Connor v. JPMorgan Chase Bank et al
Filing
113
ORDER Granting 100 Unopposed Motion for Preliminary Approval of Class Action Settlement and Certification of Settlement Class for Settlement Class Members in Group 2. Signed by Judge Gonzalo P. Curiel on 5/30/2014. (srm)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
9
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
10
11
12
PATRICIA CONNOR, Individually
and on Behalf of All Others
Similarly Situated,
Case No. 3:10-cv-1284-GPC-BGS
ORDER GRANTING UNOPPOSED
MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY
APPROVAL OF CLASS ACTION
SETTLEMENT AND
CERTIFICATION OF
SETTLEMENT CLASS FOR
SETTLEMENT CLASS MEMBERS
IN GROUP 2
13
Plaintiff,
14
15
16
17
18
v.
JPMORGAN CHASE BANK and
FEDERAL NATIONAL
MORTGAGE ASSOCIATION a/k/a
FANNIE MAE,
(ECF NO. 100)
19
20
Defendants.
21
22
23
24
25
WHEREAS, the instant putative class action (“Action”) was commenced on
June 16, 2010, (ECF No. 1);
26
WHEREAS, a putative class action in the United States District Court for the
27
Northern District of California, San Francisco/Oakland Division, entitled Bywater
28
vs. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A., case no. CV 11 2257, was voluntarily dismissed
1
10cv1284
1
in favor of the plaintiff in that action joining as a plaintiff in this Action;
2
WHEREAS, Plaintiff filed an Unopposed Motion for Settlement and
3
Approval of Class Action Settlement and Conditional Class Certification on
4
January 17, 2012, (ECF No. 50);
5
WHEREAS, pursuant to a class action settlement agreement, dated January
6
13, 2012, (“Agreement”), the Court entered an order certifying a conditional
7
Settlement Class and preliminarily approving the Agreement on March 13, 2012,
8
(“First Preliminary Approval Order”), (ECF No. 55);
9
10
WHEREAS, notice was sent to the then-identified Settlement Class Members
pursuant to the First Preliminary Approval Order;
11
WHEREAS, the final approval hearing set by the First Preliminary Approval
12
Order for August 3, 2012, was continued to allow the parties to determine whether
13
Defendants failed to identify all potential members of the Settlement Class;
14
WHEREAS, through further investigation, additional Class Members were
15
identified, as addressed in the Amendment to Settlement Agreement and Release
16
(“Amendment”), attached to the instant Motion for Preliminary Approval of
17
Amendment to Class Action Settlement (“Motion”), (ECF No. 100), and
18
collectively referred to as the “Group 2 Settlement Class Members” or “Newly
19
Identified Settlement Class Members” in the papers filed in support of the Motion;
20
21
WHEREAS, the Court’s First Preliminary Approval Order, (ECF No. 55),
remains in effect;
22
NOW, THEREFORE, based on this Court’s review of the Amendment, the
23
Motion, and all of the files, records, and proceedings herein, the Court concludes,
24
upon preliminary examination, that the Amendment appears fair, reasonable,
25
adequate, and within the range of reasonableness for preliminary settlement
26
approval, and notice should be sent to the Group 2 Settlement Class Members and a
27
final approval hearing held to confirm that the initial Settlement and Amendment
28
reflected in the Agreement (together, “Settlement”) are fair, reasonable, and
2
10cv1284
1
adequate and to determine whether the Settlement should be finally approved and
2
final judgment entered in the Action.
NOW, THEREFORE IT IS HEREBY ORDERED:
3
4
1.
Preliminary Approval of Proposed Settlement Amendment
5
The Amendment, including all corresponding documents thereto, is
6
preliminarily approved as fair, reasonable, adequate, and within the range of
7
reasonableness for preliminary approval. The Court finds that: (a) the Amendment
8
resulted from extensive arm’s length negotiations; and (b) the Amendment is
9
sufficient to warrant notice to the persons identified in the Amendment as the
10
Group 2 Settlement Class Members and a full hearing on the approval of the
11
Settlement.
12
2.
Class to Remain Certified for Settlement Purposes Only
13
The Class, as conditionally certified on March 12, 2012, pursuant to Federal
14
Rule of Civil Procedure 23(c), shall remain conditionally certified for settlement
15
purposes only. The Settlement Class shall remain defined as follows:
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
All present or former borrowers or co-borrowers as identified in
JPMCB’s records whose residential mortgage loan or home
equity line of credit is or was serviced by JPMCB or Chase
Home Finance LLC and either the borrower, co-borrower or
both, were contacted on their cellular telephone(s) by JPMCB
through the use of an automated dialer system and/or an
artificial or pre-recorded voice during the Class Period.
