Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd. et al

Filing 1415

ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL: (Re: Docket Nos. #476 , #490 , #498 , #516 , #526 , #528 , #531 , #533 , #540 , #541 , #561 , #563 , #577 , #582 , #592 , #593 , #613 , #632 , #649 , #656 , #669 , #676 , #681 , #689 , #711 , #721 , #738 , #742 and #743 ). Signed by Judge Paul S. Grewal on 3/7/2014. (ofr, COURT STAFF) (Filed on 3/7/2014)

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9

United States District Court
For the Northern District of California

10

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

11

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

12

SAN JOSE DIVISION

13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21

)
)
Plaintiff,
)
)
v.
)
SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS CO., LTD., a
)
)
Korean corporation; SAMSUNG
ELECTRONICS AMERICA, INC., a New York )
corporation; and SAMSUNG
)
TELECOMMUNICATIONS AMERICA, LLC, )
a Delaware limited liability company,
)
)
Defendants.
)
)
APPLE INC., a California Corporation,

Case No.: 5:12-cv-0630-LHK-PSG
ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL
(Re: Docket Nos. 476, 490, 498, 516, 526,
528, 531, 533, 540, 541, 561, 563, 577,
582, 592, 593, 613, 632, 649, 656, 669,
676, 681, 689, 711, 721, 738, 742, 743)

Before the court are 29 administrative motions to seal 179 documents. “Historically, courts

22
23

have recognized a ‘general right to inspect and copy public records and documents, including

24

judicial records and documents.’” 1 Accordingly, when considering a sealing request, “a ‘strong

25

presumption in favor of access’ is the starting point.” 2 Parties seeking to seal judicial records

26
27
28

1

Kamakana v. City & County of Honolulu, 447 F.3d 1172, 1178 (9th Cir. 2006)
(quoting Nixon v. Warner Commc’ns, Inc., 435 U.S. 589, 597 & n. 7 (1978)).
1
Case No.: 5:12-cv-0630-LHK-PSG
ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL

1
2

relating to dispositive motions bear the burden of overcoming the presumption with “compelling
reasons” that outweigh the general history of access and the public policies favoring disclosure. 3

3

However, “while protecting the public's interest in access to the courts, we must remain

4

mindful of the parties' right to access those same courts upon terms which will not unduly harm

5

their competitive interest.” 4 Records attached to nondispositive motions therefore are not subject

6

to the strong presumption of access. 5 Because the documents attached to nondispositive motions

7
“are often unrelated, or only tangentially related, to the underlying cause of action,” parties moving
8
9

to seal must meet the lower “good cause” standard of Rule 26(c). 6 As with dispositive motions, the

United States District Court
For the Northern District of California

10

standard applicable to nondispositive motions requires a “particularized showing” 7 that “specific

11

prejudice or harm will result” if the information is disclosed. 8 “Broad allegations of harm,

12

unsubstantiated by specific examples of articulated reasoning” will not suffice. 9 A protective order

13
14

sealing the documents during discovery may reflect the court’s previous determination that good
cause exists to keep the documents sealed, 10 but a blanket protective order that allows the parties to

15
16
17
18
19

2

Id. (quoting Foltz v. State Farm Mut. Auto. Ins. Co., 331 F.3d 1122, 1135 (9th Cir. 2003)).

20

3

Id. at 1178-79.

21

4

Apple Inc. v. Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd., 727 F.3d 1214, 1228-29 (Fed. Cir. 2013).

22

5

See id. at 1180.

23

6

Id. at 1179 (internal quotations and citations omitted).

24

7

Id.

25

8

26

Phillips ex rel. Estates of Byrd v. Gen. Motors Corp., 307 F.3d 1206, 1210-11 (9th Cir. 2002);
see Fed. R. Civ. P. 26(c).
9

27

Beckman Indus., Inc. v. Int’l Ins. Co., 966 F.2d 470, 476 (9th Cir. 1992).

