Elan Microelectronics Corporation v. Apple, Inc.

Filing 408

Declaration of Jane H. Bu in Support of 406 Objection filed byElan Microelectronics Corporation. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B, # 3 Exhibit C, # 4 Exhibit D, # 5 Exhibit E, # 6 Exhibit F, # 7 Exhibit G, # 8 Exhibit H)(Related document(s) 406 ) (Bu, Jane) (Filed on 8/22/2011)

Download PDF
EXHIBIT E Case5:09-cv-01531-RS Document288-5 Filed06/14/11 Page2 of 6 %87=/08! *29904 '875# *06;# +7# &.# *<-30.;# 5X% =FRJ ?SRIF\% =XRJ )+% *()) )(1++ A? ;UJJRGPFWW% @FWMFR 4TTPJ 8PFR E;? CJUYNHJ2 8PFR 4TTPJ DJFQ2 6FTSHHNF% BFHMJP 8PFR AUNYNPJLJ >SLV ! CXQQFUNJV SK 4TTPJ AFWJRWV >FYMFS1 9 \WNYJ WJLFWINSL Y\T NXXZJX WFNXJI NS 2UUQJ"X =TYNTS YT 4TRUJQ% &% 0<7= /<@!D -BB>9 25E9@E 4F??5C<9D 2X \J"[J UTNSYJI TZY# 2UUQJ HTSYJXYJI UWN[NQJLJI XYFYZX TK =W% <NS`X UFYJSY XZRRFWNJX KTW YMJ KNWXY YNRJ TS =F^ ),% 3JKTWJ 6QFS MFX F HMFSHJ YT J[JS WJ[NJ\ YMJ ITHZRJSYX FY NXXZJ# 2UUQJ KNQJI NYX RTYNTS YT HTRUJQ% AJLFWIQJXX TK 2UUQJ"X KFNQZWJ YT RJJY FSI HTSKJW GJKTWJ KNQNSL NYX RTYNTS YT HTRUJQ# \J SJ[JWYMJQJXX WJ[NJ\JI =W% <NS"X UFYJSY XZRRFWNJX WJKJWJSHJI NS ^TZW JRFNQ% CMJ^ FWJ QNXYJI FX 6SYW^ **'# **(# +'' TS 6QFS"X AJ[NXJI ;ZQ^ )'(' @WN[NQJLJ <TL FSI JSYW^ >T ,' TS YMJ AJ[NXJI BJUYJRGJW )'(' @WN[NQJLJ <TL% 2X F WJXZQY TK YMFY WJ[NJ\ \J MF[J IJYJWRNSJI YMFY TSJ TK YMTXJ XZRRFWNJX ITJX STY HTSYFNS FS^ UWN[NQJLJI HTRRZSNHFYNTS# \MNQJ FSTYMJW ) RF^ GJ UWTIZHJI \NYM YMJ UWN[NQJLJI NSKTWRFYNTS WJIFHYJI% DJ FSYNHNUFYJ YMFY \J \NQQ UWTIZHJ YMJXJ XZRRFWNJX YT 2UUQJ YTRTWWT\ FSI WJ[NXJ YMJ HTWWJXUTSINSL UWN[NQJLJ QTL JSYWNJX FHHTWINSLQ^% BNSHJ YMJWJ NX ST QJLFQ FSFQ^XNX NS YMJ UTWYNTSX TK YMJ XZRRFWNJX 6QFS NX UWTIZHNSL# 6QFS MFX STY \FN[JI FS^ HQFNR TK UWN[NQJLJ% '% .>5@ 2AH9C2A<@E BC9D9@E5E<A@D ".>5@ 39G<D98 49BE9?69C & 2C<G<>9;9 /A; .