Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al

Filing 1140

Administrative Motion to File Under Seal filed by Apple Inc.. (Attachments: #1 Wheeler Declaration in Support of Administrative Motion, #2 Proposed Order, #3 Declaration of Jason R. Bartlett, #4 Exhibit 1, #5 Exhibit 2, #6 Exhibit 3, #7 Exhibit 4, #8 Exhibit 5, #9 Exhibit 6, #10 Exhibit 7, #11 Exhibit 8, #12 Exhibit 9, #13 Exhibit 10, #14 Exhibit 11, #15 Exhibit 12, #16 Exhibit 13, #17 Exhibit 14, #18 Exhibit 15, #19 Exhibit 16, #20 Exhibit 17, #21 Exhibit 18, #22 Exhibit 19, #23 Exhibit 20, #24 Exhibit 21, #25 Exhibit 22, #26 Exhibit 23, #27 Exhibit 24, #28 Exhibit 25, #29 Exhibit 26, #30 Exhibit 27, #31 Public Declaration of Peter W. Bressler, #32 Exhibit 1, #33 Exhibit 2, #34 Exhibit 3, #35 Exhibit 4, #36 Exhibit 5, #37 Exhibit 6, #38 Exhibit 7, #39 Exhibit 8, #40 Exhibit 9, #41 Exhibit 10, #42 Exhibit 11, #43 Exhibit 12, #44 Exhibit 13, #45 Exhibit 14, #46 Exhibit 15, #47 Exhibit 16, #48 Exhibit 17, #49 Exhibit 18, #50 Exhibit 19, #51 Exhibit 20, #52 Exhibit 21, #53 Exhibit 22, #54 Exhibit 23, #55 Exhibit 24, #56 Exhibit 25, #57 Exhibit 26, #58 Exhibit 27, #59 Exhibit 28, #60 Exhibit 29, #61 Exhibit 30, #62 Exhibit 31, #63 Exhibit 32, #64 Exhibit 33, #65 Exhibit 34, #66 Exhibit 35, #67 Exhibit 36, #68 Exhibit 37, #69 Exhibit 38, #70 Exhibit 39, #71 Exhibit 40, #72 Exhibit 41, #73 Exhibit 42, #74 Exhibit 43, #75 Exhibit 44, #76 Exhibit 45, #77 Exhibit 46, #78 Exhibit 47, #79 Exhibit 48, #80 Exhibit 49, #81 Exhibit 50, #82 Exhibit 51, #83 Exhibit 52, #84 Exhibit 53, #85 Exhibit 54, #86 Exhibit 55, #87 Exhibit 56, #88 Exhibit 57, #89 Exhibit 58, #90 Exhibit 59, #91 Exhibit 60, #92 Exhibit 61, #93 Exhibit 62, #94 Exhibit 63, #95 Exhibit 64, #96 Exhibit 65, #97 Exhibit 66, #98 Exhibit 67, #99 Exhibit 68, #100 Exhibit 69, #101 Exhibit 70, #102 Exhibit 71, #103 Exhibit 72, #104 Exhibit 73, #105 Exhibit 74, #106 Exhibit 75, #107 Exhibit 76, #108 Exhibit 77)(Jacobs, Michael) (Filed on 6/26/2012) Modified on 6/27/2012 pursuant to General Order No. 62, attachment #1 sealed (dhm, COURT STAFF).

Download PDF

Exhibit 66 Page 1 of 64 • Products Cellphones Tablets Laptops All-in-ones Desktops Cameras E-readers Gaming Television Home Theater Headphones / Headsets Speakers / Docks PMPs Displays Storage Input Devices Misc. Recent Cellphones Xperia Sola Racer Fury B10 Galaxy Pocket Blade Ascend Y200 Ascend Y100 Ascend D lte Ascend P1 lte See All Recent Tablets Multipad 9.7 Pro M970 iPad (3rd generation, Wi-Fi + LTE) iPad (3rd generation, Wi-Fi) Child Pad Scroll Extreme AT270 Transformer Pad Infinity (Wi-Fi) Transformer Pad 300 Transformer Pad Infinity (LTE) See All Recent Laptops Pavilion g4-2000 series (Intel) Pavilion g4-2000 series (AMD) APLNDC-Y0000233502 Page 2 of 64 Pavilion dv7-7000 series Pavilion dv6-7000 series Pavilion dv4-5000 series Zenbook UX31A Zenbook UX21A Mini NB510 Mini NB520 Satellite C870 See All Recent All-in-ones Solo 21 ThinkCentre M90z ThinkCentre M70z iMac G4 iMac G3 iPAD Z1 Workstation MIseeTX IdeaCentre A720 Multitaction Cell 55" Embedded See All Recent Desktops fit-PC3 Pro fit-PC3 X51 Xi3 APPITUR3 Xi3 microSERV3R XH61 Chromebox Series 3 IdeaCentre K430 IdeaCentre H520s ProMagix HD6000 See All Recent Cameras NX11 Alpha A57 EOS 5D Mark III Cyber-shot H90 Cyber-shot HX10V Cyber-shot HX20V Cyber-shot HX30V Cyber-shot HX200V Cyber-shot TX20 Cyber-shot TX66 See All Recent E-readers Jin Yong Reader APLNDC-Y0000233503 Page 3 of 64 eReader Cybook Odyssey Hanvon C18 Bambook Sunflower Jetbook Color Kyobo e-Reader Raboo MM3280 Reader WiFi PRS-T1 See All Recent Gaming NeoGeo X OnLive Universal Wireless Controller Tablet Wireless Bluetooth Controller Ion Major League Gaming Pro Circuit Controller (PS3) Major League Gaming Pro Circuit Controller (Xbox 360) Kinect for Windows GamePad Siren Xbox 360 Tron Controller SupaBoy See All Recent Television UN55ES7500 UN55ES7100 UN55ES6600 UN55ES6500 UN50ES6100 UN55EH6000 UN50EH5300 PN43E450 PN51E450 PN51E490 See All Recent Home Theater DMP-BBT01 DMP-BDT500 Apple TV (3rd generation) Optical Smart Hub HMP2000 3D Bravia Home Theater Projector VPL-VW1000ES Bravia Home Theater Projector XJ-A246 XJ-A241 See All APLNDC-Y0000233504 Page 4 of 64 Recent Headphones / Headsets Plattan+ Chimaera 5.1 Mass Effect 3 Edition Sync by 50 Purity HD G33 Intercom HN-900 Pipe Fool's Gold Edition Pipe Swirl Tracks See All Recent Speakers / Docks Beatbox Portable inAir 5000 DS6100 GX-W100HV Play 360 Turtle Shell iD99 iD95 iD11 iW4 See All Recent PMPs Galaxy Player 70 Plus Galaxy S WiFi 4.2 Nomad Jukebox Walkman B170 series Z2 Plenue Smart Goggles inPulse Smartwatch iAudio 10 Galaxy Player 5 Galaxy Player 4 See All Recent Displays On-Lap 1302 S230HL Abii S230HL Abd S200HL Abd S235HL bii S271HL VX2336s-LED Golden-i EXOdesk Cinema Display (20-inch, Late 2005) See All APLNDC-Y0000233505 Page 5 of 64 Recent Storage My Book Thunderbolt Duo Rugged Portable Thunderbolt Lightfoot Thunderbolt G-Raid (Thunderbolt) Thunderbolt SSD See All Recent Input Devices Savu Mid-Size Hybrid Gaming Mouse Imperator Mass Effect 3 Edition BlackWidow Ultimate Mass Effect 3 Edition Touch Mouse M600 DeathTaker DX-ECO Level 10 M