Elan Microelectronics Corporation v. Apple, Inc.

Filing 408

Declaration of Jane H. Bu in Support of 406 Objection filed byElan Microelectronics Corporation. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A, # 2 Exhibit B, # 3 Exhibit C, # 4 Exhibit D, # 5 Exhibit E, # 6 Exhibit F, # 7 Exhibit G, # 8 Exhibit H)(Related document(s) 406 ) (Bu, Jane) (Filed on 8/22/2011)

EXHIBIT H

Case5:09-cv-01531-RS Document325-3

Filed07/06/11 Page2 of 17
Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25
(2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

New
No.

AUTHOR

DATE

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

PORTION
WITHHELD

12/11/2006

WP

Entire document

Document prepared by Elan for purposes of seeking legal
advice on Synaptics' U.S. patents in anticipation of the
Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

3/9/2005

WP

Entire document

RECIPIENT

DESCRIPTION

1

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

2

Duplicate of other entries on the logs
Document prepared by Elan's outside counsel for
purposes of providing legal advice re Elantech v.
Synaptics litigation.

3

293

Akin Gump (outside counsel)

4

294

Chao-Hui Hsu

5

295

Elan Legal Department

Document prepared by Elan reflecting communication
from U.S. counsel and U.S. counsel work product on
Synaptics' U.S. patents re the Elantech v. Synaptics
litigation.

9/17/2007

WP

Entire document

6

296

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

Document prepared by Elan reflecting communication
from U.S. counsel and U.S. counsel work product re
analysis on Apple's U.S. patents

8/4/2008

WP

Portion withheld

7

297

Yitai Hu (Akin Gump)

Communications with U.S. counsel in anticipation of
litigation for purposes of providing legal advice

6/30/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

3/14/2008

AC

Entire document

3/23/2008

AC

Entire document

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

8

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

9

Elan will produce

10

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

11

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

12

Elan will produce

13

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

14

298

Godwin Chiu

15

16

Charles Pai, Ian Chung

Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking
legal advice re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.
Duplicate of other entries on the logs

299

Godwin Chiu

I.H. Yeh, Ian Chung, Kuo-Lung Yen,
Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking
Chun-An Tan, Charles Pai, Minglegal advice re U.S. patent prosecution.
Shu Wang, Wayne Chang (Elan

1

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Case5:09-cv-01531-RS Document325-3

Filed07/06/11 Page3 of 17
Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25
(2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

New
No.

AUTHOR

RECIPIENT

DESCRIPTION

17

Entire document

12/25/2007

AC

Entire document

3/22/2008

AC

Entire document

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

22

AC

Elan will produce

21

7/31/2007

Irrelevant and none-responsive

20

PORTION
WITHHELD

Elan will produce

19

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

Elan will produce

18

DATE

Irrelevant and none-responsive

23

300

I.H. Yeh

Elan internal communication, reflecting U.S. counsel
Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Godwin
communication and for purpose of seeking legal advice
Chiu, W.F. Lu
re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

24

Irrelevant and none-responsive

25

Elan will produce

26

Elan will produce

27

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

28

301

I.H. Yeh

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Charles Elan internal communication, reflecting U.S. counsel
Pai, Ian Chung, Andy Wu, Godwin communication and for purposes of seeking legal advice
Chiu, W.F. Lu
re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

29

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

30

Elan will produce

31

I.H. Yeh, Ian Chung, Kuo-Lung Yen,
Chun-An Tang, Godwin Chiu,
Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking
Charles Pai, Ming-Shu Wang,
legal advice re U.S. patent prosecution.
Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

302

I.H. Yeh

32

Elan will produce

33

Elan will produce

34

Elan will produce

2

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Case5:09-cv-01531-RS Document325-3

Filed07/06/11 Page4 of 17
Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25
(2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

New
No.

