Shirazi v. Oweis et al

Filing 84

INTERIM ORDER re 79 August 29, 2022 Discovery Dispute. Plaintiff's further submissions due by 9/28/2022. Signed by Magistrate Judge Virginia K. DeMarchi on 9/15/2022. (vkdlc2, COURT STAFF) (Filed on 9/15/2022)

Case 5:21-cv-00136-EJD Document 84 Filed 09/15/22 Page 1 of 2

1
2
3
4

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

5

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

6

SAN JOSE DIVISION

7
8

SABRINA BELLE SHIRAZI,
Plaintiff,

9
10

United States District Court
Northern District of California

11
12

Case No. 21-cv-00136-EJD (VKD)
INTERIM ORDER RE AUGUST 29,
2022 DISCOVERY DISPUTE

v.
NADER OWEIS, et al.,

Re: Dkt. No. 79

Defendants.

13
14

The parties ask the Court to resolve a dispute regarding whether defendants’ counsel may

15

inquire in deposition about what was discussed during a 2-hour meeting plaintiff’s counsel held

16

with multiple clients, all of whom are non-party fact witnesses in this case. Dkt. No. 79.

17

Plaintiff’s counsel contends that all communications during the meeting are privileged.

18

Defendants question whether the non-party fact witnesses are “joint clients” of plaintiff’s counsel

19

and contend that an insufficient showing has been made that they are. Defendants argue that, as to

20

each client, the presence in the meeting of people outside that client’s attorney-client relationship

21

with plaintiff’s counsel negates any assertion of privilege as to each such client.

22

The Court does not have sufficient information to resolve this dispute. This may be due, at

23

least in part, to the fact that the Court requires parties to comply with an expedited discovery

24

dispute resolution procedure that prohibits formal motion practice and limits the submission of

25

evidentiary or other material. See https://cand.uscourts.gov/vkd-standing-order-for-civil-cases-

26

april-2022/. For this reason, the Court will permit plaintiff’s counsel and/or her clients Dr.

27
28

United States District Court
Northern District of California

Case 5:21-cv-00136-EJD Document 84 Filed 09/15/22 Page 2 of 2

1

Medina, Ms. Baker, and Ms. Nisi to submit to the Court, for in camera review if appropriate,1

2

declarations or other evidence showing, at a minimum: (1) the purpose for which plaintiff’s

3

counsel represents each client, (2) the date on which each representation began, (3) identification

4

of the people present during the meeting and their role (e.g., attorney, paralegal, client, non-client),

5

(4) a description of the allegedly privileged communications that occurred during the meeting in

6

question, including with whom the communications occurred, (5) the basis, if any, of each client’s

7

expectation that the communications during the meeting would be confidential, and (6) as to each

8

client, whether it was necessary for others (i.e., other clients or non-clients) to be present during

9

the meeting to facilitate the rendering or obtaining of legal advice. See Sky Valley Ltd.

10

Partnership v. ATX Sky Valley, Ltd., 150 F.R.D. 648, 652-53 (N.D. Cal. 1993) (identifying 10

11

non-exclusive factors bearing on the question of whether two or more people may be deemed

12

“joint clients”); see also In re Teleglobe Commc'ns Corp., 493 F.3d 345, 362-66 (3d Cir. 2007), as

13

amended (Oct. 12, 2007) (distinguishing between “joint client privilege” and “common interest

14

privilege”).
The further submissions are due by September 28, 2022. After receiving the further

15
16

submissions, the Court may conduct an evidentiary hearing, in camera if necessary.
IT IS SO ORDERED.

17
18

Dated: September 15, 2022

19
20
VIRGINIA K. DEMARCHI
United States Magistrate Judge

21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

1

Declarations and other evidence that require in camera review to avoid disclosure of potentially
privileged information to defendants or the public maybe provide to the Court by emailing Judge
DeMarchi’s courtroom deputy, Adriana Kratzmann, at [e-mail], or by
delivering the materials to the Clerk’s office in the form of paper or on electronic media (e.g., disk
or thumb drive).
2