In re National Security Agency Telecommunications Records Litigation

Filing 746

Memorandum in Opposition re 738 MOTION for Attorney Fees Defendants' Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion for Attorney's Fees (Al-Haramain v Obama) (09-cv-109-VRW) filed byUnited States. (Attachments: # 1 Appendix, # 2 Appendix, # 3 Appendix, # 4 Appendix, # 5 Appendix, # 6 Appendix, # 7 Appendix)(Coppolino, Anthony) (Filed on 8/5/2010)

Download PDF
In re National Security Agency Telecommunications Records Litigation Doc. 746 Att. 5 Defendants' Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion for Attorney Fees Al-Haramain Islamic Found. Oregon et al. v. Obama et al. (07-cv-109-VRW) (3:06-md-1791-VRW) Appendix 5 DUPLICATIVE HOURS BY ATTORNEY Dockets.Justia.com Appendix 5 - Duplicative Hours by Counsel The following spreadsheet lists the counsel who worked on an identified project in the case (e.g., complaint, motion) and sets forth a calculation of the combined hours that all counsel worked on the project. This combined duplicative number of hours is then reduced by 25%. Estimates of time devoted to a particular project were made by taking the number of hours in a block entry that identifies the subject area of the project (e.g., complaint) and dividing by the number of subject areas identified in block. More than one discrete activity that relates to work on the same project is treated as one subject area (e.g., research, writing, analysis, review of defendants' motion, and prepare opposition to motion, is treated as one subject area for purposes of this calculation). These estimates for duplicative hours attempt to account for separate reductions made for consultations with co-counsel in Appendix 4 by treating consultations as a separate activity added to the divisor (thus reducing the amount of time attributed to the particular project). For example, an entry indicating that counsel researched and drafted a work product (e.g., complaint) and consulted with co-counsel, for a total of 18 hours, is treated as 9 hours for work on the complaint. Note: Page references in the chart are to the page numbers indicated in the ECF generated header at the top of the declaration cited. Al- Haramain Islamic Foundation v. Obama Duplicative Hours NO. OF SUBJECT AREAS 2 2 2 2 1 TASK: Complaint TIMEKEEPER: Albies Eisenberg Goldberg Hassan Nelson DATES: 2/5/06 - 2/27/06 2/27/2006 12/16/05-2/28/06 2/19/06-2/28/06 12/16/05-2/28/06 HOURS IN BLOCK 18.3 1 12.2 10.6 96 HOURS: (Total Hours Claimed / No. of Subjects ) 9.1 0.5 