Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al

Filing 1362

Unredacted Exhibits to Musika Declaration in Support of Apple's Opposition to Samsung's Daubert Motion re 1256 Order on Administrative Motion to File Under Seal, (Dkt. No. 991) by Apple Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit D, # 2 Exhibit E, # 3 Exhibit F, # 4 Exhibit G, # 5 Exhibit H, # 6 Exhibit I, # 7 Exhibit J, # 8 Exhibit L, # 9 Exhibit M, # 10 Exhibit N, # 11 Exhibit O, # 12 Exhibit P, # 13 Exhibit Q, # 14 Exhibit R, # 15 Exhibit V, # 16 Exhibit W, # 17 Exhibit X)(Jacobs, Michael) (Filed on 7/26/2012) Modified text on 7/27/2012 (dhm, COURT STAFF).

Exhibit M
(Submitted Under Seal)

EXHIBIT 25-S

Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co., LTD., et al.

Demand for Utility Patents
Title of Document

Bates Beg - End

Page in Document

Party

1

Deposition of Tamara Whiteside, Worldwide Advertising
Manager at Apple, 2/28/12

N/A

P. 124

Apple

Scroll or Gesture/Zoom and
Refocus/Multi-touch

Multi-touch is focused on because "it's the way that you
interact with the product...you can pinch to zoom in or out, tap
to zoom." There are "various ways that you can interact with
this product that are unique to it."

2

Deposition of Tamara Whiteside, Worldwide Advertising
Manager at Apple, 2/28/12

N/A

P. 158

Apple

Bounce Effect

Apple featured the bounceback functionality in ads because
"nobody else had…the ability to do that in their software."

x

3

Deposition of Eric Jue, Product Line Manager for iPod at
Apple, 2/24/12

N/A

P. 49

Apple

Bounce Effect

"Q Do you think the bounceback feature was revolutionary?
A Absolutely"

x

4

"Apple: iOS - Powering the Mobility Revolution",
BernsteinResearch

APL-ITC796-0000071960 - 2051

APL-ITC796-0000071990

Apple

Multi-touch

"Apple has pioneered multi-touch and focuses on ease-of-use
of the phone (for example, the 3 MP camera in the iPhone 3GS
wasn't cutting-edge, but featured revolutionary user
functionality such as touch-to-focus)."

x

5

iPad Buyer Survey: Initial US Results, August 2010

APLNDC-Y0000023361 - 3427

APLNDC-Y0000023387

Apple

Multi-touch

When asked what was the most important features that
prompted purchase of an iPad, multi-touch was the most
important reason for 2% of those surveyed (4% choose this
feature as second-most important, and 3% choose as thirdmost important).

x

N/A

0:01; 0:19

Apple

Scroll or Gesture

Scrolling function is shown during commercial for the iPhone.

x
x

6

Exhibit 6 to Declaration of Sissie Twiggs, Director of
Worldwide Advertising at Apple, 7/1/11
Exhibit 8 to Declaration of Sissie Twiggs, Director of
Worldwide Advertising at Apple, 7/1/11

Relevant Patent or Feature

Patent
'381 '915 '163 '607

#

Comments on Utility

x

N/A

0:01; 0:11; 0:17

Apple

Scroll or Gesture

Scrolling function is shown during commercial for the iPhone
3G.

8

Exhibit 10 to Declaration of Sissie Twiggs, Director of
Worldwide Advertising at Apple, 7/1/11

N/A

0:06
0:14; 0:20

Apple

Scroll or Gesture/Zoom and
Refocus/Multi-touch

In the commercial for the iPhone 4, double tap feature is
shown once; pinch to zoom feature is shown multiple times.

x

9

Exhibit 19 to Declaration of Sissie Twiggs, Director of
Worldwide Advertising at Apple, 7/1/11

N/A

0:01
0:10; 0:15; 0:26

Apple

Scroll or Gesture/Multi-touch

In the commercial for the iPad, multi-point touch feature
shown; scrolling function is shown during commercial.

x

10

Exhibit 29 to Deposition of Sissie Twiggs, Director of
Worldwide Advertising at Apple, 7/27/11

