Personalized User Model LLP v. Google Inc.

Filing 609

REDACTED VERSION of 601 Exhibit to a Document re 588 Proposed Pretrial Order [REVISED EXHIBIT 8 TO THE [PROPOSED] PRETRIAL ORDER - - PUM'S DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS] by Google Inc.. (Moore, David)

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE
PERSONALIZED USER MODEL, L.L.P.,
Plaintiff,
v.
GOOGLE INC.,
Defendant.
GOOGLE, INC.
Counterclaimant,
v.
PERSONALIZED USER MODEL, LLP and
YOCHAI KONIG
Counterdefendants.

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

C.A. No. 09-525-LPS
PUBLIC VERSION

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

REVISED [PROPOSED] FINAL PRETRIAL ORDER
EXHIBIT 8: PUM’S DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS
OF COUNSEL:
QUINN EMANUEL URQUHART
& SULLIVAN, LLP
Charles K. Verhoeven
David A. Perlson
Antonio R. Sistos
Margaret Pirnie Kammerud
50 California St.
San Francisco, CA 94111
Joshua Lee Sohn
777 6th Street NW, 11th Floor
Washington, DC 20001-3706
Andrea Pallios Roberts
555 Twin Dolphin Drive, Suite 560
Redwood Shores, CA 94065
Dated: February 25, 2014
Public Version Dated: February 28, 2014
1141114 / 34638

Richard L. Horwitz (#2246)
David E. Moore (#3983)
Bindu A. Palapura (#5370)
POTTER ANDERSON & CORROON LLP
Hercules Plaza, 6th Floor
1313 N. Market Street
Wilmington, DE 19801
Tel: [phone]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
Attorneys for Defendant Google Inc.

EX. 8 - PUM’S DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS
EXHIBIT 8
PUM’S DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS
PUM hereby submits its deposition designations with Google’s counter designations, and PUM’s objections to such counter
designations.
The parties incorporate by reference designations of any errata pertinent to the excerpts of the deposition transcripts designated by
PUM, counter designated by Google, or counter-counter designated by PUM.
Google's objections are identified with the following abbreviations:
General Objections:

Form Objections:

R – Relevance, 402

L – Leading

P – Fed. R. Evid. 403: Prejudicial

ARG – Argumentative

H – Hearsay

A – Assuming Facts Not in Evidence

F – Lacks Foundation

C – Compound

I – Incomplete

N – Narratives

V – Vague and ambiguous

M – Misstates Testimony

S – Beyond the scope of Rule 30(b)(6) deposition topics

AA—Asked and Answered

LC – Legal Conclusion
ET – calls for expert testimony

MIS – misleading
IC – improper counter
NR – non-responsive
IH – incomplete hypothetical
SP – speculation
SN – Fed. R. Evid. 408, Settlement Negotiations

Google further notes that some of the designated testimony may be inadmissible based upon the Court's rulings on its motions in
limine, or by narrowing by PUM of the scope of its case. By way of example, certain testimony designated by PUM may be irrelevant if
PUM drops asserted claims or accused products and Google reserves the right to object to such designated testimony.

2

Alferness, Jonathan - 3/24/2011
Plaintiff's
Designations

6:15 to 6:16
7:17-19
11:25 to 12:24
17:18 to 18:11
22:20 to 23:6
24:20 to 25:10
25:23 to 28:19
33:10 to 34:8
34:11 to 34:21
35:10 to 37:25
38:2 to 38:7
55:21 to 56:9
56:25 to 57:24
58:6 to 58:25
60:16 to 60:18
62:15 to 62:19
62:25 to 64:10
73:1 to 75:20
75:23 to 76:20
77:4 to 77:7
77:11 to 78:11

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's
Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

I
R, P

18:12

F, I

Plaintiff's Objections to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

60:19-22

3

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

83:13 to 84:7
84:11 to 86:18
97:21 to 98:10
101:13 to 101:22
115:12 to 116:9
117:6 to 117:11

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's
Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

R, I

4

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Bercow, Douglas 4/14/2011
Plaintiff's
Designations

8:1 to 8:3
8:8 to 8:10
15:4 to 19:1
19:21 to 20:18
23:10 to 25:21
26:15 to 28:11
34:4 to 34:18
38:9 to 39:12
55:2 to 55:17
55:21 to 56:15

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

R
F
28:12-18
R
R, SP, F
SP, F, R

5

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Berthold, Michael - 1/23/2011
Plaintiff's
Designations

6:8 to 6:13
9:8-11
9:16 to 10:4
12:20 to 12:24
13:23 to 14:4
14:16 to 15:5
19:5 to 19:8
19:12 to 20:13
31:13 to 31:16
31:19 to 31:21
31:24 to 32:21
36:9 to 36:11
39:20 to 39:23
40:1 to 40:11
41:13 to 41:14
41:17 to 41:24
49:15 to 50:22
50:25 to 52:11
56:8 to 56:11
63:11 to 63:15
65:7 to 66:2

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

I

9:11

I

16:5-9

L, R, P, F, M, IC, MIS

I
I

32:22-33:14

S

I
ET, R, P

41:4-11

L, E, T, ARG, IC

P, I, ET, R
ET
ET, I
I
R, P

6

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

66:5 to 67:12
76:17-18
78:4
78:8 to 78:22
85:5 to 86:9
86:12 to 86:13
86:18 to 86:20
86:23 to 87:11
167:5 to 168:20
169:4 to 169:13
172:6 to 173:7
177:2 to 177:21
177:23 to 178:1
178:3 to 178:21
178:23 to 178:25

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations
I

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations
69:6-9

I

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

77:3-18

L, ET, ARG, M, IC,
MIS

R
R
V, F
R, P
F, V, R, P

7

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Brandman, Onn - 3/16/2011
Plaintiff's
Designations