10

28

See Kamakana, 447 F.3d at 1179-80.
2

Case No.: 5:12-cv-0630-LHK-PSG
ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL

1
2

designate confidential documents does not provide sufficient judicial scrutiny to determine whether
each particular document should remain sealed. 11
In addition to making particularized showings of good cause, parties moving to seal

3
4

documents must comply with the procedures established by Civ. L.R. 79-5. Pursuant to

5

Civ. L.R. 79-5(b), a sealing order is appropriate only upon a request that establishes the document

6

is “sealable,” or “privileged or protectable as a trade secret or otherwise entitled to protection under

7
the law.” “The request must be narrowly tailored to seek sealing only of sealable material, and
8
9

must conform with Civil L.R. 79-5(d).” 12 “Within 4 days of the filing of the Administrative

United States District Court
For the Northern District of California

10

Motion to File Under Seal, the Designating Party must file a declaration as required by subsection

11

79-5(d)(1)(A) establishing that all of the designated material is sealable.” 13

12
13
14

With these standards in mind, the courts rules on the instant motions as follows:
Motion
to Seal
476

15
16

476/490

17
18

476

19
20

476

21

Document to be Sealed
Samsung's Motion to
Amend Infringement
Contention
Exhibit 4 to the Briggs
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Amend
Infringement Contention
Exhibit 6 to the Briggs
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Amend
Infringement Contention
Exhibit 7 to the Briggs

Result

Reason/Explanation

UNSEALED

No declaration filed

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

UNSEALED

No declaration filed

UNSEALED

No declaration filed

11

22
23
24
25
26

See Civ. L.R. 79-5(d)(1)(A) (“Reference to a stipulation or protective order that allows a party to
designate certain documents as confidential is not sufficient to establish that a document, or
portions thereof, are sealable.”).
12

Civ. L.R. 79-5(b). In part, Civ. L.R. 79-5(d) requires the submitting party to attach a “proposed
order that is narrowly tailored to seal only the sealable material” which “lists in table format each
document or portion thereof that is sought to be sealed,” Civ. L.R. 79-5(d)(1)(b), and an
“unreadacted version of the document” that indicates “by highlighting or other clear method, the
portions of the document that have been omitted from the redacted version.”
Civ. L.R. 79-5(d)(1)(d).
13

27
28

Civ. L.R. 79-5(e)(1). The Civil Local Rules have recently been amended shortening the time
available to the designating party to file a supporting declaration from seven days to four days. As
this rule change was only recently implemented the court applies the prior form of Civ. L.R. 79-5
for the purposes of this order.
3
Case No.: 5:12-cv-0630-LHK-PSG
ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL

1
2

476

3
4
5

476

6
7

476

8
9

United States District Court
For the Northern District of California

10

498
498

11
12

498

13
14
15

498

16
17

516

18
19
20

516

21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

516

Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Amend
Infringement Contention
Exhibit 8 to the Briggs
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Amend
Infringement Contention
Exhibit 9 to the Briggs
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Amend
Infringement Contention
Exhibit 10 to the Briggs
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Amend
Infringement Contention
Samsung's Motion to
Compel Complete
Production of Source Code
Thakur Declaration ISO
Samsung's Motion to
Compel Complete
Production of Source Code
Exhibit 19 to Thakur
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Compel
Complete Production of
Source Code
Exhibit 26 to Thakur
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Compel
Complete Production of
Source Code
Apple’s Opposition to
Samsung’s Motion for
Leave to Amend and
Supplement Its
Infringement
Contentions
Exhibit 1 to the Selwyn
Declaration ISO
Apple’s Opposition to
Samsung’s Motion for
Leave to Amend and
Supplement Its
Infringement
Contentions
Exhibit 2 to the Selwyn
Declaration ISO
Apple’s Opposition to
Samsung’s Motion for
Leave to Amend and
Supplement Its
Infringement
Contentions

UNSEALED

No declaration filed

UNSEALED

No declaration filed

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED as amended by Docket
No. 515

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information
Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

SEALED as amended by Docket
No. 515

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED as amended by Docket
No. 515