Subclass A of the Settlement Class consists of those persons
whose cell phones were actually called by JPMCB or Chase
Home Finance LLC during the Class Period, and are thus
entitled to a monetary payment. Excluded from the Settlement
Class are Defendants, their parent companies, affiliates or
subsidiaries, or any employees thereof, and any entities in
which any of such companies has a controlling interest, the
Judge or Magistrate Judge to whom the Action is assigned and
any members of those Judges’ staffs and immediate families, as
well as all persons who validly request exclusion from the
28
3
10cv1284
Settlement Class.
1
2
Because the Group 2 Settlement Class merely expands, and does not
3
substantively change, the already conditionally certified class, the Court continues
4
to find, as set forth in the First Preliminary Approval Order, that the Group 2
5
Settlement Class meets the requirements for conditional certification under Federal
6
Rules of Civil Procedure 23(a) and 23(b)(3).
7
3.
Class Representatives
8
Plaintiffs Patricia Connor and Sheri L. Bywater were previously designated
9
as class representatives, (ECF No. 55), and shall remain class representatives for the
10
Settlement Class.
11
4.
Class Counsel
12
The Court previously appointed Hyde & Swigart; The Kazerouni Law
13
Group, APC; the Law Offices of Douglas J. Campion; Lieff Cabraser Heimann &
14
Bernstein, LLP; and David P. Meyer & Associates Co., LPA, as Class Counsel.
15
(ECF No. 55.) Previously appointed Class Counsel shall remain as Class Counsel
16
for the Settlement Class.
17
competent and capable of exercising all responsibilities as Class Counsel for the
18
Settlement Class.
19
5.
The Court continues to find that Class Counsel is
Settlement Hearing
20
A final approval hearing (the “Settlement Hearing”) shall be held before the
21
Honorable Gonzalo P. Curiel, at the U.S. District Court, 221 West Broadway,
22
Courtroom 2D, San Diego, CA 92101, on Friday, November 14, 2014, at 1:30
23
p.m., and notice of such hearing will be included in any future notice being
24
provided to the Settlement Class, to determine whether the Settlement should be
25
finally approved as fair, reasonable, and adequate. Papers in support of final
26
approval of the Settlement, including the Amendment, the incentive award to
27
Plaintiffs and Class Counsel’s application for an award of attorneys’ fees, costs and
28
expenses (the “Fee Application”) shall be filed with the Court at least forty-five
4
10cv1284
1
(45) days prior to the Settlement Hearing. The Settlement Hearing may be
2
postponed, adjourned, or continued by order of the Court without further notice to
3
the Settlement Class. After the Settlement Hearing, the Court may enter a final
4
approval order and final judgment in accordance with the Settlement that will
5
adjudicate the rights of the Settlement Class Members with respect to the Released
6
Claims being settled.
7
6.
Additional Class Notice
8
Additional Class Notice shall be sent to the Group 2 Settlement Class
9
Members, as specified in the Amendment, within thirty (30) days following entry
10
of this Order. The Court approves and renews the form and substance of the
11
proposed notice procedure set forth in the Agreement. Defendant JPMorgan Chase
12
Bank, N.A. (“JPMCB”) will provide the list of Group 2 Settlement Class Members
13
to the Claims Administrator selected by the parties, Gilardi & Co. LLC. The Claims
14
Administrator shall mail a Postcard Notice (as set forth at ECF No. 108-1 at 2-41) to
15
each Group 2 Settlement Class Member at his or her last known address as provided
16
on the list of Group 2 Settlement Class Members. The Claims Administrator will
17
check each address against the United States Post Office National Change of
18
Address Database, will conduct reasonable research to locate valid address
19
information for Group 2 Settlement Class Members whose Notices are returned as
20
undeliverable, will update addresses based on forwarding information received from
21
the United States Post Office, and will update addresses based on any requests to do
22
so by Group 2 Settlement Class Members. The mailed notice will reference the
23
dedicated settlement website (www.connorTCPAsettlement.com) containing the full
24
details of the Settlement and allowing claim submission. The Settlement website
25
will be updated to reflect the Amendment before the additional Class Notice is
26
27
1
28
abbreviated Latin phrase, “et al.”
The Court notes a typographical error at the top of page 1 of the Postcard Notice, to wit, in the use of the
5
10cv1284
1
mailed and shall remain active at least thirty (30) days after the Effective Date of
2
the Final Approval Order. Additional Class Notice need not be provided to any
3
Settlement Class Member previously identified and provided notice as part of the
4
Group 1 Notice process.
