HOLLISTER v. SOETORO et al

Filing 15

RESPONSE TO ORDER OF THE COURT re 14 Order to Show Cause filed by GREGORY S. HOLLISTER. (tr)

HOLLISTER v. SOETORO et al

Doc. 15

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

: : Plaintiff, : vs. : CIVIL ACTION NO. 1:08-cv-02254 JR : BARRY SOETORO, et al., : : Defendants. :

GREGORY S. HOLLISTER,

PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE TO ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE

Plaintiff, Gregory S. Hollister, through his counsel, John D. Hemenway, Esquire and Philip J. Berg, Esquire, hereby Respond to Honorable James Robertson's Order to Show Cause issued February 25, 2009 as follows:

1.

Pursuant to this Honorable Court's Order of February 11, 2009, Plaintiff

through his undersigned counsel complied with this Honorable Court's Order and timely filed a Response in Opposition to the Defendants Motion to dismiss on February 13, 2009 which appears on the Pacer Court Docket as item number thirteen (13). A true and correct copy is attached hereto as EXHIBIT "A".

2.

Plaintiff's Response in Opposition to the Defendants Motion to Dismiss

consisted of thirty eight (38) pages in total, which included a proposed Order, one (1) page; Plaintiff's Brief in Opposition to Defendants Motion to Dismiss, two (2) pages; Plaintiff's Memorandum of Law in support of his Opposition to Defendant's Motion,

I:\HollisterResponseOSC02262009.doc

1
Dockets.Justia.com

fifteen (15) pages; Exhibits, fifteen (15) pages; Affidavit of Service, one (1) page; and Declaration of Lisa Liberi, five (5) pages.

3.

In this Honorable Court's Order to Show Cause his Honor states he

received "many blank pages, decorated only by what appear to be botanical drawings and the illegible photocopy of an Hawaiian certificate of live birth....The blank pages were either somebody's idea of a joke (in which case I don't get it) or a mistake." Counsel for Plaintiff would never file blank pages or attempt to play any type of a joke on this Honorable Court as Counsel for Plaintiff have too much respect for the Judicial system.

4.

Plaintiff's Brief and Memorandum of Law in Opposition to the

Defendants Motion to Dismiss does contain as EXHIBIT "2" the Hawaii Department of Home Lands manual with a sample copy of a Hawaiian certificate of live birth. Three(3) pages in the Hawaii Department of Home Lands manual has a picture of a tree, however, this document as well as all pages filed in Plaintiff's Brief and Memorandum of Law in Opposition to the Defendants Motion are very legible and are on the Pacer Court docketing system as item thirteen (13). See EXHIBIT "A". There are absolutely no blank pages in Plaintiff's Brief and supporting Memorandum of Law in Opposition to the Defendants Motion to Dismiss. The entire Brief and Memorandum of Law in Opposition to the Defendants Motion is very clear, legible and accessible on Pacer.

I:\HollisterResponseOSC02262009.doc

2

5.

As for this Honorable Court's reference to the Motion his Honor deemed

frivolous in his February 11, 2009 Order wherein he states in his Order to Show Cause, "What was frivolous about the motion, however, was not the fact that it was filed, but the suggestion that "duties" could be filed in the registry of this court." Counsel for Plaintiff is unsure as to what is meant by this. The only thing Counsel can think of is in the Motion for Leave to File the Interpleader Action and Deposit funds with the Court, Counsel explained the Interpleader action which involved duties owed by the Plaintiff and requested Plaintiff be allowed to file an Interpleader Bond with the Court in lieu of a cash deposit if this Honorable Court required a monetary deposit.

6.

This Honorable Court also made note of the Declaration of Paralegal, Lisa

Liberi, "a paralegal (who works in the office of a Pennsylvania lawyer who has not been admitted to practice in this Court)". Counsel for Plaintiff, Philip J. Berg, Esquire and Lawrence J. Joyce, Esquire, sponsored by Washington, D.C. licensed attorney, John D. Hemenway, Esquire, filed a Motion on December 31, 2008 requesting Admittance to the Court pro hac vice. Although Judge Robertson ruled February 11, 2009 that he was holding these motions in Abeyance, a hearing has not been set by this Honorable Court to rule on Mr. Berg and Mr. Joyce's pro hac vice requests.

7.

Counsel for Plaintiff have complied with this Honorable Court's Orders

and filed their Brief and Memorandum of Law in Opposition to the Defendants

I:\\HollisterResponseOSC02262009.doc

3

Motion to Dismiss timely on February 13, 2009, which is docketed through Pacer as docket entry number thirteen (13) and can be verified on Pacer. Plaintiff's Brief and Memorandum of Law are legible copies and download legible. Thus, Plaintiff

respectfully requests this Court to deny the Defendants Motion as conceded.

Respectfully submitted,

Dated: February 26, 2009

s/ John D. Hemenway _____________________________ John D. Hemenway, Esquire Hemenway & Associates Attorney for Plaintiff 4816 Rodman Street NW Washington, D.C. 20016 [phone] D.C. Bar No. 379663

Dated: February 26, 2009

s/ Philip J. Berg ___________________________ Philip J. Berg, Esquire Attorney for Plaintiff 555 Andorra Glen Court, Suite 12 Lafayette Hill, PA 19444-2531 Identification No. 09867 [phone]

I:\\HollisterResponseOSC02262009.doc

4

EXHIBIT "A"

I:\\HollisterResponseOSC02262009.doc

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 1 of 33

* +,-+3,. 30001-, 1 / / 7 1 3578 1 24659 8: *******<* 100>10A31CEDGH, ******* = ******; >? 0@ 3 A BDFBGIJ 1 @,,.3-13,39 1 /
5 1 KLLM6N: 86 4 7O* 1 $"" $ %%! $( $$ )!""P$$"$RR!"!#TU )!(!V QSQ) & $ Q W X Y&U $( '! %Z$(Y'! $ " ) Y % # Y" !$'\^]_ \^]_ " []_[ ]_` ![ & ! 5
4a c/5

>8de78859 # E6
8

b
E dJc
4

J6
8
8

c58gg 55h734655cJ 5 , 48 5 f/
885h5 E 5 8
a,

i 8

6
75
eF

a 8
5ck5
38
88 c 8 F
j c
9
i 8 8

8
5c 8cEd
8

f 5c 85aj a4 8 8e

$""a
8

6
d8 l,mn 5a 8 d5 >k G4mn5c 8 mno G4mn
$"" $ 5
1l4dpppBq c
5fppp B G ppppppppppppppp ppppppppppppppp 785
8
8 6 , 4 J bc/5

8de
E d c

>J 8

8d 45 a E 96
l 8> 02465789
8

8

6
1 5 2 9

3
3

88

! " $" ## %$"&" %$'() #$# !

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 2 of 33

* +,-+3,. 30001-, 1 / / 7 1 3578 1 24659 8: *******<* 100>10A31DFEH, ******* = ******; >? 0@ 3 A CEGCIJ B 1 @,,.3-13,3 9 1 / -@ 1 KLLM6N: 86 4 7O 1 * P'! %QPP$ S ($"!(%$ S % $ $ R T( $ P RT !&$" PP$"&"$%$ $ %%! ( $$ )!""U$$"$VV!"!#XY )!(!S $ P&Y RWR) & $ R TZ " ) $( '! %Q$(P'! " !$ P % # P %YYYY\^]_ \^]_ "#P ]_[ []_` [! >8
8 9
+c789e

b5
ijff 6 A a b5

8d/ 9
f
5g9
hf8c

Fj987

a5 j f9
cj5
Jd
j 8
f 6 d k

J k

5l0a
F8F k

J - b
5l9
a

85l6b
jf
8
88
f
5l 6 j 885l@ 8

3
f

8
8

l58mm55n7 465e

/
88i f 5 d/
885n5 F 5 f
5g8h 8 3 , > bB 5lJ

h
6
j

4pq 8
f, le
5 li8 j58ol G pqB f g 5lBpqr
9 a
cc8 4pq 9 jl1 8 f 88 s b5
5
cjc
8

t 9
5l 4
c
55
885ll f 8 / s >9
5
5
fF95
c5l 95
c8 5 56 l
a
f
4
b
l
5> 6 9

F 5
5 8

b
l85 95
c 95
c5l F
lt l f 8A F ob 5 s b5
f5558594

5
86j 9 9
5
9
4
85l
8u8j
9

9 F568f55l
5
88
cF56
5
f a
9

fv5lGu F9
9
5lf985
9 8 F

! " $" ## %$"&" %$'() #$# !

