McDonald et al v. Toyota Motor Corporation, a Japanese Corporation et al

Filing 26

PROTECTIVE ORDER by Magistrate Judge Kathleen M. Tafoya on 7/9/13. (sgrim)

Download PDF
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO Civil Action No. 1:13-cv-00704-RPM-KMT LESLIE MCDONALD, individually and as a parent and guardian of KELLEN MCDONALD; and KELLEN MCDONALD. a minor, by and through his parent and guardian LESLIE MCDONALD, Plaintiffs, v. TOYOTA MOTOR CORPORATION, a Japanese Corporation; TOYOTA MOTOR SALES U.S.A., INC., a California Corporation; and DOES 1-30, inclusive, Defendants. STIPULATED PROTECTIVE ORDER WHEREAS, Plaintiffs filed this action against Toyota Motor Corporation (“TMC”) and Toyota Motor Sales, U.S.A., Inc. (“TMS”) (collectively, the “Toyota Defendants”), and WHEREAS, the documents listed by Bates Number as Exhibit “One” are claimed by the Toyota Defendants to contain information that includes proprietary interests, trade secrets, and confidential commercial information, in addition to other information all of which provides the Toyota Defendants a competitive advantage that will be irretrievably lost if the information is acquired by competitors of the Toyota Defendants in the automotive industry and marketing business; WHEREAS, the documents listed by the Toyota Defendants in Exhibit “One” have been reviewed by counsel for Toyota, who certify that their enumeration here is based on a good faith belief that the information they contain is confidential or otherwise entitled to protection. WHEREAS, the Toyota Defendants may produce additional documents during the course of discovery in this case which the Toyota Defendants similarly claim to contain information that includes proprietary interests, trade secrets, and confidential commercial information, in addition to other information all of which provides the Toyota Defendants a competitive advantage that will be irretrievably lost if the information is acquired by competitors of the Toyota Defendants in the automotive industry and marketing business; WHEREAS, the Toyota Defendants desire to preserve the confidentiality of such information and prevent the information from being acquired by their competitors; WHEREAS, the documents listed by Bates Number as Exhibit “Two” are claimed by the Plaintiffs to contain information that includes personal medical and psychological information that if acquired by others could be used to harass, embarrass or cause other irreparable damage to Plaintiffs; WHEREAS, Plaintiffs may produce additional documents that contain information that includes personal medical records that if acquired by non-parties could be used to harass, embarrass, or cause other irreparable damage to Plaintiffs; WHEREAS, Plaintiffs desire to preserve the confidentiality of their personal medical and psychological information from being acquired by non-parties; and WHEREAS, the documents listed by the Plaintiffs in Exhibit “Two” have been reviewed by counsel for Plaintiffs, who certify that their enumeration here is based on a -2- good faith belief that the information they contain is confidential or otherwise entitled to protection. IT IS HEREBY STIPULATED that the Court may enter the following Stipulated Protective Order for those documents listed in Exhibit “One” and Exhibit “Two” and, which the Toyota Defendants subsequently add to Exhibit “One” and Plaintiffs subsequently add to Exhibit “Two,” and such other documents as may be produced in the course of discovery in this case that may include information that includes proprietary interests, trade secrets, and confidential commercial information or information that provides the Toyota Defendants with a competitive advantage and any personal medical and psychological information as may be disclosed or produced in the course of discovery or independently acquired by Toyota Defendants through HIPAA requests that could be used