11

x

7

N/A

p.66

Apple

DJ Koh Review - 3/16/11

SAMNDCA00236805 - 6847

SAMNDCA00236817

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture/Multi-touch

12

Latest Mobile Phone Usage and Satisfaction Survey - TMobile Vibrant MRS Questionnaire

SAMNDCA00247578 - 7604

SAMNDCA00247594

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture/Zoom and
Refocus/Multi-touch

13

VZW "SCH-i905(P4_LTE)" - Product Planning Group
3/31/2011

SAMNDCA00522001 - 2025

SAMNDCA00522009

Samsung

Multi-touch

14

Samsung Equaliser - UX Forecast 2012-13

SAMNDCA00190881 - 1029

SAMNDCA00190971

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture

15

Touch Portfolio - Rollout Strategy - Recommendation
Based on Consumer Insight - 12/17/08

SAMNDCA00178021 - 8112

SAMNDCA00178036
SAMNDCA00178056

Samsung

Bounce Effect/Scroll or Gesture

Survey shows consumers are concerned about "accidental
touches" and "lack of pinpoint control" on their touch screens;
Survey found touch gestures and the "bounce" feature as "fun"
and "whimsical" features of the iPhone

16

Touchscreen Mobile Browsers: Best Practice Guidelines
and Browser Evaluations - November 2009

SAMNDCA00190046 - 0093

SAMNDCA00190053

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture/Zoom and Refocus

The iPhone "meets user needs very well for zooming."

17

ARIES (GT -I8700) Product Proposal Document
12/14/2009

S-ITC-001012125 - 2139

S-ITC-001012133

Samsung

Zoom and Refocus/Multi-touch

Document mentions "Multi-touch" and "One Finger Zoom" as
part of the "Cutting-Edge Technology" selling point.

18

Analysis of Galaxy tab Operation Speed and Screen
Effects (Translated)

SAMNDCA00201771 - 1780

SAMNDCA00201772-1780

Samsung

Bounce Effect

Document compares Galaxy Tab's Bounce feature to the iPad's.
Bounce effect is listed as unemotional in several areas.

19

VZW News Release - 6/28/10

SAMNDCA00312249 - 2251

SAMNDCA00312250

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture/Zoom and Refocus

20

Verizon Wireless Weekly Report - Week 38 - 9/26/11

S-ITC-005218927 - 8984

S-ITC-005218936

Samsung

Bounce Effect

21

Samsung Epic 4G, America's First 4G-Capable Phone with
Slide-out QWERTY Keyboard and Brilliant Super AMOLED
Touchscreen, Coming to Sprint - 6/28/10

SAMNDCA00312245 - 2251

SAMNDCA00312246

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture

Prepared by Invotex Group
Page 1 of 4

Scroll or Gesture

"Touching is Believing": advertisement depicting the ease of
use of iPhone with its touchscreen feature.
Mentions iPad 2 rumors "expect thinner, lighter device" with
"new multi-touch gestures."
Survey asks if the Samsung Vibrant is "easy to use with multitouch function (lets you enlarge/minimize everything using only
your fingers)"
Mentions Samsung P4 LTE is "Easy and Fast to Use" with "10
Finger Multi-touch"
Document mentions increase in input methods (such as
scrolling on an iPhone) as a trend in mobile platforms

Samsung Fascinate features "advanced touch screen gesture
capabilities", including different zoom methods and horizontal
swiping.
Document states that VCAST apps in Model I510 (Droid Charge)
have bounce effect.
Samsung Epic 4G "supports a series of advanced touch screen
gestures including multi-touch pinch" and "vertical and
horizontal swiping."

x

x

x

x

x
x
x

x
x

x
x

x

x

x

x

x

x

x

x

x

x

x

x

Submitted Under Seal; Highly Confidential;
Outside Counsel Eyes' Only

EXHIBIT 25-S

Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co., LTD., et al.