AUTHOR

RECIPIENT

DESCRIPTION

DATE

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

PORTION
WITHHELD

35

303

Wen Kai Lee

Charles Pai, Godwin Chiu, Ian
Chung, Ming-Shu Wang, Maco
Tang

Elan internal communication with attachment(s) prepared
under the instruction of U.S. counsel for purposes of
seeking legal advice re U.S. patent prosecution.

11/28/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

36

304

Wen Kai Lee

Elan internal communication reflecting communication
Maco Tang, Charles Pai, Ming-Shu
with outside counsel for purposes of seeking legal advice
Wang, Ian Chung, Godwin Chiu
re U.S. patent prosecution.

12/1/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

9/10/2007

AC

Entire document

37

38

Irrelevant and none-responsive

305

Chi-Tien Yeh

William Lee, David Lin, Charlie
Huang, Ian Chung

Elan internal communication for purposes seeking legal
advice in anticipation of the Elan v. Apple litigation.

39

Elan will produce

40

Irrelevant and none-responsive

41

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

42

306

Charles Pai

I.H. Yeh, Wayne Chang (Elan
Legal)

Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking
legal advice re Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

12/17/2007

AC

Entire document

43

307

Charles Pai

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), I.H.
Yeh

Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking
legal advice re Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

12/17/2007

AC

Entire document

44

308

Charles Pai

Ian Chung

Elan internal communication with work product prepared
by U.S. counsel for purposes of providing legal advice on
Synaptics' U.S. patents re Elantech v. Synaptics
litigation.

2/27/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

3/21/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

45

46

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

309

Charles Pai

Ian Chung, Wayne Chang (Elan
Legal)

Elan internal communication with work product prepared
by U.S. counsel for purposes of providing legal advice on
Synaptics' U.S. patents re Elantech v. Synaptics
litigation.

3

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Case5:09-cv-01531-RS Document325-3

Filed07/06/11 Page5 of 17
Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25
(2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

47

New
No.

310

AUTHOR

Hank Chen

RECIPIENT

DESCRIPTION

DATE

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

PORTION
WITHHELD

Yong Wang, Rong Sheng Rang

Communication between Elan and Longcheer, a third
party having a common legal interest with Elan, with
attachment reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing
legal advice on Synaptics' U.S. patents, re Elantech v.
Synaptics litigation.

1/31/2008

AC/WP/Common
Interest

Entire document

48

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

49

Elan will produce

50

Elan will produce

51

311

Pei Wang

William Lee, Chi-Tien Yeh

Elan internal communication reflecting the instruction of
U.S. counsel for purposes of providing legal advice in
anticipation of the Elan v. Apple litigation.

9/11/2007

AC

Entire document

52

312

Pei Wang

William Lee

Elan internal communication reflecting the instruction of
U.S. counsel for purposes of providing legal advice in
anticipation of the Elan v. Apple litigation.

9/12/2007

AC

Entire document

8/2/2007

AC

Entire document

53

Elan will produce

54

Elan will produce

55

Elan will produce

56

Elan will produce

57

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

58

Elan will produce

59

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

60

61

313

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

Godwin Chiu, I.H. Yeh, W.F. Lu

Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking
legal advice re Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.
Elan will produce

4

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Case5:09-cv-01531-RS Document325-3

Filed07/06/11 Page6 of 17
Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25
(2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

62

New
No.

314

AUTHOR

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

RECIPIENT

DESCRIPTION

DATE

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

PORTION
WITHHELD

Terial Lu

Communication between Elan and HTC, a third party
having a common legal interest with Elan, with work
product prepared under the instruction of U.S. counsel
and attachment reflecting communication with U.S.
counsel and U.S. counsel work prodouct for purposes of
providing legal advice on Synaptics' U.S. patents, re the
Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

10/4/2007

WP/Common
Interest

Entire document

12/17/2007

AC

Entire document

12/25/2007

AC

Entire document

5/29/2008

AC

Entire document

63

Elan will produce

64

Elan will produce

65

Irrelevant and none-responsive

66

315

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

Charles Pai, I.H. Yeh

67

68

Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking
legal advice re Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.
Duplicate of other entries on the logs

316

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

Elan internal communication reflecting communication
I.H. Yeh, Charles Pai, Ian Chung, from U.S. counsel for purposes of providing legal advice
Andy Wu, Godwin Chiu, W.F. Lu on Synaptics' U.S. patents re the Elantech v. Synaptics
litigation.

