DFSB Kollective Co. Ltd. et al v. Kuoch

Filing 16

CONSENT DECREE AND PERMANENT INJUNCTION (approving 15 ). Signed by Judge Jeremy Fogel on 10/7/2011. (jflc2, COURT STAFF) (Filed on 10/7/2011)

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9

J. Andrew Coombs (SBN 123881)
[e-mail]
Nicole L. Drey (SBN 250235)
[e-mail]
J. Andrew Coombs, A Prof. Corp.
517 East Wilson Avenue, Suite 202
Glendale, California 91206
Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: [phone]
Attorneys for Plaintiffs DFSB
Kollective Co. Ltd., in conjunction with
Jungle Entertainment, Woolim
Entertainment, Aftermoon Music
Entertainment, Inc., BooHwal
Entertainment, and Paragon Music Corp.

12

Phillip Kuoch, an individual and d/b/a
kaboomza.com and kaboomza.blogspot.com
[e-mail]
75 Henderson Road
Keysborough 3173
Melbourne Australia

13

Defendant, in pro se

10
11

14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA (SAN JOSE)
)
DFSB Kollective Co. Ltd., Jungle Entertainment, )
Woolim Entertainment, Aftermoon Music
)
Entertainment, Inc., BooHwal Entertainment,
)
and Paragon Music Corp.,
)
)
Plaintiffs,
)
)
v.
)
)
Phillip Kuoch, an individual and d/b/a
)
kaboomza.com and kaboomza.blogspot.com, and )
Does 1 through 10, inclusive,
)
)
Defendants.
)
)

Case No. CV11-1047 JF
[PROPOSED] CONSENT DECREE AND
PERMANENT INJUNCTION

25
26

The Court, having read and considered the Joint Stipulation for Entry of Consent Decree and

27

Permanent Injunction that has been executed by Plaintiffs DFSB Kollective Co. Ltd., in conjunction

28

with Jungle Entertainment, Woolim Entertainment, Aftermoon Music Entertainment, Inc., BooHwal
DFSB, et al. v. Kuoch: [Proposed] Consent Decree

-1-

1

Entertainment, and Paragon Music Corp. (collectively the “DFSB Plaintiffs”) and Defendant Phillip

2

Kuoch, an individual and d/b/a kaboomza.com and kaboomza.blogspot.com (“Defendant”), in this
3

action, and good cause appearing therefore, hereby:
4

ORDERS that based on the Parties’ stipulation and only as to Defendant, his successors,
5

heirs, and assignees, this Injunction shall be and is hereby entered in the within action as follows:
6

1)

This Court has jurisdiction over the parties to this action and over the subject matter hereof

7

pursuant to 17 U.S.C. § 101 et seq., and 28 U.S.C. §§ 1331 and 1338. Service of process was
8

properly made against Defendant.
9

2)

The DFSB Plaintiffs are the respective owners of all rights in and to certain copyright

10

registrations, including, but not limited to, the copyrights which are the subject of the registrations
11

listed in Exhibit “A” attached hereto and incorporated herein by this reference (collectively referred
12

to herein as the “DFSB Plaintiffs’ Works”).
13

3)

The DFSB Plaintiffs have alleged that Defendant has made unauthorized uses of the DFSB

14

Plaintiffs’ Works and/or materially contributed to the infringement of the DFSB Plaintiffs’ Works by
15

others and/or induced the infringement of the DFSB Plaintiffs’ Works by others.
16

4)

The Defendant and his agents, servants, employees and all persons in active concert and

17

participation with him who receive actual notice of the injunction are hereby restrained and enjoined
18

from:
19

a)

Infringing the DFSB Plaintiffs’ Works, either directly or secondarily, in any manner,

20

including generally;
21

b)

Copying, reproducing, distributing, advertising, publicly performing, and/or publicly

22

displaying the DFSB Plaintiffs’ Works, without authorization from the DFSB Plaintiffs,
23

specifically including, but not limited to:
24

i)

Posting images of any album cover art from any of the DFSB Plaintiffs’

25

Works on any website(s), forum(s), blog(s), social networking platform(s),
26

video site(s), online storage locker(s), or any other online platforms;
27
28
DFSB, et al. v. Kuoch: [Proposed] Consent Decree

-2-

1

ii)

Uploading any of the DFSB Plaintiffs’ Works to any website(s), forum(s),

2

blog(s), social networking platform(s), video site(s), online storage locker(s),
3

or any other online platforms;
4

iii)

