PacketVideo Corporation v. Spotify USA Inc. et al
Filing
1
COMPLAINT with Jury Demand against Spotify Limited, Spotify Technology Sarl, Spotify USA Inc. ( Filing fee $ 350 receipt number 0974-3802217.), filed by PacketVideo Corporation.The new case number is 3:11-cv-1659-IEG-WMC. Judge Irma E. Gonzalez and Magistrate Judge William McCurine, Jr. are assigned to the case. (Mathews, Christopher)(yeb) (mam).
<![CDATA[
!"! #$% & ' #( )*+ '&
,
- !".' #(/01#22!3+21!.&$'3
4!5!2 & 2"! 6'2 )*+ '&
,
64!5!2+2"! 6'2/01#22!3+21!.&$'3
7 #64'87! & +47!96 )*+ '&
,
$7 #63+47!96/01#22!3+21!.&$'3
'147 #(1! '+ 4 !!4 47 .''
'6 2(!.!6 +.#-' 2#+
:
!.!87'2!;
) ,
:
+$6#3#.!;
) ,
:
44' 2!<6 -' .+#24#- = >
> >
>
= >
+ >!.+9+ !
$' 8' +4#'2
.+#24#--
5&
? & + >!.+9+ ! $' 8' +4#'2
? > + 2#4!" =#2("'3
$' 8' +4#'2 +2"
?
?
+ 1@!3A'1 ( $' 8' +4#'2
'11CV1659 IEG WMc
& BBBBBBBBBBBBB
>>
C?
>!-!2"+246&
.+#24#-- +$%!4 #"!' ' 8' +4#'2 )D+$%!4 #"!'D, -' #46 $'38.+#24 +(+#264 >!-!2"+246
8'4#-< 2$& )D 8'4#-< D,E 8'4#-< #3#4!" )D 8'4#-< =D, +2" 8'4#-< !$72'.'(<
)D 8'4#-< 1@D, )+.. $'..!$4#5!.< D>!-!2"+246D, 7! !A< "!3+2"6 + F1 < 4 #+. +2" +..!(!6 +6
-'..'96;
&
GG
7#6 '1 4 7+6 F1 #6"#$4#'2 '5! 47! 61AF!$4 3+44! '- 47#6 +$4#'2 12"!
+2"
&
)", +2"
& & &
)+,&
!21! #6 !64+A.#67!" #2 47#6 F1"#$#+. "#64 #$4 81 61+24 4'
& & & GG
)A, )$,
)A,& >!-!2"+246 7+5! $'33#44!" +$46 '- #2- #2(!3!24 #2 47#6 F1"#$#+. "#64 #$4E +2"
>!-!2"+246 8'4#-< = +2" 8'4#-< 1@ + ! +.#!2 $'38+2#!6&
&
7#6 #6 + $#5#. +$4#'2 -' #2- #2(!3!24 '- 2#4!" 4+4!6 +4!24 '&
D+4!24:#2: 1#4D ' DH
)47!
+4!24D,& 7#6 +$4#'2 #6 A+6!" 18'2 47! +4!24 +96 '- 47! 2#4!" 4+4!6
& & & G !4 6!0&
&
.+#24#-- +$%!4 #"!' ' 8' +4#'2 )D+$%!4 #"!'D, #6 + $' 8' +4#'2 ' (+2#I!"
12"! 47! .+96 '- 47! 64+4! '- >!.+9+ ! 7+5#2( #46 8 #2$#8+. 8.+$! '- A16#2!66 +4 $#!2$!
!24! > #5! +2 >#!('
&
&
2 #2-' 3+4#'2 +2" A!.#!- >!-!2"+24 8'4#-< #6 #2$' 8' +4!" 12"! 47! .+96
'- 47! 64+4! '- >!.+9+ ! 7+5#2( #46 8 #2$#8+. 8.+$! '- A16#2!66 +4
.'' !9 ?' % ?
&
47 5!21! 1#4!
47
2 #2-' 3+4#'2 +2" A!.#!- 8'4#-< 8 '"1$46 +$$16!" '-
#2- #2(!3!24 #2 47#6 '38.+#24 + ! +2" 7+5! A!!2 '--! !" -' 6+.! 6'." +2" #38' 4!" A< 8'4#-<
#2 47#6 +2" '47! F1"#$#+. "#64 #$46&
&
2 #2-' 3+4#'2 +2" A!.#!- >!-!2"+24 8'4#-< = #6 #2$' 8' +4!" 12"! 47! .+96 '-
47! 2#4!" =#2("'3 7+5#2( #46 8 #2$#8+. 8.+$! '- A16#2!66 +4 '."!2 '16! !+4 1.4!2!<
4 !!4 '2"'2 J
2#4!" =#2("'3&
2 #2-' 3+4#'2 +2" A!.#!- 8'4#-< =
3+21-+$41 !6 "#64 #A14!6 +2" #38' 46 47! 8 '"1$46 +..!(!" 4' #2- #2(! 7! !#2 #2 47#6 +2" '47!
