Personalized User Model LLP v. Google Inc.

Filing 600

EXHIBIT re 588 Proposed Pretrial Order -- Revised Exhibit 9 to the [Proposed] Pretrial Order -- by Personalized User Model LLP, Konig Yochai. (Murphy, Regina)

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE
PERSONALIZED USER MODEL, L.L.P.,

)
)
Plaintiff,
)
)
v.
)
)
GOOGLE, INC.,
)
)
Defendant.
)
______________________________________ )
GOOGLE, INC.,
)
)
Counterclaimant,
)
)
v.
)
)
PERSONALIZED USER MODEL, L.L.P.
)
and YOCHAI KONIG,
)
)
Counterclaim-Defendants.
)

C.A. No. 09-525 (LPS)

REVISED EXHIBIT 9 TO
THE [PROPOSED] FINAL PRETRIAL ORDER
MORRIS, NICHOLS, ARSHT & TUNNELL LLP
Karen Jacobs (#2881)
Jeremy A. Tigan (#5239)
Regina Murphy (#5648)
1201 N. Market Street
P.O. Box 1347
Wilmington, DE 19899-1347
[phone]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
OF COUNSEL:
Marc S. Friedman
DENTONS US LLP
1221 Avenue of the Americas
New York, NY 10020-1089

POTTER ANDERSON & CORROON LLP
Richard L. Horwitz (#2246)
David E. Moore (#3983)
Hercules Plaza, 6th Floor
1313 N. Market Street
Wilmington, DE 19801
[phone]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]

Mark C. Nelson
Steven M. Geiszler
Richard D. Salgado
DENTONS US LLP
2000 McKinney Avenue, Suite 1900
Dallas, TX 75201
Jennifer D. Bennett
DENTONS US LLP
1530 Page Mill Road, Ste. 200
Palo Alto, CA 94304-1125
Andrew M. Grodin
DENTONS US LLP
101 JFK Parkway
Short Hills, NJ 07078-2708
Attorneys for Personalized User Model, L.L.P.
and Yochai Konig
February 25, 2014

OF COUNSEL:
Charles K. Verhoeven
David A. Perlson
Joshua Lee Sohn
Antonio R. Sistos
Margaret Pirnir Kammerud
QUINN EMANUEL URQUHART &
SULLIVAN, LLP
50 California St.
San Francisco, CA 94111
Andrea Pallios Roberts
QUINN EMANUEL URQUHART &
SULLIVAN, LLP
555 Twin Dolphin Drive, Suite 560
Redwood Shores, CA 94065
Attorneys for Defendant Google, Inc.

EXHIBIT 9
GOOGLE’S DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS
Google hereby submits its deposition designations with PUM’s objections and counter designations thereto, Google’s
objections to such counter designations and counter-counter designations thereto, and PUM’s objections to such counter-counter
designations.
The parties incorporate by reference designations of any errata pertinent to the excerpts of the deposition transcripts designated
by Google, or counter designated by PUM.
PUM’s objections are identified with the following abbreviations:
PUM Objections
R

Relevance: The exhibit/statement is objectionable because it is not relevant and/or any probative value it may have is
substantially outweighed by the danger of unfair prejudice, or confusion of the issues, or by considerations of undue
delay, waste of time, or needless presentation of cumulative evidence (see F.R.E. 401, 402, 403)

ND

Not disclosed: The exhibit is objectionable because it was not timely disclosed by Google

H

Hearsay: The exhibit/statement is objectionable as hearsay if offered to prove the truth of the matter asserted (see
F.R.E. 801, 802 )

A

Authentication: The exhibit may be objectionable if it is not properly authenticated (see F.R.E. 901(a))

IC

Improper Compilation: The exhibit is an improper compilation of documents that do not belong together

M

Mischaracterization: The description of this document on Google’s exhibit list mischaracterizes the document

D

Duplicate: The exhibit appears more than once on Google’s exhibit list

LF

Lack of Foundation: The exhibit/statement is objectionable as insufficient foundation or lack of personal knowledge has
been laid (see F.R.E. 602, 901)

UP

Unfair Prejudice

SW

No Sponsoring Witness (See FRE 602)

NC

Not Complete: The exhibit is objectionable because it is incomplete and the introduction of the remaining portions or
related documents ought, in fairness, to be considered contemporaneously with it (see F.R.E. 106) (exhibit appears to be
an incomplete document and/or missing pages)
DEPOSITION OBJECTIONS

ARG.

