Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al

Filing 1140

Administrative Motion to File Under Seal filed by Apple Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Wheeler Declaration in Support of Administrative Motion, #2 Proposed Order, #3 Declaration of Jason R. Bartlett, #4 Exhibit 1, #5 Exhibit 2, #6 Exhibit 3, #7 Exhibit 4, #8 Exhibit 5, #9 Exhibit 6, #10 Exhibit 7, #11 Exhibit 8, #12 Exhibit 9, #13 Exhibit 10, #14 Exhibit 11, #15 Exhibit 12, #16 Exhibit 13, #17 Exhibit 14, #18 Exhibit 15, #19 Exhibit 16, #20 Exhibit 17, #21 Exhibit 18, #22 Exhibit 19, #23 Exhibit 20, #24 Exhibit 21, #25 Exhibit 22, #26 Exhibit 23, #27 Exhibit 24, #28 Exhibit 25, #29 Exhibit 26, #30 Exhibit 27, #31 Public Declaration of Peter W. Bressler, #32 Exhibit 1, #33 Exhibit 2, #34 Exhibit 3, #35 Exhibit 4, #36 Exhibit 5, #37 Exhibit 6, #38 Exhibit 7, #39 Exhibit 8, #40 Exhibit 9, #41 Exhibit 10, #42 Exhibit 11, #43 Exhibit 12, #44 Exhibit 13, #45 Exhibit 14, #46 Exhibit 15, #47 Exhibit 16, #48 Exhibit 17, #49 Exhibit 18, #50 Exhibit 19, #51 Exhibit 20, #52 Exhibit 21, #53 Exhibit 22, #54 Exhibit 23, #55 Exhibit 24, #56 Exhibit 25, #57 Exhibit 26, #58 Exhibit 27, #59 Exhibit 28, #60 Exhibit 29, #61 Exhibit 30, #62 Exhibit 31, #63 Exhibit 32, #64 Exhibit 33, #65 Exhibit 34, #66 Exhibit 35, #67 Exhibit 36, #68 Exhibit 37, #69 Exhibit 38, #70 Exhibit 39, #71 Exhibit 40, #72 Exhibit 41, #73 Exhibit 42, #74 Exhibit 43, #75 Exhibit 44, #76 Exhibit 45, #77 Exhibit 46, #78 Exhibit 47, #79 Exhibit 48, #80 Exhibit 49, #81 Exhibit 50, #82 Exhibit 51, #83 Exhibit 52, #84 Exhibit 53, #85 Exhibit 54, #86 Exhibit 55, #87 Exhibit 56, #88 Exhibit 57, #89 Exhibit 58, #90 Exhibit 59, #91 Exhibit 60, #92 Exhibit 61, #93 Exhibit 62, #94 Exhibit 63, #95 Exhibit 64, #96 Exhibit 65, #97 Exhibit 66, #98 Exhibit 67, #99 Exhibit 68, #100 Exhibit 69, #101 Exhibit 70, #102 Exhibit 71, #103 Exhibit 72, #104 Exhibit 73, #105 Exhibit 74, #106 Exhibit 75, #107 Exhibit 76, #108 Exhibit 77)(Jacobs, Michael) (Filed on 6/26/2012) Modified on 6/27/2012 pursuant to General Order No. 62, attachment #1 sealed (dhm, COURT STAFF).

Exhibit 27

Page 1 of 6
CNET Reviews

Samsung Q1 ultramobile PC
The good: Beautiful, featherweight design; decent-size screen; multiple methods to navigate menus and input
text; plenty of networking options; dual-mic array.
The bad: Lacks keyboard; poor performance; short battery life; weak speaker sound.
The bottom line: The Samsung Q1's sleek case is definitely eye-catching, but we expect better performance and
battery life for a thousand of our hard-earned bucks.