to harass, embarrass or otherwise harm Plaintiffs, provided that counsel for the respective parties first reviews the information and certifies that the enumeration of any such additional information is based upon a good faith belief that it is confidential or otherwise entitled to protection. IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT: 1. The term “confidential information” as used in this Stipulated Protective Order shall refer to those documents identified as “Confidential” or “Subject to Protective Order” as described below, and to the substance of any information obtained from such documents that are claimed by the Toyota Defendants to contain proprietary interests, trade secrets, and confidential commercial information, in addition to information that provides the Toyota Defendants a competitive advantage that will be irretrievably lost if the information is acquired by competitors of the Toyota Defendants, and any documents identified as “Confidential” or “Subject to Protective Order” as described below, and to the substance of any information obtained from such -3- documents that are claimed by Plaintiffs to contain personal medical or psychological information. 2. The documents protected by this Stipulated Protective Order have been designated by: (a) (b) 3. Typing, stamping or imprinting upon the document the following words: “CONFIDENTIAL” or “SUBJECT TO PROTECTIVE ORDER;” and Applying such in a manner so as not to obscure any information contained therein. All information and documents designated as confidential shall be accorded confidential status until such time as determined otherwise pursuant to the following provisions of the Stipulated Protective Order. 4. Any notes, lists, memoranda, indices, compilations, electronically stored information, reports, records and documents prepared or based on an examination of “confidential information” and any summaries of “confidential information,” which quote from, identify or refer to the “confidential information” with such specificity that the “confidential information” can be identified, or by reasonable logical extension can be identified, shall be accorded the same status of confidentiality as the underlying “confidential information” from which they are made and shall be subject to all of the terms of the Stipulated Protective Order. 5. All “confidential information” shall be used for this litigation, shall not be used for any business, commercial or competitive purposes, and shall not be used to harass, embarrass, or otherwise harm a Party’s privacy interests may be disclosed only to the following individuals or entities, and shall not be revealed, discussed or disclosed in any manner or in any form, to any person, entity or judicial tribunal other than: -4- (a) (b) Counsel with the law firms representing the parties; (c) An employee of counsel with the law firms representing the parties to whom it is necessary that the material be shown for purposes of litigation; and (d) 6. The Court and Court personnel including court reporters retained by the parties; Experts or professional advisors and persons regularly employed in their offices retained by a party to assist in the prosecution or defense of this action, but only to the extent necessary for such person to perform their assigned tasks in connection with this action. “Confidential information” shall not be shown or disclosed to persons described in paragraphs 5(b), 5(c), and 5(d) until that person shall be shown this Stipulated Protective Order and signs and dates a written agreement to be bound by the terms of this Stipulated Protective Order, which agreement shall be identical to that set forth in Appendix A of this Stipulated Protective Order. 