Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al

Filing 1432

CORRECTED OBJECTIONS and COUNTERDESIGNATIONS to 1401 SAMSUNG'S RULE 26(a)(3) DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS by Apple Inc.. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit A)(Jacobs, Michael) (Filed on 7/28/2012) Modified text on 7/30/2012 (dhm, COURT STAFF).

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

Agnetta, Bryan
Agnetta, Bryan
Agnetta, Bryan
Agnetta, Bryan
Agnetta, Bryan
Agnetta, Bryan
Agnetta, Bryan
Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012
5/6/2012
5/6/2012
5/6/2012
5/6/2012
5/6/2012
5/6/2012
5/6/2012

6:7‐11
7:16‐24
8:5‐10
10:21‐22
11:5‐19
12:15‐25
14:1‐7
15:11‐17:13

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

18:9‐19:7

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

19:10‐17

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

19:19‐23

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

20:8‐11

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

20:14‐17

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

20:20‐23

untimely (*deposition taken 
after close of fact discovery)
untimely
untimely
untimely
untimely, 402, 403
untimely, 402, 403
untimely
untimely, 402, 403, LR 3‐4
untimely, 402, 403, 1002, 
form (leading), legal 
conclusion
untimely, 402, 403, 1002, 
form (leading), legal 
conclusion
untimely, 402, 403, 1002, 
form (leading), legal 
conclusion
untimely, 402, 403, 1002, 
form (leading), legal 
conclusion
untimely, 402, 403, 1002, 
form (leading), legal 
conclusion, speculation, best 
evidence
untimely, 402, 403, 
speculation

22:21‐25

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

untimely, 402, 403, form 
(leading), expert testimony, 
legal conclusion, speculation 26:17‐27:1

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

26:23‐27:1, 54:20‐55:2
26:23‐27:1, 54:20‐55:2

52:21‐53:7
52:21‐53:7

53:8‐14

53:8‐14

53:8‐14

1

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Agnetta, Bryan
Agnetta, Bryan
Agnetta, Bryan

Agnetta, Bryan

DATE

5/6/2012
5/6/2012
5/6/2012

5/6/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

23:2‐5
23:10‐11
23:14

APPLE COUNTER 
APPLE OBJECTIONS
DESIGNATIONS
untimely, LR 3‐4, 402, 403, 
1002, form (leading), expert 
testimony, legal conclusion, 
speculation
26:17‐27:1
untimely
untimely

23:16‐20

untimely, LR 3‐4, 403, 1002, 
form, expert testimony, legal 
conclusion
26:17‐27:1

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

23:23‐24:7

untimely, 403, form 
(leading), expert testimony, 
legal conclusion

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

24:10‐17

untimely, lacks foundation

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

24:20‐25:6

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

25:9‐19

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

25:23‐26:3

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

26:6‐11

untimely, 402, 403, lacks 
foundation, expert testimony
untimely, 402, 403, expert 
testimony, speculation
53:15‐16, 53:19‐23, 53:25
untimely, 402, 403, 1002, 
expert testimony, 
speculation, legal conclusion,  26:17‐27:1, 53:15‐16, 
form (leading)
53:19‐23, 53:25, 26:4‐5
untimely, 402, 403, 1002, 
expert testimony, legal 
26:17‐27:1, 53:15‐16, 
conclusion, form (leading)
53:19‐23, 53:25

26:13‐16
27:2‐4
27:8‐16

untimely, 402, 403, 1002, 
form (leading), expert 
testimony, legal conclusion
untimely, LR 3‐4, 1002
untimely, LR 3‐4, 1002

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

Agnetta, Bryan
Agnetta, Bryan
Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012
5/6/2012
5/6/2012

26:17‐27:1,  53:15‐16, 
53:19‐23, 53:25, 54:1‐3, 
54:6‐9, 54:18‐19

2

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Agnetta, Bryan

Agnetta, Bryan

DATE

5/6/2012

5/6/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

27:23‐28:2

28:5‐8

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

untimely, LR 3‐4, 402, 403, 
1002, form (leading), expert 
testimony, legal conclusion

5/6/2012

28:10‐15

Agnetta, Bryan
Agnetta, Bryan
Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012
5/6/2012
5/6/2012

28:17‐19
28:22‐29:8
29:17‐30:2

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

30:5‐13

5/6/2012

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

untimely, LR 3‐4, 402, 403, 
1002, form (leading), expert 
testimony, legal conclusion

Agnetta, Bryan

Agnetta, Bryan

APPLE OBJECTIONS

30:16‐24

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

31:2‐4

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

31:6‐19

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

31:24‐32:1

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

32:3‐5

untimely, LR 3‐4, 402, 403, 
1002, form (leading), expert 
testimony, legal conclusion
untimely, 402, 403, 
speculation
untimely, 1002
untimely, 1002
untimely, 402, 403, 1002, 
form (leading), expert 
testimony
untimely, 402, 403, 1002, 
form (leading), expert 
testimony
untimely, 402, 403, 1002, 
form (leading), expert 
testimony
untimely, 402, 403, 1002, 
form (leading), expert 
testimony
untimely, 402, 403, 1002, 
form (leading), expert 
testimony
untimely, LR 3‐4, 402, 403, 
1002, form (leading), expert 
testimony

54:1‐3, 54:6‐9, 54:18‐19
53:15‐16, 53:19‐23, 53:25, 
54:1‐3, 54:6‐9, 54:18‐19
53:15‐16, 53:19‐23, 53:25, 
54:1‐3, 54:6‐9, 54:18‐19
53:15‐16, 53:19‐23, 53:25, 
54:1‐3, 54:6‐9, 54:18‐19
53:15‐16, 53:19‐23, 53:25, 
54:1‐3, 54:6‐9, 54:18‐19

53:15‐16, 53:19‐23, 53:25

3

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

32:8

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

32:14‐23

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

32:25‐33:2

APPLE COUNTER 
APPLE OBJECTIONS
DESIGNATIONS
untimely, LR 3‐4, 402, 403, 
1002, form (leading), expert 
testimony
53:15‐16, 53:19‐23, 53:25
untimely, LR 3‐4, 403, 1002, 
form (leading)
untimely, LR 3‐4, 402, 403, 
1002, form (leading), expert 
testimony

33:5‐8

untimely, LR 3‐4, 402, 403, 
1002, form (leading), expert 
testimony, speculation
54:1‐3, 54:6‐9, 54:18‐19

33:11‐15

untimely, LR 3‐4, 402, 403, 
1002, form (leading), expert 
testimony, speculation
54:1‐3, 54:6‐9, 54:18‐19

33:17

untimely, LR 3‐4, 402, 403, 
1002, form (leading), expert 
testimony, speculation
54:1‐3, 54:6‐9, 54:18‐19

33:21‐24

untimely, 1002, 403, form 
(leading), expert testimony, 
legal conclusion

34:2‐5

untimely, 402, 403, form 
(leading), expert testimony, 
legal conclusion
54:1‐3, 54:6‐9, 54:18‐19

34:7‐11

untimely, 402, 403, form 
(leading), expert testimony, 
legal conclusion
54:1‐3, 54:6‐9, 54:18‐19

WITNESS

Agnetta, Bryan

Agnetta, Bryan

Agnetta, Bryan

Agnetta, Bryan

Agnetta, Bryan

Agnetta, Bryan

DATE

5/6/2012

5/6/2012

5/6/2012

5/6/2012

5/6/2012

5/6/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

4

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Agnetta, Bryan

DATE

5/6/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

34:14

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

untimely, 402, 403, form 
(leading), expert testimony, 
legal conclusion
54:1‐3, 54:6‐9, 54:18‐19

Agnetta, Bryan
Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012
5/6/2012

34:25‐35:5
35:7‐15

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

35:24‐25

Agnetta, Bryan
Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012
5/6/2012

36:3‐5
36:11‐37:2

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

37:6‐7

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

37:10‐13

untimely, 402, 403, form 
(leading), expert testimony, 
legal conclusion
untimely, 1002
untimely, 402, 403, 1002, 
form (leading), expert 
testimony
untimely, 402, 403,1002, 
form (leading), expert 
testimony
untimely, LR 3‐4, 403, 1002
untimely, LR 3‐4, 402, 403, 
1002, form (leading), expert 
testimony
untimely, LR 3‐4, 402, 403, 
1002, form (leading), expert 
testimony

37:15‐19

untimely, LR 3‐4, 402, 403, 
1002, form (leading), expert 
testimony, legal conclusion
untimely, 402, 403, form 
(leading), expert testimony, 
legal conclusion

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

37:22‐38:3

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

38:5‐8

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

38:11‐14

untimely, 403, speculation
untimely, 403, 1002, form 
(leading)

5

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

38:16‐39:12

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

39:14‐40:16

APPLE OBJECTIONS
untimely, LR 3‐4, form 
(leading)
untimely, 403, 1002, form 
(leading)

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

40:19‐41:4

5/6/2012

41:6‐20

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

untimely, 403, 1002, form 
(narrative), expert testimony

Agnetta, Bryan

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

untimely, 403, 1002, form 
(leading), expert testimony

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

41:23‐42:6

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

42:9‐16

Agnetta, Bryan
Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012
5/6/2012

42:19‐43:6
43:43:9‐11

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

43:14‐25

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

44:3‐12

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

44:15‐20

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

44:22‐25

untimely, 402, 403, 1002, 
form (leading), expert 
testimony, legal conclusion
untimely, 402, 403, 1002, 
form (leading), expert 
testimony
untimely, LR 3‐4, 402, 403, 
1002, expert testimony
untimely, LR 3‐4, 403, 1002
untimely, LR 3‐4, 402, 403, 
1002, expert testimony
untimely, LR 3‐4, 402, 403, 
1002, expert testimony, legal 
conclusion
untimely, LR 3‐4, 403, 1002, 
expert testimony, legal 
conclusion
untimely, LR 3‐4, 403,1002, 
speculation

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

45:3‐6

untimely, 403, 1002, expert 
testimony, legal conclusion

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

45:9‐19

untimely, 403, form (leading) 46:17‐21, 54:20‐55:2
6

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Agnetta, Bryan

Agnetta, Bryan

Agnetta, Bryan

DATE
5/6/2012

5/6/2012

5/6/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

45:21‐46:14

untimely, 403, form (leading) 46:17‐21, 54:20‐55:2

46:16

untimely, 403, form 
(leading), expert testimony, 
legal conclusion
46:17‐21, 54:20‐55:2

46:22‐23

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

untimely, 403, form 
(leading), expert testimony, 
legal conclusion
46:17‐21, 54:20‐55:2

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

47:9‐12

Agnetta, Bryan
Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012
5/6/2012

48:20‐23
48:25‐49:5

Agnetta, Bryan
Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012
5/6/2012

50:1‐7
50:10‐12

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

50:14‐17

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

50:20‐24

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

51:2

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

51:5‐9

untimely, 403, form 
(leading), expert testimony, 
legal conclusion
46:17‐21, 54:20‐55:2
untimely, LR 3‐4, 403, 1002, 
expert testimony, legal 
conclusion
untimely, 403, 1002
untimely, LR 3‐4, 403, 1002, 
expert testimony, legal 
conclusion
untimely, LR 3‐4, 403, 1002
untimely, LR 3‐4, 403, 1002, 
expert testimony, legal 
conclusion
untimely, LR 3‐4, 403, 1002, 
expert testimony, legal 
conclusion
untimely, LR 3‐4, 403, 1002, 
expert testimony, legal 
conclusion
untimely, LR 3‐4, 403, 1002, 
expert testimony, legal 
conclusion

7

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

51:11‐17

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

51:19‐52:4

Agnetta, Bryan

5/6/2012

52:7

APPLE OBJECTIONS
untimely, LR 3‐4, 403, 1002, 
expert testimony, legal 
conclusion
untimely, LR 3‐4, 403, 1002, 
expert testimony, legal 
conclusion
untimely, LR 3‐4, 403, 1002, 
expert testimony, legal 
conclusion

55:16‐22

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

untimely, LR 3‐4, 402, 403, 
1002, form (leading), legal 
conclusion, expert testimony

Agnetta, Bryan

DATE

5/6/2012

Agnetta, Bryan
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy

5/6/2012
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011

55:25‐56:1
5:14‐16
5:24‐6:11
7:8‐18
29:14‐30:5

Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy

10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011

31:6‐8
31:10‐12
32:5‐33:1
33:11‐21
34:21‐35:1
35:4‐12

Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy

10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011

37:16‐21
37:23‐38:11
38:17‐23
49:14‐20
49:25‐50:9
50:11‐15

untimely, LR 3‐4, 402, 403, 
1002, form (leading), legal 
conclusion, expert testimony

30:6‐17
Vague; hypothetical; lacks 
foundation 
see previous
see previous
33:22‐34:2, 34:6‐9
vague; hypothetical 
see previous
Ambiguous; lacks foundation; 
701
see previous
Legal conclusion 
Legal conclusion 
see previous
8

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy

10/18/2011
10/18/2011

52:18‐24
53:6‐14

Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy

10/18/2011
10/18/2011

53:16‐20
66:17‐67:9

Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy

10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011

71:7‐21
71:23‐72:12
72:15
73:24‐74:24

Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy

10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011

80:19‐20
83:15‐20

Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy

10/18/2011
10/18/2011

83:21‐84:20
84:23‐25

Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy

10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011

85:9‐12
85:14‐17
89:23‐90:1
90:3‐9
105:21‐24

Anzures, Freddy

10/18/2011

106:2‐7

Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy

10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011

106:12‐16
106:20
139:9‐140:25
142:7‐143:10

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

66:6‐9, 66:12‐16
402, 403 (OS X was excluded 
as not timely disclosed)

80:1‐3
80:5‐6
80:9‐17

Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy

APPLE OBJECTIONS
Legal conclusion; lacks 
foundation 
see previous
Legal conclusion; lacks 
foundation 

75:8‐12, 75:14‐20
78:20‐22 79:1‐12, 79:14‐25

Vague, hypothetical, 403 
(80:16‐20)

Lacks foundation; ambiguous 
see previous
Lacks foundation, vague, 
speculation 
see previous
Vague
89:15‐17, 89:20‐22
see previous
90:10‐12, 90:15‐91:1
Lacks foundation, vague 
Lacks foundation; legal 
conclusion 
Lacks foundation; legal 
conclusion 
see previous

9

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy

DATE
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
156:8‐13
156:16‐157:2
170:3‐5
170:8‐13
170:16‐21
170:24
157:7
164:23‐165:12

Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Anzures, Freddy
Balasubramaniam, Priya
Balasubramaniam, Priya
Balasubramaniam, Priya
Balasubramaniam, Priya
Balasubramaniam, Priya
Balasubramaniam, Priya
Balasubramaniam, Priya
Balasubramaniam, Priya
Balasubramaniam, Priya
Balasubramaniam, Priya
Balasubramaniam, Priya

10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
7/17/2012
7/17/2012
7/17/2012
7/17/2012
7/17/2012
7/17/2012
7/17/2012
7/17/2012
7/17/2012
7/17/2012
7/17/2012

179:14‐17
179:20‐25
180:3‐18
181:17‐182:6
204:22‐205:1
205:3‐20
6:1‐7:5
7:12‐17
7:24‐8:11
9:18‐22
12:1‐6
12:14‐18
13:21‐24
15:13‐17
15:19‐21
16:1‐17:2
17:4‐5

Balasubramaniam, Priya
Balasubramaniam, Priya

7/17/2012
7/17/2012

20:10‐21:7
21:9‐10

Balasubramaniam, Priya

7/17/2012

22:14‐18

APPLE OBJECTIONS
402, 403
402, 403
Lacks foundation; 402, 403
Lacks foundation; 402, 403
Lacks foundation, 402, 403
see previous
402, 403

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

402, 403 (OS X was excluded 
as not timely disclosed; can't 
be used for showing 
invalidity)
see previous
see previous
see previous

8:12‐22
12:7‐9
FRE 402
14:7‐20

FRE 402; misleading
FRE 402; misleading
Vague; FRE 402; misleading; 
Lacks foundation
21:11‐23
FRE 402; misleading; Lacks 
foundation

10

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Balasubramaniam, Priya

7/17/2012

27:20‐22

Balasubramaniam, Priya
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin

7/17/2012
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011

27:24‐25
8:12‐13
10:16‐25
12:19‐13:6
13:10‐25
15:19‐16:2
17:7‐14
20:1‐5
20:23‐21:5
25:5‐10
31:9‐15
32:5‐9

APPLE OBJECTIONS
FRE 402; misleading; Lacks 
foundation
FRE 402; misleading; Lacks 
foundation
None
None
Incomplete
None
None
None
None
None
None
Incomplete
Incomplete

Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin

9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011

49:2‐13
60:2‐7
93:17‐94:3
94:15‐17
97:6‐98:23
99:11‐14
99:16
99:18‐23
100:11‐18
100:20‐24
101:14‐103:3
103:5‐10
103:13‐20

Incomplete
None
Incomplete
Incomplete
None
None
None
Incomplete
None
None
None
None
Incomplete

Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin

9/17/2011
9/17/2011

137:5‐23
149:17‐150:2

Incomplete
None

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

28:18‐29:8

13:7‐9

28:18‐29:7
32:5‐9
56:14‐19; 56:21‐57:3; 57:5‐
6; 57:24‐58:2; 77:16‐20; 
77:22‐25;
78:17‐79:1; 79:3‐8;  84:20‐
23; 84:25‐85:10
93:6‐12
96:13‐97:1

99:24‐100:3

104:6‐18
135:7‐9; 135:11‐16;
148:2‐13; 148:24‐149:4;

11

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin

DATE
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
155:14‐156:9
156:16‐157:8
159:17‐160:1
160:3‐7
160:9‐16

APPLE OBJECTIONS
None
None
Incomplete
None
Incomplete

Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin

9/17/2011
9/17/2011

168:16‐22
169:3‐19

Incomplete
None

Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Bederson, Benjamin
Blevins, Tony 
Blevins, Tony 
Blevins, Tony 
Blevins, Tony 
Blevins, Tony 
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794

9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
9/17/2011
4/30/2012
4/30/2012
4/30/2012
4/30/2012
4/30/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012

171:2‐172:2
184:9‐18
185:4‐8
185:10‐16
185:18‐25
186:3‐21
193:21‐194:12
195:2‐25
202:5‐204:5
6:15‐16
10:7‐12
77:18‐20
78:9‐79:13
80:4‐6
6:5‐6
8:8‐12
11:15‐12:10
12:17‐23
13:3‐12
14:4‐15:2
19:13‐25
20:11‐13
21:9‐21

Incomplete
None
None
None
None
None
None
Incomplete
402

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

159:11‐14
160:18‐25
161:10‐18; 
163:14‐20; 165:4‐11; 
165:14‐167:6
172:6‐21; 172:23‐173:1; 
173:25‐174:5; 176:17‐19; 
176:21‐177:5; 178:5‐9; 
178:11
182:22‐183:7

198:17‐25

406
Ambiguous

12

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794

DATE
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
22:3‐5
22:17‐19
24:22‐25:6
25:10‐20
29:12‐30:2
30:7‐31:13
32:9‐25
33:24‐35:19
37:15‐23
38:5‐13
39:18‐40:22
41:3‐13
41:23‐42:10
44:5‐24
45:1‐2
45:8‐11
45:18‐22
45:24‐25
46:2‐8
51:6‐24
52:25‐53:24

Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794

2/23/2012

57:2‐5

Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794

2/23/2012

62:3‐5

Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794

2/23/2012

69:20‐25

Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794

2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012

70:21‐71:1
72:16‐22
73:19‐74:5
74:9‐12
81:5‐9
85:4‐16
85:24‐86:8

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

39:10‐17
39:10‐17; 40:23‐41:2
40:23‐41:2
402
402
402
402
402
402
Ambiguous
Ambiguous; Lacks 
Foundation
Ambiguous; Lacks 
Foundation
Ambiguous; Lacks 
Foundation
Ambiguous; Lacks 
Foundation
Not Testimony
Ambiguous
402
402
402
13