Demand for Utility Patents
#

Title of Document

Bates Beg - End

Page in Document

Party

Relevant Patent or Feature

Patent
'381 '915 '163 '607

Comments on Utility

22

Samsung Mobile and U.S. Cellular Announce Availability
of the Samsung Mesmerize, a Galaxy S Smartphone, at
CTIA Enterprise & Applications - 10/6/10

SAMNDCA00312263 - 2266

SAMNDCA00312264

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture

23

AT&T and Samsung Mobile Announce Upcoming
Availability of the Samsung Captivate, a Galaxy S
Smartphone - 6/17/10

SAMNDCA00312274 - 2279

SAMNDCA00312275

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture

24

Samsung Gem(SCH-i100) Sales Point

SAMNDCA10173553 - 3573

SAMNDCA10173564 - 3565

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture/Multi-touch

25

Samsung 'THOR' '11 Hero Proposal - 7/12/10

SAMNDCA10138344 - 8429

SAMNDCA10138389

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture

26

Competitor Benchmarking Samsung Qbowl 09/07

SAMNDCA00219766 - 9880

SAMNDCA00219878

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture

Document recommends that "traditional scroll bar aesthetics is
not used but the iPhones' scrolling mechanism instead."

x

27

Mobile Internet User Research - 1/18/08

SAMNDCA00220591 - 0672

SAMNDCA00220603

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture

Document states the iPhone's "Zoom and Scroll are simple and
intuitive using finger gestures."

x

28

Samsung Galaxy Tab Official Commercial
(http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GHPJdqgsJ9g)

N/A

0:14

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture

Scrolling function is shown in commercial for the Galaxy Tab.

x

29

Time to Tab - Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1 Global TV
Commercial
(http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QL8ePbYsdc8)

N/A

0:04

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture/Multi-touch

Pinch to zoom and scrolling features are shown in the
commercial for the Galaxy Tab 10.1.

x

N/A

0:09

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture

Scrolling function is shown in commercial for the Galaxy Tab.

x
x

30
31

Introducing the Samsung Galaxy Tab - It's Go Time!
(http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yGKthibnyTE)
Samsung Continuum - A Galaxy S Phone (Verizon)
(http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KIi32R3yciY)

Samsung Mesmerize "supports a series of advanced touch
screen gestures including multi-touch pinch" and "vertical and
horizontal swiping"

x

Samsung Captivate "supports a series of advanced touch screen
gestures including multi-touch pinch" and "vertical and
horizontal swiping."
Document states "multi-touch enhances type accuracy" and
that "pinch-zoom enabled android browser can give
convenience while browsing."
Document states "Touch is History - Gesture Input is
Innovative."

N/A

0:30; 1:12

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture

x

x

x

x

Scrolling function is shown in commercial for the Galaxy S Continuum.

32

Samsung Mobile USA, [Jo Videos] Samsung Galaxy S II
Tips & Tricks - Email
(http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EhwW3cjsbAM&list
=PLB06411CFD33597A3&feature=plcp&context=C337f15f
PDOEgsToPDskIFli7kLjB29rSJhGXwKF67)

N/A

1:08

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture/Multi-touch

Pinch to zoom and scrolling features are shown in the
commercial for the Galaxy S II.

x

33

[GALAXY Tab 10.1] Official Demo - HD
(http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7tfX3Vlz0nI&feature
=related)

N/A

0:51
3:49; 4:00
8:32

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture/Zoom and
Refocus/Multi-touch

In the commercial for Galaxy Tab 10.1, pinch to zoom and
scrolling features are shown; tap to zoom and navigate feature
shown. Tablet design is described as "revolutionary."

x

34

[GALAXY S II] Official Live Demo - Viewing
(http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LP38KFLR0U&feature=BFa&list=PL3F63929F54D9A90A&lf=plpp_
video)

N/A

0:24
1:01

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture/Multi-touch

In the commercial for the Galaxy S II, pinch to zoom and
scrolling features are shown.

x

35

Samsung Galaxy S II Presentation

SAMNDCA10775587 - 5624

SAMNDCA10775607

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture/Zoom and Refocus

36

P5 Usability Evaluation Results - 4/9/11 (Translated)

SAMNDCA00176053 - 6171

SAMNDCA00176125

Samsung

Bounce Effect

37

WOW Project - July 2007 (Translated)