02465789
8

8

6
1 5 2 9

3
3

88

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 3 of 33

6

8599
58

5 6 9
5 5
8 59 8

!

5

5 9" #
58
58

5 8

6
89
8 46

58$ ! 4 ! 8 88

%
96

94 P SUQQZ\ 5
1#4() *O**TV*X*[******
5& ( ' * Q **W** ****** *R * *Y * *T +
,
!9 .

/0 246289;07 0 357 6 :3;6 11 7 <<=89?8 ' < 5>
@
&
A55

=&BB' 79 )B<&
9+ 0

5
8)E
C (DF 8 G&H '&BI E( <I D I I I P _Z a WQ cZ 5
1#4() *O*^*[**QXb*****
5& ( ' *Q**`Z*W****** *] *****a * * A5
,8 J

.

,/0 246289;07 0 357 6 :3;6 11 7 &&
88 & <FC 9 5
'< K6 % @
LM<& 8 DF' = ="58'DE
85 (< C( G'H D'E <( B( < O**`**Z *_* P dQ f * W 5
1#4() ***S**e**`*c****
5& ( ' *Qb*QX**Z *^***** ,!

J5 8 6 .

7 7

J58
6 N= 5
B&865
K DE% @
C K5!(&
8 ? (E ' G(H BD) '' BB& ' 58FE ? )E C 6 6 02465789
8

8

6
1 5 2 9

3
3

88

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 4 of 33

!#$#%&'(#""% !) +(,%& ! " " % "* " $ "" ! %&"""%! "%"$$'!" ( % , !% % ' .&&/"%$%&%"00"&23"4 .#" ! )1). ," % ) +5 ! ,"4 $!#% "%"#! * "% $ &" ' " % ' ! ! " . " .236&%('" " 75
98
:

5 8858

4=?@55 9

9 ;
4< ;6
> @A B

98

8
B
9 E
G
5
C ;558D580 <;
9 F
H
88
9
J8 5 9

<E; 95
75
I 6 9
75
5 8 95D3 ;4

599
9C55988
K8L5
8
588 8;9 5
5
3 <99
J <

8 7 5 8 9
8 5559

48
B 8
J8 5NOA
6
88 B
9 6
89
58 86
M 6 9
N PQH
; J8 5NOA75
95

5
8S
L
88;
6 9
NPR 9
5<;
4<
8I
T9 8
5<595
9J8 575
J8 5NU=QH6
88
88

6 9
M9
I 6 9
5N>P

J8 5N>P@ 6 9
VR N H:5599 B89
;65 99
BH

5 8D

5
I8 9
7
W I 5X

7
X

;

5985< @Y5Z65
D>1@56 558 4

F85;9 W5D? @58
9@@
L58 ? [ \

8 87

:5[< B
J8
<
899 8 5 6 6 W9 6 D S

5
9 <8

J 6 9

:
858
X
F8Q9

8
5X466
98;
9 < 8 5

095
X

85
D;58
9 8
J8C
5

B
B 586559 898 <588
: <
7B
7B
: 55 9
: <8 9 59:9
75
J8 58

8:
858
X5
9
9 B89
I 6 9
095
< 8
F8 8
9 8 Q9 95
X
5X

Z9

8
X
F
95
58
0

8 4 585 5
Q90

8

88 8
:5

<
8 5<58095
B 9
5X

S

9 B5J 6 9
<

8 B
8X 4
8
7 8 5
8899 8
48
:5

8;8
975
9
9
8

D85 D5P9
9
I
8 J8 5898
98
9 8
5X4] 6 9
<8
;55

OR : 4
M 8 X N 02465789
8

8

6
1 5 2 9

3
3

88

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 5 of 33

056
8

87

5 8
89
5 89
6

9 "5

!
8
!8

#
89
5%
9
#5$#
% 8 #4
# "5
& # 8 5 8 8 !8 50'
%8#7

5'

#
6 9
%
9
6 5' %
5 7 8
8 #
#
5%
89

9 8
5)

*+

5
8 %
# #4( '55
4 , 8 8) *. )
5 )4
6
9'5# 5
/8 5
7
%&

6 #5
8'
# '
%
/
8 /8'9#
%8 8' 9'#
'9 8
' 59 7%

5# 5
59

$

5
85
'58095
5
8
)4
#
9 #/8

%

#5# 5
#6
0

8

!8 459'9
8
985
/ ' ' 96
& 5 95#

## ! 8 8
5
5'
89 8
)
819095
8 5

5 8 5

5

#! 6 9

8
7
%
5
5#

5

555
%5
8 %
4'6
#

8' 4%

## 5 )
8
)

095
8 5898
9
5
5 8 5
195

#! 6 9

# 9"5
& 8 8

!8 5 5
'
'

5)

8
)5

6 9
#/8#) 489
8
819
8
095
8"5
!8 589
9#5#

#9
& 6 9
#4

86 # 4 '
)

5896
9898

#
!8
8
4

6
#% 5#
% 9 "5
'6
#
9&
5#8#'9
% 9
8 9
!
$#6

88

"5
&

(
9 8
5)

*23 '55
4 ,4. 8) *

#9#
8

6
845647 5

8 8 55 4
88 5 5 384
5+47788598
"5
8
581454
4
! 9#89
& 8 )
819095
'
5#
8
1
8!8 8 5

5

#5 #
! 8

8 #
8

889%

8

8&9 5
85# 849 5
! !
$6 # 8 8 "5
'998#
9
!8 5878859898 9
&8

89"5
& 6 9

4
! 5

#
#"5
8
5

%
5 85#98
6
9
& 83#8
6 8
#
8 6
%8
89
%5
8'

#
# "

5#)
'

4

8
8 02465789
8

8

6
1 5 2 9

3
3

88

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 6 of 33

!"
4#
%& 855&8
$% 5
5$

' %&&(
8%
8
88 9 #
5

$

9
$6
&
8(
&55
5 )6 &
(
&
8

$
*85 5(
$%95(9*9 5 & 48
'8 5
5
*
5
& 6 9
&#&+
( 85
9(53 6
(('8 534%6785
3 9

6 9

5#7 6 9
9

, 8 5 ,6
(('8 5(

865
58
75 5

5
8
6 9
5((-

*& -
6 8 78
.5(-
95-5$
%( !"1 6 5 95
' %
8
0 58 / 2&78859 8%(5

5#456-&$ 9

4
' %

3(34%467
&85
9 $%9
8

+6
'8
8+$

4
9% 8
( $

8 %5(((

+#5#6 559
( &
5 9

*8
5#456
85
$%9&+
(5'3 &+34%567
$9
98
5
4

%
: 9*

!" &&($6
9$$9
( 8;% #5

( 2 %
8% 5

8
599 9& #
'8
8$

9$$9 &'8

&<9
%9(
8

+&6

8
592
%3((585
9 # 5
(($65>4(
*
8

58 5)
&$5(9*9 6
8 9
4?5(8& *9 6 9
$
8
5 = 8& $

5
889 5
%8
(58(@8
5
(( &8#5($
4

(

6
*8 & 8
8 & $65

( 8

6
=78
8&$5% 8 9
8+ (596 ( >?8-
&- (
8 88
8 8AA7B
%&
8
8
68

6
5
9( 576 985(58

8 (

8& 8 8
4AC6
68
-

(58$((5(*5(D *
85
#54A7& 945
$

, 59
9 89 $%9
8$

89

*8
5#467 8
(

+ ' %3( + 4%5 6 (& % 9& 3 5 0

(8

6
'8
&

(5

9 -
* 5 %98
5 9 88 & 88 85
5 81 8*88
4 <( 465&4
9 ($( 5$

( $ 54& 8

3 5 5 %9 #8%

8#8
$ $

5
8
*5
-588 %%E74788%%
$&-&& 4, *4
99 75 5
"G"I3$$
J8*8
& K,2&4% -
F"HH 5&$<
B 1
%&58 34654&$

5
DLM"A --$$
J8*

; 5 9

$ ! LN1- &$A9$
A 5 8 56A8
P&P 9 Q8$%
* 5
4& $

5

6O4P
%5&6 $9( & &

$ *

8
*5$
84&5%$6
%9&(

% ( 86 85
%
8
4

5 5 788%%-5
R 5 5
8$5&+%99

(5&# 99
7 -

95
4
#+
&
$ &+(465<*9

5
8
8(
$8(
5
8

5 98

5 &$
$$ 5$5$ 3 4 02465789
8

8

6
1 5 2 9

3
3

88

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 7 of 33

8

5 8

!#

$%%(( *! 5
9
"