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony  ITC‐794
Blevins, Tony ITC‐794 Hearing Day 4
Blevins, Tony ITC‐794 Hearing Day 4
Blevins, Tony ITC‐794 Hearing Day 4
Blevins, Tony ITC‐794 Hearing Day 4
Blevins, Tony ITC‐794 Hearing Day 4
Blevins, Tony ITC‐794 Hearing Day 4
Blevins, Tony ITC‐794 Hearing Day 4
Blevins, Tony ITC‐794 Hearing Day 4
Blevins, Tony ITC‐794 Hearing Day 4
Blevins, Tony ITC‐794 Hearing Day 4
Blevins, Tony ITC‐794 Hearing Day 4
Blevins, Tony ITC‐794 Hearing Day 4
Bogue, Adam ITC‐797
Bogue, Adam ITC‐797
Bogue, Adam ITC‐797
Bogue, Adam ITC‐797
Bogue, Adam ITC‐797
Bogue, Adam ITC‐797
Bogue, Adam ITC‐797
Bogue, Adam ITC‐797
Bogue, Adam ITC‐797
Bogue, Adam ITC‐797

DATE
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
6/7/2012
6/7/2012
6/7/2012
6/7/2012
6/7/2012
6/7/2012
6/7/2012
6/7/2012
6/7/2012
6/7/2012
6/7/2012
6/7/2012
3/9/2012
3/9/2012
3/9/2012
3/9/2012
3/9/2012
3/9/2012
3/9/2012
3/9/2012
3/9/2012
3/9/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
86:17‐22
86:24‐87:13
122:16‐124:7
124:12‐17
126:15‐128:5
128:10‐23
129:2‐10
129:18‐130:9
130:20‐131:3
131:11‐14
131:16
958:17‐24
968:11‐18
985:14‐19
986:13‐987:11
988:11‐24
989:3‐16
990:3‐991:25
992:21‐993:20
994:5‐12
997:25‐998:15
999:11‐20
1001:13‐1003:10
5:21‐6:8
6:15‐24

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

402
1002
1002
Speculation; 1002
1002

Incomplete, 602
Incomplete, 602

Incomplete

Speculation
None
None

9:18‐10:7
11:8‐12:3
12:14‐13:1
15:5‐16:3

Incomplete
Incomplete
Incomplete
None

20:21‐21:24
45:14‐46:9
46:16‐17
46:24‐47:19

Incomplete
Leading
Leading
Leading; misleading

10:8‐10; 10:12‐13; 
10:22‐11:7
12:4‐7; 12:9‐13
13:2‐8; 13:11‐13
23:5‐10; 23:20‐24:1;
24:3‐8; 28:11‐15; 31:7‐12

14

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Bogue, Adam ITC‐797

3/9/2012

48:7‐50:24

Bogue, Adam ITC‐797

3/9/2012

APPLE OBJECTIONS
Leading; misleading; 
lacks foundation; 1002
Leading; lacks foundation; 
1002; 802

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

52:2‐55:17

Bogue, Adam ITC‐797
Bogue, Adam ITC‐797
Bogue, Adam ITC‐797
Bogue, Adam ITC‐797
Bogue, Adam ITC‐797
Bogue, Adam ITC‐797

3/9/2012
3/9/2012
3/9/2012
3/9/2012
3/9/2012
3/9/2012

62:4‐64:18
64:24‐66:3
66:24‐70:3
71:3‐73:17
73:19‐78:21
84:1‐85:25

Bogue, Adam ITC‐797
Bogue, Adam ITC‐797

3/9/2012
3/9/2012

86:15‐88:12
94:4‐95:15

Bogue, Adam ITC‐797
Bright, Andrew
Bright, Andrew
Bright, Andrew
Bright, Andrew
Bright, Andrew
Bright, Andrew
Bright, Andrew
Bright, Andrew

Bright, Andrew

3/9/2012
7/17/2012
7/17/2012
7/17/2012
7/17/2012
7/17/2012
7/17/2012
7/17/2012
7/17/2012

7/17/2012

96:5‐97:8
5:7‐11
5:17‐18
6:2‐8
8:11‐23
9:3‐6
9:13‐17
9:25‐10:5
12:16‐24

13:5‐17

Leading; 402; 
lacks foundation
Leading; 402
Leading
Leading
Leading; 1002; 402
Leading; 402
Leading; 1002; 402;
Incomplete
Leading; 1002; 402

Leading; 1002; 
Incomplete

88:13‐18
99:3‐6; 99:10‐13; 
99:15; 102:2‐6; 103:24‐
104:6; 109:25‐110:6; 
115:15‐17; 115:24‐116:3; 
116:6‐9; 118:21‐119:2; 
119:11‐13; 119:15; 120:8‐
10; 120:113‐16; 120:18

13:18‐24; 14:2‐5; 14:8‐14; 
14:17‐25; 71:18‐72:5; 72:8‐
12; 72:14‐22; 72:24‐73:11; 
73:13‐24; 74:2‐3; 74:6‐8; 
74:10‐12
15

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS
Vague & Ambiguous;  FRE 
402; misleading; Lacks 
foundation

Bright, Andrew
Bright, Andrew
Bright, Andrew
Bright, Andrew
Bright, Andrew

7/17/2012
7/17/2012
7/17/2012
7/17/2012
7/17/2012

15:10‐13
15:16
15:18‐16:3
17:2‐4
18:6‐17

Bright, Andrew

7/17/2012

24:1‐20

7/17/2012

26:17‐27:9

FRE 402; vague; misleading; 
Lacks foundation

Bright, Andrew

7/17/2012

28:2‐10

FRE 402; vague; misleading; 
Lacks foundation

Bright, Andrew

7/17/2012

32:13‐33:6

FRE 402; vague; misleading; 
Lacks foundation

33:25‐34:4

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402; vague; misleading; 
Lacks foundation

Bright, Andrew

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

FRE 402; vague; misleading; 
Lacks foundation

Bright, Andrew

7/17/2012

Bright, Andrew

7/17/2012

34:7‐15

FRE 402; vague; misleading; 
Lacks foundation

Bright, Andrew

7/17/2012

34:19‐20

FRE 402; vague; misleading; 
Lacks foundation

Bright, Andrew

7/17/2012

39:10‐15

FRE 402; vague; misleading; 
Lacks foundation

Bright, Andrew

7/17/2012

40:7‐22

FRE 402; vague; misleading; 
Lacks foundation

16

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

Bright, Andrew

7/17/2012

47:3‐48:6

APPLE OBJECTIONS
Vague; misleading; Lacks 
foundation

Bright, Andrew

7/17/2012

49:20‐51:4

Bright, Andrew

7/17/2012

52:5‐53:1

Bright, Andrew
Bright, Andrew

7/17/2012
7/17/2012

53:10‐54:16
57:9‐20

Bright, Andrew

7/17/2012

58:7‐12

Bright, Andrew

7/17/2012

70:5‐71:14

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

85:14‐18

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

86:3‐20

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

90:1‐15

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

109:3‐12

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

121:14‐20

FRE 402; vague; misleading; 
67:10‐14
Lacks foundation
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002

126:18‐127:15

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402; vague; misleading; 
Lacks foundation

admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list

Buckley, Mark

DATE

2/23/2012

46:4‐13

FRE 402; vague; misleading; 
Lacks foundation
53:2‐9
vague; misleading; Lacks 
foundation
58:13‐16; 58:19; 58:21‐
59:9

17

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Buckley, Mark

Buckley, Mark

DATE

2/23/2012

2/23/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS

131:21‐25

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list

135:14‐136:8

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

142:6‐143:3

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

145:16‐19

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

145:23‐25

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

146:6‐147:16

FRE 402
FRE 403
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
FRE 402
FRE 403
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
146:1‐5 (subject to 
incomplete
objections)

18

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Buckley, Mark

Buckley, Mark

Buckley, Mark

Buckley, Mark

DATE

2/23/2012

2/23/2012

2/23/2012

2/23/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS
FRE 402
FRE 403
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

147:20‐148:6

153:9‐25

FRE 402
FRE 403
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list

155:4‐7

FRE 402
FRE 403
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list

157:13‐25

FRE 402
FRE 403
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list

19

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Buckley, Mark

Buckley, Mark

DATE

2/23/2012

2/23/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

159:20‐22

FRE 402
FRE 403
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list

160:5‐8

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402
FRE 403
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
160:12‐14

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

161:14‐20

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

169:13‐170:7

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

172:23‐25

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

182:6‐10

Incomplete
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple's objections to 
Samsung's exhibit list
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
Ambiguous
calls for a narrative
compound

20

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

183:10‐13

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

183:16‐20

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

184:1‐185:13

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

187:22‐188:21

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

190:25‐191:10

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

191:24‐192:12

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

196:8‐25

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

197:14‐17

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

203:9‐204:3

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

204:7‐13

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

204:23‐25

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

206:2‐14

APPLE OBJECTIONS
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
Beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
speculation
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
Beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
speculation
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
FRE 402; FRE 403; beyond 
scope of 30(b)(6)
FRE 402; FRE 403; beyond 
scope of 30(b)(6); 
argumentative
incomplete
Incomplete
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
Incomplete
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
Incomplete
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
FRE 402
FRE 403
ambiguous
compound

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

191:18‐23

197:1‐13

197:18‐20; 198:5‐11
201:5‐8; 201:24‐202:2 
(subject to objections)

21

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Buckley, Mark

Buckley, Mark

Buckley, Mark

Buckley, Mark

DATE

2/23/2012

2/23/2012

2/23/2012

2/23/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

209:2‐16

FRE 402
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
209:18‐210:10

210:15‐20

FRE 402
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
209:18‐210:10

212:9‐10

FRE 402
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
209:18‐210:10

212:24‐213:3

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
209:18‐210:10

22

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Buckley, Mark

Buckley, Mark

DATE

2/23/2012

2/23/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS

220:3‐5

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402
FRE 403
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list

220:14‐221:9

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

FRE 402
FRE 403
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list

Buckley, Mark

2/23/2012

Buckley, Mark
Buckley, Mark 12‐22‐11 ITC‐796
Buckley, Mark 12‐22‐11 ITC‐796

2/23/2012 241:20‐242:3
12/22/2011 10:14‐21
12/22/2011 11:15‐12:6

Buckley, Mark 12‐22‐11 ITC‐796

12/22/2011 27:8‐12

Buckley, Mark 12‐22‐11 ITC‐796

12/22/2011 27:17‐22

230:10‐22

Buckley, Mark 12‐22‐11 ITC‐796

12/22/2011 36:8‐13

Buckley, Mark 12‐22‐11 ITC‐796
Chen, Stephanie

12/22/2011 109:21‐110:2
3/8/2012
10:18‐22

admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
Beyond scope of 30(b)(6); 
Speculation
FRE 402; FRE 403
None
FRE 402; FRE 403; ambiguous
FRE 402; FRE 403; 
ambiguous; narrative
35:20‐24; 36:5‐7 (subject 
FRE 402; FRE 403; incomplete to objections)
FRE 402; FRE 403; misstates 
testimony

23

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie

DATE
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
12:17‐24
14:13‐23
15:18‐16:9
21:23‐22:8
22:22‐25
24:3‐6
25:9‐14
25:25‐26:9
28:4‐9
29:1‐6
32:15‐20
36:5‐10
36:21‐24
37:12‐17
38:15‐18
40:17‐24
42:22‐43:5
51:13‐52:2
52:7‐13
55:11‐15
56:4‐6
58:8‐21
59:20‐22
63:25‐64:4
65:23‐66:2
66:13‐17
67:17‐24
68:10‐16
69:12‐14

Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie

3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012

69:22
71:13‐16
72:1‐2

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

22:9‐21

25:17‐24
27:14‐28:3

37:4‐11
40:25‐41:4
402, 403, 802

55:16‐20

59:23‐25

66:3‐12
67:25‐68:9
68:17‐69:22
Speculation, lacks foundation 
(69:12‐22), 402, 403
1002
1002

24

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie

3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012

73:22‐25
74:2‐3
74:9‐15

Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie

3/8/2012
3/8/2012

76:24‐77:1
77:5‐8

Speculation, lacks foundation 
(73:22‐74:1), 402, 403, 1002
see previous
74:7‐8
402, 403, 1002
Speculation, lacks 
foundation, calls for legal 
conclusion (76:24‐77:8), 402, 
403, 1002
see previous

Chen, Stephanie

3/8/2012

82:15‐20

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

Speculation, lacks foundation 
(82:20‐24), 402, 403, 1002
82:13‐14

Chen, Stephanie

3/8/2012

82:22‐83:6

Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie

3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012

83:25‐84:5
84:7
84:12‐14
85:6‐9
85:16‐22
86:10‐15
88:9‐11
88:22‐25
93:3‐5
94:14‐15
94:17‐18
95:19‐23
96:25‐97:2
98:23‐99:3
100:2‐5
101:12‐17

Speculation, lacks 
foundation, argumentative  
(83:4‐9), 402, 403, 1002
Speculation, lacks 
foundation, ambiguous  
(83:25‐84:14), 402, 403
see previous
see previous
1002
1002
85:10‐15
86:7‐9
402, 403
88:12‐21
402, 403

402, 403, 802, 1002
402, 403, 802, 1002
402, 403, 1002

25

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie

Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie

Chen, Stephanie

Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie

DATE
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012

3/8/2012
3/8/2012

3/8/2012

3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
102:18‐103:7
104:14‐16
106:4‐107:5
107:8‐108:10

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

1002
402, 403
402, 403

109:1‐4
109:7

Argumentative, calls for 
speculation, lacks foundation 
(109:1‐7), 402, 403
see previous

109:23‐110:2

Argumentative, calls for 
speculation, lacks foundation 
(109:23‐110:14), 402, 403

110:5‐17
110:19
112:20‐113:4
113:13‐20
115:17‐19
118:21‐24
121:12‐20
122:6‐14
122:16‐123:2
124:13‐15
124:23‐125:3
125:5‐14
126:15‐22
127:19‐22
128:6‐10
129:18‐24
133:16‐134:22
135:15‐136:4

Argumentative, calls for 
speculation, lacks foundation 
(109:15‐19), 402, 403
see previous
402, 403, 1002
111:24‐112:19
402, 403
114:4, 114:6‐13, 114:15
402, 403
114:22‐115:16
402, 403
118:25‐119:2
402, 403
120:11‐121:7
402, 403
402, 403
402, 403
124:6‐12
402, 403
402, 403
125:15‐126:14
402, 403
402, 403
127:23‐128:1
402, 403
402, 403
402, 403
134:23‐135:2
402, 403
135:10‐14

26

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Chen, Stephanie

3/8/2012

144:18‐145:4

Chen, Stephanie

3/8/2012

149:6‐10

Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie

3/8/2012
3/8/2012

149:12‐16
149:18‐19

Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Chen, Stephanie
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg

3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011

Christie, Greg

10/18/2011 75:19

Christie, Greg

10/18/2011 75:22‐24

155:4‐7
155:9‐10
170:1‐7
187:2‐8
187:14‐16
5:13‐15
10:3‐9
10:19‐23
12:18‐19
13:5
13:9‐21
18:10‐19:5
19:18‐20:17
53:2‐12
62:17‐18
63:1‐4
64:10‐25
74:25
75:1‐13
75:16‐17

APPLE OBJECTIONS
402, 403, not testimony, 
1002
Lacks foundation, 
speculation, 402, 403, 802, 
1002
Lacks foundation, 
speculation, 402, 403, 802, 
1002
see previous
assumes facts, 402, 403, 
1002
see previous
402, 403, 1002
402, 403, 1002

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

148:14‐23

154:22‐155:1, 155:3

501

10:16‐17

501
501
402; 403

13:1‐4
13:1‐4

form; vague
form; vague
form; 402; 403
vague; ambiguous
vague; ambiguous
form; legal conclusion; 
foundation
form; legal conclusion; 
foundation; speculation

76:1‐6

27

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

Christie, Greg

10/18/2011 77:13‐14

legal conclusion; foundation

Christie, Greg

10/18/2011 77:17‐19

legal conclusion; foundation

Christie, Greg

10/18/2011 77:21‐22

legal conclusion; foundation

Christie, Greg

10/18/2011 77:25‐78:1

legal conclusion; foundation

Christie, Greg

10/18/2011 78:3‐5

legal conclusion; foundation

Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg

10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

legal conclusion; foundation
compound
form
form
402; 403
vague
vague
vague
vague
80:24‐81:2
legal conclusion
legal conclusion
misleading; 403
83:14‐84:7
misleading; 403
84:18‐86:20

78:8‐9
78:11‐17
78:20‐79:3
79:5‐6
79:8‐14
80:12‐14
80:16
80:18‐19
80:21‐22
82:21‐24
83:3‐7
83:10‐12
84:15‐17
105:8‐12
107:25‐108:1
108:4
108:6‐10
109:15‐110:19
111:2‐10
111:22‐112:2
112:17‐19
117:16‐118:5
118:9‐18
122:24‐123:1

foundation; speculation
foundation; speculation
402; 403

misleading; 403

112:3‐5

vague
28

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
123:3‐4
123:6‐15
123:17
123:21‐124:1
142:23‐143:2
143:10‐11
145:12‐21
145:23‐148:17

Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg

DATE
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011

Christie, Greg

10/18/2011 194:3‐13

Christie, Greg

10/18/2011 196:22‐198:21

Christie, Greg

10/18/2011 199:3‐15

Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Christie, Greg
Coster, Daniel

10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/27/2011

199:23‐25
200:8‐9
201:3‐4
201:7‐8
201:10‐202:7
202:23‐25
203:5‐8
223:6‐11
227:8‐9
227:11‐12
227:14‐228:8
5:5‐22

Coster, Daniel

10/27/2011

15:12‐14

Coster, Daniel

10/27/2011

15:18‐16:4

APPLE OBJECTIONS
vague
vague
vague
misleading; 403
misleading; 402; 403
misleading; 402; 403
misleading; 402; 403
misleading; 402; 403; 802; 
1002
misleading; 402; 403; 802; 
1002
misleading; 402; 403; 802; 
1002
form; misleading; 402; 403; 
802; 1002
foundation; speculation
foundation; speculation
misleading; 402; 403
foundation
foundation
misleading; 402; 403
vague; 402; 403
vague; 402; 403
vague; 402; 403

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

143:3‐8
143:12‐144:14
143:12‐144:14
143:12‐144:14

200:1‐7

222:22‐223:5

Calls for Legal Concluson; 
Calls for Expert Testimony; 
402
Calls for Legal Concluson; 
Calls for Expert Testimony; 
402

29

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Coster, Daniel
Coster, Daniel

DATE

10/27/2011
10/27/2011

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

16:7‐19
23:15‐18

Coster, Daniel

10/27/2011

30:22‐32:4

Coster, Daniel

10/27/2011

36:5‐37:6

Coster, Daniel
Coster, Daniel ITC‐796
Coster, Daniel ITC‐796

10/27/2011
2/7/2012
2/7/2012

50:14‐52:22
227:10‐13
227:19‐25

Coster, Daniel ITC‐796

2/7/2012

229:21‐23

Coster, Daniel ITC‐796
Coster, Daniel ITC‐796

2/7/2012
2/7/2012

230:4
230:11‐14

Coster, Daniel ITC‐796

2/7/2012

231:2‐10

Coster, Daniel ITC‐796

2/7/2012

231:13‐18

Coster, Daniel ITC‐796

2/7/2012

232:4‐6

Coster, Daniel ITC‐796

2/7/2012

238:2‐240:21

APPLE OBJECTIONS
Calls for Legal Concluson; 
Calls for Expert Testimony; 
402

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

21:14‐18; 21:20‐23:14

Leading; Speculation; Calls 
for Legal Conclusion; 1002
33:13‐20
Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation; Calls for 
Expert Testimony; 
Speculation
Calls for Speculation; Calls for 
Expert Testimony; Lacks 
49:19‐50:12
Foundation; 402
226:13‐16
Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation 
Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation 
230:15‐17
Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation; Calls for 
Speculation
Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation; Calls for 
Speculation
Lacks Foundation; 
Incomplete