Ballista MK-1 Kinzu v2 Pro Kinzu v2 See All Recent Misc. SmartWatch Pogo Desktop Dock Nike+ FuelBand GUS II JUC600 Powertrekk All-In-One Mobile Companion Wemo Motion Sensor Wemo Home Control Switch Thunderbolt Express Dock See All • Reviews Cellphones Tablets Laptops All-in-ones Desktops Cameras E-readers Gaming Home Theater Headphones / Headsets Speakers / Docks PMPs Displays Input Devices Misc. APLNDC-Y0000233506 Page 6 of 64 Recent Cellphone Reviews Sony Xperia S review Motorola Defy+ review Samsung Galaxy Note review Motorola Droid 4 review Porsche Design P'9981 BlackBerry review Motorola Droid RAZR Maxx review LG Spectrum review Nokia Lumia 710 for T-Mobile review Motorola Admiral review Review Of Verizon Galaxy Nexus See All Recent Tablet Reviews Toshiba Excite 10 LE review iPad review (2012) Sony Tablet P review BlackBerry PlayBook 2.0 review Pantech Element review Ainovo Novo7 Basic review Samsung Galaxy Note review Toshiba Thrive 7-inch review Verizon Droid Xyboard 8.2 and 10.1 review Motorola Xoom 2 review See All Recent Laptop Reviews HP Envy 14 Spectre review Dell XPS 13 review Razer Blade review MacBook Air with Windows 7 review: the ultrabook to rule them all? HP Envy 15 (late 2011) review HP Folio 13 review Samsung Series 7 Chronos review Toshiba Portege Z835 ultrabook review Lenovo IdeaPad U300s ultrabook review Asus Zenbook UX31 review See All Recent All-in-one Reviews Samsung Series 7 all-in-one review See All Recent Desktop Reviews Alienware X51 review Samsung Series 7 all-in-one review Mac mini review (mid 2011) Apple iMac review (mid 2011) See All APLNDC-Y0000233507 Page 7 of 64 Recent Camera Reviews Lytro review Canon PowerShot G1 X review Sony NEX-7 review Dropcam HD review Sony Bloggie Live review Fujifilm X10 review Canon PowerShot S100 review Nikon 1 J1 review Contour Roam Review See All Recent E-reader Reviews Kindle Touch review Kindle (2011) review iriver Story HD review Barnes & Noble Nook review (2011) See All Recent Gaming Reviews OnLive Universal Wireless Controller review Sony PlayStation Vita review Nintendo 3DS Circle Pad Pro review Hulu Plus for Xbox 360 review See All Recent Home Theater Reviews Samsung Optical Smart Hub review See All Recent Headphones / Headset Reviews Sync by 50 wireless headphones review See All Recent Speakers / Dock Reviews Logitech Mini Boombox review Jawbone Jambox with LiveAudio review Sonos Play:3 review Libratone Live review Libratone Lounge review See All Recent PMP Reviews Samsung Galaxy Player 4.0 and Galaxy Player 5.0 review See All APLNDC-Y0000233508 Page 8 of 64 Recent Display Reviews Sony PlayStation 3D Display review See All Recent Input Device Reviews Wacom Inkling review See All Recent Misc. Reviews Nike+ FuelBand review WIMM One review Jawbone Up fitness band review Fitbit Ultra review j5 Create Wormhole KM Switch review See All • Features 5 Minutes on The Verge: Shaun Inman The best tech writing of the week, March 18th What's in your bag, Chris Welch? 5 Minutes on The Verge: Irin Carmon Sparrow takes flight: how a startup built the Gmail app Google couldn’t Sparrow for iPhone review Rdio's Wilson Miner: 'iTunes is just a fancy CD changer' New iPad: launch day buyer's guide Samsung Galaxy S II with Android 4.0 hands-on video SXSW: David Carr and the Curator's Code • Show Episode 003 with Jimmy Fallon APLNDC-Y0000233509 Page 9 of 64 Episode 002 with John Gruber Episode 001 with Matias Duarte • Podcast The Vergecast with Joshua Topolsky, Nilay Patel, and Paul Miller The Verge Mobile Podcast with Chris Ziegler, Dieter Bohn, and Vlad Savov • About • Tip Us • Forums Most Popular Apple Core 1377 posts (8 new) Android Army 1142 posts (5 new) Meta 1002 posts (2 new) APLNDC-Y0000233510 Page 10 of 64 Microsoft Tribe 806 posts (5 new) Gaming 465 posts Off-topic / chit-chat 391 posts (3 new) See All Forums Search articles & products Go • Previous Story Galaxy Tab 7.0 Plus shipping from Amazon, just a little early • Next Story HTC Vivid hands-on • Microsoft • Mobile • Review Nokia's vanguard Windows Phone has arrived, all dressed up in the N9's clothing By Vlad Savov on November 3, 2011 10:14 am 472Comments APLNDC-Y0000233511 Page 11 of 64 320 145 16 Like Jump To Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia's N9 — a benchmark setter in some design aspects, yet a complete dead end in terms of software ecosystem — and now the 800 arrives ensconced in a nearly identical physical body. How do you begin to grade a device that feels, superficially at least, like a cuckoo — a parasite occupying the shell that rightfully belongs to another? Well, you probably start by dispensing with such romantic notions and treating the Nokia Lumia 800 as what it is: a Windows Phone 7.5 handset with a competitive, if unremarkable, spec sheet and the full backing of Nokia's engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What will truly matter to end users of the Lumia 800 is how much of an upgrade this new flagship phone represents relative to previous, Symbian-powered generations of Nokia hardware and, potentially, the rest of the current Windows Phone crop. Whether you're actively contemplating jumping aboard the good ship