3:35 to 4:2
6:21 to 7:20
8:23 to 9:8
9:12 to 9:23
10:13 to 11:21
16:2-4
17:15 to 19:20
20:18 to 21:14
22:2-3
23:4 to 23:9
23:11 to 25:3
32:20 to 33:20

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

11:22-12:23, 21:1522:3

V/A, ET, L, ARG, S,
IC

19:21-24
20:5-17

S, R

35:23-36:12

S, M, R, I

8

Plaintiff’s Countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

37:8-16

P, R, I

Dupont, Cedric - 4/14/2011
Plaintiff's
Designations

6:24 to 7:4
8:17-19
11:3 to 12:16
14:3 to 15:8
17:7 to 17:13
18:18 to 19:5
22:9 to 23:6
24:1 to 24:17
25:10 to 26:2
28:7 to 28:22
29:12 to 31:18
35:18 to 36:17
37:18 to 38:6
38:15 to 39:5
39:9 to 40:12
41:24 to 42:19
44:9 to 45:5
45:9 to 45:13
45:22 to 46:5
48:24 to 50:10
51:10 to 55:2
64:22 to 65:2

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

I
R, P
R, P

21:24-22:6

I

R, P
R, P
R, P
R, P
R, P
R, P
R, P
R, P
R, P
I
I, R, P

47:2-5, 50:11-23
51:5-9

9

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

66:12 to 67:12
67:18 to 67:25
68:3 to 68:8
70:7 to 71:1
74:13 to 74:24
76:1 to 76:8
84:12 to 85:8
85:18 to 86:12
106:11 to 107:21

I, R, P
R, P
R, P
R, P
R, P
R, P

68:12-25

10

Franco, Horacio 4/14/2011
Plaintiff's
Designations

6:7 to 6:9
6:11 to 6:18
16:11 to 16:21
43:10 to 46:10
54:24 to 55:21
61:17 to 62:5
66:6 to 66:13
74:17 to 75:1
102:23 to 103:23

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

66:14-21

R, UFP

R

ET
ET, SP

11

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Friedman, Greg - 3/7/2011
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

9:12 to 9:16
12:7-9
18:2 to 18:15
19:10 to 19:20
19:22 to 19:23
24:25
25:1 to 25:2
25:4 to 26:9
26:13
26:15 to 27:19
30:18 to 31:8
37:22 to 38:15
49:19 to 51:3
52:9 to 55:23
55:25 to 59:6
60:14 to 60:22
69:13-18
69:25-70:13
72:14 to 74:23
75:2 to 75:12
77:1 to 77:24

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

I

I

30:14-16

R
I

59:7-60:13

12

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

IC

18:16-17
19:25-20:9

Plaintiff’s Countercounter-designations

20:12-14, 20:16-22:1,
26:24-27:19

ARG
R, P, IC

Plaintiff's
Designations

78:1 to 78:20
79:16 to 80:7
80:14 to 81:10
84:24 to 85:3
85:11 to 86:22
87:9 to 87:11
88:10 to 88:14
88:22 to 89:9
89:11 to 90:2
124:8 to 126:13
126:24 to 127:8
127:17 to 128:23
129:25 to 132:23
138:17 to 139:7
140:8 to 141:6
146:13 to 148:25
149:2 to 149:11
176:12 to 178:7

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

85:4-10

88:16-20

127:9-13

S

I

13

Plaintiff’s Countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Gopalratnam, Karthik - 10/8/2010
Plaintiff's
Designations

11:11 to 11:19
11:24 to 12:5
12:20-21
13:2 to 13:4
13:12-15
14:21 to 16:1
16:20-18:7
19:10-16
20:3-10
20:17-21:5
21:18 to 22:14
22:16 to 22:25
23:3 to 23:20
23:22 to 24:10
24:12 to 24:14
26:15 to 26:19
27:16 to 28:5
28:17 to 30:5
30:14-16
30:23-31:1
32:2 to 33:3
33:5 to 33:12

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

19:19-21

R

31:2-8, 31:12-32:1

R

R

L, F
L, F

R, ARG
14

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

33:17 to 34:1
34:3 to 34:24
35:1 to 35:3
36:14 to 38:12
38:19 to 40:17
41:4 to 41:7
43:16 to 43:22
45:14 to 45:25
47:8 to 47:10
47:15 to 48:6
55:12 to 57:4
57:8 to 58:9
58:18 to 59:23
59:15 to 61:7
62:10 to 65:10
65:16 to 65:20
65:25 to 66:5
66:11 to 66:19
66:25 to 69:3
69:18 to 70:14
72:5 to 72:24
73:14 to 73:24
74:10 to 75:20
77:7 to 78:15

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations
C, ARG, V

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

48:7-15

R, S

58:10-17

78:16-22
15

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

79:6 to 79:15
80:7 to 81:7
81:10 to 82:12
83:2 to 83:14
83:21-24
84:6 to 87:10
87:19-21
87:24-25
88:1-24
90:1 to 90:19
91:14 to 92:3
92:12 to 93:20
93:21 to 94:14
94:18 to 96:1
96:2 to 96:4
96:6 to 96:14
96:16 to 96:20
97:2 to 97:15
99:16 to 99:18
99:24 to 100:21
102:10 to 103:8
106:4 to 107:19
113:1 to 114:5
116:10 to 117:25

