Barr, et al v. Qwest Comm Intl Inc, et al
Filing
162
ORDER Allowing Non-Compliant Exclusion Requests and Confirming All Exclusions by Judge Wiley Y. Daniel on 01/11/13. (jjhsl, )
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO
Civil Action No.: 1:01-cv-00748-WYD-KLM
ROBERT C. BARR and BARBARA S. BARR,
LAMMCO PROPERTIES, LTD., a Colorado corporation,
KENNETH J. SCHWEIZER and ARLENE J. SCHWEIZER,
VINCENT J. POTESTIO and CAROL A. POTESTIO, and
ORIN LOOS, for themselves and on behalf of all others similarly situated,
Plaintiffs,
v.
QWEST COMMUNICATIONS COMPANY, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company,
SPRINT COMMUNICATIONS COMPANY L.P., a Delaware limited partnership,
LEVEL 3 COMMUNICATIONS, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company, and
WILTEL COMMUNICATIONS, LLC, a Delaware limited liability company,
Defendants.
ORDER ALLOWING NON-COMPLIANT EXCLUSION REQUESTS
AND CONFIRMING ALL EXCLUSIONS
Upon consideration of Plaintiffs’ Unopposed Motion to Allow Non-Compliant
Exclusion Requests (ECF No. 155) and for good cause shown, the motion is
GRANTED. It is hereby ORDERED that the following exclusions are allowed and that
each person listed below and all other persons who own or have owned a listed parcel
of property are excluded from the Settlement Class:
Property Owner
David S. Supperstein
David S. Supperstein
Mel Eskanos
Bruce A. & Katherine A.
Tenenbaum
Exclusion Requested By
David S. Supperstein
David S. Supperstein
David S. Supperstein
Bruce A. & Katherine A.
Tenenbaum
Tax Parcel ID
6418222008
6418222007
5606400014
146336000010
County
El Paso
El Paso
El Paso
Boulder
Property Owner
Richard S. & Jean F.
Hlasnicek
Kenneth E. Fetzer
Cordillera Corp.
Cordillera Corp.
Cordillera Corp.
Cordillera Corp.
Exclusion Requested By
Richard S. & Jean F.
Hlasnicek
Richard S. & Jean F.
Hlasnicek
Barton Brundage
Barton Brundage
Barton Brundage
Barton Brundage
Cordillera Corp.
Barton Brundage
Larkspur Prop.
Perry Park Water &
Sanitation Dist.
Joe Maskalenko
Joe Maskalenko
Tax Parcel ID
92038001026
County
Washington
92038001026
Washington
182135010015
182135010001
182135010014
018213400009
9
018213421600
2
260728200001
260728200001
Adams
Adams
Adams
Adams
Adams
Douglas
Douglas
It is further ORDERED that no further non-compliant exclusion requests will be
allowed, in the absence of a showing that the failure to comply with applicable exclusion
request requirements is beyond the control of the person seeking exclusion and that no
other person is prejudiced by the non-compliance.
It is further ORDERED that the persons listed in Exhibit B (“Colorado Exclusion
Requests,” attached hereto) to Plaintiffs’ Unopposed Motion to Allow Non-Compliant
Exclusion Requests and all other persons who own or have owned a listed parcel of
property are excluded from the Class.
Dated: January 11, 2013
BY THE COURT:
s/ Wiley Y. Daniel_________
Honorable Wiley Y. Daniel
Senior United States District Judge
-2-
EXHIBIT B
Property Owner
Donald E. & Marietta F. Chapman
Max & Marion Shivley
Max & Marion Shivley
Max & Marion Shivley
Marion & Marjorie Shivley LE
Marion & Marjorie Shivley LE
Marion & Marjorie Shivley c/o Max Shivley
Marion & Marjorie Shivley c/o Max Shivley
Marion & Marjorie Shivley c/o Max Shivley
Marion & Marjorie Shivley c/o Max Shivley
Mark & Max Shivley
Marion & Marjorie Shivley c/o Max Shivley
Marion & Marjorie Shivley c/o Max Shivley
Max Lee Shivley
Marie I. & Frank J. Sauer LE
David S. Supperstein
David S. Supperstein
Mel Eskanos
Randy & Sherri Schlegel
Nelson E. & Jeri W. Brown
Nelson E. & Jeri W. Brown