Microkia or just a curious onlooker, read on for all the answers. APLNDC-Y0000233512 Page 12 of 64 Hardware Hardware / design The effortless grace of the N9's design has been reproduced with the Lumia 800 APLNDC-Y0000233513 Page 13 of 64 Lumia 800 hardware View full Gallery Previous • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What APLNDC-Y0000233514 Page 14 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What APLNDC-Y0000233515 Page 15 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What APLNDC-Y0000233516 Page 16 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What APLNDC-Y0000233517 Page 17 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What APLNDC-Y0000233518 Page 18 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What APLNDC-Y0000233519 Page 19 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What APLNDC-Y0000233520 Page 20 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What APLNDC-Y0000233521 Page 21 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What APLNDC-Y0000233522 Page 22 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What APLNDC-Y0000233523 Page 23 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices aren't actually the most pertinent topic of inquiry here. What Next APLNDC-Y0000233524 Page 24 of 64 Photographing the Lumia 800 is an exercise in deja vu. Except for the addition of a dedicated camera key, the relocation of the dual-LED flash, and the introduction of capacitive Windows Phone keys up front, this is the N9. I'd usually be first to protest if a company decides to recycle a design quite so flagrantly, but in this case, it's more a matter of why wouldn't you? My lasting impression of the N9's case was that it was akin to Apple's unibody MacBook Pro — so tantalizingly close to perfection as to make you wonder where future upgrades could possibly come from. Three years after its introduction, that MBP design is still going strong and Nokia should have to make no apologies for sticking with a similarly splendid piece of engineering. The Lumia 800 / N9 design ethos is all about effortless simplicity for the user, but it's backed by a stupefying amount of calculation, modeling, and testing behind the scenes. What you see and feel in your hand is a seamless piece of soft-touch plastic, curved on all sides and gently tapering toward flattened-out top and bottom surfaces, fronted by a curved screen. It's natural and pleasant to the touch, with great ergonomics and weight balance — the diametric opposite of the cold and impersonal appearance of most modern technology. Being able to meld that aggressively minimalist monobody design with a fully functional smartphone is where Nokia's manufacturing chops really shine through. It's natural and pleasant to the touch, with great ergonomics and weight balance Perfection does elude the Lumia 800, however, and it's almost entirely down to the few physical keys this phone is adorned with. Its right side plays host to a volume rocker, a power / lock button, and a dedicated camera key, neither of which does a great job of what are typically routine tasks. The volume rocker and lock button sit too close to one another and are almost flush with the phone's side, making for difficult tactile recognition. They're also a bit loose and generate an innocuous, though irritating, rattle when you move the 800 around. The shutter release button is better: it's firmer and more pronounced, has more travel, and reacts to pressure without a definite click at the bottom (something that can introduce motion blur in the resulting photos). The latter is a good thing for camera results, but it's less intuitive from a user perspective. While I'm bemoaning buttons, it's arguable that the Windows Phone capacitive trifecta under the screen is a little too close to the touchscreen, leading to some unintentional taps. Nokia is sticking to the three color options introduced with the N9 — black, cyan and magenta, all featuring a soft matte finish — with each of those being the hue of the actual polymer the phone is built out of. That means no matter how deeply you may scratch the Lumia 800, it'll maintain the same consistent color. It'd actually be quite the challenge to force any nicks or scuffs to appear on this handset as that polycarbonate stuff it's made of is deceptively strong and resistant to abrasions. The same can't be said of the elliptical metal plate built into the center of its back — finished to a mirror sheen, that surface seems a magnet for little scrapes. Nokia bundles in a very good silicon case with the Lumia 800, however it has a cutout specifically designed to expose the reflective metal on the back, rather offsetting its protective qualities. Minor issues aside, the Lumia 800 is exactly the sort of delight for the senses that you will have expected an N9 clone to be. APLNDC-Y0000233525 Page 25 of 64 Display Display The ClearBlack Display lives up to its marketing bluster APLNDC-Y0000233526 Page 26 of 64 Lumia 800 display View full Gallery Previous • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a APLNDC-Y0000233527 Page 27 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a