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

R, P
I

87:17-18

97:16-21, 97:23-98:25

108:2-109:3
112:15-25

R

16

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

122:6 to 122:16
124:13 to 125:1
126:21 to 127:16
129:18 to 130:4
130:12-18
131:10-24
136:6 to 138:9
144:25 to 145:18
163:14 to 164:16
164:20 to 165:7
168:2-10
170:9 to 171:15
185:9 to 185:20
186:12 to 186:14
193:22 to 194:14
198:6-15
203:1 to 210:25
214:12-21
215:13-17
217:7-16
218:4 to 220:25

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

126:11-20, 127:17-20

120:4 -23

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations
119:23-120:3, 120:24121:1, 121:3-16,
121:18-122:5
122:17-124:12

S, ET, IC

127:21-24

R, P

I

R
R, I

170:6-8

195:12-14
197:12-198:5
I

217:3-6

17

Plaintiff's
Designations

227:8 to 232:1
246:1-16
248:25 to 249:6
249:12 to 250:8

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations
R

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

18

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Haveliwala, Taher - 4/19/2011
Plaintiff's
Designations

12:15 to 12:18
13:6 to 13:18
14:4 to 14:9
14:23-15:5
16:5 to 16:15
16:21 to 17:5
19:17 to 20:13
20:21 to 20:22
20:24 to 21:10
22:13 to 22:15
22:19 to 22:24
23:4 to 23:7
23:12 to 23:21
25:15 to 25:16
25:18 to 25:22
25:24 to 26:20
27:12 to 29:1
29:18 to 30:20
31:6 to 31:18
31:6 to 33:20
33:22 to 34:16
34:18 to 35:25

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

R, P
F, V, SP, R, P
R, P
R, P
R, P
N, V, F, R, D
N, V, R, P
R, P
V, ARG, R, P
R, P, V, R
R, P, ARG, V
R, V, IH, V, C
R, V, C
19

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

36:2 to 36:14
40:14 to 40:16
40:18 to 41:19
41:21 to 42:1
42:3 to :42:18
42:20 to 43:2
43:4 to 43:6
43:10 to 43:12
43:14 to 44:3
45:2 to 45:5
45:7 to 47:1
48:4 to 48:9
48:11 to 49:2
49:4 to 49:23
49:25 to 51:16
51:20 to 54:19
54:23 to 55:17
60:17 to 61:7
61:10 to 61:14
61:16 to 61:20
62:15 to 62:16
62:18 to 63:1
63:25 to 64:3
64:17 to 64:18

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations
R
I, V, F
I
V, F, I
V

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

I, V, P, R
P, R

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

44:5-45:1

58:13-60:4

V

40:20-41:1
41:17-20

P, R, V, MIS
V
P, R
P, R, V
P, R, I

I
55:18-56:23, 58:1-6

C, V
V, I
I

64:4-16

20

Plaintiff's
Designations

65:2 to 66:8
69:15 to 70:3
71:1 to 71:5
72:24 to 73:5
73:7 to 73:18
74:1 to 74:2
74:4 to 74:10
74:12 to 75:12
76:6 to 76:15
76:17
79:2 to 79:8
79:10 to 80:15
80:17 to 81:11
82:15 to 82:25
83:19 to 83:22
83:24 to 84:13
86:4 to 86:10
86:14 to 87:2
87:4 to 88:5
125:16 to 126:1

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

V
V

C, V

I

C
I

88:22-89:8

21

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Horling, Bryan C. 11/12/2010
Plaintiff's
Designations

11:10 to 11:13
12:17-19
13:8-11
13:20-14:9
14:24 to 15:2
16:11 to 16:21
16:24 to 17:15
19:22 to 20:10
21:23 to 22:24
23:5 to 23:12
24:4 to 24:25
25:3 to 25:19
25:22 to 26:7
27:19 to 28:9
30:13 to 32:20
32:25 to 34:1
34:7 to 34:9
35:11 to 35:14
35:20 to 35:25
36:17 to 36:21
37:2 to 38:1
38:12 to 39:9

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

I
I

17:16-18:20
21:5-14

I

30:7-10

I

34:10-35:8

I

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

39:10-22
22

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

39:23 to 40:15
40:22 to 41:2
42:16 to 45:14
46:1 to 47:16
47:18
47:23 to 48:5
48:16 to 48:22
49:1 to 49:7
50:4 to 50:24
51:7 to 51:20
52:8 to 52:11
52:13 to 52:14
52:17 to 53:11
54:14 to 54:19
55:12 to 56:1
56:17 to 56:19
56:21 to 56:22
57:4 to 57:24
58:2 to 58:18
58:25 to 59:10
63:13 to 63:20
64:20 to 66:11
67:15 to 68:22
69:16 to 69:19
69:25 to 70:2
70:5 to 70:16
71:2 to 71:3

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations
I
I

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations
40:16-21
41:3-23
45:15-25

V, A, M, I

47:19-22

I

51:21-52:7

I
I
I, R
V
I

53:20-23
54:10-13, 54:20-21
55:10-11

I

60:7-10, 62:4-8

I
I

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

70:3-4
70:17-6

56:23-25

23

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

74:14 to 74:21
75:7 to 75:13
75:16 to 75:17
75:21 to 76:2
76:9 to 76:15
76:23 to 77:21
78:20 to 79:7
79:15 to 81:6
81:25 to 82:20
83:5 to 83:25
84:7 to 84:9
84:13 to 84:20
85:20 to 86:4
86:17 to 86:25
87:6 to 87:9
99:2 to 99:17
102:3 to 103:15
109:6 to 109:17
115:1 to 115:7
119:4 to 119:12
119:24 to 120:25
121:8 to 121:12
121:16 to 121:18
122:2 to 122:7
122:25 to 123:10
123:19 to 123:23
127:12 to 127:18
127:22 to 128:5