F1"#$#+. "#64 #$46&
&
2 #2-' 3+4#'2 +2" A!.#!- >!-!2"+24 8'4#-< 1@ #6 #2$' 8' +4!" 12"! 47! .+96 '-
1@!3A'1 ( 7+5#2( #46 8 #2$#8+. 8.+$! '- A16#2!66 +4 5!21! + #!:7! !6!
1@!3A'1 ( 1@!3A'1 (&
2 #2-' 3+4#'2 +2" A!.#!- 8'4#-< 1@ 3+21-+$41 !6 "#64 #A14!6 +2"
#38' 46 47! 8 '"1$46 +..!(!" 4' #2- #2(! 7! !#2 #2 47#6 +2" '47! F1"#$#+. "#64 #$46&
: :
&
8'2 #2-' 3+4#'2 +2" A!.#!- +4 +.. !.!5+24 4#3!6 3!24#'2!" #2 47#6 '38.+#24
>!-!2"+246 +2" !+$7 '- 47!3 9! ! 47! +(!246 '- !+$7 '47! +2" #2 "'#2( 47! 47#2(6 +..!(!"
7! !#2 !+$7 9+6 +$4#2( 9#47#2 47! 6$'8! +2" $'1 6! '- #46 +(!2$< +2" +147' #4< +2" 9+6 61AF!$4 4'
+2" 12"! 47! 618! 5#6#'2 '- #46 $':"!-!2"+246 +6 $':$'268# +4' 6&
&
2 #2-' 3+4#'2 +2" A!.#!- >!-!2"+246 + ! 61AF!$4 4' 47#6 '1 4H6 8! 6'2+.
F1 #6"#$4#'2 A!$+16! 47!< 7+5! $'2"1$4!" +2" "' $'2"1$4 A16#2!66 9#47#2 47#6 "#64 #$4& >!-!2"+246
#2$.1"#2( 47 '1(7 #24! 3!"#+ #!6 )#2$.1"#2( "#64 #A14' 6 !4+#.! 6 8+ 42! 6 61A6#"#+ #!6 +2"
'47! 6, 3+%! 3+21-+$41 ! 67#8 "#64 #A14! '--! -' 6+.! 6!.. +"5! 4#6! +2" 16! 47!# 8 '"1$46
+2" 6! 5#$!6 #2 47! 2#4!" 4+4!6 #2$.1"#2( 47#6 "#64 #$4 47 '1(7 97#$7 47!< "! #5! 61A64+24#+.
!5!21!& ! 6'2+. F1 #6"#$4#'2 !@#646 68!$#-#$+..< '5! >!-!2"+246 A!$+16! '- 47!# #2- #2(#2(
$'2"1$4 9#47#2 +2" "# !$4!" +4 $#4#I!26 #2 47#6 "#64 #$4 #2$.1"#2( A< 5# 41! '- +4 .!+64 47!# 9!A6#4!
)999&68'4#-<&$'3, 47+4 +$4#5!.< !+$7!6 '14 4' $#4#I!26 #2 47! '147! 2 >#64 #$4 '- +.#-' 2#+ +2"
'--! 6 >!-!2"+246H #2- #2(#2( 8 '"1$46& 7!6! #2- #2(#2( 8 '"1$46 7+5! A!!2 +2" $'24#21! 4' A!
16!" #2 47#6 "#64 #$4& >!-!2"+246 7+5! $'33#44!" 8+4!24 #2- #2(!3!24 9#47#2 47#6 "#64 #$4&
&
'12"!" #2
+$%!4 #"!' #6 + +2 >#!(':A+6!" $'38+2< 47+4 8 '"1$!6
6'-49+ ! 47+4 +..'96 47! 16! 4' !2F'< 9# !.!66 316#$ +2" 5#"!'& +$%!4 #"!' '--! 6 !5! <47#2(
- '3 A '96#2( -' !$'33!2"+4#'2 '- +2" "#6$'5! < '- 316#$ +2" 5#"!' 4' 47! 81 $7+6!
8.+<A+$% +2" 67+ #2( '- 316#$ +2" 5#"!'& 7! $'38+2<H6 6'-49+ ! 6188' 46 +.. 3+F' 3!"#+
-' 3+46 A '+"$+64 64+2"+ "6 7'3! 2!49' %#2( 8 '4'$'.6 '8! +4#2( 6<64!36 +2" 7+2"6!46K3'A#.!
87'2!6&
+$%!4 #"!'H6 $164'3! 6 #2$.1"! 3'A#.! '8! +4' 6 61$7 +6 ! #I'2 J# !.!66
>' '' +2"
+2(! 7+2"6!4 3+21-+$41 ! 6 +2" $'2613!