Argumentative

A&A

Asked and Answered

Att Col Attorney Colloquy or Objection
B/S

Beyond the Scope of the topics for which the corporate witness was designated

BE

Best Evidence

C

Outside the scope of the witness’ Competence or Expertise

2

C/S

Evidence of a Compromise or Settlement

CMP

Completeness

CNF

Confusion of Issues

FNE

Assumes Facts Not in Evidence

F

Form

L

Leading

LC

Calls for Legal Conclusion

MIS

Misleading

MPT

Mischaracterizes Prior Testimony

N

Narrative Question

OB

Overly Broad

P

Privilege

RPT

Repetitive

S

Speculative

UFP

Unfair Prejudice

V/A

Vague or Ambiguous

3

WP

Work Product

Google’s objections are identified with the following abbreviations:
General Objections:

Form Objections:

R – Relevance, 402

L – Leading

P – Fed. R. Evid. 403: Prejudicial

ARG – Argumentative

H – Hearsay

A – Assuming Facts Not in Evidence

F – Lacks Foundation

C – Compound

I – Incomplete

N – Narratives

V – Vague and ambiguous

M – Misstates Testimony

S – Beyond the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) deposition
topics

AA—Asked and Answered

LC – Legal Conclusion
ET – calls for expert testimony
MIS – misleading
IC – improper counter
NR – non-responsive
IH – incomplete hypothetical

4

SP – speculation
SN – Fed. R. Evid. 408, Settlement Negotiations

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

Aspitz, Doron

06/10/2011

3:10-15
5:4-9
5:19-6:1
6:12-7:11
11:18-22
12:16-13:5
13:18-14:3
17:10-19
19:9-11
22:15-19
23:2-4

PUM's
Objections

PUM's
Counter
Designations

R; L
R; L
R; VA; CMP;
UFP

5:10-18
6:2-11
7:12-14

R; VA; CNF;
S
R; FNE; UFP;
N
R; CNF
R; CNF
R; CNF; FNE;
CMP
R; CNF; FNE;
CMP

13:6-12

5

22:20-23:1
22:20-23:1

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

PUM's
Counter
Designations

26:3-19

R; CMP; LC;
UFP; N; F;
CNF; L; C;
OB; UFP
R; CMP; LC;
UFP; N; F;
CNF; L; C;
OB; UFP
R; CNF; OB;
UFP
R; UFP; CNF;
S; VA
R; CNF; L;
UFP
R; CMP; S;
CNF;
R
R; UFP
R; UFP; CNF
R; UFP; L;
CNF
R; UFP; CMP
R; UFP; CNF
R; UFP; VA
R; UFP; VA;
S

27:13-20

26:22-24

27:1-7
29:10-20
30:8-16
39:7-15
40:10-11
40:24-41:10
41:13-25
43:7-10
43:20-44:1
44:5-45:2
58:2-7
58:13-19

6

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

27:13-20

27:13-20
28:15-21

P

30:20-31:7

IC, R

43:11-44:4

58:22-59:3

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

60:18-61:7

R; UFP; CNF;
L

62:8-12
64:6-66:12
66:25-67:9
69:3-8
75:12-14
75:18-76:12
97:10-13
97:18-98:8
98:13-17
103:15-23
104:2-17

Benquessous
(Banks), Jack

06/07/2011

108:25-109:6
5:9-12
8:11-19
16:18-22
17:2-13

PUM's
Counter
Designations

R; S; CNF;
UFP
R; S; UFP;
CNF
R; L; CNF;
UFP

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

67:10-22
67:10-22

R; S; L; FNE;
UFP

76:13-22

IC, R

R; S; L; UFP
R; UFP; CNF
R; C; S; FNE;
CNF; VA
R; C; S; FNE;
CNF; VA;
UFP
R; L; UFP

98:9-12

IC, R

R; LF; S;
UFP; C
R; UFP; CNF
R; UFP

20:4-7

IC, R, P

7

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

18:2-10

R; UFP; S;
LF; C
R; S
R; S; FNE;
UFP; CNF; C
R; S; FNE;
UFP
R; S; UFP;
RPT
R; A; UFP;
CNF
R; RPT
R; UFP
R; UFP; CNF;
S
R; UNF

20:4-7

IC, R, P

20:8-24
23:12-24:10
30:3-25
31:4-11
35:1-13
35:23-25
39:19-25
40:23-41:12
48:1-2
53:22-54:2
54:8-18
54:20-21
54:24-25
58:3-7
58:10-11
58:18-19

31:1-3; 92:515

R; LF; A
R; UFP; V/A;
S
R; UFP; S
8

IC, R, P

55:1-55:12;
92:25-94:2
55:1-55:12;
92:25-94:2

R; UFP; F;
MPT
R; UFP; F;
MPT
R; UNF;

20:4-7

IC, R
IC, R

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

60:8-60:13
61:8-15

R; CNF
R; UFP; CNF;
S; C
R; UFP; CNF;
L; S; C
R; UFP; L
R; UFP; S; L
R; S; C; LF;
UFP
R; S; LF; C;
UFP
R; A; F; UFP;
S;
R; UFP

62:8-13
63:13-17
65:17-20
67:6-68:7
68:11-24
71:20-73:2
73:11-16
74:2-75:5
76:16-22
77:21-25
89:23-90:17

Bercow,
Douglas

04/14/2011

92:17-24
8:8-10
15:1-20

PUM's
Counter
Designations

R; UFP; S;
V/A
R; UFP; V/A
R; V/A; S; C;
UFP
R; UFP

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

61:16-21;
62:23-63:2
62:23-63:2;
92:25-94:2

IC, R, I, P

62:23-63:2

IC, R, I, P

73:8-10;
91:11-23
73:8-10;
91:11-23

89:20-22;
90:18-23;
91:2-4
92:5-15

R; UFP; CNF

9

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

63:3-8

R, UFP, C,
LF

90:24-91:1,

R, IC

IC, R

R

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

PUM's
Counter
Designations

19:7-20

MIS, CMP,
CNF. UFP

22:9-15
26:5-9
52:25-53:9

CMP
CMP
MIS, CMP

26:20-27:10;
31:4-32:5;
35:14-36:18;
37:18-40:1;
38:2-8; 39:1340:1
22:21-25
25:22-27:10
31:4-32:5;
35:14-36:18;
37:18-40:1;
38:2-8; 39:1340:1; 53:1054:5