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

UNSEALED

No declaration filed

4
Case No.: 5:12-cv-0630-LHK-PSG
ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL

1

516

2
3
4
5

516

6
7
8
9

516

United States District Court
For the Northern District of California

10
11
12
13

516

14
15
16
17

516

18
19
20
21

516

22
23
24
25
26
27
28

516

Exhibit 3 to the Selwyn
Declaration ISO
Apple’s Opposition to
Samsung’s Motion for
Leave to Amend and
Supplement Its
Infringement
Contentions
Exhibit 4 to the Selwyn
Declaration ISO
Apple’s Opposition to
Samsung’s Motion for
Leave to Amend and
Supplement Its
Infringement
Contentions
Exhibit 5 to the Selwyn
Declaration ISO
Apple’s Opposition to
Samsung’s Motion for
Leave to Amend and
Supplement Its
Infringement
Contentions
Exhibit 6 to the Selwyn
Declaration ISO
Apple’s Opposition to
Samsung’s Motion for
Leave to Amend and
Supplement Its
Infringement
Contentions
Exhibit 9 to the Selwyn
Declaration ISO
Apple’s Opposition to
Samsung’s Motion for
Leave to Amend and
Supplement Its
Infringement
Contentions
Exhibit 10 to the Selwyn
Declaration ISO
Apple’s Opposition to
Samsung’s Motion for
Leave to Amend and
Supplement Its
Infringement
Contentions
Exhibit 11 to the Selwyn
Declaration ISO
Apple’s Opposition to
Samsung’s Motion for
Leave to Amend and
Supplement Its
Infringement

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

5
Case No.: 5:12-cv-0630-LHK-PSG
ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL

1

526

2
3
4

528

5
6

528

7
8
9

528

United States District Court
For the Northern District of California

10
11

528

12
13
14

528

15
16

528

17
18
19

531

20
21

531

22
23
24

533

25
26
27
28

533

Contentions
Exhibit 1 to the Declaration
of Joshua Furman ISO
Apple’s Motion for Leave
to Amend
and Supplement Its
Infringement Contentions
Samsung's Reply in
Support of Motion to
Amend Infringement
Contentions
Exhibit 4 to the Briggs
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Reply in Support of
Motion to Amend
Infringement Contentions
Exhibit 5 to the Briggs
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Reply in Support of
Motion to Amend
Infringement Contentions
Exhibit 6 to the Briggs
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Reply in Support of
Motion to Amend
Infringement Contentions
Exhibit 7 to the Briggs
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Reply in Support of
Motion to Amend
Infringement Contentions
Exhibit 8 to the Briggs
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Reply in Support of
Motion to Amend
Infringement Contentions
Apple’s Opposition to
Samsung’s Motion to
Compel Documents from
Related Litigations
Exhibit 19 to the Kolovos
Declaration ISO Apple’s
Opposition to Samsung’s
Motion to Compel
Documents from
Related Litigations
Arrouye Declaration ISO
Apple’s Opposition to
Samsung’s Motion to
Compel Documents from
Related Litigations
Chu Declaration ISO
Apple’s Opposition to
Samsung’s Motion to
Compel Documents from

UNSEALED

Not narrowly tailored
to confidential
business information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED as amended in Docket
No. 542

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

UNSEALED

No declaration filed

SEALED as amended in Docket
No. 542

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

UNSEALED

Declaration
submitted indicating
no redaction
necessary
Declaration
submitted indicating
no redaction
necessary

UNSEALED

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

6
Case No.: 5:12-cv-0630-LHK-PSG
ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL

1

533

2
3
4

533

5
6

533

7
8
9

533

United States District Court
For the Northern District of California

10
11

533

12
13
14

540

15
16

540

17
18

540

19
20
21

540

22
23

540

24
25
26
27
28

540

Related Litigations
Krugler Declaration ISO
Apple’s Opposition to
Samsung’s Motion to
Compel Documents from
Related Litigations
Lew Declaration ISO
Apple’s Opposition to
Samsung’s Motion to
Compel Documents from
Related Litigations
Manickam Declaration ISO
Apple’s Opposition to
Samsung’s Motion to
Compel Documents from
Related Litigations
McFarlane Declaration ISO
Apple’s Opposition to
Samsung’s Motion to
Compel Documents from
Related Litigations
Shenoy Declaration ISO
Apple’s Opposition to
Samsung’s Motion to
Compel Documents from
Related Litigations
Samsung’s Motion For
Leave to Amend Its
Invalidity Contentions
Exhibit 3 to Thakur
Declaration ISO
Samsung’s Motion For
Leave to Amend Its
Invalidity Contentions
Exhibit 10 to Thakur
Declaration ISO
Samsung’s Motion For
Leave to Amend Its
Invalidity Contentions
Exhibit 17 to Thakur
Declaration ISO
Samsung’s Motion For
Leave to Amend Its
Invalidity Contentions
Exhibit 18 to Thakur
Declaration ISO
Samsung’s Motion For
Leave to Amend Its
Invalidity Contentions
Exhibit 19 to Thakur
Declaration ISO
Samsung’s Motion For
Leave to Amend Its
Invalidity Contentions