7. The original and copies of the signed agreement(s) shall be maintained in the possession, custody and control of respective counsel for the parties who disclose discovery marked as Confidential to persons described in paragraphs 5(b), 5(c), and 5(d). The Parties will meet and confer if a party requests the other party to disclose such signed copies to them and if necessary may seek a Court Order requiring the withholding party to disclose such signed copies to them. 8. All persons who receive “confidential information” and/or material or information accorded the status of confidentiality in this action shall maintain the confidentiality of such material and information in accordance with the terms of this Stipulated Protective Order. -5- 9. Copies of discovery responses and documents containing “confidential information” shall not be filed with the Court, except in accordance with Paragraph 10 herein. 10. In the event that any document, deposition testimony, deposition exhibit, interrogatory, answer thereto, exhibit or attachment to an interrogatory or answer, request for production, answer to request for production, documents and/or exhibits accompanying a document request or answer, request for admission or response thereto, motion, memorandum, affidavit, brief or any other submission by any party is filed with the Court which includes, incorporates or quotes “confidential information,” such filings shall be submitted in sealed envelopes and other appropriate containers endorsed to the effect that they are sealed pursuant to this Stipulated Protective Order by reason of containing “confidential information” and shall be maintained under seal and not disclosed, except to the Court, except upon further Order of this Court. 11. To the extent that any “confidential information” is used in the taking of depositions, such “confidential information” shall remain subject to the provisions of this Stipulated Protective Order. At the time any “confidential information” is used in any deposition, counsel for the parties must inform the reporter of this Stipulated Protective Order. The reporter shall operate in a manner consistent with this Stipulated Protective Order and shall separately label the confidential portions of the deposition transcript, including documents and other exhibits containing confidential information. The confidential information shall be sealed and made part of the original deposition transcript, not any certified copies, and counsel for the Party or Parties claiming Confidentiality shall retain custody and control of the original transcript, or that portion of the original transcript referring to the confidential information and the sealed confidential documents. -6- 12. The Parties may designate depositions or other testimony concerning the documents and the information contained therein as “confidential information” by: (a) Stating orally on the record the day the testimony is given that the information is expected to be “confidential;” and, (b) Sending written notice designating by page and line the portions of the transcript of the deposition or other testimony to be treated as “Confidential,” within 10 days after receipt of the transcript. The reporter shall operate in a manner consistent with this Stipulated Protective Order and shall prepare a separate transcript containing the confidential portions of the deposition, including documents and other exhibits containing “confidential information,” and counsel for the Party or Parties claiming confidentiality shall maintain custody and control of that portion of the original transcript. Those pages in any transcript referring to confidential information shall include a stamp identifying all such pages as “confidential.” 13. Any party may apply to the Court for the imposition of further limitations upon the disclosure of specific information if such party deems further limitations are required in specific instances. Any party may apply to the Court for relief from limitations if such party deems such relief is required in specific instances. 