SAMNDCA00202212 - 2225

SAMNDCA00202221

Samsung

Multi-touch

38

Relative Evaluation Report on S1, iPhone, 3/2/10

SAMNDCA00203880 - 4010

SAMNDCA00203909, '3928,
and '3944

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture/Zoom and Refocus

SAMNDCA00251506 - 1512

SAMNDCA00251508 and
'1513

x

39

3G iPhone US Market Impact, July 2008

Samsung

Prepared by Invotex Group
Page 2 of 4

Multi-touch

Diagrams showing "a double tap and tilt of the device will
zoom in and out" and "Tap and Pan will move the user from
widgets to menus."
Samsung notes their current browser has no Bounce effect, and
for the iPad, "there is an element of Fun from the natural
Bounce effect following hand movements." There is a text
screen noting that the GA Lab Evaluation will evaluate the
Bounce effect.
Samsung compares the Samsung Optical Joystick, with 'Multi
Touch' next to an Apple logo.
After comparing the web browser of the i9000 and iPhone,
Samsung notes iPhone's drag and Double Tap feature, and
recommend "add various features that a user can easily notice
such as up/down transitions."
Two options to deal with the iPhone: "Option 1: match the
iPhone on mainly one dimension (product)…. Option 2: match
the iPhone on multiple dimensions."
Under the Samsung short/medium term plan for Product,
under User Interface, it lists "Multi Finger Touch."

x

x

x

x

x

x

x

x

x

x

x

Submitted Under Seal; Highly Confidential;
Outside Counsel Eyes' Only

EXHIBIT 25-S

Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co., LTD., et al.

Demand for Utility Patents
#

Title of Document

Bates Beg - End

Page in Document

Party

Relevant Patent or Feature

Patent
'381 '915 '163 '607

Comments on Utility

40

Behold3 Usability Evaluation Results, 5/10/10
(Translated) [Chung Exhibit B]

SAMNDCA00508318 - 8411

SAMNDCA00508344, and
'8383

Samsung

Bounce Effect/Scroll or Gesture

On the Behold3, "unintentional unlocking is possible because
the sliding action works on any part of the screen."
The document also notes that when "a web page is dragged to
the bottom edge or the sides, no effects are provided and the
overall feel is plain."

x

41

Email from Jaegwan Shin to Ioi Lam et al., RE" "[P1
Browser] Request for Implementation of Additional
Effects", 10/6/10 (Translated)

SAMDCA00525347 - 5349

SANDCA00525347

Samsung

Bounce Effect

Samsung HQ requested for the implementation of the Bounce
effect: "HQ is asking us to make it for P1 project…. 3. There is
no bounce effect in Browser screen."

x

42

Email from Sangwook Han of Nemustech to Seungyun
Lee of Samsung RE "[List Bouncing] Questions regarding
bouncing", 10/28/10 (Translated)

SAMNDCA10850604 - 0607

SAMNDCA10850604

Samsung

Bounce Effect

"With regards to bounce, we used Mass Spring Damper model
which followed the actual physical effect and obtained the
bounce effect that is similar to iPad. "

x

43

Email from Sangwook Han of Nemustech to Seungyun
Lee of Samsung RE: "[Tiffany Effect] P1 Application Case /
Additional Review Items Inquiry", 7/21/10 (Translated)

SAMNDCA10850822 - 0824

SAMNDCA10850822

Samsung

Bounce Effect

"There is a request to insert Bouncing in GridView."

x

x

x

x

44

45
46

Email from Jaegwan Shin to Arum Kumar et al., RE: "P4
Browser Touch performance problems", 5/7/11

Email from Jaegwan Shin to Ioi Lam et al., RE: "[San Jose]
Request for update of P5/P4 zoom/scroll progress",
4/19/11 (Translated)
GT-P7500/P7510_Browser_Touch Performance Test
(Translated)

SAMNDCA00201351 - 1356

SAMNDCA00201351 - 1523

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture/Zoom and
Refocus/Multi-touch

HQ reported problems regarding:
"2. Scroll not respond….
3. Touch performance fail..
1) Pinch zoom in: focus time slow than iPad 2;
2) Double Tap: zoomout time is slow than iPad 2.
4. While Scroll/DoubleTap, checkboarder is showing too much
vs iPad 2."