CNET Editors' Rating
2.0
stars
Mediocre
[]

Set price alert []
Review Date: 6/05/2006

Average User Rating
4.0
stars
out of 40 user reviews
[http://www.cnet.com/laptops/samsung-q1-ultramobile-pc/4852-3121_7-31781057.html]

Page 2 of 6
THE BEST ALTERNATIVES

1

[http://www.cnet.com/laptops/apple-macbook-pro-fall/4505-3121_7-35045560.html]
Apple MacBook Pro Fall 2011 [http://www.cnet.com/laptops/apple-macbook-pro-fall/4505-3121_7-35045560.html]
Starting at$1,679.95 [http://reviews.cnet.com/laptops/apple-macbook-pro-fall/4014-3121_7-35045560.html]

4.0 stars
[http://reviews.cnet.com/laptops/apple-macbook-pro-fall/4505-3121_7-35045560.html]

2

[http://www.cnet.com/laptops/apple-macbook-air-13/4505-3121_7-34850081.html]
MacBook Air Summer 2011 [http://www.cnet.com/laptops/apple-macbook-air-13/4505-3121_7-34850081.html]
Starting at$1,498.00 [http://reviews.cnet.com/laptops/apple-macbook-air-13/4014-3121_7-34850081.html]

4.0 stars
[http://reviews.cnet.com/laptops/apple-macbook-air-13/4505-3121_7-34850081.html]

3

[http://www.cnet.com/laptops/hp-folio-13/4505-3121_7-35096620.html]
HP Folio 13 [http://www.cnet.com/laptops/hp-folio-13/4505-3121_7-35096620.html]
Starting at$899.99 [http://reviews.cnet.com/laptops/hp-folio-13/4014-3121_7-35096620.html]

4.0 stars
[http://reviews.cnet.com/laptops/hp-folio-13/4505-3121_7-35096620.html]

4

Page 3 of 6

[http://www.cnet.com/laptops/samsung-series-7-15/4505-3121_7-35003063.html]
Samsung Series 7 (15-inch) [http://www.cnet.com/laptops/samsung-series-7-15/4505-3121_7-35003063.html]
Starting at$949.99 [http://reviews.cnet.com/laptops/samsung-series-7-15/4014-3121_7-35003063.html]

4.0 stars
[http://reviews.cnet.com/laptops/samsung-series-7-15/4505-3121_7-35003063.html]

CNET Editors' Review
Starting at $1,099, the Samsung Q1 seeks to combine elements of a laptop, a tablet, a PDA, a PVP, an MP3
player, a GPS module, and a gaming handheld into a form factor that falls between that of a smart
phone/Pocket PC and an ultraportable laptop [http://www.cnet.com/4520-7602_7-10160822.html] . When we first laid eyes on [http://www.cnet.com/4531-10921_7-6461497.html] the
UMPC form factor at the Intel Developer Forum back in March, we thought that the concept was sort of
cool, but we had our doubts about how useful it could really be, lacking a built-in keyboard. After spending
some time with the machine (provided to us by longtime importer Dynamism.com
[http://www.dynamism.com/] ), those doubts persist; its 7-inch display and Windows operating
system make it more comfortable to use than mobile devices such as the Treo 650
[http://www.cnet.com/Palm_Treo_650_Cingular_GSM_GPRS/4505-6452_731138486.html] and the Sony PSP [http://www.cnet.com/Sony_PSP/4505-6464_730895581.html] , but its lack of an attached keyboard and its mediocre performance make the Q1
difficult to use for anything more than basic media consumption. What's worse, the Q1 couldn't hit the
three-hour mark on our battery-drain tests, which we consider a deal-breaker for a mobile, go-anywhere
device. While the Q1's sleek case is definitely eye-catching, we expect more for the money. Unless you have
cash to burn on slick-looking (if impractical) gadgets, we recommend you spend more to get the $1,549
Fujitsu LifeBook P1510D
[http://www.cnet.com/Fujitsu_LifeBook_P1510D_Notebook_512MB/4505-3121_731469144.html] , a small-form-factor tablet that offers stronger performance and includes a keyboard.
At 1.7 pounds, the Q1 is one of the lightest computers we've seen--lighter even than the diminutive
Toshiba Libretto U100 [http://www.cnet.com/Toshiba_Libretto_U100_S213/4505-3121_731383674.html] (though the latter has a keyboard)--but it's quite a bit larger than the personal
electronic devices currently taking up space in our bag. Measuring 9 inches wide, 5.5 inches deep, and 1
inch thick, the Q1 is about twice the size of the Sony PSP [http://www.cnet.com/Sony_PSP/45056464_7-30895581.html] and more than three times the size of the Treo 650
[http://www.cnet.com/Palm_Treo_650_Cingular_GSM_GPRS/4505-6452_731138486.html] . With its two-prong AC adapter, the Q1 has a travel weight of 2.6 pounds.
In exchange for that extra bulk, you'll get a slightly more comfortable wide-screen size: 7 inches (diagonal)
with a native resolution [http://www.answers.com/native%20resolution] of 800x480 (the
Sony PSP, by comparison, has a 4.3-inch display and a 480x272 resolution). That should be just enough
for jotting quick notes and watching movies on the run but not much else. The Q1's display is also touch
sensitive, letting you navigate windows and menus with a stylus or your finger--a key feature for a device
that lacks a keyboard. We were disappointed in the screen brightness, which measured just 208.9 cd/m2
on our Minolta luminance meter; it was just fine for sitting in the office but became almost completely
washed out when we moved to a sunny room.