14. Nothing in this Stipulated Protective Order shall prevent the Toyota Defendants from amending Exhibit “One” nor the Plaintiffs from amending Exhibit “Two” to identify additional documents that they have designated as confidential and will therefore be subject to the terms of this Stipulated Protective Order. 15. Nothing in this Stipulated Protective Order shall prevent any disclosure if the party designating the information as confidential consents to such disclosure. -7- 16. The execution of this Stipulated Protective Order shall not in any way detract from the right of a party to object to the production of discovery materials on grounds other than confidentiality. 17. Failure by a party to challenge the confidentiality of any document or information at the time of receipt thereof shall not preclude a subsequent challenge thereto. In the event a party to this litigation disagrees with the designation of any information as confidential, the parties shall attempt to dispose of such dispute in good faith on an informal basis. If the disagreement cannot be resolved in this fashion, the party contesting the confidentiality of the material may, by sealed motion setting forth with specificity the items challenged, seek an Order freeing the material in question from the designation as “confidential information.” The party asserting that documents or other tangible litigation materials constitute “confidential information” shall bear the burden of proof that the terms of this Stipulated Protective Order apply. Any information as to which such Motion is made shall remain “confidential information” under the provisions of this Stipulated Protective until further Order of the Court. 18. Nothing contained in this Stipulated Protective Order shall prevent a party to this action from using its own confidential information and material in any way that it sees fit, or from revealing its own confidential information and material to whomever it chooses, without prior consent of any person or of the Court. 19. After the conclusion of this litigation as to all parties, all “confidential information” and all copies thereof shall be either returned to counsel for the other Party, or destroyed by counsel for the other Party. In either event, counsel for the Parties shall execute and provide to counsel for the other Party an affidavit stating under oath that all “confidential information” and all copies thereof have either been destroyed or returned. Moreover, all such “confidential information” shall remain subject to the terms of this -8- Stipulated Protective Order, and the parties Stipulated to the continuation of jurisdiction and venue of this Court to resolve any disputes arising from the treatment or disposition of “confidential information” after conclusion of this litigation. 20. This Stipulated Protective Order shall not be abrogated, modified, amended or enlarged except by agreement of the parties or by Motion, with notice given to each of the parties. 21. Nothing contained herein shall restrict the presentation of any evidence, including “Confidential Information,” to a jury or the Court during a trial or other hearing of this action. However, such presentation shall not constitute a waiver of any restrictions provided for in this Stipulated Protective Order and the parties agree to take reasonable steps to maintain the confidentiality of any “confidential information” at any hearing or upon trial of this matter in such a manner and until such time as the Court may direct and/or as the parties may otherwise agree. Before any such presentation of “confidential information,” the presenting Party shall provide the other Party with appropriate notice so that the Party claiming confidentiality may have the opportunity to lodge appropriate objections or seek the Court’s direction to prevent disclosure of the “confidential information.” SO ORDERED, this 9th day of July, 2013. __________________________________ U.S. Magistrate Judge -9- STIPULATED TO AND AGREED: Date: July 8, 2013 Date: July 8, 2013 s/ Richard J. Hood Richard J. Hood Andrus, Hood & Wagstaff, P.C. 1999 Broadway, Suite 4150 Denver, CO 80202 Telephone: 303.376.6360 rjh@ahw-law.com s/ Stephen E. Oertle John R. Trigg Edward C. Stewart Stephen E. Oertle Wheeler Trigg O’Donnell LLP 370 Seventeenth Street, Suite 4500 Denver, CO 80202 Telephone: 303.244.1800 trigg@wtotrial.com stewart@wtotrial.com oertle@wtotrial.com Attorney for Plaintiffs Leslie and Kellen McDonald Attorneys for Defendants Toyota Motor Corporation and Toyota Motor Sales U.S.A., Inc. - 10 - IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO Civil Action No. 1:13-cv-00704-RM-KMT LESLIE MCDONALD, individually and as a parent and guardian of KELLEN MCDONALD; and KELLEN MCDONALD. a minor, by and through his parent and guardian LESLIE MCDONALD, Plaintiffs, v. TOYOTA MOTOR CORPORATION, a Japanese Corporation; TOYOTA MOTOR SALES U.S.A., INC., a California Corporation; and DOES 1-30, inclusive, Defendants. APPENDIX A TO STIPULATED PROTECTIVE ORDER I, ___________________________________________________, certify that I have read the Stipulated Protective Order dated _____________, entered in the abovecaptioned action and further certify that I fully understand the procedural and substantive requirements of that Stipulated Protective Order, a copy of which is attached hereto. Before reviewing or receiving access to any document, material, information and/or discovery subject to the protection of that Stipulated Protective Order and as a condition for such review and/or access, I understand and agree that I am personally bound by and subject to all of the terms and provisions of the Stipulated Protective Order. I subject myself to the jurisdiction and venue of said the U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado for purposes of enforcement of the Stipulated Protective Order. ___________________________________ (signature) ___________________________________ (print name) Sworn to and subscribed before me this day of , 2013. ___________________________________ Notary Public EXHIBIT “ONE” Documents Produced by Defendants Subject to a Stipulated Protective Order (A) Frame sub-assembly drawings applicable to the 2007-2012 U.S. bound F.J. Cruiser, and Engineering Change Instruction (ECI) sheets mentioned in those drawings. Part No. Document Description Bates Nos. 51001-35A00-C FRAME SUB-ASSY MY 2007-2010 FRAME SUB-ASSY MY 2010 FRAME SUB-ASSY MY 2010-2011 FRAME SUB-ASSY MY 2011-2012 828213 51001-35A70 51001-35A70-D 51001-35A71-B 828214 828215 828216 ECI No. Bates Nos. 244WF1808 327WF0120 327WF0473 327WF0551 327WF0578 327WF0661 493WF0032 493WF0095 493WF0240 493WF0242 493WF0295 460780-460790 828531-828536 599674-599755 828537-828544 828545-828551 828560-828565 828552-828559 828566-828574 828590-828597 828575-828581 828582-828589 (B) Rear drive shaft drawings applicable to the 2007-2012 U.S. bound F.J. Cruiser, and ECI sheets mentioned in those drawings. Part No. Document Description Bates Nos. 00421-60029-A ASSY DRAWING, RR AXLE MY 2007-2010 181294-181294A 00421-60033 00421-60033-A 00421-60033-B 00421-60033-C 00421-60033-D 00421-60033-F ASSY DRAWING, RR AXLE MY 2010 ASSY DRAWING, RR AXLE MY 2010-2011 ASSY DRAWING, RR AXLE MY 2011 ASSY DRAWING, RR AXLE MY 2011-2012 ASSY DRAWING, RR AXLE MY 2012 ASSY DRAWING, RR AXLE MY 2012 828239 828240 828241 828242 828243 828244 ECI No. Bates Nos. 244WF0363 244WF0482 243WF0313 244WF0580 244WF0883 244WF1896 327WF0055 327WF0294 445WF1613 445WF2732 445WF3116 445WF3254 445WFV004 445WS0023 828427-828428 828429-828430 828431-828432 828433-828435 460937 460940-460945 460964-460971 460972-460978 828439-828445 651807-651812 828458-828463 828464-828512 828446-828457 828436-828438 (C) Assembly drawings applicable to the fuel system (including the fuel tank, fuel line, fuel tank protector, fuel