Misstates Testimony; 
Misleading; Vague

263:10‐16

232:7‐13
131:7‐132:8; 132:9‐13; 
132:15‐136:14; 136:17‐21; 
151:24‐153:1; 155:6‐156:9; 
183:2‐7; 234:20‐235:7

30

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Coster, Daniel ITC‐796
Coster, Daniel ITC‐796
De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele

2/7/2012
2/7/2012
10/21/2011
10/21/2011
10/21/2011
10/21/2011
10/21/2011
10/21/2011
10/21/2011
10/21/2011

241:1‐242:2
245:22‐246:4
76:23‐77:10
78:3‐16
79:10‐80:1
80:3‐5
140:1‐2
140:5‐11
140:13‐25
141:4‐10

De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele

10/21/2011
10/21/2011
10/21/2011

157:3‐10
157:14‐158:3
158:8‐18

De Iuliis, Daniele

10/21/2011

158:21‐159:1

De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele

10/21/2011
10/21/2011
10/21/2011
10/21/2011
10/21/2011

159:3‐8
159:10‐12
164:18‐20
164:23‐25
165:2‐3

De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele

10/21/2011
10/21/2011

165:20‐21
166:2‐5

De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele

10/21/2011
10/21/2011
10/21/2011

170:10‐13
170:16‐17
185:10‐25

APPLE OBJECTIONS
Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation; Calls for 
Speculation

Vague; 402
Vague; 402

402; Vague
Vague; 
402
Vague;
402

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

242:3‐10; 242:25‐243:7

`
141:12‐14; 141:17‐142:2;
156:8‐9; 156:15‐21; 156:24‐
157:1
158:5‐6

159:14‐17; 159:21‐160:5

Calls for Legal Conclusion, 
Lacks Foundation;
402

165:5‐18

Lacks Foundation;
402

170:19‐20; 170:23‐24; 
171:10‐14

31

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele

De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele

DATE

10/21/2011
10/21/2011

10/21/2011
10/21/2011

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

187:20‐188:10
188:14

188:24‐189:1
189:5‐15

De Iuliis, Daniele

10/21/2011

190:4‐10

De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele

10/21/2011
10/21/2011
10/21/2011
10/21/2011

191:5‐19
191:21‐22
192:2‐6
192:6‐11

De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele
De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796
De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796

10/21/2011
10/21/2011
10/21/2011
10/21/2011
10/21/2011
10/21/2011
10/21/2011
2/22/2012
2/22/2012

192:13‐24
193:5‐6
194:13‐16
195:4‐5
195:8‐14
195:17‐21
195:24‐25
5:9‐25
41:13‐42:21

De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/22/2012

51:4‐11

De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796
De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/22/2012
2/22/2012

135:15‐136:11
145:1‐9

APPLE OBJECTIONS
Vague; Lacks Foundation, 
Calls for Legal Conclusion;
402

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

Vague; Lacks Foundation, 
Calls for Legal Conclusion;
402
189:16‐17; 189:21
Vague; Lacks Foundation, 
Calls for Legal Conclusion;
402
Vague; Lacks Foundation, 
Calls for Legal Conclusion;
402

Vague; Lacks Foundation, 
Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
402 

Vague, Lacks Foundation

49:12‐17; 49:19; 
51:20‐52:5; 52:7‐15; 52:17
132:20‐133:4; 133:6‐10; 
133:13‐15; 133:18‐24; 
Overbroad; Lacks Foundation 134:1‐14; 134:17‐21

Vague

32

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796

DATE
2/22/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
145:17‐20

De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/22/2012

146:5‐7

De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/22/2012

146:9‐11

De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/22/2012

146:13‐15

De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/22/2012

146:17‐147:1

De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/22/2012

147:3‐8

De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796
De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796
De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796
De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796
De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796
De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796
De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796
De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012

147:10‐20
157:16‐18
157:20‐158:7
158:9‐13
158:15
160:11‐18
160:25‐161:2
161:4‐7

De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796

De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796

De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796
De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796

De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/22/2012

2/22/2012

2/22/2012
2/22/2012

2/22/2012

APPLE OBJECTIONS

161:22‐162:5
162:7‐10

162:12‐14

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

Lacks Foundation;
402; Misleading
Lacks Foundation;
402; Misleading
Lacks Foundation;
402; Misleading
Lacks Foundation;
402; Misleading
Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Testimony
Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Testimony
Vague
Vague
Vague

163:17; 163:19‐164:1; 
164:3‐5

161:11‐12

161:14‐20

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

Calls for Legal 
Conclusion,Calls for Expert 
Testimony; Lacks Foundation
Calls for Legal 
Conclusion,Calls for Expert 
Testimony; Lacks Foundation

Calls for Legal 
Conclusion,Calls for Expert 
Testimony; Lacks Foundation
33

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796

De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796
De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796

De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796

De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796

DATE

2/22/2012

2/22/2012
2/22/2012

2/22/2012

2/22/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

162:16‐163:2

163:4‐11
163:13‐15

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

Calls for Legal 
Conclusion,Calls for Expert 
Testimony; Lacks Foundation
Calls for Legal 
Conclusion,Calls for Expert 
Testimony; Lacks Foundation

164:7‐10

Calls for Legal Conclusion, 
Calls for Expert Testimony; 
Lacks Foundation

164:12‐19

Calls for Legal Conclusion, 
Calls for Expert Testimony; 
Lacks Foundation

De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/22/2012

164:21‐165:11

De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796
De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796
De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012

165:13‐23
166:5‐19
182:3‐4

De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796
De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796
De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012

182:6‐22
199:15‐18
199:21‐200:4

De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796
De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796
De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012

200:9‐201:5
201:7‐14
222:4‐17

Calls for Legal 
Conclusion,Calls for Expert 
Testimony; Lacks Foundation 165:20‐23; 165:25‐166:3
Vague; Calls for Legal 
Conclusion; 402; 403
Lacks Foundation
Lacks Foundation
Lacks question

190:7‐10; 190:12‐18; 
193:22‐194:1; 194:3‐6
199:2‐13

Vague;
402; 403
201:16‐202:15
402, 403

34

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796
De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/22/2012
2/22/2012

222:24‐223:5
223:7‐9

De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/22/2012

226:6‐8

De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796
De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796
De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796
De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796
De Iuliis, Daniele Vol 1 ITC‐796
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger

2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011

226:10‐17
226:19‐20
230:2‐3
230:5‐10
230:12‐14
7:17‐19
8:23‐9:20
11:14‐12:5
12:17‐13:5
13:10‐18
23:15‐18
23:21‐24
24:4‐10
25:14‐25
26:2
26:4‐7
26:10‐13
26:16‐27:14
27:18‐20
27:24‐29:11
29:23‐30:3
30:6
30:21‐24
38:9‐11
38:18‐21
38:24‐39:3
39:10‐40:18
48:6‐15

APPLE OBJECTIONS
Vague; Lacks Foundation; 
Calls for Legal Conclusion;
402, 403

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

223:11‐16

Calls for Legal Conclusion 
Lacks Foundation
Calls for Legal Conclusion 
Lacks Foundation
231:10‐15

23:25‐24:3
24:11‐24
25:11‐13
26:7‐9

30:7‐20
38:12‐17

47:23‐48:5
35

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations

Fidler, Roger

DATE
9/23/2011

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
48:18‐49:2

Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger

9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011

49:14‐50:7
62:9‐63:5
70:12‐25
72:4‐7
73:12‐14
82:8‐16
84:11‐85:11
87:21‐88:11
88:16‐23
93:10‐12
95:23‐96:4
96:11‐19
97:6‐98:1
99:24‐101:8
104:12‐15
106:21‐22
106:25
107:6‐13
123:24‐124:4
124:7‐11
125:14‐126:13
128:23‐25
138:12‐20
139:1‐140:11
141:23‐144:8
144:12‐145:16
146:1‐2
146:8‐147:2
148:19‐149:18
150:3‐153:1
155:22‐159:4
160:21‐161:20
162:17‐163:2

WITNESS

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

49:10‐13; 52:4‐9; 52:23‐
53:6

91:11‐18; 93:13
96:20‐97:5

106:13‐17

36

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger

Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger

DATE
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011

9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011
9/23/2011

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
164:1‐6
164:23‐165:2
165:8‐22
171:24‐172:3
173:23‐174:2
174:16‐180:7
189:22‐24
190:5‐192:14
192:18‐25
195:21‐196:2
198:25‐200:8
208:15‐209:24
257:10‐18
290:4‐293:4
293:9‐295:20
295:23‐296:5

296:8‐297:13
297:25‐299:9
301:6‐302:20
303:22‐305:25
306:20‐24
307:1‐2
307:19‐24
308:2‐309:1
309:3‐4
309:6
309:25‐311:3
310:9‐22
311:5‐7
311:9
314:7‐315:22
316:1‐2

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

196:3‐14; 196:3‐16
200:9‐201:6

Best Evidence; Document 
speaks for itself; FRE 402; 
vague; misleading; Lacks 
foundation

37

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger

DATE
9/23/2011
9/23/2011

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
316:4‐24
317:2‐3

Fidler, Roger

9/23/2011

323:9‐324:8

Fidler, Roger

9/23/2011

324:16‐17

Fidler, Roger

9/23/2011

324:21‐23

Fidler, Roger

9/23/2011

325:1

Fidler, Roger

9/23/2011

332:1‐3

Fidler, Roger

9/23/2011

332:7‐21

Fidler, Roger
Fidler, Roger
Forlines, Clifton ITC‐797
Forlines, Clifton ITC‐797

9/23/2011
9/23/2011
3/8/2012
3/8/2012

332:24‐333:4
333:19‐335:17
6:5‐9
8:3‐6

APPLE OBJECTIONS

None
None

3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012

63:21‐64:2
64:8‐13
69:12‐23

Lacks foundation
None
Incomplete

Forlines, Clifton ITC‐797

3/8/2012

71:19‐72:3

Forlines, Clifton ITC‐797

3/8/2012

98:4‐21

None
1002; 
Not trial exhibit; 402; 
Incomplete
Leading; lacks foundation; 

Forlines, Clifton ITC‐797

3/8/2012

109:15‐113:5

3/8/2012

125:14‐129:22

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony

Forlines, Clifton ITC‐797
Forlines, Clifton ITC‐797
Forlines, Clifton ITC‐797

Forlines, Clifton ITC‐797

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

14:9‐12; 14:14‐20; 
23:25‐24:8; 24:10‐11; 42:9‐
14; 42:17‐18
65:6‐12
69:7‐11; 70:3‐5
83:3‐9; 87:16‐18; 
87:20
98:23‐24; 99:6‐7; 
99:16‐17; 99:19‐20
108:19‐109:4; 
109:6‐8

Leading; 1002; Incomplete;
Not trial exhibit; 402; 403; 
lacks foundation
38

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Forlines, Clifton ITC‐797

DATE
3/8/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
129:25‐131:9

Forlines, Clifton ITC‐797

3/8/2012

153:1‐154:9

Forlines, Clifton ITC‐797

3/8/2012

155:9‐157:2

Forlines, Clifton ITC‐797
Gosler, Jared
Gosler, Jared
Gosler, Jared
Gosler, Jared
Gosler, Jared
Gosler, Jared
Gosler, Jared
Gosler, Jared

3/8/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012

209:7‐24
7:3‐9
22:18‐19
34:22‐35:3
51:12‐15
52:1‐6
89:15‐24
92:19‐25
114:3‐11

Gosler, Jared
Gosler, Jared
Gosler, Jared

2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012

115:7‐9
138:2‐16
151:25‐152:3

Gosler, Jared
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson

2/22/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012

168:4‐11
18:2‐6
27:9‐28:2
36:18‐37:13
37:24‐38:11
39:13‐24
41:18‐42:4
42:19‐43:1
44:2‐24
44:6‐9
45:24‐46:8
56:10‐14
57:5‐8

APPLE OBJECTIONS
Leading
Leading; 1002; 802; 
lacks foundation
Leading; Incomplete;
Not trial exhibit; 1002; Lacks 
foundation
Leading; 
Lacks foundation

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

incomplete
FRE 402, FRE 403, FRE 602
FRE 402, FRE 403
FRE 402, FRE 403

51:7‐11

FRE 402, FRE 403, 
ambiguous, incomplete
FRE 403, FRE 602
FRE 403, FRE 602 

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

114:12‐18, 114:20‐115:1, 
115:3‐4 

FRE 403, FRE 602, 
foundation, incomplete

167:13‐22, 167:24‐168:1, 
168:3‐11 (subject to 
objection) 

402; 403

misleading; 402; 403

39:5‐12

misleading; 402; 403

43:2‐44:1

39

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations

Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson

DATE
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
59:16‐60:4
63:9‐25
68:7‐8

Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson

2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012

71:22‐72:3
73:24‐74:15
78:11‐15
88:23‐90:8
93:1‐11
111:15‐112:23
113:23‐119:17
121:24‐134:5
136:21‐137:4
142:11‐22
145:17‐147:3

Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Han, Jefferson
Hieta, Saku
Hieta, Saku
Hieta, Saku
Hieta, Saku
Hieta, Saku
Hieta, Saku
Hieta, Saku
Hieta, Saku
Hieta, Saku
Hieta, Saku
Hieta, Saku

2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
7/13/2012
7/13/2012
7/13/2012
7/13/2012
7/13/2012
7/13/2012
7/13/2012
7/13/2012
7/13/2012
7/13/2012
7/13/2012

148:17‐156:13
196:3‐18
199:25‐200:19
201:17‐21
204:8‐11
205:23‐206:5
211:16‐21
216:19‐217:12
7:20‐22
8:4‐7
8:22‐9:12
12:5‐19
12:21‐13:24
14:2‐9
14:13‐20
14:22‐25
15:16‐20
15:23‐16:14
16:16‐17:2

WITNESS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS
60:5‐61:7
64:1‐8, 218:17‐221:8

APPLE OBJECTIONS
misleading; 402; 403
misleading; 403; 1002
402; 403
403; 403; vague; assumes 
facts

72:4‐73:3

vague; 402; 403; 1002
402; 403; 1002
402; 403; 1002
402; 403; 802; 1002
402; 403; 802; 1002

119:18‐120:7
134:6‐135:23

402; 403; 1002
402; 403; 1002
402; 403; 802; 1002; 
speculation
vague
vague
misleading; 402; 403

200:20‐201:16
201:22‐202:18, 204:2‐7

misleading; 403; vague
misleading; 402; 403
misleading; 402; 403

205:5‐22
212:18‐213:25
217:19‐24

602
602

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

15:1‐9

40

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations

Hieta, Saku
Hieta, Saku
Hieta, Saku
Hieta, Saku
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin

DATE
7/13/2012
7/13/2012
7/13/2012
7/13/2012
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
17:4‐5
17:7‐10
19:2‐10
27:23‐29:5
5:13‐16
5:20‐6:1
7:9‐8:17
16:14‐17:12
18:11‐14
21:11‐22:5

Hoellwarth, Quin

10/25/2011

22:23‐25

lack of foundation, 402, 403

Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin

10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011

23:3‐10
25:8‐26:4
26:7‐11
26:15‐18
26:20‐24
27:3
27:7‐11
39:15‐20
39:23‐40:2
40:5
78:20‐24
80:6‐10
81:11‐16
81:23‐82:3
96:2‐13
96:17
100:24‐101:3
101:10‐18
102:5‐13
103:9‐19

 lack of foundation, 402, 403

WITNESS

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

21:25‐23:14; 27:3‐19
402

402, 403
402, 403
402, 403

41

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin
Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796

DATE
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
10/25/2011
1/11/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
104:2‐4
109:7‐19
110:6‐10
116:25‐117:4
117:8
117:25‐119:2
121:21‐122:16
123:7‐23
149:4‐15
194:12‐14
194:17‐18
220:10‐12
235:7‐21
237:2‐8
237:10‐14
237:16
238:18‐239:5
239:11‐13
261:7‐15
261:19
262:24‐263:2
263:5
273:17‐25
284:22‐285:5
285:12‐14
285:17‐18
285:21‐25
287:24‐288:17
289:5‐24
290:19‐23
291:10‐13
291:19‐21
291:24‐292:5
292:8
5:15‐18

APPLE OBJECTIONS
402, 403

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

109:20‐110:5
109:20‐110:5

1002
1002
1002
402, 403
402, 403
402, 403
402, 403, 702
Vague, 402, 403, 702
402, 403, 702
402, 403
402, 403
402, 403
402, 403
402, 403
402, 403
402, 403
402, 403, 1002
402, 403
402, 403
402, 403

291:14‐18
402, 403
402, 403
402, 403

42

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796
Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796
Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796
Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796
Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796
Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796
Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796
Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796

DATE
1/11/2012
1/11/2012
1/11/2012
1/11/2012
1/11/2012
1/11/2012
1/11/2012
1/11/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
7:6‐9
22:18‐23:8
29:12‐25
34:2‐13
34:18‐20
34:25‐35:14
36:18‐37:11
102:2‐25

Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796

1/11/2012

135:21‐136:2

Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796

1/11/2012

136:5‐6

Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796
Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796

1/11/2012
1/11/2012

136:18‐22
136:25‐137:5

Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796

1/11/2012

141:20‐23

Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796
Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796
Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796
Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796

1/11/2012
1/11/2012
1/11/2012
1/11/2012

142:4‐9
142:13
145:24‐146:15
183:17‐21

Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796
Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796
Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796
Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796
Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796
Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796
Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796
Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796
Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796
Hoellwarth, Quin ITC‐796

1/11/2012
1/11/2012
1/11/2012
1/11/2012
1/11/2012
1/11/2012
1/11/2012
1/11/2012
1/11/2012
1/11/2012

243:15‐244:7
253:25‐255:18
257:12‐22
258:6‐259:19
267:9‐11
267:19‐24
268:9‐15
268:25‐269:16
273:18‐25
277:6‐14

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

1002
1002
1002
1002
1002
1002

Lacks foundation, 402, 403, 
702, 1002
Lacks foundation, 402, 403, 
702, 1002
Lacks foundation, 
speculation; 402, 403, 702
See previous
Lacks foundation, 
speculation; 402, 403, 702
Lacks foundation, 
speculation; 402, 403, 702
See previous
1002
402, 403
incomplete q/a (instructed 
not to answer)
1002
1002
1002
1002
1002
1002
1002

131:7‐14; 132:16‐133:3; 
134:11‐12; 134:14‐20; 
134:22‐135:2; 135:4‐7; 
135:10‐12

1002
43

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796

DATE
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
36:15‐22
60:5‐24
78:13‐20
79:23‐80:15
82:4‐9
106:11‐108:6
116:17‐19

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/23/2012

116:21‐118:22

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/23/2012

118:24‐119:13

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/23/2012

119:15‐21

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/23/2012

119:23‐120:2

Vague
Lacks foundation; Vague; 
Assumes facts
Lacks foundation; Vague; 
Assumes facts
Lacks foundation; Vague; 
Assumes facts
Lacks foundation; Vague; 
Assumes facts