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

I

76:3-8

S

I

79:8-14

I

81:12-24

I
I

84:21-85:4
85:10-19

I

87:1-5

I

119:13-23
122:16-17, 122:20-24

I
I
I
I

123:11-15
123:24-124:2
127:19-21
128:6-15
24

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

128:16 to 129:1
129:25 to 130:9
132:9 to 133:12
135:14 to 135:22
136:4 to 136:7
136:13 to 136:19
141:16 to 141:18
141:24 to 142:1
142:16 to 142:19
143:9 to 143:14
143:17 to 144:7
144:18 to 146:7
147:5 to 148:7
148:21 to 149:4
149:13 to 149:20
149:24 to 150:3
150:14 to 152:12
152:16 to 153:18
154:16 to 154:22
155:21-23
171:13 to 171:20
172:12 to 173:3
173:8 to 173:20
195:25 to 196:2
212:6 to 212:7
212:11 to 212:22
239:1 to 239:6
241:9 to 241:18

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

R, P
R, I

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

133:13-24

144:8-17

I

149:5-12
149:21-23

I

154:23-155:7

I
R, P, I
I
R, P

212:23-213:7

I

25

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

Source code
transcript
157:14 to 157:18
158:8 to 158:13
158:24 to 159:4
159:8 to 159:11
159:14 to 160:13

26

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Illowsky, Rebecca Maxine 3/22/2011
Plaintiff's
Designations

8:14 to 8:15
9:8-10
10:4 to 10:17
10:18 to 11:10
11:23 to 13:1
14:4 to 14:11
16:10 to 14:18
16:23 to 17:2
17:3 to 18:12
19:11 to 20:18
21:14 to 23:15
24:10 to 24:18
25:5 to 25:13
26:5 to 26:13
28:19 to 30:12
31:9 to 33:3
34:11 to 34:20
35:14 to 36:23
40:22 to 41:5
44:3 to 44:24
50:1 to 51:10
53:24 to 54:5

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

I
14:12-14

I

18:13-19:10

I

23:16-18

R

I

53:8-23
27

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

56:23 to 57:11
61:7 to 61:9
61:11 to 62:8
65:6 to 66:14
66:22 to 67:12
67:17 to 68:5
68:15 to 68:17
69:2 to 71:3
71:13 to 71:15
71:22 to 72:1
77:24 to 78:15
86:9 to 87:19
87:23 to 88:11
88:13 to 89:5
89:11 to 91:7
91:9 to 91:25
92:15 to 92:19
93:4 to 93:12
94:10 to 94:12
96:14-15
96:19-21
99:7 to 99:25
101:15 to 101:23
102:1 to 102:3

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations
I

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations
57:12-13

I
I

71:5-12
72:2-4

R, I

87:21

I
V
A, V

89:7-10

I

98:3-5

I

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

102:4-103:1

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

103:2-9
28

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

V, P, IC

Plaintiff's
Designations

114:20 to 115:18
115:20 to 115:24
116:1 to 116:15
116:21 to 116:22
116:24 to 117:7
117:9 to 117:14
117:16 to 117:25
118:1 to 120:8
130:25 to 131:7
135:17 to 136:20
147:7 to 147:21
156:1 to 156:21
157:1 to 157:17
157:20 to 157:22
157:24 to 159:24
165:2 to 165:23

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

I

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

116:16-19

R, I, V, C
I
I, R
R

R, V, A

29

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Jeh, Glen 2/14/2011
Plaintiff's
Designations

12:14 to 12:17
13:16-22
16:9 to 17:2
17:11 to 18:22
18:25
19:5 to 19:20
19:25 to 20:20
22:9 to 22:25
23:6 to 23:20
23:24 to 24:23
25:4 to 25:23
26:25 to 27:20
27:25 to 28:12
28:15 to 29:9
29:23 to 30:19
31:9 to 31:12
31:14 to 31:20
32:4 to 32:6
32:8 to 32:24
33:5 to 33:8
33:10 to 33:18
33:20 to 34:15

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

R, P
R, P

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

19:1-4

M,K
V, F
R
I

26:20-24

C, V, I

32:25-33:4

V, ARG, R

30

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

34:17
36:11 to 37:9
37:11 to 37:14
38:1 to 38:8
41:4 to 41:13
41:15 to 42:12
42:14 to 42:20
42:22 to 44:18
45:7 to 45:23
47:17 to 48:10
53:12 to 53:18
58:6 to 59:23
60:10 to 60:13
61:3 to 61:18
62:16 to 64:2
64:9 to 64:13
64:15 to 65:4
65:6 to 67:15
68:6 to 72:8
72:14 to 74:15
76:23 to 77:10
78:18 to 81:8
82:4 to 82:19
84:21 to 85:8

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

ARG, V, I
I

37:15-25
39:4-21
40:5-17
41:14

I

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

IC

ARG, V, C
ARG, V, M

67:16-68:5

I

I
31

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

85:22 to 88:22
93:15 to 94:11
96:7 to 99:20
100:20 to 101:8
105:4 to 105:7
105:23 to 106:17
107:18 to 107:25
108:2 to 108:21
108:23 to 109:9
112:6 to 112:9
112:11 to 113:1
113:3 to 113:18
113:20 to 114:7
114:9 to 114:16
116:17 to 117:2
117:4 to 118:3
119:8 to 119:10
119:17 to 120:1
120:6 to 121:11
121:18 to 121:20
123:24 to 124:13
124:24 to 125:2
127:5 to 127:21