pressure regulator, fuel pulse damper, fuel injector, canister, filler pipe, and fuel filler neck and cap) of the 2007-2012 U.S. bound F.J. Cruiser, and ECI sheets mentioned in those drawings. Part No. Document Description Bates Nos. 23209-31010-B INJECTOR SET, FUEL MY 2007 754953 23209-31010-C 23209-31060-A 23209-31060-B 23209-31100 23270-31010 23270-31010-A 23270-31080 23270-31080 23280-31010-B 23280-31010-C 23280-31050-A 23280-31051 23807-31010-D 23807-31010-F 23807-31120 77020-35120-B 77020-35121 77020-35121-B 77020-35170 77020-35171 77100-35A30 77100-35A30 INJECTOR SET, FUEL MY 2007-2012 INJECTOR SET, FUEL MY 2007 INJECTOR SET, FUEL MY 2007-2010 INJECTOR SET, FUEL MY 2010-2012 DAMPER ASSY, FUEL PRESSURE PULSATION MY 2007 DAMPER ASSY, FUEL PRESSURE PULSATION MY 2007-2010 DAMPER ASSY, FUEL PRESSURE PULSATION MY 2010 DAMPER ASSY, FUEL PRESSURE PULSATION MY 2010-2012 (drawing reproduction) REGULATOR ASSY, FUEL PRESSURE MY 2007-2008 REGULATOR ASSY, FUEL PRESSURE MY 2008-2010 REGULATOR ASSY, FUEL PRESSURE MY 2010-2012 REGULATOR ASSY, FUEL PRESSURE MY 2012 PIPE SUB-ASSY, FUEL DELIVERY MY 2007 PIPE SUB-ASSY, FUEL DELIVERY MY 2007-2012 PIPE SUB-ASSY, FUEL DELIVERY MY 2007-2012 TUBE ASSY, FUEL SUCTION W/PUMP & GAGE, MY 2007 TUBE ASSY, FUEL SUCTION W/PUMP & GAGE, MY 2007-2008 TUBE ASSY, FUEL SUCTION W/PUMP & GAGE, MY 2008-2010 TUBE ASSY, FUEL SUCTION W/PUMP & GAGE, MY 2010-2012 TUBE ASSY, FUEL SUCTION W/PUMP & GAGE, MY 2012 TANK ASSY, FUEL MY 2010 TANK ASSY, FUEL MY 2010 (drawing reproduction) 738020 754954 754955 707602 754956 754957 707604 707605 828247 828248 828249 828250 828235-828236 828237-828238 707607-707608 828258-828259 828260-828261 828262-828263 828264-828266 828267-828269 828276-828278 828279-828281 77100-35A30-A 77100-35A30-C 77100-35A30-C 77100-35A30-D 77100-3S350-B 77100-3S350-C 77200-35070 77200-35130 77210-35040-A 77300-52040-B 77300-52040-C 77300-52040-D 77300-52040-F 77300-52040-G 77300-52040-H 77300-52040-J 77300-52040-K 77300-52040-M 77606-35070-D 77643-35050-A 77740-35530 77740-35530-A TANK ASSY, FUEL MY 2010 TANK ASSY, FUEL MY 2010 TANK ASSY, FUEL MY 2010-2012 TANK ASSY, FUEL MY 2012 TANK ASSY, FUEL MY 2007 TANK ASSY, FUEL MY 2007-2009 TUBE ASSY, FUEL W/CLAMP MY 2007-2010 TUBE ASSY, FUEL W/CLAMP MY 2010-2012 PIPE ASSY, FUEL TANK FILLER MY 2007-2012 CAP ASSY, FUEL TANK W/TETHER MY 2007 CAP ASSY, FUEL TANK W/TETHER MY 2007 CAP ASSY, FUEL TANK W/TETHER MY 2007-2008 CAP ASSY, FUEL TANK W/TETHER MY 2008-2010 CAP ASSY, FUEL TANK W/TETHER MY 2010 CAP ASSY, FUEL TANK W/TETHER MY 2010-2011 CAP ASSY, FUEL TANK W/TETHER MY 2011 CAP ASSY, FUEL TANK W/TETHER MY 2011-2012 CAP ASSY, FUEL TANK W/TETHER MY 2012 PROTECTOR SUB-ASSY, FUEL TANK MY 2007-2012 PROTECTOR, FUEL TANK, NO. 3 MY 2007-2012 CANISTER ASSY, CHARCOAL MY 2007-2010 CANISTER ASSY, CHARCOAL MY 2010-2011 828282-828284 828285-828287 828288-828290 828291-828293 828270-828272 828273-828275 828294 828295 828296 828217-828218 828219-828220 828221-828222 828223-828224 828225-828226 828227-828228 828229-828230 828231-828232 828233-828234 828297 828298 738096 738097 77740-35531 CANISTER ASSY, CHARCOAL MY 2011-2012 828299 ECI No. Bates Nos. 000GF9BMD 000GF9BRS 000GF9CJ3 000GF9CQF 000GF9CUR 000GF9D46 000GF9DR1 000GF9DUG 000GF9E38 000GF9EMT 000GF9GZ9 000GF9HDM 000GF9HDN 045YF0002 045YF0018 045YF0067 045YF0069 045YF0079 045YF0102 045YF0179 045YF0272 045YF0333 045YF0345 045YF0420 045YF0563 045YS0002 056YF0040 056YF0093 244WF1697 244WF2651 299WF1095 299WF1262 315WF2474 327WF0065 327WF0094 327WF0096 767108-767132 828741-828755 828324-828341 828928-828946 738260-738271 707735-707743 721802-721829 828764-828772 828773-828780 828349-828360 828385-828393 828394-828414 828415-828426 755149-755149 755150 755151 828523-828524 755152-755153 738297-738298 755154-755166 755167-755173 707744-707777 707691-707696 828525-828530 754927-754934 738299 755175-755226 707778-707786 738812-738818 738840-738845 828317-828323 