&''! )+ ,(') /12 #85458

8

4
' - . 13

5

9 9 &3 0 5 !7! *7&)&;%)<!%-9&.00@

8 6 8 9-:%! 9!=> ?&%@AB020/ C#
/@D : !=G(H I@B01//1C#
# @/EF <! 9-022@# /2D @1

888

J50

8
588
6 995
8 K
6 8 L9 988 8
89

59

5 4
M
88 8
88

N
8859
8
M 8J O88

5
8

5
8

4656

4
5 L #
Q 3 5 R5 8 8
6 5 8 P 8
L
34654

5
5594636
5

8 4 5 R

88
5 L 8 J 6
5985
3465
1L
6
8 58
598 5 R 4
S
56 58
4

S 95 1
48L 465
L
6
8 5
1 85
S53 5 R 4
"
56 S
"6
9

L5543465
Q

5
5
R M 556 5 8R5
54
5594

85
J4 5
5
L89 9 585
T
R
586 9

J

L554
8U6
5
N3 554 8
4 5

346558
75 5

@/5

5 4
5
8
/I5
N8 Q
VM5
6
5
8
U "

6
958 5544

5
5

W X6 8 8
44 R

4
J 5 6

5

L 3

56

" ZZ] _` aZc _deef Yeg^
4
9
8 Y [\^ Z b^ d\Z^ [h
ijgd\gk3l59"

9

5
ll54 [eeZj
89 3 5 #
l

5
8

"

5
9
5"

5
4l5
/186
594
5
8
ll
/S/5
4 5
8 8 95

5
644
9
B
48L

5

5
4548
5 8 6
95
LJ5

"

8 5 5

5
8
9 8

9587
6 7 5
6 3 R .346558
88
85
#J6
B4m /5 5 47 993

8
8 5

5859
5Q
5
75 5

5
6 5
"
9

M5
6 J 8 7
9 5
34658

5

5
8
8
8
5 M 5 RL94
55 5
9
58

88 4654
5 5

opq q ^t 8

8
63 5 R
7

n Y rsk M 02465789
8

8

6
1 5 2 9

3
3

88

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 8 of 33

5
5

575 5

5
8

98 4
8

!" 6
5 8
3!$"945 5
&558
9 #

8

%

7
59 ' 9 8 45 5
555
4

5 5

(5 448
"

7

59 8&55

'048
5 55*
88,58 &55 '89 89
)8+ 4 4 (
8
.0 585&55'
05 8

05
-/*
49
(88
7 "4
5

5 5
5
485
)5&55

(8

7
5455899
(
&5581

5575 5

5
8

94'

!"
5 8 #3!$
846584

5
8
3465 2 8 3 5 %

8" 5 598
( 5&55 '
4

8 3

5
8

5
"
"9
!"
4 6

8
8
5&55 8 4'7
(

5
8

4
8"

"
8 8 *
055
!"

8

75 5

5
5 5
78
!# 77!$8

6
6 5

59 5 5 8 87 5 5 95
8

9:; ; >@
6 8

8 < =?A 8 * 84"5858 )
788598%

58
5

86 9
4
3 B5
9

856 B

8
88 9

6 8 85 3 8

3

8

6
5% 88 CDEFG8H=> > ;> JKM6N>OPQQRST5 UL4>SLGL6V5>5 VP> I L4MN 4 P>M> O KM6 >> 6P>N WS> > C L T >

*
885

8

6
B5
8 5 58 9
9
% 6 9

88 85Z0.B5
9536
8 59
5 X5)YY09

6 9

B5

988

8
B5
36
8 5

86

9 89
%

6 9
6

8

6

6
8*
\^acedhac# 5%
8
6 8
1[ ]_bdfg a dX 8 ` b 89
$i0* YY0$lhdfm bo_a_ahdhr st# 9 /Yjk# 01] `ednd `c\dpq ^l _dX ) 02465789
8

8

6
1 5 2 9

3
3

88

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 9 of 33

89
8
8
!""# &"((*"# -/14 9
#$% '")( #$+, .02 3 ,5 5528047/23849 -/=.=4=AA 0;2>7@B40DE89
8 6 .7549 3;05504 82>0? 344 71 54=A 7 9 : < @ BC = , *
8
!"#'%&'')G"#
# "F' " #' " * 9 !

I8
!
!
)*)

5

5 98 H9 J 9'5* 5

1 KL5MA 65;;-;OD165.1 1-2> 14N4 =54=4LD5 =-4 5;=8 : P * 6

8
R5 5 6
9 Q * 6
55 8
)
S5 ! Q
8 Q556
95
S8J565 8
6 5

5 !1
8 J *
8
4
S
8H95
S Q

HT5

+ 4 U
8 *

#

H

8H95
S
8 "55
S 95
S
5

TU U
59T

5
8

95
9 5 J
5 95 8 U 8 8U J QJ88
J
8Q
9!
)*V!
WX5 J
SU ! !8 5 9'5S55
5
548!
S85

J65
5

8S5U 9
59
UY6 U8 9
8J5 89
6 5 58
H58H95
S5
J! 58

8

8 J56 U UU 88

1Z654A\L8=:808?=AB4 1^ -? ""($`$
6
- 8[4 704 83A@34A]2 6 =4 _("""_* 4 3"
##RU89598JS

5!
)*S55
55
5 "#
!
U5
8a 9'5!
V9

U S6
5J65
5

4
5U958H
U85 8 9
8J5
8

5

6 U

1bB=4A,/84 -/. =c0.A,0DE89
8
8
95
SY
-8B4 -5c =-. 4 7>4 7* 9
!"#'%&'')S"# # 'F) #' " "* RU8
94

88
8H95
S

6
58 !
5

Q 8
J
U U5 88
J
8Q
95%
UH

J5

5 8
! ! 5U5
5
5
99
6 8 V

8

8U!8 !
)- 54A\L8=
6 58H95
S
8
9'YZ6 8[4 704 :802.84 34A 1^ -""($"#
9809;7.4 83-5?=A 4 2 6 = _( _ Q##
51 =55-5 @ B] 3 " "* , c5 021:8d?@34A\25'""e)*Q568
6 7-4 8=4=AB4 =8"'* Q _V 8 8 02465789
8

8

6
1 5 2 9

3
3

88

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 10 of 33

8
5
85

!
$%$

6 89

895
!" 9#5
58 8

%59!&6

658
&88
! 6
9 895
5
&
8 9
5
&8' 5 8
68
%&)85

&5
98*
,.01

8& (
!&5&
6 8!

1+ -/-0 8 21$ 89
%58
8
!789:7;;7% 34 9
6* 8< )8 ) " 7 = $ (&9
?5

!
$%

6
)8 55 !>5

9!" 9#589 &6@
6 9
5
658
&&&
8

6
895
4

6
5

8

8 &!&

8 68 8 0BDEFGCJG11 .N,EO0CHC. R7$
7& A C0 BHI0 L00 M 0 .P,DGH 76Q#;&)7%
K -3 IQ S
&&)

5

9
9 8
6
)8 5 !

5
6 98>5
T
56@
6 9
5
&
55
65)& 8
8
ABDEFGCU8 5&

0&*
6
6 C0 BHI/6 9
5
?&9&68

5
BDEFGC 8
85
8 5(&
5 9?
C0 BHI6 6 6 9

89 A

)8
& 8

6

5& 8
6

!5
6 8 &9&
6 85 &4 8 5 8 ?5
68&8@
9
5

5VW55&5

8(
) ! 5
5&9 & 8 8 & 5 5 8
!55?59
98
!#5VW
BD 9 5
8
8 5

5& C0 6
5R 5 & A EFGCU 8
6

65
68
65)&T 8

6
BHI/6 5 8 9

8
6 88 & * 88
8

58 5 >5
&
5

8 9
6
& 96 9
0 9

?
9
56@

)8 5

&5

8 5X
9 89
6 6 9
5 558? &6 9
&
>5
T

@6
)8 5 5 588
0
8Y
BDEFGC

6 9
? 56 !5 !5A C0 BHI&

9 8 9
@6
)8 5

&

8

>5
T
6 9
&

5T 8
8
6
68 8 Z [\ ]_ a` Z` Z e] eh_bek_hemZ eom f_`Z [Z ^` bc_a^ Zfgi^jZ ^lZndZ p ib^ d ^

5
5
59
)8 5 8
!5

5 &9 5
8 6 9

9 8 &
8 & 58 & )88&!