SAMNDCA00229399 - 9409,
SAMNDCA00229410

SAMNDCA00229399, and
'9410

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture/Zoom and
Refocus/Multi-touch

Performance test results after applying patch for scroll/zoom
on P5 benchmarked against various models of the iPad.

x

x

x

SAMNDCA00229410 - 9415

SAMNDCA00229410

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture/Zoom and
Refocus/Multi-touch

Browser Touch Performance Test of P7510 benchmarked
against various models of the iPad.

x

x

x

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture/Zoom and
Refocus/Multi-touch

"Here is some test result from HW regarding zoom/scroll. As we
has been asked, HQ wants us to improve initial response for
zoom especially." Email then lists results for Pinch Zoom, Scroll,
and DoubleTap between the i9100, Optimus 2x, and iPhone4.

x

x

x

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture/Zoom and
Refocus/Multi-touch

HQ requested for various performance improvements regarding
the zoom in and scrolling feature.

x

x

x

47

Email chain between Ioi Lam and Jaegwan Shin, RE: "U1
browser scrolling patch", 3/3/11

SAMNDCA00229440 - 9448
(chart shown more clearly on
SAMNDCA00229449 - 9451)

SAMNDCA00229440 - 9442
(chart shown more clearly
on SAMNDCA00229449 9451)

48

Email chain between Jaegwan Shin and Ioi Lam et al., RE:
"[San Jose - Urgent] [U1] zoom/scroll performance",
3/20/11 (Translated)

SAMNDCA00229396 - 9397

SAMNDCA00229396

49
50
51

x

i900 Improvement Points

SAMNDCA10042955 - 2984

SAMNDCA10042979 and
'2981

European Telecommunication Operation P5 vs. iPad 2,
5/18/11
Acme, July 2008

S-ITC-010617659 - 7694
SAMNDCA10275576 - 5646

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture

S-ITC-010617661 and '7691

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture

SAMNDCA10275618

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture

On the SMS-manager and Contact list overview, it is noted
"scrolling up/down by vertical finger dragging (just like it is
realized on iPhone)."
The P5 "touch respond is slow, especially, if you scroll fast, it
follows the fingers with delay."
"…the up and down scrolling action is seen as fun…."

x
x
x

"The most preferred method is "Double-Tap" Zooming…
Simplicity is the primary reason of the choice."
"The least preferred methods were split between u960 Browser
and TouchWiz designs." "Too many steps...""dislike of long
press, perception of reliability issues and complicated
interactions were reasons given...."
"Suggestions - Adopt Double-Tap as a supplementary zooming
method... the UX of iPhone can be used as a design benchmark.
Apply double-tap method consistently in other applications
supporting zoom....."

52

Browser Zooming Methods UX Exploration Study,
4/17/09

SAMNDCA11104115 - 4139

SAMNDCA11104133, '4134,
'4138

Samsung

Zoom and Refocus

53

Touch Devices Browser User Experience Comparison,
November 2008

SAMNDCA11082242 - 2299

SAMNDCA11082273

Samsung

Multi-touch

54

Apple iPad (untranslated document), 1/28/10

SAMNDCA10806707 - 6720

SAMNDCA10806713

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture/Zoom and
Refocus/Multi-touch

Document compares the Browser functionality across several
different phones. "Rendering is among the most accurate
among all browsers with dynamic magnification and reduction
with multi-touch."
Diagrams showing the iPad with Panning, Pinching and Double
Tap features.

55

Email from Seung Yun Lee to Meeso Kim et al., RE:
"Today's Conference Call - Action Items", 10/12/10

SAMNDCA00533366 - 3373

SAMNDCA00533366

Samsung

Bounce Effect

"List Bouncing effect is applied to all the applications."

Prepared by Invotex Group
Page 3 of 4

x

x

x

x

x

x

Submitted Under Seal; Highly Confidential;
Outside Counsel Eyes' Only

EXHIBIT 25-S

Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co., LTD., et al.