APLNDC-Y0000233528 Page 28 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a APLNDC-Y0000233529 Page 29 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a APLNDC-Y0000233530 Page 30 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a APLNDC-Y0000233531 Page 31 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a APLNDC-Y0000233532 Page 32 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a APLNDC-Y0000233533 Page 33 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a APLNDC-Y0000233534 Page 34 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a APLNDC-Y0000233535 Page 35 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a APLNDC-Y0000233536 Page 36 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Phone devices a Next Sticking with the N9 lineage and a recent preference for AMOLED in its flagship phones, Nokia has installed an 800 x 480 AMOLED display inside the Lumia 800. What was a 3.9-inch panel on the N9 has shrunken to 3.7 inches (and lost 54 horizontal lines of pixels in the process) in order to accommodate the Windows Phone keys. Yes, the Pentile Matrix RGBG subpixel arrangement is present here too, though as with the N9, I have to stress that it has almost no distinguishable impact on the display's quality. If you put your eye right up to the screen, you may notice some color fringing on white text in front of a black background, but that's it. Pixel density at this 3.7-inch size and WVGA res feels just about right for Windows Phone and the Lumia 800 does it justice with very clear, richly saturated imagery. As usual with AMOLED, some users will find the colors rendered a little too rich, though there's sadly no option to tone down saturation as there is on Samsung's Galaxy S II. One thing nobody can complain about, however, is the way the Lumia 800 renders — or doesn't render, to be precise — blacks. It features the anti-glare polarizer that earns it Nokia's ClearBlack Display designation, which to us simple APLNDC-Y0000233537 Page 37 of 64 humans just means that its screen is less reflective than most and dark shades appear truly dark. Most of the time, you'll struggle to distinguish where the display panel ends, creating the wonderful illusion that onscreen imagery is simply suspended atop the surface of the phone — it's a very organic appearance that lends Microsoft's Metro tiles an extra air of sophistication. Nokia's spec sheets don't list it, but a visit to Corning's website confirmed that the Lumia 800 does indeed have a Gorilla Glass front, much like the N9, N8 and E7 before it. That should provide you with an extra sense of security when using this phone since Gorilla Glass has shown itself to be a reliably rugged screen for mobile phones. Battery life Battery life, reception, and audio From my brief time with the Lumia 800, I'd say its battery life has been marginally less impressive than the N9, though that's not unreasonable given it's having to power a 1.4GHz processor. Anyone coming from Nokia's previous Symbian family — which typically sacrificed brute firepower for longer endurance — will have to adapt his or her expectations to a new reality. I got to 23 hours while subjecting the 800 to my usual routine of push email updates, web browsing, music playback, photo and video capture, and lots of idling. It's an effort to simulate real world use, but the only thing constant about the real world is that it's different for everyone, so take it as nothing more than an indicator. Nokia lists the Lumia 800 as offering longer talk time (13 hours on GSM / 9.5 hours over 3G) than the N9 (11 and 6.5 hours, respectively) but shorter standby time. When it comes to the Windows Phone competition, HTC's 1.5GHz Titan lasts just about as long as the 800, though the 1GHz Radar offers a little more stamina than both. Reception on the Lumia 800 has been consistently good, allowing for clear calls and generally speedy web connectivity. While on the subject of wireless connections, I do have to express disappointment at Nokia's decision to disable Windows Phone's Internet Sharing feature. That's the facility that allows you to share your Lumia's 3G connection with nearby Wi-Fi-capable devices, turning it into a mobile hotspot. Nokia may look to enable it in a future update, however it wasn't deemed a top priority for launch and the company chose to focus on improving other areas of the phone experience. Also missing from the Lumia 800 is the NFC connection included on the N9. NFC is still a rarely used sideshow for the smartphones that have it, so I can definitely see why Nokia nixed it, but APLNDC-Y0000233538 Page 38 of 64 almost everyone is pushing for its wider adoption and its absence from the 800 casts a bit of a shadow over its longterm prospects. What the Lumia 800 does have is Bluetooth, which is harnessed nicely by a Bluetooth Contacts Transfer app. It does what its name suggests and helps to bridge the software incompatibility that arises between Nokia's new Windows Phone and its line of legacy devices — provided they too have Bluetooth on board, of course. The loudspeaker at the bottom of the Lumia 800 may look identical to the one