6.1 5.3 96 DECL. CITATION: Albies Decl. 3:10-11 Eisenberg Decl. 5:14-15 Goldberg Decl. 5:2 Hassan Decl. 3:26-27 Nelson Decl. 7:4-10 TOTAL: 117 Recusal Judge Eisenberg Goldberg Nelson 3/2/06-3/7/06 2/28/06-12/20/06 3/1/06-12/20/06 2 2 5 1.7 3.4 65.6 0.85 1.7 13.12 Eisenberg Decl.5:16-17 Goldberg Decl. 5:5-6 Nelson Decl. 7:13-19 TOTAL: 1 15.67 Al- Haramain Islamic Foundation v. Obama Duplicative Hours NO. OF SUBJECT AREAS HOURS: (Total Hours Claimed / No. of Subjects ) TASK: TIMEKEEPER: DATES: HOURS IN BLOCK DECL. CITATION: Preparation of Discovery; Motion to Compel Albies Albies Eisenberg Eisenberg Goldberg Goldberg Goldberg Goldberg Hassan Hassan Jaskol Nelson 3/2/06-4/17/06 5/16/06-8/29/06 3/18/06-4/14/06 5/3/06-5/21/06 3/17/06-5/25/06 7/2/06-9/22/06 7/1/06-8/29/06 3/14/07-3/27/07 3/17/06-5/25/06 5/26/06-6/28/06 5/17/06-9/14/06 3/1/06-12/20/06 5 4 5 2 2 1 3 5 8 2 4 5 2 54.8 52.5 26.5 7.2 11 18 23 17 21.5 5.4 7.3 65.6 10.96 13.13 5.3 3.6 5.5 18 7.6 3.4 2.7 2.7 1.8 13.12 Albies Decl. 3:13-15 Albies Decl. 3:22-24 Eisenberg Decl. 5:20-22 Eisenberg Decl. 5:27-28 Goldberg Decl. 5:21-22 Goldberg Decl. 6:7-8 Goldberg Decl.6:9-13 Goldberg Decl. 6:24-28 Hassan Decl. 4:1-4 Hassan Decl. 4:26-27 Jaskol Decl. 5:1-3 Nelson Decl. 7:13-19 Al- Haramain Islamic Foundation v. Obama Duplicative Hours NO. OF SUBJECT AREAS 5 13 TASK: TIMEKEEPER: Nelson Nelson DATES: 3/25/06-5/1/06 5/6/06-9/22/06 HOURS IN BLOCK 112.1 214.5 HOURS: (Total Hours Claimed / No. of Subjects ) 22.42 16.9 DECL. CITATION: Nelson Decl. 8:1-2 Nelcon Decl. 8:3-15 TOTAL: Opposition to Ex Parte Filing by USG 127.13 Albies Albies Eisenberg Eisenberg Goldberg Goldberg Goldberg Hassan Hassan 4/18/06 - 4/23/06 5/16/06-8/29/06 4/18/06-5/22/06 5/25/06-5/26/06 3/17/06-5/25/06 3/17/06-5/25/06 3/17/06-5/25/06 3/17/06-5/25/06 3/17/06-5/25/06 3 1 2 2 5 2 4 8 4 3 33.5 1 70 1.5 10.9 15.5 34 21.5 46.1 11.2 1 35 0.75 2.18 7.75 8.5 2.7 11.5 Albies Decl. 3:16-18 Albies Decl.3:25-26 Eisenberg Decl.5:23-24 Eisenberg Decl. 6:1-2 Goldberg Decl.5:15-18 Goldberg Decl. 5:10-14 Goldberg Decl. 5:7-9 Hassan Decl. 4:1-4 Hassan Decl. 4:7-13 Al- Haramain Islamic Foundation v. Obama Duplicative Hours NO. OF SUBJECT AREAS 1 5 TASK: TIMEKEEPER: Jaskol Nelson DATES: 4/19/06-5/25/06 3/25/06-5/1/06 HOURS IN BLOCK 21.5 112.1 HOURS: (Total Hours Claimed / No. of Subjects ) 21.5 22.42 DECL. CITATION: Jaskol Decl. 4:25-28 Nelson Decl. 8:1-2 TOTAL: 124.5 Plaintiffs Access to Sealed Documents Albies Albies Eisenberg Goldberg Goldberg Hassan Jaskol 3/2/06-4/17/06 3/2/06-4/17/06 5/28/06-6/16/06 3/17/06-5/25/06 