+$%!4 #"!'L6 6'-49+ ! #6 $1 !24.< !3A!""!" #2 3' ! 47+2
3' ! 47+2
&
!.!$4 '2#$6 $'38+2#!6&
3#..#'2 "!5#$!6 9' ."9#"! +2"
"#--! !24 8 '"1$46&
+$%!4 #"!'H6 6'-49+ ! 8 '"1$46 -' 3 47! -'12"+4#'2 -' +1"#!2$!:#24! +$4#5!
3!"#+ !@8! #!2$!6 47+4 (#5! $'2613! 6 47! - !!"'3 4' !2F'< 31.4#3!"#+ $'24!24 7'9!5!
97!2!5! +2" 97! !5! 47!< 9+24&
: :
&
>!-!2"+246 '--!
+ 316#$ 64 !+3#2( 6! 5#$! $+..!" 8'4#-< -'12" +4
999&68'4#-<&$'3& 7! 8'4#-< 6! 5#$! 8 '5#"!6 64 !+3#2( '- 6!.!$4!" 316#$ - '3 + +2(! '!$' " .+A!.6 )
'2< J+ 2! 2#5! 6+. ,& 7! 8'4#-< 6! 5#$! !2+A.!6 16! 6 4' +$$!66
316#$ +5+#.+A.! 47 '1(7 47! 6! 5#$!& 8!$#-#$+..< 47! 8'4#-< 6! 5! 6 !2+A.! 16! 6 4' A '96! A<
-' !@+38.! + 4#64 +.A13 !$' " .+A!. (!2 ! ' 8.+<.#64& 7! 6! 5#$! #6 8 !6!24.< '2.< +5+#.+A.! #2
47! 2#4!" 4+4!6 +2" #2 $! 4+#2 $'124 #!6 '- 1 '8!& 7! 6<64!3 #6 $1 !24.< +$$!66#A.! 16#2(
"#--! !24 $'3814! 6'-49+ ! '8! +4#2( 6<64!36 +2" 3'A#.! '8! +4#2( 6<64!36&
&
47! H
2 C12!
47! 2#4!" 4+4!6 +4!24 +2" +"!3+ %
--#$! )D
D, #661!"
+4!24 4' '.- * 1((! -' 7#6 #25!24#'2 !24#4.!" D>!5#$! -' 47! >#64 #A14#'2 '- 16#$ #2
>#(#4+. ' 3&D +$%!4 #"!' #6 47! !@$.16#5! +2" $1 !24 '92! '- +.. #(74 4#4.! +2" #24! !64 #2
+2" 4' 47! H
+4!24 #2$.1"#2( 47! #(74 4' A #2( 47#6 61#4 -' #2F12$4#5! !.#!- +2" "+3+(!6&
!
" #$ %
&
+ +( +876 47 '1(7
+ ! #2$' 8' +4!" A< !-! !2$! +6 #- 64+4!" -1..< 7! !#2&
&
7! H
&
4 .!+64 +6 !+ .< +6 +<
+4!24 #6 5+.#" +2" !2-' $!+A.!&
97!2 +$%!4 #"!' A '1(74 47! H
+4!24 4'
>!-!2"+246H +44!24#'2 >!-!2"+246 7+5! 7+" +$41+. %2'9.!"(! '- A'47 +$%!4 #"!'H6 #(746 #2 47!
H
+4!24 +2" 47! "!4+#.6 '- >!-!2"+246H #2- #2(!3!24 '- 47! H
+4!24& !5! 47!.!66 8'4#-<
7+6 '--! !" -' 6+.! 6'." +2" #38' 4!" 8 '"1$46 +2"K' 6! 5#$!6 $'2-#(1 !" 4' #2- #2(! 47!
H
+4!24 +2" #264 1$4!" +2" !2$'1 +(!" '47! 6 4' 16! 47! H
&
J#47 %2'9.!"(! '- 47! H
47+4 8'4#-< %2!9 #2- #2(!" 47! H
#2- #2(#2( 47! H
+4!24 #2 +2 #2- #2(#2( 3+22! &
+4!24 +2" #24!24 4' !2$'1 +(! '47! 6 4' 8! -' 3 +$46
+4!24 8'4#-< 7+6 #2- #2(!" +2" #6 $1 !24.<
+4!24 A< 3+%#2( 16#2( 6!..#2( '--! #2( -' 6+.! +2"K' #38' 4#2( #24' 47!