$ 85q%&5
5!9
789 !5
Y
#8(
&8
9>5
9
8
02465789
8

8

6
1 5 2 9

3
3

88

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 11 of 33

68
558
4

55!" 59

55! 8
65!8 54
99
8!5

8!8 9

5!# 5
9 8
%
!9 9 5$
9 4

5&4
!8') 5

85$8
!
!45859

(*+6 !6 5
59 $8 9!
8
5
9

!

, !6 58 95
8 & 0 0

!5-5

856566

856 095
9

!8 8
!5
5 .
!8
/8 5 8&
80!595
!4 8
6 9
/ 5
,

9

8
5

958594

5
86 99
855! 55
4
85!
818
9
56
05!
&1 89 , 56+
234)79:)4)9:)4 '>584 @A9C9
5
8

9

568 *;= 59 8?769 B B 8 < @A>56)8>D4; '6FH I JL
, 09H +
5 8<?6A49 5E 8B G + F K
5! MN
98 9 # UK O84P5<59< ;=R9B )T;J!#HS)T;J!#HK
MJ *5 ) >79 A*>C9 6A> #I"N 6A> #I"N /J
4Q S#
65859

!V

5!859 095

I/ 5& 8 ,85558

5!
5
4
5
8
5
4
8
5 !6
!&
6 ! 9
8 !58

/8 5W#
6
!!/8 5

!
8
%
6 9
5H .
6 9
W 8K I N N F+
X?(5C98<*Y74G!NJK
MF #
879B ) 9<<> "I"G /H O4

!6
5

5

!
8 8
5
95985
5 95
5
0
856
5

5
9585

8

5
9 9 8

5 &
6
V5!
4888K8

! 56
6 !5

!
8
8
K5!
" 5Z

8
6

8
8
8
[5

56 !5
5

!4
89
98%

-5
78959558
4
!4 5
5
9
9

4
59

8
8 8 5

!8!
5! 5Z .

!

!095

8 5 5Z

!9 88 8

/8Z
9
56 99

905! !
9 ,8
8 9
56 5!88
55!

5 &1

5
9
&

8

5
5
8\& 5
5
%
!9!9 8
9 02465789
8

8

6
1 5 2 9

3
3

88

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 12 of 33

8 55
8
!""
6
5595
6 9
5 9 #$%!
8 5&'(

*59

85
,
9 6 9
"5"$) 54
+9 8 )
*

59 ) )
-

4.4
/8 94
5 859

9
5

559/5

8 54*) 598
85
)85
) 6 9
58

5/01357846:;<>4 6= 4; *$$EF G5
/
8 2 6339464= ?@6 ;B $% $( G 6 4 6 A$CD 8H 6 9J1L= 4 6= K4 E$
$'4351 &S I6K 6 ?@6 N1 $%OO $(P;= 4=QORC D S >M CE D8 5VD
6
8 5'! OD &TU QO 6 9
5 !
6 9
VD( % 56
585
7898 59)58/9
* 4*9
9
W 6 9
59

)5
8
*5

. 6*48

)
/)4 /8
/*
4 6=
/

9 8)55! 8 58
> ?@6 A4;(
89

59/

6 5 8

!
908 ;B7 9
/9 5 *8 6 )
00/*

8 . )6 8 / 5
/8
8)6
)/

8
/
9
*

8). *58) * !/89)

89)
-)/9
789).8
9 /

/5/
)5
9
5

9 )
8 5 5 /
88 4
)69
*
) 5658 558)//5

-

5)85 - 5 8 8 86 4

5
))89 5
845998-)/
6*8
F
59985
4

8

5

)) 4 9 8 5-4

/
5

89
-
5594

8
)8
8
)5
)-8 8
.
98)6 .8 65
)
)
9/984*) 5/5
/ )
-
5
8
8
*
8
/88 5 5 5/ 8 )
9
5 /
*
8
8
5
789-
5+ 8
9 .5
8,
/)6 58) 9
9
5

8

5"

)8 4
6
) ) *8+
6 5

5* -
8 8
- 8
) 8 4

598))/8
-)/55

4 *X/85/9
Y *
! 8
)4/
*6 6
8 .
!
8/8 5
5/8
8
)8 5

5C 88 ) 6 %
6 )./
) *- )9 - + 5 898
9
89)5!58/9
6 /
. 5
9
W

*5
7
)
.

5
* 9
5
88)
8

6
598/ 6 9
8)/
*
8
8 5-
5+
8 8
/8
//9 8Z
/

*8/

5)8 5
5
*9
/
5) ) )
02465789
8

8

6
1 5 2 9

3
3

88

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 13 of 33

88
5 8

5

!"$%&'

8
5
!#" 8 8
88
85(8*

85

)845 5 )
8
)

)
+
8
99985555598-. !/

/5
58)
5
)959 5
5 !8 0 5
8,
5

)9 59)6

50 5
)
+ 5
/
9
8 59
4
5
5 *
4 +
8 /
(8 ! 1)4 -, 565

5
89 ) ! -2 ( 5.
5 ) 34 3 )8 5

5
9
789/

+ 8

5 /
75
9
8 4 )9 6 9
5 6
)5 !89
9)88
8 8
!/ ) 5+ 6 6 8
45

5
+89:;< !="'@"$A ' DE85A ' DE 59898: : < % ?$#"B C :, -. B C : "> /

/55
48)
2
65
H /5/ 8 0 5)
F )F

8 G *

8)
565 B' DE31 J-,5I
)6

+88 9
A C : I2( J1 435. 8

/
5)B' DE
88
85 )
6 5 858*8
A C :8 5
5
6)8

K 8
55
598+*8
B' DE 9
06 9498)
L5
)A C :8
88
8 5
59
(8 5M )

88

5 9 5

6 9
6 )5

8 K 4
58

)5

90985/

/

89 409

, -.0 8 0 5 8
0 L 08 )
*85

5
B' DE8 +8
5

) 855A C :6 /

8 8 8*8

8 895

2

(898

5 / )( )/ )0
5)6 )555N 6
5
9 /
5 55 9 1 88 KO)
,.48)
M
6
95
5 ,P 934,.
88
5 548 Q

88 5R559RS,
9 )R
49 56 9
)959 5
.5/ 9

8 G
65 5
0

5
8
+ 95
8 9
+8

55O 0 6 5
068
5 )9
+.A ' DEI 2( 54
+

9R B C : 3 J1 TL ,
6

.
8 58

5
&?"$ ?' 5
8
88
85

598U=V#" ?B 9 5
W 5 +

8 (8/)+6
5
5
5
.
6
),
8
9 09 8
5
8 9 /
A ' DE)U=V
+/)G58 5
+ 89 B C :
&?5 8485
+6 9
6 9 8 02465789
8

8

6
1 5 2 9

3
3

88

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 14 of 33

59
98555
48
5
4
!59
9
8
5
9
9 98

"5

5
8 5"45958
85

5"4

8

5 5
5
98 98 5
9 5 6588988
5"5

%')+ 8 9

# 988

84 $&(*)
,-'/ 14 6 160

65

'. 023 5 78 # 1:6 9
5

0 9 5 #8;& )+%;&> 1? 8;&
8$ <*) & = 23 08 # 1: 5:4$ < %$ 0 9 9 8 0 @
% #8559
A59

56
58

5
9 5

988
8
5

8 5

55
5
59

85

59 5
B 6 9

# 5
9 5

8

59
4 #

D5
985E;& 0 C9 4
8"
# 845 8
9$ < " % 23 6 89%';& 5
95

55
F
" &(5$ <C85
5 $ % 8 8

5#88988G. -)+IJKJ. ;>&-&L).O 5985
8 / H*) ) ; LM< NJ '+ . P 55

58

5 5
# 5
8
5 # 5 5
65

"