5
7.
Declaration to be Filed Regarding Notice
6
At least fifteen (15) days prior to the Settlement Hearing, the Claims
7
Administrator shall file a declaration of compliance with the notice procedures set
8
forth in the Agreement and this Court’s orders.
9
8.
Findings Concerning Class Notice
10
The Court finds the foregoing program of additional Class Notice, directed to
11
the Group 2 Settlement Class Members, and the manner of its dissemination is the
12
best practicable notice under the circumstances and is reasonably calculated to
13
apprise the Newly Identified Settlement Class Members of the pendency of this
14
Action and their right to object to the Settlement or exclude themselves from the
15
Settlement Class. The Court further finds the additional Class Notice program set
16
forth herein is reasonable; that it constitutes due, adequate, and sufficient notice to
17
all persons entitled to receive notice; and that it meets the requirements of due
18
process and Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23.
19
9.
Approval Of Claims Process
20
The claims submission process described in the Agreement, as modified by
21
the Amendment as to Group 2 Settlement Class Members, is hereby approved. The
22
Court previously approved the claims process set forth in the Agreement and
23
hereby adopts the same procedure as it relates to claims submitted by Group 2
24
Settlement Class Members.
25
approval of the Settlement, the maximum total Settlement Costs are increased from
26
$9,000,000 to $11,268,058. Claims by Group 2 Settlement Class Members are
27
capped at $69.97. Because the Settlement contemplates a finite fund, the total
28
amount that Group 1 and Group 2 Settlement Class Members will be paid may be
As set forth in the Amendment, subject to final
6
10cv1284
1
reduced on a pro rata basis if the Group 2 claim rate is higher than anticipated. Any
2
reduction will apply equally to Group 1 and Group 2 Settlement Class Members,
3
such that members from both groups will receive the same amount.
4
10.
5
Exclusion From The Settlement Class
(a)
Group 2 Settlement Class Members may opt out of the Settlement Class
6
by sending a written request to the address designated in the approved
7
Class Notice forms within ninety (90) days after entry of this Order.
8
All Group 2 Settlement Class Members who do not opt out in accordance
9
with the terms set forth herein will be bound by all determinations and
judgments in the Action.
10
11
(b)
Exclusion requests must: (i) be signed; (ii) include the full name, address
12
and cell phone number of the person(s) requesting exclusion; and (iii)
13
include a statement to the effect that the person(s) requesting exclusion
14
wish to be excluded from the Settlement. No request for exclusion will be
15
valid unless all of the information described above is included. No Group
16
2 Settlement Class Member, or any person acting on behalf of or in
17
concert or participation with that Group 2 Settlement Class Member, may
18
exclude any other Group 2 Settlement Class Member from the Settlement
19
Class.
20
(c)
The Claims Administrator will retain a copy of all requests for exclusion.
21
Not later than fifteen (15) days before the Final Approval Hearing, the
22
Claims Administrator shall file with the Court a declaration that lists all of
23
the opt-outs received. The list shall be publicly filed with any redactions
24
required by Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 5.2. The list shall also be
25
lodged with the Court in either Word or WordPerfect format via the
26
Court’s email address (efile_curiel@casd.uscourts.gov) so that it may be
27
appended to any final approval order.
28
///
7
10cv1284
1
(d)
If ten percent (10%) or more persons in the Group 2 Settlement Class opt
2
out of the Settlement, then JPMCB, in its sole discretion, will have the
3
right to terminate the Amendment.
4
pursuant to this paragraph, the parties will be returned to the status quo
5
ante pursuant to the terms of the Agreement.
6
(e)
If the Amendment is terminated
Settlement Class Members previously provided notice as part of the
7
Group 1 Settlement Class Member Notice program and an opportunity to
8
opt out shall not be provided an additional opportunity to opt out.
9
10
9.
Objections and Appearances
(a)
Any Group 2 Settlement Class Member who has not timely submitted a
11
valid request for exclusion from the Settlement may appear at the
12
Settlement Hearing to argue that the proposed Settlement should not be
13
approved and/or to oppose the application of Class Counsel for an award
14
of attorneys’ fees and the incentive awards to Plaintiffs.
15
(b)
To be heard at the Settlement Hearing, a Group 2 Settlement Class
16
Member must make any objection in writing and file it with the Court no
17
later than thirty (30) days before the Settlement Hearing.