5/28/06-6/7/06 5/28/06-6/7/06 3/17/06-6/19/06 5 4 2 4 2 2 3 54.8 52.5 55.7 34 18 7.1 32.9 10.96 13.13 27.85 8.5 9 3.5 10.9 Albies Decl. 3:13-15 Albies Decl. 3:22-24 Eisenberg Decl. 6:3-5 Goldberg Decl. 5:7-9 Goldberg Decl. 5:23-26 Hassan Decl. 4:14-16 Jaskol Decl. 4:22-24 4 Al- Haramain Islamic Foundation v. Obama Duplicative Hours NO. OF SUBJECT AREAS 5 TASK: TIMEKEEPER: Nelson DATES: 3/1/06-12/20/06 HOURS IN BLOCK 65.6 HOURS: (Total Hours Claimed / No. of Subjects ) 13.12 DECL. CITATION: Nelson Decl. 7:13-19 TOTAL: 96.96 Oregonian Motion to Unseal Albies Goldberg Goldberg Hassan Nelson Nelson 4/18/06-4/23/06 3/17/06-5/25/06 3/17/06-5/25/06 3/17/06-5/25/06 3/1/06-12/20/06 5/6/06-9/22/06 3 2 5 4 5 13 33.5 15.5 10.9 46.1 65.6 214.5 11.2 7.75 2.18 11.5 13.12 16.9 Albies Decl. 3:16-18 Goldberg Decl. 5:10-14 Goldberg Decl.5:15-18 Hassan Decl. 4:7-13 Nelson Decl. 7:13-19 Nelson Decl. 8:3-15 TOTAL: 62.65 5 Al- Haramain Islamic Foundation v. Obama Duplicative Hours NO. OF SUBJECT AREAS HOURS: (Total Hours Claimed / No. of Subjects ) TASK: TIMEKEEPER: DATES: HOURS IN BLOCK DECL. CITATION: Opposition to 2006 Motion to Dismiss Albies Eisenberg Eisenberg Goldberg Hassan Jaskol 5/16/06-8/29/06 6/12/06-7/4/06 8/17/06-8/29/06 7/1/06-8/29/06 7/1/06-8/29/06 6/6/09-9/7/06 4 2 1 3 4 3 52.5 66.5 41.6 23 21 26.3 13.13 33.25 41.6 7.6 5.25 8.76 Albies Decl. 3:22-24 Eisenberg Decl. 6:6-7 Eisenberg Decl. 6:15-16 Goldberg Decl.6:9-13 Hassan Decl. 4:22-25 Jaskol Decl. 5:10-13 Opposition to MDL Transfer TOTAL: Eisenberg Eisenberg Eisenberg Eisenberg Goldberg 6/20/06-6/27/06 9/12/06-9/25/06 10/24/06-10/26/06 11/8/06-11/9/06 6/21/06-10/28/06 2 1 1 1 2 6 45.7 20.8 10.1 5.7 22.5 109.59 22.85 20.8 10.1 5.7 11.25 Eisenberg Decl.6:8-9 Eisenberg Decl. 6:22 Eisenberg Decl. 6:25 Eisenberg Decl.7:4-5 Goldberg Decl. 6:1-3 Al- Haramain Islamic Foundation v. Obama Duplicative Hours NO. OF SUBJECT AREAS 1 4 1 13 TASK: TIMEKEEPER: Hassan Jaskol Jaskol Nelson DATES: 6/22/06-9/18/06 6/2/06-9/5/06 9/21/06-11/9/06 5/6/06-9/22/06 HOURS IN BLOCK 13.4 9.9 13.4 214.5 HOURS: (Total Hours Claimed / No. of Subjects ) 13.4 2.5 13.4 16.9 DECL. CITATION: Hassan Decl. 4:17-21 Jaskol Decl. 5:5-8 Jaskol Decl. 5:20-22 Nelson Decl. 8:3-15 TOTAL: 116.9 Preparation Plaintiffs 2006 Partial Summary Judgment Albies Eisenberg Goldberg Hancock Hassan 10/23/2006-11/1/06 8/30/06-10/31/06 10/23/06-11/1/06 11/1/06-11/27/06 9/7/06-11/1/06 2 2 2 5 5 7 30.5 71.2 22 5.7 18.6 15.25 35.6 11 1.14 3.72 Albies Decl.4:6-8 Eisenberg Decl. 6:20-21 Goldberg Decl. 6:14-19 Hancock Decl. 4:6-7 