69

Elan will produce

70

Elan will produce

71

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

72

Elan will produce

73

Irrelevant and none-responsive

74

Elan will produce

75

Irrelevant and none-responsive

76

317

Ji-Han Liu (Elan Legal)

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), I.H.
Yeh, W.F. Lu

Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking
legal advice re U.S. patent prosecution.

77

Elan will produce

78

Elan will produce

79

Elan will produce

5

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Case5:09-cv-01531-RS Document325-3

Filed07/06/11 Page7 of 17
Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25
(2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

New
No.

AUTHOR

RECIPIENT

DESCRIPTION

80

Elan will produce

83

Elan will produce

84

Elan will produce

85

Elan will produce

86

Elan will produce

87

Elan will produce

88

Irrelevant and none-responsive

89

Elan will produce

90

Elan will produce

91

Elan will produce

92

Irrelevant and none-responsive

93

Elan will produce

94

PORTION
WITHHELD

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

82

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

Elan will produce

81

DATE

Produced as ELN1312136-ELN1312137

95

318

Akin Gump (outside counsel)

Document prepared by Elan's outside counsel for
purposes of providing legal advice re patent litigation

4/20/2006

AC/WP

Entire document

96

319

Akin Gump (outside counsel)

Document prepared by Elan's outside counsel in
anticipation of litigation purposes of providing legal
advice re patent litigation

12/11/2006

AC/WP

Entire document

97

320

Charles Pai

Nick Lin (Elan Legal), Wayne
Chang (Elan Legal), I.H. Yeh

Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking
legal advice re U.S. patent prosecution.

2/13/2009

AC/WP

Entire document

98

321

Charles Pai

Ming-Shu Wang , Roven Lee,
WenJun Chen, Maco Tang, ChiTien Yeh

Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking
legal advice re Elan v. Apple litigation.

3/2/2009

AC/WP

Entire document

99

322

Richard Chae (Akin Gump)

Roven Lee, Wayne Chang (Elan
Legal)

Email communications with Elan outside US counsel in
anticipation of litigation for purposes of sproviding legal
advice re patent litigation

9/19/2008

AC

Entire document

100

Elan will produce

6

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Case5:09-cv-01531-RS Document325-3

Filed07/06/11 Page8 of 17
Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25
(2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

New
No.

AUTHOR

DATE

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

PORTION
WITHHELD

Elan internal communication with attachment(s) prepared
by Elan under the instruction of U.S. counsel for
purposes of seeking legal advice re Elan v. Apple
litigation.

4/6/2009

AC/WP

Entire document

Elan internal communication under the instruction of U.S.
Bill Tsai (Elan Legal), Nick Lin (Elan
counsel for purposes of seeking legal advice re Elan v.
Legal)
Apple litigation.

4/6/2009

AC

Entire document

RECIPIENT

DESCRIPTION

101

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

102

Irrelevant and privileged.
Ming-Shu Wang, Chi-Tien Yeh, WJ
Hsu, Venny Lin, Chun-Chung
Huang, James Chen, Roven Lee,
TH Liu, Vincent Tao

103

323

Nick Lin (Elan Legal)

104

324

Jimmy Wang

105

325

Roven Lee

Ian Chung

Elan internal communication with attachment(s) prepared
under the instruction of U.S. counsel for purposes of
seeking legal advice re U.S. patent prosecution.

5/20/2005

AC/WP

Entire document

106

326

Roven Lee

Bill Tsai (Elan Legal)

Elan internal communication with attachment(s) prepared
under the instruction of U.S. counsel and to provide to
U.S. counsel re Elan v. Apple litigation.

