Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al

Filing 1505

Declaration of Henri Lamiraux in Support of 1495 Administrative Motion to File Under Seal APPLE'S MOTION TO SEAL CONFIDENTIAL TRIAL EXHIBITS filed byApple Inc.. (Related document(s) 1495 ) (Jacobs, Michael) (Filed on 7/30/2012)

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9

HAROLD J. MCELHINNY (CA SBN 66781)
[e-mail]
MICHAEL A. JACOBS (CA SBN 111664)
[e-mail]
JENNIFER LEE TAYLOR (CA SBN 161368)
[e-mail]
ALISON M. TUCHER (CA SBN 171363)
[e-mail]
RICHARD S.J. HUNG (CA SBN 197425)
[e-mail]
JASON R. BARTLETT (CA SBN 214530)
[e-mail]
MORRISON & FOERSTER LLP
425 Market Street
San Francisco, California 94105-2482
Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: [phone]

10

WILLIAM F. LEE
[e-mail]
WILMER CUTLER PICKERING
HALE AND DORR LLP
60 State Street
Boston, MA 02109
Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: [phone]
MARK D. SELWYN (SBN 244180)
[e-mail]
WILMER CUTLER PICKERING
HALE AND DORR LLP
950 Page Mill Road
Palo Alto, California 94304
Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: [phone]

11
12

Attorneys for Plaintiff and
Counterclaim-Defendant APPLE INC.

13
14

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

15

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

16

SAN JOSE DIVISION

17

APPLE INC., a California corporation,

18
19
20
21
22

Plaintiff,
v.

Case No. 11-cv-01846-LHK
DECLARATION OF HENRI LAMIRAUX IN
SUPPORT OF APPLE’S MOTION TO SEAL
TRIAL EXHIBITS

SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS CO., LTD., a
Korean corporation; SAMSUNG
ELECTRONICS AMERICA, INC., a New
York corporation; and SAMSUNG
TELECOMMUNICATIONS AMERICA,
LLC, a Delaware limited liability company,

23
Defendants.
24
25
26
27
28
DECLARATION OF HENRI LAMIRAUX IN SUPPORT OF RENEWED MOTION TO FILE UNDER SEAL
CASE NO. 11-CV-01846-LHK
sf-3174344

1

I, Henri Lamiraux, hereby declare as follows:

2

1.

I am an employee of Apple Inc. (“Apple”). My title is Vice President of iOS Apps

3

& Frameworks for Apple. As part of my role, I am very familiar with the development of

4

Apple’s source code and Apple’s efforts to ensure that its source code is not disclosed outside of a

5

select group of individuals at Apple. I submit this declaration in support of Apple’s Renewed

6

Motion to Seal Trial Exhibits. I have personal knowledge of the matters set forth below. If called

7

as a witness I could and would competently testify as follows.

8
9
10
11

2.

I have been employed at Apple since 1990 and am currently the Vice President of

iOS Apps & Frameworks. I received an engineering degree in chemistry from Ecole Nationale
Supérieure de Chimie de Montpellier.
3.

My responsibilities as Vice President of iOS Apps & Frameworks involve

12

managing employees who develop the source code, applications and frameworks for Apple’s iOS.

13

iOS is the operating system on Apple’s iPhone, iPad and iPod touch products. Part of my

14

responsibilities include maintaining the security and secrecy of Apple’s iOS source code. Apple

15

does make certain very limited portions of the iOS code available as open source code, but the

16

large portions of the code relating to the unique functionality of the iOS operating system are not

17

publicly available.

18

4.

Apple source code is provided the highest level of protection and security within

19

Apple. Physical access to the iOS source code is limited to select groups of authorized Apple

20

employees, with access being provided only to portions of code on a need-to-know basis. Access

21

is limited to employees directly involved in software development, management, and security.

22

The employees with such access must be approved by management as authorized employees,

23

their accounts must be specifically granted access.