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

UNSEALED

Declaration
submitted indicating
no redaction
necessary
Declaration
submitted indicating
no redaction
necessary

UNSEALED

UNSEALED

Declaration
submitted indicating
no redaction
necessary

UNSEALED

Not narrowly tailored
to confidential
business information

UNSEALED

Not narrowly tailored
to confidential
business information

UNSEALED

Declaration
submitted indicating
no redaction
necessary

7
Case No.: 5:12-cv-0630-LHK-PSG
ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL

1

540

2
3

540

4
5
6

541

7
8

541

9

United States District Court
For the Northern District of California

10
11

541

12
13
14

541

15
16
17

541

18
19
20

541

21
22
23

541

24
25
26
27
28

541

Exhibit 20 to Thakur
Declaration ISO
Samsung’s Motion For
Leave to Amend Its
Invalidity Contentions
Exhibit 22 to Thakur
Declaration ISO
Samsung’s Motion For
Leave to Amend Its
Invalidity Contentions
Samsung’s Motion To
Preclude Apple
From Asserting Untimely
Dates Of Conception
Exhibit C to Thakur
Declaration ISO
Samsung’s Motion To
Preclude Apple From
Asserting Untimely Dates
Of Conception
Exhibit D to Thakur
Declaration ISO
Samsung’s Motion To
Preclude Apple From
Asserting Untimely Dates
Of Conception
Exhibit E to Thakur
Declaration ISO
Samsung’s Motion To
Preclude Apple From
Asserting Untimely Dates
Of Conception
Exhibit F to Thakur
Declaration ISO
Samsung’s Motion To
Preclude Apple From
Asserting Untimely Dates
Of Conception
Exhibit G to Thakur
Declaration ISO
Samsung’s Motion To
Preclude Apple From
Asserting Untimely Dates
Of Conception
Exhibit H to Thakur
Declaration ISO
Samsung’s Motion To
Preclude Apple From
Asserting Untimely Dates
Of Conception
Exhibit I to Thakur
Declaration ISO
Samsung’s Motion To
Preclude Apple From
Asserting Untimely Dates

SEALED as amended by Docket
No. 657

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED as amended by Docket
No. 657

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

UNSEALED

No declaration filed

UNSEALED

No declaration filed

UNSEALED

No declaration filed

UNSEALED

No declaration filed

UNSEALED

No declaration filed

UNSEALED

No declaration filed

UNSEALED

No declaration filed

UNSEALED

No declaration filed

8
Case No.: 5:12-cv-0630-LHK-PSG
ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL

1

541

2
3
4

541

5
6
7

561

8
9

United States District Court
For the Northern District of California

10

563

11
12

563

13
14
15

563

16
17
18

563

19
20
21

563

22
23
24

577

25
26
27
28

577

Of Conception
Exhibit J to Thakur
Declaration ISO
Samsung’s Motion To
Preclude Apple From
Asserting Untimely Dates
Of Conception
Exhibit K to Thakur
Declaration ISO
Samsung’s Motion To
Preclude Apple From
Asserting Untimely Dates
Of Conception
Exhibit A to the
Declaration of Amar
Thakur ISO Samsung’s
Reply On Its MTC
Documents From Related
Litigations
Samsung’s Reply ISO
Motion to Compel
Complete Production of
Source Code
Thakur Declaration ISO
Samsung’s Reply ISO
Motion to Compel
Complete Production of
Source Code
Exhibit 3 to Thakur
Declaration ISO
Samsung’s Reply ISO
Motion to Compel
Complete Production of
Source Code
Exhibit 4 to Thakur
Declaration ISO
Samsung’s Reply ISO
Motion to Compel
Complete Production of
Source Code
Exhibit 10 to Thakur
Declaration ISO
Samsung’s Reply ISO
Motion to Compel
Complete Production of
Source Code
Samsung’s Supplemental
Brief ISO Samsung's
Motion to Amend
Invalidity Contentions
Briggs Declaration ISO
Samsung’s Supplemental
Brief ISO Samsung's
Motion to Amend
Invalidity Contentions