4/1/2009

AC/WP

Entire document

107

327

Roven Lee

Clark Jablon (Outside Counsel )

Email communications with Elan outside counsel in
anticipation of litigation for purposes of seeking legal
advice re patent litigation

3/29/2006

AC

Entire document

4/20/2006

AC/WP

Entire document

2/12/2003

WP

Entire document

108

109

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

328

Akin Gump (outside counsel)

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

Email attaching documents prepared by Elan's outside
counsel in preparation of litigation and for purposes of
providing legal advice re Synaptics litigation

110

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

111

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

112

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

113

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

114

329

Godwin Chiu; Ting-Hao Yeh;
Yung-Lieh Chien; Shih-Chi Lin

Elan Legal Department

Document prepared under the instruction of U.S. counsel
re U.S. patent prosecution.

7

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Case5:09-cv-01531-RS Document325-3

Filed07/06/11 Page9 of 17
Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25
(2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

New
No.

AUTHOR

115

330

Elan Legal Department

RECIPIENT

DESCRIPTION
Document prepared by Elan, under U.S. counsel
direction, in anticipation of the Elan v. Apple litigation.

116

PORTION
WITHHELD

3/25/2009

WP

Entire document

10/3/2008

AC

Entire document

8/30/2007

AC

Entire document

Elan will produce

118

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

Elan will produce

117

DATE

Elan will produce

119

331

Phoenix Lin

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

Elan internal communication reflecting the instruction of
U.S. counsel re Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

120

Elan will produce

121

Elan will produce

122

Elan will produce

123

Elan will produce

124

Elan will produce

125

Irrelevant and none-responsive

126

332

W.F. Lu

I.H. Yeh

Elan internal communication, reflecting U.S. counsel
communication and for purposes of seeking legal advice
re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

127

Elan will produce

128

Elan will produce

129

Elan will produce

130

333

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

W.F. Lu

Elan internal communication reflecting communication
with U.S. counsel with work product prepared by U.S.
counsel for purposes of providing legal advice re the
Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

6/6/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

131

334

W.F. Lu

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

Elan internal communication reflecting communication
with U.S. counsel for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

6/6/2008

AC

Entire document

132

335

W.F. Lu

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

Elan internal communication reflecting communication
with U.S. counsel for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

6/6/2008

AC

Entire document

8

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Case5:09-cv-01531-RS Document325-3

Filed07/06/11 Page10 of 17
Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25
(2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

New
No.

AUTHOR

RECIPIENT

133

336

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

W.F. Lu

DESCRIPTION
Elan internal communication reflecting communication
with U.S. counsel for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

DATE

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

PORTION
WITHHELD

6/6/2008

AC

Entire document

134

Elan will produce

135

Elan will produce

136

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

137

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

138

337

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

Phoenix Lin

Elan internal communication with attachment(s) reflecting
communication with U.S. counsel and U.S. counsel work
product for purposes of providing legal advice on
Synaptics' U.S. patents re the Elantech v. Synaptics
litigation.

12/20/2007

AC/WP

Entire document

139

338

Violet Yeh

Alfie Tsai

Elan internal communication with work product prepared
by U.S. counsel for purposes of providing legal advice re
the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

5/30/2008

AC/WP

Entire document

5/23/2008

AC/WP

Portion withheld

140

141

Elan will produce

339

Alfie Tsai

Phoenix Lin

Document reflecting communication with U.S. counsel
and U.S. counsel work product for purposes of providing
legal advice on Synaptics' U.S. patents re the Elantech v.
Synaptics litigation.

142

Elan will produce

143

Elan will produce

144

Elan will produce

145

Elan will produce

146

Elan will produce

147

Irrelevant and none-responsive

148

Elan will produce

9

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Case5:09-cv-01531-RS Document325-3

Filed07/06/11 Page11 of 17
Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25
(2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

New
No.