Page 4 of 6
Buttons around the screen also help you navigate without a mouse or a keyboard; on the left side are a
four-way joystick and a handy button that lets you toggle between screen resolutions (the computer will
scale up to 1,024x600) so that you can get more screen real estate. On the right side, there are four
programmable application-launch buttons, an enter button, and a menu button that calls up frequently
used controls, including screen brightness, Wi-Fi on/off, and sound controls. Above the screen are two
speakers with decent, though unsurprisingly tinny, sound; volume is controlled with a rocker switch on
the left side of the device. A dual-mic array below the screen can record lectures and lets you participate in
VOIP calls.
We are impressed with the feature set on the Samsung Q1, especially compared to another Origami device
we've seen, the TabletKiosk eo v7110
[http://www.cnet.com/TabletKiosk_eo_v7110_white/4505-3126_7-31876463.html] . The
Samsung has the basics covered, with two USB 2.0 ports, a headphone jack, VGA out, and a CompactFlash
slot that can be used as an expansion card reader. (At our demo in early May
[http://www.cnet.com/4531-10921_7-6514652.html] , a Microsoft representative was using a
CompactFlash GPS device.) Networking options include Ethernet, 802.11b/g Wi-Fi, and Bluetooth. That
matches the ports and connections found on the larger Fujitsu LifeBook P1510D and exceeds those of the
Sony PSP and the TabletKiosk eo.
Like the LifeBook P1510D, the Samsung Q1 runs on Windows XP Tablet PC Edition
[http://www.cnet.com/Microsoft_Windows_XP_Tablet_PC_Edition_2005/4505-3672_731164178.html] , meaning you can run all your existing software (including games). While most tablet
PCs, such as the ThinkPad X41 Tablet
[http://www.cnet.com/Lenovo_ThinkPad_X41_Tablet/4505-3126_7-31398077.html] ,
require an active stylus that sends a signal to the display, the Q1's passive stylus and touch screen mean
that some of the operating system's handwriting recognition features are disabled. Included DialKeys
software lets you choose from six types of onscreen keyboards for entering text with your fingers. Samsung
also includes AVStation Now, which lets you play movies and MP3s and access other multimedia content
without booting up the Windows OS.
Our enthusiasm wanes when we get to the internal components. At $1,099, the Samsung Q1 costs more
than some full-fledged laptops, yet it features an ultra-low-voltage Celeron M processor with only
900MHz of processing power; most laptops and tablets, even ultraportables, include Pentium M or latestgeneration Core Solo processors. The rest of the Q1's specs are what we'd expect from a laptop of its size:
integrated Intel graphics, 512MB of sluggish 400MHz RAM, and a slow 4,200rpm hard drive. (We suspect
the hard drive's 40GB capacity is likely to fill up quickly if you use the device as a true media player.) It all
adds up to performance that's sufficient for surfing the Web and playing media files but definitely isn't
enough to replace your laptop. On CNET Labs' mobile productivity benchmarks
[http://www.cnet.com/how-we-test/laptops/] , the Q1 scored well ahead of the previousgeneration Sony VAIO VGN-U50 [http://www.cnet.com/Sony_VAIO_VGN_U50/45053126_7-30979271.html] , which also runs on a 900MHz Celeron processor but has less RAM, but it
couldn't match the performance of the LifeBook P1510D.