65
8 9

5
84
8 9
5

5 8
5
58
5
86959 8 85 8
9998
8559 5
:
8
G. - 55

5
#85

6
98 / H 55 4
5
8 58 5
895
5
55

4
6 9
59

48
9 Q

"
" 29
8

S8

54 . -4279966
5

5 9#C9 8:G / H6 6!9?8 # 5: R # P. -

95

55
/ H

585
G9 8 8

5

#88T---)+UH &8 855 598
ONL*) H L :

C5
5

59

6
5

"6 55
55

3

8 " #89859
5C5 8
58

5
8

88
5"89 9 5
55

5
56

59Q5

5
8

9
D 6 9 5
E " 8 9 "

C85
8
8 5 ---64
8
9 6
"
6 9
T ONL ?V3 0 8 8 9419759WX917?:"
55
? 43#59 95 9854 85
95 9 02465789
8

8

6
1 5 2 9

3
3

88

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 15 of 33

5
89 55

859 5 8

9
9
6

6 9 5
8

7

8
8 48
!8 5#$&
6
"8 5#$+ 5

6 9
%'
6 9
*&, " 5# () 5# --/ 0/24 /7 9:;</>4? 3 />AB9>/ -. 135 6 8 / 4;= 2 / 9@ / 3 CD / >1 / )
8 5

58

6
FFIKMFK " 5 58EGHJ JN

88 L OKRRTHUGHV4!,
"8

99
"8 5 P SJ OFMF!,W 559 5
8 6 9
QK 5 5
8 5 595859

8
58
5
YH NH\K
55 9
4

X89
Z [O] ^HRIK F[HK\aSKH NH\K O\bcF ORJdOe[J(%! M]UJQ \F_`UKaYZ [O]Q M[K Z HIK NR f&% I g% "
gg ONKa O FK FR\^jOKR[R[V(%++ "
g* g,c HFSK i Hc HOKUOJ NHU%gV W! g, h k 0 5
5
5

"8 8

9 8 6 l

6 95

8 6
6 X4
8$ 8
mMRNbSK F\bS\IkF[OK\ROZF[J 58598
6 X5n G\oKaT\NJIRK ea Pp SH\ \IK K LFOHF&fV "
g* NMUN g(V ! f, f &%

8
5
5
59
789"8 5 586 q
5
9
r 6 9

68
58
9
8 9

86'm559 8 " 9
s r 5

9
5 m 6
58$$6
8
m86
8
m
5 % f,)

8
5 8 5 ! V * 6
8

5
789m5

89
5 q9
9
r
44 6 8
s 5
8
m698

8XX"8
5

58

858
58 m
8t8
8
5 89"8 59

7 9
r 6 9
5
856 8
8
4
m095
5
IJ UHGK
9 5
5u

5

c J\oO[

R cFRIKa^\NTjH IF[IN85 cIJ UHG
5
GUJSKOMK IZ UMR J! *,
J\oO[ 9
U R 559
8
8

88
58

9

"

5

m 8
95

8

v 5
65l3

59

6 w u5

45 8

9

8 IJ UHG f 88
58556
" c J\oO[gg(w R V*g,

5
8
8 WV+! "gf u
5
5888 8 02465789
8

8

6
1 5 2 9

3
3

88

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 16 of 33

5
7898 5

!8 9
9
6 9
5695
889

5 8 8898 5586
8
9
6 9

9 8 7

5

5
858095
5
$& (*,-(.08 "

#%' )+* &/

88
859
68
591

095
56

5
9 6

8

5 4 8 8 8 2
56

88
3
5
888

96
5
9
8 455 2
85

8 4
85$& ( 55

95
8

5 67 #%' )1 51
5

8

5 59

5
151
8

!
95 56 8 56 99

!
8

55
55!
8
5 5 95

095

99 751
1 8
!
48

568

5
89
51
8
55
9
56 5
1 8 5!6 !
5 4 4

199
6
4
69

5 5 8
5

1
5
5
89 4 5 2

55
5
!
8
96 68
58 8
4
6 4 95
56 8 ! :
5

#$& (:<:= =>=?
@6B

5 9
6 %' ); := ::5 A7
B
98 1
5$& ( !
#%' ) 88 C
5

955
5

8
25 0
9
9
8
4

985 5

15598
556
9
8
5!
9 09
6
68
D
!
4
85 5 5
! 5
5 5 8

8E

88
6

8

95 8 69
5

8 5"
95
50
6 9
6 9

5 9
6 6
9
5

8!1

9 956

5

8
8F8
8
505 6

98 9 9
8 988 5 6 85
B
6

50
8 G 1
!
95 9 ! 8 6 F
58 856
8
1 85
5 9
8 6 5

8 5 89825

9

8
8

856 1

5 H #$& (; =
@6 %' ) <: 5 ?5 A7 : :? E
8
5

9
89
8
5

99
6 5
5
9
89 25

7
58428
55

5
55

8
5 9
5
89

8
6
889
7898 5895 8
8
9
5
9
6 9

8
1 6889
8 5
8 ! 02465789
8

8

6
1 5 2 9

3
3

88

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 17 of 33

!## %'%** &
588 58095
5
"$ &( !(( - 8
) +, .

4

6
2 4 !## %4
5
8 / 505
9

81&3 %0 "$ &
8
9 / 5

5
5
0
45
8 8
89 0 9
8

0
65
8 .8
8 8 5 8 7 8 /
56

5855
55

;568
!## 08
8

: 08 49 "$ 8
% =>=@A
CDF9

.5
& ? < BCE

8
. 90 5
< ?
9
7
89B8 9
!## %
5
5
.
5
8 .8 0G5
"$ &9 5/
HIJ 8
H8 8
.
8
05
5 !## % 5 8
8 . K
B
"$ &
8
/
55
8 .5

5
5
.
5
9 .
5
0

8
559 5
8 855I8
98 5555
95
.

98
5

/
6

J 8

8

B8
0G85
B859
B8

8 95

4 0
0 8 / 56
/ B8
0)2 5
05
9 !## %8
LM 7 /
58
"$ &08 0
095
455
98

58

9

88
8
5 0 5

6

8 5
5 50

8
!## %85989

N 55055 "$ &

8 0 / 08
08559)2 !## %5 058

5
LMH 0
"$ &

12 49
05
59 8
8

&3 %
5
588
8

5
.I
. 8/
8O
85 8.9
.89
.

4
858

0

9.

G5
08
5
59 8555
5

9

. 4
J

5
.
859 5
5P
8 8

6
595
8
59
789B8 5 8 9
554
9G5
9
P 6 9
8

0

I
08/

5
5

86 98 8
. 5

9 6 54 85
8 6 8

.568
0

G5
789

8
8 N 9
9
P
.

09 9

8
.49
5
8

Q P88
558 G

02465789
8

8

6
1 5 2 9

3
3

88

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 18 of 33

58

589

9

8859 86

5

9 !
7 4
8 "88

8

6

66

#9 $
5 8 3
5
8
559 8 8 5
8%6
"8 5 9

6 9
& ' ) *+,*-./+,& (& '
58
58

58 9

9
5 84#6

5

9 !

8 8
8

58115527346553

58 5 0
88525 5 8
4 8
6
5
"8 557864784
0 9
5 6 9
84"64785789

"8

8:5

68
9

9

9 5 5

9 !
8 8
85
"8 55
8"88 8 6
6 9
8
:

8 58
9 #

6 5 4
96

94 [ ^ a> 5
14;<= >Y>]_>>>e>>>>>>
5 < 6 >Z>>`>[d>>>>>>> >\>^[b >f >c
3
: 9 !

? @A CEGCIJLAH A DFH G KDLG BB H MM%89"8 6 M 5N
0

O55

%PP6; 79 =PQM
9 0

5
8=9
R <S 8 78 6QP& 9< M;;& & & Z iej [b m 5
14;<= >Y[h>d>da>l>d >>>>
5 < 6 >>>> k> [>k >>>> >g >> >a > > >>> O5
38 $

!