2#4!" 4+4!6 9#47'14 +147' #4< 8 '"1$46 ' 6! 5#$!6 47+4 + ! $'5! !" A< '2! ' 3' ! $.+#36 '47! H
+4!24 #2$.1"#2( $.+#3 #2$.1"#2( A14 2'4 .#3#4!" 4' >!-!2"+246H #2- #2(#2( 316#$
64 !+3#2( 6<64!3 +2" 6! 5#$!6 #2$.1"#2( -' 47!# 8'4#-< 6<64!3 +2" 6! 5#$!&
: :
&
J#47 %2'9.!"(! '- 47! H
+4!24 8'4#-< 7+5! $'24 #A14!" 4' +2"K'
#2"1$!" +2" 9#.. $'24#21! 4' $'24 #A14! 4' +2"K' #2"1$! 47! #2- #2(!3!24 '- 47! H
+4!24 A<
'47! 6 #2 47#6 >#64 #$4 +2" !.6!97! ! #2 47! 2#4!" 4+4!6 A< 6!..#2( '--! #2( -' 6+.! +"5! 4#6#2(
.!+6#2( '--! #2( 4' .!+6! #264 1$4#2( +2"K' #38' 4#2( #24' 47! 2#4!" 4+4!6 9#47'14 +147' #4<
9#47 47! "# !$4 #2- #2(!3!24 A!#2( +$$'38.#67!" A< !2" 16! 6 '- +4 .!+64 47! -' !('#2( 8 '"1$46
+2"K' 6! 5#$!6&
&
8'4#-< #6 2'4 .#$!26!" ' '47! 9#6! +147' #I!" A< +$%!4 #"!' 4' 8 +$4#$!
$'24 #A14' #.< 8 +$4#$! +2"K' #2"1$! 47# " 8+ 4#!6 4' 8 +$4#$! 47! $.+#36 '- 47! H
&
+4!24&
*< !+6'2 '- 8'4#-< H6 #2- #2(#2( +$4#5#4#!6 +$%!4 #"!' 7+6 61--! !" +2"
9#.. $'24#21! 4' 61--! 61A64+24#+. "+3+(!6 #2 +2 +3'124 4' A! 8 '5!2 +4 4 #+. A14 #2 2' !5!24 .!66
47+2 + !+6'2+A.! '<+.4<&
&
8'4#-< H6 $'24#21#2( +$46 '- #2- #2(!3!24 + ! # !8+ +A.< 7+ 3#2( +2" $+16#2(
"+3+(! 4' +$%!4 #"!' -' 97#$7 +$%!4 #"!' 7+6 2' +"!01+4! !3!"< +4 .+9 +2" 9#.. $'24#21!
4' 61--! 61$7 # !8+ +A.! #2F1 < 12.!66 >!-!2"+246H $'24#21#2( +$46 '- #2- #2(!3!24 + ! !2F'#2!"
A< 47! '1 4& 7! 7+ "67#86 47+4 9'1." A! #38'6!" A< +2 #2F12$4#'2 + ! .!66 47+2 47'6! -+$!" A<
+$%!4 #"!' 67'1." +2 #2F12$4#'2 2'4 #661!& 7! 81A.#$ #24! !64 9'1." A! 6! 5!" A< #661+2$! '- +2
#2F12$4#'2&
&
8'4#-< H6 #2- #2(!3!24 '- 47! H
+4!24 7+6 A!!2 +2" $'24#21!6 4' A! 9#..-1.
+2" "!.#A! +4! F164#-<#2( + 4 !A.#2( '- "+3+(!6 12"!
&
8'4#-< H6 #2- #2(!3!24 '- 47! H
& & & G
&
+4!24 #6 !@$!84#'2+. +2" !24#4.!6
+$%!4 #"!' 4' +44' 2!<6H -!!6 +2" $'646 #2$1 !" #2 8 '6!$14#2( 47#6 +$4#'2 12"!
& & & G
&
!
" #$ &%
&
+ +( +876 47 '1(7
+ ! #2$' 8' +4!" A< !-! !2$! +6 #- 64+4!" -1..< 7! !#2&
&
7! H
&
4 .!+64 +6 !+ .< +6 +<
+4!24 #6 5+.#" +2" !2-' $!+A.!&
97!2 +$%!4 #"!' A '1(74 47! H
+4!24 4'
>!-!2"+246H +44!24#'2 >!-!2"+246 7+5! 7+" +$41+. %2'9.!"(! '- A'47 +$%!4 #"!'H6 #(746 #2 47!
H
+4!24 +2" 47! "!4+#.6 '- >!-!2"+246H #2- #2(!3!24 '- 47! H
: :
+4!24& !5! 47!.!66 8'4#-<
= 7+6 "#64 #A14!" +2" #38' 4!" 8 '"1$46 +2"K' 6! 5#$!6 $'2-#(1 !" 4' #2- #2(! 47! H
+2" #264 1$4!" +2" !2$'1 +(!" '47! 6 4' 16! 47! H
&
+4!24
+4!24 #2 +2 #2- #2(#2( 3+22! &
J#47 %2'9.!"(! '- 47! H
+4!24 +2" #24!24 4' !2$'1 +(! '47! 6 4' 8! -' 3 +$46
47+4 8'4#-< = %2!9 #2- #2(!" 47! H
+4!24 8'4#-< = 7+6 #2- #2(!" +2" #6 $1 !24.<
#2- #2(#2( 47! H
+4!24 A< 3+%#2( 16#2( 6!..#2( '--! #2( -' 6+.! +2"K' #38' 4#2( #24' 47!