UNSEALED

No declaration filed

UNSEALED

No declaration filed

SEALED as amended by Docket
No. 586

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED as amended by Docket
No. 587-1

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED as amended by Docket
No. 587-2

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED as amended by Docket
No. 587-3

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

UNSEALED except last 3 pages, Public information
which remain SEALED

SEALED as amended by Docket
No. 587-4

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

UNSEALED

Declaration
submitted indicating
no redaction
necessary
Declaration
submitted indicating
no redaction
necessary

UNSEALED

9
Case No.: 5:12-cv-0630-LHK-PSG
ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL

1

577

2
3
4

577

5
6
7

577

8
9

United States District Court
For the Northern District of California

10

577

11
12
13

582

14
15

592

16
17
18

592

19
20
21

592

22
23
24

593

25
26
27
28

613

Exhibit 1 to Briggs
Declaration ISO
Samsung’s Supplemental
Brief ISO Samsung's
Motion to Amend
Invalidity Contentions
Exhibit 2 to Briggs
Declaration ISO
Samsung’s Supplemental
Brief ISO Samsung's
Motion to Amend
Invalidity Contentions
Exhibit 3 to Briggs
Declaration ISO
Samsung’s Supplemental
Brief ISO Samsung's
Motion to Amend
Invalidity Contentions
Exhibit 4 to Briggs
Declaration ISO
Samsung’s Supplemental
Brief ISO Samsung's
Motion to Amend
Invalidity Contentions
Apple's Opposition to
Samsung's Motion for
Leave to File Supplemental
Briefing
Exhibit 2 to Supplemental
Furman Declaration ISO
Samsung's Motion for
Leave to Amend and
Supplement Its
Infringement Contentions
Exhibit 3 to Supplemental
Furman Declaration ISO
Samsung's Motion for
Leave to Amend and
Supplement Its
Infringement Contentions
Exhibit 4 to Supplemental
Furman Declaration ISO
Samsung's Motion for
Leave to Amend and
Supplement Its
Infringement Contentions
Exhibits B and L to the
Declaration of Brian
Buroker ISO Apple's
Opposition to Samsung's
Motion to Preclude Apple
From Asserting Untimely
Dates of Conception
Samsung's Reply in
Support of its Motion for

UNSEALED

Defended solely on
attorney-client
privilege grounds;
privilege waived by
production

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

UNSEALED

Defended solely on
attorney-client
privilege grounds;
privilege waived by
production

UNSEALED

Defended solely on
attorney-client
privilege grounds;
privilege waived by
production

UNSEALED

Declaration
submitted indicating
no redaction
necessary
Not narrowly tailored
to confidential
business information

UNSEALED

UNSEALED

Not narrowly tailored
to confidential
business information

UNSEALED

Not moved under seal

UNSEALED

Declaration
submitted indicating
no redaction
necessary

UNSEALED

No declaration filed

10
Case No.: 5:12-cv-0630-LHK-PSG
ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL

1
2

632

3

Leave to Amend Invalidity
Contentions
Samsung’s Motion to
Compel Production of
Documents and Response
to Interrogatory No 32

4
5
6

632

7
8
9

632

United States District Court
For the Northern District of California

10
11

632

12
13
14

632

15
16

Exhibit 4 to Samsung’s
Motion to Compel
Production of Documents
and Response to
Interrogatory No 32
Exhibit 12 to Samsung’s
Motion to Compel
Production of Documents
and Response to
Interrogatory No 32
Exhibit 25 to Samsung’s
Motion to Compel
Production of Documents
and Response to
Interrogatory No 32
Exhibit 26 to Samsung’s
Motion to Compel
Production of Documents
and Response to
Interrogatory No 32

17

SEALED
12:1-13: 1
13:7
14:6-7
14:17-20

UNSEALED
6:1-25
13:5-6
13:8-9
14: 2-6
14:7-8
14: 14-17
14:20-25
15:1-25
SEALED as amended by Docket
No. 655-2

Sealed portions
reflect narrow
tailoring to protect
confidential business
information.
Unsealed portions do
not.