Nelson E. & Jeri W. Brown
Martha C. Hubert
Martha C. Hubert
Martha C. Hubert
Colorado Exclusion Requests
Exclusion Requested By
Donald E. & Marietta F. Chapman
Max, Marjorie, & Mark Shivley
Max, Marjorie, & Mark Shivley
Max, Marjorie, & Mark Shivley
Max, Marjorie, & Mark Shivley
Max, Marjorie, & Mark Shivley
Max, Marjorie, & Mark Shivley
Max, Marjorie, & Mark Shivley
Max, Marjorie, & Mark Shivley
Max, Marjorie, & Mark Shivley
Max, Marjorie, & Mark Shivley
Max, Marjorie, & Mark Shivley
Max, Marjorie, & Mark Shivley
Max, Marjorie, & Mark Shivley
Kenneth Sauer
David S. Supperstein
David S. Supperstein
David S. Supperstein
Randy & Sherri Schlegel
Nelson E. & Jeri W. Brown
Nelson E. & Jeri W. Brown
Nelson E. & Jeri W. Brown
Nelson E. & Jeri W. Brown
Nelson E. & Jeri W. Brown
Nelson E. & Jeri W. Brown
-1-
Tax Parcel ID
157508113002
W000042
W000042
W000043
W000042
W000042
W000037
W000037
W000037
W000037
W000040
W000042
W000042
W000043
096129223016
6418222008
6418222007
5606400014
168513400050
158127400363
158127400012
158127400362
158127400363
158127400012
158127400362
County
Boulder
Yuma
Yuma
Yuma
Yuma
Yuma
Yuma
Yuma
Yuma
Yuma
Yuma
Yuma
Yuma
Yuma
Weld
El Paso
El Paso
El Paso
Eagle
Gilpin
Gilpin
Gilpin
Gilpin
Gilpin
Gilpin
Property Owner
Bruce A. & Katherine A. Tenenbaum
Doris M. Brown, Trustee
Cargill Inc.
Excel Corp.
Weakland Investments LLC
Hill Industries LLC
Nellie P. Price Liv. Tr.
Nellie P. Price Liv. Tr.
Lobo LLC
Richard S. & Jean F. Hlasnicek
Kenneth E. Fetzer
Cordillera Corp.
Cordillera Corp.
Cordillera Corp.
Cordillera Corp.
Cordillera Corp.
Larkspur Prop.
Perry Park Water & Sanitation Dist.
Robert D. Cranwell
James E. & Pamela J. Bustamante
Miramonte Limited Liability Company
Miramonte LLC
Miramonte LLC
Suzanne M. Hillas
TRT NOIP E 28 Aurora LLC
Istar HQ I LP
Exclusion Requested By
Bruce A. & Katherine A. Tenenbaum
Douglas A. Brown, Trustee
Beth Huizinga, Paralegal
Beth Huizinga, Paralegal
Beth Huizinga, Paralegal
Beth Huizinga, Paralegal
Sterling Kenneth Price
Sterling Kenneth Price
Alan Gillan
Richard S. & Jean F. Hlasnicek
Richard S. & Jean F. Hlasnicek
Barton Brundage
Barton Brundage
Barton Brundage
Barton Brundage
Barton Brundage
Joe Maskalenko
Joe Maskalenko
Robert D. Cranwell
James E. & Pamela J. Bustamante
Arthur H. Bosworth II, Attorney
Arthur H. Bosworth II, Attorney
Arthur H. Bosworth II, Attorney
Arthur H. Bosworth II, Attorney
JJ Asarch
JJ Asarch
-2-
Tax Parcel ID
146336000010
158733301016
0224121007000
1229-050-00-028
0224121007000
1229-050-00-028
147105210007
147105210008
0182508211002
92038001026
92038001026
182135010015
182135010001
182135010014
0182134000099
0182134216002
260728200001
260728200001
147105217002
130932306013
157931000001
157931000001
157931000001
157931000001
0182128010010
0182128010010
County
Boulder
Grand
Denver
Morgan
Denver
Morgan
Weld
Weld
Adams
Washington
Washington
Adams
Adams
Adams
Adams
Adams
Douglas
Douglas
Weld
Weld
Boulder
Boulder
Boulder
Boulder
Adams
Adams
Property Owner
Badge LLC
Intermountain Rural Elec. Assoc.
Intermountain Rural Elec. Assoc.
Intermountain Rural Elec. Assoc.
Russell L. & Donna R. Skinner
Marilyn F. Eisele
Randall E. & Gena M. Muir
Gordon A. Paulsen as LF
Exclusion Requested By
Gerald Schramek
Amy M. Watson
Amy M. Watson
Amy M. Watson
Amy M. Watson
Marilyn F. Eisele
Randall E. Muir
Chris Paulsen
-3-
Tax Parcel ID
5531103001
250515000033
250503400005
250503400006
250515000033
250527000001
157932000061
29-251-11-017
County
El Paso
Douglas
Douglas
Douglas
Douglas
Douglas
Boulder
Jefferson
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?