2#4!" 4+4!6 9#47'14 +147' #4< 8 '"1$46 ' 6! 5#$!6 47+4 + ! $'5! !" A< '2! ' 3' ! $.+#36 '47! H
+4!24 #2$.1"#2( $.+#3 #2$.1"#2( A14 2'4 .#3#4!" 4' >!-!2"+246H #2- #2(#2( 316#$
64 !+3#2( 6<64!3 +2" 6! 5#$!6 #2$.1"#2( 47!# 8'4#-< 6<64!3 +2" 6! 5#$!&
&
J#47 %2'9.!"(! '- 47! H
+4!24 8'4#-< = 7+5! $'24 #A14!" 4' +2"K' #2"1$!"
+2" 9#.. $'24#21! 4' $'24 #A14! 4' +2"K' #2"1$! 47! #2- #2(!3!24 '- 47! H
+4!24 A< '47! 6 #2
47#6 >#64 #$4 +2" !.6!97! ! #2 47! 2#4!" 4+4!6 A< 6!..#2( '--! #2( -' 6+.! +"5! 4#6#2( .!+6#2(
'--! #2( 4' .!+6! #264 1$4#2( +2"K' #38' 4#2( #24' 47! 2#4!" 4+4!6 9#47'14 +147' #4< 9#47 47!
"# !$4 #2- #2(!3!24 A!#2( +$$'38.#67!" A< !2" 16! 6 '- +4 .!+64 47! -' !('#2( 8 '"1$46 +2"K'
6! 5#$!6&
&
8'4#-< = #6 2'4 .#$!26!" ' '47! 9#6! +147' #I!" A< +$%!4 #"!' 4' 8 +$4#$!
$'24 #A14' #.< 8 +$4#$! +2"K' #2"1$! 47# " 8+ 4#!6 4' 8 +$4#$! 47! $.+#36 '- 47! H
&
+4!24&
*< !+6'2 '- 8'4#-< =H6 #2- #2(#2( +$4#5#4#!6 +$%!4 #"!' 7+6 61--! !" +2" 9#..
$'24#21! 4' 61--! 61A64+24#+. "+3+(!6 #2 +2 +3'124 4' A! 8 '5!2 +4 4 #+. A14 #2 2' !5!24 .!66 47+2
+ !+6'2+A.! '<+.4<&
&
8'4#-< =H6 $'24#21#2( +$46 '- #2- #2(!3!24 + ! # !8+ +A.< 7+ 3#2( +2" $+16#2(
"+3+(! 4' +$%!4 #"!' -' 97#$7 +$%!4 #"!' 7+6 2' +"!01+4! !3!"< +4 .+9 +2" 9#.. $'24#21!
4' 61--! 61$7 # !8+ +A.! #2F1 < 12.!66 >!-!2"+246H $'24#21#2( +$46 '- #2- #2(!3!24 + ! !2F'#2!"
A< 47! '1 4& 7! 7+ "67#86 47+4 9'1." A! #38'6!" A< +2 #2F12$4#'2 + ! .!66 47+2 47'6! -+$!" A<
+$%!4 #"!' 67'1." +2 #2F12$4#'2 2'4 #661!& 7! 81A.#$ #24! !64 9'1." A! 6! 5!" A< #661+2$! '- +2
#2F12$4#'2&
&
8'4#-< =H6 #2- #2(!3!24 '- 47! H
+2" "!.#A! +4! F164#-<#2( + 4 !A.#2( '- "+3+(!6 12"!
: :
+4!24 7+6 A!!2 +2" $'24#21!6 4' A! 9#..-1.
& & & G
&
&
8'4#-< =H6 #2- #2(!3!24 '- 47! H
+4!24 #6 !@$!84#'2+. +2" !24#4.!6
+$%!4 #"!' 4' +44' 2!<6H -!!6 +2" $'646 #2$1 !" #2 8 '6!$14#2( 47#6 +$4#'2 12"!
& & & G
&
!
" #$ '%
&
+ +( +876 47 '1(7
+ ! #2$' 8' +4!" A< !-! !2$! +6 #- 64+4!" -1..< 7! !#2&
&
7! H
&
4 .!+64 +6 !+ .< +6 +<
+4!24 #6 5+.#" +2" !2-' $!+A.!&
97!2 +$%!4 #"!' A '1(74 47! H
+4!24 4'
>!-!2"+246H +44!24#'2 >!-!2"+246 7+5! 7+" +$41+. %2'9.!"(! '- A'47 +$%!4 #"!'H6 #(746 #2 47!