SEALED as amended by Docket
No. 655-3

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED
13: 5-8
20:19-21:8
21:25-22:1
22:22
32:6-7
33: 3-4

18
19
20
21

632

22
23

632

24
25
26
27
28

632

Exhibit 31 to Samsung’s
Motion to Compel
Production of Documents
and Response to
Interrogatory No 32
Exhibit 32 to Samsung’s
Motion to Compel
Production of Documents
and Response to
Interrogatory No 32
Exhibit 33 to Samsung’s
Motion to Compel
Production of Documents
and Response to
Interrogatory No 32

SEALED

Sealed portions
reflect narrow
tailoring to protect
confidential business
information.
Unsealed portions do
not.
Page numbers varied
between versions.
For purposes of this
order, pg. 12
correlates to pg. 67 of
deposition testimony.
Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

11
Case No.: 5:12-cv-0630-LHK-PSG
ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL

UNSEALED
12:1-25
13:1-4, 9-25
14:1-20:8
20: 9-12
21: 10-24
22: 2-21
22:23-31:25
32: 1-12
33: 6-25
34: 1-25

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

1

632

Exhibit 34 to Samsung’s
Motion to Compel
Production of Documents
and Response to
Interrogatory No 32

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

632

Exhibit 35 to Samsung’s
Motion to Compel
Production of Documents
and Response to
Interrogatory No 32
Exhibit 36 to Samsung’s
Motion to Compel
Production of Documents
and Response to
Interrogatory No 32
CORRECTED Exhibit A
to Stipulation re Samsungs
Proposed Invalidity
Contentions
Exhibit 2 to Michael
Valek’s Declaration ISO
Apple Inc.'s Opposition to
Google Inc.'s Motion to
Quash Apple's Subpoenas
for the Production of
Documents and Testimony
Exhibit 13 to Shannon
Mader’s Declaration ISO
Apple Inc.'s Opposition to
Google Inc.'s Motion to
Quash Apple's Subpoenas
for the Production of
Documents and Testimony

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

UNSEALED except pg. 12
(deposition transcript pg. 111),
which shall remain SEALED

Public information

UNSEALED

No declaration filed

UNSEALED

Public information

SEALED as follows: 10:2, 10:
21, 11: 1, 12: 4, 12: 25-27.
Remainder UNSEALED

Sealed portions
reflect narrow
tailoring to protect
confidential business
information.
Unsealed portions do
not.

Samsung's Motion to
Compel Production of
Financial Documents and
to Enforce the April 12,
2013 Order
Thakur Declaration ISO
Samsung's Motion to
Compel Production of
Financial Documents and
to Enforce the April 12,
2013 Order
Exhibit 5 to Thakur
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Compel
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
Exhibit 6 to Thakur
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Compel

UNSEALED

Public information

UNSEALED

Public information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

2
3
4
5
6

632

7
8
9

649

United States District Court
For the Northern District of California

10
11

656

12
13
14

656

15
16
17
18

669

19
20
21

669

22
23
24

669

25
26
27
28

669

12
Case No.: 5:12-cv-0630-LHK-PSG
ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL

1
2

669

3
4
5

669

6
7
8

669

9

United States District Court
For the Northern District of California

10
11

669

12
13
14

669

15
16
17

669

18
19
20

669

21
22
23

669

24
25
26
27
28

669

Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
Exhibit 7 to Thakur
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Compel
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
Exhibit 8 to Thakur
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Compel
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
Exhibit 9 to Thakur
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Compel
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
Exhibit 10 to Thakur
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Compel
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
Exhibit 11 to Thakur
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Compel
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
Exhibit 12 to Thakur
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Compel
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
Exhibit 13 to Thakur
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Compel
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
Exhibit 14 to Thakur
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Compel
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
Exhibit 15 to Thakur
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Compel
Production of Financial

UNSEALED

Not marked
confidential, and
public information

UNSEALED

Not marked
confidential, and
public information

UNSEALED

Not marked
confidential, and
public information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