2/23/2012

132:16‐20

Misleading; Incomplete

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/23/2012

132:22‐133:2

Misleading; Incomplete

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012

133:4‐5
134:7‐19
135:11‐19
136:5‐6
136:8‐10

Misleading; Incomplete

2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012

137:16‐138:3
139:7‐16
139:25‐140:12
141:11‐142:17
142:20‐143:1
143:3‐12

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

9:2‐4

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS

126:5‐7, 126:9‐25, 127:2‐4; 
128:9‐11, 128:13‐129:16, 
130:21‐131:12
126:5‐7, 126:9‐25, 127:2‐4; 
128:9‐11, 128:13‐129:16, 
130:21‐131:12
126:5‐7, 126:9‐25, 127:2‐4; 
128:9‐11, 128:13‐129:16, 
130:21‐131:12

Beyond scope; Lacks 
foundation; Speculation 

Argumentative
44

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796

DATE
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
143:14‐18
143:20‐144:1
144:14‐18
146:12‐147:5

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/23/2012

149:16‐20

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/23/2012

150:8‐10

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012

150:12‐15
152:8‐11
152:13‐153:19

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

Incomplete; Lacks 
foundation; Speculation
Vague; Lacks foundation; 
Speculation
Vague; Lacks foundation; 
Speculation
Vague

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/23/2012
2/23/2012

158:19‐160:3
165:5‐10

FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii) (exhibit 
not on pretrial list); FRE 1002
Incomplete

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012

174:6‐12
181:9‐20
181:22‐182:12
193:7‐15

Lacks foundation; FRE 1002
Beyond scope
Beyond scope
Beyond scope

217:11‐218:18

FRE 802; Admission of and 
testimony regarding exhibit is 
made subject to objections 
noted on Apple’s objections 
to Samsung’s exhibit list

224:6‐225:13

FRE 402; FRE 802; Admission 
of and testimony regarding 
exhibit is made subject to 
objections noted on Apple’s 
objections to Samsung’s 
226:14‐19 (subject to 
exhibit list
objections)

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/23/2012

2/23/2012

45

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012

227:5‐14
236:22‐237:6
237:8‐238:21
238:25‐239:23
240:3‐5
240:18‐23
241:20‐242:1

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012

247:1‐12
257:2‐9
263:25‐264:10
274:22‐275:18
275:20‐24
276:7‐11
277:3‐6

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796

2/24/2012

347:9‐22

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796

2/24/2012
2/24/2012

348:7‐22
348:24‐349:1

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796

2/24/2012

358:15‐20

APPLE OBJECTIONS
Beyond scope; Lacks 
foundation

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS
226:14‐19 (subject to 
objections)

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402
Beyond scope; FRE 402; Not 
testimony
256:11‐23, 262:11‐263:24
264:11‐17
273:20‐274:21

276:12‐22
FRE 802; Admission of and 
testimony regarding exhibit is 
made subject to objections 
noted on Apple’s objections 
to Samsung’s exhibit list

FRE 802; Beyond scope; Lacks 
foundation; Admission of and 
testimony regarding exhibit is 
made subject to objections 
noted on Apple’s objections 
to Samsung’s exhibit list

FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii) (exhibit 
not on pretrial list); FRE 1002

46

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796

2/24/2012

358:24‐25

FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii) (exhibit 
not on pretrial list); FRE 1002

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796

2/24/2012

359:2‐5

FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii) (exhibit 
not on pretrial list); FRE 1002

359:7‐10

FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii) (exhibit 
not on pretrial list); FRE 1002

366:8‐21

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii) (exhibit  366:22‐24, 367:1‐24 
not on pretrial list); FRE 1002 (subject to objections)

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796

2/24/2012

2/24/2012

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796

2/24/2012

381:5‐10

FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii) (exhibit 
not on pretrial list); FRE 1002

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796

2/24/2012

381:12‐22

FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii) (exhibit 
not on pretrial list); FRE 1002

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796

2/24/2012

382:3‐18

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796

2/24/2012

384:16‐385:15

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796

2/24/2012

385:19‐386:2

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796

2/24/2012

387:17‐389:5

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796

2/24/2012

390:25‐391:7

FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii) (exhibit 
not on pretrial list); FRE 1002
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii) (exhibit 
not on pretrial list); FRE 1002;  385:16‐22, 386:3‐9 
FRE 802
(subject to objections)
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii) (exhibit 
not on pretrial list); FRE 1002;  385:16‐18, 386:3‐9 
(subject to objections)
FRE 802
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii) (exhibit 
not on pretrial list); FRE 1002; 
FRE 802
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii) (exhibit 
not on pretrial list); FRE 1002; 
FRE 802

47

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796

DATE

2/24/2012

2/24/2012

2/24/2012

2/24/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

398:9‐399:6

APPLE OBJECTIONS
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii) (exhibit 
not on pretrial list); FRE 1002; 
FRE 802

402:16‐403:4

FRE 802; Admission of and 
testimony regarding exhibit is 
made subject to objections 
noted on Apple’s objections 
to Samsung’s exhibit list

411:18‐412:6

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

Admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list

410:17‐411:9

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

FRE 802; Admission of and 
testimony regarding exhibit is 
made subject to objections 
noted on Apple’s objections 
to Samsung’s exhibit list

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796

2/24/2012

415:9‐417:6

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796

2/24/2012

418:24‐420:8

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796

2/24/2012

420:10‐11

FRE 802; Admission of and 
testimony regarding exhibit is 
made subject to objections 
noted on Apple’s objections 
to Samsung’s exhibit list
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii) (exhibit 
not on pretrial list); FRE 1002; 
FRE 802
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii) (exhibit 
not on pretrial list); FRE 1002; 
FRE 802

48

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 802; Admission of and 
testimony regarding exhibit is 
made subject to objections 
noted on Apple’s objections 
to Samsung’s exhibit list
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796

2/24/2012

421:13‐422:7

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796

2/24/2012

422:10‐23

Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796
Joswiak, Gregory Vol 2 ITC‐796
Jue, Eric
Jue, Eric
Jue, Eric
Jue, Eric
Jue, Eric

2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012

425:10‐19
430:25‐431:13
431:15‐17
440:13‐19
471:7‐23
473:4‐7
6:4‐10
19:24‐20:6
31:13‐20
32:23‐33:6
37:21‐38:1

Jue, Eric

2/24/2012

42:9‐43:9

Jue, Eric

2/24/2012

49:20‐50:4

Jue, Eric

2/24/2012

50:14‐15

Jue, Eric

2/24/2012

50:17‐18

FRE 802; Admission of and 
testimony regarding exhibit is 
made subject to objections 
noted on Apple’s objections 
to Samsung’s exhibit list
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii) (exhibit 
not on pretrial list); FRE 1002; 
FRE 802
FRE 1002; FRE 802
431:18‐20, 431:22‐432:3
FRE 1002; FRE 802
431:18‐20, 431:22‐432:3
FRE 1002; FRE 802
472:18‐25

41:19‐42:8; 43:10‐12; 
43:14‐15
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation
49:2‐10
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation

49

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Jue, Eric

2/24/2012

51:3‐52:9

Jue, Eric

2/24/2012

74:1‐25

APPLE OBJECTIONS
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony

Jue, Eric

2/24/2012

102:11‐105:13

Jue, Eric

2/24/2012

108:10‐109:19

2/24/2012

121:11‐124:16

FRE 402; vague; misleading; 
lack of foundation

124:18‐128:18

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE402; vague; misleading; 
lack of foundation

Jue, Eric

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

FRE402; vague; misleading; 
lack of foundation

FRE402; vague; misleading; 
lack of foundation

Jue, Eric

DATE

2/24/2012

Jue, Eric

2/24/2012

131:6‐132:1

FRE402; vague; misleading; 
lack of foundation

Jue, Eric

2/24/2012

134:9‐135:15

FRE402; vague; misleading; 
lack of foundation

Jue, Eric

2/24/2012

190:10‐191:11

FRE402; vague; misleading; 
lack of foundation

Jue, Eric

2/24/2012

191:24‐192:13

FRE402; vague; misleading; 
lack of foundation

192:23‐193:18

FRE402; vague; misleading; 
lack of foundation

197:25‐198:12

FRE402; vague; misleading; 
lack of foundation

Jue, Eric

Jue, Eric

2/24/2012

2/24/2012

50

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS

Jue, Eric

2/24/2012

198:25‐199:16

2/24/2012

200:14‐18

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE402; vague; misleading; 
lack of foundation

Jue, Eric

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

FRE402; vague; misleading; 
lack of foundation

Jue, Eric
Kerr, Duncan
Kerr, Duncan

2/24/2012 201:14‐203:23
10/26/2011 8:15‐19
10/26/2011 11:20‐21

Kerr, Duncan

10/26/2011 12:25‐13:6

Kerr, Duncan

10/26/2011 13:10‐13

Kerr, Duncan

10/26/2011 13:18‐24

Kerr, Duncan

10/26/2011 14:1‐5

Kerr, Duncan

10/26/2011 14:10‐16

Kerr, Duncan

10/26/2011 14:20‐24

Kerr, Duncan

10/26/2011 15:1‐6

Kerr, Duncan

10/26/2011 15:8‐13

Kerr, Duncan

10/26/2011 15:16‐25

Kerr, Duncan

10/26/2011 18:11‐13

Kerr, Duncan

10/26/2011 18:17‐18

Kerr, Duncan

10/26/2011 23:22‐24:2

FRE402; vague; misleading; 
lack of foundation

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
51

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Kerr, Duncan

10/26/2011 24:6‐14

Kerr, Duncan

10/26/2011 24:21‐23

Kerr, Duncan

10/26/2011 26:1‐4

Kerr, Duncan

10/26/2011 26:6‐9

Kerr, Duncan

10/26/2011 26:12‐19

Kerr, Duncan

10/26/2011 26:24‐27:2

Kerr, Duncan
Kerr, Duncan

10/26/2011 27:4‐23
10/26/2011 28:1

Kerr, Duncan

10/26/2011 28:6‐9

Kerr, Duncan

10/26/2011 28:12‐19

Kerr, Duncan

10/26/2011 28:21‐25

Kerr, Duncan

10/26/2011 29:6‐10

Kerr, Duncan

10/26/2011 29:14‐21

Kerr, Duncan
Kerr, Duncan

10/26/2011 29:25‐30:6
10/26/2011 76:20‐22

Kerr, Duncan
Kerr, Duncan
Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796
Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796
Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796

10/26/2011
10/26/2011
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012

76:25‐77:4
77:6
5:15‐25
9:23‐25
10:11‐11:1

APPLE OBJECTIONS
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

39:17‐19; 39:21‐25

FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation

14:5‐7; 14:13‐18; 15:10‐14; 
15:17
52

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796
Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796

Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796

Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796

Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796

Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796

Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796

DATE
2/22/2012
2/22/2012

2/22/2012

2/22/2012

2/22/2012

2/22/2012

2/22/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
34:23‐24
35:7‐9

APPLE OBJECTIONS

36:3‐4

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

37:9‐11

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

53:4‐9

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

53:12‐15

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

36:11‐37:6

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation
FRE 402; misleading; vague; 
lack of foundation

Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796

2/22/2012

53:18

Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796
Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796

2/22/2012
2/22/2012

93:9‐94:2
94:5

Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796

2/22/2012

94:16‐22

FRE 402; misleading; vague; 
lack of foundation

102:14‐15

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796

2/22/2012

94:6‐7; 94:10‐14

53

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796

DATE

2/22/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

105:9‐106:3

Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796

2/22/2012

106:6‐14

Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796

2/22/2012

107:11‐18

Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796
Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796
Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796
Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796
Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796
Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796

2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012
2/22/2012

107:22‐23
129:10‐12
130:22‐131:9
133:20‐25
138:6‐11
138:14‐16

Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796

2/22/2012

141:3‐7

Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796

2/22/2012

147:14‐18

Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796

2/22/2012

148:4‐14

Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796

2/22/2012

148:17‐149:2

Kerr, Duncan ITC‐796
Lutton, Richard

2/22/2012
7/26/2011

149:4‐6
5:19‐6:1

Lutton, Richard
Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011
7/26/2011

6:14‐7:4
8:21‐9:3

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation
107:15‐23 (Incomplete 
110:22‐112:3; 114:20‐
hypothetical; FRE 402)
115:21
FRE 402; misleading; vague; 
lack of foundation
131:10‐12; 131:15‐19
134:1‐3; 134:6‐7
138:17‐23
FRE 402; misleading; vague; 
lack of foundation
141:8‐11; 141:14‐22
FRE 402; misleading; vague; 
lack of foundation
FRE 402; misleading; vague; 
lack of foundation
FRE 402; misleading; vague; 
lack of foundation
FRE 402; misleading; vague; 
lack of foundation
None
misleading
incomplete
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
None

144:2‐12; 144: 15‐19; 
147:19‐20; 147:23‐148:2

149:8‐20; 149:23‐24

7:5‐8:10

54

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
9:21‐10:6
11:6‐16

Lutton, Richard
Lutton, Richard
Lutton, Richard
Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011
7/26/2011
7/26/2011
7/26/2011

28:6‐10
38:20‐39:3
39:7‐9
40:1‐6

APPLE OBJECTIONS
None
None
FRE 402
FRE 403
incomplete
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
FRE 402
FRE 403
incomplete
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
Incomplete
None
Incomplete

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

48:2‐19

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

48:22‐23

7/26/2011
7/26/2011
7/26/2011

49:19‐21
50:17‐24
51:5‐53:8

Lutton, Richard
Lutton, Richard
Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011
7/26/2011
7/26/2011

54:17‐55:4
64:25‐65:2
65:5‐7

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

65:13‐25

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002

Lutton, Richard
Lutton, Richard
Lutton, Richard

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002

Lutton, Richard
Lutton, Richard

Lutton, Richard

DATE
7/26/2011
7/26/2011

7/26/2011

28:2‐4

Incomplete
FRE 802
Asked and answered
None
FRE 402
FRE 403 
FRE 408 
FRE 802
FRE 402
FRE 402
FRE 402
FRE 1002

27:6‐10; 27:17‐21; 27:23‐
28:1 (subject to objections)

27:6‐10; 27:17‐21; 27:23‐
28:1 (subject to objections)
36:21‐37:19; 37:23‐38:2
41:2‐8

49:6‐18; 49:22‐23; 50:1‐16 
(subject to objections)

55

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

66:11‐21

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

69:10‐12

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

70:3‐6

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

82:21‐23

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

83:2‐11

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

83:20‐24

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

84:15‐17

Lutton, Richard
Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011
7/26/2011

84:20‐21
94:8‐9

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

APPLE OBJECTIONS
FRE 402
FRE 408
incomplete
FRE 1002
FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
FRE 1002
FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
FRE 1002
FRE 402 
FRE 403 
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
FRE 402 
FRE 403 
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
FRE 402 
FRE 403 
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
FRE 402 
FRE 403 
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
FRE 402
FRE 403 
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
FRE 501
FRE 402 
FRE 403 
FRE 501

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

66:22‐67:22; 68:13‐25 
(subject to objections)

94:17‐95:9

56

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Lutton, Richard

Lutton, Richard

Lutton, Richard
Lutton, Richard

DATE

7/26/2011

7/26/2011

7/26/2011
7/26/2011

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

96:5‐15

APPLE OBJECTIONS
FRE 402 
FRE 403 
FRE 501

107:14‐109:10

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

misleading or 
mischaracterizing document
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 802
FRE 1002

109:14‐110:1
118:14‐119:4

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

misleading or 
mischaracterizing document
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 802
FRE 1002
None

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

125:9‐23

Lutton, Richard
Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011
7/26/2011

126:1‐20
129:12‐22

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

130:7‐19

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

132:4‐16

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

135:10‐136:6

incomplete 
misleading
FRE 802
incomplete 
misleading 
FRE 802
FRE 802
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
Incomplete 
misleading
FRE 802

124:17‐125:8; 126:21‐
127:20 (subject to 
objections)
126:21‐127:20 (subject to 
objections)

135:3‐9

57

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

136:8‐17

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

141:15‐142:2

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

142:6‐21

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

143:2‐13

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

151:8‐152:13

Lutton, Richard
Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011
7/26/2011

161:13‐162:16
165:22‐166:17

APPLE OBJECTIONS
FRE 402 
FRE 403
FRE 802
FRE 402
FRE 403
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
legal conclusion
asked and answered
FRE 802
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002 
FRE 402
FRE 403
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
legal conclusion
asked and answered
FRE 802
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002 
FRE 402
FRE 403
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
legal conclusion
asked and answered
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
FRE 402 
FRE 403
FRE 408 
asked and answered
FRE 802
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
FRE 802
None

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

58

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Lutton, Richard

DATE
7/26/2011

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
167:5‐19

APPLE OBJECTIONS
Incomplete

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS
168:3‐18

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
FRE 802
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

175:25‐177:12
FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
FRE 802
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

178:11‐24
FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
FRE 802
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

179:9‐13

59

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
FRE 802
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

179:16‐23
FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list

Lutton, Richard

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

7/26/2011

180:2‐15

188:17‐19

FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
FRE 802
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
189:2‐5; 189:8‐24 (subject 
to objections)

60

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

188:22‐24

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

195:18‐20

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

196:1‐16

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

200:17‐19

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

200:23‐25

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

201:13‐202:7

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
FRE 802
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
189:2‐5; 189:8‐24 (subject 
to objections)
FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
190:17‐192:8 (subject to 
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
objections)
FRE 402 
FRE 403 
FRE 408 
FRE 802
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
FRE 402 
FRE 403 
FRE 408 
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
FRE 402 
FRE 403 
FRE 408 
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
FRE 402 
FRE 403 
FRE 408 
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)

61

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Lutton, Richard

Lutton, Richard

Lutton, Richard

DATE

7/26/2011

7/26/2011

7/26/2011

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

203:19‐21

FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
incomplete
argumentative
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
203:16‐18 (subject to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
objections)

203:25‐204:5

FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
204:6‐205:6 (subject to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
objections)

210:15‐16

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
FRE 802
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
argumentative
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list

62

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

210:19‐211:6

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

211:11‐15

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

211:18‐212:1

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
FRE 802
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
argumentative
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
FRE 402 
FRE 403 
FRE 408 
beyond scope of 30(b)(6) 
FRE 501
FRE 402 
FRE 403 
FRE 408 
beyond scope of 30(b)(6) 
FRE 501

212:17‐19

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
asked and answered
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

63

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

212:22‐213:1

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

225:14‐17

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

225:21‐24

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

229:16‐18

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

229:24‐230:11

APPLE OBJECTIONS
FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
FRE 501
asked and answered
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
FRE 402
FRE 403
assumes facts
incomplete
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
FRE 802
FRE 402
FRE 403
assumes facts
incomplete
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
FRE 403 
FRE 403 
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
FRE 802
FRE 403 
FRE 403 
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

222:8‐223:7 (subject to 
objections)

222:8‐223:7 (subject to 
objections)

64

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
FRE 802
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

232:19‐21
FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
FRE 802
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

232:24‐233:6
FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
FRE 802
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

238:2‐4

65

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
FRE 802
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

238:7‐19
FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
FRE 802
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

240:1‐243:25
FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
FRE 802
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

246:1‐247:8
FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
FRE 802
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

248:8‐18

66

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

253:15‐16

Lutton, Richard
Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011
7/26/2011

253:18‐254:8
255:14‐24

Lutton, Richard

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

7/26/2011

268:8‐269:11

310:9‐13

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

310:15‐20

Lutton, Richard

7/26/2011

336:11‐20

APPLE OBJECTIONS
FRE 402 
FRE 403 
FRE 408
FRE 802
FRE 402 
FRE 403 
FRE 408
FRE 802
None
FRE 802
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
Incomplete
402
408
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
Incomplete
402
408
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii)
FRE 1002
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
FRE 402
FRE 403
hypothetical
legal conclusion
incomplete
FRE 501