H
+4!24 +2" 47! "!4+#.6 '- >!-!2"+246H #2- #2(!3!24 '- 47! H
+4!24& !5! 47!.!66 8'4#-<
1@ 7+6 "#64 #A14!" +2" #38' 4!" 8 '"1$46 +2"K' 6! 5#$!6 $'2-#(1 !" 4' #2- #2(! 47! H
+2" #264 1$4!" +2" !2$'1 +(!" '47! 6 4' 16! 47! H
&
+4!24
+4!24 #2 +2 #2- #2(#2( 3+22! &
J#47 %2'9.!"(! '- 47! H
+4!24 +2" #24!24 4' !2$'1 +(! '47! 6 4' 8! -' 3 +$46
47+4 8'4#-< 1@ %2!9 #2- #2(!" 47! H
+4!24 8'4#-< 1@ 7+6 #2- #2(!" +2" #6 $1 !24.<
#2- #2(#2( 47! H
+4!24 A< 3+%#2( 16#2( 6!..#2( '--! #2( -' 6+.! +2"K' #38' 4#2( #24' 47!
2#4!" 4+4!6 9#47'14 +147' #4< 8 '"1$46 ' 6! 5#$!6 47+4 + ! $'5! !" A< '2! ' 3' ! $.+#36 '47! H
+4!24 #2$.1"#2( $.+#3 #2$.1"#2( A14 2'4 .#3#4!" 4' >!-!2"+246H #2- #2(#2( 316#$
64 !+3#2( 6<64!3 +2" 6! 5#$!6 #2$.1"#2( 47!# 8'4#-< 6<64!3 +2" 6! 5#$!&
&
J#47 %2'9.!"(! '- 47! H
+4!24 8'4#-< 1@ 7+5! $'24 #A14!" 4' +2"K'
#2"1$!" +2" 9#.. $'24#21! 4' $'24 #A14! 4' +2"K' #2"1$! 47! #2- #2(!3!24 '- 47! H
+4!24 A<
'47! 6 #2 47#6 >#64 #$4 +2" !.6!97! ! #2 47! 2#4!" 4+4!6 A< 6!..#2( '--! #2( -' 6+.! +"5! 4#6#2(
.!+6#2( '--! #2( 4' .!+6! #264 1$4#2( +2"K' #38' 4#2( #24' 47! 2#4!" 4+4!6 9#47'14 +147' #4<
9#47 47! "# !$4 #2- #2(!3!24 A!#2( +$$'38.#67!" A< !2" 16! 6 '- +4 .!+64 47! -' !('#2( 8 '"1$46
+2"K' 6! 5#$!6&
&
8'4#-< 1@ #6 2'4 .#$!26!" ' '47! 9#6! +147' #I!" A< +$%!4 #"!' 4' 8 +$4#$!
$'24 #A14' #.< 8 +$4#$! +2"K' #2"1$! 47# " 8+ 4#!6 4' 8 +$4#$! 47! $.+#36 '- 47! H
&
+4!24&
*< !+6'2 '- 8'4#-< 1@H6 #2- #2(#2( +$4#5#4#!6 +$%!4 #"!' 7+6 61--! !" +2" 9#..
$'24#21! 4' 61--! 61A64+24#+. "+3+(!6 #2 +2 +3'124 4' A! 8 '5!2 +4 4 #+. A14 #2 2' !5!24 .!66 47+2
+ !+6'2+A.! '<+.4<&
: :
&
8'4#-< 1@H6 $'24#21#2( +$46 '- #2- #2(!3!24 + ! # !8+ +A.< 7+ 3#2( +2" $+16#2(
"+3+(! 4' +$%!4 #"!' -' 97#$7 +$%!4 #"!' 7+6 2' +"!01+4! !3!"< +4 .+9 +2" 9#.. $'24#21!
4' 61--! 61$7 # !8+ +A.! #2F1 < 12.!66 >!-!2"+246H $'24#21#2( +$46 '- #2- #2(!3!24 + ! !2F'#2!"
A< 47! '1 4& 7! 7+ "67#86 47+4 9'1." A! #38'6!" A< +2 #2F12$4#'2 + ! .!66 47+2 47'6! -+$!" A<
+$%!4 #"!' 67'1." +2 #2F12$4#'2 2'4 #661!& 7! 81A.#$ #24! !64 9'1." A! 6! 5!" A< #661+2$! '- +2
#2F12$4#'2&
&
8'4#-< 1@H6 #2- #2(!3!24 '- 47! H
+4!24 7+6 A!!2 +2" $'24#21!6 4' A! 9#..-1.
+2" "!.#A! +4! F164#-<#2( + 4 !A.#2( '- "+3+(!6 12"!
&
8'4#-< 1@H6 #2- #2(!3!24 '- 47! H
& & & G
&
+4!24 #6 !@$!84#'2+. +2" !24#4.!6
+$%!4 #"!' 4' +44' 2!<6H -!!6 +2" $'646 #2$1 !" #2 8 '6!$14#2( 47#6 +$4#'2 12"!
