tan, Jenny Chang patent analysis. Email communications with Elan legal department and containing attachment prepared at the direction of Elan legal department in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis. Email communication containing attachment prepared by Elan legal department for third parties having a common legal interest Alfie Tsai, WF Lu, Phoenix Lin with Elan, containing communications with counsel regarding patent analysis in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Phoenix Lin, Elsa Tsai (Elan in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Legal) seeking/providing legal advice re patent license. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Phoenix Lin, Elsa Tsai (Elan in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of Legal) seeking/providing legal advice re patent license. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel WF Lu in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel Phoenix Lin in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel IH Yeh, Alfie Tsai, Phoenix Lin in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent analysis. Email communications with Elan legal department and/or counsel in anticipation of litigation and/or for purposes of seeking/providing legal advice re patent litigation. Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Certain Electronic Devices with Multi-Touch Enabled Touchpads and Touchscreens ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-714 DESCRIPTION 22 DATE PRIVILEGE ASSERTED PORTION WITHHELD 5/13/2008 AC/WP Entire Document 9/18/2008 AC/WP Entire Document 7/28/2008 AC/WP Entire Document 4/22/2008 AC/WP Entire Document 2/4/2009 WP/Common Interest Portion Withheld 12/3/2008 AC Entire Document 12/3/2008 AC Entire Document 10/3/2008 AC Entire Document 6/7/2008 AC Entire Document 7/14/2008 AC Entire Document 8/28/2008 AC Entire Document AC/WP/ irrelevant Portion Withheld Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc. Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PVT) Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25 NO. AUTHOR RECIPIENT 231 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) 232 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) 233 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) 234 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 235 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 236 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 237 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 238 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 239 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 240 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 241 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 242 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 243 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 244 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 245 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 246 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 247 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 248 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 249 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 250 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 251 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Certain Electronic Devices with Multi-Touch Enabled Touchpads and Touchscreens ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-714 23 Portion Withheld AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) AC/WP/ irrelevant Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) PORTION WITHHELD Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) PRIVILEGE ASSERTED Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel COPY RECIPIENT AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant DESCRIPTION DATE Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc. Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PVT) Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25 NO. AUTHOR RECIPIENT 252 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 254 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 255 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 256 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 257 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 258 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 259 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 260 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 261 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 262 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 263 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 264 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 265 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 266 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 267 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 268 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 269 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 270 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 271 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 272 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) Certain Electronic Devices with Multi-Touch Enabled Touchpads and Touchscreens ITC Inv. No. 337-TA-714 DESCRIPTION Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Billing statements and invoices prepared by Elan's outside counsel Wayne Chang (Elan Legal) 253 Alston & Bird (Outside Counsel) COPY RECIPIENT 24 DATE PRIVILEGE ASSERTED AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant AC/WP/ irrelevant PORTION WITHHELD Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Portion Withheld Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc. Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PVT)

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?