18
objection must also be mailed to each of the following, postmarked no
19
later than thirty (30) days before the Settlement Hearing: (i) Connor
20
Counsel: Douglas J. Campion, 409 Camino Del Rio South, Suite 303,
21
San Diego, CA 92108; (ii) Bywater Counsel: Daniel M. Hutchinson,
22
Lieff, Cabraser, Heimann & Bernstein, LLP, 275 Battery Street, 29th
23
Floor, San Francisco, CA 94111; (iii) JPMCB Counsel: Julia B.
24
Strickland, Stroock & Stroock & Lavan LLP, 2029 Century Park East,
25
Los Angeles, CA 90067; and (iv) Fannie Mae Counsel: Christopher
26
Yoo, AlvaradoSmith, 1 MacArthur Place, Suite 200, Santa Ana, CA
27
92707.
The
28
8
10cv1284
1
(c)
A Group 2 Settlement Class Member or his or her attorney intending to
2
make an appearance at the Settlement Hearing must: (i) file a notice of
3
appearance with the Court no later than fifteen (15) days prior to the
4
Settlement Hearing or as the Court may otherwise direct and (ii) within
5
the same time period, serve a copy of such notice of appearance by mail
6
on both Counsel for Defendants and Class Counsel at the addresses set
7
forth directly above. Except as described in the following sentence, any
8
Group 2 Settlement Class Member who fails to comply with these
9
provisions shall waive and forfeit any and all rights he or she may have to
10
appear separately and/or to object to the Settlement, and shall be bound by
11
all the terms of the Settlement, and by all proceedings, orders, and
12
judgments in the Action. Any objections that are not timely filed and
13
served shall be barred, except for good cause shown as determined by the
14
Court.
15
(d)
Any response to any objections to the Settlement, including the
16
Amendment, shall be filed with the Court no later than ten (10) days
17
before the Settlement Hearing.
18
10.
Effect of Failure to Approve the Agreement
19
In the event the Settlement is not approved by the Court, or for any reason
20
the parties fail to obtain a Final Judgment as contemplated in the Agreement or
21
Amendment, or the Settlement is terminated pursuant to its terms for any reason,
22
then the following shall apply:
23
(a)
All orders and findings entered in connection with the Settlement shall
24
become null and void and have no further force and effect except as to
25
payment of notice and claims administration costs to date, shall not be
26
used or referred to for any purposes whatsoever in the Action, and shall
27
not be admissible or discoverable in any other proceeding;
28
9
10cv1284
1
(b)
The conditional certification of the Settlement Class pursuant to this
2
Order and the First Preliminary Approval Order, (ECF No. 55), shall
3
automatically be vacated and deemed void; no doctrine of waiver,
4
estoppel, or preclusion shall be asserted in any litigated certification
5
proceedings in the Action; and the Agreement, including the Amendment,
6
and its existence shall be inadmissible to establish any fact relevant to
7
class certification or any alleged liability of Defendants for the matters
8
alleged in the Action or for any other purpose;
9
(c)
Nothing contained in this Order is, or may be construed as, any admission
or concession by or against the Parties on any point or fact of law; and
10
11
(d)
Neither the Settlement terms nor any publicly disseminated information
12
regarding the Settlement, including, without limitation, the Class Notices,
13
court filings, orders and public statements, may be used as evidence for
14
any purpose whatsoever.
15
documents relating to JPMCB or Fannie Mae’s withdrawal from the
16
Settlement, any failure of the Court to approve the Settlement and/or any
17
objections or interventions may be used as evidence for any purpose
18
whatsoever.
19
11.
In addition, neither the fact of, nor any
Stay/Bar Of Other Proceedings
20
All proceedings in this Action are stayed until further order of the Court,
21
except as may be necessary to implement the terms of the settlement. Pending final
22
determination of whether the Settlement should be approved, Plaintiffs, all persons
23
in the Settlement Class (inclusive of Class Members identified in the Agreement,
24
including the Amendment) and persons purporting to act on their behalf are
25
enjoined from commencing or prosecuting (either directly, representatively, or in
26
any other capacity) against any of the Released Parties any action, arbitration or
27
proceeding in any court, arbitration forum or tribunal asserting any of the Released
28
Claims.
10
10cv1284
1
12.
Continuing Jurisdiction
2
The Court retains continuing and exclusive jurisdiction over the Action to
3
consider all further matters arising out of or connected with the Settlement,
4
including the administration and enforcement of the Agreement, including the
5
Amendment.
6
IT IS SO ORDERED.
DATED: May 30, 2014
7
___________________________
HON. GONZALO P. CURIEL
United States District Judge
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
11
10cv1284
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?