( )*( ( (*
& & & G
&
*
J
+$%!4 #"!' !68!$4-1..< !01!646 47! -'..'9#2( !.#!-;
&
F1"(3!24 7'."#2( 47! >!-!2"+246 .#+A.! -' #2- #2(!3!24 '- 47! +4!24:#2: 1#4
+66! 4!" +(+#264 47!3E
*&
8! 3+2!24 #2F12$4#'2 81 61+24 4'
& & & G
+(+#264 >!-!2"+246 47!#
'--#$! 6 +(!246 !38.'<!!6 +44' 2!<6 8+ !24 +2" 61A6#"#+ < $' 8' +4#'26 +66#(26 +2" 61$$!66' 6
#2 #24! !64 +2" +.. '47! 6 +$4#2( #2 $'2$! 4 ' 8+ 4#$#8+4#'2 9#47 47!3 !2F'#2#2( 47!3 - '3
$'24#21!" +$46 '- #2- #2(!3!24 '- 47! +4!24:#2: 1#4 +66! 4!" +(+#264 47!3 4' 47! !@4!24 47'6!
8+4!246 7+5! 2'4 <!4 !@8# !"E
&
2 +$$'124#2( '- "+3+(!6 !61.4#2( - '3 47! >!-!2"+246H #2- #2(!3!24 '- 47!
+4!24:#2: 1#4 +66! 4!" +(+#264 47!3 4'(!47! 9#47 8 !:F1"(3!24 +2" 8'64:F1"(3!24 #24! !64E
>&
F1"(3!24 7'."#2( 47+4 47! >!-!2"+246H #2- #2(!3!24 #6 9#..-1. +2" + 4 !A.#2( '-
"+3+(!6 81 61+24 4'
& & & G
E
: :
&
F1"(3!24 7'."#2( 47#6 $4#'2 4' A! +2 !@$!84#'2+. $+6! +2" +2 +9+ " 4' .+#24#--
+$%!4 #"!' -' #46 +44' 2!<6H -!!6 +2" $'646 81 61+24 4'
&
>>; C1.<
& & & G
E +2"
1$7 '47! +2" -1 47! !.#!- +6 47#6 '1 4 "!!36 F164 +2" 8 '8! &
!68!$4-1..< 61A3#44!"
*<;
7 #6 +47!96
44' 2!<6 -' .+#24#- = >
:
:
C? >>>
+$%!4 #"!' ' 8' +4#'2 "!3+2"6 + 4 #+. A< F1 < '2 +.. #661!6 4 #+A.! '- #(74 A< + F1 <&
>>; C1.<
*<;
7 #6 +47!96
44' 2!<6 -' .+#24#--
= >
: :
CIVIL COVER SHEET
JS 44 (Rev. 12/07)
The JS 44 civil cover sheet and the information contained herein neither replace nor supplement the filing and service of pleadings or other papers as required by law, except as
provided by local rules of court. This form, approved by the Judicial Conference of the United States in September 1974, is required for the use of the Clerk of Court for the
purpose of initiating the civil docket sheet. (SEE INSTRUCTIONS ON THE REVERSE OF THE FORM.)
I. (a) PLAINTIFFS
DEFENDANTS
PACKETVIDEO CORPORATION, a Delaware
corporation
SPOTIFY USA INC., a Delaware corporation,
SPOTIFY LIMITED, a United Kingdom
corporation, and SPOTIFY TECHNOLOGY SARL,
a Luxembourg corporation,
(b) County of Residence of First Listed Plaintiff
San Diego
County of Residence of First Listed Defendant
(EXCEPT IN U.S. PLAINTIFF CASES)
NY/San Diego
(IN U.S. PLAINTIFF CASES ONLY)
NOTE: IN LAND CONDEMNATION CASES, USE THE LOCATION OF THE
LAND INVOLVED.