on the N9, but it's subtly different. Whereas the N9's speaker was impossible to muffle, the 800's is much more susceptible to being muted by pressing something against it — that basically rules out listening to music on the phone while standing it in an upright position. Aside from such an eclectic concern, the sound produced by the Lumia 800 is very good indeed. The usual size limitations imposed by the smartphone form factor do apply, but it's good enough that you will actually want to listen to music through it. Nokia's bundled ear buds, on the other hand, are not. They're quite terrible, sit loosely in the ear, and your best course of action may be to never unpack them so as to keep up the phone's resale value. Disappointing to see NFC and Internet Sharing omitted from the 800 Camera Camera There are some color balance issues, but the camera takes some very detailed shots APLNDC-Y0000233539 Page 39 of 64 Lumia 800 camera sample photos View full Gallery Previous • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia the Nokia Lumia 800 as what it is: a Windows Phone 7.5 handset with a competitive, if unremarkable, spec sheet and t potentially, the rest of the current Windows Phone crop. Whether you're actively contemplating jumping aboard APLNDC-Y0000233540 Page 40 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia the Nokia Lumia 800 as what it is: a Windows Phone 7.5 handset with a competitive, if unremarkable, spec sheet and t potentially, the rest of the current Windows Phone crop. Whether you're actively contemplating jumping aboard • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia the Nokia Lumia 800 as what it is: a Windows Phone 7.5 handset with a competitive, if unremarkable, spec sheet and t potentially, the rest of the current Windows Phone crop. Whether you're actively contemplating jumping aboard • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia the Nokia Lumia 800 as what it is: a Windows Phone 7.5 handset with a competitive, if unremarkable, spec sheet and t potentially, the rest of the current Windows Phone crop. Whether you're actively contemplating jumping aboard APLNDC-Y0000233541 Page 41 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia the Nokia Lumia 800 as what it is: a Windows Phone 7.5 handset with a competitive, if unremarkable, spec sheet and t potentially, the rest of the current Windows Phone crop. Whether you're actively contemplating jumping aboard • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia the Nokia Lumia 800 as what it is: a Windows Phone 7.5 handset with a competitive, if unremarkable, spec sheet and t potentially, the rest of the current Windows Phone crop. Whether you're actively contemplating jumping aboard • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia the Nokia Lumia 800 as what it is: a Windows Phone 7.5 handset with a competitive, if unremarkable, spec sheet and t potentially, the rest of the current Windows Phone crop. Whether you're actively contemplating jumping aboard APLNDC-Y0000233542 Page 42 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia the Nokia Lumia 800 as what it is: a Windows Phone 7.5 handset with a competitive, if unremarkable, spec sheet and t potentially, the rest of the current Windows Phone crop. Whether you're actively contemplating jumping aboard • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia the Nokia Lumia 800 as what it is: a Windows Phone 7.5 handset with a competitive, if unremarkable, spec sheet and t potentially, the rest of the current Windows Phone crop. Whether you're actively contemplating jumping aboard • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia the Nokia Lumia 800 as what it is: a Windows Phone 7.5 handset with a competitive, if unremarkable, spec sheet and t potentially, the rest of the current Windows Phone crop. Whether you're actively contemplating jumping aboard APLNDC-Y0000233543 Page 43 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia the Nokia Lumia 800 as what it is: a Windows Phone 7.5 handset with a competitive, if unremarkable, spec sheet and t potentially, the rest of the current Windows Phone crop. Whether you're actively contemplating jumping aboard • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia the Nokia Lumia 800 as what it is: a Windows Phone 7.5 handset with a competitive, if unremarkable, spec sheet and t potentially, the rest of the current Windows Phone crop. Whether you're actively contemplating jumping aboard • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia the Nokia Lumia 800 as what it is: a Windows Phone 7.5 handset with a competitive, if unremarkable, spec sheet and t potentially, the rest of the current Windows Phone crop. Whether you're actively contemplating jumping aboard APLNDC-Y0000233544 Page 44 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia the Nokia Lumia 800 as what it is: a Windows Phone 7.5 handset with a competitive, if unremarkable, spec sheet and t potentially, the rest of the current Windows Phone crop. Whether you're actively contemplating jumping aboard • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia the Nokia Lumia 800 as what it is: a Windows Phone 7.5 handset with a competitive, if unremarkable, spec sheet and t potentially, the rest of the current Windows Phone crop. Whether you're actively contemplating jumping aboard • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia the Nokia Lumia 800 as what it is: a Windows Phone 7.5 handset with a competitive, if unremarkable, spec sheet and t potentially, the rest of the current Windows Phone crop. Whether you're actively contemplating jumping aboard APLNDC-Y0000233545 Page 45 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia the Nokia Lumia 800 as what it is: a Windows Phone 7.5 handset with a competitive, if unremarkable, spec sheet and t potentially, the rest of the current Windows Phone crop. Whether you're actively contemplating jumping aboard • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia the Nokia Lumia 800 as what it is: a Windows Phone 7.5 handset with a competitive, if unremarkable, spec sheet and t potentially, the rest of the current Windows Phone crop. Whether you're actively contemplating jumping aboard • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia the Nokia Lumia 800 as what it is: a Windows Phone 7.5 handset with a competitive, if unremarkable, spec sheet and t potentially, the rest of the current Windows Phone crop. Whether you're actively contemplating jumping aboard APLNDC-Y0000233546 Page 46 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia the Nokia Lumia 800 as what it is: a Windows Phone 7.5 handset with a competitive, if unremarkable, spec sheet and t potentially, the rest of the current Windows Phone crop. Whether you're actively contemplating jumping aboard • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia the Nokia Lumia 800 as what it is: a Windows Phone 7.5 handset with a competitive, if unremarkable, spec sheet and t potentially, the rest of the current Windows Phone crop. Whether you're actively contemplating jumping aboard • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia the Nokia Lumia 800 as what it is: a Windows Phone 7.5 handset with a competitive, if unremarkable, spec sheet and t potentially, the rest of the current Windows Phone crop. Whether you're actively contemplating jumping aboard Next APLNDC-Y0000233547 Page 47 of 64 Yet another hand-me-down from the N9 production line, the Lumia 800's camera is composed of the same 8megapixel sensor and f/2.2 Carl Zeiss lens as on the MeeGo Harmattan phone. That's generally a good thing, as the Lumia 800 is capable of filling those eight million pixels with tons of detail and Nokia's been very frugal with its noise reduction. Nonetheless, issues of color fidelity do arise, ostensibly caused by Nokia's post-processing which occasionally introduces an artificial green hue to pictures. This probably has to do with the camera's automatic white balance misreading the scene; whatever the reason, it takes away from the ease of use and reliability of the Lumia 800's camera, which are the two most paramount considerations when you're building imaging equipment for phones. Less critical, though still important, is the speed of operation and this is where the Lumia 800 shines. Microsoft has emphasized quick camera operation with Windows Phone from its start, and the Lumia 800 keeps up that standard beautifully. A long press of the side-mounted camera button sends you right into the camera app and tapping anywhere on the screen instructs the camera to focus and auto-expose the image based on the information in that spot. You can also half-press the physical camera key to get the camera to do the same in the center of the picture. Focusing speed isn't sublime and there are none of the N9's special software optimizations for speeding things up — the Lumia 800's camera software is stock Windows Phone — but relying on Microsoft's already strong platform isn't a bad choice here, performance is still satisfyingly quick. Motion blur detracts from what's otherwise very high quality 720p video The dual-LED flash works very well on nearby objects and avoids washing out scenes when it's called into action. It's intelligent enough to recognize how much light it needs to provide, so if you focus on your hand in a dark room, it'll light it accurately, but if you focus on the black phone in your hand, it'll readjust for the phone and over-expose your hand. That may not sound ideal, but the good aspect of it is that it works predictably and reliably. Video recording, much like stills, benefits from some really nice detail, however motion blur is exhibited a bit too readily for my liking. If the Galaxy S II was capable of handling motion perfectly at 1080p resolution back in April, your new flagship phone should be able to do the same at 720p without bother. Nokia doesn't live up to that standard with the Lumia 800, unfortunately. Another way in which this phone falls short on the imaging front is in its omission of a front-facing camera. Sure, most people consider them gimmicky and video conversations aren't exactly threatening to overtake regular voice calls, but front-facing cameras have become essentially standard equipment nowadays and it's odd to see Nokia