60:2-61:22
63:7-66:22

MIS, C, LF
R, UFP, MIS,
C, LF, CMP,
CNF
R, S, LF, UP,
CNF, MIS,
CMP, NC, C
C, LF, MIS,
UFP, CNF, R
R, CMP, NC,
UFP, C, LF, S
R, MIS, CMP,
NC, C, LF, S

67:15-75:5

75:18-76:8
76:20-77:24
78:15-23

10

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

IC
IC for 35:1436:18 and
53:10-54:5

63:2-6

75:6-18

77:25-78:11

IC

79:6-81:17

IC

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

80:19-81:5

C, LF, S,
CMP, NC,
MIS, CNF
R, UFP, C,
LF, S, CNF
CMP, LF, C,
CNF

81:18-82:11
83:7-11
Berthold,
Michael

01/23/2011

6:8-13
11:9-13
12:20-24
14:10-1515:3-16:4
16:10-18
21:25-22:15
23:3-5
28:1-29:19
32:5-21
33:2-14

42:9-12
48:15-49:12

PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

83:12-84:5;
84:12-24

I, IC, F, R, P

84:6-11

R

14:16-15:5;
165:1-166:17
175:19176:14
16:19-17:13;
165:1-166:17

IC, I
IC, I
IC, R, I

15:6-16:4;
166:18-21

L, LC, S

I
IC, I

17:14-18;
166:18-21

R, UFP;
R, UFP

34:14-25;
35:21-23;
36:1-6

R;
R

81:6-83:5

R, S, CNF,
UP, FNE
L, LC, S,
R, S, CNF,
UP, FNE
LC
R, S, CNF,
UP, LC, CMP

22:16-23:2
29:20-30:22

R, S, CNF,

33:15-34:13;
I
35:7-23; 36:16
42:13-14

R, S

11

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

63:16-22

LC, OB, V/A,
CNF,
L, LC, F, OB,
V/A, CMP
LC, V/A, S

63:23- 64:15;
175:19-24
67:1-69:5

IC, I
IC, R

64:16-25

78:4-22

IC, R, I

76:17-18;
77:3-8;
77:15-18

V/A, CMP,
CNF, R

91:20-92:4
95:25-96:7

IC
IC

92:5-11

UFP

99:24-100:13
109:4-6;
109:9-16;
175:19-24.
109:21-22;
109:25-110:4

I

99:2-23

R
R, UFP

I

108:4-17

I

110:5-12

R, LC,CMP

I

132:17-24

R, UFP

69:6-9
74:2-17

86:6-24
92:13-16
95:2-24
97:10-24
98:1-99:1
108:22-109:3

109:17-20
114:4-11
122:25-123:14
131:2-18
132:6-16
136:12-137:25
138:4-8

S, LC, R,
CMP
R, LC
R, LC, L,
CNF, UP
R,
R, CNF, UP
L, LC, F, UP,
CNF,
L,LC, F, UP,
CNF
R
L, LC, F,
CNF, UP
R
R
R
R

86:24-87:11

131:19-22
132:25-133:4

12

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations
V/A, R, UFP

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

140:24-141:11

ARG, R, L,
UP,
ARG, R, L,
UP,

142:13-145:2

PUM's
Counter
Designations

145:3-10;
184:15185:15
184:15185:15
147:22-148:6;
184:15185:15
161:11-12

145:11-16

ARG, R, L,
UP,
146:22-147:21-t ARG, R, L,
UP,
161:8-10

ARG, R, L,
UP,

163:14-164:2

Black, Phillip

05/06/2011

4:7-11
6:18-7:21
13:4-17
17:4-17
21:25-22:7
26:11-27:15
29:6-9
29:13-30:6
34:14-25

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

ARG, R, UP;
R

I

185:16-20;
186:3-9

I

148:7-22

R, UFP

166:23-167:1;
167:3-4;
167:10-24
R; UFP
R; N; V/A; C;
S
R; V/A; C
R; UFP; S;
CMP
R; S; L; UFP
R; UFP; CNF;
S
R; UFP

13

10:10-19

IC, R

22:17-24

I, IC

22:25-23:1

CMP, R,

35:6-18

IC, I, R

35:1-7

R, UFP

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

36:24-37:10
45:10-15
45:21-47:19
48:15-17
52:23-54:13

R; S; V/A; LF
R; UFP
R; UFP; S

55:17-56:14
59:14-15
59:18-61:11
62:5-7
62:9-20
63:15-18
68:5-10
68:20-69:3
84:3-13
87:14-23
93:2-10
93:17-96:6
97:5-7
99:2-12
107:9-20
107:22

PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

86:20-87:5

IC, R, P

99:13-100:2

P

R; S; UFP;
CNF
R; UFP; S
R; S; UFP;
CNF
R; S; F; V/A;
R; S; F; V/A;
L
R
R
R
R; UFP; C; S;
L
R; S; UFP
R; S; L; UFP
R; S; UFP; C;
CNF
R; S; C; CNF;
LF; F
R; S; F
14

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

Brandman, Onn

03/16/2011

3:25-4:2
7:8-13
8:23-9:8
9:12-14
10:13-23
11:17-12:4
12:6-11
12-13-17
15:19-16:4
17:15-18:2
19:21-24
20:5-22:3

25:8-26:4
26:6-7
26:18-27:13
28:4-5
28:12-32:14
34:2-11

PUM's
Objections

PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

R, OB, V/A,
UP, CNF
R, UP, CNF, S
R, UP, CNF
L, LC, C, UP,
CNF,
CMP

12:18-22

IC

12:18-23

R, IC

12:18-22
12:18-22

IC
IC

12:18-23
12:18-23

R, IC
R, IC

18:3-20,
18:14-19:20

P

20:5-17-R,
CNF, UP
21:15-22:1UP, R, S,
S, R, CNF,
R, CNF
R, CNF,
R, S, CNF, UP
R, S, CNF,
UP, FNE
R, S, CNF

15

Witness

04/14/2011

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

35:23-36:12

Franco, Horacio

Date

R, S, UP,
37:8-23
CNF,
FNE,OB,
V/A, CMP
R, S, UP, CNF

38:14-20
6:15-18
11:6-19
16:11-21
17:5 -18:5

45:10-13
45:20 – 46:7
46:11 – 49:7

PUM's
Counter
Designations

02/10/2011

5:9-12
7:4 – 8:17
8:24 – 9:5
10:23 – 12:20

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

I, R

37:8-16

12:14-13:9

IC, R, P

49:8-50:25;
61:17-63:8;
93:9-94:19
99:11-100:11

R, CMP

IC, R, P

18:6-19:13;
22:25-23:11;
24:22-:26:2

95:10 – 99:10
R, CMP, UP
100:11 – 102:10
102:23 – 103:13 CMP
Gal, Ari

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

F, IC,

104:11-25;
106:8-11

R, L, UFP,
CNF
R, L, LF, S,
8:18-23
UFP, CNF
R, LF, S, UFP,
CNF
16

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations
CMP

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

13:3 – 14:8

R, LF, S, UFP,
CNF, B/S, C
R
R, LF, L, S,
UFP, CNF,
B/S, C
R, L, S, UFP,
CNF
R, L, S, UFP,
CNF, B/S
R, L, S
17:16-19,
18:4-6
R, S, UFP,
17:16-19,
CNF, C
18:4-6
R, S, LF, UFP,
CNF, B/S, C
R, S, L, LF,
UFP, CNF,
B/S, C
R, S, L, LF,
UFP, CNF,
B/S, C
R, L, UPF,
CNF, A&A, C
R
R, UFP, CNF

16:3-7
18:7 – 21:5

21:10-24
22:3-8
23:10-19
24:18 – 25:4
37:20-22
38:11 – 39:9

39:16 – 40:21

45:24 – 48:11
48:19 – 49:9
49:21 – 49:23

PUM's
Counter
Designations

17

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

IC
IC

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

49:25-50:11

R, LF, C, S,
UFP, CNF
R, C, CNF,
UFP, S
R, C, CNF,
UFP, S
R, C, CNF,
UFP
R, CNF, UFP
R, CNF, UFP
R, CNF, UFP,
S
R, C, LF,
CNF, UFP, S
R, C, LF,
CNF, UFP, S,
OB
R, UFP, CNF,
A&A
R, UFP, CNF,
S,
R, CNF, UFP,
OB
R, CNF, UFP,
OB, B/S,
A&A, ARG

50:12-13

IC

51:13-14

IC

53:16-17

IC

51:4-12
53:7-13
53:18 – 54:15
56:9-23
63:15 – 64:8
65:19 – 66:16
67:4-18
68:6 – 69:18

70:15 – 73:14
73:22 – 74:4
75:9-18
76:1 – 79:12

18

75:1-8

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

PUM's
Counter
Designations

87:7-8

IC

87:12-13

IC

84:7 – 85:24

Jacobs, Ron

08/25/2010

R, CNF, UFP,
S, L
87:4-6
R, CNF, UFP,
C, B/S
87:9-11
R, CNF, UFP,
C, B/S
87:14-19
R, CNF, UFP,
C, B/S
118:18 – 118:21 R
118:24-119:8
R, S
120:5 – 121:2
R, S, L, B/S,
C
123:13 – 124:21 R, L, B/S, C,
ARG., F,
CNF, UFP
170:4-19
R, L, B/S. C,
CNF, UFP
5:7-9
8:12-9:16
V/A, A&A
12:8-18
R
14:8-14
R
15:2-20
R, UFP, C

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

20:12-19

R, CNF

24:7-12

CMP, C, R

19

169:19-170:3

10:3-17
12:23-13:1
14:15-24
15:21-16:4;
17:2-8
20:20-23;
21:22-22:10
23:20-24:6;
24:13-17

