SOLIDFX LLC v. Jeppesen Sanderson Inc

Filing 308

RULING on Objections to Deposition Designations, by Judge William J. Martinez on 4/3/2014. (evana, ) (Modified on 4/3/2014 edited the title of the text to reflect that this is a RULING)(evana, ).

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO
Judge William J. Martínez
Civil Action No. 11-cv-01468-WJM-BNB
SOLIDFX, LLC,
Plaintiff,
v.
JEPPESEN SANDERSON, INC.,
Defendant.

RULINGS ON OBJECTIONS TO DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS

This matter is before the Court on the parties’ deposition designations and
objections thereto. The objections to the following portions of the deposition
designations are SUSTAINED:
Page Number

Lines

Axel Friedrich, Ph.D
136

10-18 (including Exhibit 8)

137

1-18

138

1-18

161

2-22

162

1-22

163

1-22

164

1-22

165

1-22

166

1-22

167

1-12

315

2-22

316

1-20

Page Number

Lines

Michael D. Kolman
197

9-16

Lonne R. Lyon
244

16-18

245

4-8

Michelle Schopp
45

12-25 (including Exhibit 60)

46

1-25

47

1-25

48

1-25

49

1-3

57

4-25 (including Exhibit 63)

58

1-25

59

1-20

61

11-25

62

1-11

64

15-25

65

1-16

84

23-25 (including Exhibit 21)

85

1-25

86

1-25

87

1-11

89

1-5, 25

90

1-21 (including Exhibit 83)

96

14-25

97

1-6

139

18-25 (including Exhibit 173)

140

1-25

141

1-25

142

1-25

2

Page Number

Lines

Michelle Schopp (Con’t)
143

1-14

218

13-25 (including the portions of the email
exchange that consist of Ms. Schopp’s
statements or those of George Adams. Mr.
Elia’s statements are non-hearsay and may be
admissible if other portions are redacted.)

219

1-17

220

11-22

257

19-25 (including Exhibit 173)

258

1-24

Matthew T. Elia
207

5-21 (including the portions of the exhibit
containing statements from a non-party. Mr.
Elia’s statements are not hearsay)

208

1-22

209

1-4

210

7-22 (including the portions of the exhibit
containing statements from a non-party. Mr.
Elia’s and Ms. Flamme’s statements are not
hearsay and may be admissible with redaction.)

211

15-22

212

1-12

213

8-20

214

11-22 (including the portions of the exhibit
containing statements from a non-party. Mr.
Elia’s and Mr. McDonald’s statements are not
hearsay and may be admissible with redaction.)

215

1-22

216

1-22

217

1-3 (the portions of the exhibit containing
statements from a non-party. Mr. Elia’s
statements are not hearsay and may be
admissible with redaction.)

218

16-22
3

Page Number

Lines

Matthew T. Elia (Con’t)
219

1-9

The portions of the above-designated deposition testimony to which the Court
has sustained the objection should be redacted from the parties’ presentations.
Additionally, the parties are free to eliminate any other designations, or portions of
designations, that are no longer relevant and material to the issues to be tried, given the
Court’s rulings on the objections herein, or any other ruling or order entered by the
Court in this case.
All other objections to the testimony of the above-referenced deponents are
OVERRULED. Additionally, all objections to the deposition designations for Tyler N.
Snow, George John, Ph.D, and Christopher Tyson Weihs are OVERRULED.
Dated this 3rd day of April, 2014.
BY THE COURT:

William J. Martínez
United States District Judge

4