skimping on one here. APLNDC-Y0000233548 Page 48 of 64 Software Software Nokia's historic move to a new mobile operating system is finally complete. Gone are the days of trudging through outdated Symbian menu systems, no longer will you be laughed at by your trendy app-loving peers. Nokia's latest handset runs Windows Phone, a truly up-to-date OS with a future bright enough to justify the Lumia branding. So why does it feel so underwhelming? APLNDC-Y0000233549 Page 49 of 64 WINDOWS PHONE The first issue is one of familiarity. We've seen both Windows Phone 7.5 and the Lumia 800's chiseled physique already, so combining the two is like making yourself a banana sandwich, new and potentially tasty, but not an altogether unpredictable combination. The Lumia 800 is a device embodying all of Nokia's phone manufacturing nous and relies on Microsoft's best mobile software to date, but what it doesn't do is create something new and altogether better out of those components. The two parts are welded together, whereas what the world really wanted to see was for them to melt into one spectacular new juggernaut that would do battle with iOS and Android. Windows Phone isn't there yet and if any one phone will push it into that stratosphere, the Lumia 800 won't be it. The Lumia 800 equipped with all of the N9's software bells and whistles might have been that hero device, but alas, time constraints have forced Nokia to serve up a very ordinary helping of Mango with almost no improvements of its own. Nokia has been consistent in saying that it'll endeavor to bring the swipe gestures, the double-tap-to-wake, and everything else that was good about the N9's UI over to Windows Phone, but the fact remains that those goodies are not present in the Lumia 800 today. What you get are sadly superficial tweaks: Nokia alerts, ringtones, wallpapers, and a "Nokia blue" theme are scattered around the phone, while the Metro tiles, email client, calendar, and all other native apps are left untouched. There aren't obvious ways to improve on them, mind you, as Microsoft has done a really stellar job of refining the basic Windows Phone user experience. Still, it would have been nice to see Nokia implement the awesome onscreen keyboard of the N9, along with its terrific haptic feedback, in the Lumia phone that's probably being built on the exact same manufacturing line. APLNDC-Y0000233550 Page 50 of 64 Lumia 800 software View full Gallery Previous • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho APLNDC-Y0000233551 Page 51 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho APLNDC-Y0000233552 Page 52 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho APLNDC-Y0000233553 Page 53 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho APLNDC-Y0000233554 Page 54 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho APLNDC-Y0000233555 Page 55 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho APLNDC-Y0000233556 Page 56 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho APLNDC-Y0000233557 Page 57 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho APLNDC-Y0000233558 Page 58 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho APLNDC-Y0000233559 Page 59 of 64 • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho • Nokia Lumia 800 review Reviewing the Lumia 800 is a hard and, dare I say, unprecedented task. Never before have we seen a phone like Nokia engineering, development, and marketing might. The similarities shared between Nokia's Harmattan and Windows Pho Next APLNDC-Y0000233560 Page 60 of 64 Nokia Drive and Nokia Music are the two big additions on launch day. Drive provides offline navigation with voice turn-by-turn instructions and Music includes a Mix Radio streaming service that's loaded up with genre-based playlists of free music. Both are actually very good at what they do and are sure to figure in your long-term use of the Lumia 800. The Mix Radio library is being built out continually, so there'll be more and more content for you to access in the future, while the Music app also pulls in the venues for upcoming gigs near you. I still would've liked to see Nokia do more than just throw in some added apps, although unlike HTC's underwhelming Hub for WP7, Nokia's additions offer real added value for the user. Moreover, Nokia Maps — the new name for Ovi Maps — will be available for the Lumia 800 and all Windows Phones within the next couple of weeks, so we can at least say that the Microsoft-Nokia partnership is headed in the right direction. APLNDC-Y0000233561 Page 61 of 64 ECOSYSTEM Perhaps the main reason for Nokia's abandonment of MeeGo and embrace of Microsoft was the need to have a thriving software ecosystem to empower its handsets with. The Windows Phone Marketplace isn't quite up to that standard yet, however Microsoft is putting good tools in developers' hands and Nokia's presence adds extra clout and credibility to the platform. Stephen Elop's vision of Windows Phone as "the third ecosystem" behind Apple's iOS and Google's Android looks set to indeed materialize, meaning that prospective Lumia 800 owners should have plenty to look forward to. Skype's absence from the