IC, R

I
IC, R, ET
IC

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

Witness

02/14/2011

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

24:18-20
32:1-3
34:12-15
Jeh, Glen

Date

PUM's
Counter
Designations

CMP, R,
CMP, R, CNF 32:20-33:8
CMP, R, CNF,
V/A

12:16-17
22:9-25

19:18-20;
20:21-22:20
24:6-9;
25:4-14
37:16-20

24:10-20
37:7-14
38:9-13
38:15-39:21
40:5-17

Konig, Yochai

12/02/2010

40:19-24;
41:4-13;
41:15-42:12;
42:14-16

5:14-17
5:22-25
8:12-14
9:6-17
10:6-21
14:1-15:15
16:25-18:23
21:1-10
22:23-23:2
23:4-12
23:19-22

15:16-19

20

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

R
I

37:21-38:8

R

I, IC, R, P
I

41:14-14

IC, I, R

R, P, IC
R, P, IC

R, CMP, IC

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

23:24-24:10
24:12-25:20
26:21-28:6
30:6-13
37:13-16
39:16-22
43:7-44:5
44:10-45:5
45:10-21
47:6-8
49:22-50:7
57:14-58:12
62:24-64:20
66:19-23
67:4-13
70:2-71:2
72:4-12
72:16-73:7
73:11-20
75:12-16
79:4-22
84:5-85:15
105:11-21

PUM's
Objections

PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

28:7-14
30:14-17
37:17-20

IC

R
44:6-9
45:6-9
45:22-46:2

IC

R
58:13-25
R as to 64:920
67:14-25

IC

71:22-72:3

R as to 79:1422
Argumentative

21

78:9-14

IC

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

PUM's
Counter
Designations

117:14-118:4

A&A as to
117:20-118:4

117:4-13

149:9-16
149:22-150:22
152:11-155:11
155:22-156:3

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

R
R
R,
Argumentative

178:1-9
181:9-13
182:10-14
186:23-22
189:20-190:2
190:8-191:6
202:13-203:17
206:8-207:1
207:7-9
207:14-208:25
220:16-221:24
223:3-224:2
233:14-22
240:7-10
240:15-16
242:24-243:22
244:12-17
258:2-12

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

181:14-182:9

190:3-7
190:3-7
202:7-12;
203:18-204:1
R
R
R
R
R
R
R

IC
I

233:18-22

R
R
R

259:2-12

22

IC

R, CMP
204:3-4

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

Konig, Yochai

05/04/2011

282:22-283:11
283:23-285:11
285:25-286:5
286:25-287:8
288:18-289:4
290:8-292:6
293:1-294:23
296:11-18
299:1-299:14
303:10-20
304:15-25
306:4-307:4
308:10-17
311:3-16
312:9-25
316:20-318:7
323:10-326:1
327:21-24
328:1-24
329:5-23
332:4-21
333:8-15
343:12-1
350:18-351:3
353:11-23

PUM's
Objections

PUM's
Counter
Designations

283:12-18
286:6-8
289:5-11;
289:13-290:7
292:4-7
R

305:1-15

311:17-312:8

329:24-330:2
331:24-332:3

23

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

PUM's
Counter
Designations

356:19-357:19
358:21-359:13
359:17-360:25
362:9-363:13
364:5-16
367:16-369:1
369:9-12
369:14-370:4
370:6-10
370:20-372:7
378:1-9
381:18-382:10
384:14-23
386:6-12
386:14-21
386:23-387:20
399:2-401:6
401:8-11
401:13-17
401:19
403:23-404:3

357:20358:19

363:14-364:4
369:2-8
370:12-19
372:9-16
R as to
381:18-23
R

R as to
387:8-15

R as to
403:23-24

404:5-404:11
408:17-22

408:10-15
24

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

Witness

Konig, Yochai

Konig, David

Date

01/26/2012

07/08/2011

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

PUM's
Counter
Designations

409:4-7
419:22-420:9
436:1-3
436:6-11
455:1-456:13
457:6-459:5
469:12-24
475:6-16
476:25-477:4
478:9-15
479:1-8
482:12-17
490:2-13
532:15-533:7
543:3-544:7
545:3-10
547:15-548:4
555:16-556:3
558:3-14
564:10-14
574:14-22
576:20-577:6
4:3-6
10:12-18
10:22 – 11-4

574:23575:10
R

25

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

11:7-9
12:3-10
12:23 – 13:3
15:18-19
15:21-23
16:4 – 17:7
20:16-18
24:14 – 25:13
25:15-21
31:21-22
32:17 – 33:4
33:6-15
33:20 – 34:23
34:25 – 36:3
39:6-22
40:21-24
45:16 – 46:15
48:7-23
55:15 – 56:17
56:20-21
56:25 – 57:22
58:8-10