What You'll Pay
MSRP:

$999.00
[http://www.cnet.com/laptops/samsung-q1-ultramobile-pc/4014-3121_7-31781057.html]

Page 5 of 6

See manufacturer website [http://dw.com.com/redir?edId=3&siteId=7&oId=4505-3121_731781057&ontId=3121&lop=txt&ltype=mfgpao&astId=2&pid=31781057&ttag=noprice&destUrl=
3A%2F%2Fwww.samsungusa.com%2F] for availability.
Set Price Alert

Perhaps the Samsung Q1's fatal flaw is its battery life. We think a mobile device that strikes a compromise
between a laptop (average battery life of 3 hours) and a smart phone/pocket PC (average battery life of 8
to 9 hours talk time, six to seven days standby) should run for 5 or more hours if it's going to be truly
indispensable. But the Q1 lasted for just 2 hours, 49 minutes in our battery-drain tests--below average for
a laptop and certainly distressing for anyone who wants the Q1 to be their primary computer on the run.
For the moment, at least, Samsung does not offer an extended-life battery.
Continue to next page [http://www.cnet.com/laptops/samsung-q1-ultramobile-pc/45053121_7-31781057-2.html]
1 2 [http://www.cnet.com/laptops/samsung-q1-ultramobile-pc/4505-3121_7-317810572.html]

THE BEST ALTERNATIVES

1

[http://www.cnet.com/laptops/apple-macbook-pro-fall/4505-3121_7-35045560.html]
Apple MacBook Pro Fall 2011 [http://www.cnet.com/laptops/apple-macbook-pro-fall/4505-3121_7-35045560.html]
Starting at$1,679.95 [http://reviews.cnet.com/laptops/apple-macbook-pro-fall/4014-3121_7-35045560.html]

4.0 stars
[http://reviews.cnet.com/laptops/apple-macbook-pro-fall/4505-3121_7-35045560.html]

2

[http://www.cnet.com/laptops/apple-macbook-air-13/4505-3121_7-34850081.html]
MacBook Air Summer 2011 [http://www.cnet.com/laptops/apple-macbook-air-13/4505-3121_7-34850081.html]
Starting at$1,498.00 [http://reviews.cnet.com/laptops/apple-macbook-air-13/4014-3121_7-34850081.html]

4.0 stars
[http://reviews.cnet.com/laptops/apple-macbook-air-13/4505-3121_7-34850081.html]

Page 6 of 6

3

[http://www.cnet.com/laptops/hp-folio-13/4505-3121_7-35096620.html]
HP Folio 13 [http://www.cnet.com/laptops/hp-folio-13/4505-3121_7-35096620.html]
Starting at$899.99 [http://reviews.cnet.com/laptops/hp-folio-13/4014-3121_7-35096620.html]

4.0 stars
[http://reviews.cnet.com/laptops/hp-folio-13/4505-3121_7-35096620.html]

4

[http://www.cnet.com/laptops/samsung-series-7-15/4505-3121_7-35003063.html]
Samsung Series 7 (15-inch) [http://www.cnet.com/laptops/samsung-series-7-15/4505-3121_7-35003063.html]
Starting at$949.99 [http://reviews.cnet.com/laptops/samsung-series-7-15/4014-3121_7-35003063.html]

4.0 stars
[http://reviews.cnet.com/laptops/samsung-series-7-15/4505-3121_7-35003063.html]
@CBS Interactive. All rights reserved.

Page 1 of 3
CNET Reviews

Samsung Q1 ultramobile PC

CNE E
T ditors' Review(continued)
Samsung backs the Q1 with an industry-standard, one-year mail-in warranty. It's easy to find the Q1
manual, firmware, and driver downloads on the company's support Web site, and we like the feature that
lets you track the repair status of your device. At the time of review, though, there were no FAQs
specifically focused on the Q1; we also wish there were helpful interactive features, such as user forums or
real-time chat with a technician.

Mobile application performance
(Longer bars indicate better performance)
BAPCo MobileMark 2005 performance rating

Fujitsu P1510D [http://reviews.cnet.com/Fujitsu_LifeBook_P1510D_Notebook_512MB/4505-3121_731469144.html?]

166
Samsung Q1 [http://reviews.cnet.com/Samsung_Q1_Ultra_Mobile_PC/4505-3126_7-31781057.html?]

122
Sony VAIO VGN-U50-ULV [http://reviews.cnet.com/Sony_VAIO_VGN_U50/4505-3126_7-30979271.html?]

105

Battery life
(Longer bars indicate better performance)
BAPCo MobileMark 2005 battery life in minutes

Fujitsu P1510D [http://reviews.cnet.com/Fujitsu_LifeBook_P1510D_Notebook_512MB/4505-3121_731469144.html?]

