ZO Skin Health, Inc. v. Advanced Skin Care, LLC et al

Filing 20

ORDER GRANTING STIPULATED MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION #19 by Judge Marcia S. Krieger on 7/20/12.(msksec, )

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO
Honorable Marcia S. Krieger
Civil Action No. 12-cv-01584-MSK-MEH
ZO SKIN HEALTH, INC.,
Plaintiff,
v.
ADVANCED SKIN CARE, LLC; and
TARA K. SALZ,
Defendants.

ORDER GRANTING STIPULATED MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION

This matter comes before the Court pursuant to a Stipulated Motion for Preliminary
Injunction filed by Plaintiff, ZO Skin Health, Inc. (“ZO Skin Health”) and Defendants Advanced
Skin Care, LLC and Tara K. Salz (collectively, “Defendants”) (#19). Upon review of ZO Skin
Health’s Verified Complaint for Trademark Infringement and Jury Demand, and the Stipulated
Motion filed by the parties, the Court finds that, pursuant to Fed. R. Civ. P. 65, the Stipulated
Motion should be GRANTED.
The Court therefore orders that Defendants, and any employees, agents, servants, officers,
representatives, directors, attorneys, successors, affiliates, assigns, any and all other entities owned
or controlled by Defendants, and all of those in active concert and participation with Defendants (the
“Enjoined Parties”) are enjoined as follows:
i)

The Enjoined Parties are prohibited from advertising or selling, via the
Internet or otherwise, any and all ZO Skin Health products as well as any
products bearing any of the ZO Trademarks including, but not limited to, ZO,
Offects, Ossential, Ommerse, Oclipse, Olluminate, Oraser, Balatone,

Brightenex, Cebatrol, Glycogent, Melamin, Melamix, Normacleanse,
Oilacleanse, Retamax, and ZO Medical,
ii)

The Enjoined Parties are prohibited from using any of the ZO Trademarks
including, but not limited to, ZO, Offects, Ossential, Ommerse, Oclipse,
Olluminate, Oraser, Balatone, Brightenex, Cebatrol, Glycogent, Melamin,
Melamix, Normacleanse, Oilacleanse, Retamax, and ZO Medical in any
manner, including advertising on the Internet,

iii)

The Enjoined Parties are prohibited from importing, exporting,
manufacturing, producing, distributing, circulating, selling, offering to sell,
advertising, promoting, or displaying any and all ZO Skin Health products
as well as any products bearing any of the ZO Trademarks including, but not
limited to, ZO, Offects, Ossential, Ommerse, Oclipse, Olluminate, Oraser,
Balatone, Brightenex, Cebatrol, Glycogent, Melamin, Melamix,
Normacleanse, Oilacleanse, Retamax, and ZO Medical,

iv)

The Enjoined Parties are required to take all action to remove from the
Enjoined Parties’ websites any reference to any of ZO Skin Health’s
products, or any of the ZO Trademarks including, but not limited to, ZO,
Offects, Ossential, Ommerse, Oclipse, Olluminate, Oraser, Balatone,
Brightenex, Cebatrol, Glycogent, Melamin, Melamix, Normacleanse,
Oilacleanse, Retamax, and ZO Medical,

v)

The Enjoined Parties are required to take all action, including but not limited
to requesting removal from the Internet search engines (such as Google,
Yahoo!, and Bing), to remove from the Internet any of the ZO Trademarks
which associate ZO Skin Health’s products or the ZO Trademarks with the
Enjoined Parties or the Enjoined Parties’ websites,

vi)

The Enjoined Parties are required to take action all action to remove the ZO
Trademarks from the following URLs:
1. http://www.amazon.com/dp/B0082EN4RW/ref=asc_df_B0082EN4R
W2015489?smid=A172LZXPBCQCT9&tag=dealtmp992920&linkCode=asn&creative=395105&creativeASIN=B0082EN4RW
2. http://www.coolscent.com/100-3760911-B002O4AQ5OZO_Skin_Health_Ommerse_Overnight_Recovery_Creme.html
3. http://www.zimbio.com/Skin%2BCare/articles/1TMNbkIQKPN/ZO%
2BSkin%2BHealth%2BOmmerse%2BOvernight%2BRecovery
4. http://www.google.com/products?q=%22Zo+Skin+Health+Ommerse+