Hassan Decl. 5:1-6 Al- Haramain Islamic Foundation v. Obama Duplicative Hours NO. OF SUBJECT AREAS 2 TASK: TIMEKEEPER: Jaskol DATES: 10/23/06-10/27/06 HOURS IN BLOCK 5.6 HOURS: (Total Hours Claimed / No. of Subjects ) 2.8 DECL. CITATION: Jaskol Decl. 5:23-25 TOTAL: 69.51 Opposition to Petition for Interlocutory Review & Stay Pending Appeal Albies Albies Eisenberg Eisenberg Eisenberg Eisenberg Eisenberg Goldberg Hancock Hassan 8/18/06-9/25/06 9/25/06-10/24/06 8/10/06-8/15/06 9/20/06-11/1/06 2/1/07-2/19/07 3/26/07-3/28/07 4/5/07-4/6/07 3/14/07-3/27/07 2/05/07-2/20/07 9/7/06-11/17/06 2 2 2 2 3 1 1 5 2 2 8 5.6 27.9 5 44.3 21.3 23 1 17 4.5 12.7 2.8 13.95 2.5 22.15 7.1 23 5.2 3.4 2.25 6.35 Albies Decl.4:1-3 Albies Decl.4:4-5 Eisenberg Decl. 6:12-14 Eisenberg Decl. 6:23-24 Eisenberg Decl. 7:26-27 Eisenberg Decl. 8:6-7 Eisenberg Decl. 8:8-9 Goldberg Decl. 6:24-28 Hancock Decl. 4:10-11 Hassan Decl. 5:7-9 Al- Haramain Islamic Foundation v. Obama Duplicative Hours NO. OF SUBJECT AREAS 8 2 2 1 13 TASK: TIMEKEEPER: Hassan Hassan Jaskol Jaskol Nelson DATES: 11/17/06-3/22/07 3/24/07-4/12/07 9/20/06-9/29/06 10/24/06-11/1/06 5/6/06-9/22/06 HOURS IN BLOCK 12.3 3.9 11.2 3.6 214.5 HOURS: (Total Hours Claimed / No. of Subjects ) 1.54 1.95 5.8 3.6 16.9 DECL. CITATION: Hassan Decl. 5:11-15 Hassan Decl. 5:16-19 Jaskol Decl. 5:17-19 Jaskol Decl. 5:26-27 Nelcon Decl. 8:3-15 TOTAL: Work on Merits of 2006 Appeal Albies Eisenberg Eisenberg Eisenberg Eisenberg Eisenberg Eisenberg Eisenberg 5/31/07-8/28/07 3/26/07-4/26/07 4/17/07-4/20/07 4/27/07-7/5/07 6/15/07-6/26/07 7/2/07-8/16/07 7/21/07-7/25/07 8/4/07-8/6/07 2 1 2 2 1 1 1 1 9 31.5 22.7 12 177.1 9.8 121.1 7.4 6.5 118.49 15.75 22.7 6 88.5 9.8 121.1 7.4 6.5 Albies Decl.4:14-16 Eisenberg Decl. 8:4-5 Eisenberg Decl. 8:10-11 Eisenberg Decl. 8:12-13 Eisenberg Decl. 8:14-15 Eisenberg Decl. 8:16-18 Eisenberg Decl. 8:19 Eisenberg Decl. 8:20 Al- Haramain Islamic Foundation v. Obama Duplicative Hours NO. OF SUBJECT AREAS 1 1 1 2 1 1 4 1 2 1 7 6 TASK: TIMEKEEPER: Eisenberg Eisenberg Eisenberg Goldberg Hancock Hancock Hancock Hancock Hassan Jaskol Nelson Nelson DATES: 8/17/07-8/31/07 8/16/07-8/31/07 11/16/07-11/26/07 5/31/07-8/28/07 5/1/07-6/30/07 7/1/07-9/30/07 3/13/07-4/30/07 10/1/07-12/31/07 5/31/07-8/31/07 6/10/07-8/30/07 1/1/07-6/29/07 7/1/07-12/14/07 HOURS IN BLOCK 33.9 6.6 13.2 80.8 12.6 41 7.3 4.3 46.8 29 152.7 48.1 HOURS: (Total Hours Claimed / No. of Subjects ) 33.9 6.6 13.2 40.4 12.6 41 1.8 4.3 23.4 29 21.8 8 DECL. CITATION: Eisenberg Decl. 8:21-22 Eisenberg Decl. 8:23-24 Eisenberg Decl. 