24

5.

iOS source code is provided the highest level of protection and security within

25

Apple because it is not public information and it is at the heart of the success and unique

26

functionality of its iOS devices including the iPhone, iPad and iPod touch. iOS source code

27

controls how these devices operate and provides Apple’s iOS devices with their unique, easy to

28

operate user interfaces. Apple has invested billions of dollars in conjunction with the
DECLARATION OF HENRI LAMIRAUX IN SUPPORT OF RENEWED MOTION TO SEAL
CASE NO. 11-CV-01846-LHK
sf-3174344

1

1

development of its iOS source code. This source code, including the source code files identified

2

in Appendix A, is extremely valuable. In part, this value exists because Apple’s source code is

3

unique to Apple.

4

6.

To preserve this uniqueness, Apple does not share its source code with others or

5

make it available to the public. Accordingly, disclosure of the source code files listed in

6

Appendix A to the general public including Apple’s competitors would cause Apple significant

7

competitive harm. If these source code files were to enter the public record, Apple’s competitors

8

would be free to copy Apple’s extremely valuable source code. This ability to copy Apple’s

9

source code would give its competitors an unfair competitive advantage, to the significant

10

detriment to the investment that Apple has made in developing iOS and the specific source code

11

files listed in Appendix A.

12

7.

Any dissemination of source code outside the tight controls maintained within

13

Apple’s or its counsel’s facilities poses the risk of unauthorized disclosure and great injury to

14

Apple. In fact, even in cases such as this one in which source code must be produced (under the

15

strict guidelines of source code provisions of the Protective Order), Apple does not permit its own

16

experts to have electronic or hard copies of its source code during litigation.

17

8.

Apple’s restrictions on access to its source code by third parties and its employees

18

are especially necessary because the electronic nature of source code renders the code easily

19

copied.

20

9.

The specific portions of Apple source code which we are asking this Court to seal

21

have always been non-public, and their exposure would cause Apple to lose significant

22

competitive advantage.

23

10.

Plaintiff’s Exhibit 121 is a collection of four (4) Apple iOS source code files.

24

Apple considers these source code files to be trade secrets. Public disclosure of this information

25

would be extremely harmful to Apple to for the reasons described above.

26

11.

Defendant’s Exhibit 645 is a collection of one hundred sixty-nine (169) Apple iOS

27

source code files. Apple considers these source code files to be trade secrets. Public disclosure

28

of this information would be extremely harmful to Apple to for the reasons described above. To
DECLARATION OF HENRI LAMIRAUX IN SUPPORT OF RENEWED MOTION TO SEAL
CASE NO. 11-CV-01846-LHK
sf-3174344

2

1

my knowledge, with the exception of part of source code file AVPlayer.h and source code files

2

MFMailComposeViewController.h and MFMessageComposeViewController.h, this information

3

has never been publicly disclosed. Apple does not seek to file under seal any public portions of

4

Exhibit 645.

5
6

12.

Attached as Appendix A is a list of the individual source code files in Exhibits 121

and 645 that Apple seeks to seal for the reasons explained above.

7
8
9

I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed this
30th day of July, 2012 at Cupertino, California.

10
11

/S/ Henri Lamiraux
Henri Lamiraux

12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
DECLARATION OF HENRI LAMIRAUX IN SUPPORT OF RENEWED MOTION TO SEAL
CASE NO. 11-CV-01846-LHK
sf-3174344

3

Appendix A to the Declaration of Henri Lamiraux

Trial Exhibit

Bates range

Samsung 645

APLNDC-WH-SC 00000390-4001

Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645

1

APLNDC-WH-SC 00000401-403
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000404-409
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000386-389
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007695-704
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007705
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007706-707
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007709-710
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007711-713
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007708
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007715
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007716-717
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007714
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007718
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007719-21
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009584
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009585-86
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009857-58
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009559-72
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009859-85
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007930
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009573
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009574-75
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009886-87

Because part of this file is public, a redacted version will be lodged with the Court.