Marketplace, for example, will soon be rectified by the folks working in Microsoft's freshly inaugurated Skype Division. The gravitational pull of Microsoft and Nokia's collective determination can reasonably be expected to produce the critical mass of good apps for Windows Phone to truly compete with the best — it's just that at this particular moment in time, it continues to lag. While closing the gap on Android and iOS, Windows Phone doesn't improve on them in any dramatic way. Its multitasking overview is good, the live tiles offer information more quickly and easily, and its calendar is arguably the best of the bunch, but those are small advantages. iOS still wins when I want to browse the web or check out a new app and Android is still the best platform for users of Google services. The gravitational pull of Microsoft and Nokia's collective determination should attract plenty of dev talent I've been using the Lumia 800 alongside an Android handset and an iPhone 4S recently and one thing's abundantly clear: all three platforms are getting the basics right. Push email is arriving at more or less the same time, calendar alerts are going off simultaneously, notifications are mostly unobtrusive, pinch-to-zoom is smooth, web browsers are rendering pages correctly, and email conversations are threaded. What will make the difference going forward are things like the extra layer of polish that iOS can offer, and Windows Phone, as the new entrant to this competition, will need to beat the others to such new features and improvements if it wants to attract defectors to its cause. An honorable mention is earned by Microsoft's windowsphone.com website. As the name suggests, it's the web portal unto your ownership of a Windows Phone, and allows you to browse the Marketplace and send apps directly to your device. There are also guides for novices as well as a pretty comprehensive My Windows Phone menu. The latter allows you to find your phone (with disturbing accuracy), ring it, lock it up with a password and a message for its lock screen, or even wipe it completely. In a classy little touch, Microsoft has also made the color theme of the website match the theme of your phone, which can actually be useful if you're managing multiple Windows Phones and need a visual way to distinguish between them online. Everything on the site worked exactly as advertised, and though the functionality it offers isn't unique, it's a great extra to have and a wonderful base from which to build and expand the WP web ecosystem. Video review APLNDC-Y0000233562 Page 62 of 64 Video review Nokia Lum ia 80 0 review 00:00 | 00:00 Wrap-up Windows Phone provides a modern and attractive UI and the Lumia 800's hardware maintains Nokia's reputation for high build quality The Lumia 800 is exactly what it looked like when it was first announced at Nokia World: it is an N9 running Windows Phone. Ironically, in moving from the wildly imaginative Harmattan to the more straight-laced Windows Phone OS, this smartphone has undergone the reverse of the transition Stephen Elop wants to see Nokia make. He wants the company to stop being known for unexciting reliability and to start inspiring greater emotional attachment in its users. The N9 was that irrationally loved device, and no matter how hard the Lumia 800 tries, it simply isn't as thrilling. For anyone still stuck on one of Nokia's Symbian devices, the 800 is an obvious upgrade. It lacks the N8's superb camera, but otherwise it easily trumps anything and everything in the company's recent portfolio. Windows Phone provides a modern and attractive user interface and the Lumia 800's hardware maintains Nokia's reputation for attention to detail and insistence on high build quality. The picture is less clear for those considering alternative Windows Phones, as the Lumia 800 actually falls behind by not including a front-facing camera or mobile hotspot capabilities. Choosing your favorite there will depend on how much you love the Lumia 800's sterling physical design and how much faith you place in Nokia's ability to execute on its ambitious plans for software differentiation. The Lumia 800 has the potential to be great, but today it's merely good. APLNDC-Y0000233563 Page 63 of 64 Compare It Nokia Lumia 800 7.8 Verge Score 8.4 User Score Write Review Good Stuff • Excellent design • Attractive display • Brightest future of any recent Nokia phone Bad Stuff • No Internet Sharing • Fiddly volume rocker and lock key • No front-facing camera The Breakdown More times than not, the Verge score is based on the average of the subscores below. However, since this is a nonweighted average, we reserve the right to tweak the overall score if we feel it doesn't reflect our overall assessment and price of the product. Read more about how we test and rate products. • • • • • • • • • • 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 • • • • • Design 9 Display 9 Camera(s) 7 Reception / call quality 8 Performance 8 APLNDC-Y0000233564 Page 64 of 64 • Software 8 • Battery life 7 • Ecosystem 6 APLNDC-Y0000233565

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.

Why Is My Information Online?