PUM's
Objections

PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

25:22-25

IC

25:22-25

IC

31:23-25

IC

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

32:4-10
32:4-10

R, IC
R, IC

R
R, C, OB
R, C, OB
R, OB
R, P, CMP,
UFP
R, P, CMP,
UFP
S, CMP, C
R
R

R, CMP

39:23-42:4

R, CMP,

46:16-17,
46:19-47:2

R, CNF, OB,
V/A
R, CNF, UP
R, UP, CNF
R, UP, CNF
R, UP, CNF

26

42:5-7

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

58:14-25

71:25 – 73:25
6:4-7
10:12-24
11:2-4

R, UP, CNF,
S,
R, CNF, S
R, S, UP,
CNF, CMP
R, CNF, S
H
H
H

44:13-18

H

44:22-45:3
8:10-13
13:6-14:11

H
R
L, LC, CNF,
F, CMP
L, LC, CNF,
F, CMP
L, LC, CNF,
F, CMP
L, LC, CNF,
F, CMP
R
L, LC, F, R,
CNF
L, LC, F, R,
CNF

59:2-11
60:22 – 61:5

Montes, Frank

03/17/2011

Pazzani, Michael 11/17/2012
J.

14:21-23
14:25-15:2
15:4-8
17:11-22
18:6-10
18:12-21

PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

61:6-7

11:19-12:5;
21:6-22:19
28:3-33:4;
42:11-43:10
46:24-47:8
14:12-19,
15:10-17:7
14:12-19,
15:10-17:7
14:12-19,
15:10-17:7
14:12-19,
15:10-17:7

27

IC, R, P
IC, R, P
IC, R, P

IC
IC
IC

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

18:23-19:23

L, LC, F, R,
CNF
L, LC, F, R,
CNF
L, LC, F, R,
CNF
L, LC, F, R,
CNF

19:24-30:6

IC

31:22-33:1

IC

CMP

17:18-24

31:2-21
33:7-10
33:12-34:12
Perrault,
Raymond C.

08/17/2011

7:15-23
16:15-17:21
18:6-8
22:1-13
26:11-22
27:13-17
36:9-13
39:10-40:14
41:5-43:2
52:1-16
52:24-56:3
56:9-19
56:21-23

Salter, James H.

9/10/2010

R, UP
R, CMP
R, CMO, UP
R, CNF, UP

30:20-31:6;
19:11-15
30:20-31:6;
19:11-15
51:24-52:2
55:6-16

R, CNF, UP

R, CNF, UP
R, CNF, UP
R, CNF, UP,
CMP

57:3-58:1

3:7-9

28

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

4:12-18

CMP, CNF

IC, R

13:17-21
15:4-16
21:3-23
22:14-8
24:3-11
34:3-35:9
35:17-25
38:1-9

CMP, CNF
CMP, R,CNF
CMP, R,CNF
CMP, R,CNF
R,CNF
CMP, R,CNF
CMP, R,CNF
R, UFP

5:2-10;
9:21-2;
12:24-13:3
14:15-19
15:17-21
22:8-13

IC

42:2-16
43:20-25
44:8-45:20
49:6-50:7
51:4-15
54:11-14

CMP, CNF, R

24:12-15
35:15-16
37:19-25
41:10-15;
41:19-42:1
42:17-21

IC

R, UFP
R, CNF
R, UFP
R, CMP, V/A

48:16-49:2

IC, R, P

57:6-8;
57:10-17;
57:24-58:6
58:24-59:21;
59:23
60:25-61:6;
61:11-62:1;
62:4

IC

62:11-19

R

62:20-24
29

IC

IC
IC, ET

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

Witness

08/15/2011

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

64:6-65:7
Sonmez,
Mustafa Kemal

Date

R, UP

65:13-15;
65:17-19

IC, P

43:7-44:15

IC, I

R, MIS, UFP,
CNF, CMP,
NC

47:11-49:3

IC

R, UFP, CNF,
MIS, CMP,
NC

65:1-15

4:9-11
4:18-19
12:18-13:23
18:17-25
19:9-20:1
29:21-24
30:13-17
34:4-11
35:3-36:7
41:22-42:16
42:18-21
43:1-8
45:22-46:4
46:9-47:10

55:8-21
64:23-25

R
CMP

R, MIS, UFP,
CNF, CMP
R, MIS, UFP,
CNF
R, MIS, UFP,
CNF

30

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

PUM's
Counter
Designations

71:21-72:18

R, UFP, CNF,
MIS, CMP,
NC
R, UFP, CNF,
MIS,

72:19-74:7

CMP, MIS

14:2-8

R, CMP
R
R

20:20-21:1

75:15-76:1

Stolcke, Andreas 07/06/2011

100:6-11
100:22-101:15
101:23-102:1
7:22-9:5
9:9-10:7
10:23-25
11:3-4
11:8-10
12:5-18
13:23-14:1
16:11-13
16:17-17:10
17:12-22
17:24
18:1-4
18:12-17
18:19-23
18:25-20:7
20:13-17
21:8-19
21:22-22:2

31

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

22:9-17
23:1-11
23:13-15
23:17-24:18
24:20-25:21
28:4-12

R
R, MIS
R, MIS
R, MIS
R, MIS
MIS, CMP,
NC, CNF,
UFP
MIS, CNF,
UFP, CMP,
NC
MIS, CNF,
UFP, CMP,
NC
MIS, CNF,
UFP, CMP,
NC
MIS, CNF,
UFP
MIS, CNF,
UFP, CMP,
NC