828342-828348 828300-828316 828887-828892 828893-828898 828961-828968 327WF0102 327WF0183 327WF0224 327WF0342 327WF0545 327WF0582 327WF0605 327WF0643 327WF0649 327WR0003 327WR0010 327WR0019 327WS0011 405WF2207 432WF2057 432WF2774 445WF2053 445WF2537 493WF0208 493WF0266 493WF0285 493WF0300 493WF0306 493WF0310 493WH0020 828905-828910 738887-738893 828756-828763 828911-828916 828781-828801 828817-828823 828899-828904 828824-828829 828830-828835 828811-828816 828947-828953 828954-828960 828728-828740 828969-828976 828361-828372 828373-828384 685288-685296 685335-685340 828836-828856 828857-828865 828866-828880 828917-828926 828802-828810 828881-828886 828927 (D) Floor assembly and main body welding drawings applicable to the 2007-2012 U.S. bound F.J. Cruiser and ECI sheets mentioned in those drawings. Part No. Document Description Bates Nos. 00580-35009-C INSTRUCTION DRAWING, MAIN BODY WELDING, MY 2007-2008 INSTRUCTION DRAWING, MAIN BODY WELDING, MY 2008-2010 INSTRUCTION DRAWING, MAIN BODY WELDING, MY 2010-2011 INSTRUCTION DRAWING, MAIN BODY WELDING, MY 2011-2012 INSTRUCTION DRAWING, MAIN BODY WELDING, MY 2012 INSTRUCTION DRAWING, SIDE PANEL WELDING, MY 2007-2008 574292-574293 00580-35010 00580-35010-B 00580-35012-B 00580-35012-C 00610-35010-L 574294-574295 574296-574297 652080-652081 828245-828246 574298-574300 00610-35012 57012-35080 57012-35081 57012-35082 58101-3G210 58101-3G210-C 58101-3G210-F 58101-3G210-H INSTRUCTION DRAWING, SIDE PANEL WELDING, MY 2008-2012 BODY SUB-ASSY, UNDER, RR MY 2007-2012 BODY SUB-ASSY, UNDER, RR MY 2010 BODY SUB-ASSY, UNDER, RR MY 2012 PAN SUB-ASSY, FR FLOOR MY 2007-2009 PAN SUB-ASSY, FR FLOOR MY 2009-2010 PAN SUB-ASSY, FR FLOOR MY 2010-2011 PAN SUB-ASSY, FR FLOOR MY 2011-2012 574301-574303 828255 828256 828257 828251 828252 828253 828254 ECI No. Bates Nos. 327WP0209 327WP0232 327WP0250 327WP0372 327WP0374 327WP0529 327WP0990 327WP0995 327WP1067 327WP1331 327WP1367 327WP1607 327WP1709 327WP1747 327WP1780 327WP1790 327WP1848 327WP1862 327WP1887 327WP1930 327WRP019 327WRP254 573505 828651-828658 573407 828659-828670 828598-828605 573408 828606-828612 573491-573497 828671-828679 828680-828686 828687-828693 573409-573470 828613-828620 828621-828631 828694-828700 828710-828718 573471-573479 828632-828639 573480-573490 828701-828709 573506-573514 573498-573504 327WSP004 493WP0156 493WP0206 493WP0387 493WP0489 493WPV029 493WSP007 573699 820709-820731 651816-651824 828640-828650 828513-828522 828719-828727 651813-651815 (E) Relevant crash test reports applicable to the 2007-2012 U.S. bound F.J. Cruiser. Document Description Model Year Bates Nos. Test Report No. RRMS-051021 155L 35mph Frontal Collision Test (AM50 w/belt) FMVSS 204, 208, 212, 219 and 301 Video 2007-2012 573815-573840 J 600496-600521 E Test Report No. RRMS-051022 155L 25mph Frontal Collision Test (AM50 w/o belt; FMVSS 208 Video 2007-2012 Test Report No. RRMS-051025 155L 30mph Frontal Collision Test (AF05 w/belt); FMVSS 208 Video 2007-2011 Test Report No. RRMS-051027 155L 25mph Frontal Collision Test (AF05 w/o belt); FMVSS 208 Video 2007-2012 Test Report No. RRMS-091005 35mph head-on (FMVSS 301) Video 2010-2010 Test Report No. RRMS-101001 35mph head-on (FMVSS 208, 212, 219) 2011-2012 HEAD ON 575704 573841-573863 J 600522-600544 E 575705 573910-573934 J 600591-600615 E 575708 573960-573982 J 600641-600663 E 575709 651963-651980 J 652059 651907-651934 J Video Test Report No. RRMS-101003 30mph head-on (FMVSS 208) Video 652057 2011-2012 651935-651962 J 652058 RIGHT OBLIQUE Test Report No. RRMS-051023 155L 25mph Right Oblique Collision Test (AM50 w/o belt) FMVSS 208 Video 2007-2012 Test Report No. RRMS-051032 155L 30mph Right Oblique Collision Test (AM50 w/belt); FMVSS 301 Video 2007-2009 Test Report No. RRMS-091004 30mph right oblique (FMVSS 301) Video 2010-2012 573864-573886 J 600545-600567 E 575706 574000-574016 J 600681-600697 E 575711 651997-652014 J 652061 LEFT OBLIQUE Test Report