Streaming any of the DFSB Plaintiffs’ Works on any website(s), forum(s),

5

blog(s), social networking platform(s), video site(s), online storage locker(s),
6

or any other online platforms; and
7

iv)

Offering for download any of the DFSB Plaintiffs’ Works on any website(s),

8

forum(s), blog(s), social networking platform(s), video site(s), online storage
9

locker(s), or any other online platforms;
10

c)

Contributing to, assisting, aiding, abetting, or facilitating the copying, reproduction,

11

distribution, advertisement, public performance, and/or public display of the DFSB
12

Plaintiffs’ Works, specifically including, but not limited to:
13

i)

Compiling, organizing, and/or posting links to any website(s), forum(s),

14

blog(s), social networking platform(s), video site(s), online storage locker(s),
15

or any other online platforms which offer unauthorized copies of the DFSB
16

Plaintiffs’ Works for download;
17

ii)

Compiling, organizing, and/or posting links to any website(s), forum(s),

18

blog(s), social networking platform(s), video site(s), online storage locker(s),
19

or any other online platforms which offer unauthorized copies of the DFSB
20

Plaintiffs’ Works for streaming; and
21

iii)

Providing instructions and/or answering questions on how to find, download,

22

and/or stream unauthorized copies of the DFSB Plaintiffs’ Works;
23

d)

Inducing the copying, reproduction, distribution, advertisement, public performance,

24

and/or public display of the DFSB Plaintiffs’ Works, specifically including, but not
25

limited to:
26

i)

Compiling, organizing, and/or posting links to any website(s), forum(s),

27

blog(s), social networking platform(s), video site(s), online storage locker(s),
28
DFSB, et al. v. Kuoch: [Proposed] Consent Decree

-3-

1

or any other online platforms which offer unauthorized copies of the DFSB

2

Plaintiffs’ Works for download;
3

ii)

Compiling, organizing, and/or posting links to any website(s), forum(s),

4

blog(s), social networking platform(s), video site(s), online storage locker(s),
5

or any other online platforms which offer unauthorized copies of the DFSB
6

Plaintiffs’ Works for streaming;
7

iii)

Providing instructions and/or answering questions on how to find, download,

8

and/or stream unauthorized copies of the DFSB Plaintiffs’ Works; and
9

iv)

Encouraging, enticing, persuading, and/or intending any third-parties to

10

engage in any form of infringement of the DFSB Plaintiffs’ Works, including
11

those other acts proscribed herein.
12

5)

Each side shall bear its own fees and costs of suit.

6)

Except as provided herein, all claims alleged in the Complaint are dismissed with prejudice.

7)

This Injunction shall be deemed to have been served upon Defendant at the time of its

13
14
15

execution by the Court.
16

8)

The Court finds there is no just reason for delay in entering this Injunction and, pursuant to

17

Rule 54(a) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, the Court directs immediate entry of this
18

Injunction against Defendant.
19

9)

The Court shall retain jurisdiction of this action to entertain such further proceedings and to

20

enter such further orders as may be necessary or appropriate to implement and enforce the provisions
21

of this Injunction.
22

10)

The above-captioned action, shall, upon filing by the DFSB Plaintiffs of the Settlement

23

Agreement, Stipulation for Entry of Judgment and [Proposed] Final Judgment, and requesting entry
24

of judgment against Defendants, be reopened should Defendant default under the terms of the
25

Settlement Agreement.
26

11)

This Court shall retain jurisdiction over Defendants for the purpose of making further orders

27

necessary or proper for the construction or modification of this consent decree and judgment; the
28
DFSB, et al. v. Kuoch: [Proposed] Consent Decree

-4-

/s/ Nicole L. Drey

1

EXHIBIT A

2

THE DFSB PLAINTIFFS’ WORKS

3

5

BooHwal

6

BooHwal

Track
[Seug Gak Eeh Na]
Remembering
[Tto Da Si Sa Rang
Eeh] Again Love Again

BooHwal

OZ

BooHwal

BooHwal

[Uh Jae] Yesterday
[Seul Peun Sa Seum]
Sad Dear
[Heuk Baek Young
Hwah] Black & White
Movie

Dok2

14

Dok2

15

Dok2

16

Dok2

4

Performer

7
8
9
10

BooHwal

11

Album
25th Anniversary:
Retrospect (Vol.1)
25th Anniversary:
Retrospect (Vol.1)
25th Anniversary:
Retrospect (Vol.1)
25th Anniversary:
Retrospect (Vol.1)
25th Anniversary:
Retrospect (Vol.1)