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

307:16‐17; 307:25‐308:8; 
309:14‐310:2 (subject to 
objections)

307:16‐17; 307:25‐308:8; 
309:14‐310:2 (subject to 
objections)

336:6‐10

67

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Lutton, Richard
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794

DATE

7/26/2011
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

337:1‐20
7:11‐20
8:5‐15
13:22‐14:3
15:6‐12
23:7‐18
23:21‐24:5
24:8‐14
25:23‐26:5
35:6‐36:15
36:17‐37:13
38:25‐39:25
40:19‐41:1
42:21‐24
43:6‐12
47:23‐25
48:4‐14
54:13‐55:1
56:23‐25
57:5‐8
57:15‐58:8
58:19‐59:8
66:7‐10
67:2‐12
70:23‐71:6
76:4‐8
79:6‐22
86:23‐87:2

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
FRE 402
FRE 403
hypothetical
legal conclusion
incomplete
FRE 501

336:6‐10

incomplete

14:4‐15:5

incomplete

21:20‐23:6

incomplete

37:14‐38:6

incomplete
incomplete

43:14‐21
48:1‐3

incomplete
incomplete

55:3‐56:22
57:1‐4

incomplete

58:9‐18

incomplete
incomplete

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

76:9‐18
79:23‐80:23

68

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794

2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012

87:5‐11
92:13‐22
93:25‐94:6
95:18‐96:17
99:17‐100:4
100:14‐20
103:6‐14
104:2‐13
104:19‐21

Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794

2/29/2012

106:12‐107:1

Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794

2/29/2012

112:3‐9

Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794

2/29/2012

112:12‐19

Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794

2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012

112:21‐22
115:14‐22
116:2‐3
117:14‐16
117:20‐23
118:1‐3
119:5‐10

Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794

2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012

119:13‐19
119:24‐120:2
120:16‐20
126:12‐14
126:18‐23

Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794

2/29/2012
2/29/2012

132:2‐8
132:10‐14

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS
asked and answered; 
speculation; ambigous; 
incomplete
incomplete
incomplete
incomplete
1002
1002; incomplete

100:21‐101:13

1002; incomplete

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

104:14‐18

1002; 802; speculation; 
incomplete
assumes facts; 
mischaracterization
assumes facts; 
mischaracterization
assumes facts; 
mischaracterization
incomplete

incomplete
overbroad; ambiguous
lacks foundation; 
speculation; incomplete
incomplete
incomplete
assumes facts; 802

87:13‐88:24
92:23‐93:24
94:7‐95:17; 97:2‐3
96:18‐22

107:2‐24

115:2‐13

118:5‐119:4

93:25‐96:22
93:25‐96:22
120:21‐24

402; lacks foundation; 
ambiguous

69

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794

2/29/2012

132:21‐133:1

Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794

2/29/2012
2/29/2012

144:7‐10
144:17‐20

Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794

2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012

146:2‐148:22
150:3‐20
152:23‐25
153:16‐19
157:23‐25
158:6‐7
158:10‐13
158:15
158:18‐22

Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794

2/29/2012

159:24‐160:5

Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794

2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012

160:7‐161:12
161:15‐17
169:14‐20
201:5‐13
205:8‐15
209:18‐210:9
212:2‐213:10

Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794

2/29/2012

219:15‐24

Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794

2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012

222:14‐17
222:20‐223:3
224:18‐24
225:2‐7
225:17‐226:6

APPLE OBJECTIONS
402; lacks foundation; 
ambiguous
402; lacks foundatin; 802; 
overbroad

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

402; 802; ambiguous; 
speculation
incomplete
incomplete

155:15‐157:3
155:15‐157:3

402; 802; speculation; 
ambiguity
402; 802; speculation; 
ambiguity; 
mischaracterization
incomplete

161:19‐162:8

incomplete
incomplete
incomplete
402; 802

incomplete
overbroad; ambiguous; lacks 
foundation

201:14‐17; 202:15‐22
205:16‐207:1
210:10‐211:2
219:25‐220:13; 208:13‐
209:9; 209:18‐211:2; 205:8‐
207:1

70

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Lutton, Richard  ITC‐794
Ng, Stanley

DATE
2/29/2012
2/21/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
228:20‐24
23:13‐16

APPLE OBJECTIONS
incomplete

Ng, Stanley

2/21/2012

53:8‐25

FRE 402, FRE 403, ambiguous

Ng, Stanley

2/21/2012

55:11‐25

FRE 402, incomplete

Ng, Stanley
Ng, Stanley
Ng, Stanley

2/21/2012
2/21/2012
2/21/2012

57:5‐15
62:24‐63:3
70:23‐72:10

FRE 402, incomplete

Ng, Stanley
Ng, Stanley
Ng, Stanley

2/21/2012
2/21/2012
2/21/2012

75:24‐76:7
103:4‐17
105:8‐17

Ng, Stanley
Ng, Stanley
Ng, Stanley
Nishibori, Shin
Nishibori, Shin

2/21/2012
2/21/2012
2/21/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012

135:8‐136:5
144:17‐145:2
148:7‐16
6:24‐7:1
10:6‐21

Nishibori, Shin

5/2/2012

15:10‐12

Nishibori, Shin

5/2/2012

15:21‐24

Nishibori, Shin

5/2/2012

16:3‐12

Nishibori, Shin

5/2/2012

16:16‐18

Nishibori, Shin
Nishibori, Shin

5/2/2012
5/2/2012

17:5‐25
18:6‐18

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS
228:10‐14

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

54:2‐5, 54:8‐55:25 (subject 
to objection)
57:5‐23 (subject to 
objection)

75:19‐76:7 (subject to 
FRE 402, FRE 403, Incomplete objection)
FRE 402
Admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
FRE 402
FRE 402, FRE 403, FRE 602

FRE 402; misleading; lack of  13:5‐7; 13:16‐24; 14:3‐4; 
foundation; vague
14:21‐15:9
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
16:13‐15; 16:19‐17:3
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
18:19‐19:1
71

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations

Nishibori, Shin

DATE
5/2/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
19:2‐5

Nishibori, Shin

5/2/2012

21:11‐22:19

Nishibori, Shin
Nishibori, Shin

5/2/2012
5/2/2012

22:24‐23:15
24:8‐13

Nishibori, Shin

5/2/2012

25:13‐21

WITNESS

Nishibori, Shin

5/2/2012

28:9‐29:15

Nishibori, Shin

5/2/2012

29:25‐31:6

Nishibori, Shin

5/2/2012

34:6‐35:5

Nishibori, Shin

5/2/2012

37:10‐38:12

Nishibori, Shin

5/2/2012

48:5‐13

Nishibori, Shin

5/2/2012

48:23‐49:16

Nishibori, Shin
Nishibori, Shin
Paltian, Markus
Paltian, Markus
Paltian, Markus
Paltian, Markus
Paltian, Markus
Paltian, Markus
Paltian, Markus
Paltian, Markus
Paltian, Markus
Paltian, Markus
Paltian, Markus

5/2/2012
5/2/2012
3/20/2012
3/20/2012
3/20/2012
3/20/2012
3/20/2012
3/20/2012
3/20/2012
3/20/2012
3/20/2012
3/20/2012
3/20/2012

53:1‐9
53:16‐54:1
7:11‐20
10:7‐11:21
12:7‐14:18
17:15‐21
17:23‐18:8
18:14‐18
18:20‐19:3
21:8‐10
21:12‐15
21:18‐22
21:24‐25

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
23:16‐23
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague

42:14‐43:13; 44:3‐17; 
44:25‐45:5; 45:7‐46:3; 46:5‐
14; 46:19‐47:18
33:16‐34:5
36:17‐37:9
38:17‐19; 39:1‐6; 41:6‐21;
48:14‐22
49:17‐50:19; 50:25‐51:19

54:2‐13

lacks foundation; vague
lacks foundation; vague 
lacks foundation; vague
leading
leading
leading
leading

22:2‐4; 22:6
72

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Paltian, Markus
Paltian, Markus
Paltian, Markus

DATE
3/20/2012
3/20/2012
3/20/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
52:21‐53:7
78:9‐20
78:22‐79:1

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

lacks foundation; vague
lacks foundation; vague

Paltian, Markus

3/20/2012

89:8‐19

 leading

Paltian, Markus
Paltian, Markus
Paltian, Markus

3/20/2012
3/20/2012
3/20/2012

89:21
96:2‐4
96:6‐8

 leading

134:18‐21; 134:23‐135:8; 
135:10‐136:18; 136:20‐22; 
143:20‐25; 144:3‐22
134:18‐21; 134:23‐135:8; 
135:10‐136:18; 136:20‐22; 
143:20‐25; 144:3‐22

134:18‐21; 134:23‐135:8; 
135:10‐136:18; 136:20‐22; 
143:20‐25; 144:3‐22

Paltian, Markus
Platzer, Andrew
Platzer, Andrew
Platzer, Andrew

3/20/2012
10/18/2011
10/18/2011
10/18/2011

Platzer, Andrew
Platzer, Andrew
Platzer, Andrew

10/18/2011 24:9‐32:10
10/18/2011 34:1‐25
10/18/2011 47:15‐48:14

n/a
n/a
403
402, 403, 1002, misstates 
testimony, argumentative
402, 403, 1002
402, 403, 1002

Platzer, Andrew

10/18/2011 49:1‐16

402, 403, 1002, speculation

10/18/2011 50:18‐57:12

402, 403, 1002, legal 
conclusion, asked & 
answered, argumentative, 
lacks foundation, misstates 
testimony

10/18/2011 57:25‐61:22
10/18/2011 65:2‐66:3

402, 403, 1002, lacks 
foundation, argumentative, 
asked & answered
62:20‐63:4
402, 403, 1002

Platzer, Andrew

Platzer, Andrew
Platzer, Andrew

111:14‐112:11
5:3‐5
5:20‐21
19:16‐23

32:23‐33:1

48:15‐20

73

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS
402, 403, 1002, misstates 
testimony

Platzer, Andrew

10/18/2011 67:8‐68:19

Platzer, Andrew

10/18/2011 70:23‐75:12

Platzer, Andrew

10/18/2011 76:4‐83:2

402, 403, 1002, asked & 
answered, legal conclusion, 
lacks foundation, misstates 
testimony

10/18/2011 99:2‐100:1

402, 403, 1002, legal 
conclusion, lacks foundation, 
asked & answered

10/18/2011 102:6‐104:7

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

402, 403, 1002, legal opinion, 
asked & answered
402, 403, 1002, legal 
conclusion, lacks foundation, 
vague

10/18/2011 83:24‐97:2

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

402, 403, 1002, asked & 
answered, legal conclusion, 
lacks foundation

Platzer, Andrew

Platzer, Andrew

Platzer, Andrew

Platzer, Andrew
Platzer, Andrew

10/18/2011 107:15‐111:9
10/18/2011 118:21‐120:9

Platzer, Andrew

10/18/2011 123:21‐124:8

402, 403, 1002, legal 
conclusion, lacks foundation, 
asked & answered
403, 1002
403, legal conclusion, 
misstates testimony

10/18/2011 125:1‐131:9
2/7/2012
11:24‐12:16
2/7/2012
13:3‐9

68:20‐69:21

402, 403, 1002, vague, legal 
cocnlusion, lacks foundation, 
asked & answered
402, 403, 1002
402, 403

Platzer, Andrew
Platzer, Andrew ITC‐796
Platzer, Andrew ITC‐796

74

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Platzer, Andrew ITC‐796

2/7/2012

13:23‐14:14

Platzer, Andrew ITC‐796
Platzer, Andrew ITC‐796
Platzer, Andrew ITC‐796
Platzer, Andrew ITC‐796
Rohrbach, Matthew
Rohrbach, Matthew
Rohrbach, Matthew
Rohrbach, Matthew
Rohrbach, Matthew
Rohrbach, Matthew
Rohrbach, Matthew
Rohrbach, Matthew
Rohrbach, Matthew
Rohrbach, Matthew
Rohrbach, Matthew
Rohrbach, Matthew
Rohrbach, Matthew
Rohrbach, Matthew

2/7/2012
2/7/2012
2/7/2012
2/7/2012
10/24/2011
10/24/2011
10/24/2011
10/24/2011
10/24/2011
10/24/2011
10/24/2011
10/24/2011
10/24/2011
10/24/2011
10/24/2011
10/24/2011
10/24/2011
10/24/2011

19:13‐20:13
22:16‐23:23
81:17‐82:9
106:1‐4
6:9‐12
6:16‐22
18:3‐5
18:18‐22
21:5‐17
22:15‐16
22:19‐23
23:3
24:6‐8
24:11‐12
24:14‐18
30:17‐18
30:20‐31:5
31:7

Rohrbach, Matthew
Rohrbach, Matthew
Rohrbach, Matthew

10/24/2011
10/24/2011
10/24/2011

32:23‐25
33:3‐4
33:21‐25

Rohrbach, Matthew
Rohrbach, Matthew
Rohrbach, Matthew
Rohrbach, Matthew

10/24/2011
10/24/2011
10/24/2011
10/24/2011

34:4‐8
34:10‐15
34:18‐19
95:11‐13

Rohrbach, Matthew

10/24/2011

96:2‐8

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

402, 403, vague & 
ambiguous, lacks foundation
402, 403, 1002, vague & 
ambiguous, lacks foundation
401, 402, 403
402, 403, 1002
402, 403, 1002, misleading
105:22‐25, 106:5‐9

Calls for speculation 
Calls for speculation 
Lacks foundation; Calls for 
speculation

402; 403
402; 403
402; 403

31:9‐12; 27:21‐28:3; 28:5

32:8‐11; 32:14‐16

24:20‐22; 25;1‐2; 26:15‐19; 
26:22‐23

Lacks Foundation; Calls for 
Legal Conclusion; Calls for 
Expert Testimony; 402
75

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Rohrbach, Matthew

10/24/2011

96:13

Rohrbach, Matthew
Rohrbach, Matthew

10/24/2011
10/24/2011

96:15‐17
96:20

Rohrbach, Matthew
Rohrbach, Matthew

10/24/2011
10/24/2011

106:14‐16
106:19

Rohrbach, Matthew

10/24/2011

115:18‐19

Rohrbach, Matthew

10/24/2011

115:23‐116:1

Rohrbach, Matthew
Rohrbach, Matthew
Rohrbach, Matthew

10/24/2011
10/24/2011
10/24/2011

116:5‐9
116:13
116:15‐17

Rohrbach, Matthew

10/24/2011

117:1‐11

Rohrbach, Matthew

10/24/2011

117:15‐21

Rohrbach, Matthew
Rohrbach, Matthew

10/24/2011
10/24/2011

117:25
119:15‐17

APPLE OBJECTIONS
Lacks Foundation; Calls for 
Legal Conclusion; Calls for 
Expert Testimony; 402
Lacks Foundation; Calls for 
Legal Conclusion; Calls for 
Expert Testimony; 402

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

97:8; 97:10‐12; 98:7‐11

Calls for Legal conclusion; 
Calls for Speculation; Lacks 
Foundation; 402; 403
Calls for Legal conclusion; 
Calls for Speculation; Lacks 
Foundation; Calls for Expert 
Testimony
Calls for Legal conclusion; 
Calls for Speculation; Lacks 
Foundation; Calls for Expert 
Testimony
Calls for Legal conclusion; 
Calls for Speculation; Lacks 
Foundation; Calls for Expert 
Testimony

Calls for Legal conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation; Calls for 
Expert Testimony
Calls for Legal conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation; Calls for 
Expert Testimony
Calls for Legal conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation; Calls for 
Expert Testimony

76

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Rohrbach, Matthew

10/24/2011

120:1‐6

Rohrbach, Matthew

10/24/2011

120:10

Rohrbach, Matthew

10/24/2011

120:12‐13

Rohrbach, Matthew

10/24/2011

120:17‐23

Rohrbach, Matthew

10/24/2011

121:2

Rohrbach, Matthew

10/24/2011

123:16‐22

Rohrbach, Matthew

10/24/2011

124:8‐9

Rohrbach, Matthew

10/24/2011

124:14‐15

Rohrbach, Matthew

10/24/2011

124:17‐20

Rohrbach, Matthew

10/24/2011

124:24

Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796

2/23/2012

83:19‐22

APPLE OBJECTIONS
Calls for Legal conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation; Calls for 
Expert Testimony
Calls for Legal conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation; Calls for 
Expert Testimony
Calls for Legal conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation; Calls for 
Expert Testimony
Calls for Legal conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation; Calls for 
Expert Testimony
Calls for Legal conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation; Calls for 
Expert Testimony
Calls for Legal conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation; Calls for 
Expert Testimony
Calls for Legal conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation; Calls for 
Expert Testimony
Calls for Legal conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation; Calls for 
Expert Testimony
Calls for Legal conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation; Calls for 
Expert Testimony
Calls for Legal conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation; Calls for 
Expert Testimony
Calls for Legal conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation; Calls for 
Expert Testimony

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

82:5‐12; 83:2‐9

77

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796

2/23/2012

83:24‐84:11

Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796
Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796

2/23/2012
2/23/2012

84:13‐24
128:13‐16

APPLE OBJECTIONS
Calls for Legal conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation; Calls for 
Expert Testimony
Calls for Legal conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation; Calls for 
Expert Testimony

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

85:4‐15; 90:4‐91:17
129:9‐21; 130:14‐17; 
130:19‐20; 140:19‐20
115:12‐116:22

Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796
Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796

2/23/2012
2/23/2012

128:21‐129:4
129:7

Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796

2/23/2012

137:6‐8

Calls for Expert Testimony; 
Calls for Legal Conclusion

Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796

2/23/2012

137:10

Calls for Expert Testimony; 
Calls for Legal Conclusion

Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796

2/23/2012

137:12‐14

Calls for Expert Testimony; 
Calls for Legal Conclusion
Calls for Expert Testimony; 
Calls for Legal Conclusion

Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796

2/23/2012

137:16

Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796
Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796
Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796
Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796
Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796
Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796

2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012

145:3‐10
145:19‐146:11
146:24‐147:6
147:9‐16
147:19‐23
147:25

Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796
Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796
Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796
Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796
Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796

2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012
2/23/2012

148:2‐14
149:9‐14
233:12‐235:2
235:10‐236:1
240:5‐12

137:18‐138:11

145:11‐18; 146:12‐19; 
146:21‐22

148:15‐16; 148:19‐20; 
148:22‐25
402; 403
402; 403
Vague

235:3‐9

78

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796

Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796

Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796

Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796

Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796

Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796

Rohrbach, Matthew ITC‐796
Rothkopf, Fletcher
Rothkopf, Fletcher
Rothkopf, Fletcher
Rothkopf, Fletcher
Rothkopf, Fletcher
Rothkopf, Fletcher

DATE
2/23/2012

2/23/2012

2/23/2012

2/23/2012

2/23/2012

2/23/2012

2/23/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
243:4‐8

APPLE OBJECTIONS

244:24‐245:2

Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Testimony; 
Lacks Foundation; 402

245:15‐18

Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Testimony; 
Lacks Foundation; 402

245:20‐246:1

Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Testimony; 
Lacks Foundation; 402

246:4‐19

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Testimony; 
Lacks Foundation; 402

245:5‐12

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS
243:10‐18; 243:21‐23

Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Testimony; 
Lacks Foundation; 402

246:21‐22
5:21‐23
6:1‐6
6:12‐21
9:5‐16
10:21‐11:6
12:12‐22

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

17:5‐9

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

17:17‐18:3

Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Testimony; 
Lacks Foundation; 402