(c)
Attorneys (If Known)
Attorney’s (Firm Name, Address, and Telephone Number)
Christopher A. Mathews (SBN 144021)
Quinn Emanuel Urquhart & Sullivan LLP
865 South Figueroa Street, 10th Floor
Los Angeles, CA 90017
(213) 443-3000
II. BASIS OF JURISDICTION
x
1 U.S. Government
Plaintiff
(Place an “X” in One Box Only)
'11CV1659 IEG WMc
III. CITIZENSHIP OF PRINCIPAL PARTIES
(For Diversity Cases Only)
3 Federal Question
(U.S. Government Not a Party)
PTF
DEF
PTF
IV. NATURE OF SUIT
110
120
130
140
150
151
152
153
160
190
195
196
REAL PROPERTY
210 Land Condemnation
220 Foreclosure
230 Rent Lease & Ejectment
240 Torts to Land
245 Tort Product Liability
290 All Other Real Property
x 1
1
1
Citizen of Another State
2
2
3
3
Incorporated or Principal Place
of Business In This State
Incorporated and Principal Place
of Business In Another State
Foreign Nation
TORTS
PERSONAL INJURY
PERSONAL INJURY
310 Airplane
362 Personal Injury 315 Airplane Product
Med. Malpractice
Liability
365 Personal Injury 320 Assault, Libel &
Product Liability
Slander
368 Asbestos Personal
Injury Product
330 Federal Employers'
Liability
Liability
340 Marine
PERSONAL PROPERTY
4
5
5
6
6
345 Marine Product
370 Other Fraud
Liability
371 Truth in Lending
350 Motor Vehicle
380 Other Personal
355 Motor Vehicle
Property Damage
Product Liability
385 Property Damage
360 Other Personal
Product Liability
Injury
PRISONER PETITIONS
CIVIL RIGHTS
441 Voting
510 Motion to Vacate
442 Employment
Sentence
Habeas Corpus:
443 Housing/
Accommodations
530 General
444 Welfare
535 Death Penalty
445 Amer. w/Disabilities 540 Mandamus & other
Employment
550 Civil Rights
446 Amer. w/Disabilities 555 Prison Condition
Other
440 Other Civil Rights
BANKRUPTCY
610 Agriculture
620 Other Food & Drug
625 Drug Related Seizure
of Property 2 1 USC 88 1
630 Liquor Laws
640 R.R. & Truck
650 Airline Regs.
660 Occupational
Safety/Health
690 Other
LABOR
OTHER STATUTES
422 Appeal 28 USC 158
FORFEITURE/PENALTY
400 State Reapportionment
410 Antitrust
430 Banks and Banking
450 Commerce
460 Deportation
470 Racketeer Influenced
and Corrupt Organizations
480 Consumer Credit
490 Cable/Sat TV
423 Withdrawal
28 USC 157
PROPERTY RIGHTS
820 Copyrights
x
830 Patent
840 Trademark
SOCIAL SECURITY
861 HIA (1395ff)
862 Black Lung (923)
863 DIWC/DIWW
(405(g))
864 SSID Title XVI
865 RSI (405(g))
710 Fair Labor Standards
Act
720 Labor/Mgmt. Relations
730 Labor/Mgmt. Reporting
& Disclosure Act
740 Railway Labor Act
790 Other Labor Litigation
FEDERAL TAX SUITS
791 Empl. Ret. Inc.
Security Act
870 Taxes (U.S. Plaintiff
IMMIGRATION
or Defendant)
462 Naturalization Application
871 IRS - Third Party
463 Habcas Corpus 26 USC 7609
Alien Detainee
465 Other Immigration
Actions
2 Removed from
VI. CAUSE OF ACTION
3 Remanded from
4 Reinstated or
5 Transferred from
6 Multidistrict
Litigation
another district
(specify)
Cite the U.S. Civil Statute under which you are filing (Do not cite jurisdictional statutes unless diversity):
State Court
810 Selective Service
850 Securities/Commodities/
Exchange
875 Customer Challenge
12 USC 3410
890 Other Statutory Actions
891 Agricultural Acts
892 Economic Stabilization
Act
893 Environmental Matters
894 Energy Allocation Act
895 Freedom of Information
Act
900 Appeal of Fee
Determination Under
Equal Access to Justice
950 Constitutionality of
State Statutes
Appeal to District
(Place an “X” in One Box Only)
Original
Proceeding
DEF
4
(Place an “X” in One Box Only)
CONTRACT
Insurance
Marine
Miller Act
Negotiable Instrument
Recovery of Overpayment
& Enforcement of Judgment
Medicare Act
Recovery of Defaulted
Student Loans
(Excl. Veterans)
Recovery of Overpayment
of Veteran's Benefits
Stockholders' Suits
Other Contract
Contract Product Liability
Franchise
V. ORIGIN
Citizen of This State
Citizen or Subject of a
Foreign Country
4 Diversity
(Indicate Citizenship of Parties in Item III)
2 U.S. Government
Defendant
(Place an “X” in One Box for Plaintiff
and One Box for Defendant)
Appellate Court
Reopened
35 USC 1 et seq.
7 Judge from
Magistrate
Judgment
35:145 yeb
Brief description of cause:
Patent infringement.
VII. REQUESTED IN
COMPLAINT:
VIII. RELATED CASE(S)
IF ANY
CHECK IF THIS IS A CLASS ACTION
UNDER F.R.C.P. 23
(See instructions):
DATE
CHECK YES only if demanded in complaint:
x Yes
No
JURY DEMAND:
DEMAND $
JUDGE
DOCKET NUMBER
SIGNATURE OF ATTORNEY OF RECORD
/s/ Christopher A. Mathews
July 27, 2011
FOR OFFICE USE ONLY
RECEIPT #
AMOUNT
APPLYING IFP
JUDGE
MAG. JUDGE
CSDJS44
]]>
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?