No. RRMS-051024 155L 25mph Left Oblique Collision Test (AM50 w/o belt) FMVSS 208 Video 2007-2012 573887-573909 J 600568-600590 E Test Report No. RRMS-051031 155L 30mph Left Oblique Collision Test (AM50 w/belt); FMVSS 301 2007-2009 573983-573999 J 600664-600680 E Test Report No. RRMS-091003 30mph left oblique (FMVSS 301) Video 2010-2012 651981-651996 J 575707 652060 OFFSET Test Report No. RRMS-051026 155L 25mph Left Offset Frontal Deformable Barrier Test (AF05 w/belt); FMVSS 208 2007-2012 573935-573959 J 600616-600640 E Test Report No. RRMS-051029 155L 40mph Left Offset Frontal Deformable Barrier Test Video 2007-2010 575715-575745 J 600465-600495 E Test Report No. RRMS-101007 40mph ODB Video 2011-2012 575710 651872-651906 J 652056 LINCAP Test Report No. RRMS-052005 LINCAP Right Side Collision Test on 155L (Non-SIAB specification, Passenger side) Video 2007-2012 Test Report No. RRMS-052006 LINCAP Left Side Collision Test on 155L (SIAB specification, driver side) Video 2007-2012 574082-574155 J 600763-600836 E 850672-850676 574017-574081 J 600698-600762 E 575712 Car to Car Rear-End Test Report No. RRMS-052015 155L 55mph Left Side 70% Overlap Rear-end Collision Test (FMVSS 301) Video 2007-2012 829226-829233 J 829234-829241 E 829409-829412 SENSOR ON/OFF Test Report No. RRMS-051034 155L Airbag Sensor (ON/OFF, Lo/Hi) Confirmation Test (low speed frontal) 2007-2012 829120-829172 J 829173-829225 E Video 829396-829408 (F) Documents related to Failure Mode and Effect Analysis applicable to the frame sub assembly, rear drive shaft, main body welding, floor assembly and fuel system (including the fuel tank, fuel line, fuel tank protector, fuel pressure regulator, fuel pulse damper, fuel injector, canister, filler pipe, and fuel filler neck and cap) of the 2007-2012 U.S. bound F.J. Cruiser. Document Description Bates Nos. 155L 64km/h ODB Frontal Collision Formal Genzu Drawing Model Ability Confirmation 827325-827376 155L 64km/h ODB RrFloor × RockerInner SPOT Breaking Countermeasure 827377-827456 155L 64km/h ODB Frontal Collision 827457-827499 Untitled 827500-827543 Examination of the Possibility of Base Material Breaking 827544-827589 Regarding 155L SE ODB Frontal Collision 827590-827638 Untitled 827639-827654 Displacement Rank Graph 827655-827696 Side View of Vehicle Deformation Drawing 827697-827758 Untitled 827759-827807 155L 64km/h ODB Frontal Collision Countermeasure Examination Meeting Hondout 827808-827822 AS CAE Genzu Drawing 2 Corner Countermeasure Calculation Result 827823-827856 AS CAE Genzu Drawing First Calculation Result 827857-827895 Comparison to Test and Calculation 827896-827935 155L ODB Rapid Report 827936-827966 Examination of the 2 Corner Part Using Cut Model 827967-828031 155L CAE Genzu Drawing 828032-828075 155L 64km/h ODB Belt Line Reinforcement Effect Examination 828076-828124 155L 64km/h ODB Frontal Collision Analysis 828125-828164 155L ODB Rocker ME Examination 828165-828174 155L 64km/h ODB Frontal Collision Formal Genzu Drawing Model Ability Confirmation 828175-828179 Untitled 828180-828183 Side View of Vehicle Deformation Drawing 828184-828212 EXHIBIT “TWO” Documents Produced by Plaintiffs Subject to a Stipulated Protective Order 1. “McDonald – 000194 through 000286” – Kellen McDonald medical records from University of Utah Hospital. 2. “McDonald – 000287 through 001271” – Kellen McDonald medical records from Children’s Hospital. 3. “McDonald – 001272 through 001341” – Kellen McDonald plastic surgery records from Dr. Elliott Rose. 4. “McDonald – 001342 through 001354” – Kellen McDonald therapy records from Dr. Robert Tinker. 5. “McDonald – 001355 through 001433” – Leslie McDonald San Juan Regional Medical Center records. 6. “McDonald – 001434 through 001444” – Leslie McDonald University of Colorado Hospital records. 7. “McDonald – 001445 through 001725” – Billing Records and Expenses.

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?