Registration
Number
PA 1-673-477
PA 1-673-477
PA 1-673-477
PA 1-673-477
PA 1-673-477

25th Anniversary:
Retrospect (Vol.1)

PA 1-673-477

I'm Back

Thunderground

PA 1-673-478

You Don't Know
It's Me (feat. Joo
Young)

Thunderground

PA 1-673-478

Thunderground

PA 1-673-478

Thunderground

PA 1-673-478

Thunderground

PA 1-673-478

Thunderground

PA 1-673-478

12
13

21

Dok2

Beyond
[Hoom Chuh] Rob It
(feat. Double K)
64% (feat. Beatbox
DG)
[Ma Ji Mak] Last (feat.
Mr.Gordo)
It's Me (feat. Epik High
& MYK)

22

Epik High

[Suh Rap] Shelves

Epilogue

PA 1-673-425

23

Epik High

Epilogue

PA 1-673-425

Epik High

Run
[Ba Bo] Fool (feat.
Bumkey)

Epilogue

PA 1-673-425

Epik High

Wordkill

Epilogue

PA 1-673-425

27

Epik High

Epilogue

PA 1-673-425

28

Epik High

Blossom
[Bi Neul] Skin (feat.
Yankie)

Epilogue

PA 1-673-425

17

Dok2

18

Dok2
19
20

24

Dok2

Thunderground

PA 1-673-478

Thunderground

PA 1-673-478

25
26

DFSB, et al. v. Kuoch: [Proposed] Consent Decree

-6-

Copyright
Claimant
BooHwal
Entertainment
BooHwal
Entertainment
BooHwal
Entertainment
BooHwal
Entertainment
BooHwal
Entertainment
BooHwal
Entertainment
Woolim
Entertainment
Woolim
Entertainment
Woolim
Entertainment
Woolim
Entertainment
Woolim
Entertainment
Woolim
Entertainment
Woolim
Entertainment
Woolim
Entertainment
Woolim
Entertainment
Woolim
Entertainment
Woolim
Entertainment
Woolim
Entertainment
Woolim
Entertainment
Woolim
Entertainment

1
2

Epik High

[Jap Eum] Distorted

Epilogue

PA 1-673-425

3

Epik High

Coffee (feat. SungAh)

Epilogue

PA 1-673-425

4

Epik High

Over

Epilogue

PA 1-673-425

5

Epik High

[Soop] Roots

Epilogue

PA 1-673-425

House Rulez Happy 2010

Winter 2010

PA 1-673-475

House Rulez Dee
[Gyuh Oor Eeh Ya Gi]
House Rulez Winter Story
[Gyuh Oor Eeh Ya Gi]
Winter Story (Sax
House Rulez Version)

Winter 2010

PA 1-673-475

Winter 2010

PA 1-673-475

Winter 2010

PA 1-673-475

6
7
8
9

Woolim
Entertainment
Woolim
Entertainment
Woolim
Entertainment
Woolim
Entertainment
Aftermoon Music
Entertainment Inc.
Aftermoon Music
Entertainment Inc.
Aftermoon Music
Entertainment Inc.

Winter 2010

PA 1-673-475

13

House Rulez Sherbet
No.5 (Rap feat.Eun
J.ae
JiWon)

Sentimental

PA 1-674-065

14

J.ae

Sentimental

PA 1-674-065

Aftermoon Music
Entertainment Inc.
Aftermoon Music
Entertainment Inc.
Paragon Music
Corporation
Paragon Music
Corporation

PA 1-674-065

Paragon Music
Corporation

PA 1-674-065

Paragon Music
Corporation

10
11
12

15
16

J.ae

17
18

J.ae

19
20

J.ae

21

J.ae

[Gnh Jit Mar] Lie
ShaReuReu (I Wanna
be Your Love) (feat.
Jung Yup)
[Kkeut Eul Mar Har
Soon Up Uh Do] Can't
Say it's Over (feat.
MBLAQ 'Zio')
Angel's Disguise (From
Coreana Cosmetics
OVLEAU TV
Commercial)
[Nur Sa Rang Het Eul
Kka?] Did I Love You?