Overnight+Recovery+Creme%22&hl=en
5. http://healthcareinstantly.info/zo-skin-health-oraser-overnight-handrecovery/
6. http://shopping.yahoo.com/779590351-zo-skin-health-oraserovernight-hand-recovery/specs
7. http://www.shopping.com/zo-skin-health/products
8. http://relief2ouncebottles.likecheapnow.com/Skin-Health-OssentialDaily-Defense.html
9. http://www.bestcovery.com/zo-skin-health-ossential-daily-powerdefense
10. http://beauty3.reviews88.org/recent-zo-skin-health-ossential-dailypower-defense/
11. http://beauty2.reviews88.org/save-zo-skin-health-ossential-dailypower-defense/
12. http://trendylifes.com/zo-skin-health-ossential-daily-power-defense/
13. http://www.americanonlinehealth.com/zo-skin-health-ossentialgrowth-factor-serum.html
14. http://www.beautyshoppingonline.com/Cheap-ZO-Skin-HealthOssential-Growth-Factor-Serum
15. http://cheapprice151.bestcheappriceonsale.com/1-offer-for-zo-skinhealth-ossential-growth-factor-serum-sale/
16. http://www.amazon.com/ZO-Skin-Health-OSSENTIALRadical/dp/B003GENV8K
17. http://www.amazon.com/ZO-Health-Ommerse-OvernightRecovery/dp/B002O4AQ5O
18. http://www.amazon.com/Skin-Health-Oraser-OvernightRecovery/dp/B003H8FI2C%3FSubscriptionId%3DAKIAJ4FSUWQE
BDO7ZX3Q%26tag%3Dhealthcareins20%26linkCode%3Dxm2%26camp%3D2025%26creative%3D165953
%26creativeASIN%3DB003H8FI2C
19. http://violetandblueboutique.com/beauty-11055981-B003GENV8KZO_Skin_Health_OSSENTIAL_Radical_Night_Repair_Plus.html

20. http://www.mybargainbasement.net/index.php%3Fc%3Dbeauty%26n%3D11055981%26i%3
DB002O4FLYA%26x%3DZO_Skin_Health_Ossential_Growth_Facto
r_Serum
21. http://obagiclear3.us/2-11055981-B002O4FLYAZO_Skin_Health_Ossential_Growth_Factor_Serum.html
22. http://www.home-theatre.co/1-667846011-B002O4FLYAZO_Skin_Health_Ossential_Growth_Factor_Serum
23. http://www.makebeautylife.com/daily-defense-tinted-moisturizerspf30-unisex-32-oz.html
24. http://skillcare.freehostingnoads.net/%3Fp%3D142
25. http://hairsboston.com/shop%3Fpage%3D1%26SearchIndex%3DBeau
ty%26Brand%3D%253Catrix%26BrowseNode%3D11062591%26Mi
nimumPrice%3D5000%26MaximumPrice%3D10000
26. http://www.google.com/aclk?sa=L&ai=CoWNwLunZT72IJpS48ASzv
snrA7PtlLYBxZSu5RH7ka_JFAgAEAIoAlCrt87dBmDJvrmH4KO0E
JABCsgBAaoEHk_QsC6aazXf1gijVVM0SB63hRdSzRhqnVAKBTY
mMQ&sig=AOD64_3JLCrXSs3c3wDcta0f6K3TFdsyvg&adurl=http:/
/www.amazon.com/s/%3Fie%3DUTF8%26keywords%3Dzo%2Bskin
%2Bhealth%26tag%3Dgooghydr20%26index%3Daps%26hvadid%3D4686316727%26hvpos%3D10t2
%26hvexid%3D%26hvnetw%3Dg%26hvrand%3D212316714564576
4148%26hvpone%3D%26hvptwo%3D%26hvqmt%3Db%26ref%3Dp
d_sl_58wfz9lyu6_b
27. http://www.amazon.com/ZO-Health-Ommerse-OvernightRecovery/dp/B002O4AQ5O?SubscriptionId=AKIAIRVSV5PTMTT4
HXNA&tag=gifts-for-you20&linkCode=xm2&camp=2025&creative=165953&creativeASIN=B
002O4AQ5O
28. http://www.amazon.com/dp/B003H8FI2C/ref=asc_df_B003H8FI2C20
10464?smid=A172LZXPBCQCT9
29. http://www.amazon.com/Skin-Health-Ossential-DailyDefense/dp/B002O4BIM4%3FSubscriptionId%3DAKIAJ3LA3JWIFZ
VLEBOQ%26tag%3Dsandpp20%26linkCode%3Dxm2%26camp%3D2025%26creative%3D165953
%26creativeASIN%3DB002O4BIM4
30. http://www.amazon.com/Skin-Health-Ossential-Daily-