8:28-9:1 Goldberg Decl. 7:1-10 Hancock Decl. 4:14-16 Hancock Decl. 4:17-19 Hancock Decl. 4:12-13 Hancock Decl. 4:20-21 Hassan Decl. 5:20-28 Jaskol Decl. 6:11-16 Nelson Decl. 9:1-9 Nelson Decl. 9:10-18 TOTAL: 10 513.75 Al- Haramain Islamic Foundation v. Obama Duplicative Hours NO. OF SUBJECT AREAS HOURS: (Total Hours Claimed / No. of Subjects ) TASK: TIMEKEEPER: DATES: HOURS IN BLOCK DECL. CITATION: Plaintiffs 2007 Partial Summary Judgment Eisenberg Eisenberg Hancock 3/12/07-3/23/07 12/28/07-2/5/08 3/13/07-4/30/07 2 2 4 30.2 71.5 7.3 15.1 35.75 1.8 Eisenberg Decl.8:2-3 Eisenberg Decl. 9:4-5 Hancock Decl. 4:12-13 TOTAL: 52.65 Opposition to USG Second Motion to Dismiss Albies Eisenberg Eisenberg 3/15/08-4/23/08 2/11/08-3/31/08 4/9/08-4/14/08 2 1 1 11 12.3 87.5 19.1 6.15 87.5 19.1 Albies Decl.4:20-22 Eisenberg Decl. 9:8-9 Eisenberg Decl. 9:10-11 Al- Haramain Islamic Foundation v. Obama Duplicative Hours NO. OF SUBJECT AREAS 1 2 4 4 2 8 TASK: TIMEKEEPER: Eisenberg Goldberg Hancock Hassan Jaskol Nelson DATES: 4/15/08-4/24/08 2/7/08-4/23/08 1/1/08-5/31/08 1/30/08-7/3/08 3/16/08-7/2/08 2/3/08-7/2/08 HOURS IN BLOCK 29 83.3 14.3 15.8 19.3 11.7 HOURS: (Total Hours Claimed / No. of Subjects ) 29 41.65 3.57 3.95 9.65 1.5 DECL. CITATION: Eisenberg Decl. 9:13-14 Goldberg Decl. 7:16-22 Hancock Decl.3: 22-24 Hassan Decl. 6:4-10 Jaskol Decl. 6:19-23 Nelson Decl. 9:19-24 TOTAL: 202.07 Plaintiffs Amended Complaint Albies Eisenberg Goldberg 7/3/08-7/21/08 7/4/08-7/29/08 7/2/08-9/15/08 3 2 4 12 3.6 72.9 34.8 1.2 36.45 8.7 Albies Decl.3:23-24 Eisenberg Decl. 9:17-18 Goldberg Decl. 7:23-27 Al- Haramain Islamic Foundation v. Obama Duplicative Hours TASK: TIMEKEEPER: Hancock Hassan Hassan Jaskol Nelson Nelson Nelson DATES: 6/1/08-7/31/08 11/17/06-3/22/07 7/2/08-9/15/08 7/6/08-7/24/08 1/1/07-6/29/07 7/3/08-12/15/08 1/09-present NO. OF SUBJECT AREAS 3 8 6 2 7 3 11 HOURS IN BLOCK 27.6 12.3 12.3 11.1 152.7 22.3 113 HOURS: (Total Hours Claimed / No. of Subjects ) 9.2 1.54 2.05 5.5 21.8 7.4 10.27 DECL. CITATION: Hancock Decl. 4:25-27 Hassan Decl. 5:11-15 Hassan Decl. 6:11-15 Jaskol Decl. 6:24-26 Nelson Decl. 9:1-9 Nelson Decl. 10:3-10 Nelson Decl. 10:12-24 TOTAL: 104.11 13 Al- Haramain Islamic Foundation v. Obama Duplicative Hours NO. OF SUBJECT AREAS HOURS: (Total Hours Claimed / No. of Subjects ) TASK: TIMEKEEPER: DATES: HOURS IN BLOCK DECL. CITATION: Opposition to Third USG Motion Albies to Dismiss Eisenberg Eisenberg Goldberg Hancock Hassan Jaskol Nelson 10/7/08-12/18/08 11/16/08-12/9/08 9/30/08-10/23/08 9/24/08-12/2/08 8/1/08-12/31/08 