Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd. et al

Filing 1550

EXHIBITS re 1549 MOTION to Strike Apple's Response to Declaration of John B. Quinn and Purported Recommendation Regarding Sanction Exhibit 1 to Declaration of Joby Martin filed bySamsung Electronics America, Inc.(a New York corporation), Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd., Samsung Telecommunications America, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 2, # 2 Exhibit 3, # 3 Exhibit 4, # 4 Exhibit 5, # 5 Exhibit 6)(Related document(s) 1549 ) (Maroulis, Victoria) (Filed on 8/2/2012)

EXHIBIT 1

Samsung’s Independent Creation of Smartphones

Report of the Samsung Mobile Design Team – “Master Popular Communication Piece” – Summer 2006 (Exh. 596.009)
11

Samsung Designs In Development Before The iPhone
“Vessel”
Report of the Samsung Mobile Design Team –
“MPCP Project 2006” (Exh. 522.042)

12

Samsung Designs In Development Before The iPhone
“Q-Bowl”
Report of the Samsung Mobile Design Team –
“MPCP Project 2006” (Exh. 522.045)

13

Samsung Designs In Development Before The iPhone
“Bowl”
Report of the Samsung Mobile Design Team –
“MPCP Project 2006” (Exh. 522.043)

14

Samsung Designs In Development Before The iPhone
“Slide”
Samsung Mobile Design Team –
“Master Popular Communication Piece” –
July 2006 (Exh. 625.010)

15

Samsung Designs In Development Before The iPhone

Samsung Mobile UX Group – Report Entitled “IReen Interaction Design” – Sept. 14, 2006 (Exh. 566.014)
16

Samsung Designs In Development Before The iPhone
Samsung Mobile UX Group –
“IReen Interaction Design”
(Sept. 14, 2006) (Exh. 566.014)

17

Samsung Designs In Development Before The iPhone
Samsung Mobile UX Group –
“IReen Interaction Design”
(Sept. 14, 2006) (Exh. 566.038)

18

Samsung Designs In Development Before The iPhone

Samsung
“Vessel”

Samsung
“Q-Bowl”

Samsung
“Bowl”

Samsung
“Slide”

2006

Samsung Design
from “IReen” Report

Initial iPhone

2007

19

“Sony-Style” Designs
Shin Nishibori - Apple Design Inventor
A. Well, may I explain how the direction of this process -- rather, may I explain
how this idea came out?

Q. Please.
A. First, Jonathan Ive talked to me. "Well, Shin, I have something to talk to you
about.” He said, "You can do this as an aside of your job and enjoy - I want
you to enjoy doing this. But if Sony were to make an iPhone, what would it be
like? Would you make it for me?”
– 5/2/12 Depo. at 22:24-23:12

Exh. 1.43
10

“Sony-Style” Designs
Shin Nishibori - Apple Design Inventor
Q. Do you recognize what these pictures are? …Please tell us what you
recognize them as.

A. It is -- these are renderings that I created based on my own thoughts or my
understanding of Sony-like designs - Sony’s design, based on the request by
Jonathan Ive.
– 5/2/12 Depo. at 30:3-12

Exh. 623.001
21

“Sony-Style” Designs

Exh. 562.001003

22