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

105:23-106:17

IC

I
I
105:8-20
ARG, V, IH, M
ARG, V, IH, M
C, ARG, IH, V
ARG, IH, V, M
ARG, V
IH, ARG, V
I, V
I, C
I

32

Plaintiff's
Designations

144:23 to 145:13
152:13 to 152:19
152:23 to 153:3
154:1 to 154:5
154:16-21
155:9 to 156:1
156:25 to 158:4
162:4 to 162:14
162:21 to 163:5
170:15 to 172:2
173:16 to 174:19
175:10-18
178:24 to 180:9
180:25 to 181:7
181:9 to 182:10
197:15 to 198:4
199:13 to 201:2
201:10 to 201:12
204:23 to 205:22
206:1 to 208:12
208:15 to 208:18
213:3
213:5 to 214:4

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations
I

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations
146:14-147:2

I

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

152:20-22

I

H
H

I
I
R

V, IH
R
33

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

147:3-17, 147:22148:3

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations
IC, I (should include
147:18-21)

Plaintiff's
Designations

214:9 to 214:18
241:9 to 241:23
242:25 to 243:6
243:8 to 243:9
244:16 to 244:25
245:2 to 245:14
245:22 to 246:2
246:5 to 246:8
246:10 to 246:15
267:6 to 267:7
267:10 to 268:12

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

V, R, I
V, R, I, P, F
I
SP, ET, R, P, F
F, ET, R, P
F, ET, R, P
F, ET, R, P
F, ET, R, P
F, ET, R, P

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

242:15-23

34

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Konig, David 7/8/2011
Plaintiff's
Designations

4:3 to 4:14
8:23 to 9:14
10:12 to 11:6
12:3 to 12:19
14:2 to 14:5
14:10 to 14:17
15:5 to 15:11
15:13 to 15:14
16:4 to 17:10
23:3 to 23:24
33:20 to 34:8
34:21 to 34:23
34:25 to 35:3
35:6 to 36:3
39:6-7
39:25 to 42:4

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

11:7-9

15:18-19, 15:21-23
20:16-18

I

31:21-22, 32:17-33:15
34:9-20

32:4-10

39:8-21
42:5-7

F

35

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Montes, Frank 3/17/2011
Plaintiff's
Designations

5:22 to 6:1
6:5 to 6:7
10:1 to 11:1
11:16 to 11:18
19:17 to 20:6
25:14 to 27:19

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

R, LC, F, SP, H

36

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Nemeth, Andras 7/14/2011
Plaintiff's
Designations

8:19 -20
11:6-9
11:16-23
11:25 to 13:18
15:19-22
16:9-18:7
22:14-19
22:25-23:2
23:15-25
24:13-23
28:14-21
29:15-30:6
30:8-32:5
32:7-14
33:2-12
34:20 to 35:17
39:6-9
36:11-17
52:4-6
52:8-24
53:1-7
53:9-19

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

I

11:10-13

R

ET
I

22:20-24

I
R, P, I
I, R, P
R, P
R, P
R, P, I
I, R, P
R, P, I
I, V, C, R, P
R, P, I, V
R, P
R, P
R, P
R, P, I

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

55:9-56:25

R, P, IC, V, A

23:10-13
25:21-26:1
28:2-13

32:15-17
35:18-21
35:22-36:5
36:18-23

54:18-24

ET, IC
37

Plaintiff's
Designations

56:6-9
56:11-18
56:20-25
57:22-24
58:1-13
60:2-20
64:8 to 64:17
65:20 to 65:25
118:15-19
118:21 to 119:19
122:16-19
123:24 to 124:3
124:5-16
126:16 to 127:2
127:4-10
218:21-219:21
219:23-220:5
221:24-222:7
223:3-224:3
224:5-10

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations
V, A, R, P

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

V, A, R, P, I
R, P
R, P, I
R, P
I
I

54:18-24

ET, IC

55:9-56:25

R, P, IC, V, A

58:14-23

I

63:15-20
66:1-8

S

I

64:19-23

I
I, V

64:19-23
64:19-23

I

222:8-223:1

Oztekin, Bilgehan Uygar 3/8/2011
38

Plaintiff's
Designations

10:17 to 10:18
11:22 to 12:1
12:13-17
15:5 to 16:14
18:1 to 18:7
20:5 to 21:6
21:15 to 23:5
26:1 to 27:4
33:7 to 34:13
53:24 to 54:3
54:10 to 56:1
56:7 to 56:8
56:12 to 56:25
57:2 to 58:8
59:3 to 59:10
66:5 to 67:6
67:8 to 69:9
70:7 to 71:9
71:18 to 71:23
72:16 to 73:2
74:1 to 74:6
76:25 to 77:16
78:24 to 79:20

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

R, P

R, P
I, R, P
I
R, P

54:5-9

M, P

I
I
I

73:3-25
74:12-19
77:17-19

39

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

80:1 to 80:3
80:6 to 82:6
82:25 to 84:5
84:20 to 85:22
86:11 to 86:17
87:1 to 87:15
87:23 to 88:3
88:18 to 89:15
89:23 to 91:23
102:5 to 102:18
116:3 to 118:1
124:12 to 125:3
169:14 to 170:25
171:12 to 171:14
172:10 to 172:14
244:17 to 244:18
245:18 to 247:18

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

I
I

82:7-9
84:6-19

V, I

87:17-20, 88:4-15

I
I

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

118:2-6
123:11-124:9, 131:17132:11

R, UP, S, IC

R, P

I

40

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Perrault, Raymond 8/17//2011
Plaintiff's
Designations

7:8 to 7:10
16:15 to 17:22
18:6 to 20:8
22:19 to 23:25
30:20 to 31:6
32:14 to 33:5
36:9 to 37:1

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

SP, F

37:2

41

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Ponnekanti, Shankar 10/7/2010
Plaintiff's
Designations