9/4/08-12/2/08 10/3/08-1/7/09 2/3/08-7/2/08 3 3 2 3 6 4 2 8 18.1 27.1 90.6 43.7 17.6 16 8.1 11.7 6 9 45.3 14.56 2.9 4 4.05 1.5 Albies Decl. 4:25-28 Eisenberg Decl. 9:27-28 Eisenberg Decl. 9:23-24 Goldberg Decl.8:1-4 Hancock Decl. 5:1-5 Hassan Decl. 6:16-20 Jaskol Decl. 7:8-10 Nelson Decl. 9:19-24 TOTAL: 87.31 14 Al- Haramain Islamic Foundation v. Obama Duplicative Hours NO. OF SUBJECT AREAS HOURS: (Total Hours Claimed / No. of Subjects ) TASK: TIMEKEEPER: DATES: HOURS IN BLOCK DECL. CITATION: Work on Plaintiffs Albies 1806(f) Motion Eisenberg Eisenberg Goldberg Goldberg Hancock Hassan Hassan Jaskol Nelson Nelson 10/7/08-12/18/08 8/26/08-9/30/08 10/23/08-11/14/08 11/18/07-1/29/08 9/24/08-12/2/08 8/1/08-12/31/08 9/1/07-1/29/08 9/4/08-12/2/08 9/4/08-11/3/08 2/3/08-7/2/08 7/3/08-12/15/08 3 2 2 4 3 6 4 4 2 8 3 18.1 70.7 51 12.4 43.7 17.6 26.2 16 3.1 11.7 22.3 6 35.35 25.5 3.1 14.56 2.9 6.55 4 1.55 1.5 7.4 Albies Decl. 4:25-28 Eisenberg Decl. 9:21-22 Eisenberg Decl. 9:25-26 Goldberg Decl. 7:12-15 Goldberg Decl.8:1-4 Hancock Decl. 5:1-5 Hassan Decl. 6:1-3 Hassan Decl. 6:16-20 Jaskol Decl. 7:5-6 Nelson Decl. 9:19-24 Nelson Decl.10:3-10 15 Al- Haramain Islamic Foundation v. Obama Duplicative Hours NO. OF SUBJECT AREAS HOURS IN BLOCK HOURS: (Total Hours Claimed / No. of Subjects ) TASK: TIMEKEEPER: DATES: DECL. CITATION: TOTAL: 108.41 Work on USG Appeal in Jan. 2009 1292(b), Stay Pending Appeal, Ninth Circuit Work Eisenberg Eisenberg Eisenberg Eisenberg Eisenberg Goldberg Hancock Jaskol 1/17/09-2/23/09 1/26/09-2/6/09 2/12/09-2/13/09 2/23/09-2/26/09 2/27/2009 1/28/09-2/25/09 1/1/09-3/31/09 1/17/09-2/26/09 2 2 2 1 1 2 1 2 16 53.5 32.5 11.6 17.5 1 21.4 10.7 4.6 26.75 16.25 5.8 17.5 1 10.7 10.7 2.3 Eisenberg Decl. 10:7-8 Eisenberg Decl. 10:9-10 Eisenberg Decl. 10:13-15 Eisenberg Decl. 10:16-17 Eisenberg Decl. 10:18-19 Goldberg Decl. 8:12-15 Hancock Decl. 5:6-8 Jaskol Decl. 7:11-13 Al- Haramain Islamic Foundation v. Obama Duplicative Hours NO. OF SUBJECT AREAS 11 TASK: TIMEKEEPER: Nelson DATES: 1/09-present HOURS IN BLOCK 113 HOURS: (Total Hours Claimed / No. of Subjects ) 10.27 DECL. CITATION: Nelson Decl. 10:12-24 TOTAL: 101.27 Work Proposed Protective Order Eisenberg Goldberg Jaskol Jaskol Nelson 4/20/09-5/15/09 3/2/09-6/3/09 4/21/09-4/23/09 5/15/2009 1/09-present 2 4 1 1 11 29.4 32.4 3 1 113 14.7 8.1 3 1.7 10.27 Eisenberg Decl. 11:2-4 Goldberg Decl. 8:16-23 Jaskol Decl. 7:17 Jaskol Decl. 7:18-20 Nelson Decl. 10:12-24 TOTAL: 37.77 17 Al- Haramain Islamic Foundation v. Obama Duplicative Hours TASK: TIMEKEEPER: DATES: NO. OF