187
Samsung Q1 [http://reviews.cnet.com/Samsung_Q1_Ultra_Mobile_PC/4505-3126_7-31781057.html?]

169
Sony VAIO VGN-U50-ULV [http://reviews.cnet.com/Sony_VAIO_VGN_U50/4505-3126_7-30979271.html?]

163

Find out more about how we test laptops [http://www.cnet.com/how-we-test/desktops/] .
System configurations
Fujitsu P1510D
[http://reviews.cnet.com/Fujitsu_LifeBook_P1510D_Notebook_512MB/4505-3121_7-

Page 2 of 3
31469144.html?]
Windows XP Professional; 1.2GHz Intel Pentium M 753 ULV; 512MB DDR2 SDRAM PC3200 400MHz;
Intel 915GM/GMS, 910GML Express 128MB; Toshiba MK2006GAL 30GB 4,200rpm
Samsung Q1 [http://reviews.cnet.com/Samsung_Q1_Ultra_Mobile_PC/4505-3126_731781057.html?]
Windows XP Tablet PC Edition 2005; 900MHz Intel Celeron M353; 512MB DDR2 SDRAM PC4300
533MHz; Mobile Intel 915GM/GMS, 910GML Express 128MB; Hitachi Travelstar C4K60 40 Go 40GB
4,200rpm
Sony VAIO VGN-U50-ULV [http://reviews.cnet.com/Sony_VAIO_VGN_U50/4505-3126_730979271.html?]
Windows XP Home; 900MHz Intel Celeron; 256MB SDRAM 333MHz; Intel 82852/82855 GM/GME
64MB; Toshiba MK2004GAL 20GB 4,200rpm
Previous page [http://www.cnet.com/laptops/samsung-q1-ultramobile-pc/4505-3121_731781057.html]
1 [http://www.cnet.com/laptops/samsung-q1-ultramobile-pc/4505-3121_7-317810571.html] 2

THE BEST ALTERNATIVES

1

[http://www.cnet.com/laptops/apple-macbook-pro-fall/4505-3121_7-35045560.html]
Apple MacBook Pro Fall 2011 [http://www.cnet.com/laptops/apple-macbook-pro-fall/4505-3121_7-35045560.html]
Starting at$1,679.95 [http://reviews.cnet.com/laptops/apple-macbook-pro-fall/4014-3121_7-35045560.html]

4.0 stars
[http://reviews.cnet.com/laptops/apple-macbook-pro-fall/4505-3121_7-35045560.html]

2

[http://www.cnet.com/laptops/apple-macbook-air-13/4505-3121_7-34850081.html]
MacBook Air Summer 2011 [http://www.cnet.com/laptops/apple-macbook-air-13/4505-3121_7-34850081.html]
Starting at$1,498.00 [http://reviews.cnet.com/laptops/apple-macbook-air-13/4014-3121_7-34850081.html]

Page 3 of 3
4.0 stars
[http://reviews.cnet.com/laptops/apple-macbook-air-13/4505-3121_7-34850081.html]

3

[http://www.cnet.com/laptops/hp-folio-13/4505-3121_7-35096620.html]
HP Folio 13 [http://www.cnet.com/laptops/hp-folio-13/4505-3121_7-35096620.html]
Starting at$899.99 [http://reviews.cnet.com/laptops/hp-folio-13/4014-3121_7-35096620.html]

4.0 stars
[http://reviews.cnet.com/laptops/hp-folio-13/4505-3121_7-35096620.html]

4

[http://www.cnet.com/laptops/samsung-series-7-15/4505-3121_7-35003063.html]
Samsung Series 7 (15-inch) [http://www.cnet.com/laptops/samsung-series-7-15/4505-3121_7-35003063.html]
Starting at$949.99 [http://reviews.cnet.com/laptops/samsung-series-7-15/4014-3121_7-35003063.html]

4.0 stars
[http://reviews.cnet.com/laptops/samsung-series-7-15/4505-3121_7-35003063.html]
@CBS Interactive. All rights reserved.