8:8 to 8:22
8:25-9:4
9:11-20
9:22-23
10:4 to 10:11
13:7 to 14:3
14:13 to 14:19
14:24 to 15:2
15:20 to 16:20
17:7 to 17:10
17:16-23
18:19 to 20
18:23 to 19:5
20:1 to 20:11
21:25 to 22:2
22:7 to 22:19
22:22 to 23:2
26:6 to 26:25
27:5 to 27:14
27:19 to 28:13
30:9 to 30:25
31:6-13

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

I
I

10:18-21
12:14-16

I
I

10:21

I
I

23:3-10
26:1-5

I

23:11-18

I

28:21-29:3

I

31:1-5
42

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

R, P

Plaintiff's
Designations

31:15-16
33:23 to 34:2
34:4-13
34:15 to 34:19
34:21 to 34:24
36:23 to 37:2
37:12 to 37:21
38:8 to 38:12
38:23 to 39:5
39:9-12
40:11-19
41:19 to 41:16
41:21 to 42:3
42:6 to 42:18
43:21 to 44:9
44:11 to 45:13
47:7 to 47:10
47:19 to 47:22
48:10-24
50:7-11
51:7-12
52:11 to 53:10
53:12 to 54:8

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations
I

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations
31:17-20

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations
I

R
V, ARG, R, P, M
I, R, P
I, R, P

47:11-18

R, P

43

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

31:24-32:11

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations
ARG, I (should
include 32:12-17)

Plaintiff's
Designations

54:17 to 56:23
57:1 to 58:12
58:14 to 58:17
58:19 to 58:25
60:12 to 60:23
62:6 to 62:24
63:18 to 64:2
64:5 to 64:17
66:20 to 67:7
67:14 to 67:23
69:3 to 70:1
70:20 to 71:6
72:2 to 72:23
73:3 to 74:1
74:2 to 74:10
74:19 to 75:2
75:11 to 76:12
79:17 to 80:7
80:14 to 81:5
82:13 to 82:24
83:2 to 84:5
86:14 to 86:18
88:17 to 89:7
96:14 to 96:19

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

76:13-25

I, ET

77:1-9

R, P

R
V

I

R, P
44

Plaintiff's
Designations

97:2 to 97:6
97:11 to 97:21
99:3 to 100:2
100:7 to 100:11
100:17 to 101:5
101:9 to 101:13
102:12 to 103:12
108:6 to 108:21
108:25 to 109:4
112:9-12
113:5 to 113:8
114:20 to 115:4
115:23 to 116:22
117:8 to 117:10
117:12 to 118:9
118:17 to 119:8
120:7 to 120:14
120:21 to 120:22
121:2 to 121:9
121:15 to 121:18
121:20 to 121:23
122:18 to 123:1
123:14 to 123:15
123:17-19

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations
R, P

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

I

109:5-110:7

ET

V, M
I

121:24-122:4

I

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

R, P
R, P
I, P, R

45

122:5-17

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

124:14 to 124:20
126:18 to 127:4
127:21 to 128:5
128:23 to 129:8
131:24 to 132:4
132:12 to 132:20
134:11 to 135:24
137:14 to 137:23
138:9 to 139:1
141:1 to 141:19
143:8 to 143:9
143:11 to 143:13
144:10 to 146:23
147:20 to 148:14
149:2 to 149:5
149:7 to 149:21
150:4-20
155:18 to 156:5
164:3 to 164:19
164:20 to 165:9
167:2 to 167:19
168:2 to 168:22
169:17 to 170:2
175:18 to 175:20

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

I

132:21-133:3

I

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

137:24-138:8

R, P

R, I, P
R, P
R, P

R, P

46

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

175:22 to 176:12
179:11-12
180:21 to 182:13
183:16-20
192:15 to 193:8
193:10 to 193:19
194:10-22
203:4 to 204:11
204:13-14
206:1-17
208:5-17
237:13-21
246:11-23
253:13-25
256:17-23
256:25 to 259:7
262:1-14

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations
V, I, R
R, P

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

ARG, V
P, R, I
R, P

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

I

207:24-208:4
237:22-238:4

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

238:5-10

ARG, I, R, P

194:23-25

I
I
I
R, P

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

R, P

47

Rohe, Andre 2/4/2011
Plaintiff's
Designations

9:7 to 9:9
9:24 to 10:5
15:20 to 18:9
18:16 to 19:16
19:22 to 20:7
25:9 to 26:4
27:15 to 27:18
30:20 to 32:6
33:14-22
38:1 to 42:18
41:1 to 43:2
44:19 to 45:17
45:21 to 46:13
46:17 to 46:25
47:2 to 49:23
48:7 to 48:14
50:22 to 54:7
53:17 to 54:7
54:15 to 55:24
56:7 to 57:1

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

I
I
I

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

21:20-22:1
24:14-25:8, 26:5-27:14
30:4-19
37:20-25

I

45:18-20
46:15-16

S, I
S

49:24-50:12

I
I

55:25-56:6
57:2-5, 57:18-24,
58:1-2

58:13 to 58:23
48

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

59:1 to 59:14
60:23 to 64:16
72:1 to 73:8
74:19 to 75:15
81:21 to 82:1

I

60:10-22

I
I

79:24-81:20

49

Sonmez, Mustafa Kemal 8/15/2011
Plaintiff's
Designations

4:1 to 4:3
4:9 to 4:11
7:21 to 9:16
11:15 to 12:21
13:12 to 13:23
18:17 to 21:8
27:5 to 27:16
29:21 to 30:17
34:4 to 34:11
35:13 to 37:1
55:8 to 60:11
62:1 to 64:6
65:24 to 66:5
92:9 to 94:12
100:17 to 102:10