3? @A CEGCIJLAH A DFH G KDLG BB H
88 MSR 9 5
6M T6 4 0
UVM 8 S6 % %W5869
85 <M R< 768 Q69 M< P<; M [ >> o m 5
14;<= >Y>l>[b>p>j>>>>>>
5 < 6 >Z>]>n> d>d>h>>>> >a>j >[ > >i> 3

$5 8 6 7 7

$58
6 X% 5
P865
T 94 0
R T5<
:8 " <9 6 7<8 PQ= 66 PP 6 58S9; " =9 R; 02465789
8

8

6
1 5 2 9

3
3

88

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 19 of 33

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

1234479 5688

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 20 of 33

0 0 0 17732556799672735 2
94678
5
45 8 75
5
9

0

234
57378 495=? >= AB@ C?DE5 5 5 49 5 9: ; ><@ = 5CA< 5 5 6 < F7
527H 7 58 79
I 75
K7 5 22918 45 H 2 777 G57 ::
857 8 J 5 :5
L5 7:M 2 N5 92 9J447L
4L5 5 3512 2P6747 5Q ? RA5 JL25
574275 27 O 3 45 G
K2875? A< S 4 H J K 2 4 89 445 7
2795574
H
7L
4L5 57: 57 59:
7H 577 5J L
47 54 57427 8
9 3 9
595 7 2JJ9 7 G55 : 45
55 7G7 9
5 272 TH7477: 54 5 L
5 2 : 4 7 2
0 F7
J
;544 L95J 7 5
7K5J 2 2P5: 54 5 7 7797525

95 2 J 5 5 2795 3 4; 9 T3 5 U 7 1 79 7 1 42 7 7 67 425J 4 37 525
587
35G
7 5: 5 T

95 5 244 5 97 28932 945 97 72
V 2 K L 9 2:2:778 5J4 79
; 278
9 257 :2
G
4
25 445 5 795 5 L
5 G57 : 7 5: 5747 5 7 3 G2
7 3 J7 712 2PK57 2 7 J 7 5257 5 H 29442547 7 5 3 45 274 8
:5 5 2 7 K :5 2 N5
:
5 4 91 7 M T H L
4L5:
L
5 5L9
:734 559442
897 875 74279 579
42L
2 L5 278 75: 5
L

5 J : 7 L 0 9279J44L8 4TW97:
X: 2X: ; 25G
4
L7 5 25 55JL2;:
: 5 G
954
54T75 775 8
45 7 : 7 454 79
H 52
7 555 2 :

J
:59 5:5754 79
7G 5 L
577 :
42 : 75477
2 397
G 5 L
5 2
: JJ 2
45 78 79 5J7 55J 2 245 : 59 4:95 7K2795 3 45 7 15 YZ\^` bcde_a_\ cjZka\l^ \n n_ c ni c i l c q5 [ _a \ fg \ i \_ iZa\ cm o _Y p Zb g\ \ ni 5 ] h^ c i \ am ^ 5 rX 6FU K5= A5 r M @ = 55 5 5 5 5 5
5 5= t12 24 7 9
5 L5vH 85u 7957GL5D
23D943u 44:5J 4H3 s@ = 5 3 46 8
7;:55 9 5F
5J
47u 4 L5 5X 4 952 40 5 Uu w5 K 5 G L 5 29 X 4

#$% ')" * !" & !( !'' + ( /''0($!' ' 5 , - . !& !) ' $ 1 '

5

5

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 21 of 33

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

1234479 5688

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 22 of 33

!"# & ' $ % (

0135 15
3 3
79 13 246 78 8
8 6 8 7 9 3
3198 3 3 558

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 23 of 33

0135428 24667 9

5
4 43
12354 12 5
5 52 5 54 5
2 23 4 4 5 352
5 5
4 42
52 255 5 452
5 5 0
5
3 4 2 4 4
5
!
4 45 5

45

5 45

5 2
54 5
!1

5 ! 4 3 " 3 355
2552$35
552
5 2
145 74#75 44 5

4
%
# 1# 22 22 5
5
22

5
#7252
75 2
54 5 !5 1 15#75 5 52
2 3 34 53 4#5 43

4254552
"2557' 1 552
5 7 # #715 4654& 2 #
2 #25!5
52(5
93155
56

5
5 2
# 2#75 132#5 2

5 2 4# 5

4 2

555
1 2
5

5 2155 42
1 3
52

53 3"21
554
#755
5
25 526
55

652

# 2
54 4 2 3 2
557
751)

$15
354 43
234 1 52"
5 65 5 7

5
52 4 5 37
4 12545!57

552
454 2

45 5

4
2 22 9
125 4
5
!52 5 6 5 #7 22 2 013 24 35
4

4 42
)4
* 5 5 5 5 2 4

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 24 of 33

013 2 44 4784262 32
5
244 245 65 24 9
8 213 67

76224
2
22 4474543 2484454

3 8 744 7 72
2 247
262
4 32
5
244 27 763 213 67

8451242243 84 417

3 84
4 2 2 47

8 24 3 224224 2

! "" # ! #! "" #$ !& $ ! "% '( *" ! ") & ) ! !$ !"

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

2 3 3 4 5 6 6 6 7 8 7 8 7 8 7 2 7 2 7 3 7 3 7 4 7 9 7 9 7 : 7 ; 2 8 2 7 2 3

6 9 9

6 323
544 4

9 0
96
4 43 1 5 5 9 16
164

5 9 46
5 64
9 1 9
54
7
!9"
8
145 6
6 9#5 64
9 6 3 4 9 $1
6 595 1 45
4%1 4
19 % 65 9 35 491 351565 6464

6 16 24 7
&
5 919 '44
5 456
64

56
5 9 ! 3
6 5
!19 649 0457(6 4
1 54 !65 4) 14 (6 4
1 545#1 251 4) 14 1323
539 #1 3544
15*1 1324 93
4 4655 1 195 6 4)1 5 6 4
1 54 9 7
571( * 1 ( 5 9 ( 4) 14 ! 37
1(6 4
1 54 !9 5655 4) 14 81 595! 39
4 4337
19 9 4 !1 [phone]
6 4919574
! 3
6 5
593"
6 65 65 !19 646 04 ! 39
4! 923
4 5 !1 [phone]
6 25 4 5! 39
9 ,- 95% * !1 86 6 3545 4
6 25! 39
5 6
9 ,- 95 !1 ' 5 4 6 54'1
9)
9
5 5 .
4/ 1 1 699 5 50 9 ! 4 1 !9

0 24656
9 13578 94

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 25 of 33

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 26 of 33

246 8 46 357 9
3

!

!

" #
$ %
( # ) #

&'

%
#

&
*+-,0 +2 42 4
5
$

"

,. /11 3, 3,
5
#

( (
6

* "

$
*5 %
6 7 6 8 9 5: (78;<

">7 $
%
"

(
=

)
$
%

?
"
A) " )
9 ?
@

$ < ( B

&"9 CD
6
5
<
"
8
?
?
?
*# 5 B
*( !

$<
( )B

% * 6 "
&
%

%
6
?
"

"( %

")B "
E #6
*
( ( F"
E((F;
#

"
%
6
:
<*6 $ ( 6
$ )E((F

&

%

" 6

* #
&
*$( #

$

%
#

" 6<*

$
*
"# 6
*)

01010 11
G

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 27 of 33

02462389676991369283 72
4 135472
22
73 242 392362 66 7 96491723 265721 21 2392199722 426721 1623
3 955 292
12 1676
1 266345 22 697 6732 9 913 695 9517266276 48 12 92 8 2 1 9642962728 497721 695792 2 2426
9
2 37123 5471 27 43 64891911 221647276 !2198741 6 1
232 7767322 25 16 3 482 161
66 673243
724" 7249 ! 26792
8 12726 12641 2 99723583 473 23 6773 776242
6
1726 17962 4 5 8 1912 92966
7 7 4763 48 32249

#$&'$(*,./0, ( %%%%)+ - %, 12

332
672
2322 9 91 86
1 867926 266
23949 923 29523 65
96 878677 34" 6 674 3 2 2 62 2648 1 8 2 926 2 32 2 I532 7627
976726942968915 3 3 2 26917 9 912 6 9295 12 229 6 95 15 91 26 I537
82791216:
29422626352226296261597726 1 26 7 3 73 7 3 3 7 4 7 92
1 91 9 910
1 6236 ; 2 861 3 2 7 9295243 72; 792 2 92 8 296 3 93 5" 97829262=4679 912 2
3 21 327
97< 2612 93 2 4" 6 674891211 6222 !>29 648 126 951676 96 2? 6 16 @

326692632 82668< 2612
3 21 614
4
27 21574 11 2=4673 5" 978 23 21 5 86773 241 23 4193 723 4
72 8 763 23 19179 266
23 2
9 91932 3 69972653
2323 921674 8 2
11621 29
7 2 1473 G7922376495 967 6691227 2241 41 7 H7689265723276 941232 4 91 42 162 29
442 76662 38 73 3 1 21
3 2 722468762431
6679
24 39
29
2 6723726112 72
19 4 9 9193 921674
J

A/C1 *E /F, ,$& B%&D .* 1 BE )

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 28 of 33

01 336 313
715
717383365 2 457 9575
7359571
7 8 1 2
77 37 4715317 95
1
7 715 !" 3757
83
79
1 1! 7 7 #34737567178735337 73
75 71$3%&
1%
17383755 83
1 331737278717 315! 71
337
1 3

95 75 1 "5757 1537937

733

3

333 731
171
37 5 78' 2

5 577315!