-1ACTIVEUS 98855608v1

Appendix A to the Declaration of Henri Lamiraux

Trial Exhibit
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645

Bates range
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009576
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009888
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009577-79
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009889-91
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009580
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009581-83
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009892
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009893-95
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009896
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009897-98

Samsung 645
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000298
Samsung 645
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000299
Samsung 645
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000300
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645

APLNDC-WH-SC 00007990-91
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007992-94
APLNDC-WH-SC 00010108-117
APLNDC-WH-SC 00010118-125
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009795-802
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009803-10
APLNDC-WH-SC 00010052-55
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009683-87
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009688-737

-2ACTIVEUS 98855608v1

Appendix A to the Declaration of Henri Lamiraux

Trial Exhibit
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645

Bates range
APLNDC-WH-SC 00010056
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009738
APLNDC-WH-SC 00010057
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009739
APLNDC-WH-SC 00010058-60
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009740-43
APLNDC-WH-SC 00010061-90
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009744-78
APLNDC-WH-SC 00010100
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009787
APLNDC-WH-SC 00010091-92
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009779-80
APLNDC-WH-SC 00010093-99
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009781-86
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000301-00000304
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000410-414
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000415-416
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009937
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009938-40
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009606
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009907
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009607-09
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009908-10
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009911
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009912-21
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009935
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009936
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009948-50
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009944-71
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009610

-3ACTIVEUS 98855608v1

Appendix A to the Declaration of Henri Lamiraux

Trial Exhibit

Bates range

Samsung 645
Samsung 645

APLNDC-WH-SC 00009611-16

Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645

APLNDC-WH-SC 00009624
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009980
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009625
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009981
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009620-23
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009975-79
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009628-29
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009984-87
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009630
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009631-32
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009633
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009634-35
APLNDC-WH-SC 00009999
APLNDC-WH-SC 00010000-01
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000305
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000306
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000307-314
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000329-332
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000333-336
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000337-359
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000360-363
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000364
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000365-369
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000327-28
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000379

-4ACTIVEUS 98855608v1

Appendix A to the Declaration of Henri Lamiraux

Trial Exhibit
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645

Bates range
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000370-378
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000417-432
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000380-385
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000315-26
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007623-25
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007459-61
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007462-508
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007626-27
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007628-52
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007653-74
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007320‐7431
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007909-15
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007916-22
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007923-29
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007902-08

Samsung 645 &
Apple 121
Samsung 645 &
Apple 121

APLNDC-WH-SC 00000079‐126

Samsung 645

APLNDC-WH-SC 00007987-89

Samsung 645 &
Apple 121
Samsung 645

APLNDC-WH-SC 00010644-45

Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645

APLNDC-WH-SC 00000078‐96

APLNDC-WH-SC 00000235‐247
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000458‐468
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000468‐471
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000471‐475
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000475‐479
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000479‐491
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007722-23
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007724-46

-5ACTIVEUS 98855608v1

Appendix A to the Declaration of Henri Lamiraux

Trial Exhibit
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645

Bates range
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000450-452
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000433-444
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007747
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007748-52
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007753-54
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007755-768
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007769
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007770
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007771
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007772
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007773-774
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007775-803
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007804-807
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007808-830
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007831
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007832-35
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007843
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007836
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007837-42
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007844-47
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007848-60
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000448-449
APLNDC-WH-SC 000007874-7889
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007874-901
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000513‐517
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000453‐454
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007861
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007862-63
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007931-40
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007941-86
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007864
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007865
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007866
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007867-73

-6ACTIVEUS 98855608v1

Appendix A to the Declaration of Henri Lamiraux

Trial Exhibit
Samsung 645
Samsung 645
Samsung 645

Bates range
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000492
APLNDC-WH-SC 00000496-498
APLNDC-WH-SC 00007675-94

-7ACTIVEUS 98855608v1