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

65:20-23, 66:6-18

CMP, MIS, CNF, UFP

ET
ET, NR
ET, NR
ET, NR, SP, F
I, SP, F, NR,

NR, LC, ET, F,
ET,

50

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Stolcke, Andreas 7/6/2011
Plaintiff's
Designations

3:4 to 3:6
7:22 to 9:1
10:23 to 12:4
14:21 to 15:15
16:11 to 18:9
36:21 to 38:19
51:18 to 52:6
54:4 to 54:14
55:1 to 55:10
74:11 to 77:7
78:5 to 79:2
79:21 to 80:7
82:12 to 82:17
90:2 to 91:9

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

SP, R, ET

18:10-17, 18:19,
18:21-23, 18:25-19:25
38:20-39:25

MIS, R, CNF UFP
R, MIS, UFP, CNF

NR
LC, SP, F
LC, SP, F
R, SP, F, ET
ET
SP

51

Plaintiff’s Countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

40:22-41:2

IC, ET

Ventilla, Max 7/31/2012
Plaintiff's
Designations

9:24 to 9:25
10:21-23
12:11-13:6
15:10-17:8
18:12 to 18:16
18:18 to 18:22
19:9 to 19:17
23:14 to 23:19
39:3-4
39:15 to 40:1
40:24 to 41:6
41:8 to 41:9
41:11 to 41:25
42:9 to 42:14
43:10 to 43:11
44:15 to 44:20
45:5 to 46:10
46:16 to 47:4
47:6 to 48:10
48:19 to 49:15
50:20 to 50:22
51:10 to 51:11

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

I

40:2-9

I

42:1-2

I
I

42:15-24
43:5-9

I
I
I

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

46:11-15
48:11-12
50:23-51:8

I

52

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

51:15 to 17
51:19 to 20
51:22
51:24
52:1
52:3
52:5
52:7
52:9
52:11
52:13 to 52:14
52:20
52:22 to 52:24
53:1 to 53:5
56:22 to 57:1
57:5 to 57:8
57:24 to 58:1
58:6 to 58:16
58:18 to 58:20
58:22 to 58:23
58:25 to 59:1
59:3 to 59:7
59:9 to 59:10
59:12

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

I

53:6-54:3

I

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

57:10-23

53

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

73:21 to 74:13
74:20 to 75:23
75:25
76:2
76:4 to 76:6
76:8
76:10
76:12 to 76:14
110:16 to 111:19
111:23 to 112:4
114:21 to 115:19
119:6 to 119:23
120:12 to 121:6
122:4 to 123:22
124:5 to 124:13
128:11 to 128:23
135:12 to 135:18
141:10 to 141:16
144:1 to 145:2
148:12 to 149:1
152:9 to 152:12
152:14 to 152:16
152:19 to 152:20
152:22 to 152:25

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

I
I

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

110:4-15
111:20-22

S
S

I
I

141:3-9, 141:17-19

V, I

54

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

153:2 to 154:25
170:15 to 171:20
183:1 to 186:18
186:24 to 187:10

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

I
I

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

169:15-170:14
186:19-23

I

55

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

186:24-187:10

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Weinberg, Aitan 3/2/2011
Plaintiff's
Designations

5:18 to 5:19
6:13-15
7:8 to 7:17
9:17 to 10:15
11:15 to 12:25
13:12 to 14:13
17:22 to 18:11
18:18 to 18:23
19:2 to 19:7
28:13 to 29:7
30:5 to 31:17
32:8 to 33:4
33:8 to 33:18
33:25 to 36:22
37:9 to 39:25
40:12 to 41:3
41:8 to 41:12
41:21 to 41:24
42:15 to 42:23
43:5 to 46:10
46:16 to 47:8
51:2 to 51:21

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

R
R
I

18:12-17

I
I
I
I
I, V
M, ET

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

18:12-17
31:18-32:3
32:4-7
18:12-17
18:12-17
41:13-20

R, V
I
ARG, V, I

47:9-10, 47:12-13
52:8-20
56

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

52:21 to 54:8
54:25 to 55:11
55:21 to 56:14
57:6 to 60:8
69:23 to 70:12
76:14-22
77:8 to 78:13
83:5 to 84:5
86:17 to 87:14
87:22 to 88:2
90:17 to 91:14
93:16 to 95:17
99:16-100:8
106:20 to 107:9
109:24 to 110:23

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

F, V
AA, I
R, I
R
R
I

I
R, P
I
I

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

18:12-17
70:13-71:3

R

84:6-10

107:10-12, 107:19-22
107:19-22

57

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Zamir, Oren E. 4/13/2011
Plaintiff's
Designations

9:13 to 9:14
10:3 to 10:16
10:22-25
11:18-20
12:10-14
13:16 to 13:18
14:23 to 15:20
16:12 to 16:20
17:1 to 18:2
18:8 to 18:10
18:17 to 18
19:3 to 19:8
21:18 to 22:14
23:6 to 23:10
24:7 to 24:12
29:23 to 30:7
35:21 to 36:14
36:16 to 36:21
36:22 to 38:19
38:21 to 40:8
41:10 to 41:21
45:5-6

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

I

14:13-22, 15:21-16:10

R

I

18:20-19:3

I

20:25-21:7, 21:11-17

I, R, P

28:23-29:22

V, M
I

41:22-42:17

58

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

45:9 to 45:11
46:17 to 47:9
47:11 to 47:15
47:17 to 47:19
47:21 to 49:16
50:5 to 50:7
50:9 to 50:15
50:17 to 51:20
51:23 to 52:11
52:19 to 52:23
53:6 to 54:13
54:20 to 55:2
55:4 to 55:24
57:6 to 57:9
62:19-23
63:4-15
65:2-3
65:5-9
65:12 to 66:1
70:1-4
70:11 to 71:13
73:5 to 73:16
82:3 to 82:6
83:25 to 85:8