()+,-/02 3 5 * ). 1 + 46

"75 37
7 271 757937

3
571
371
1 3177 7793 47
3
30 2
75' 93 17 == :BA ;D Y 8735

71799:;<>?@<A>C=<E 5

17 == :BA = C;DA 3 1 Y 8793775799:;<>?@<A>F@G@=@HA=<I

1
1 3 3E Y 8735

71799:;<>?@<A>J:KL:MA=<! 93 17 == :BA @ C;D N1 7
335

855

371' 2 7 37 73937
739
95
9 Y N153E 7 11 7 E Y N158

9357 711 7 ! Y N158

135 "77 3 317 3P #0Q7
731731 6 3
3O 5 790 7O 6R S 5
T
55
37
7 7

P37 73 3171
8 7

571 5
Q8 773 17 3335 ! 9 747 1 11
Q P U71 5811
73$1 371 $351 371 9 7
5
7
7547 7 47V 737

56 2

735

373
7W530 2
7371 7 7137393 855

371'
739
95 7 11 7 $ 3
7 Y N158

935
75E 7 11 7 $ 3
Y N158

135
75!
X

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

0 23576
6

6965989 1 46895
15

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 29 of 33

59896859 1576 6

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 30 of 33

02462249
2348
1227624
17
2 13543836
2 8 7
3 7 2 7
7
93 1 3 5321763
2 2 6"7 922 62924 312132 241 32 !2 42 67 4
%3 #
$ 612
223698664942 34 72
26 )3 46&' 2
423 72 3532 247 17 2 2 2
6 $ ( 6"7223 874147587,2763
2 !2 4*9 6+66
624137&- $ 712 241
2 7 326"722
67 6
536292698741475 !2 4#
!232 212 1
167 23 6+66
6 )4.6253
26
1$2& 2 4

57 1 497 2 (6 ! 3 /14.67
945982 34 7267
63 260 62
2267 62332 2494972 7 2 7 61 $ 4
1635267 132246 484:: < 6< 6964?BCDC6F< 94
-9 2 2576396; =>?@49A 45; 6 E 9 3 35 5 GHHI6?K BBE@ M5@6< 64M@8K 6N769D; 3 6N J 9<4L6; 6 5 ?;466< ><6 4<CC@6 < 7> 5 ( 6Q C ; IC4PC56; 6<6 48QK 59D;95M )6N @3 DC6< 9 O6 97@ M; 576< ?4R44@46 ST6 C; 6 >? 5 9A 45<QL 3@4N3C6F<6HHI6?K BB6 6 4E 4B;N9 4?B6 9 6 4B6 3;E 9G J 9<4EC 5 6U @< 6 N K C6 ;7 < U4?BCD@V45N46< > 645< SW46YQK4< 6@4Z[ A 45; 66 9CCMV K EB8C;6X44@ 36;K D6S 6 \6
2367
22231626

65
462 3213
6172 7 12 4 42
2
26!9&02 8
21 3 3 2 89234675223 67
325
#276
2^ %1282 462 59 1*,
32
2
7 9 2 3 ] #3%12
4 22249
2346
*,212 2226%223 452 2 7836
2.67
43
_# 6
3 3 4 2 37 #
73467594
6
2
5723& 12 2 46267 97*, 2 9 63 0266672 635267 156232
6
$494
64 17 2!126072 94
-9 23
17 !227267 972 7
1 3 3
3234
6724 41841
2622
6
` 3494`94
1 12 2 41
32
5
67# 22a [phone] & 8 7
3 ` 3494`94
1612626412
494
2622
175 a [phone]

74
92 352 91321 3
76 7 764.675$494
6&\6
272a3494`94
1# 2
627267 97
2
6
$ 7
` [phone] 27623 6722& 34 4 9 1
7 35 3 02324258634 97294224$$

6&2 2
6
3752 233
244 3583
26520 7
$ $6
21

9 272
26
22
732267 766 2 34 17162

$2$67

2 712 2719732 3 1 $33
2
67&b53
6651212
7
29

926 9 41
2 57 1 2 813234 4 4 4 7167 8 2 5 89 9 c 2342
26
2268724
116&0234
d 7 $2$67232626 3 7 232652 3 71 3 2
37 13946226-
632

e32
26
2262233234 58 29457 2772 # $2$677 982 3 1 2 3
3
27267
62 96
722772581494
23 66
41 49497&b 9
2 37 2
6
37 2 35 # !4!4 $ 2 3 3
36 2
947264
67 6f4
7 1 93512 7 2 89 2 59 & 3 6 ! 3

g) j(l (h ik m )n

'424262176$494
62 4 3461o4 34
67 66
67
# 62 27267 97
2
2 532 2 41
3
8 3241841

617!$6
5!2371` 3494`94
1 4
5
6724232
21232
67 2a [phone]

6 3 3 22&2
2967635423 67292
71 4 2
982 91
59 1
#

2 2
67$12 2624 321 2292 4
5967&

7
3235.
78
632 423 1

$ 1 8
p

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 31 of 33

8
4 3
7878 9 697
: 796 59 3 6 5 ;13
7

1 <59 8

.0 (12 34 +- = / ' , ,, 5, 6712 34 +- = , ,, 5, >!1 $! ?@BCCFGHE I@K A DE ? DJ LM! '1 # ! NCO E QRI @IP E H S$(U!W X$( MT V' # ' 1 Y@C[IJ\[]Z A@J^EJA ZI @ E I G \I _ Q ` V!(1 $! [K@@E]J\JbcEGd@B@b AaA[ @ @ E [ D^ J & $(eT .!( '1 ) $ ( #T M ! fKIE@h ]DgDK i' ' 0558 1 35 1 598 1< 0 j310 2 46 78
35

198 1<855k9
9
l
8
35 j398 7547 m!$MX($#WM/ ' ( M$ Xn ' ' ( # / !WMM ( o 0Mp ' Mq('MM' $0 0/ X $(/'Mm!' (( . $' $ M$ r #) /$ ' !XM'p $$T & $(0 q( MLM( (q$$ ! $!' L' $0 ' ) $' Wn $' W (M s#p ' nmr #) M s 0 q m& $(&' eWtuv xx{}x"/M $) S /! ( ' ) $ q ( M w yz|{~ z X( 0$ !Xm$$' !n ' X WM $ 'mX(r #!