29:13-23

30:1-20

30:22-32:3

34:11-35:1
35:14-17

35:20-36:8
36:15-21
36:23-37:10
37:12-25

PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

35:2-9

CMP

28:20-29:12

29:24-25

32:4-12;
33:25-34:10

R

35:9-13

I

36:9-14

R, MIS, UFP,
CNF
32

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

38:22-39:25

R, MIS, UFP,
CNF
R, MIS, UFP,
CNF

40:3-14
40:21-41:2
41:10-14
41:16-42:6
42:8-12
45:8-47:1
48:20-24
49:1-3
49:7-50:23
50:25-51:7
51:9-11
57:18-23
58:2-4
58:18-59:1

PUM's
Counter
Designations

R, MIS, UFP,
CNF
R, MIS, UFP,
CNF
R, MIS, UFP,
CNF
R, MIS, UFP,
CNF, S, CMP

R, MIS, UFP,
CNF, S
R, MIS, UFP,
CNF
R, MIS, UFP,
CNF, CMP
MIS, CMP,
CNF
C, R, MIS,
UFP, CNF, S
C, R, MIS,
UFP, CNF, S
33

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

47:2-5

47:2-5

IC

65:2-5;
65:17-19

65:17-19

52:8-18

52:8-18

57:10-17

57:10-17

IC

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

60:1-3

C, R, MIS,
UFP, CNF, S
R, MIS, UFP,
CNF, S, C

60:5
73:13-74:7
74:11-22
74:25
75:2-4
75:6-9
75:12-13
75:16
75:18-24
76:1-8
76:10
76:12-14
76:16
78:18-22
78:24-79:16
79:18-80:7
96:17-20
96:22-24
100:8-16

PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

80:8-10

IC

R, MIS, UFP,
CMP
R, MIS, UFP,
CNF
CMP
R, MIS, UFP,
CNF
R, MIS, UFP,
CNF
R, CNF, S, C.
LF
34

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

100:19-101:8

R, CNF, S,
LF, C
R, MIS, UFP,
CNF
R, MIS, UFP,
CNF
R, MIS, UFP,
CNF
R, MIS, UFP,
CNF

103:15-19
104:16-20
105:17-19
105:21-106:23
Twersky, Roy

12/03/2010

5:13-15
7:10-22
7:25 – 8:5
8:13-15
8:24 – 9:3
10:16-18
12:16-20
18:4-9
18:12-17
20:14-20

PUM's
Counter
Designations

CMP, MIS
S, CNF, MIS,
UFP
S, MIS, CMP,
UFP
MIS, C, CMP,
CNF, S
MIS, C, CMP,
CNF, S
LF, C, MIS,
UFP, S
LF, C, MIS,
UFP, S
LF, C, MIS,
UFP, S
35

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

7:23-24

IC

9:9-15

IC, R

13:3-11; 15:5- IC, I, R, P
16:21

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

16:22-24,
17:2-12

R, MIS, CNF,
S

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

20:22 – 21:1

LF, C, MIS,
UFP, S
LF, C, MIS,
UFP, S, CMP

21:5 – 22:14

22:22 – 23:6
24:2-22
27:3-11
27:19-21

PUM's
Counter
Designations

LF, C, MIS,
UFP
R, UFP, MIS,
S
R, MIS, CNF,
C
MIS, CNF,
UFP

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

101:10102:11;
104:21-25
23:12-18

IC, R, P

101:4-9

Improper
counter, R,
MIS. CNF

P

23:19-20

27:22-28:2;
28:22-29:24;
30:7-11
34:10-14;
35:12-23;
36:15-18
87:14-88:2;
99:1-4

IC, R, P

34:22 – 35:11

CMP, S

37:14-19

R, UFP, CNF,
MIS
R, UFP, CNF,
MIS
UFP, CNF, C,
MIS LF
R, UFP, S, LF,
C, CNF, MIS
UFP, S, LF, C, 44:12-17
CNF, MIS

39:8-25
42:7 -18
43:2-10
45:17-25

36

IC, R, P, I

I, IC, R, P

IC, ET, P

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

50:14 – 51:2

MIS, UFP,
CNF, CMP

49:25-50:7;
51:3-52:8;
53:24-54:5;
54:10-14

IC, ET

54:6-9

92:6-13

R, S, LF, C,
UFP
R, S, LF, C,
UFP
MIS, CNF, C, 109:6-110:21
LF, CMP
MIS, CNF
R, MIS, C.
LF, CNF, UFP

96:21-25
107:16 – 109:5
110:22 – 111:4
111:15 – 113:4

114:1 – 115:5
115:14 – 116:12 R, MIS, CNF,
UFP, CMP
117:1-8
R, MIS, UFP,
CNF
119:6 – 125:22 R, UFP, CNF,
MIS
126:20 – 127:2 R, UFP, CNF,
MIS, CMP