AUTHOR

RECIPIENT

DESCRIPTION

149

PORTION
WITHHELD

Irrelevant and none-responsive

151

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

Elan will produce

150

DATE

Irrelevant and none-responsive

152

340

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

WF Lu, Phoenix Lin, JH Liu (Elan
Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking
Legal), Eric Yang, IH Yeh, Bill Tsai
legal advice in anticipation of the Elan v. Apple litigation.
(Elan Legal)

11/26/2007

AC

Entire Document

153

341

WF Lu

Elan internal communication with attachment prepared by
JH Liu (Elan Legal), Eric Yang, Alfie
Elan for purposes of seeking legal advice in anticipation
Tsai, Jacky Wu, Phoenix Lin
of the Elan v. Apple litigation.

4/16/2008

AC/WP

Entire Document

154

Elan will produce

155

342

Draco Wu

Godwin Chiu

Elan internal communication with attachment prepared by
Elan for purposes of seeking legal advice on Synaptics'
U.S. patents in anticipation of the Elantech v. Synaptics
litigation.

1/15/2004

AC/WP

Entire Document

156

343

JH Liu (Elan Legal)

WF Lu

Elan internal communication with attachment prepared by
Elan for purposes of seeking legal advice on Synaptics'
U.S. patents re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

1/15/2008

AC/WP

Entire Document

157

Irrelevant and none-responsive

158

Irrelevant and none-responsive

159

Elan will produce

160

344

JH Liu (Elan Legal)

Eric Yang

Elan internal communication attaching work product
prepared by U.S. counsel for purposes of providing legal
advice in anticipation of the Elan v. Apple litigation.

6/9/2008

AC/WP

Entire Document

161

345

Godwin Chiu

Daisuke Shudo

Elan internal communication for purpose of seeking legal
advice in anticipation of the Elantech v. Synaptics
litigation.

4/20/2005

AC

Entire Document

162

346

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

Daisuke Shudo

Elan internal communication attaching work product
prepared by U.S. counsel for purposes of providing legal
advice re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

3/6/2006

AC/WP

Entire Document

10

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Case5:09-cv-01531-RS Document325-3

Filed07/06/11 Page12 of 17
Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25
(2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

New
No.

AUTHOR

RECIPIENT

DESCRIPTION

DATE

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

PORTION
WITHHELD

163

347

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

Daisuke Shudo

Elan internal communication with attachment(s) prepared
under the instruction of U.S. counsel re the Elantech v.
Synaptics litigation.

6/20/2005

AC/WP

Entire Document

164

348

Roven Lee

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

2/23/2006

AC/WP

Entire Document

349

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

Daisuke Shudo, Ian Chung

11/6/2006

AC

Entire Document

1/10/2007

AC

Entire Document

8/25/2006

AC/WP

Entire Document

6/21/2006

AC

Entire Document

165
166

167

Elan internal communication with work product prepared
under the instruction of U.S. counsel for purposes of
providing legal advice re the Elantech v. Synaptics
litigation.
Elan will produce
Elan will produce
Elan internal communication reflecting communication
with U.S. counsel for purposes of providing legal advice
re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

168

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

169

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

170

350

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

Ian Chung, Draco Wu

Elan internal communication for the purpose of seeking
legal advice, under U.S. counsel instruction, in
anticipation of the Elan v. Apple litigation.

171

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

172

Duplicate of other entries on the logs
Elan internal communication reflecting work product
prepared by U.S. counsel for purposes of providing legal
advice re Elan patents
Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking
legal advice on Synaptics' U.S. patents re the Elantech v.
Synaptics litigation.

173

351

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

Rich Tan, Daisuke Shudo

174

352

Godwin Chiu

Ian Chung

175

353

Godwin Chiu

Stober Chen, Rich Tan, Ocean
Chen, Daisuke Shudo

Elan internal communication re the Elantech v. Synaptics
litigation.