!"# % $ &' '## *+ ( "& ) $$ , .0 (12 34 +- / ' , ,, 5, 6712 34 +- , ,, 5,

01 35 1 59 2 46 78
3 3
78 9 13
3 6 8 7 34 3 8

1
6 7

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 32 of 33

0135 1 598 3 3
78 9 13 2 46 78

3 6 8 7 558
3 3 3198

8 5

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 33 of 33

! "!# $%# !$ &%#'# %&$%()* !$ " +,-+3,. 30001-, 1 / / 7 1 23578 1 4659 8: ;;;;;;;=; 100?10B31DFEHI, ;;;;;;; > ;;;;;;< ?@ 0A 3 B CEGCHJK 1 A,,.3-13,39 1 /
5 1 LMMN6O: 86 4 7P; 1 0R
K
TVS4
W59
38
8
S9 -U

WF
SR5
X 5Y

/ 8S88
8
8

Y58ZZ55[7 4655Y V

5 W/
885[5 F 5 S 8 3 K

X8
6
R5
?8 5V5]]`;c];efgg 8
S, Y 9
X 6 9
R V8\^_ab a=d; <a ; h_i^_,V
jkH4jkm5
GYG5

8

S5 d]c] 9H4jk5Yjkl
9FF9 T
nSYW8
o4VCV8
9 m
T
5WHC 89 1 S8 ,8
5
V 4 V-U

o p#q !$% lroV

B C8
S/
s s5SCCECn
T8 ? CIHC H 1

S1HHHElC 98
Ck DlC jl oF

1jCk nElC 56 9HH J
J ,5
t
8
F6 V
[F
8 |uu~~u } u u uuuuuuuuuuuuu u~uuuu uuuuuuu R 00 -,+ / w0- 70RK v , xy _];_hagye y z{e ; `zg; dd e IIA89?8 VH I Y5+
V/

055

AJEI W 79 JJHn
9R jk HEJ lC Inn D $# "%&! #Q &$ $

02465789
8

8

6
1 5 2 9

3
3

88

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13-2

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 1 of 5

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA : : Plaintiff : vs. : CIVIL ACTION NO. 1:08-cv-02254 JR : BARRY SOETORO, a/k/a Barack : Hussein Obama, in his capacity as : a natural person; in his capacity as : de facto President in posse; and in his : capacity as de jure President in posse : and : JOSEPH R. BIDEN, JR., in his capacity : as a natural person; in his capacity as : de jure Acting President in posse; in his : capacity as de jure President in posse; : and in his capacity as de jure Vice: President in posse; : and : NATURAL and UN-NATURAL : DOES 1-100 INCLUSIVE, : : Defendants : DECLARATION OF LISA LIBERI GREGORY S. HOLLISTER,

I, Lisa Liberi, being over the age of eighteen (18) and not a party to the within action prepared this Declaration of Lisa Liberi regarding certain events regarding this litigation. If called to do so, I could and would competently testify under oath as follows: 1. I am employed by the Law Offices of Philip J. Berg as Assistant to and Paralegal

for Philip J. Berg, Esquire. Our business address is located at 555 Andorra Glen Court, Suite #12, Lafayette Hill, PA 19444-2531. 2. On December 31, 2008, I caused the Complaint for our Client, Gregory S.

Hollister, to be filed in the within action.

I:\Obama\Hollister Liberi Declaration 02 13 09.doc

1

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13-2

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 2 of 5

3.

On or about January 2, 2009 at approximately 10:00 a.m. Eastern time, I received

a call from John Hemenway, Esquire, local counsel and sponsors of Philip J. Berg, Esquire and Lawrence J. Joyce, Esquire to be entered in this Court to practice pro hac vice in the within matter. 4. Mr. Hemenway informed me he had received a call from Maureen Higgins, a

Clerk at the United States District Court, District of Columbia. Mr. Hemenway stated Ms. Higgins refused to file Plaintiff's Complaint without a Motion for Leave to File an Interpleader Action. 5. Mr. Hemenway stated he went down to the Court and asked who the Judge was in

this matter; however, the Clerk refused to tell him. Mr. Hemenway stated he wanted to appear before the Judge regarding the issues with the Court's Clerk. 6. I immediately contacted Maureen Higgins via telephone to discuss the issue

regarding the Motion she was requesting. Ms. Higgins informed me that we had to file a Motion for Leave to file our Interpleader Complaint by noon, as it was year end close, or she would not file Petitioner's Complaint. I explained to Ms. Higgins that this was not normal protocol. Ms. Higgins first stated it was a local rule. Ms. Higgins then retracted this statement claiming it was in her Interpleader Manual that she was required to follow. 7. I explained to Ms. Higgins that it was normal protocol to file a Motion for Leave

to Deposit Funds with the Court in an Interpleader Action, however, not to file a Motion seeking Leave of the Court to file a Complaint for Interpleader. Ms. Higgins again stated she would not file Plaintiff's Complaint without said Motion. 8. I hung up with Ms. Higgins and immediately contacted David Scott, Ms. Higgins

Supervisor. Mr. Scott placed my call on speaker and called Ms. Higgins into his Office. I

I:\Obama\Hollister Liberi Declaration 02 13 09.doc

2

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13-2

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 3 of 5

informed Mr. Scott and Ms. Higgins I pulled the law books pertaining to the Interpleader Action as well as the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and the local rules for the U.S. District Court, District of Columbia. Nowhere was I able to locate such a requirement as dictated by Ms. Higgins. 9. Ms. Higgins became frustrated and began speaking very loudly. I continued

reading exactly what the law stated pursuant to the Interpleader Actions. Ms. Higgins finally stated if we did not file an original Motion for Leave to File an Interpleader Action, our Client's Complaint would be rejected and she would mail it back to us. This of course was doing nothing more than prejudicing our client. 10. Mr. Scott stated we should file the Motion even though we did not agree and

email it to him. Mr. Scott stated the reason they needed it by noon was due to the fact of year-end close. Mr. Scott stated if Ms. Higgins attempted to reject Plaintiff's Complaint again, he would personally go before the Judge. 11. Although in disagreement, to preserve the rights of our Client, I prepared a

Motion for Leave to file an Interpleader Action. I submitted the Motion to all counsel who reluctantly agreed to have it filed. 12. At the time of the filing of Plaintiff's Complaint a Motion to Shorten time

for Defendants to Answer was filed as well as a Motion to enter Philip J. Berg, Esquire and Lawrence J. Joyce, Esquire to Appear Pro Hac Vice. 13. On or about February 4, 2009, this Honorable Court entered an order deeming the

Motion for Leave to file Plaintiff's Interpleader Action frivolous and therefore denied it. At the same this Honorable Court held Mr. Berg's and Mr. Joyce's Motion to Appear Pro Hac Vice in abeyance until the Court has had the opportunity in open Court to examine their

I:\Obama\Hollister Liberi Declaration 02 13 09.doc

3

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13-2

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 4 of 5

credentials, their competence, their good faith, and the factual and legal bases of the Complaint they have signed. 14. I immediately contacted David Scott back regarding this Order. Mr. Scott

remembered the events involving his Clerk, Maureen Higgins and the Motion in question. Mr. Scott apologized and stated he was discussing this issue with his Supervisors. Mr. Scott pulled the Order of this Court and took it to his Supervisors so they would discuss this issue with Ms. Higgins. I told Mr. Scott I hoped he would inform the Court as to the actions that forced the filing of the Motion for Leave to File an Interpleader Action.

I declare under the laws of the United States that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed this 13th day of February, 2009. Respectfully submitted,

s/ Lisa Liberi ______________________________ LISA LIBERI

I:\Obama\Hollister Liberi Declaration 02 13 09.doc

4

Case 1:08-cv-02254-JR

Document 13-2

Filed 02/13/2009

Page 5 of 5

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

: : Plaintiff, : vs. : CIVIL ACTION NO. 1:08-cv-02254 JR : BARRY SOETORO, et al : : Defendants. :

GREGORY S. HOLLISTER,

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I, Lisa Liberi, hereby certify that the Declaration of Lisa Liberi was served via electronic filing this 13th day of February 2009 upon the following: Robert F. Bauer, Esquire PERKINS COIE 607 Fourteenth Street N.W. Washington, D.C. 20005-2003 Telephone: [phone] Facsimile: [phone] [e-mail]

s/ Lisa Liberi ______________________________ LISA LIBERI

I:\Obama\Hollister Liberi Declaration 02 13 09.doc

5

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA

: : Plaintiff, : vs. : CIVIL ACTION NO. 1:08-cv-02254 JR : BARRY SOETORO, et al., : : Defendants. :

GREGORY S. HOLLISTER,

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I, Philip J. Berg, Esquire, hereby certify that Plaintiff's Response to Honorable James Robertson's Order to Show Cause was served via email this 26th day of February 2009 upon the following: Robert F. Bauer, Esquire PERKINS COIE 607 Fourteenth Street N.W. Washington, D.C. 20005-2003 Telephone: [phone] Facsimile: [phone] [e-mail]

s/ Philip J. Berg ______________________________ PHILIP J. BERG, ESQUIRE Attorney for Plaintiff 555 Andorra Glen Court, Suite 12 Lafayette Hill, PA 19444-2531 [phone]

I:\\HollisterResponseOSC02262009.doc