92:1‐9; 92:16‐23
11:7‐9; 11:25‐12:11
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
17:10‐16
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
18:4‐11
79

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

18:12‐19:4

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

20:13‐21:2

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

21:17‐22:9

Rothkopf, Fletcher
Rothkopf, Fletcher
Rothkopf, Fletcher
Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012
2/29/2012

25:1‐11
26:10‐15
27:23‐28:2
28:5‐12

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

49:12‐25

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

51:2‐8

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

85:8‐86:19

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

93:22‐94:25

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

129:15‐130:3

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

130:8‐25

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

134:12‐14

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

139:4‐16

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

140:18‐24

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

141:24‐142:2

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

142:7‐15

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

144:2‐5

APPLE COUNTER 
APPLE OBJECTIONS
DESIGNATIONS
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
19:5‐16
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
21:13‐16
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
25:12‐19

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

28:3‐4
28:13‐24
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague

49:1‐11

129:2‐14
130:4‐7
134:15‐20

140:25‐141:14
142:3‐6

80

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

144:7‐13

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

192:7‐11

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

192:18‐194:10

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

196:1‐18

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

197:21‐198:7

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

198:22‐199:3

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

199:15‐19

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

200:12‐22

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

200:24‐201:3

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

201:5‐12

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

201:14‐20

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

202:13‐203:18

Rothkopf, Fletcher

2/29/2012

203:23‐204:10

Rothkopf, Fletcher ITC‐796

4/19/2012

28:8‐29:17

Rothkopf, Fletcher ITC‐796

4/19/2012

31:1‐6

205:10‐15; 205:22‐24
5:14‐18; 5:20‐6:20; 17:15‐
FRE 402; misleading; lack of  18:19; 29:18‐30:25; 49:15‐
foundation; vague
50:8
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
31:7‐33:11

Rothkopf, Fletcher ITC‐796

4/19/2012

37:15‐38:8

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402; FRE 802; misleading; 
lack of foundation; vague
38:9‐19

144:14‐23

199:4‐14

200:3‐11

81

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Rothkopf, Fletcher ITC‐796

4/19/2012

41:22‐42:3

Rothkopf, Fletcher ITC‐796

4/19/2012

42:13‐43:18

Rothkopf, Fletcher ITC‐796

4/19/2012

124:19‐125:7

Rothkopf, Fletcher ITC‐796
Sinclair, Steven
Sinclair, Steven
Sinclair, Steven
Sinclair, Steven

4/19/2012
4/4/2012
4/4/2012
4/4/2012
4/4/2012

125:13‐126:16
28:12‐30:25
32:24‐33:15
34:7‐12
34:14‐35:10

Sinclair, Steven

4/4/2012

35:14‐19

Sinclair, Steven

4/4/2012

37:1‐11

Sinclair, Steven

4/4/2012

37:15‐25

Sinclair, Steven
Sinclair, Steven
Sinclair, Steven

4/4/2012
4/4/2012
4/4/2012

38:3‐9
38:11‐25
39:4‐6

Sinclair, Steven

4/4/2012

39:23‐40:3

Sinclair, Steven
Sinclair, Steven

4/4/2012
4/4/2012

40:7‐11
40:14‐41:8

APPLE COUNTER 
APPLE OBJECTIONS
DESIGNATIONS
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
42:4‐12; 89:13‐90:6
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

402, 403
Vague, 402, 403 
see previous
Vague, mischaracterizes; 402, 
403
Vague, lacks foundation, 
argumentative; 402, 403, 
1002
Vague, lacks foundation; 402, 
403, 1002
Vague, lacks foundation (38:6‐
13); 402, 403, 1002
402, 403, 1002
Vague; 402, 403, 1002
Argumentative, vague, lacks 
foundation, asked and 
answered; 402, 403, 1002
Lacks foundation, vague, 
asked and answered, calls for 
speculation (40:9‐15), 402, 
403, 1002
402, 403, 1002

82

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS
vague, lacks foundation, calls 
for legal conclusion, calls for 
speculation (41:5‐14, 41:15‐
20); 402, 403

Sinclair, Steven
Sinclair, Steven
Singer, David ITC‐794
Singer, David ITC‐794
Singer, David ITC‐794
Singer, David ITC‐794
Singer, David ITC‐794
Singer, David ITC‐794
Singer, David ITC‐794
Singer, David ITC‐794
Singer, David ITC‐794
Singer, David ITC‐794
Singer, David ITC‐794
Singer, David ITC‐794
Singer, David ITC‐794

4/4/2012
4/4/2012
2/16/2012
2/16/2012
2/16/2012
2/16/2012
2/16/2012
2/16/2012
2/16/2012
2/16/2012
2/16/2012
2/16/2012
2/16/2012
2/16/2012
2/16/2012

41:12‐20
137:9‐138:4
6:13‐15
23:4‐13
23:17‐22
37:1‐38:13
41:9‐45:11
46:8‐15
58:14‐58:19
59:1‐3
61:2‐61:9
62:9‐11
62:16‐63:4
77:22‐78:21
81:2‐25

Singer, David ITC‐794
Singer, David ITC‐794
Singer, David ITC‐794
Singer, David ITC‐794

2/16/2012
2/16/2012
2/16/2012
2/16/2012

81:19‐83:18
85:7‐10
85:12‐25
87:23‐88:11

Singer, David ITC‐794

2/16/2012

90:20‐97:10

Singer, David ITC‐794

2/16/2012

98:6‐99:17

Incomplete
701; incomplete; 402, best 
evidence; speculation; 
Ambiguous; 
Mischaracterization; 
Incomplete

Singer, David ITC‐794

2/16/2012

105:25‐106:14

Incomplete

Singer, David ITC‐794

2/16/2012

112:24‐114:8

Singer, David ITC‐794
Singer, David ITC‐794

2/16/2012
2/16/2012

118:22‐120:10
121:5‐122:8

Incomplete
Incomplete; Hearsay; best 
evidence

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

402
402
Ambiguous
Incomplete
Incomplete
Incomplete

46:16‐47:19
58:3‐13, 58:20‐25
58:3‐25

Ambiguous
Incomplete

62:13‐62:15

402; Hearsay; best evidence

86:01‐87:22
97:12‐98:5

99:19‐103:12
45:08‐11; 67:03‐68:08; 
77:11‐13
114:09‐116:04; 141:13‐
143:22   
67:03‐68:08; 77:11‐13; 
131:22‐133:04

83

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Singer, David ITC‐794
Singer, David ITC‐794
Singer, David ITC‐794

DATE

2/16/2012
2/16/2012
2/16/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

122:16‐124:10
124:20‐25
125:12‐126:4

Singer, David ITC‐794
Singer, David ITC‐794
Singer, David ITC‐794
Singer, David ITC‐794
Singer, David ITC‐794
Singer, David ITC‐794
Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael

2/16/2012
2/16/2012
2/16/2012
2/16/2012
2/16/2012
2/16/2012
2/21/2012
2/21/2012
2/21/2012

127:7‐131:21
134:9‐19
140:12‐141:11
144:22‐146:21
147:1‐24
148:2‐11
6:4‐19
6:24‐7:9
7:17‐8:7

Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael

2/21/2012
2/21/2012
2/21/2012
2/21/2012
2/21/2012
2/21/2012
2/21/2012

66:6‐67:8
67:9‐13
67:14‐68:16
68:23‐69:3
69:5‐20
69:22‐70:10
76:3‐78:2

Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael

2/21/2012
2/21/2012
2/21/2012
2/21/2012
2/21/2012

81:20‐82:3
83:20‐24
95:16‐22
109:14‐110:12
111:11‐21

Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael

2/21/2012
2/21/2012
2/21/2012

113:20‐114:1
131:24‐132:16
132:18‐23

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS
Assumes facts; lacks 
foundation; speculation; 
ambiguous
Incomplete

141:13‐143:22 
121:5‐12, 124:17‐19

Hearsay; speculation; 
ambiguous; best evidence; 
402; incomplete

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

131:22‐133:04

Incomplete
Beyond scope of 30(b)6
Beyond scope of 30(b)6

Incomplete, FRE 402
FRE 402
FRE 402
FRE 402, ambiguous
FRE 402, ambiguous
FRE 402, ambiguous
FRE 402, incomplete, 
misleading
FRE 402
FRE 402
incomplete
incomplete
FRE 402, incomplete, 
misleading

141:13‐143:22 

66:2‐67:8 (subject to 
objection)

81:20‐82:5 (subject to 
objection)

109:14‐111:21
109:14‐111:21
113:20‐114:13 (subject to 
objection)

speculation
84

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael

Tchao, Michael

Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael

DATE
2/21/2012
2/21/2012
2/21/2012
2/21/2012
2/21/2012
2/21/2012
2/21/2012
2/21/2012
2/21/2012

2/21/2012

2/21/2012
2/21/2012
2/21/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
133:18‐21
134:4‐5
134:7‐20
135:7‐8
135:10‐136:1
136:4‐25
137:2‐4
139:19‐140:1
140:3‐5

142:4‐143:1

143:15‐21
159:4‐7
159:17‐160:22

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402
FRE 402

FRE 402
FRE 402
Admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
Admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
Incomplete
158:16‐159:7

Tchao, Michael

2/21/2012

163:23‐166:2

FRE 602, FRE 802, 
Incomplete

Tchao, Michael

2/21/2012

190:25‐191:10

FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii) (not on 
pretrial disclosure), FRE 1002

193:9‐21

Admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list

Tchao, Michael

2/21/2012

161:2‐11, 163:23‐166:2 
(subject to objection)

85

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Tchao, Michael

Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael
Tchao, Michael ITC‐796
Tchao, Michael ITC‐796

Tchao, Michael ITC‐796
Tchao, Michael ITC‐796
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794

DATE

2/21/2012

2/21/2012
2/21/2012
1/10/2012
1/10/2012

1/10/2012
1/10/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

194:17‐195:2

201:2‐202:1
202:4‐6
5:4‐20
10:6‐22

48:10‐49:24
50:3‐51:1
5:10‐11
6:1‐5
6:11‐18
14:25‐15:4
15:11‐16:10
16:20‐17:8
23:12‐15
23:18‐23
24:1‐5
24:8‐9
24:12‐15
24:18‐24
26:9‐22

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

Admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
Admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list

Admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list

86

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794

DATE
2/24/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
28:14‐16

Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794

2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012

31:21‐23
31:25‐32:1
33:4‐19
34:11‐13
34:22‐35:14
36:6‐9
36:12‐15
36:18‐25
38:7‐11

Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794

2/24/2012
2/24/2012

41:22‐25
42:3‐7

Teksler, Boris ITC‐794

2/24/2012

44:24‐45:3

Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794

2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012

45:6‐10
45:13
50:15‐25
52:9‐10
52:12‐15
52:17‐53:3
56:17‐57:12
57:14‐15
67:24‐68:2
68:4‐14
69:10‐20
73:7‐10
73:13‐16
73:19‐21

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

Beyond the Scope of the 
30(b)(6) Designation; 402, 
403

402; lacks foundation; 
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)

ambiguous; lacks foundation; 
overbroad; argumentative
ambiguous; lacks foundation; 
overbroad; argumentative

incomplete

56:7‐16

incomplete
incomplete

66:15‐67:23
68:15‐25

87

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Teksler, Boris ITC‐794

2/24/2012

74:17‐75:2

Teksler, Boris ITC‐794

2/24/2012

75:5‐12

Teksler, Boris ITC‐794

2/24/2012

75:15‐20

Teksler, Boris ITC‐794

2/24/2012

75:23‐76:2

Teksler, Boris ITC‐794

2/24/2012

76:5‐13

Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794

2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012

76:16
77:12‐21
88:15‐23
89:2‐7
90:21‐91:10
92:2‐16
93:25‐94:8
102:5‐103:3

Teksler, Boris ITC‐794

Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794

2/24/2012

2/24/2012
2/24/2012

110:13‐14

110:17‐18
111:14‐21

Teksler, Boris ITC‐794

2/24/2012

114:15‐23

Teksler, Boris ITC‐794

2/24/2012

114:25‐115:10

APPLE OBJECTIONS
402; lacks foundation; 
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
402; lacks foundation; 
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
402; lacks foundation; 
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
402; lacks foundation; 
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)
402; lacks foundation; 
beyond scope of 30(b)(6); 
speculation
402; lacks foundation; 
beyond scope of 30(b)(6)

incomplete

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

90:3‐20; 91:11‐23

incomplete; compound; 
beyond scope of 30(b)(6); 
lacks foundation; speculation 110:8‐12
incomplete; compound; 
beyond scope of 30(b)(6); 
lacks foundation; speculation 110:8‐12
802; overbroad; 
mischaracterization; 
speculation; 402
802; overbroad; 
mischaracterization; 
speculation; 402
88

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794

DATE
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
116:22‐117:2
127:8‐18
166:9‐11

Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794

2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012

166:13‐167:5
169:4‐8
169:10‐11
169:13‐16
170:11‐22
170:24‐25
172:12‐15
172:17‐21
179:3‐5
179:7‐18
187:5‐12
187:15‐188:2
188:5‐6

Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794

2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012

192:12‐16
197:1‐21
200:5‐9
203:19‐22
205:5‐7
205:9‐15

Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794

2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012

206:1‐4
206:6
220:17‐222:8

Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794

2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012

223:13‐234:1
224:15‐19
224:22‐225:9
226:5‐19

APPLE OBJECTIONS
incomplete
incomplete

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

incomplete

127:19‐21
165:21‐166:12
165:21‐166:12; 167:6‐
168:21

incomplete

169:17‐24

incomplete

179:19‐21

incomplete
802; speculation; lacks 
foundation; ambiguous

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

188:7‐189:5

compound; ambiguous; lacks 
foundation
incomplete

220:6‐16; 222:9‐223:1

incomplete; lacks foundation; 
802;speculation; ambiguous

89

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐794
Teksler, Boris ITC‐796
Teksler, Boris ITC‐796
Teksler, Boris ITC‐796
Teksler, Boris ITC‐796
Teksler, Boris ITC‐796

DATE
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
2/24/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
226:22‐227:3
227:18‐228:7
230:2‐11
233:8‐11
235:4‐10
236:2‐13
237:15‐22
237:24‐25
238:4‐25
239:2‐4
5:7‐8
5:21‐6:10
8:24‐9:12
10:1‐11
11:1‐8

Teksler, Boris ITC‐796
Teksler, Boris ITC‐796
Teksler, Boris ITC‐796

3/16/2012
3/16/2012
3/16/2012

11:19‐12:11
31:8‐12
32:2‐15

incomplete
FRE 802
None
None

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

incompete

233:12‐234:1

incomplete

237:9‐14

None
None
incomplete
None
incomplete

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

9:13‐17
10:21‐25
11:9‐18; 12:12‐15, 12:17‐
25; 13:11‐13; 13:16‐22

FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
Teksler, Boris ITC‐796

3/16/2012

47:13‐23

90

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Teksler, Boris ITC‐796

DATE

3/16/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

60:19‐61:9

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
60:3‐18 (subject to 
objections)
FRE 402
FRE 403
FRE 408
admission of and testimony 
regarding exhibit is made 
subject to objections noted 
on Apple’s objections to 
Samsung’s exhibit list
63:8‐12

Teksler, Boris ITC‐796
Twiggs, Sissie
Twiggs, Sissie
Twiggs, Sissie
Twiggs, Sissie

3/16/2012
7/27/2011
7/27/2011
7/27/2011
7/27/2011

63:13‐64:14
18:22‐19:1
19:8‐11
19:23‐20:2
23:13‐19

Twiggs, Sissie

7/27/2011

81:8‐11

Incomplete
23:3‐18
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii) (not on 
pretrial disclosure), FRE 1002,  81:8‐15 (subject to 
Incomplete
objection)

86:3‐11
100:1‐4
101:7‐14

FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii) (not on 
pretrial disclosure), FRE 1002
FRE 402
FRE 402

119:22‐23

FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii) (not on 
pretrial disclosure), FRE 1002

Twiggs, Sissie
Twiggs, Sissie
Twiggs, Sissie

Twiggs, Sissie

7/27/2011
7/27/2011
7/27/2011

7/27/2011

91

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Twiggs, Sissie

DATE

7/27/2011

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

120:2‐3

Twiggs, Sissie

7/27/2011

123:12‐24

Twiggs, Sissie

7/27/2011

192:13‐20

Twiggs, Sissie
Van Liere, Kent
Van Liere, Kent
Van Liere, Kent
Van Liere, Kent
Voron, Vincent ITC‐796
Voron, Vincent ITC‐796
Voron, Vincent ITC‐796

7/27/2011
4/26/2012
4/26/2012
4/26/2012
4/26/2012
3/20/2012
3/20/2012
3/20/2012

193:6‐9
17:20‐18:14
69:13‐22
71:8‐15
91:2‐19
6:10‐12
7:1‐13
7:15‐17

Voron, Vincent ITC‐796

3/20/2012

11:23‐12:6

Voron, Vincent ITC‐796

3/20/2012

12:8‐10

Voron, Vincent ITC‐796

3/20/2012

16:1‐7

Voron, Vincent ITC‐796

3/20/2012

16:9‐10

Voron, Vincent ITC‐796

3/20/2012

26:2‐7

Voron, Vincent ITC‐796
Voron, Vincent ITC‐796
Voron, Vincent ITC‐796

3/20/2012
3/20/2012
3/20/2012

26:9‐19
42:17‐20
44:24‐45:10

Voron, Vincent ITC‐796

3/20/2012

51:9‐23

APPLE COUNTER 
APPLE OBJECTIONS
DESIGNATIONS
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii) (not on 
pretrial disclosure), FRE 1002,  120:2‐8 (subject to 
Incomplete
objection)

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii) (not on 
pretrial disclosure), FRE 1002,  123:12‐24 (subject to 
Incomplete, FRE 402
objection)
FRE 402, FRE 403, FRE 602,  192:2‐20 (subject to 
Incomplete
objection)
FRE 402, FRE 403, FRE 602,  193:6‐17 (subject to 
Incomplete
objection)
69:23‐71:7
142:16‐143:3
248:22‐251:23

FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
185:9‐188:1; 46:15‐22; 
FRE 402; misleading; lack of  48:9‐17; 57:12‐23; 84:14‐
foundation; vague
22; 
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
27:1‐6
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague

FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
92

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Voron, Vincent ITC‐796

3/20/2012

61:15‐18

Voron, Vincent ITC‐796

3/20/2012

61:20‐62:8

Voron, Vincent ITC‐796

3/20/2012

71:16‐72:11

Voron, Vincent ITC‐796

3/20/2012

72:14‐22

Voron, Vincent ITC‐796

3/20/2012

75:7‐12

Voron, Vincent ITC‐796

3/20/2012

78:8‐10

Voron, Vincent ITC‐796
Voron, Vincent ITC‐796

3/20/2012
3/20/2012

81:18‐82:10
88:15‐24

Voron, Vincent ITC‐796

3/20/2012

89:9‐11

Voron, Vincent ITC‐796

3/20/2012

89:14‐24

Voron, Vincent ITC‐796
Voron, Vincent ITC‐796
Voron, Vincent ITC‐796
Voron, Vincent ITC‐796

3/20/2012
3/20/2012
3/20/2012
3/20/2012

90:1‐5
90:7‐15
90:17‐91:2
96:10‐13

Voron, Vincent ITC‐796

3/20/2012

96:15‐20

Voron, Vincent ITC‐796
Voron, Vincent ITC‐796
Voron, Vincent ITC‐796

3/20/2012
3/20/2012
3/20/2012

102:19‐23
102:25‐103:5
135:24‐136:5

Voron, Vincent ITC‐796

3/20/2012

136:12‐18

APPLE COUNTER 
APPLE OBJECTIONS
DESIGNATIONS
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
66:12‐13; 66:15‐67:23
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
82:11‐24