Defense/dp/B002O4BIM4%3FSubscriptionId%3D02B7Y8VZ2ZRE5
MXHPMR2%26tag%3Dbestcoverycom20%26linkCode%3Dxm2%26camp%3D2025%26creative%3D165953
%26creativeASIN%3DB002O4BIM4
31. http://www.amazon.com/Skin-Health-Ossential-DailyDefense/dp/B002O4BIM4%3FSubscriptionId%3DAKIAISYAKS2DB
2MS25WA%26tag%3Dhttpcheapsbco20%26linkCode%3Dxm2%26camp%3D2025%26creative%3D165953
%26creativeASIN%3DB002O4BIM4
32. http://www.amazon.com/Skin-Health-Ossential-DailyDefense/dp/B002O4BIM4%3FSubscriptionId%3DAKIAISYAKS2DB
2MS25WA%26tag%3Dhttpcheapsbco20%26linkCode%3Dxm2%26camp%3D2025%26creative%3D165953
%26creativeASIN%3DB002O4BIM4
33. http://www.amazon.com/Skin-Health-Ossential-DailyDefense/dp/B002O4BIM4%3FSubscriptionId%3DAKIAIHOSTEN7F
Y7EEIKQ%26tag%3Duaredoctorcom20%26linkCode%3Dxm2%26camp%3D2025%26creative%3D165953
%26creativeASIN%3DB002O4BIM4
34. http://www.amazon.com/Skin-Health-Ossential-GrowthFactor/dp/B002O4FLYA%3FSubscriptionId%3D02J54C6K23C6XSY
JEJG2%26tag%3Dwwwwebadrcom20%26linkCode%3Dxm2%26camp%3D2025%26creative%3D165953
%26creativeASIN%3DB002O4FLYA
35. http://www.amazon.com/dp/B002O4FLYA/?tag=facebeautycare-20
36. http://www.amazon.com/dp/B002O4FLYA?tag=savepriceapplynow20

vii)

As it is foreseeable that the above-referenced URLs and ZO Skin Health
products and the ZO Trademarks including, but not limited to, ZO, Offects,
Ossential, Ommerse, Oclipse, Olluminate, Oraser, Balatone, Brightenex,
Cebatrol, Glycogent, Melamin, Melamix, Normacleanse, Oilacleanse,
Retamax, and ZO Medical thereon will be referenced on additional webpages
in the future, including but not limited to index, directory, and search results
pages, that the Enjoined Parties are required to take all actions, including
requesting removal from the Internet search engines Google, Yahoo!, and
Bing, to remove all such webpages from the Internet, and

viii)

The Enjoined Parties are prohibited from disposing of, destroying, altering,

moving, removing, concealing, or tampering with any records related to any
products sold by them which contain the ZO Trademarks including invoices,
correspondence with vendors and distributors, bank records, account books,
financial statements, purchase contracts, sales receipts, and any other records
that would reflect the source of the products that Defendants sold bearing
these trademarks.
DATED this 20th day of July, 2012.

BY THE COURT:

Marcia S. Krieger
United States District Judge