7/25/2006

AC

Entire Document

176

354

Godwin Chiu

Ian Chung

Elan internal communication with work product prepared
by U.S. counsel for purposes of providing legal advice re
U.S. re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

4/11/2006

AC/WP

Entire Document

177

Elan will produce

11

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Case5:09-cv-01531-RS Document325-3

Filed07/06/11 Page13 of 17
Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25
(2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

178

New
No.

355

AUTHOR

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

RECIPIENT

DESCRIPTION

DATE

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

PORTION
WITHHELD

Ares Yang (Acer), Louise Tsai
(Compal)

Communication between Elan, Compal and Acer, third
parties having a common legal interest with Elan,
attaching common intrerest agreement, prepared by U.S.
counsel for purposes of providing legal advice on
Synaptics' U.S. patent, re the Elantech v. Synaptics
litigation.

5/7/2006

WP/Common
Interest

Entire document

179

Elan will produce

180

356

Godwin Chiu

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

Elan internal communication, for the purpose of seeking
legal advoce re Elan patent

8/17/2006

AC

Entire Document

181

357

Godwin Chiu

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

Elan internal communication reflecting communication
with U.S. counsel re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

4/13/2006

AC

Entire Document

12/11/2006

AC/WP

Entire Document

4/27/2006

AC

Entire Document

4/19/2006

AC

Entire Document

5/29/2008

AC/WP

Entire Document

5/28/2008

AC

Entire Document

182

183

Elan will produce

358

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

Draco Wu

184

Elan will produce

185

359

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

Daisuke Shudo

186

360

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

Daisuke Shudo

189

361

Violet Yeh

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

190

362

JH Liu (Elan Legal)

187
188

191

Elan internal communication with work product prepared
by U.S. counsel for purposes of providing legal advice re
the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

Elan internal communication, reflecting Elan outside
counsel communication, re the Elantech v. Synaptics
litigation.
Elan internal communication, reflecting Elan outside
counsel communication, re the Elantech v. Synaptics
litigation.
Elan will produce
Irrelevant and none-responsive
Elan internal communication with work product prepared
by U.S. counsel for purposes of providing legal advice re
the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), IH Yeh, Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking
WF Lu
legal advice re U.S. patent prosecution.
Irrelevant and none-responsive

12

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Case5:09-cv-01531-RS Document325-3

Filed07/06/11 Page14 of 17
Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25
(2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

New
No.

AUTHOR

RECIPIENT

DESCRIPTION

192

PORTION
WITHHELD

Irrelevant and none-responsive

194
195
196

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

Irrelevant and none-responsive

193

DATE

Elan will produce
Elan will produce
Elan will produce

197

363

Ian Chung

Communication between Elan and Elan agent Sinbon, a
Ian Chung, Jesse Huang, Godwin third party having a common legal interest with Elan, with
Chiu
document reflecting U.S. counsel communication and
work product

12/9/2008

Portion Withheld
AC/WP/Common
from ELN1023928
Interest
to ELN1023960

198

Elan will produce

199

364

Ian Chung

Elan communication with Garmin, a third party with
common legal interest, attaching document prepared by
Elan for its customers with common legal interest,
reflecting U.S. counsel communication and work product

8/4/2008

AC/WP

Portion Withheld
from ELN1036236
to ELN1036265

200

365

IH Yeh

Elan internal communication, for purpose of seeking legal
advice, re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

7/31/2008

AC

Entire Document

201

366

IH Yeh

Elan internal communication, for purpose of seeking legal
advice, re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

7/30/2008

AC

Entire Document

7/3/2008

AC

Entire Document

5/28/2008

AC

Entire Document

5/28/2008

AC

Entire Document

Tom Tsai (Garmin), Yuka Yeh

IH Yeh, Wayne Chang (Elan Legal),
Kuo-Lung Yen, Ian Chung, Godwin
Chiu, WF Lu
Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), KuoLung Yen, Ian Chung, Godwin Chiu,
WF Lu

202

203

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

367

IH Yeh

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal), Dai-Min Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking
Liu
legal advice in anticipation of the Elan v. Apple litigation.