13
Case No.: 5:12-cv-0630-LHK-PSG
ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL

1
2

669

3
4
5

669

6
7
8

669

9

United States District Court
For the Northern District of California

10
11

669

12
13
14

669

15
16
17

669

18
19
20

669

21
22
23

669

24
25
26
27
28

669

Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
Exhibit 16 to Thakur
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Compel
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
Exhibit 17 to Thakur
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Compel
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
Exhibit 18 to Thakur
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Compel
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
Exhibit 19 to Thakur
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Compel
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
Exhibit 20 to Thakur
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Compel
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
Exhibit 21 to Thakur
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Compel
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
Exhibit 22 to Thakur
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Compel
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
Exhibit 23 to Thakur
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Compel
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
Exhibit 24 to Thakur
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Compel
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

14
Case No.: 5:12-cv-0630-LHK-PSG
ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL

1

669

2
3
4

676

5
6

the April 12, 2013 Order
Exhibit 25 to Thakur
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Motion to Compel
Production of Financial
Documents and to Enforce
the April 12, 2013 Order
Apple's Opposition to
Samsung's Motion to
Compel Production of
Documents and Response
to Interrogatory No. 32

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

Pgs. 3, 13: SEALED
Remainder: UNSEALED

Sealed portions
reflect narrow
tailoring to protect
confidential business
information.
Unsealed portions do
not.
No declaration
submitted

7
8

676

9

United States District Court
For the Northern District of California

10
11

676

12
13
14

676

15
16
17
18
19

681
689

20
21
22

689

23
24
25
26
27
28

689

Walden Declaration ISO
Apple's Opposition to
Samsung's Motion to
Compel Production of
Documents and Response
to Interrogatory No. 32
Exhibit A to Walden
Declaration ISO Apple's
Opposition to Samsung's
Motion to Compel
Production of Documents
and Response to
Interrogatory No. 32
Exhibit B to Walden
Declaration ISO Apple's
Opposition to Samsung's
Motion to Compel
Production of Documents
and Response to
Interrogatory No. 32
Apple’s Amended
Infringement Contentions

UNSEALED

Samsung's Reply in
Support of Its Motion to
Compel Production of
Documents and Response
to Interrogatory No. 32
Drezdzon’s Declaration
ISO Samsung's Reply in
Support of Its Motion to
Compel Production of
Documents and Response
to Interrogatory No. 32
Exhibit 37 to Drezdzon’s
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Reply in Support of Its
Motion to Compel
Production of Documents
and Response to
Interrogatory No. 32

UNSEALED

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

UNSEALED

No declaration
submitted

UNSEALED

Not narrowly tailored
to confidential
business information
No declaration
submitted

UNSEALED

No declaration
submitted

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

15
Case No.: 5:12-cv-0630-LHK-PSG
ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL

1

689

2
3
4

689

5
6
7
8

689

9

United States District Court
For the Northern District of California

10
11

711

12
13
14

721

15
16

738

17
18

742

19
20
21

743

Exhibit 38 to Drezdzon’s
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Reply in Support of Its
Motion to Compel
Production of Documents
and Response to
Interrogatory No. 32
Exhibit 39 to Drezdzon’s
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Reply in Support of Its
Motion to Compel
Production of Documents
and Response to
Interrogatory No. 32
Exhibit 40 to Drezdzon’s
Declaration ISO Samsung's
Reply in Support of Its
Motion to Compel
Production of Documents
and Response to
Interrogatory No. 32
Apple's Opposition to
Samsung's Motion to
Compel Production of
Financial Documents and
to Enforce the April 12,
2013 Order
Samsung's Reply In
Support of Motion to
Compel Financial
Documents and Exhibits
Apple’s Notice of Joinder
in Nokia’s Motion for a
Protective Order
Stipulation With Proposed
Order Re Motion For
Protective Order By Nokia
Corporation
Samsung’s Opposition to
Apple’s Notice of Joinder
in Nokia’s Motion for a
Protective Order

SEALED as amended by Docket
No. 702

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED as amended by Docket
No. 702

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

SEALED

Narrowly tailored to
confidential business
information

UNSEALED

Public information

UNSEALED

Public information

UNSEALED

Public information

UNSEALED

Public information

UNSEALED

Public information

22
23

IT IS SO ORDERED.

24

Dated: March 7, 2014

25

_________________________________

26

PAUL S. GREWAL
United States Magistrate Judge

27
28

16
Case No.: 5:12-cv-0630-LHK-PSG
ORDER RE: MOTIONS TO SEAL