SUBJECT AREAS HOURS IN BLOCK HOURS: (Total Hours Claimed / No. of Subjects ) DECL. CITATION: Work on Order to Show Cause re: Protective Order Albies Sanctions Eisenberg Eisenberg Goldberg Hancock Nelson 1/5/09-6/5/09 5/25/09-5/31/09 6/1/09-6/3/09 3/2/09-6/3/09 4/1/09-6/30/09 1/09-present 6 2 1 4 5 11 33.2 39.7 15.9 32.4 30.9 113 5.5 19.85 15.9 8.1 6.2 10.27 Albies Decl. 5:1-5 Eisenberg Decl. 11: 7-10 Eisenberg Decl. 11:11-12 Goldberg Decl. 8:16-23 Hancock Decl. 4:9-15 Nelson Decl. 10:12-24 TOTAL: 65.82 18 Al- Haramain Islamic Foundation v. Obama Duplicative Hours NO. OF SUBJECT AREAS HOURS: (Total Hours Claimed / No. of Subjects ) TASK: TIMEKEEPER: DATES: HOURS IN BLOCK DECL. CITATION: Work on Plaintiffs 2009 Partial Summary Judgment Motion Albies Eisenberg Eisenberg Eisenberg Eisenberg Goldberg Hancock Hassan Jaskol Nelson 6/11/09-9/23/09 6/4/09-7/9/09 7/13/09-9/9/09 7/10/09-7/12/09 9/17/09-9/23/09 6/16/09-9/23/09 7/1/09-12/31/09 5/27/09-3/30/10 5/27/09-4/13/10 1/09-present 2 2 2 1 1 3 3 2 2 11 21.5 63.9 82.2 7 23.5 35.8 6.8 10.4 14 113 10.75 31.95 41.1 7 23.5 11.9 2.26 5.2 7 10.27 Albies Decl. 4:6-10 Eisenberg Decl. 10:13-14 Eisenberg Decl. 10:16-18 Eisenberg Decl. 11:15 Eisenberg Decl. 11:25-26 Goldberg Decl. 8:25-28 Hancock Decl. 4:16-18 Hassan Decl. 6:23-27 Jaskol Decl. 7:23-25 Nelson Decl. 10:12-24 TOTAL: 19 150.93 Al- Haramain Islamic Foundation v. Obama Duplicative Hours TASK: TIMEKEEPER: DATES: NO. OF SUBJECT AREAS HOURS IN BLOCK HOURS: (Total Hours Claimed / No. of Subjects ) DECL. CITATION: SUMMARY Timekeeper: Albies Eisenberg Goldberg Hancock Hassan Jaskol Nelson TOTAL: 2006 / (25%) 141.56 / (35.4) 262.6/ (65.65) 114.61 / (28.65) 1.14 /(.28) 62.27 / (15.57) 71.06 / (17.76) 260.92 / (65.23) 914.16 / (228.54) 2007 / (25%) x 366.1 / (91.52) 43.8 / (10.95) 63.75 / (15.93) 28.43 / (7.1) 29 / (7.25) 51.6 / (12.5) 582.68 / (145.25) 2008 / (25%) 19.35 / (4.83) 341.05 / (85.26) 82.57 / (20.64) 18.57 / (4.64) 20.55 / (5.13) 20.75 / (5.16) 19.3 / (4.82) 522.14 / (130.48) 2009 / (25%) 16.25 / (4.1) 190.8 / (47.7) 38.8 / (9.7) 19.16 / (4.79) 5.2 / (1.3) 14 / (3.5) 51.35 / (12.83) 335.56 / (83.92) 2010 x x x x x x x x TOTAL 177.16 / (44.33) 1160.55 / (290.13) 279.78 / (69.94) 102.62 / (25.64) 116.45 / (29.1) 134.81 / (33.67) 383.17 / (95.38) 2354.54 / (588.19) 20 Defendants' Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion for Attorney Fees Al-Haramain Islamic Found. Oregon et al. v. Obama et al. (07-cv-109-VRW) (3:06-md-1791-VRW) HEARING ATTENDANCE

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?