Demand for Utility Patents
#

Title of Document

Bates Beg - End

Page in Document

Party

Relevant Patent or Feature

56

Touch Devices Browser User Experience Best Practices,
STA UX, 2/13/09

SAMNDCA10166661 - 6742

SAMNDCA1016698, '6708,
'6721

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture/Zoom and
Refocus/Multi-touch

57

3G iPhone Counter Plan, 6/14/08

SAMNDCA00251457 - 1505

SAMNDCA00251472, '1473,
'1503

Samsung

Multi-touch

58

iPhone 3G UX Analysis, 7/12/08

SAMNDCA00251538 – 1565

SAMNDCA00251545

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture

59

Email chain between Jee Won Lee and others, RE Q1]
Email Body, 8/17/11

SAMNDCA10524415 - 4420

SAMNDCA10524416

Samsung

Gesture

McKinsey Report - Winning in smartphones: It's now or
never

SAMNDCA10807316 (Hong
Exhibit 2152)

SAMNDCA10807332, and
'7358

Supplement
Samsung

Scroll or Gesture/Zoom and Refocus

60

Patent
'381 '915 '163 '607

Comments on Utility
"Touch screen is very responsive and accurate."
"Multi-touch user interface is a competitive advantage for
finger touch interaction design."
"There is no widget needed to zoom in and out - users interact
with screen objects directly."
"Scrollbars appear when scrolling but will time out quickly
after."

x

In a product competitive chart, "What is inferior? Less
sophisticated User Interface.. No multi-touch UI."
Instinct Action Item, "Touchwiz UI."
Product competitive analysis for the OMNIA also includes "no
multitouch UI."
Shows screenshots of the iPhone "sweep horizontally and
delete email."

x

x

x

x

“The tablet team will check with the development team to see
if the technology identical to that of the iPad (lining-up within
the screen without scrolling left-to-right in test view/ fit to
screen in the image web view) to email that is fit to screen.”

x

7332: Above chart showing consumer rating of user interface:
"Samsung is weak in user interface compared to key
competitors, and this is affecting the user experience of
smartphone features. . . . E.g., interacting with the browser:
'The way the zoom on web pages and ability to scroll around is
very bad and hard to do on this phone.'. . . E.g., the UI decisions
made in the browser design: 'the resizing of web pages is
poor.'"

x

x

x

x

'7358: "Strategic plays for Samsung . . . Match the iPhone UI
within the next 12 months. Build Samsung brand credibility in
smartphone around user experiences."
Gravity Tank: Touch Portfolio: Rollout Strategy Recommendation Based on Consumer Insight

SAMNDCA00191811 (Sohn
Exhibit 1654)

SAMNDCA00191846, '1907,
and '1928

Samsung

Scroll or Gesture/Zoom and
Refocus/Multitouch/Bounce Effect

61

1846: "The iPhone isn't just easy to use, 'it's sexy to use' - Fun:
Gestures like the two fingered pinch and flick add a game-like
quality to interactions . . . "With the multi-touch function you
can zoom in and zoom out and move photos, and that's great" Whimsical: Lists bounce, icons flitter - the iPhone has a sense of
whimsy that shows a thoughtful character in the interface "You play with it because it's simply fun to handle" - Dramatic . . . "It's sexy to use."

x

x

'1907, '1928: "Accuracy is the most important factor in a touch
screen phone across segments." "A highly responsive,
compelling UI is critical to delivering promise of touch Addressing input deficiency is key user pain point."

62

Palm Pre, Apple iPhone, HTC Magic US: UI
Weakness/Strength Report - August 5, 2009 - R&D
Management Group

SAMNDCA00391937 - 1960

SAMNDCA00391958

Samsung

Prepared by Invotex Group
Page 4 of 4

Multi-touch/Gesture

Under Apple iPhone 3GS, Multi touch, Multi-touch "enhances
usability of Application with Multi-touch support. Allows to
operate instruments, 2-person game play, etc. with use of
Multi-touch. Samsung - we use one finger zoom."

x

x

Submitted Under Seal; Highly Confidential;
Outside Counsel Eyes' Only