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague; 
incomplete
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague; 
incomplete
92:22‐93:3; 93:5‐10
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague; 
96:22‐‐25; 97:3‐11; 97:14‐
incomplete
98:2
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague; 
103:6‐12

FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague; 
93

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Voron, Vincent ITC‐796

DATE
3/20/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
136:21‐25

Voron, Vincent ITC‐796

3/20/2012

146:22‐147:2

Voron, Vincent ITC‐796
Voron, Vincent ITC‐796

3/20/2012
3/20/2012

159:22‐24
160:2‐6

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague; 
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague; 
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague; 
incomplete
FRE 402; misleading; lack of 
foundation; vague; 

Voron, Vincent ITC‐796

3/20/2012

167:8‐13

Voron, Vincent ITC‐796
Voron, Vincent ITC‐796
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael

3/20/2012
3/20/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012

167:15‐21
167:23‐168:1
6:19‐7:1
8:21‐9:18
10:13‐22
11:8‐12:1
12:14‐17
17:24‐18:6
22:2‐17
23:24‐24:7
33:9‐14
34:1‐8
39:15‐19

Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael

5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012

40:19‐41:24
44:1‐5
46:18‐47:3

402; Incomplete; Speculation 40:11‐18

Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael

5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012

52:16‐56:1
59:24‐60:4
60:8‐18
63:22‐64:10
64:13‐24
66:17‐22
68:7‐23

Ambiguous; Legal Conclusion

402; Incomplete

40:11‐18

402
Ambiguous

94

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael

DATE
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
70:11‐21
71:22‐72:3
73:2‐19
74:17‐75:19
78:12‐79:9
80:12‐23
82:22‐83:24
96:7‐16
97:22‐98:22
102:23‐103:14
109:2‐17
110:4‐114:8
116:19‐23
118:4‐7
118:24‐119:4
120:4‐11
123:24‐126:3
131:9‐132:7
133:1‐22
135:4‐9
137:3‐16
137:18‐138:23
143:17‐23
143:25‐145:17
148:20‐150:23
153:16‐154:3
154:16‐155:5
155:23‐157:10
171:25‐172:7

Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael

5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012

174:11‐175:5
181:16‐182:8
183:7‐184:1
187:23‐188:2
189:18‐190:6

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

1002

402, 403
Speculation
Incomplete
Speculation; Incomplete

325:19‐326:20
109:18‐21
114:9‐115:6

402
402

118:8‐23; 119:5‐21
118:8‐23; 119:5‐21

402, 403
1002
402, 403
402
Ambiguous
402, 403

136:9‐21; 138:24‐139:15
136:9‐21; 138:24‐139:15
136:9‐21; 138:24‐139:15
141:21‐142:10

403, 1002, Ambiguous

402
402

174:4‐10; 211:1‐213:19; 
220:5‐8

Ambiguous; Speculation
95

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS

Walker, Michael

5/2/2012

201:15‐205:14

Ambiguous

Walker, Michael

5/2/2012

207:8‐210:15

Argumentative

Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Walker, Michael
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ

5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
5/2/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012

224:19‐225:3
253:12‐254:23
255:1‐256:19
256:22‐258:23
260:21‐264:14
272:14‐273:16
274:16‐275:9
280:20‐282:21
284:11‐285:1
286:15‐24
287:18‐289:16
290:6‐20
296:14‐25
298:4‐300:6
312:12‐313:1
313:10‐25
317:19‐319:6
320:22‐321:14
323:1‐6
323:17‐324:8
5:12‐13
7:9‐15
11:4‐13
13:8‐25
14:5‐8
16:2‐14
17:7‐14
17:20‐18:6
18:25‐19:11
20:2‐6

Argumentative

Ambiguous; Speculation
402; 802
402
402
402

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS
174:4‐10; 211:1‐213:19; 
220:5‐8
174:4‐10; 211:1‐213:19; 
220:5‐8
174:4‐10; 211:1‐213:19; 
220:5‐8

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

255:8‐14; 260:13‐20
260:13‐20

402; 1002
402
802; Legal Conclusion
1002
1002; 802
402; 802
Incomplete

327:14‐328:11
327:14‐328:11
313:2‐9

323:7‐16
323:7‐16; 328:12‐20

incomplete

11:14‐12:24

incomplete

18:8‐13

96

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations

Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ

DATE
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
22:5‐13
22:23‐24
23:4‐16
24:10‐15

Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ

3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012

27:8‐16
34:20‐23
35:1‐9
36:2‐37:10
41:5‐9
44:3‐4
44:7
44:18‐25
45:4‐15
49:6‐9
50:2‐3
50:9‐22
51:3‐11
51:19‐52:9
53:8‐19
58:15‐24

Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ

3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012

59:2‐20
60:10‐14
61:12‐62:4
62:7‐13

Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ

3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012

62:24‐63:2
63:9‐11
68:4‐13
69:1‐10
69:13‐22
69:24‐25
70:2‐23
73:20‐25

WITNESS

APPLE OBJECTIONS
incomplete

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS
22:14‐22

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

802; lacks foundation; 
speculation

incomplete

48:22‐49:4

incomplete

50:24‐51:2

incomplete

52:10‐17

argumentative; assumes 
facts; lacks foundation

incomplete
lacks foundation; assumes 
facts; speculation

62:14‐23

incomplete

74:1‐6
97

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations

Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ

DATE
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
74:7‐10
83:13‐20
90:2‐17
90:25‐91:1
91:3‐8

Watrous, BJ

3/8/2012

95:4‐7

Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ
Watrous, BJ

3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012
3/8/2012

95:18‐96:3
96:7‐14
96:25‐97:2
97:4

WITNESS

APPLE OBJECTIONS
incomplete
incomplete
incomplete
incomplete

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS
74:19‐75:6
83:2‐12
84:11‐88:11; 88:25‐89:19
84:11‐88:11; 88:25‐89:19

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

lacks foundation; ambiguous; 
802; speculation
lacks foundation; ambiguous; 
802; speculation

asked and answered; 
compound

Watrous, BJ
Whang, Eugene

3/8/2012
10/27/2011

100:2‐101:13
5:24‐6:7

Whang, Eugene

10/27/2011

24:5‐16

Whang, Eugene

10/27/2011

27:16‐23

Whang, Eugene
Whang, Eugene

10/27/2011
10/27/2011

27:25‐28:2
48:9‐12

1002; Not trial exhibit; 402; 
Lacks Foundation
1002; Not trial exhibit; 402; 
Lacks Foundation
1002; Not trial exhibit; 402; 
Lacks Foundation
Lacks question

51:8‐11

Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Testimony; 
Lacks Foundation

51:14‐52:3

Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Testimony; 
Lacks Foundation

53:16‐23

Lacks Foundation; Calls for 
Speculation; Overbroad

Whang, Eugene

Whang, Eugene

Whang, Eugene

10/27/2011

10/27/2011

10/27/2011

27:25‐28:11
28:3‐11

54:13‐54:24; 55:1‐56:2
98

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Whang, Eugene
Whang, Eugene
Whang, Eugene
Whang, Eugene
Whang, Eugene

10/27/2011
10/27/2011
10/27/2011
10/27/2011
10/27/2011

54:3‐11
58:8‐11
58:23‐59:11
60:21‐61:7
61:9‐14

Whang, Eugene

10/27/2011

62:13‐16

Whang, Eugene

10/27/2011

62:20‐63:7

Whang, Eugene

10/27/2011

63:11‐17

Whang, Eugene
Whang, Eugene

10/27/2011
10/27/2011

83:18‐22
84:1‐2

Whang, Eugene

10/27/2011

95:4‐6

Whang, Eugene

10/27/2011

95:9‐16

Whang, Eugene
Whang, Eugene Vol 1 ITC‐796
Whang, Eugene Vol 1 ITC‐796

10/27/2011
2/17/2012
2/17/2012

95:18
91:3‐14
91:16‐22

Whang, Eugene Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/17/2012

160:13‐19

Whang, Eugene Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/17/2012

160:22‐161:6

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

Lacks Foundation; Calls for 
Speculation; Overbroad
59:12‐16
Vague; 402
Vague; 402
Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Opinion; 
Lacks Foundation
Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Opinion; 
Lacks Foundation
Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Opinion; 
Lacks Foundation
Lacks Foundaton; Calls for 
Legal Conclusion; Overbroad; 
Calls for Speculation; Calls for 
Expert Testimony
Lacks Foundaton; Calls for 
Legal Conclusion
Lacks Foundaton; Calls for 
Legal Conclusion
Lacks Foundaton; Calls for 
Legal Conclusion
Calls for Speculation; 402
Calls for Speculation; 402
Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation ;
402, 403
Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation 

64:6; 64:9‐16; 64:18‐65:5

99

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Whang, Eugene Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/17/2012

161:9‐11

Whang, Eugene Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/17/2012

161:15‐19

Whang, Eugene Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/17/2012

161:22‐24

Whang, Eugene Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/17/2012

162:13‐16

Whang, Eugene Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/17/2012

162:19‐24

Whang, Eugene Vol 1 ITC‐796
Whang, Eugene Vol 1 ITC‐796
Whang, Eugene Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/17/2012
2/17/2012
2/17/2012

163:2‐3
172:17‐20
172:23

Whang, Eugene Vol 1 ITC‐796

Whang, Eugene Vol 1 ITC‐796

Whang, Eugene Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/17/2012

2/17/2012

2/17/2012

APPLE OBJECTIONS
Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation 
Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation 
Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Lacks Foundation 
Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Testimony 
Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Testimony 
Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Testimony 

186:1‐6

Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Testimony; 
Lacks Foundation

187:5‐9

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Testimony; 
Lacks Foundation

186:9‐10

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Testimony; 
Lacks Foundation

Whang, Eugene Vol 1 ITC‐796
Whang, Eugene Vol 1 ITC‐796
Whang, Eugene Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/17/2012
2/17/2012
2/17/2012

187:12‐13
199:20‐200:15
200:17‐19

Whang, Eugene Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/17/2012

207:21‐25

Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Testimony; 
Lacks Foundation
200:20‐201:7
Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Testimony

100

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Whang, Eugene Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/17/2012

208:3‐4

Whang, Eugene Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/17/2012

208:6‐8

Whang, Eugene Vol 1 ITC‐796

2/17/2012

208:10‐11

Whang, Eugene Vol 1 ITC‐796
Whang, Eugene Vol 2 ITC‐796

2/17/2012
4/30/2012

209:15‐22
350:22‐351:2

APPLE OBJECTIONS
Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Testimony
Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Testimony
Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Testimony
Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Testimony
802

Whang, Eugene Vol 2 ITC‐796

4/30/2012

351:5‐352:5

802

384:22‐25

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Testimony; 
Lacks Foundation; 403

Whang, Eugene Vol 2 ITC‐796

DATE

4/30/2012

Whang, Eugene Vol 2 ITC‐796
Whiteside, Tamara
Whiteside, Tamara
Whiteside, Tamara
Whiteside, Tamara

4/30/2012
2/28/2012
2/28/2012
2/28/2012
2/28/2012

385:4‐9
5:10‐13
8:14‐22
35:5‐8
39:8‐14

Whiteside, Tamara

2/28/2012

43:16‐44:5

Whiteside, Tamara

2/28/2012

49:17‐18

Whiteside, Tamara
Whiteside, Tamara
Whiteside, Tamara

2/28/2012
2/28/2012
2/28/2012

49:21‐24
59:16‐21
61:4‐6

Whiteside, Tamara
Whiteside, Tamara

2/28/2012
2/28/2012

71:22‐72:1
131:18‐21

350:1‐21
352:6‐9; 352:11‐19; 360:1‐
7; 360:10; 360: 12:‐15; 
360:18‐22; 360:24

Calls for Legal Conclusion; 
Calls for Expert Testimony; 
Lacks Foundation; 403

Incomplete

33:24‐35:8

FRE 402, FRE 403, 
ambiguous, FRE 1002
FRE 402, FRE 403, 
ambiguous, FRE 1002
FRE 402, FRE 403, 
ambiguous, FRE 1002
FRE 402, FRE 403, FRE 602

FRE 402,  FRE 611c, FRE 1002

101

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations

Whiteside, Tamara

2/28/2012

160:23‐161:1

Whiteside, Tamara

2/28/2012

161:7

APPLE COUNTER 
APPLE OBJECTIONS
DESIGNATIONS
beyond the scope of 30(B)(6),  160:22‐161:1 (subject to 
Incomplete
objection)
beyond the scope of 30(B)(6),  161:7 (subject to 
Incomplete
objection)

Whiteside, Tamara

2/28/2012

161:8

beyond the scope of 30(B)(6)

Whiteside, Tamara

2/28/2012

161:11

Whiteside, Tamara

2/28/2012

161:23‐162:3

beyond the scope of 30(B)(6)
beyond the scope of 30(B)(6),  161:23‐162:3, 162:6 
Incomplete
(subject to objection)

Whiteside, Tamara

2/28/2012

162:6

beyond the scope of 30(B)(6),  161:23‐162:3, 162:6 
Incomplete
(subject to objection)

WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Whiteside, Tamara

2/28/2012

172:9‐12

Whiteside, Tamara

2/28/2012

176:2‐4

Whiteside, Tamara

2/28/2012

176:11‐12

Whiteside, Tamara
Whiteside, Tamara

2/28/2012
2/28/2012

188:3‐8
223:9‐11

Whiteside, Tamara
Williamson, Richard
Williamson, Richard

2/28/2012 273:7‐25
10/28/2011 5:13‐16
10/28/2011 12:1‐9

Williamson, Richard
Williamson, Richard
Williamson, Richard
Williamson, Richard
Williamson, Richard

10/28/2011
10/28/2011
10/28/2011
10/28/2011
10/28/2011

35:2‐25
36:3‐4
36:6‐13
62:3‐5
62:13‐16

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402, FRE 403, beyond the  172:9‐12, 172:15‐16 
scope of 30(B)(6), incomplete (subject to objection)
FRE 402, FRE 403, beyond the 
scope of 30(B)(6)
FRE 402, FRE 403, beyond the 
scope of 30(B)(6)
186:22‐187:12, 188:3‐
Incomplete, misleading
188:8
FRE 402, FRE 403
FRCP 26(a)(3)(A)(iii) (not on  270:21‐24, 271:13‐25, 
pretrial disclosure), FRE 1002,  273:7‐25 (subject to 
Incomplete, Misleading
objection)

vague; ambiguous; 
foundation
speculation
402; 403

34:15‐35:1

102

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Williamson, Richard
Williamson, Richard

SAMSUNG 
DATE
DESIGNATIONS
10/28/2011 62:18‐19
10/28/2011 62:22‐24

Williamson, Richard

10/28/2011 63:1‐4

Williamson, Richard

10/28/2011 66:22‐67:14

Williamson, Richard

10/28/2011 67:17‐24

Williamson, Richard

10/28/2011 68:7‐8

Williamson, Richard

10/28/2011 68:11‐17

Williamson, Richard

10/28/2011 68:20‐69:11

Williamson, Richard

10/28/2011 69:13‐14

Williamson, Richard
Williamson, Richard
Williamson, Richard

10/28/2011 69:17‐18
10/28/2011 69:24‐70:6
10/28/2011 71:6‐17

Williamson, Richard

10/28/2011 93:7‐9

Williamson, Richard

10/28/2011 93:12‐17

vague; ambiguous; 402; 403
vague; ambiguous; 
incomplete hypothetical; 
legal conlusion; 402; 403
vague; ambiguous; 
incomplete hypothetical
vague; ambiguous; 
incomplete hypothetical; 
lacks foundation
vague; ambiguous; lacks 
foundation; incomplete 
hypothetical
vague; ambiguous; 
incomplete hypothetical
vague; ambiguous; 
incomplete hypothetical
misleading; 402; 403
misleading; 402; 403
vague; ambiguous; legal 
conclusion
vague; ambiguous; legal 
conclusion

10/28/2011 93:19‐21

misleading; vague; 
ambiguous; legal conclusion; 
asked and answered
92:10‐93:6, 93:25‐94:19

10/28/2011 93:23‐24

misleading; vague; 
ambiguous; legal conclusion; 
asked and answered
93:25‐94:19

Williamson, Richard

Williamson, Richard

APPLE OBJECTIONS
legal conclusion
legal conclusion
foundation; speculation; 
legal conclusion; 402; 403

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

63:5‐13

67:25‐68:6

70:7‐71:5
70:7‐71:5
92:10‐93:6
92:10‐93:6

103

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS
vague; ambiguous; legal 
conclusion
vague; ambiguous; legal 
conclusion
vague; ambiguous; legal 
conclusion
vague; ambiguous; legal 
conclusion; 402; 403
vague; ambiguous; 
foundation

Williamson, Richard

10/28/2011 94:20‐21

Williamson, Richard

10/28/2011 94:24‐25

Williamson, Richard

10/28/2011 95:1‐11

Williamson, Richard

10/28/2011 95:23‐96:10

Williamson, Richard

10/28/2011 96:23‐97:9

Williamson, Richard

10/28/2011 99:15‐100:11

Williamson, Richard

10/28/2011 100:14‐101:1

Williamson, Richard

10/28/2011 101:4‐16

Williamson, Richard

10/28/2011 155:25‐159:8

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

vague; ambiguous; 402; 403
vague; ambiguous; 
foundation; 402; 403
vague; ambiguous; 
foundation; 402; 403
402; 403; 802; 1002; 
foundation

10/28/2011 159:10‐17

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

402; 403; 802; 1002; 
foundation; mischaracterizes 
testimony

Williamson, Richard

Williamson, Richard

10/28/2011 159:20‐160:10

Williamson, Richard

10/28/2011 161:12‐17

Williamson, Richard

10/28/2011 161:24‐162:3

96:11‐22

402; 403; 802; 1002; 
foundation; mischaracterizes 
testimony
misleading; 402; 403; 802; 
1002; misstates testimony; 
foundation
161:18‐23
misleading; 402; 403; 802; 
1002; vague; ambiguous; 
misstates testimony; 
foundation

104

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS
402; 403; 802; 1002; vague; 
ambiguous; misstates 
testimony
402; 403; 802; 1002; form
402; 403; 802; 1002; form

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

Williamson, Richard
Williamson, Richard
Williamson, Richard
Winer, Russell
Winer, Russell
Winer, Russell
Winer, Russell
Winer, Russell
Winer, Russell
Winer, Russell
Winer, Russell
Winer, Russell
Winer, Russell
Winer, Russell
Winer, Russell

10/28/2011
10/28/2011
10/28/2011
4/27/2012
4/27/2012
4/27/2012
4/27/2012
4/27/2012
4/27/2012
4/27/2012
4/27/2012
4/27/2012
4/27/2012
4/27/2012
4/27/2012

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

7:8‐10

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

7:19‐25

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

8:1‐5

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

8:18‐22

Woodring, Cooper
Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011
8/5/2011

9:8‐15
11:21‐12:1

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

13:1‐14:3

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

14:10‐16

FRE402; FRE802; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE 402; FRE802; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE 402; FRE 802; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE 402; FRE 802; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE 402; FRE 802; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE 402; FRE 802
FRE 402; FRE 802; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE 402; FRE 802; Withdrawn 
expert

14:18‐21

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402; FRE 802; Withdrawn  17:2‐16 (subject to FRE402 
expert
and FRE802 objections)

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

162:8‐163:11
163:13‐20
163:22‐164:1
4:19‐6:3
35:7‐15
37:6‐9
108:20‐109:17
111:3‐19
126:23‐128:5
216:9‐21
224:21‐225:20
264:15‐265:12
278:8‐279:2
343:9‐344:3
344:16‐347:11