Sentimental

Sentimental

Sentimental

PA 1-674-065

Sentimental

PA 1-674-065

Sentimental

PA 1-674-065

Hexagonal

PA 1-673-512

Paragon Music
Corporation
Paragon Music
Corporation
Paragon Music
Corporation
Jungle
Entertainment

Hexagonal

PA 1-673-512

Jungle
Entertainment

Hexagonal

PA 1-673-512

Jungle
Entertainment

22
23

J.ae

24

LeeSSang

25
26

LeeSSang

27
28

LeeSSang

Love
Intro (Hexagonal) (feat.
Enzo.B)
[Woo Ri Ji Geum Man
Na) Let's Meet Now
(feat. Chang Kiha &
The Faces)
[HaeUhJiJiMotHaNeun
YuhJa, Ttuh
NaGaJiMotHaNeunNa

DFSB, et al. v. Kuoch: [Proposed] Consent Decree

-7-

1
2
3

LeeSSang
4
5

LeeSSang

6
7

LeeSSang

mJa) Can't Breakup
Girl, Can't Breakaway
Boy (feat. Jung In)
Carousel (feat. Lee
Juk)
[Byun Hae Ga Nae)
Changing (feat. Jung
In)
[Bu Suh Jin Dong Nae)
Shattered
Neighborhood (feat.
Lucid Fall)
[Il Tuh) Workplace
(feat. Bizzy)

Hexagonal

Hexagonal

PA 1-673-512

Jungle
Entertainment

PA 1-673-512

Jungle
Entertainment

Jungle
Entertainment
Jungle
Entertainment
Jungle
Entertainment
Jungle
Entertainment
Jungle
Entertainment
Jungle
Entertainment
Jungle
Entertainment
Jungle
Entertainment
Jungle
Entertainment

Hexagonal

PA 1-673-512

Hexagonal

PA 1-673-512

Hexagonal

PA 1-673-512

Hexagonal

PA 1-673-512

Hexagonal

PA 1-673-512

LeeSSang

Journey (feat. Casker)
Dying Freedom (feat.
Kim Bada)
Skit - [Bur Chik]
Penalty
[Woon Myung] Fate
(feat. Malo)

Hexagonal

PA 1-673-512

LeeSSang

Run (feat. YB)

Hexagonal

PA 1-673-512

16

LeeSSang

To. LeeSSang

Hexagonal

PA 1-673-512

17

LeeSSang

Canvas
Skit - [Nae Mom Eun
Nuh Reul Ji Wot Da]
My Body Erased You
[Ttuh Na Ji Ma] Please
Don't Go
[Ttuh Na Ji Ma] Please
Don't Go
(Instrumental)

Hexagonal

PA 1-673-512

Hexagonal

PA 1-673-512

Please Don't Go

PA 1-673-400

Jungle
Entertainment
Jungle
Entertainment

PA 1-673-400

Jungle
Entertainment

8
9

LeeSSang

10

LeeSSang

11

LeeSSang

12

LeeSSang

13
14
15

18
19
20

LeeSSang
Yoonmirae

21

Yoonmirae

Please Don't Go

22
23
24
25
26
27
28
DFSB, et al. v. Kuoch: [Proposed] Consent Decree

-8-

PROOF OF SERVICE
I, the undersigned, certify and declare that I am over the age of 18 years, employed in the
County of Los Angeles, and not a party to the below-entitled cause. I am employed by a member
of the Bar of the United States District Courts of California. My business address is 517 East
Wilson Avenue, Suite 202, Glendale, California 91206.
On October 6, 2011, I served the:
x

JOINT STIPULATION RE ENTRY OF [PROPOSED] CONSENT DECREE AND
PERMANENT INJUNCTION
x [PROPOSED] CONSENT DECREE AND PERMANENT INJUNCTION

for the following civil action:
DFSB Kollective Co. Ltd., et al. v. Phillip Kuoch, et al.
on the following interested parties in this action:
Phillip Kuoch, an individual and d/b/a kaboomza.com and
kaboomza.blogspot.com
75 Henderson Rd.
Keysborough 3173
Melbourne Australia
[e-mail]
by placing a true and correct copy thereof in an envelope to be immediately sealed thereafter. I
am readily familiar with the office’s practice of collecting and processing correspondence for
mailing. Under that practice it would be deposited with the United States Postal Service on the
same day with postage thereon fully prepaid at Glendale, California, in the ordinary course of
business. I am aware that on motion of the party served, service may be presumed invalid if
postal cancellation date or postage meter is more than one day after date of deposit for mailing in
affidavit.
Place of Mailing: Glendale, California
Executed on October 6, 2011, at Glendale, California

__________________________
Katrina Bartolome