204

Elan will produce

205
206

Elan will produce
368

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

IH Yeh, WF Lu, Bill Tsai (Elan
Legal), JH Liu (Elan Legal)

207
208

Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking
legal advice re U.S. patent prosecution.
Duplicate of other entries on the logs

369

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

IH Yeh, WF Lu, JH Liu (Elan Legal)

Elan internal communication for purposes of seeking
legal advice re U.S. patent prosecution.

13

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Case5:09-cv-01531-RS Document325-3

Filed07/06/11 Page15 of 17
Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25
(2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

New
No.

AUTHOR

RECIPIENT

DESCRIPTION

DATE

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

PORTION
WITHHELD

209

370

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

IH Yeh, WF Lu

Elan internal communication with work product prepared
by U.S. counsel for purposes of providing advice re the
Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

5/28/2008

AC/WP

Entire Document

210

371

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

WF Lu, IH Yeh, Dennis Liu, Godwin Elan internal communication with work product prepared
Chiu, Alfie Tsai, Eve Chang (Elan by U.S. counsel for purposes of providing advice re the
Legal), JH Liu (Elan Legal)
Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

5/27/2008

AC/WP

Entire Document

211

372

IH Yeh

5/23/2008

AC

Entire Document

5/13/2008

AC/WP

Entire Document

4/22/2008

AC/WP

Entire Document

Godwin Chiu, WF Lu, Wayne
Chang (Elan Legal)

Elan internal communication, for purpose of seeking legal
advice re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

212

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

213

Irrelevant and none-responsive

214

Elan will produce

215

Elan will produce

216

Elan will produce

217

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

218

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

219

Elan internal communication with attachment(s) prepared
by Elan for purposes of seeking legal advice in
anticipation of the Elan v. Apple litigation.

373

220

Elan will produce

221

Elan will produce

222

374

Alfie Tsai

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal),
Phoenix Lin

Elan internal communication with attachment(s) prepared
by Elan for purposes of seeking legal advice in
anticipation of the Elan v. Apple litigation.

14

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Case5:09-cv-01531-RS Document325-3

Filed07/06/11 Page16 of 17
Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25
(2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.

223

New
No.

375

AUTHOR

IH Yeh

RECIPIENT

Chin-Chih Wu (Acer)

DESCRIPTION
Elan communication to Acer, a thrid party with common
legal interesst,with attachment prepared by Elan and its
outside counsel for purposes of seeking legal advice re
the Elan v. Apple litigation.

224

2/4/2009

WP/Common
Interest

Portion Withheld
from ELN1036700
to
ELN1036706

6/7/2008

AC

Entire Document

8/28/2008

AC

Entire Document

Irrelevant and none-responsive

226

PORTION
WITHHELD

Irrelevant and none-responsive

225

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

DATE

Duplicate of other entries on the logs

227

376

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

IH Yeh, WF Lu

228
229

Elan internal communication reflecting communication
with U.S. counsel with work product prepared by U.S.
counsel for purposes of providing legal advice re the
Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.
Elan will produce

377

Wayne Chang (Elan Legal)

Jason Liu

Elan internal communication reflecting the instruction of
U.S. counsel re the Elantech v. Synaptics litigation.

230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250

Produced as ELN1040103-ELN1040497
15

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)

Case5:09-cv-01531-RS Document325-3

Filed07/06/11 Page17 of 17
Elan's Privilege Log 2010-10-25
(2nd Revision)
(Revised on July 1, 2011)

NO.
251

New
No.

AUTHOR

RECIPIENT

DESCRIPTION
Produced as ELN1040103-ELN1040497

DATE

PRIVILEGE
ASSERTED

PORTION
WITHHELD

252
253
254
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268
269
270
271
272

16

Elan Microelectronics Corp. v. Apple Inc.
Case No. C-09-01531 RS (PSG)