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

I

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

49:23-50:4

V

V
70:5-10
I
I

83:14-24
59

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

85:10 to 86:1
86:10 to 87:16
88:11 to 89:4
90:14 to 90:23
91:13 to 91:18
91:23 to 93:12
93:18-23
93:25 to 94:3
94:13 to 95:5
97:13 to 97:25
98:3 to 98:18
98:25 to 99:8
99:13 to 99:17
99:20 to 100:10
100:17 to 100:25
101:2 to 101:8
101:11-17
103:6 to 103:21
104:22 to 104:24
105:1 to 105:17
105:24 to 106:1
106:3 to 106:6
106:13 to 106:21

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations
V, C

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

I

90:24-91:10, 91:19-21

ET, L, IC

91:13-21

93:14-17
V, A
94:5-12

V. C, A
V
V, A

I

106:9-12

60

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

107:4 to 107:13
108:4 to 108:5
109:4 to 109:17
109:21 to 110:1
110:18 to 110:20
110:22
111:4 to 111:7
111:14 to 111:22
111:24 to 112:3
112:14 to 113:8
113:10 to 113:13
113:16 to 114:7
114:9 to 115:11
115:7 to 115:21
116:7 to 117:14
117:16 to 118:17
119:3 to 119:9
119:11 to 119:12
122:6 to 122:16
124:5 to 124:16
124:18 to 124:23

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations
I
I
I

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations
106:22-107:3, 107:1419,
107:23-108:3
108:7-109:3

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

I

115:23-116:3
V. A
I

118:18-119:2

I

122:17-123:1, 123:1720

I

124:24-125:5, 125:710
61

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

139:20-21
140:1-17
141:20 to 141:7
142:11 to 142:19
142:21 to 143:25
144:2 to 144:19
147: 22 to 148:8
148:10-21
148:23 to 149:8
151:17 to 152:4
152:6 to 153:1
163:4 to 164:7
164:10-14
165:2 to 165:7
171:4 to 171:23
172:9 to 172:19
173:5 to 173:8
173:10 to 173:25
174:2 to 174:3
174:9 to 174:17
174:19
178:14 to 178:24

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations
I
I

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

S

146:10-24

I
I

153:2-4
163:13-164:9, 164:16165:1, 165:8-14

I

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

171:24-172:8, 172:2324

V

62

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

179:1 to 180:8
180:10 to 180:22
186:7 to 186:17
186:20 to 187:17
189:6-9
189:10 to 189:18
190:4 to 190:19
190:21 to 190:25
191:2 to 191:9
191:11 to 193:17
194:11 to 194:13
194:15 to 195:18
196:3 to 197:13
197:15-16
197:18 to 199:6
201:2 to 201:9
201:11 to 201:25
202:1 to 205:4
209:20 to 209:24
210:4 to 210:5
210:7
210:9 to 210:14
225:17 to 226:1
226:3 to 227:10

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

R, P
I, R, P

R, P
193:20-194:4
R, P
R, P
V, A, R, P, I
R, P
V, S, SP, R, P
R, P, V
R, P
V, C, R, P

199:7-200:5

63

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

Plaintiff's
Designations

227:14 to 228:10
228:16 to 228:25
229:2 to 229:6
230:2 to 230:8
230:10 to 230:11
230:13 to 230:22
230:24 to 231:16
232:3 to 232:4
232:6 to 233:2
236:5 to 236:18
239:3 to 239:12
242:2 to 242:6
248:15 to 249:10
250:18 to 251:6
254:11 to 254:14
254:16 to 254:24
264:20 to 265:2
265:4 to 265:17
269:19 to 269:25

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's
Designations
R, P
PRIV, R, P, V, C
V, C, R, P, I
R, P
V, R, P
V, C, R, P
R, P

V, R, P
I
V
I, SP, S

Defendant's Counter
Designations to
Plaintiff's
Designations

Plaintiff's Objections
to Defendant's
Counter-Designations

229:8-14

S, R

262:14-15, 264:17-19
269:9-16

01980.51575/5782829.2

64

Plaintiff’s countercounter-designations

Defendant's
Objections to
Plaintiff's Countercounter-Designations

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, David E. Moore, hereby certify that on February 28, 2014, the attached document was
electronically filed with the Clerk of the Court using CM/ECF which will send notification to the
registered attorney(s) of record that the document has been filed and is available for viewing and
downloading.
I further certify that on February 28, 2014, the attached document was Electronically
Mailed to the following person(s):
Karen Jacobs Louden
Jeremy A. Tigan
Regina S.E. Murphy
Morris, Nichols, Arsht & Tunnell LLP
1201 North Market Street, 18th Fl.
P.O. Box 1347
Wilmington, DE 19899-1347
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]

Marc S. Friedman
Dentons US LLP
1221 Avenue of the Americas
New York, NY 10020-1089
[e-mail]

Jennifer D. Bennett
Dentons US LLP
1530 Page Mill Road, Ste. 200
Palo Alto, CA 94304-1125
[e-mail]

Mark C. Nelson
Richard D. Salgado
Steven M. Geiszler
Dentons US LLP
2000 McKinney, Suite 1900
Dallas, TX 75201
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]

Andrew M. Grodin
Dentons US LLP
101 JFK Parkway
Short Hills, NJ 07078
[e-mail]

/s/ David E. Moore
Richard L. Horwitz
David E. Moore
Bindu A. Palapura
POTTER ANDERSON & CORROON LLP
[phone]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
932168 / 34638

2