1002

105

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

23:12‐14

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

23:17‐19

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

23:21‐24

APPLE OBJECTIONS
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Speculation; Vague; 
Incomplete hypothetical; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Speculation; Vague; 
Incomplete hypothetical; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE 402; FRE802; 
Speculation; Vague; 
Incomplete hypothetical; 
Withdrawn expert

24:6‐8

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
calls for a legal conclusion; 
Withdrawn expert

Woodring, Cooper

DATE

8/5/2011

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

24:13‐15

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

25:14‐16

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

25:18

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

27:11‐12

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

27:14

FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
calls for a legal conclusion; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
vague; speculation; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
vague; speculation; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
vague; speculation; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
vague; speculation; 
Withdrawn expert

25:19‐24 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)

106

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Woodring, Cooper

Woodring, Cooper

Woodring, Cooper

Woodring, Cooper

Woodring, Cooper

DATE

8/5/2011

8/5/2011

8/5/2011

8/5/2011

8/5/2011

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

28:4‐6

28:8

28:10‐12

28:14‐15

28:17‐19

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

28:21

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

29:7‐21

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

29:24‐30:3

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

30:6

APPLE OBJECTIONS
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
vague; speculation; legal 
conclusion; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
vague; speculation; legal 
conclusion; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
vague; speculation; 
argumentative; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
vague; speculation; 
argumentative; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
vague; speculation; 
argumentative; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
vague; speculation; 
argumentative; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
compound; vague; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
compound; vague; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
compound; vague; 
Withdrawn expert

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

27:16‐25 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)
27:16‐25 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)
27:16‐25 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)
27:16‐25 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)
27:16‐25 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)
27:16‐25 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)

107

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

30:8‐9

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

30:11‐17

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

30:19‐23

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

30:25‐31:2

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

31:4

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

34:22‐23

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

35:5‐7

APPLE OBJECTIONS
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
vague; speculation; 
incomplete hypothetical; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
vague; speculation; 
incomplete hypothetical; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
vague; speculation; 
incomplete hypothetical; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
compound; vague; 
speculation; incomplete 
hypothetical; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
compound; vague; 
speculation; incomplete 
hypothetical; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
compound; vague; 
speculation; incomplete 
hypothetical; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
compound; vague; 
speculation; incomplete 
hypothetical; Withdrawn 
expert

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

108

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

40:23‐25

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

52:23‐25

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

53:2‐4

APPLE OBJECTIONS
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
vague; speculation; 
incomplete hypothetical; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
vague; speculation; 
incomplete hypothetical; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
vague; speculation; 
incomplete hypothetical; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
vague; speculation; 
incomplete hypothetical; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
vague; speculation; 
incomplete hypothetical; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
vague; lacks foundation; 
speculation; incomplete 
hypothetical; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE 402; FRE602; FRE 802; 
vague; lacks foundation; 
speculation; incomplete 
hypothetical; Withdrawn 
expert

57:17‐20

FRE402; FRE802; Vague; 
Withdrawn expert

Woodring, Cooper

Woodring, Cooper

Woodring, Cooper

Woodring, Cooper

Woodring, Cooper

DATE

8/5/2011

8/5/2011

8/5/2011

8/5/2011

8/5/2011

39:2‐3

39:5‐9

40:8‐10

40:13‐20

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

37:25‐38:3, 38:5, 38:7, 
38:9‐13 (subject to FRE402 
and FRE802 objections)
37:25‐38:3, 38:5, 38:7, 
38:9‐13 (subject to FRE402 
and FRE802 objections)
37:25‐38:3, 38:5, 38:7, 
38:9‐13 (subject to FRE402 
and FRE802 objections)
37:25‐38:3, 38:5, 38:7, 
38:9‐13 (subject to FRE402 
and FRE802 objections)
37:25‐38:3, 38:5, 38:7, 
38:9‐13 (subject to FRE402 
and FRE802 objections)

57:21, 57:23‐24 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)

109

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

58:1‐2

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

58:4‐12

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

58:14

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

58:19‐59:9

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

74:21‐25

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

75:2‐3

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

76:2‐6

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

76:9‐12

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

87:9‐25

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

88:17‐89:4

APPLE OBJECTIONS
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE402; FRE602;  FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; legal 
conclusion; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; legal 
conclusion; Withdrawn 
expert

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS
57:21, 57:23‐24 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)
57:21, 57:23‐24 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)
57:21, 57:23‐24 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

76:13‐25 (subject to FRE 
402 and FRE802 objection)
76:13‐25 (subject to FRE 
402 and FRE802 objection)

110

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

96:4‐8

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

96:11

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

111:6‐11

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

111:13‐14

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

111:16‐112:2

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

112:4‐9

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

114:12‐22

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

115:10‐116:21

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

118:7‐15

APPLE OBJECTIONS
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; legal 
conclusion; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; legal 
conclusion; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; legal 
conclusion; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; legal 
conclusion; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; legal 
conclusion; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; legal 
conclusion; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; legal 
conclusion; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; legal 
conclusion; Withdrawn 
expert

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

118:16‐119:1 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)

111

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Woodring, Cooper

Woodring, Cooper

Woodring, Cooper

Woodring, Cooper

DATE

8/5/2011

8/5/2011

8/5/2011

8/5/2011

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

122:22‐123:2

123:5‐6

153:12‐18

153:21‐154:14

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

154:16

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

156:11‐13

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

156:15

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

157:14‐18

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

157:21‐158:12

APPLE OBJECTIONS
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; 
Incomplete hypothetical; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; 
Incomplete hypothetical; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Compound; Vague; 
Speculation; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Compound; Vague; 
Speculation; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Compound; Vague; 
Speculation; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; 
Withdrawn expert

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

121:22‐122:12 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)
121:22‐122:12 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)
296:18‐298:6 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)
296:18‐298:6 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)
296:18‐298:6 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)
156:17‐157:4 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)
156:17‐157:4 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)
156:17‐157:4 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)
156:17‐157:4 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)

112

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Woodring, Cooper

DATE

8/5/2011

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

173:11‐21

APPLE OBJECTIONS
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; 
Withdrawn expert

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS
169:25‐170:12, 172:7‐21, 
174:12‐22 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)
169:25‐170:12, 172:7‐21, 
174:12‐22 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

173:25‐174:1

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

181:14‐182:6

FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; 
Withdrawn expert

206:15‐207:1

FRE402; FRE403; FRE602; 
FRE802; Vague; Speculation; 
Misleading; Calls for legal 
conclusion; Incomplete 
hypothetical; Limiting 
instruction needed; 
Withdrawn expert

211:22‐212:16, 212:23‐
213:22; 216:24‐217:8; 
217:16‐218:1; 223:2‐23; 
224:2‐12; 224:20‐225:11; 
227:19‐229:18 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)

207:7‐14

FRE402; FRE403; FRE602; 
FRE802; Vague; Speculation; 
Misleading; Calls for legal 
conclusion; Incomplete 
hypothetical; Limiting 
instruction needed; 
Withdrawn expert

211:22‐212:16, 212:23‐
213:22; 216:24‐217:8; 
217:16‐218:1; 223:2‐23; 
224:2‐12; 224:20‐225:11; 
227:19‐229:18 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)

207:16‐24

FRE402; FRE403; FRE602; 
FRE802; Vague; Speculation; 
Misleading; Calls for legal 
conclusion; Incomplete 
hypothetical; Limiting 
instruction needed; 
Withdrawn expert

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

211:22‐212:16, 212:23‐
213:22; 216:24‐217:8; 
217:16‐218:1; 223:2‐23; 
224:2‐12; 224:20‐225:11; 
227:19‐229:18 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)

Woodring, Cooper

Woodring, Cooper

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

8/5/2011

8/5/2011

113

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Woodring, Cooper

DATE

8/5/2011

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

208:1‐16

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

208:20‐21

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

229:19‐22

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

229:25‐230:1

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

231:12‐18

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

235:10‐14

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

FRE402; FRE403; FRE602; 
FRE802; Vague; Speculation; 
Misleading; Calls for legal 
conclusion; Incomplete 
hypothetical; Limiting 
instruction needed; 
Withdrawn expert

211:22‐212:16, 212:23‐
213:22; 216:24‐217:8; 
217:16‐218:1; 223:2‐23; 
224:2‐12; 224:20‐225:11; 
227:19‐229:18 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)

FRE402; FRE403; FRE602; 
FRE802; Vague; Speculation; 
Misleading; Calls for legal 
conclusion; Incomplete 
hypothetical; Limiting 
instruction needed; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; Calls for 
legal conclusion; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; Calls for 
legal conclusion; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; Calls for 
legal conclusion; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; Calls for 
legal conclusion; Withdrawn 
expert

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

211:22‐212:16, 212:23‐
213:22; 216:24‐217:8; 
217:16‐218:1; 223:2‐23; 
224:2‐12; 224:20‐225:11; 
227:19‐229:18 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)

230:2‐8 (subject to FRE402 
and FRE802 objections)
231:19‐232:7 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)

114

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

236:9‐16

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

252:7‐12

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

252:14‐18

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

252:23‐24

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

255:19‐24

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

256:2‐3

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

279:9‐280:1

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

280:8‐18

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

282:22‐283:1

APPLE OBJECTIONS
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; Calls for 
legal conclusion; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; Calls for 
legal conclusion; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; Calls for 
legal conclusion; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; Calls for 
legal conclusion; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; Calls for 
legal conclusion; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; Calls for 
legal conclusion; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; Calls for 
legal conclusion; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; Calls for 
legal conclusion; Withdrawn 
expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; 
Withdrawn expert

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

235:15‐18, 236:2‐3 
(subject to FRE402 and 
FRE802 objections)

282:16‐21; 283:2‐6 
(subject to FRE402 and 
FRE802 objections)
115

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

283:9‐15

Woodring, Cooper

8/5/2011

283:19‐20

Woodring, Cooper
Zadesky, Stephen

8/5/2011
3/5/2012

284:1‐6
9:11‐12

Zadesky, Stephen ITC‐796

4/12/2012

14:23‐15:20

Zadesky, Stephen ITC‐796

4/12/2012

34:11‐36:14

Zadesky, Stephen ITC‐796

4/12/2012

63:1‐3

Zadesky, Stephen ITC‐796

4/12/2012

63:6‐12

Zadesky, Stephen ITC‐796
Zadesky, Stephen ITC‐796

4/12/2012
4/12/2012

69:18‐71:15
76:5‐13

Zadesky, Stephen ITC‐796
Zorkendorfer, Rico

4/12/2012 175:13‐178:2
10/21/2011 6:9‐7:7

APPLE OBJECTIONS
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; 
Withdrawn expert
FRE402; FRE602; FRE802; 
Vague; Speculation; 
Withdrawn expert

Zorkendorfer, Rico

10/21/2011 44:18‐25

1002; Not trial exhibit
1002; Not trial exhibit; 403

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

284:7‐21 (subject to 
FRE402 and FRE802 
objections)
15:21‐16:1; 
16:2‐14; 16:16‐24; 19:10‐
20:4
36:15‐17

Lacks Foundation;
402; 403

62:18‐25; 63:13; 63:15‐16; 
63:18‐64:10; 64:12‐64:14

Lacks Foundation; 
402; 403
Lacks Foundation; 
Speculation;
403
Lacks Foundation
1002; Not trial exhibit; 402; 
403

62:18‐25; 63:13; 63:15‐16; 
63:18‐64:10; 64:12‐64:14

71:16‐23
76:18‐24
178:6‐8

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

116

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS

10/21/2011 45:10‐14

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 45:24‐25

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 47:6‐8

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 47:11‐12

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 47:25‐48:5

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 48:7‐8

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 50:15‐20

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 45:17‐21

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

117

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS

10/21/2011 50:23‐51:3

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 51:14‐20

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 51:22‐52:2

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 52:2‐3

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 52:4‐9

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 52:11‐18

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 52:20‐25

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 51:6‐12

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

118

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico
Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico
Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS

10/21/2011 53:2‐3

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 62:3‐8

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 61:24‐62:1

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 62:11‐16
10/21/2011 62:18‐19

10/21/2011 90:6‐20

10/21/2011 90:23‐91:8
10/21/2011 91:11‐12

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation
FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 92:9‐21

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 92:25‐93:5

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

119

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS

10/21/2011 93:7‐16

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 93:25‐94:1

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 94:4‐9

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 94:11‐16

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 94:19‐24

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 95:2‐5

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 108:4‐8

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 93:19‐22

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

120

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico
Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico
Zorkendorfer, Rico

Zorkendorfer, Rico ITC‐796

Zorkendorfer, Rico ITC‐796
Zorn, Andre

Zorn, Andre
Zorn, Andre
Zorn, Andre

DATE

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

APPLE OBJECTIONS

10/21/2011 108:10‐17

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 110:3‐21

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

10/21/2011 110:23‐111:2
10/21/2011 111:4

10/21/2011 111:12‐14
10/21/2011 111:16

2/10/2012

2/10/2012
3/20/2011

3/20/2011
3/20/2011
3/20/2011

154:9‐16

154:9‐16
7:7‐16

9:2‐10:22
11:23‐25
12:2‐6

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation

FRE 402; FRE 701; Calls for 
expert testimony; misleading; 
lack of foundation
37:14‐38:14; 115:11‐17; 
115:19‐116:4; 152:22‐
FRE 402; misleading; lack of  154:7; 179:20‐180:6; 202:2‐
foundation; vague; 
203:2
37:14‐38:14; 115:11‐116:4; 
152:22‐154:7; 179:20‐
180:6; 202:2‐203:2
30:13‐30:15; 30:17‐31:10; 
31:13; 35:23‐25; 36:2‐3; 
38:23‐39:4; 40:19‐24; 41:2‐
12; 89:25‐90:7; 90:9; 91:22‐
23; 92:1‐4; 92:6; 92:19‐22; 
92:25

121

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS
Zorn, Andre

DATE
3/20/2011

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS
12:8‐13:8

Zorn, Andre

3/20/2011

19:1‐3

Zorn, Andre

3/20/2011

19:5‐15

Zorn, Andre

3/20/2011

19:17‐22

Zorn, Andre

3/20/2011

APPLE OBJECTIONS
Vague ‐ 12:19‐21

20:4‐7

Zorn, Andre

3/20/2011

23:12‐15

Vague/Foundation ‐ 23:14‐
15; Vague/Foundation ‐ 
23:17

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

30:13‐30:15; 30:17‐31:10; 
31:13; 35:23‐25; 36:2‐3; 
38:23‐39:4; 40:19‐24; 41:2‐
12; 89:25‐90:7; 90:9; 91:22‐
23; 92:1‐4; 92:6; 92:19‐22; 
92:25
30:13‐30:15; 30:17‐31:10; 
31:13; 35:23‐25; 36:2‐3; 
38:23‐39:4; 40:19‐24; 41:2‐
12; 89:25‐90:7; 90:9; 91:22‐
23; 92:1‐4; 92:6; 92:19‐22; 
92:25
30:13‐30:15; 30:17‐31:10; 
31:13; 35:23‐25; 36:2‐3; 
38:23‐39:4; 40:19‐24; 41:2‐
12; 89:25‐90:7; 90:9; 91:22‐
23; 92:1‐4; 92:6; 92:19‐22; 
92:25
30:13‐30:15; 30:17‐31:10; 
31:13; 35:23‐25; 36:2‐3; 
38:23‐39:4; 40:19‐24; 41:2‐
12; 89:25‐90:7; 90:9; 91:22‐
23; 92:1‐4; 92:6; 92:19‐22; 
92:25
30:13‐30:15; 30:17‐31:10; 
31:13; 35:23‐25; 36:2‐3; 
38:23‐39:4; 40:19‐24; 41:2‐
12; 89:25‐90:7; 90:9; 91:22‐
23; 92:1‐4; 92:6; 92:19‐22; 
92:25

122

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations

Zorn, Andre

3/20/2011

23:17‐25

Zorn, Andre

3/20/2011

28:7‐10

Zorn, Andre

3/20/2011

29:5‐16

Vague 29:13‐16

Zorn, Andre
Zorn, Andre
Zorn, Andre
Zorn, Andre
Zorn, Andre

3/20/2011
3/20/2011
3/20/2011
3/20/2011
3/20/2011

29:19‐30:4
31:15‐20
37:25‐38:17
39:5‐20
40:3‐9

Vague 29:19

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS
30:13‐30:15; 30:17‐31:10; 
31:13; 35:23‐25; 36:2‐3; 
38:23‐39:4; 40:19‐24; 41:2‐
12; 89:25‐90:7; 90:9; 91:22‐
23; 92:1‐4; 92:6; 92:19‐22; 
92:25
30:13‐30:15; 30:17‐31:10; 
31:13; 35:23‐25; 36:2‐3; 
38:23‐39:4; 40:19‐24; 41:2‐
12; 89:25‐90:7; 90:9; 91:22‐
23; 92:1‐4; 92:6; 92:19‐22; 
92:25
30:13‐30:15; 30:17‐31:10; 
31:13; 35:23‐25; 36:2‐3; 
38:23‐39:4; 40:19‐24; 41:2‐
12; 89:25‐90:7; 90:9; 91:22‐
23; 92:1‐4; 92:6; 92:19‐22; 
92:25
30:13‐30:15; 30:17‐31:10; 
31:13; 35:23‐25; 36:2‐3; 
38:23‐39:4; 40:19‐24; 41:2‐
12; 89:25‐90:7; 90:9; 91:22‐
23; 92:1‐4; 92:6; 92:19‐22; 
92:25

Incomplete 

30:13‐30:15; 30:17‐31:10; 
31:13; 35:23‐25; 36:2‐3; 
38:23‐39:4; 40:19‐24; 41:2‐
12; 89:25‐90:7; 90:9; 91:22‐
23; 92:1‐4; 92:6; 92:19‐22; 
92:25

WITNESS

Zorn, Andre
Zorn, Andre

DATE

3/20/2011
3/20/2011

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

40:11‐18
41:17‐42:1

APPLE OBJECTIONS

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

123

Apple v. Samsung , No. 11‐01846
Apple's Objections and Counter‐Designations
WITNESS

Zorn, Andre
Zorn, Andre
Zorn, Andre

DATE

3/20/2011
3/20/2011
3/20/2011

SAMSUNG 
DESIGNATIONS

48:7‐49:5
59:20‐60:4
60:6‐10

Zorn, Andre

3/20/2011

67:16‐68:6

Zorn, Andre

3/20/2011

68:8‐11

Zorn, Andre

3/20/2011

73:4‐74:15

APPLE OBJECTIONS

APPLE COUNTER 
DESIGNATIONS
100:2‐6; 100:8‐13; 100:16‐
101:3; 101:5‐13; 101:15‐
21; 102:4‐7; 102:10‐20; 
102:22‐24; 103:1‐15; 
103:17‐104:5; 104:8‐15; 
104:18‐24 

SAMSUNG 
OBJECTIONS

100:2‐6; 100:8‐13; 100:16‐
101:3; 101:5‐13; 101:15‐
21; 102:4‐7; 102:10‐20; 
102:22‐24; 103:1‐15; 
103:17‐104:5; 104:8‐15; 
104:18‐24
100:2‐6; 100:8‐13; 100:16‐
101:3; 101:5‐13; 101:15‐
21; 102:4‐7; 102:10‐20; 
102:22‐24; 103:1‐15; 
103:17‐104:5; 104:8‐15; 
104:18‐24
100:2‐6; 100:8‐13; 100:16‐
101:3; 101:5‐13; 101:15‐
21; 102:4‐7; 102:10‐20; 
102:22‐24; 103:1‐15; 
103:17‐104:5; 104:8‐15; 
104:18‐24

124