130:15 – 134:4
134:21 – 135:7

R, UFP, MIS,
CMP
R, UFP, MIS

37

IC, R, P

116:17-25

I, IC

126:15-17;
127:3-128:12;
129:12-16;
129:17-130:4
134:10:20

IC, I, P, R

IC, P

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations
S, R, C, MIS,
UFP

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

PUM's
Counter
Designations

173:15-23

IC

185:14186:14;
186:24 –
187:2

IC, R, P, I

220:13-16;
235:2-4;
238:7-17

IC

225:20-23

I, IC, P

226:11-17

MIS, CNF.
UFP, CMP
177:9 – 178:7
MIS, CNF.
UFP, CMP
178:21 – 180:25 R, MIS, CNF.
UFP
181:7 – 182:17 R, MIS, CNF.
UFP, CMP

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

IC

160:9 – 162:6

Twersky, Roy

05/05/2011

189:10-16
190:17 – 191:11
209:14 – 210:22
212:13-19
215:9-13
215:15-19
215:21 – 219:10
220:2-3
220:10-12

R, MIS, C. LF
R

R
R, UFP, MIS,
CNF
CMP, MIS

221:13 – 222:1 R, MIS, UFP
224:15 – 225:12 CNF, MIS,
UFP, CMP
226:8-10
MIS, CMP
228:18 – 232:21 R, MIS
38

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

PUM's
Counter
Designations

236:19 – 237:7

R, MIS, UFP,
CNF
237:19-22
R, MIS. UFP,
CNF
238:7 – 239:16 R, UFP, MIS,
CNF, CMP
248:16 – 249:25 R, MIS, UFP,
CNF
250:25 – 251:12 S, R, UFP,
CNF, MIS
252:17-21
S, R, UFP,
CNF, MIs
254:13-15
S, R, UFP,
CNF, MIS
255:2 – 256:10 S, R, UFP,
CNF, MIS
256:23 – 257:2 S, R, UFP,
CNF, MIS
257:4-12
R, S, UFP,
CNF, MIS
257:14-19
R, S, UFP,
CNF, MIS
257:21-25
R, S, UFP,
CNF, MIS
261:5-12
R, S, UFP,
CNF, MIS

39

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations
IC, I, P

239:17-20

I, IC, P

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

269:23-270:3;

I, IC, P

268:23269:22;
270:4-272:14

Improper
counter, R,
MIS, S, CNF

275:8-21

I, IC, P

301:4-7;
303:25304:11;
308:24-309:2
S

I, IC, P

311:24

CMP, R,
improper
counter

319:7 –
320:15

R, S, UFP,
CNF, MIS
272:15 – 273:11 R, S, UFP,
CNF, MIS,
CMP
273:13-16
273:18-24
R, S, UFP,
CNF, MIS,
CMP
278:2 – 280:8
R
280:10-15
280:17-23
R
296:17-25
MIS, CMP,
CNF, UFP

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

IC

320:16-22

improper
counter

263:17-22

311:2-23

R, MIS, C, LF

312:25 – 313:7
314:2 – 315:11
316:18-21
316:23 – 317:4
317:6-7
317:12 – 319:6

CMP

320:23 – 321:1
40

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

321:4-25

CMP

321:21-323:6

I, IC

324:16-326:4

328:1-16

R. MIS. CNF,
C, LC

332:3-25

R, UFP, MIS,
S
R
R, UFP, MIS,
S

334:14-21
335:12-21

335:23 – 338:10
339:6 – 340:7
340:9 – 341:3
342:4-19
350:6-7
350:11-20
LC, C

326:13327:25;
328:24-329:4

343:5-11

41

IC, P

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations
improper
counter, new
subject matter
and
documents, R,
CNF, MIS,
UFP, CMP
improper
counter, new
subject matter
and
documents, R,
CNF, MIS,
UFP, CMP

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

PUM's
Counter
Designations

S, LC, C,
CNF, MIS,
UFP
353:8-10
S, LC, C, CNF
MIS, UFP
353:12 – 355:14 S, LC, C,
CNF, MIS,
UFP
355:16 – 356:3 S, LC, C,
CNF, MIS,
UFP
356:18 – 357:1 S, LC, C,
CNF, MIS,
UFP, CMP
371:23 – 372:9 LC, CNF,
MIS, UFP
379:18 – 381:2 R, MIS. CNF
383:1-9
CMP, MIS
385:2-4
CMP, MIS.
CNF, UFP
395:10 – 396:22 CMP, MIS,
CNF
398:22-25
399:12-16
402:1 – 404:7
404:9-12
405:8 – 406:18

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

357:8-358:2

I, IC

357:2-7

392:10-17;
393:11-23
394:25-395:9

IC, P

352:21 – 353:6

42

IC, P

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

Witness

Date

Defendant's
Designations

PUM's
Objections

411:22 – 413:1

UFP, MIS, R,
CNF
UFP, MIS, R,
CNF

413:3 – 414:2

Twersky, Roy

01/26/2012

PUM's
Counter
Designations

431:2-11
432:11-23
433:25 – 434:11 R, MIS, CNF
447:3 – 449:12 R, MIS, UFP,
CNF, LC
450:2 – 451:2
LC, MIS,
CNF, UFP
451:5 – 452:25 LC, MIS,
CNF, UFP
454:17-23
S, LC, UFP
456:4-25
S, LC, MIS,
UFP
482:3-22
486:12-22

43

Defendant's
Objections to
PUM's
Counter
Designations

Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations

PUM's
Objections to
Defendant's
CounterCounter
Designations