@EC<9D &$(+, 39G<D98 17EA69C ') /A; 9@ECI 0A% *# BNRNQFWQ^# 6QFS NX \NQQNSL YT INXHZXX F UTXXNGQJ WJXTQZYNTS TK TZW INXUZYJ HTSHJWSNSL ITHZRJSYX XMFWJI \NYM 6QFS"X HZXYTRJWX UZWXZFSY YT YMJNW HTRRTS QJLFQ NSYJWJXY% DMNQJ YMJWJ NX F [FQNI HTRRTS QJLFQ NSYJWJXY GJY\JJS 6QFS FSI YMTXJ HZXYTRJWX YMFY 6QFS MFI INXHQTXJI YMJ @T\JW@TNSY XQNIJX# 6QFS \NQQ HTSXNIJW UWTIZHNSL YMJR YT 2UUQJ% 8T\J[JW# 6QFS \NQQ TSQ^ UWTIZHJ YMJ ZSWJIFHYJI ITHZRJSYX TS YMJ HTSINYNTS YMFY 2UUQJ \NQQ STY ZXJ YMJ UWTIZHYNTS YT FWLZJ KTW F GWTFIJW \FN[JW TK UWN[NQJLJ TW \TWP UWTIZHY% DMNQJ \J IT STY GJQNJ[J XZHM F HQFNR \TZQI MF[J FS^ GFXNX# FSI YT JSFGQJ 2UUQJ YT HTSKNWR YMFY KFHY# \J \TZQI HTSXNIJW FQQT\NSL 2UUQJ"X HTZSXJQ YT WJ[NJ\ F WJUWJXJSYFYN[J ZSWJIFHYJI ITHZRJSY NK 2UUQJ \NQQ UWT[NIJ F GNSINSL FLWJJRJSY YMFY NY \NQQ STY FWLZJ YMFY 6QFS MFX \FN[JI FS^ HQFNR TK UWN[NQJLJ G^ UJWRNYNSL YMJ WJ[NJ\# FSI STY YT INXHQTXJ YMJ HTSYJSY TW HMFWFHYJWN_J YMJ HTSYJSY NS FS^ KZYMJW INXUZYJX WJLFWINSL YMJ ITHZRJSYX% @QJFXJ HTSKNWR YMFY 2UUQJ \NQQ FLWJJ YT YMJXJ YJWRX% 9Y NX TZW MTUJ YMFY YMJ UFWYNJX HFS WJFHM FS FLWJJRJSY \NYMTZY KZWYMJW 4TZWY NSYJW[JSYNTS \NYM WJXUJHY YT YMNX NXXZJ% 3JXY# ;FSJ #-,*! 5PFFMCKBRR" 9BRIBM @LBJKRN.MBRIBM#HPFFMCKBRR0UFJK#DNLA $(+.! ?FEMFQEBV" 6SMF $%" &$%% %%.'- 18 %,! 2S" 6BMF % Case5:09-cv-01531-RS Document288-5 Filed06/14/11 Page3 of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ase5:09-cv-01531-RS Document288-5 Filed06/14/11 Page4 of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ase5:09-cv-01531-RS Document288-5 Filed06/14/11 Page5 of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`X UWN[NQJLJ QTLX# TSQ^ JSYW^ STX% )()$)*/# )+'$)+.# )+0$),0# )-($)-)# )-.# )0/# *(+$*))# *+($*+)# *++# *+.# +*(# +**# +-+# ,*-# ,00$-'' TS 6QFS`X AJ[NXJI ;ZQ^ (# )'(' @WN[NQJLJ <TL# JSYW^ STX% +*$++# ('0# (-(# (-+# (/+# FSI )+/ TS 6QFS`X AJ[NXJI BJUYJRGJW (# )'(' @WN[NQJLJ <TL# FSI JSYW^ STX% *# (*# )(# 0,$0-# ('.# ('0# (-'# (-)$(-*# (.-# (/*# )'0# )(/# ))'# )*'$ ).) TS 6QFS`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ase5:09-cv-01531-RS Document288-5 Filed06/14/11 Page6 of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

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?